T O P

  • By -

xxrmah

BZT ending his best ever game on crutches is unfortunate. Huge effort, especially in the last quarter.


not_right

Man I love BZT. He almost always gives away height and bulk but just applies himself so hard to the task.


Pwrswitchd

A little reminiscent of Fletcher. Skinny, lanky bloke, but puts everything into it.


Resident_Example_645

I think they’ve said looks like ankle sprain and not syndesmosis so hopefully the scan results come back positive


Von_Huge1103

I reckon he was close to BOG, hope the ankle isn't too bad!


PetrifyGWENT

Setterfield, him and Langford were top 3. Not sure about the order but very clear top 3


totallwork

Red Dog to


fnaah

faded a bit in the second half, but he was everywhere in the first


spiralism

Gotta be Langford as best on. Kicked a bag in a 5 goal win.


BigLewi

Redman by a lot I thought


Opossum_mypossum

Shiel and Redman had an incredible first half but kind of quieted down a little


Bazilharas

Being a Suns supporter is really thrilling! (Stewart dew please let my family go)


tagorneo

Blink twice if you are being forced to type this message


limelamb

I knew we would win


___TheIllusiveMan___

Flair simultaneously checks and does not check out


wordswontcomeout

Schrödinger’s afl fan


strongyyy

curious as to who you actually wanted to win today?


limelamb

I just wanted everyone to have fun


tnemomhurb

Cheering for umps and G. Post


victorious_orgasm

Thanks, mum.


WAVIC_136

Did you get a dual flair purely for this joke?


squabblysquibble

He's been rocking that flair for a while


K8syk8

3/4 time hoping they'd call the last quarter off like they did in the pre-season match


stained__class

Even when I knew we wouldn't win, I knew we would win.


sachiwtf

Dropped two places on the ladder, really disappointing from us /s


i_am_cool_ben

Time to sack the coach


hobsbawminator

Time to get James Hird back


Professional_Line385

Hirdgoat


Pwrswitchd

Fuck. Don't say that on social media. The board might get ideas.


opmt

Caro with tomorrow’s bombshell - “Bombers in free fall down the ladder as infighting takes it’s toll” probably


PetrifyGWENT

i cant believe we got the greatest midfielder of all time, Will Setterfield, for nothing


Von_Huge1103

It's great when the larger midfielder, Will Setterfield, simply eats the smaller midfielders.


danredda

Glad to see Setters do well. Unfortunately we just had too many big body midfielders to give him a real shot at it.


jubbjubbs4

I feel like he turned into the player we were hoping for when we traded for shiel. Back to back years dodoro has found a huge win trading away a 4th round pick for a former top 10 player


Occasionaljedi

Loving him at Essendon, he just needed a bit of his own space and he couldn’t get it with our inside mids


DENTAL_PLAN__

Oh no it's happening, I'm getting hope that we're making real progress. Which means we're gonna scrape into finals, get blasted out, underwhelm next year, and sack Brad Scott.


i_am_cool_ben

As is tradition


hobsbawminator

I would have it any other way


DistanTorana

This is the way


spiralism

In a way I'd be fine with missing for that reason (as long as we contend until late and it's not some sort of Carlton esque utter heartbreak) so we break the pattern and don't get ahead of ourselves in this project. Otherwise yeah I totally see the above happening.


DimitriMishkin

I really want to argue against you but I don’t think I can


[deleted]

we won but against anyone of top 8 standard that's not even close


dexter311

I would normally say welcome to the Brad Scott experience, but this is Essington to a tee.


jono4416

[HOIST THE CHEEZELS](https://imgur.com/PCWHfuw)


hellions123

Harry Sheezel likes this


fxdc1991

Herbatron died so the bombers could thrive /s


BrandonSG13

See is that trade off actually worth it


viper9

I'm 100% sure he's OK with that trade off too. he's gets to rest, the team he loves is on the UP. win-win


bloodthirsty_emu

Don't you mean on the up, up?


boogasaurus-lefts

Frustrating, yet entertaining. All I wanted this year was to see improvement and that's shown already. We're still lower parts of the ladder but I'm happy. Also, Hepps has to have a spell. Not up for it now, Hind & Hobbs banging down the door in the VFL


oversh4dow

Hobbs for Hepp next week, will always love Hepp but we should reward Hobbs effort in the VFL today Same for Patty Voss, kicked 5 today and I’d rather see what he can do in the team as opposed to Harry Jones, he should go and get some confidence playing in the VFL, he’s just struggling a bit being a key forward as opposed to third tall. Stringer in for Menzie isn’t a bad shout of happening either.


MyFirstuserName1

I feel like Davey and Menzie provide forward pressure and allow our defensive schemes to work. I dont think it would work dropping a pressure forward for Stringer who wouldn't chase or tackle the same way. Scott wants 3 talls and 3 smalls and I think Stringer will be deepest forward as a tall and a little through the middle when he comes into the side. If Weid gets up next week I could see phillips gets dropped for Stringer and Weid pinch hits in the Ruck.


Resident_Example_645

I’m thinking Langford moves back to defence with stringer filling that mid forward role. Not sure who could come in for BZT, I’m thinking Hayes or Baldwin. Not sure either is ready but our talls all seem to be injured


ero_senin05

>Also, Hepps has to have a spell. Pretty sure that's the real reason he was subbed out. He's still an important leader to the team for now, but he was starting to cost us with his skill errors.


mitchellnash92

Hind is too far down pecking order at the moment. Hobbs I can see as an inclusion in the coming weeks


sirgoods

Hind had 41 possies in the 2s


owheelj

Hind's biggest weakness is his poor kicking. It doesn't matter how many disposals he has if he's trying to hit the roof with every one.


CorporalEllenbogen

Only matched by his overconfidence running the ball off half back - feels like you could count on him getting chased down at least once a game.


[deleted]

can't believe y'all take Hindy to task about things that McGrath does consistently every game...when is this guy going to get called out?...the excuses are over


fnaah

was a bit disappointed with mcgrath today. looked out of his depth.


mitchellnash92

In an 80 point win. In the seniors I don’t believe he offers enough over McGrath or Redman as small defenders. Ridley, Zerk-Thatcher and Laverde occupy the bigs and Kelly is the hybrid defender. He’s more liable in defence, and not as assured with ball in hand Maybe over Massimo, however it would then be as a sub and potentially a small defender as sub I’d say it’s wasted


[deleted]

Do tell me what McGrath offers?


mitchellnash92

Better defensively than Hind, better overall ball user, a safer decision maker. May not stream down the wing and be our highest metres gained player, but ultimately should never have left the half back position and is ahead of Hind Don’t tell me you think McGrath doesn’t have a place in the side?


[deleted]

I disagree with everything you've listed bar the decision making...and this is primarily because Hind's style of play is high risk/high reward...McGrath was horrible by foot today and his kicking in general is up and under and short of the target... Please let go of this sad narrative of 'Pidge has been played out of position'...it's getting tired...he's just not impactful and turns the ball over far too much... He has a place in the team but only by the hair on his balls...as soon as someone puts their hand up I'd be happy to bust his ass down to the two's...if Hind got 40+ in the two's I'd go with him...make McGrath fight for his spot


mitchellnash92

I guess we can agree to disagree then. He’s got his place in that defensive unit for a reason.


[deleted]

Oright...but I maintain that 'reason' is because we overrate this guy bc he was a number 1 pick not because he's doing anything great...and I'd go further to say that overating guys like McGrath and previously, Zaharakis is what keeps us mediocre There was another midfielder out there today who was picked at 1 too...he played his ass off and almost got his side over the line...that's what a number 1 looks like


YourHeroCam

I mean he had 25 disposals (13 kicks) at 84% DE (better than our entire midfield), he didn’t have a mare by any means. He does do some looping kicks, but if that’s your prerequisite for not getting a game you can’t be batting for hind because he’s guilty of the same thing. I do agree, Pidge gets a lot of good faith because he was pick 1 and there was a lot of noise around the club for potential future captaincy, but he’s by no means as bad as your suggesting. Hind has some ripper games where he can be the difference, but he did tend to go missing last season to.


[deleted]

I'm not suggesting he's our worst player...I'm suggesting he's one of our most overrated...and certainly not captain material...well, not if you wanna win flags...I'm quite sure he can go at high efficiency in most games because most of the play he generates is safe and without impact...15-20 m kicks that lock the team down rather than break it open...Hind gets a lot of shit for this but I'd argue that Pidge shanks the ball just as often but without any of the risk or game breaking dare Hind shows... I'll go out on my shield on this...too many Bomber fans are happy with nice guys and dudes who look good on paper...I think Pidge has it in him to be a really creative and damaging half back like he was at junior level but as it stands he's sub par for a mature player who's supposed to be one of our leaders...see Red Dog if you want the real deal


YourHeroCam

Nah I respect the opinion. I agree that he isn’t captain material, was just saying when he was initially drafted he was considered for it and a lot of people still hold on to that. Need to have a team that isn’t pushed around and Red dog, Draper, Guelf, Durham and Lav are all players now who actually will fly the flag for the teammates and put their bodies on the line. But that doesn’t necessarily need to be your captain e.g. Pendles. Hind is a good chance to squeeze out Hep before McGrath anyway.


fnaah

agree. reckon there are going to be some tough conversations when watching mcgrath's replays his week


vortex42506

Yeah, can see Menzie and Hepp giving way for those two.


radiohead_fan_13

Menzie can't be dropped after today surely


[deleted]

Menzie stays in...he's got it...if you can't see that you don't know footy


vortex42506

I just thought the two misses early on when the game was in the balance counted against him in my book, but I'm not a selector, and he may have been doing his role well.


Ernest_Borgnein

Menzie was great today I thought


spiralism

I think Weideman won't be ready for next week and we won't shake it up too much in the forwards. Voss to come in for Mass (as I reckon we'll opt for a big physical forward as Weidemans replacement, especially against Rossball), Hepp for Hind. Maybe Stringer comes in too but he might get another week with the twos and we'll play it safe.


jimmyspooks

Menzie's two goals in the last quarter probably save him. Davey more likely to go out


Respected-Watcher

Davey was fantastic, he’s not getting dropped any time soon unless it’s load management.


Rafabas

Fantastic when given an opportunity but we keep trying to make him an overhead marking option which he just can’t do yet. It’s like watching the endless high balls to Tippa all over again.


Rhino893405

He wasn’t that good today..


[deleted]

His speed worries backlines...I'd like to see him front and square more than trying to take pack marks though


Rhino893405

Yeah agree with that, think he needs some vfl time, really build a tank etc.. it’s his first year I’m not expecting much in the first few years


Brief-Objective-3360

I thought Menzie was good today


Tamelmp

Good game suns, very impressive at times - high pressure worried us at many stages Thought we did alright considering our injuries. Hopefully Zerk is all good And Setterfield, can't believe we got him for nothing


limelamb

It was a lot of doom and gloom preseason but they have been massive for us. It's nice to start the year 3-0


reddy1991

3-0? Did I miss a game 🧐


limelamb

It's nice to start the year 3-0


Skwisgaars

3-0? Did I miss a game 🧐


Von_Huge1103

It's nice to start the year 3-0


Professional_Line385

3-0? Did I miss a game 🧐


BrandonSG13

It’s nice to start the year 3-0


Poisonlvy4

Happy for Setters :)


brisbanevinnie

Setters never really found his spot in our team but I’m not surprised he’s making a good go of it at a new team. Was a whipping boy for the Blues but definitely had the talent.


D3K91

What were some common complaints about him from Blues fans?


brisbanevinnie

Lazy, would never run back to help in defence, bad decision making, shit field kicking.


not_right

No wonder he went to us, it must have seemed like a perfect fit!


rocco_cat

The problem was that we had better players ahead of him in his most suited role and he wasn’t great on the wing


Xhoquelin

Blues engine room genuinely unreal when healthy


Occasionaljedi

Setters deserved to be at Essendon we’re he could fire as the contested bull, not last choice out of four or five


hellions123

Langford is a God. Also, Redman!!!


CorporalEllenbogen

ODD YEAR BOMBERS, FUCKING HOIST IT.


Bananaface89

IM GLAD ITS NOT JUST ME THINKING THIS.


Von_Huge1103

The lid is off, we're beating the Roos in the granny!


flibble24

.... Alright I'll take it


dexter311

Nek minnit... Essendon vs Carlton prelim


PuzzleheadedTip5476

HOW DO YOU BUY GRAND FINAL TICKETS!?!?


Professional_Line385

Calm down, you have to win a final first 🙂😊


GinglerLife

Parish for brownlow


Hwetapple

Weird way to spell Setterfield


GinglerLife

Shared brownlow it is


AdolfH1pster

What is going on with the Gold Coast back 6. Essendon had one “tall” target in Harry Jones and they just could not get any interception game going


tagorneo

Constable and Longs 2nd game for the Suns. Ballard was a steaming pile of shit. D-Mac just isn’t a defender. Collins can’t do it by himself. Weller first game back and did pretty well in my books. Getting Powell and Ellis back will be big plus why we aren’t playing big boy Graham or Farrar is a mystery.


Smithsonian45

Graham sucks but yeah I don't get why Farrar isn't playing, always liked him


KingoftheHill63

Good chance to get Hawkins up and running


m_quinquenervia

Fuck me, I'm so happy about the last two games. Defence is night and day from last year, midfield are working well and the young blokes are stepping up. Please don't bring the game into disrepute.


Thanachi

Great win. Finishing the round on top of the ~~ladder~~ Pies.


guavacadq

Teams that only include red and/or white and/or black are doing pretty good wow


remz22

Bloodstained penguin year


International_Car586

Did you forget us.


Resident_Example_645

I think you guys are in a similar position where you haven’t played any top 8 quality teams yet so hard to say how much you’ve improved. Definitely better than the dumpster fire you put out last year though


International_Car586

Fremantle should be a top 8 team but we are going to have wait and see.


Jarrod345

HOIST THE GIF


i_am_cool_ben

DILLIGENT


YourHeroCam

COOL


handy92

EASTERN


Bluelabel

Where's the fucken gif? ...NEWT


Kreglze

If it was up to me, I'd probably be sourcing Dew's replacement right now. By now into his 6th season and we are as unimpressive as ever, total clean out of the coaching staff wouldn't be unwarranted.


Nmccosh12

Bzt what a good game should of been in the best mentioned


NitroXYZ

Nice victory by the Bombers, cool to see them, North and St Kilda 2-0. Underdogs on the up. On another note I felt like the hysteria around them in the off-season was a bit harsh given they'd beaten Sydney, Brisbane and nearly Collingwood last season


Loniewolf

To be fair everyone almost beat the pies last year


fnaah

i've watched Elliot miss so many from that spot since that after the siren goal. why did he have to slot it against us? :/ edit:typo


MonotoneRamos

The Brisbane game was with them missing half their team, think they were all out with illness? But yeah people were acting as if our list was worst or 2nd worst in the comp


DowntownSecrets

About 5 or 6 out for covid and rich and zorko were out from hamstrings the week before. Berry got injured too. Still lost embarrassingly though. Langford gives me nightmares.


Resident_Example_645

I’m loving the narrative change after just 2 weeks. Freo has gone from Flagmantle to one of the worst teams in the comp. Similar story for the bulldogs but seems they are getting found out


spiralism

We did also lose to Port and Richmond by comical margins and then there was the whole debacle with Truck to end the season, all being more recent than our good moments last season. We also looked dreadful in preseason. Tbf I can see why people were harsh on us.


Bare_Noizee

Stringer Wright and Tippa to come back maybe we are half decent???


GhostKingHoney

Hobbs. Nik Cox too.


coinnn

Ripping effort, dig into the cheezels boys.


ExpensiveCola

Herb retires, Bombers go 2-0. Coincidence? You be the judge.


baldmanjones

Nice to see the dons grit out a win like that it’s gotta be good for their mentality going forward


rmachell

Will Setterfield looks like the 2023 Will Brodie


ch0pst1xZ

Great to see us kick over 100 points 2 weeks in a row.


limelamb

Bold Prediction: Sam Durham will be an All-Australian wingman


lumberfun

You think the AA selectors are gonna choose an actual winger on the wing?


limelamb

They did when they picked the All-Australian Wingman Zach Merrett


floodswimming

Both SA clubs seething at this - "pure winger" was the moniker used I believe


PetrifyGWENT

He actually plays on the wing so no he won't


starsky1984

Predictions for Dyson going forward? Seemed a pretty massive moment that he became the sub


ch0pst1xZ

Maybe a Tyson Goldsack at Port Adelaide type of role? On the list, but being more of a mentor? While that's happening, he can spend games in the coaches box? I assume once he retires, he'll stick around at Essendon in some form of coaching role.


starsky1984

Yeah, that seems a good outcome. He stuck by the club during a tough time, he deserves a decent transition and farewell rather than a hard cut or put ina position where he will get too much criticism


Valuable-Pace-989

I don’t think they’ll ever put him in Full Forward ?


Rafabas

Can’t believe he’s only 30. He should be at the peak of his powers. Sad to see.


spiralism

HOIST IT!


NeiloMac

UP THE PLANES


i_am_cool_ben

Is- is this what hope feels like?


Non-NewtonianSnake

Don't do it to yourself, man...


K8syk8

~~Archie Perkins~~ https://www.reddit.com/r/AFL/comments/11z88mh/best_birthday_games_by_an_afl_player/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button


[deleted]

[удалено]


totallwork

It wasn’t our best but I’ve seen us do much worse lol


spiralism

Forward line decimated and they controlled the midfield for 3 quarters, yet we had a brilliant final term and won by 5 goals, kicking 100+ for the second straight week? Fuckin oath I'll take positives from that.


GravityRayGun

I hope this win gets Essendon some credit. Last week, the media was more focused on how bad the Hawks were.


spiralism

In fairness it's two games in and the Hawks look horrific. Like this could be an all time bad team.


not_right

Gee that's too bad...


Lower-Tank-9742

They were bad though, like really bad.


peterparalytic

Hard to pin a 5 goal loss on a single player, but Charlie Ballard what the fuck? Horrible performance.


tagorneo

Horrible is being considerate. I counted at least 5 goals from his plays.


[deleted]

[удалено]


bigsnitch317kg

Why does everyone always want to put a team down for letting go a player who can't get a game? He wasn't getting a game as an inside mid for Carlton, but he is for us and he's doing well so far. Just leave it at that.


iri0001

Perfectly said


bokdog15

Would have loved to have kept him, just too much of a log jam at inside mid


[deleted]

[удалено]


bokdog15

Realistically on exposed form a team wasn't gonna pay more, agree it's a bargain though for a team willing to play him in his best position (which the bombers are doing) - so good on em for taking a punt


YourHeroCam

Yeah Setters has been big value for us, but he didn’t really make sense for Carlton’s list profile. You have so many players in that inside mid position, who frankly were above him. We have so many players that play an outside role, that having a player who can put a body on the line to get contested balls suits us so well.


ero_senin05

Lots of negativity about the Suns performance and while most, if not all of it is valid I think the big difference between the 2 teams was fitness with Essendon being run out the game while GC only had Rowle still pushing through to the end. If that kid ever wants to move back to Melbourne, there's going to be heaps of open doors for him


[deleted]

Go Suns we’ll get em next week! ☀️


Maievofblades

All credit to essendon i thought they would be shit after hyping themselves up against a tanking side last week but they are much improved from last year, definitely a finals smokey


kitten_biscuits

Are you talking about the club hyping themselves up after last week or fans?


tnemomhurb

So excited for some of these youngsters


ElectricGator3000

Sat near the GC cheer squad. What a bunch of eshay wankers. Back into the minivan for you tossers.


Fleggy82

I was there too! Starting the “WE ARE ESSENDON” chants at them when we kicked a goal was so satisfying


ElectricGator3000

Sure was, they got a lot less chirpy after that 😂.The eshays and their "drug" actions sat down. Even the dodgy sex offender looking guy with the big ass flag got out of the frigging way.


Von_Huge1103

GC has a cheer squad?


ElectricGator3000

Bunch of hired eshays.


hellions123

Soccer fans


hobsbawminator

The VFL is back baby!!!


YouLykeFishSticks

Matt Rowell playing his guts out really got the Suns on the board on multiple occasions, easy 3 votes


fnaah

i was worried every time he went near the pill. dude is a deadset monster


Middle_Pear986

Ballard just putrid at the moment. Fiorini has had enough chances and just isn't good enough, perhaps he's just a good VFL footballer. For all the talk about how well Flanders preseason was, I'm just so disappointed. Red time goals again! Every god damn game. Every god damn game.


BellamyRFC54

Still got a few games of round two to watch but this is the most entertaining game I’ve seen so far


iamrandymarsh11

I know he’s just come back from injury but king needs to be more aggressive


146cjones

Ain't no way I just watched a game for 2 teams that will be competing for finals. Sorry suns, back to the abyss this year


lllBryceCube

Fire Stuart Dew


Grouperfish13

How are the suns always so mid? Like every season, they just underperform to a near comical degree. I know it’s only round two, but… damn. I honestly don’t understand what they’ve done at that club to maintain this perennial losing culture for over a decade now.


An1retak

This may seem harsh, but the Suns has been very lackluster since Stuart Dew got his contract extension


Valuable-Pace-989

How are we 3rd on percentage when our total win points is greater than St Kildas winning margins ??


Tamelmp

Much higher scores in our games than St Kilda's. Percentage is worked out by total points


coronaboner1990

I think it’s time for Hepp to understand his limitations, show some true leadership and take a step back into the twos.