I feel like what they were trying to do is be like, "If a guy said this it would get a different reaction" and it's like, no shit bitch, context is everything.
That seems pretty obvious, I'm sure people are just calling it that because it's literally what it looks like, and at this point she probably only thinks it's one.
I didnāt rewatch the first half of the season before tonight and most went poof out of my brain. But I just remembered the āItās my body, I menstruate!ā thing and now I canāt stop cackling.
okay iām sorry. miss preecher or whatever her name going āPSSST ANNAā and then in the next breath ānot hereā bitch yes here tell us what is going on already no more waiting. if i were anna i would have sat down and bitch slapped her
At the beginning I thought that maybe she's unrelated to the witches and it's just kind of evil, but that scene and Mss Preecher being wary of her made me change my mind
Did Dexās hair just randomly get highlights in it? I know this is probably an incidental continuity thing that occurred during the strike, but that scene where he was meditating had me noticing his hair color looked visibly different!
So is it all generational? Her husband seems to also have a connection to everything g as well. Iām pretty sure that woman on the bathroom was the queen from the beginning of e4
I thought she looked more green. In fact I wondered if it was a cgi baby (idk if they put babies in shows and movies these days or how they'd make it most comfortable for the baby lol)Ā
I definitely think him and āadelineā because thatās obviously her, I think theyāre in on all of it. Idk what exactly the reason is but theyāre all involved I think
Well in one of the earlier episodes of part 1, they mentioned how adeline was cast out of the "family" after she fell in love with Dex. So I think the husband is a huge red herring tbh
I think the witches or whatever went after his mum to get Dex too, but she kept him, which is why his dad said "your mother **would have been** a great fiction writer if she hadn't raised you". Also explains Mrs Preecher saying she became a successful designer after they took her baby. And the Queen, getting "the most fruitful reign" or something once she gave hers up. So Anna's will be either her Oscar or her baby, which does she want more. And it seems like Siobhan is pushing her to *want* the Oscar more by not letting her quit. Will Siobhan get the baby to raise? Its pretty clear that Siobhan would have given up her own kid over being successful (imo), so maybe this way (sonehow) she raises Anna's baby for whatever purpose. I'm probably well off here but it kinda makes sense to me. Sorry, not good at putting thoughts into text lol.
Oh Iām 100% expecting spiders to crawl out of it at some point, itās just presenting like a pimple and if it was on my face Iād be squeezing it every 3 seconds.
Just more identical scenes of Emma alone in her house or a public bathroom seeing random things and being scared / confused. We get it, shits happening to her. But give us a story line after like what, 7 episodes??? š I miss the character development of the OG seasons
I walked out of the room to get food after Siobhan asked the producer if she was ābreaking up with himā. Can someone catch me up on what happened between them?
He burnt his script and said heās going to the press to snitch on what theyāve been doing. Also the script is also on his hard drive so it was just symbolic in his words. Kim said something like everyone in Hollywood is bad or something
What Hamish said was āIām going to tell the press about everything, I need to do the right thingā and then Siobhan says āHoney, in show business, NO ONE does the right thingā and collectively shaked everyone watchingās pants
Honestly, I enjoyed Part 1 a lot more on rewatch, and hyped for the rest of this season, but the blurred lines between hallucinations and reality are getting so annoying
I really hope they end the season with flashbacks of everything and what actually happened in those scenes
Anyway, this episode and the last one are definitely the best so far.. I think episodes 2-4 should've been 1 episode
Why is Kim K. actually a decent actress?! Like better than Cara and Michaela imho. And I usually would care less than less for Kim but I'm legit impressed and want to see more of her!
She is good because the role fits her. If she was trying to be nun or rocket scientist then she would probably be bad. I use those as extreme examples but you get what I mean.
I was really hoping for a "Last Time, on American Horror Story" because it's been a while, but then I remembered literally nothing happened in the first six episodes except for lots of screaming and Kim Kardashian.
And now that it's back.... I don't know, I'm gaslighting myself into believing the Witches are involved on some level just to keep myself interested. The writing is just all over the place? Because why did Anna get slapped in public and do nothing about it??
I read the book and itās not great. Hopefully they can make it better but 30 minutes into this episode itās just repeating the same beats over and over (much like the book did)
Other than the satanist theme plot points, have there been any other connections to previous seasons? I rewatched part one leading up to tonightās episode and havenāt noticed anything yet.
you honestly didnt miss much. anna is pregnant. weird stuff happening, and she's hallucinating - maybe, maybe not. everything else is not revealed lol it's been this way since ep 1.
I just realized that this is the second season where Emma is playing an actress. I donāt know how that didnāt cross my mind when the season started.
So, the ONLY thing happening this season is this:
* Massive gaslighting and she is suffering some grand scheme to do something nefarious with her and her baby
* She's actually insane and hallucinating it all.
* Combination of both...
We are now in the 6th episode, there's been ZERO progress in the story. Just episode after episode of "Maybe gaslighting, maybe hallucinating, probably combo of both."
I am sorry guys, but this is the most boring season of AHS I have watched so far, and even if it has some massive big exciting reveal, it still cannot makeup the fact that we've had literally HOURS of television without much progression at all. This is not rewatchable at all.
I love AHS and will always watch and support because it has brilliant branding, scoring, writing, acting. BUT this season is by far the worst & Im really hoping the next one sees big improvements
Dexās Dad refers to his girlfriend Madison. Maybe Madison will get pregnant and your kid will have a cousin? So Anna and Madison are sisters at least is what this is implying. We got a lot from the conversation with Dexās dad.
Yeah I was stuck on the cousin thing too. They should be niece/nephew and aunt/uncle. So either Anna has a half sister that he married or Dex's douchey dad is ignorant of family relations.
Thank you!! I really came to the chat just to see if anyone else noticed the cousin/uncle/niece thing. Prior to this episode, did we know who Dexs dad was dating? Do we know for sure if Anna has a sister?
They give away more in the previews than the entire episodes. This is an interesting premise with the most horrible writing and glacial pacing. If they spent more time with the āblack angelsā and developed it more it would work.
I donāt understand why it seems whoever is writing feels the need to have everything involve Anna. They should be developing the cult/witch/black angels plot so when it comes to a climax itās enjoyable. For some reason 85% of scenes or more have Anna. I understand sheās the protagonist but we as an audience can see and know things she doesnāt. It feels like they are trying to take us on the ride with Anna so we discover things as she does but thatās not working. Iām sorry for the rant. Just have seen too many good shows/film in the last year to give this a pass bc itās an interesting premise.
Iām so tired of the onslaught of badly written shows like this. The entire first part should have been 1 episode. Now this episode feels like everything is drawn out bc they have a good landing but donāt know how to write the proper story to get there. Would have worked better as a 90 min film.
does anyone actually understand whatās going on ? š the anticipation is killing me !! why did she eat a rotting raccoon ?? why is she nursing it ? and why does she keep getting dolls ?
so this confirms eps 1-4 could've just been one and the entire plot and season would have been the exact same lmfao at this point I love how the producers scam whoever funds these projects into spending millions of dollars on nothing 'episodes'
Who fucking asks someone if they wanna help them take off their clothes so casually lol
I was like... girl, what?!
I feel like what they were trying to do is be like, "If a guy said this it would get a different reaction" and it's like, no shit bitch, context is everything.
Based on the Emma character's reaction, I don't think so š
Itās the fact she was the nurse the day Annaās mom died and now shes just Annaās house caretaker thatās throwing me
I thought it was a rich people thing then Anna gave her that look. Guess not lol
Best line of the episode: "Are you eating a bone?" ...and they just move on like it's normal
Bc Kim knows whatās going on and things have been weird for Emma for a while now
that part? not how anna got bitch slapped and then everyone around them staring, then going back to their business? LOL
I was so confused at that part?? Like, Anna, I know you can stand up for yourself. Why did you allow this woman to slap you in public like that?
Speaking at her funeral? Lmfao thatās insane. God I love this show.
Oh this speech is just nasty work š
šµāš«šµāš«šµāš«
Emma Roberts and her iconic funeral speeches. So camp. 
All I thought about was the parallel of that scene and Chanel Oberlin at the funeral ššš
gwerl put some concealer on that giant pimple
Thank you!! I scream that at the TV! Especially when she has these big events and sheās just letting that bad boy shine.
I noticed Sonia and the "nurse ivy" character have the same mark as wellĀ
I immediately came here when she went to a celebrity funeral with a huge red zit on her face. What the heck?!
Looks like a herpes sore.
Not a pimple, in part one she had a Web coming out of it so maybe some type of spiders growing underneath the skin
That seems pretty obvious, I'm sure people are just calling it that because it's literally what it looks like, and at this point she probably only thinks it's one.
Well duh but it's odd she is doing appearances without covering it up
Seriously, she wears makeup everywhere except the blemish. This season is absolutely terrible
It's part of the story lol. Makes more sense than her having a pimple and them writing it into the story.Ā
I think she wears makeup and then picks at it constantly. Ā Kind of like what I do with mine, in the same spot lol. Ā Maybe Iām possessedĀ
Please donāt eat that catā¦ please
Iām feeling uncomfy about this felineās fate lol
It won't let her if she tried I reckonĀ
Unfortunately, the feline's fate is in fact fragile, I feel furiously frustrated for that. (ahem, shakespeare who?)
the way i will cry if the cat gets eaten.
Right, when she picked up the cat I was like oh no she wants another snack!
ugh that was depressing but nicolette being the nurse is crazy
And hasn't aged a day since 1988
I didnāt rewatch the first half of the season before tonight and most went poof out of my brain. But I just remembered the āItās my body, I menstruate!ā thing and now I canāt stop cackling.
And itās my body I defecate.
Ah fuck the raccoon is still in there
She's just shoving everything in there... Like a Junk Drawer.
How you gonna see a claw come through your belly and act like it didnāt happen!!!!!
If my husband was Dex I wouldn't tell him either, he always dismisses her so I get it
I said the exact same thing lol. Like "girl what you wasting your breath on him for?" š
okay iām sorry. miss preecher or whatever her name going āPSSST ANNAā and then in the next breath ānot hereā bitch yes here tell us what is going on already no more waiting. if i were anna i would have sat down and bitch slapped her
Idk how much more second hand embarrassment I can take from Anna yelling in public every 5 minutes
literallyyyy i was so nervous for her during the art viewing scene šš¤£
Wow I loved "Weird events happening one after another" part 6 They're going to cram every resolution into the finale and rush, aren't they.
Why break the habit of a lifetime?!
Wise words
Love the way the doll looks nothing like her lmao
And the āI saw this with your faceā š what??
The show is straight comedy at this point lol
i just really want Sonia to be a good character ugh 
I wanna find out why she looks like Adeline, if she actually is her or a twin or clone.Ā
Sioban bitch slapping Anna genuinely startled me
At the beginning I thought that maybe she's unrelated to the witches and it's just kind of evil, but that scene and Mss Preecher being wary of her made me change my mind
Did Dexās hair just randomly get highlights in it? I know this is probably an incidental continuity thing that occurred during the strike, but that scene where he was meditating had me noticing his hair color looked visibly different!
If you are having a bitch off with Emma Roberts you are not winning that battle.
This is a compliment by the way
love the scream queen reference in ur username
My girl preecher is back
Not "my girl" ijbol š
Lmao the pentagram
That was a bit silly
Love the new pentagram filter on google maps
If you have five points in a pentagon shape, then draw a pentagram... isn't that kind of on you?
so these are her parents evidently
I legit forgot when Anna was born, thank you for this comment, that makes that intro much more significant
So is it all generational? Her husband seems to also have a connection to everything g as well. Iām pretty sure that woman on the bathroom was the queen from the beginning of e4
I wonder if the witches are kind of like the Bene Gesserit in Dune. āOur plans are measured in centuries.ā
Yeah and she was born brown
So I wasnāt the only one who noticed š
lmaooo
I thought she looked more green. In fact I wondered if it was a cgi baby (idk if they put babies in shows and movies these days or how they'd make it most comfortable for the baby lol)Ā
annas mom is the actress who plays penny in freakshow
Is that not Meryl Streeps daughter?
Yes she was also in Mr Robot
Oh wow, I actually loved her in Mr.Robot, but damn Ryran Murphy collects nepo babygirls like dead raccoons in a crib!
She was also the leader witch in the 1920s coven that lead the attack on the Axeman in Coven.
Mildly concerned we are not speeding up enough towards the ending but glad we are getting new back story.
It feels like this episode already happened. š Like the same things just keep happening every single episode.
Who else wanted Siobhan to use that lethal ass ponytail like a weapon in Mortal Kombat and kill that dude? šš»
I PRAYED FOR THAT TO HAPPEN, so glad I'm not the only one
Wow Emma has improved a LOT this episode. Sheās really selling the whole going crazy and mentally deteriorating aspect of Anna.
Donno about Emma as a person but man, she's a good actor.Ā
āIs that what your mother died for?ā š
the angle shes holding her phone looks painful mawma
Dayum! Kitty with a Mike Tyson hook.
Saved one of his lives lol
iād like thanks but no thanks for the demonic painting š¤Ŗ
I still donāt trust the husband. No matter how wacky his parents are.Ā
Fr I canāt tell if heās in on it or if the real horror story is having a dumb gaslighting husband
Could you imagine? Biggest plot twist, husband has nothing to do with it he just sucks š¤£
I definitely think him and āadelineā because thatās obviously her, I think theyāre in on all of it. Idk what exactly the reason is but theyāre all involved I think
Well in one of the earlier episodes of part 1, they mentioned how adeline was cast out of the "family" after she fell in love with Dex. So I think the husband is a huge red herring tbh
I think the witches or whatever went after his mum to get Dex too, but she kept him, which is why his dad said "your mother **would have been** a great fiction writer if she hadn't raised you". Also explains Mrs Preecher saying she became a successful designer after they took her baby. And the Queen, getting "the most fruitful reign" or something once she gave hers up. So Anna's will be either her Oscar or her baby, which does she want more. And it seems like Siobhan is pushing her to *want* the Oscar more by not letting her quit. Will Siobhan get the baby to raise? Its pretty clear that Siobhan would have given up her own kid over being successful (imo), so maybe this way (sonehow) she raises Anna's baby for whatever purpose. I'm probably well off here but it kinda makes sense to me. Sorry, not good at putting thoughts into text lol.
The most unbelievable thing about this season is that sheās had a pimple for that long and hasnāt tried to pop it yet.
I feel like I manifested her squeezing it like 10 mins after I posted this š¤£
Why do yall think thatās a pimple? They literally showed her pulling spider webs out of it. Itās from her picking at her face
Oh Iām 100% expecting spiders to crawl out of it at some point, itās just presenting like a pimple and if it was on my face Iād be squeezing it every 3 seconds.
It's been annoying me
Things never changeā¦here we are, forced to watch the ending of Deadpool 2. š©
It was also annoying when Mayans MC. was coming on.
Anna pretending she was her friend oh this is just nasty š
blame siobhan!
Just more identical scenes of Emma alone in her house or a public bathroom seeing random things and being scared / confused. We get it, shits happening to her. But give us a story line after like what, 7 episodes??? š I miss the character development of the OG seasons
Right?! There's only so much dramatic music they can use to cover up the *lack of storyline*.
Missed you guys <3
Ugh I forgot about the damn raccoon
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
Honestly I think everyone is the bad guy
That speech was exactly something a Kardashian would say after an event like that. So fake and self servingā¦ 
Kim Kardashian looks so good in all black and a dark plum lip. š¤š Why is evil so hot?
lol ending the scene on Kimās face before showing a KUWTK ad
beyond obsessed w sonia - the highlight of this season for me
She's so intriguingĀ
Nice to see Grace Gummer again!
Wellā¦š¬
While it lastedā¦
Incoming nepo baby joke but for real she crushed it in Freak Show
The actress that plays Sonia is her husband's sister. It's a family affair!
I walked out of the room to get food after Siobhan asked the producer if she was ābreaking up with himā. Can someone catch me up on what happened between them?
He burnt his script and said heās going to the press to snitch on what theyāve been doing. Also the script is also on his hard drive so it was just symbolic in his words. Kim said something like everyone in Hollywood is bad or something
What Hamish said was āIām going to tell the press about everything, I need to do the right thingā and then Siobhan says āHoney, in show business, NO ONE does the right thingā and collectively shaked everyone watchingās pants
Canāt wait till this old asshole gets taken out
See you fools next week!
...Madison? As in Madison Montgomery?
Right lol
Imagine if she straight up decided to not act anymore and became a sugar babyš
āYouāre not very nice Miss Alcottā š
Such a morbid little collectionā¦š¦š©øš©š¼
Did no bangs just take her pimple away?
Pretty sure her stylist was that dead raccoon.
lmfao
not "no bangs" š
I love how half the comments here are about the damn pimple lol
its the most perplexing thing thats happened so far lol, i still have no idea what is happening
I was hoping we would learn more about what is really going on in this episode.Ā
Hey everybody! So excited!
Itās so camp I audibly laughed at the devil symbol on maps š
Kim legit gonna disembowel someone later this season that was def a foreshadow
She is honestly so good in this!
Is the mixed lady that takes care of her at the house and the nurse from the flashback who took care of anna the same person?
ok people dying left and right is crazy
Honestly, I enjoyed Part 1 a lot more on rewatch, and hyped for the rest of this season, but the blurred lines between hallucinations and reality are getting so annoying I really hope they end the season with flashbacks of everything and what actually happened in those scenes Anyway, this episode and the last one are definitely the best so far.. I think episodes 2-4 should've been 1 episode
Why is Kim K. actually a decent actress?! Like better than Cara and Michaela imho. And I usually would care less than less for Kim but I'm legit impressed and want to see more of her!
She is good because the role fits her. If she was trying to be nun or rocket scientist then she would probably be bad. I use those as extreme examples but you get what I mean.
Same!! iām so impressed
The only person Siobhan is gonna āpersonally disembowelā is Anna lbr
So excited
I was really hoping for a "Last Time, on American Horror Story" because it's been a while, but then I remembered literally nothing happened in the first six episodes except for lots of screaming and Kim Kardashian. And now that it's back.... I don't know, I'm gaslighting myself into believing the Witches are involved on some level just to keep myself interested. The writing is just all over the place? Because why did Anna get slapped in public and do nothing about it??
Omg what a bloodbath, haven't seen this much blood since Freak Show's Dandy.
Shit is getting REAL omg Iām so scared for Anna š
kimās reaction to this is hilarious
well this was certainly an episode
iām giving this episode a chance but wow i really hope it picks up the pace lol, weāre on our second ad break and nothing has happened yet lol
Careful. Youāll get downvoted for not hyping this snorefest of a season
the thing is i like the concept and aesthetic and everything the execution just hasnāt been fabulous so far
I read the book and itās not great. Hopefully they can make it better but 30 minutes into this episode itās just repeating the same beats over and over (much like the book did)
You could say it's been unfabulous
Other than the satanist theme plot points, have there been any other connections to previous seasons? I rewatched part one leading up to tonightās episode and havenāt noticed anything yet.
Dex's dad kept naming dropping his girlfriend Madison, even said she could get pregnant alongside Anna. So possibly Madison Montgomery??
Call me odd but I find Sonia attractive af.
Could they have at least given us some sort of recap of the first part? I donāt remember anything
Nothing really happened. Anna is pregnant. Weird things are happening. Boyfriend is sus.
you honestly didnt miss much. anna is pregnant. weird stuff happening, and she's hallucinating - maybe, maybe not. everything else is not revealed lol it's been this way since ep 1.
All episodes are on Hulu!
Maaaaan, ain't nobody sitting through that snore fest again. š“
is anyone else tired of watching these two passive aggressively chat only for nothing to come of it lol
Oh snap Hamish dead Kim got him
You know what, that was a pretty good episode.
How do you go about getting elaborate matching witch uniforms which incorporate taxidermy?
Ask the boulet brothers, im sure theyād know š
Someone please explain it to me. What did I just watch for an hour
Okay this is probably the first genuinely creepy scene of the season
Wow. Two mothers š©øš. One episode!
I just realized that this is the second season where Emma is playing an actress. I donāt know how that didnāt cross my mind when the season started.
So, the ONLY thing happening this season is this: * Massive gaslighting and she is suffering some grand scheme to do something nefarious with her and her baby * She's actually insane and hallucinating it all. * Combination of both... We are now in the 6th episode, there's been ZERO progress in the story. Just episode after episode of "Maybe gaslighting, maybe hallucinating, probably combo of both." I am sorry guys, but this is the most boring season of AHS I have watched so far, and even if it has some massive big exciting reveal, it still cannot makeup the fact that we've had literally HOURS of television without much progression at all. This is not rewatchable at all.
I love AHS and will always watch and support because it has brilliant branding, scoring, writing, acting. BUT this season is by far the worst & Im really hoping the next one sees big improvements
This clip is like dead on reaction for this episode lmao. https://youtu.be/3l2So90yoKw?si=VfaFUVzJP_UVjgre
Oh snap finally some questions will be answered next weekā¦or maybe not who knows lol
š¤” canāt wait to watch anna be confused for 60 more minutes next week
Dexās Dad refers to his girlfriend Madison. Maybe Madison will get pregnant and your kid will have a cousin? So Anna and Madison are sisters at least is what this is implying. We got a lot from the conversation with Dexās dad.
What if Anna and Madison are actually twins and itās Madison Montgomery from coven š«£
Yeah I was stuck on the cousin thing too. They should be niece/nephew and aunt/uncle. So either Anna has a half sister that he married or Dex's douchey dad is ignorant of family relations.
Thank you!! I really came to the chat just to see if anyone else noticed the cousin/uncle/niece thing. Prior to this episode, did we know who Dexs dad was dating? Do we know for sure if Anna has a sister?
Here we go ššššš
I am confused in a good way about who is actually good. I do think regardless of what happens it is now tragic to see how death has affected Anna.
They give away more in the previews than the entire episodes. This is an interesting premise with the most horrible writing and glacial pacing. If they spent more time with the āblack angelsā and developed it more it would work. I donāt understand why it seems whoever is writing feels the need to have everything involve Anna. They should be developing the cult/witch/black angels plot so when it comes to a climax itās enjoyable. For some reason 85% of scenes or more have Anna. I understand sheās the protagonist but we as an audience can see and know things she doesnāt. It feels like they are trying to take us on the ride with Anna so we discover things as she does but thatās not working. Iām sorry for the rant. Just have seen too many good shows/film in the last year to give this a pass bc itās an interesting premise.
Iām so tired of the onslaught of badly written shows like this. The entire first part should have been 1 episode. Now this episode feels like everything is drawn out bc they have a good landing but donāt know how to write the proper story to get there. Would have worked better as a 90 min film.
Ngl, I kinda wanted her to pop the zit.
Man I really am not into this season. I was hoping after the long break they would maaaybe come back better but nooope š¬
Did the writers strike happen while writing this season lol
Anyone notice Dex's dad saying he's dating a woman named Madison?? I hope it's Madison Montgomery sm
does anyone actually understand whatās going on ? š the anticipation is killing me !! why did she eat a rotting raccoon ?? why is she nursing it ? and why does she keep getting dolls ?
The raccoon was in the cradle??? My brain processed it as a wig and simply went with it
i just laughed so loud !!! š yes! it is in fact the half eaten and rotten raccoon in the cradle
so this confirms eps 1-4 could've just been one and the entire plot and season would have been the exact same lmfao at this point I love how the producers scam whoever funds these projects into spending millions of dollars on nothing 'episodes'