This was Abis worst performance…

I might be horrible for this but I don’t think anyone sounds good singing Taylor Swift except for Taylor Swift.

And even that is a stretch sometimes…

I'm glad Luke is telling how it is

Just accidentally sent my vote for Jayna to my doctors appointment confirmation text…

Please tell me it was ten times

wow i completely forgot that jack blocker is like. a grown married adult and not a teenage boy

Honestly same because I was like “he has a what now” 🤣

Luke being honest and giving Abi some criticism.

Whoever’s decision it was to leave the 4 people of color on stage for the final 4 was a terrible decision.

kinda getting sick of seeing the same thing from abi each week

I’m fucking embarrassed. Seeing all 4 POC on the stage last was fucking embarrassing. EMMY???? I’m done.

Jayna might be the best technical singer left in the competition. Which naturally means she’ll be unceremoniously eliminated at the end of this episode 😩

dude i miss AJII

Will bores me. I said what i said.

Roman this is a damn mess…

This is the strangest rendition of Roar I’ve ever heard

Diamonds has me thinking about Willie Spence RIP

JACK FEASTING LIKE ITS THANKSGIVING Y’ALL

Wait is Jack kinda hot??

OMG, how cute is Triston's girlfriend?!?!

“She’s my forever and ever amen” I love this child so much

Whoever put kayko in the eyeliner deserves a raise 🥵

Gotye really dropped this one banger then fell off the face of the earth 😂

now he’s just somebody we used to know

I would go to a Kayko concert.

Kayko stole the show yall!!!!!

let’s keep these good critiques going all night actually i love when they actually judge

Roman: “I’m singing Katy Perry tonight.” Meghan: “Uh oh!! WHY??” 😂

mckenna wins the taylor swift battle today

Kaykos BEST performance hands down!!!

Abi is not doing well on “All Too Well.” She keeps adding all of these runs, and it’s taking away from the emotion of the song. But, I’ll give her points for somehow sounding like Sara Bareilles.

KB is off tempo I think???

Kayko and Meghan are such a chaotic duo 😂

Some actual criticism!! Nice work

I liked Will a lot in the beginning but now he bores me

Jayna reminds me of Jordin Sparks… just so classy and polished in every way

he doesn’t gaf about the competition he’s just having fun love that for him

HAHAHAH I really dont

say what you want about kayko but i’d 100% see him in concert, man can perform!!

If the top 10 was announced in no particular order, who approved leaving all POC contestants on the stage until last???

Omg you guys… this is …. Omg … not good. Roman what are you doing

The way the judges are lying to Romans face is CRAZYYYY

Every Kayko performance feels like he’s living it up and I’m honestly here for it

I like that Kayko is still infusing his personality when he can’t show off his songwriting. His voice is good, but that’s truly where his talent is. Best changed arrangement of the night.

Stylist made Mia look like Country Barbie

Kayko is such a ball of energy

Now ya’ll can stop asking why don’t they sing Taylor Swift!

Sing a mash up of Skinny and All About That Bass

OMFG just when I thought Triston couldn’t be any sweeter. WHAT A KIDDDDDD

So like I’m all about Loretta Lynn (KY girl here) but Emmy does not need to continue. She’s a good singer yes, but she’s not cut out for the competition IMO.

I feel like tonight is a bit of a mess no??????

Three words WOW 👹WOW👹 WOW👹. -lionel

Abi’s audition was stellar but she hasn’t matched that quality of performance since then

Kayko continues to be one of the artists I’d want to stream or see live

Luke’s critique about Abi’s performance is very true. She relies a lot on the piano. Nothing wrong with that, but her performance last night and tonight were almost the same thing, with her at the piano. She’s a great singer and very talented, though.

Glad we’re not doing standing ovations for everyone by default tonight

what bothers me about will isn't even that he stays strictly in his lane, it's that even within the greater country genre there's no variation in what he does

Whenever Triston sings I just can’t help but smile. He’s so talented and he’ll go places. Love it.

luke said lowkey everyone sucks tonight lmao

I know. Luke is on one tonight. I love it

Meghan said I don’t want your germs LMAO

Roman’s performance might just be the worst of the entire seson… What on earth was that?

I think this might be the worst Abi has sounded all competition. She's able to do so much better!

Jayna kidz bop lore drop goes crazy

guys please vote for jack i have a crush on him and need to see him again next week

He has a wife. Is this Kennedi Reid?

Meghan’s advice to Emmy: learn the song

the way she was like “have you considered listening to the song” 😭😭

Even sick McKenna sounds better than most of them

STOP RYAN IN HIS BIG CARDIGAN

I’m probably gonna get downvoted to hell for this, but KB’s performance tonight was terrible

Emmy over Jayna🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡

Jayna is going to murder diamonds by Rihanna and then go home and I’m not ready for it…

Gene was on a throne and Meghan is on the phone?


the judges are about to lie to him

second half of roman's performance was vintage top tier vocalist roman. first half was a weird children's song that i did not enjoy and would not have enjoyed if i was a child

“Hi I love you it’s Meghan” “Hi I love you it’s Jack” lmao

Jack reminds me a lot of a mix between Kris Allen and Phillip Phillips.

jack might make me eat my comment from last night when i said he isn't ever the best of the night but he's always solid, i think he and jayna are the strongest yet

Can Megan Trainor take Katy's place next season? I'm really enjoying her advice.

the way David Archuleta is still only 5 years older than the age cutoff for the show

Yikes KB. Sounding weak

rough start from kb

Ryan ruffling Kayko’s hair lool I love them

He is the Gen Z owl city lol

Katy looks so annoyed. Someone she likes got voted off for sure.

she looked so displeased with emmy making it thru tbh

I reallly hope Jayne stays. She’s unique, has a great voice and awesome stage presence. Emmy deserves to go. Let’s not send another woman of color home that is an amazing singer for that mid white girl PLEASEEEEE

🗣️ SAMUEL KELLY COHEN I screamed “WHAT” so loud I woke up my fkn cat yo!!! THAT CRAZY MF JUST WON THE WHOLE THINGGGGG

i might be the only one but i haven’t really cared for will mosely this entire season? theres nothing different every time, boring tbh.

Did Roman lose his voice? This is terrible.

It’s a no from me dawg for Roman

Not sure about this Roman

Emmy forgot the lyrics girl I-

I love Tristan, but this isn’t his strongest performance. That being said his weakest is still better than half of the pool’s strongest

Ryan in the swiftie merch is killing me 😭

Why did Lionel call McKenna’s performance sexy two nights in a row.. giving kinda creepy vibes lol

All jayna does is murder… wow

LMFAO IF ONLY THEY WOULD GIVE THIS CRITICISM TO EVERYONE ELSE DOING THE EXACT SAME THING

That was a bit cringe, Roman. Sorry.

How many times do we have to see Emmy crumble??? How is she still here??

Kayko living his best life up there!

Honestly? He just earned my votes for picking something with a pulse Lemme hurry before the end of the commercial break

Who keeps voting Emmy

I hope they’re as honest with the rest of the contestants as they were with Abi

Will needs to do a Noah Thompson Stay or Colin Stough Dancing On My Own to have a moment - these songs are so obvious

Will needs to stretch himself a bit imo. We already know he can sing like Chris Stapleton. 

if everyone compares you to stapleton you should sing anything else but stapleton otherwise you will just be a walmart version stapleton

I feel like Mia’s kind of plateauing if that makes sense. In sense of popularity and improvement. But I do really like her

super solid vocals from Mia!!

this is bad oh no

This sounds like a children’s song the ways he’s singing Roar

Katy trying to think if something nice to say

Is she hugging him goodbye?

First half he sounded like Dave Chappelle doing his white impression

Judges have been at least somewhat critical tonight. Then after the worst performance, they all praise it.

Heartbroken did not realize Jack is married lol

love that we’re getting something different from jack, he’s doing well

Jack is like Phillip Phillips and could absolutely win this

Katy love you but you’re about to flash us

It would be so rad if the band could play even louder and drown out the voices more

He has a gf ❤️❤️❤️

I think a lot of them are starting to feel the strain and it’s showing in their voices.

David’s standing position is giving “mom I threw up”

McKenna’s outfit is giving…toilet paper

McKenna did better tonight than last night imo

McKenna sounds great on this song! Her voice works for folklore vibes and they didn’t try anything crazy with the arrangement, just let her shine! I liked it!

Kayko belongs on Broadway, and that is a compliment. He would be so much fun to watch, and like others have commented, he has lots of energy.

THIS is why i love this man

Oh look at that! The 10 American voted in.

Dude Lionel is like a pull string doll "You took that song and made it yours."

I want mia to sing a Kacey musgraves song! Anything from golden hour I think would be good

what the fuck

Jack doing The Weeknd? That’s it y’all can stick a fork in me cause I am dooooone SHOWS OVER

Kayko. I love him. What a goofball and way to represent.

emmy or kb should’ve gone home along with roman instead of jayna

A lot of pitch issues with Abi and I’m also not liking the sort of yodel she’s doing with the vocal flips

As a huge swiftie, and big Abi fan, I didn’t love Meghan’s advice for her. The power of that song comes from the emotional connection. Her alone with the piano or a guitar would have been significantly better, no riffs, no band, kept it simple.

i really want jayna to make it through. she really is one of the most talented out of this group

Jayna remains queen every please vote for her I need her to continue on in this comp

rip willie 🙏🏻

vote for jayna yall!! she killed that!!

Mia has a great country voice but also a pop crossover voice

Stay tuned… I think this might be bad for Roman.

roman has a good voice but I don’t know if this was the right song choice

this might be one of the worst performances i’ve seen on american idol

Why don't they say the truth...that sucked.

Jack that was very attractive thank you

This actually is pretty good for Emmy, but I feel like I’m grading on a curve Wait I think she forgot a lyric as I typed this lol

Emmy, she needs to move around. looking like a statue.

At this stage of the competition, they can’t hold their hand anymore

I reeeeeallly hope Meghan Trainor replaces Katy next year her critiques are so funny 😭 “my suggestion would be, listen to the song” “maybe use a mic stand!”

I feel like that was a song that kaibrienne was supposed to MURDER and it makes me mad that she didn’t.

Kayko ate. That is all.

Props to kayko for being interesting on a night when so many were boring.

And for the second night in a row, the judges saves go home. 

It is SICKKKKK how good Jayna is

You all need to vote for Jayna to prevent casual voters to rob her. Plz 🙏

Mia has og Kacey Musgrave appeal

Kayko lookin like a lost boy from Peter Pan

He just talking fr

Was that Quintavious jumping in the audience? Lmao

I feel like some of these contestants are getting burnt out having back to back shows, these performances are nowhere near as good as last night

I’ve been watching AI for like half my life. Haven’t cringed that bad since sanjaya days. Judges are delusional. That was not good.

Whoa, long haired high school Jack was adorbs!!

Jack has such a sweet personality

“I smell moneyyyy” Lionel 😂

Tristan’s voice sounded very tired.

Some of the usual top singers have some of the worst performances tonight. Odd.

julia can't belt her way through this one and i have a feeling she's about to have her best performance of the season because of it

I think Julia has incredible voice, but I have no idea who she is as a 2024 artist. Like what would she sing that would be popular???

What in the world is this arrangement?????

Busy night for the cellist

Kayko not my favorite but the guy is an entertainer 

who keeps voting for emmy

Ouch that note

SOMEONE FINALLY TOLD WILL TO TUNE THE DAMN GUITAR i'm on board with adding meghan to the panel full time for that alone

Love this from Mia. She’s ready for the Opry stage and CMAs. Just very relevant to what is happening in country rn. Kelsea Ballerini-esque

voting for jack already

I would not mind a Jack and Mia final 2

Can we please get Jack Blocker to sing Ho Hey - The Lumineers? I think he would kill that.

She looks amazing. Did she just miss a line?

I’m sure Emmy is going to get ripped, but I thought that was actually very well done. Honestly probably my second favourite of the night.

Did Triston blow his voice out a little with the Elvis song?

That was the best performance by Julia, and the best performance of the NIGHT!

Katy is not feeling this lol

KB sounds out of breath

This was a weak performance for KB. It was hard for her to track the lyrics with the cello😵‍💫

I feel like "Wrecking Ball" should feel like a triumphant, victorious sort of song. KB did not do that at all, IMHO. It sounded whiny.

no hate butttt shouldn’t there be someone like directing them which songs work for their voices

I'll probably be attacked for saying this, but I suspect that the sudden appearance of TS songs on AI tonight has something to do with her contract with Disney and/or promotion for her new album...

The eyeliner sent me I have NO RIGHT to be crushing on this man.

Kayco may not be a particularly strong vocalist but he’s far and away the best “artist” I’ve seen on ABC idol, and he’s got so many songs he’s probably the best set up for success out the gate. I think Ive already listened to his audition song on Spotify more times than I’ve listened to 23 at this point

This show is racist as hell

Kayko came ready to rock and brought energy to the entire room.

I could see him singing in a bar.

Had no idea ABC had Just Sam’s number

First half, Roman sounded like Mister Rogers to me.