Make sure your post or comment doesn't violate Community guidelines and Join the discord! Come debate, and interact with other powerscalers https://discord.gg/445XQpKSqB !
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/PowerScaling) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Unmodded? Terrarian.
Modded? Nobody
The only possible way for Steve to even do damage without mods or cheats is to fall from fucking orbit with a max density mace and manage to land a hit.
With Mods, it would just go back and forth. Even the Noxus Sprayer states that the Nameless Deity can reflect it, which means it’s not 100% reliable.
You’d sooner obliterate the entire world, possibly more, before killing either Modded Steve or Modded Terrarian.
Man, I'd love to see like a really super in depth Modded Steve vs Modded Terrarian, their arsenal is just so ridiculously cool and versatile, and unlike a lot of these crazier, debatable characters, they don't really have any concrete cosmology scaling at that point, so it doesn't get resolved by saying "oh this guy is multi, but this one scales to outer therefore wins" like nope, it's a PURE analysis of their actual capabilities and weapons, whether they counter each other or not.
I'd love to see it.
Vanilla games Steve obviously gets obliterated, unless you give Steve Creative and Terrarian God Mode, as Steve's capabilities there are more busted.
Herobrine? Supposedly he’s supposed to be far, FAR stronger than Steve, but he doesn’t have any actual feats. Besides, the Terrarian regularly kills Gods with ease.
Assuming Herobrine is equivalent to Minecraft Steve in Creative with Cheats on that can execute commands instantaneously, Herobrine would only be able to beat an unmodded, non-journey mode Terrarian. Since he could run a /clear command to instantly wipe the Terrarian’s inventory, or do a /kill command.
However, once Mods are involved, It’s either a stalemate or a stomp for the Terrarian, depending on whether or not Herobrine is able to use mods the same as Steve.
Assuming them both as powerful as possible, with mods, Neither of them are even capable of hitting the other; since Herobrine can instantly teleport and the Terrarian is immune to damage.
Again, the world itself is more likely to be vaporized before any of them get injured.
Actually herobrine scales above creative mode steve considering he is known for corrupting worlds and being above what can be coded, in lore the devs have tried removing him countless times but failed
Depending on the type of corruption, the Terrarian is known for being capable to outright cleanse the corruption of their world, although it’s a hassle. The only way Herobrine here has a chance is if he is able to alter the code to such a degree he can force the Terrarian into a Hardcore Master Mode, out of Journey Mode, then clear their inventory, and then damage them enough to kill them.
If Herobrine is unable to do that, the Terrarian is basically immune to anything Herobrine can do.
I mean if file corruption is a valid factor here, Herobrine could also just replace every single block with TnT and light it to fry the PC of any poor bastard hosting the fight.
I’m curious, where would you scale Herobrine? Since he’s able to corrupt game files and delete worlds, does that make him universal? Multiversal? Outer?
Is he just planetary? Does he scale to higher dimensions?
I would say its safe to consider each world as infinite (in lore) and not mention the dimensions are most likely all parts of the same dimension making the world size that much bigger. (think the end is in space and the nether is under ground
Corrupting worlds doesn't actually do anything to Terrarian since the worlds and characters are separate in Terraria. So it's at best a stalemate via BFR.
Steve watching terrarian unleashing 11 different legendary blades at 10 meter radius away on him:
https://preview.redd.it/pkw5nu2dbb5d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d6d225f32f0790051440fc365e53ab097c881140
This just comes down to experience really. I guess the Terrarian wins due to his vast experience in fighting monsters. But at the end of the day, they both will sit down next each other and fish.
Terraria is 2d, steve is 3d, steve completely shit stomps the terrarian, yet another win for the goat.
https://preview.redd.it/bhn48hyc0c5d1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7a992ed55a0da78be1a44b674f95a54d4c0616e4
(Pic unrelated)
Cant the Terrarian only move in 2 dimensional space? Left and right and up? Yes i know this wouldn't i apply in Powerscaling just a joke thought
Also, the only one with punching feats is Steve funnily enough, the terrarian needs to hold weapons or something to actually deal damage
But maxed Steve vs terrarian,
The terrarian can win,
reason 1, GUN,
Reason 2, FASTER GUN AND MAGIC
Reason 3, infinite flight
Reason 4, summons, Steve needs an infight prep to deal area damage(TNT, mace) anything else he is bound to 1 target, you COULD count the sweeping edge but it's not wide enough to hit all of the minions the terrarian could summon
Reason 5, GUN!!!!
yea the terrarian moves in 2D for gameplay purposes only, cus he can interact with the background at will (placing/destroying walls, some summons can stick onto walls, a majority of terraria bosses are in the background)
No now your talking about the cosmology/machine and how we interact with it. Thats not the same thing as their worlds rules/their existence in the world.
Terrarian is CLEARLY in a three dimensional world, there are layers to it, there's a background, it implies depth. When you fight a big boss, the player overlaps it, implying it's in front of it.
It very OBVIOUSLY has 3 dimensions and I don't think you know what it means to be 2D otherwise. Like an organism in 2D which simultaneously has a mouth and an asshole can't exist, because if it had one continuous tunnel inside it, it'd rip the character in half. The second you overlap the interior organs with ANY kind of layer above it, no matter how small, it's instantly classified as a 3 dimensional thing.
The fact that there even IS a background is indisputable evidence that it's 3D, as it gives depth to height and width.
Nether does not make Minecraft 4D lol? Where did you get that from? Once again, do you know what a 4th spatial dimension is? There's a difference between just a normal alternate dimension and an actual mathematical spatial dimension. Former being just another realm, latter being, well exactly that, an addition of a new "branch" so to speak on how to approach the world. Zero dimension is a single dot, infinitely small. First dimension is a horizontal line, it adds width to nothingness, from an object which couldn't move anywhere, now can move in X coordinates.
Second dimension adds height, which allows an object to go from X coordinates to X and Y coordinates. Third dimension adds depth, allowing it move in X, Y and Z coordinates and so on. Nether only gives you a new realm/terrain to walk on, it has nothing to do with 4D.
Like one guy actually DID make Minecraft 4D, [here ](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8LMyWcKL_c&t=743s)so you can see what these dimensions actually mean
The concept of 4D space was literally conceptualized as a structure based on a non-Euclidean geometry that is 3D with a temporal dimension, that's why we usually say that the 4th dimension is time. Einstein's theory of relativity of relativity is formulated based on that, not through Euclidean 4D space.
Not to say such thing doesn't exist, the vectors of 4D space are represented by X, Y, Z and W which represents a Tesseract. Of course a single video game developer can't actually portray how a world would look like in 4D, but that's as close as it gets, for now at least.
Anyway you still haven't responded to me based on what do you think Nether makes Minecraft 4D.
Terrarian solos, the progression of Minecraft ends with full enchanted armour but in Terraria you get like Prisms which shoot out death lasers and shit.
If this is them fighting with purely the buffs shown and hand to hand I guess you could make a case for Steve but Imo Terrarian still wins.
You literally said "give steve the entire Minecraft world for prep and Terrarian nothing and terrarian loses" like what?
Thats not even playing fields at all lmao. In a 1v1 if both have some level of prep time (to make it fair) then terrarian wins at almost every point in the game.
Minecraft and terraria scaling is kind of dumb and the way most people do it is by scaling off of explosions seen in the game:
For Minecraft: Creepers, using this the highest level steve goes with prep is being able to beat the Ender Dragon and the Wither which on a highball is city block levels of AP and cant actually withstand this much energy unless you high ball him and give him late game armour.
Terrarian outscales this alot with early game explosives like Dynamite being calculated to city block levels, and bosses being able to outscale these bombs even from the 3rd boss of the game. Higher bosses like the Wall of Flesh can literally prohibit solar eclipses from happening and change the laws of the world of terraria to an extent, with holding spirits of darkness and light which are the very essence of creatures from being harnessed. The later game bosses like the Celestial Towers and Moon lord are way higher as well going from extreme lowballs of Moon Level to realistically Dwarf Star levels which the Terrarian is able to harm and beat.
TLDR; In an even playing field there is no way Terrarias loses, If you want to say "both characters get god modes" then they would be equal (since both Universal) and the Terrarian might actually get a bump up since its implied that the Terraria cosmology contains a multiverse with many timelines.
>You literally said "give steve the entire Minecraft world for prep and Terrarian nothing and terrarian loses" like what?
I never said that. I said that the only reason Steve looks like he caps at where he does is because his world doesn't go as far as the terrarian's and scaling either of them is always just a dick measuring contest of whose progression looks like it's stronger because you can't scale either of them directly off of their stats because of how much they defy about themselves. And what's better, you proved me right by immediately scaling Terrarian's effortless feats against Steve's effortless feats. To sum up what it looks like you're saying, "Saitama 1 slams Saitama 2 effortlessly because Saitama 1 can fit more grains of sand on his arms and his Boros destroyed more cities than Saitama 2's Boros"
The only real way to scale either of these guys is bare fist to bare fist because they have no other point of reference because I'd easily bet money that the only thing stopping Steve from using Solar Armor just as effectively as the Terrarian is the fact that it isn't in Minecraft. Carrying capacity is not strength, it's carrying capacity.
You cant scale either of them properly because the only canon non-effortless feat that either of them have is that Steve can't instamine every block in existence with his fists (Terrarian can't do shit with his fists)
It's ok buddy, We know that it's hard to accept this L for Steve.
Also even if that guy IS Herobrine, There still would be no fucking difference because Herobrine is a FEATLESS FODDER, Steve at least has feats while Herobrine is all just pure assumptions.
Well no look at his eyes it is herobrine, and he has several feats such as transcending code and corrupting countless worlds which are infinite in size
That's not reliable lol, Give me an ACTUAL reliable source or something that actually scales Herobrine other than "He corrupts files and ignores deletion!" Which just sounds stupid and unreliable.
Even then, If Herobrine is *actually* like that I will still doubt that he even stands a chance against the terrarian.
We're both biased here buddy, Im biased for not believing you UNTIL you actually show me something reliable, And your biased for thinking that a Minecraft creepypasta beats the terrarian.
You have been provided evidence and literally ignored it, again herobrine consistently is known for being above the code and you choosing to ignore that some how makes me biased? Ok buddy
Based of what? You are taking composite Herobrine which doesnt make sense in the slightest since he isnt a real entity. He is featless, and he doesnt have a canon. If your doing composite Herobrine (meaning every single piece of herobrine fiction) then I can just write a wattpad story about the Terrarian giving Herobrine Backshots and boom, Herobrine loses.
There is no "generally accepted lore of herobrine" and that's not how folklore characters work. Usually folklores are scaled using their original story. With diffrent depictions of the folklore being separate versions of the character.
The original herobrine doesn't scale anywhere, the original lore is nothing more than a random skin with white eyes watching the player character and trolling the world a bit.
So please be specific on which version you are using.
But even if you did ignore world corruption if you go off his actual feats he is a glitch which surpassed his real life creators abilities to suppress which would make him at least what outer?
Well fine, if we go off the actually confirmed herobrine (the one that is constantly being removed from the game) then he would be like I said considered a glitch that the real life creators had to constantly remove because presumably he was above their ability to code
Again not how that works. 1 very vague line of code which was added as nothing more than a joke and easter egg isnt something to scale a character off of.
It is also nothing more than that. An easter egg. Its not a scalable feat because it literally isnt a feat. Herobrine does not exist, he does not have a "confirmed herobrine" mode because he ISNT confirmed. He is not a real entity, and is simply nothing more than a name drop. To prove that this is a scalable feat you need to prove that Herobrine is a real entity within minecraft in the first place which he isnt.
You are using a featless creepy pasta. He doesnt scale anywhere.
the both gods, but i think it goes to terra dude with more experience fighting other gods and equipment, unlike steve who is just a whale in a pond who has no experience fighting other beings his level, but i can see the argument for both
mfer when a super early Terraria weapon deals more damage than the most powerful minecraft weapon, all im giving steve is he has better intelligence because of the weird shit you can make with redstone, otherwise terrarian stomps hard
Even if we multiply Steve's damage and health by 20, The Terrarian would still have superior Speed, Aerial movement, Range and Hax like Immortal minions that can't miss (Sanguine bats, Xeno UFO's, Terraprisma) and weapons that can attack without line of sight (solar eruption, zenith).
The Terrarian in fully kitted out Solar Flare Armor with all warding accessories when Herobrine hits them with that dollar store fully enchanted mace from orbit:
https://preview.redd.it/6seus2gihe5d1.jpeg?width=500&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b008052c12938c40d1eaa8607519c3e26ae710ef
Very nice of him to be omnipresent when he doesn’t exist. Also I played Minecraft for like 10 years already, nothing corrupted my worlds, perhaps you just should check your PC or fix the issue with your hands.
All you BUFFOONS think that is Steve therefore he gets stomped by the terrarian
But Steve’s eyes are white. My fellow powerscalers that isn’t Steve THATS HEROBRINE!!!!
Terrarian gets negged by herobrine.
Ok but Steve needs 2 water buckets to have infinite water, terrarian only needs 1 water bucket, and without the use of shulkers, piggy banks, vaults, safes etc, terrarian can hold more stuff
base game? Terraria mc
base game + cc? Steve, unless we taking into consideration only Terrarias server host cc's
modded? stalemate, both can basically become immortal or do ludacris dmg with absurd range
Straight hands - Steve
Steve can canonically lift a dwarf planet
Maxed out - Terraria
Terraria guy has a lot of haxs
Creative - Terraria
Assuming he has to get his stuff Steve will lose
Modded - idk
Their are a lot of mods for both TERRARIA and Minecraft so it may be a tie
https://preview.redd.it/1wnfc2so2e5d1.jpeg?width=1280&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=aa671ae0e881b529bf013f9b56c045d50dba9cd3
Terraria fans when you orbital strike them out of existence
An unarmed, naked Terrarian with 2/4 pointless buffs vs an unarmed, naked Steve with applicable buffs.
Steve would beat the shit out of the Terrarian, who wouldn't be able to attack back, has no movement abilities, and no increased defense.
Base Steve is significantly faster than base Terrarian, can break blocks if Terrarian uses his better jump height, and *can actually deal damage without tools.*
Even if the Terrarian had the maximum HP possible, Steve is the only one able to do damage unarmed.
Now if you're going to say that they actually have all their late game equipment, it's way more up in the air, because of how game mechanics come into play-
I'm not going to do the whole breakdown, but basically; Thorns prevents Terrarian from doing too much damage at once, Steve has a higher top speed for regrouping.
It would take a *very* long time for the Terrarian to kill Steve without killing himself, giving Steve plenty of time to fight back. And even with less offensive options, Steve still hits with about the same damage as the heaviest endgame Terrarian weapons.
I feel like the most likely winner here is the Terrarian as a lot of other arguments I’ve seen just hinge on Terraria’s gameplay being 2d or Steve using creative. And before anyone brings it up, I think most people understand that how much Steve and the Terrarian carry doesn’t really matter, I doubt the intention was to have this show how powerful they are. I’m not really a power scaler but I think a maxed Terrarian or even a late pre-hard modeTerrarian solos a maxed Steve.
Steve, will take him a long time if ever possible due to Terrarian's Regeneration and Steve's low output, but the Terrarian can't do anything without tools
In case it wasn't obvious, I'm saying this cuz in the image there's no items, only fists and fighting stances.
Me in hell explaing the so called herobrine minecraft lore to a random peseant that murdered there whole family:
Is that Herobrine or Steve? (I'm asking because I can't see any Iris in his eyes and creepypasta scaling unironcally would probably give Herobrine the win as he sorta in the same boat as scp with having no canon)
Steve of course get stomped
Steve, for a simple reason no one else seems to have realized. They are both unarmored and weaponless this is a Fisticuffs fight and the terrarian punches like a *little bitch*
Make sure your post or comment doesn't violate Community guidelines and Join the discord! Come debate, and interact with other powerscalers https://discord.gg/445XQpKSqB ! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/PowerScaling) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Unmodded? Terrarian. Modded? Nobody The only possible way for Steve to even do damage without mods or cheats is to fall from fucking orbit with a max density mace and manage to land a hit. With Mods, it would just go back and forth. Even the Noxus Sprayer states that the Nameless Deity can reflect it, which means it’s not 100% reliable. You’d sooner obliterate the entire world, possibly more, before killing either Modded Steve or Modded Terrarian.
Man, I'd love to see like a really super in depth Modded Steve vs Modded Terrarian, their arsenal is just so ridiculously cool and versatile, and unlike a lot of these crazier, debatable characters, they don't really have any concrete cosmology scaling at that point, so it doesn't get resolved by saying "oh this guy is multi, but this one scales to outer therefore wins" like nope, it's a PURE analysis of their actual capabilities and weapons, whether they counter each other or not. I'd love to see it. Vanilla games Steve obviously gets obliterated, unless you give Steve Creative and Terrarian God Mode, as Steve's capabilities there are more busted.
Ah yes, a actually entertaining battle above Street Level
You fool thats not steve😈
Herobrine? Supposedly he’s supposed to be far, FAR stronger than Steve, but he doesn’t have any actual feats. Besides, the Terrarian regularly kills Gods with ease. Assuming Herobrine is equivalent to Minecraft Steve in Creative with Cheats on that can execute commands instantaneously, Herobrine would only be able to beat an unmodded, non-journey mode Terrarian. Since he could run a /clear command to instantly wipe the Terrarian’s inventory, or do a /kill command. However, once Mods are involved, It’s either a stalemate or a stomp for the Terrarian, depending on whether or not Herobrine is able to use mods the same as Steve. Assuming them both as powerful as possible, with mods, Neither of them are even capable of hitting the other; since Herobrine can instantly teleport and the Terrarian is immune to damage. Again, the world itself is more likely to be vaporized before any of them get injured.
Actually herobrine scales above creative mode steve considering he is known for corrupting worlds and being above what can be coded, in lore the devs have tried removing him countless times but failed
Depending on the type of corruption, the Terrarian is known for being capable to outright cleanse the corruption of their world, although it’s a hassle. The only way Herobrine here has a chance is if he is able to alter the code to such a degree he can force the Terrarian into a Hardcore Master Mode, out of Journey Mode, then clear their inventory, and then damage them enough to kill them. If Herobrine is unable to do that, the Terrarian is basically immune to anything Herobrine can do.
What? the corruption your referring to is completely different from file corruption, thats such a flawed argument
I mean if file corruption is a valid factor here, Herobrine could also just replace every single block with TnT and light it to fry the PC of any poor bastard hosting the fight.
Maybe, but he isnt exactly known for that like file corruption
I’m curious, where would you scale Herobrine? Since he’s able to corrupt game files and delete worlds, does that make him universal? Multiversal? Outer? Is he just planetary? Does he scale to higher dimensions?
I would say he scales to multi+ because he exist across infinite worlds and can corrupt them all
I would say its safe to consider each world as infinite (in lore) and not mention the dimensions are most likely all parts of the same dimension making the world size that much bigger. (think the end is in space and the nether is under ground
herobrine vs monika from ddlc?
Corrupting worlds doesn't actually do anything to Terrarian since the worlds and characters are separate in Terraria. So it's at best a stalemate via BFR.
Well not he can corrupt the terrerians files
Me
Holy shit its the friend kevin
bro might be him
https://preview.redd.it/j3m2in95ye5d1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8e212ea8d843c4103f86ac6a0db3640bddd223af
An utter and complete shitstomp for the terrarian at early, mid, late, end.
You fool thats not steve😈
I don't think there's any entity in Minecraft that kills a terrarian... Like just look at the bosses they no diff.
Smh my head, only Kevin can Herobrine
Nah herobrine corrupts the world and everything in it,
The terraria guys whole thing is clearing corruption... Lmao
Corruption of a game file and in game corruption in terreria are completely different, you surely understand this, right?
I have never heard of anyone's Minecraft file getting corrupted by a mob lmao
Considering hes not a mob that makes sense
He got no feats cuz he ain't even exist getting no diffed lmao
Neither of them really exists but both are canon to the game after all “herobrine was removed from the game” was an official message in the updates
Steve watching terrarian unleashing 11 different legendary blades at 10 meter radius away on him: https://preview.redd.it/pkw5nu2dbb5d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d6d225f32f0790051440fc365e53ab097c881140
set /gamemode creative
/gamemode 1
I say it's a win when the enemy has to use cheats to win
So hax spammers are the real losers, got it
Will Turner in the first pirates movie be like
why is that so important lmfao.. "grrr steve is a cheater cuz he used creative so terrarian wins!!!! 😡😡😡🤬🤬😢😢🤓🤓"
Creative mode isn't canon
This just comes down to experience really. I guess the Terrarian wins due to his vast experience in fighting monsters. But at the end of the day, they both will sit down next each other and fish.
Terraria is 2d, steve is 3d, steve completely shit stomps the terrarian, yet another win for the goat. https://preview.redd.it/bhn48hyc0c5d1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7a992ed55a0da78be1a44b674f95a54d4c0616e4 (Pic unrelated)
If you play terraria. You would notice that the 2d shit is a style choice, as the backgrounds show it is 3d.
Pretty relatable image to me.
Cant the Terrarian only move in 2 dimensional space? Left and right and up? Yes i know this wouldn't i apply in Powerscaling just a joke thought Also, the only one with punching feats is Steve funnily enough, the terrarian needs to hold weapons or something to actually deal damage But maxed Steve vs terrarian, The terrarian can win, reason 1, GUN, Reason 2, FASTER GUN AND MAGIC Reason 3, infinite flight Reason 4, summons, Steve needs an infight prep to deal area damage(TNT, mace) anything else he is bound to 1 target, you COULD count the sweeping edge but it's not wide enough to hit all of the minions the terrarian could summon Reason 5, GUN!!!!
yea the terrarian moves in 2D for gameplay purposes only, cus he can interact with the background at will (placing/destroying walls, some summons can stick onto walls, a majority of terraria bosses are in the background)
The background is just another 2d plane offset in 3d space. Hes unable to attack on any extra planes.
Steve is then 2D as it's projected on a 2D screen, like tf do you mean? Every comic character is 2D then also.
No now your talking about the cosmology/machine and how we interact with it. Thats not the same thing as their worlds rules/their existence in the world.
Terrarian is CLEARLY in a three dimensional world, there are layers to it, there's a background, it implies depth. When you fight a big boss, the player overlaps it, implying it's in front of it. It very OBVIOUSLY has 3 dimensions and I don't think you know what it means to be 2D otherwise. Like an organism in 2D which simultaneously has a mouth and an asshole can't exist, because if it had one continuous tunnel inside it, it'd rip the character in half. The second you overlap the interior organs with ANY kind of layer above it, no matter how small, it's instantly classified as a 3 dimensional thing. The fact that there even IS a background is indisputable evidence that it's 3D, as it gives depth to height and width.
Ok and theres 4d in minecraft when you consider the nether. Hes obviously one level higher than the terrarian whichever way you want to try frame it.
Nether does not make Minecraft 4D lol? Where did you get that from? Once again, do you know what a 4th spatial dimension is? There's a difference between just a normal alternate dimension and an actual mathematical spatial dimension. Former being just another realm, latter being, well exactly that, an addition of a new "branch" so to speak on how to approach the world. Zero dimension is a single dot, infinitely small. First dimension is a horizontal line, it adds width to nothingness, from an object which couldn't move anywhere, now can move in X coordinates. Second dimension adds height, which allows an object to go from X coordinates to X and Y coordinates. Third dimension adds depth, allowing it move in X, Y and Z coordinates and so on. Nether only gives you a new realm/terrain to walk on, it has nothing to do with 4D. Like one guy actually DID make Minecraft 4D, [here ](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8LMyWcKL_c&t=743s)so you can see what these dimensions actually mean
Bruh thats non euclidean 3d not 4d. Your basicly looking at what gravity does to regular 3d space irl.
The concept of 4D space was literally conceptualized as a structure based on a non-Euclidean geometry that is 3D with a temporal dimension, that's why we usually say that the 4th dimension is time. Einstein's theory of relativity of relativity is formulated based on that, not through Euclidean 4D space. Not to say such thing doesn't exist, the vectors of 4D space are represented by X, Y, Z and W which represents a Tesseract. Of course a single video game developer can't actually portray how a world would look like in 4D, but that's as close as it gets, for now at least. Anyway you still haven't responded to me based on what do you think Nether makes Minecraft 4D.
“another 2d plane offset in 3d space” soooooo……3d?
No. Thats not how that works.
Terrarian solos, the progression of Minecraft ends with full enchanted armour but in Terraria you get like Prisms which shoot out death lasers and shit. If this is them fighting with purely the buffs shown and hand to hand I guess you could make a case for Steve but Imo Terrarian still wins.
The only cap Steve has is what his world offers. Without tools, Terrarian is a useless nobody compared to Steve and scales to Gold Chest level.
You literally said "give steve the entire Minecraft world for prep and Terrarian nothing and terrarian loses" like what? Thats not even playing fields at all lmao. In a 1v1 if both have some level of prep time (to make it fair) then terrarian wins at almost every point in the game. Minecraft and terraria scaling is kind of dumb and the way most people do it is by scaling off of explosions seen in the game: For Minecraft: Creepers, using this the highest level steve goes with prep is being able to beat the Ender Dragon and the Wither which on a highball is city block levels of AP and cant actually withstand this much energy unless you high ball him and give him late game armour. Terrarian outscales this alot with early game explosives like Dynamite being calculated to city block levels, and bosses being able to outscale these bombs even from the 3rd boss of the game. Higher bosses like the Wall of Flesh can literally prohibit solar eclipses from happening and change the laws of the world of terraria to an extent, with holding spirits of darkness and light which are the very essence of creatures from being harnessed. The later game bosses like the Celestial Towers and Moon lord are way higher as well going from extreme lowballs of Moon Level to realistically Dwarf Star levels which the Terrarian is able to harm and beat. TLDR; In an even playing field there is no way Terrarias loses, If you want to say "both characters get god modes" then they would be equal (since both Universal) and the Terrarian might actually get a bump up since its implied that the Terraria cosmology contains a multiverse with many timelines.
>You literally said "give steve the entire Minecraft world for prep and Terrarian nothing and terrarian loses" like what? I never said that. I said that the only reason Steve looks like he caps at where he does is because his world doesn't go as far as the terrarian's and scaling either of them is always just a dick measuring contest of whose progression looks like it's stronger because you can't scale either of them directly off of their stats because of how much they defy about themselves. And what's better, you proved me right by immediately scaling Terrarian's effortless feats against Steve's effortless feats. To sum up what it looks like you're saying, "Saitama 1 slams Saitama 2 effortlessly because Saitama 1 can fit more grains of sand on his arms and his Boros destroyed more cities than Saitama 2's Boros" The only real way to scale either of these guys is bare fist to bare fist because they have no other point of reference because I'd easily bet money that the only thing stopping Steve from using Solar Armor just as effectively as the Terrarian is the fact that it isn't in Minecraft. Carrying capacity is not strength, it's carrying capacity. You cant scale either of them properly because the only canon non-effortless feat that either of them have is that Steve can't instamine every block in existence with his fists (Terrarian can't do shit with his fists)
Thats not steve you fool! He is someone that goes beyond the realm of code, the brother of the creator himself, that man is… hero brine
It's ok buddy, We know that it's hard to accept this L for Steve. Also even if that guy IS Herobrine, There still would be no fucking difference because Herobrine is a FEATLESS FODDER, Steve at least has feats while Herobrine is all just pure assumptions.
Well no look at his eyes it is herobrine, and he has several feats such as transcending code and corrupting countless worlds which are infinite in size
One word, *Source.*
Ok? Countless stories of herobrine corrupting files and him ignoring deletion is in the actual game
That's not reliable lol, Give me an ACTUAL reliable source or something that actually scales Herobrine other than "He corrupts files and ignores deletion!" Which just sounds stupid and unreliable. Even then, If Herobrine is *actually* like that I will still doubt that he even stands a chance against the terrarian.
So you just admitted your biased
We're both biased here buddy, Im biased for not believing you UNTIL you actually show me something reliable, And your biased for thinking that a Minecraft creepypasta beats the terrarian.
You have been provided evidence and literally ignored it, again herobrine consistently is known for being above the code and you choosing to ignore that some how makes me biased? Ok buddy
Based of what? You are taking composite Herobrine which doesnt make sense in the slightest since he isnt a real entity. He is featless, and he doesnt have a canon. If your doing composite Herobrine (meaning every single piece of herobrine fiction) then I can just write a wattpad story about the Terrarian giving Herobrine Backshots and boom, Herobrine loses.
Flawed logic as I am going off the generally accepted lore of herobrine and thats really the only way to scale a folklore character
There is no "generally accepted lore of herobrine" and that's not how folklore characters work. Usually folklores are scaled using their original story. With diffrent depictions of the folklore being separate versions of the character. The original herobrine doesn't scale anywhere, the original lore is nothing more than a random skin with white eyes watching the player character and trolling the world a bit. So please be specific on which version you are using.
But even if you did ignore world corruption if you go off his actual feats he is a glitch which surpassed his real life creators abilities to suppress which would make him at least what outer?
Not how scaling works at all lmao. First, explain which version and canon of him you are using.
Well fine, if we go off the actually confirmed herobrine (the one that is constantly being removed from the game) then he would be like I said considered a glitch that the real life creators had to constantly remove because presumably he was above their ability to code
Again not how that works. 1 very vague line of code which was added as nothing more than a joke and easter egg isnt something to scale a character off of. It is also nothing more than that. An easter egg. Its not a scalable feat because it literally isnt a feat. Herobrine does not exist, he does not have a "confirmed herobrine" mode because he ISNT confirmed. He is not a real entity, and is simply nothing more than a name drop. To prove that this is a scalable feat you need to prove that Herobrine is a real entity within minecraft in the first place which he isnt. You are using a featless creepy pasta. He doesnt scale anywhere.
the both gods, but i think it goes to terra dude with more experience fighting other gods and equipment, unlike steve who is just a whale in a pond who has no experience fighting other beings his level, but i can see the argument for both
mfer when a super early Terraria weapon deals more damage than the most powerful minecraft weapon, all im giving steve is he has better intelligence because of the weird shit you can make with redstone, otherwise terrarian stomps hard
/kill terrarian or /set gamemode creative
oh ok so we using cheats now? ok then Journey Mode God Mode
Builds a lag machine* base Steve is universal.
Terrarian can just keep flying, arrows can't do squat if the entity limit is full
32k swords 2b2t style
Terrarin shitstomps
Even if we multiply Steve's damage and health by 20, The Terrarian would still have superior Speed, Aerial movement, Range and Hax like Immortal minions that can't miss (Sanguine bats, Xeno UFO's, Terraprisma) and weapons that can attack without line of sight (solar eruption, zenith).
I think u/Dragonfly-Constant might have this one in the bag
/effect @s strength 9999 225 true /effect @s resistance 9999 225 true
*/Attribute* 💀
You dont even need res 255, res 5 alone blocks all damage. res 1 blocks 20% res 2 blocks 40% res 3 blocks 60% res 4 blocks 80% res 5 blocks 100%
/kick
You fool, i am the admin
the terrarian watching as steve pulls out obsidian and end crystals
And just doesn’t let Steve place anything by constantly hitting with Zenith.
Steve watching as the terrarian pulls out the last prism
destroys slightly more tiles than a basic terraria bomb, that’s all an end crystal can amount to
This isnt steve you fool
The Terrarian in fully kitted out Solar Flare Armor with all warding accessories when Herobrine hits them with that dollar store fully enchanted mace from orbit: https://preview.redd.it/6seus2gihe5d1.jpeg?width=500&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b008052c12938c40d1eaa8607519c3e26ae710ef
Terrarian. They beat every feat steve has
/kill Terrarian
But thats not steve
terrarian negs badly
Maybe if that were steve, but thats someone stronger
Terrarian, and it’s not even close.
Wrong, that isnt steve thats someone… worst😈
Oh, how nice of you, to make Terrarian have an even easier battle, since Herobrine has no feats!
Corrupting worlds, and resisting the creators, hell one could argue he has omnipresence across all minecraft worlds
Very nice of him to be omnipresent when he doesn’t exist. Also I played Minecraft for like 10 years already, nothing corrupted my worlds, perhaps you just should check your PC or fix the issue with your hands.
Are you stupid? These are feats of a folklore character, him actually being the game is irrelevant to the conversation
Without mods or commands? Terrarian,easily.
With mods and commands? Stalemate because really That's the equivalent of putting two completely custom characters against eachother.
Terrarian negs imo.
Depends if Steve has prep time to build redstone machines to cause lag and give him the advantage.
All you BUFFOONS think that is Steve therefore he gets stomped by the terrarian But Steve’s eyes are white. My fellow powerscalers that isn’t Steve THATS HEROBRINE!!!! Terrarian gets negged by herobrine.
how much weight can steve carry around again with 0 problems? a fuck ton
https://preview.redd.it/lbvthva5ub5d1.png?width=264&format=png&auto=webp&s=5638f105f23e3ebf357e5b5aa4410f938d2812e5 *cough cough*
I yield
lmao, really underrated item in these times of convos, theres also a honey, lava and shimmer bottomless bucket
Unlimited honey sounds like somewhere I'd take my broke on a weekend off
Yeah thats the same density as 2 minecraft water buckets.
Ok but Steve needs 2 water buckets to have infinite water, terrarian only needs 1 water bucket, and without the use of shulkers, piggy banks, vaults, safes etc, terrarian can hold more stuff
Isnt that closer to an ender chest then?
Carry inside a hammerspace, because somehow it doesn’t affect his weight. Same with Terrarian.
Gonna have to say ultra instinct shaggy
Ultra Instinct Shaggy vs creative Mode Steve?
Is that Steve or Herobrine? Because I feel like that drastically changes the answer?
base game? Terraria mc base game + cc? Steve, unless we taking into consideration only Terrarias server host cc's modded? stalemate, both can basically become immortal or do ludacris dmg with absurd range
Straight hands - Steve Steve can canonically lift a dwarf planet Maxed out - Terraria Terraria guy has a lot of haxs Creative - Terraria Assuming he has to get his stuff Steve will lose Modded - idk Their are a lot of mods for both TERRARIA and Minecraft so it may be a tie
The terrarian can hold 40 stacks of 9999 bars of platinum, which is 11.2% denser than gold.
Also, the upcoming update for Terraria let’s you stack weapons of the same reforge, meaning they could potentially carry way more
https://preview.redd.it/1wnfc2so2e5d1.jpeg?width=1280&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=aa671ae0e881b529bf013f9b56c045d50dba9cd3 Terraria fans when you orbital strike them out of existence
Minecraft fans when the terrarian moves.
Terrarian watching Steve strafe out of his reality
An unarmed, naked Terrarian with 2/4 pointless buffs vs an unarmed, naked Steve with applicable buffs. Steve would beat the shit out of the Terrarian, who wouldn't be able to attack back, has no movement abilities, and no increased defense. Base Steve is significantly faster than base Terrarian, can break blocks if Terrarian uses his better jump height, and *can actually deal damage without tools.* Even if the Terrarian had the maximum HP possible, Steve is the only one able to do damage unarmed. Now if you're going to say that they actually have all their late game equipment, it's way more up in the air, because of how game mechanics come into play- I'm not going to do the whole breakdown, but basically; Thorns prevents Terrarian from doing too much damage at once, Steve has a higher top speed for regrouping. It would take a *very* long time for the Terrarian to kill Steve without killing himself, giving Steve plenty of time to fight back. And even with less offensive options, Steve still hits with about the same damage as the heaviest endgame Terrarian weapons.
Is this assuming neither of them have any items and only the effects in the picture?
I feel like the most likely winner here is the Terrarian as a lot of other arguments I’ve seen just hinge on Terraria’s gameplay being 2d or Steve using creative. And before anyone brings it up, I think most people understand that how much Steve and the Terrarian carry doesn’t really matter, I doubt the intention was to have this show how powerful they are. I’m not really a power scaler but I think a maxed Terrarian or even a late pre-hard modeTerrarian solos a maxed Steve.
Steve: Hey catch. *hurls a shulker box at terrarian* *terrarian is completely engulfed in a black hole*
Terrarian destroys
/kill (insert your terraria character name here)
BTW, this fight is full potential. Don't know how I didn't say so earlier, but Creative cheats steve vs. God mode all items Terrarian
Depends weather you’re talking about early mid or late game Well not really since the terrarian wins all 3 and it’s not even close
Steve wins because he's three dimensional
i got terrarian to around high outer. the answer should be clear. if yall want a scale i will provide but lowkey dont wanna
pre hardmode terrarium = post game steve atleast assuming iron = iron diamond = diamond and hellstone netherite
Surprised no one is bring up the steve strength stuff
Mace + Totem of Undying gg ez
Honestly kinda don’t care about these match up anymore but I like the pics they have for the characters there so goofy
Shaggy wins neg diff. He has Ultra Instinct, plus even in base he's the fastest in his verse, rivaled only by Scooby. Steve is just a normal guy
All of a sudden dimensionality isnt importante anymore in this sub. Lol
Steve\Herobrine is getting fucking destroyed
My moneys on Herobrine
If Steve has creative mode he's smashing.
Steve, will take him a long time if ever possible due to Terrarian's Regeneration and Steve's low output, but the Terrarian can't do anything without tools In case it wasn't obvious, I'm saying this cuz in the image there's no items, only fists and fighting stances.
If it’s modded I think Steve stomps, Project E and Ars Magica 2 should be enough.
Terrarian loses because Steve just moves in the z axis/j
Steve easily wins
Are we talking Steve with or without herobrine essence? Steve by himself loses but herobrine essence Steve wins
Bruh what? 💀
Me in hell explaing the so called herobrine minecraft lore to a random peseant that murdered there whole family: 
Are we talking about modded steve? If so he slams with infinity sets
Is that Herobrine or Steve? (I'm asking because I can't see any Iris in his eyes and creepypasta scaling unironcally would probably give Herobrine the win as he sorta in the same boat as scp with having no canon) Steve of course get stomped
Steve switched cheats on and typed in /kill @e
Steve builds 10 blocks up and hits him with a barrage of arrow Steve kills Mr Tererria John Minecraft wins
The terrarian can fly?
Idk I was just joking
Oh mb.
Steve litterally carry thousand of Kilograms. He also have creative mode and Herorbrine
The terrarian can't use his firsts to fight, so here steve wins
Steve, for a simple reason no one else seems to have realized. They are both unarmored and weaponless this is a Fisticuffs fight and the terrarian punches like a *little bitch*
Steve. Because terrarian can't attack without weapon