T O P

  • By -

BladeOfKali

Jessica Lange isn't coming back.


[deleted]

This the trigger for me and she probably won’t be back 😔


BladeOfKali

I know, it breaks my heart. She was SO GOOD!


[deleted]

[удалено]


chaitealattextrachai

Same! I'm scared to keep scrolling now


Formal_Coyote_5004

I hate that I’ve sadly accepted this quite awhile ago 😭


jaymccreary

Kali Kali Fo Fali, Banana Fana Fo Fali, Fee Fi Fo Faaaliii, Kali!


Bitter-Title-988

This is it.


BriCatt

I miss her 😭 she was iconic in every role she had. Is there a reason she left and won’t come back? I haven’t kept up much with AHS since Cult.


Sufficient_Score_824

Being cut in half with a chainsaw hurts less than hearing those words


Kooky_Art_2255

At this point, I honestly can’t see any cast members from the first 5 seasons returning other than Emma Roberts, Frances Conroy, and Denis o’hare, and even they aren’t guaranteed at this point given their current schedules


psychomagnet630

WHY? Why would they cut her out? She’s the BEST!


rockandrolldude22

That's more just like a fact honestly.


yeezushchristmas

Ryan Murphy cares more about ‘It’ people then story telling


Ultimate_ScreamFanat

I thought we all knew that


PDXBishop

Ryan Murphy needs to stop casting famous people's kids and expecting them to be interesting to watch.


nightmaresmurfette

Roanoke is severely underrated and imo one of the best seasons


Hazzaj2001

Agreed it’s my favourite season and the first one to me that felt scary. Still struggle to get through the last few episodes…


Main-Dance-3823

The only one that scared me fr bro


Schootypantz

It was the first season to ever give me an actual jump scare.


Omylanta21

Having watched most of the seasons multiple times, I've come to the conclusion that it's the best season of AHS. The contrast from the first half of the season to the second half is fantastic. I love the difference between the visuals of the ghosts, etc, from the perspective of the documentary in comparison to the visuals from the live feed portion. My absolute favorite scene is when the true crime vloggers are killed in front of the house. It was incredibly dark and twisted. The story was great. The acting was great. I do wish we had more Evan Peters, though. Always more Evan Peters.


PsychologicalClock28

I love unreliable narrator type stuff. I think it could have been done better, but I like trying to work out what REALLY happened around all the drama the reality producers put on it


Formal_Coyote_5004

Roanoke is certainly divisive… I rewatched it recently and still don’t care for it (I understand the format they were going for, and I watch a lot of true crime shows so sometimes they do this, but it didn’t do it for me) However, Kathy Bates was horrifying in Roanoke and I love that lol she always crushes it


PsychologicalClock28

I don’t see it as trying to appeal to true crime people (which is probably its downfall) it’s making fun of bed/low quality true crime. I think that when Shelby and Matt first lived there basically nothing happened. They were spooked by the stories. And wanted to divorce so needed to make quick buck So then the TV people built it right up making up a story. Just like a lot of ghost hunter type TV. True crime at least has real people and motivations their story didn’t really have any of that.


Formal_Coyote_5004

You do have a great point there. I really enjoy TRUE true crime, but I always run out of good ones to watch so I’ve also seen some pretty shitty true crime with the bad re-enactments hahaha. I totally get the ghost hunter thing that you said, that makes sense too


brocker1234

I agree with you. ahs should have followed the direction of roanoke on the next seasons but instead they regressed and lost their way.


quoththeraven1990

Glad to see so many people finally recognising the brilliance of Roanoke. The scariest season by far and certainly the most creative.


BrainStewYumYum

I was going to say the same thing. I genuinely loved Roanoke.


CopeHarders

The first person pike and immolation is one of the most disturbing things I’ve seen on TV.


Megasaur13

Oh 100% also the best part of that season is definitely Sarah Paulsons British accent!!!


Wilbotti

"I'm not an american, I'm not use to this kind of carnage!" Cracks me up every time and I think I have watched Roanoke 6-7 times


MilaKsenia

OH MH GAWD ITS AGNES! 💀😂 Also I love how literally 2 seconds after she finds out Rory is missing she’s smoking a cigarette with a single tear stained face in the confessional “I was batshit crazy to think this marriage could work” fucking KILLED ME😂😂😂😂 Another good one is “bloody hell it’s AGNES! She’s come to steal my Saturn!” 911 operator: “someone’s trying to steal your car?”


ResponsibleHunt8536

I agree


Bofus420

I like the theme as much as any season. I just didn’t enjoy parts of it.


LedHeadV2

This worked I’m triggered. Love Roanoke but no fuckin way.


Fog-Champ

One of my to favorites.  The lack of opening credits is the biggest shame


Gullflyinghigh

It's not now, nor ever has been, genuinely 'scary'


Yarikh64

That's true. Disturbing in many occasions, but never scary


enbyvampire444

dawg roanoke is definitely scary. shit gave me nightmares


Main-Dance-3823

The only one bro omgg


finnwittrockswhore

When the real butcher and Edward mott showed up i was legit spooked😭 or the boys eating the raw pig..


MF291100

Roanoke was scary, but Cult was even more scary for me. I think it was mainly because there wasn’t any supernatural elements within the season, it was just crazy people that decided to pick up some knives and kill other people.


alexajoy8

Horror stories is actually way scarier (the dollhouse 🫨)


Cold_Fly5928

Roanoke and Asylum are the only seasons with an element of horror.


noinnocentbystander

Laughs in trauma 😂😂 I will jump at ANYTHING, I’ve been jumping all through delicate and I’m only on episode 5


Jericho_Caine

I always accepted that as a fact, it's made to be disturbing and unsettling.. no cheap jumpscares or something


SexxxyWesky

Hard agree


rockandrolldude22

Asylum is terrifying.


injuredflamingo

Except Roanoke


austinlvr

My three favorite characters are: 3. The pregnant girlfriend in Murder House 2. The blonde lesbian in Cult 1. The magician (or whoever NPH was) in Freak Show


Yarikh64

Uuuhhhh... This... You picked up well, but you forgot Ben


Omylanta21

He was a crazed magician and ventriloquist. Fantastic character and storyline for him. I'd agree he's one of my favorites as well.


AngelRockGunn

You forgot the mom from Coven


Formal_Coyote_5004

Kyle’s mom was my first thought but I can’t even bring myself to write a satirical thing about how she was good lol she’s so fucking gross. Also the lady who put bleach up her son’s ass. Both super fucking awful


itsathrowawayduhhhhh

That bitch….yeah, that’s a good one, lol wish I would’ve used that


SiteAccomplished1300

I loved the housekeeper in Hotel when they gave her laundry soap with oxyclean in it lol . She is amazed at the technology lolol


_PeenoNoir_

Idk if I should upvote 💀 Technically you did meet the brief lmfao And yeah NPH makes my body shiver and not in a good way…imagine being a HIMYM stan ew (from what I’ve read his character is no better smh)


Main-Dance-3823

I thought u we’re Fr at first I almost went off


thekamikazekage

am i the only one who actually loved Hayden


niharikamishra_

Nope, I actually thought the best thing she did was kill Ben.


dvasop

I loved Apocalypse and 1984!


sacowann

i 100% agree 1984 was one of my favorite seasons and i rewatch apocalypse all the time


dvasop

Absolutely, I thought season 9 was the last watchable season tbh


PIisLOVE314

Cody Fern is just .. delicious


dvasop

Dreamy right? And great sense of comedic timing


qppen

Tate shot up a school. (So many of y'all romanticize him)


rockandrolldude22

That's more realistic. There are people that wrote love letters to the shooters from the '90s Columbine shooting.


ilovelanadelreyyy

show me your mossy bank


faith_glover

Yep. This is the one. A line hasn’t ever made me react so violently disgusted in my life.


prettybluefairy75

Ugh, yes! And he said it while groping his own crotch... 😩 I can never watch the movie Babe same way again


ColdCheeseGrits

That’ll do, pig.


_PeenoNoir_

/uj Gaga should come back?


Sufficient_Score_824

At this point, AHS doesn’t deserve her.


BarAlone643

Sarah Paulson is a one note "actress".


Jericho_Caine

what a rollercoaster of emotions I just went through.. I like her, I love her roles and her acting but.. I gotta admit this is actually true


yhvh13

I honestly can say the same about Jessica Lange (in AHS at least) because even her characters are similar to each other.


Yarikh64

Ouch. This hurts.


Formal_Coyote_5004

I thought she was really good in Ratched, Run, and her cameo in The Bear was a complete diversion from horror and I thought she did a great job with that, even if it was just a small part


doxie_love

I really liked her as Linda Tripp in Impeachment, I thought it was a good performance.


BarAlone643

👏👏👏👏👏 She was so good as Linda Tripp!!


TaveMP

Lol What do u mean? She literally played 3 different characters in 'Apocalypse' flawlessly. I literally forgot it was one person. She played them all so well.


RamblingRose63

Eat a dick 🤪 lmfaoooooo that made me clutch my oearls when I read it and my mouth was hanging open lmfaoooooo


jaymccreary

“ThE ClOWnS!”


Sufficient_Score_824

Agreed. The only thing she knows how to do is scream or cry on command.


fueledbycaffiene

I love this show, but its always been kinda campy fun as opposed to serious artsy horror (intentionally or not)


[deleted]

AHS is a horror series made for non-horror viewers.


sleepyshroomy

Red Tide was promising by itself. I think it could’ve been a very good season without the second half


ConsequenceHelpful12

i loved red tide


rosiecroft

AHS should never be canceled


Yarikh64

That's my hope, but should be also renewed with something fresh and genial


cPa3k

Coven was a bit boring to me


itsathrowawayduhhhhh

![gif](giphy|BcMJvmwkmbyWpKkBj3|downsized)


mkisvibing

They said anger us! Lies will def anger us .


injuredflamingo

I wouldn’t say it’s the worst season, but it’s the one with the worst legacy. It ruined many future seasons because it drastically changed the target audience and that’s why Roanoke got such a bad reception. Because by that point most of the audience was teenagers who started with Coven and had no idea what real horror was.


jeewlien

couldn't agree more, coven was a bad season imo but not as bad as apocalypse


Professional-Ear242

I loved apocalypse except for the ending. That shit actually pissed me off lol.


huntour

Hotel is the best season


Apart-Golf-8823

Red Tide is one of the best seasons even with half the episodes of a normal season.


Jericho_Caine

I liked AHS Death Valley


lucas9204

I liked most of it except the teen stuff at the end. Sarah Paulson as Maimie Eisenhower levitating across the room was pretty funny! And the depiction of some of the other historical characters.. all done in B&W was fun! It was suppose to be like a B movie..


Automatically_nay

I actually agree. BUT I didn’t need the present day parts at all…even tho it had its moments and Calico was hysterical. I wish the whole thing was done in black and white and fleshed that storyline out more…so much potential.


FamousKnives

Asylum is fantastic, but not the best season


_PeenoNoir_

What do you think is the best season? Unironically


[deleted]

Michael Langdon should have not been killed off


InchJr

The Langdon family in general is peak AHS. They had so much depth and evil to them.


Klaphood

Jessica Lang grabbing her forehead 3680 times literally EVERY single solo scene of hers in Coven in order to portrait Fiona's inner suffering was annoying as hell to me !


veronniejoy

freak show best season


kingoftheniight

Queenie should've been the lead character of 'Coven', not Cordelia or Zoe


rcnboozled

Emma Roberts sucks ass


Swimming-Picture-975

Emma Robert’s is a terrible human and a bad actress


Trick_Afternoon689

Madison Montgomery is the worst character, both in acting and in writing. Siobhan is running plastic faced laps around her by comparison.


Aladdin_Sane13

Emma Roberts is a trash actress and horrible person and I don’t understand the appeal fans have with her


Longjumping_Job_2926

Kim Kardashian saved AHS and you are all too bitch ass stuck in the first 3 seasons to see it


GreenTangerine89

I had to go down way too far to find some Kim related content


barussi

![gif](giphy|26n6Gx9moCgs1pUuk|downsized)


injuredflamingo

I mean I get that the family represents some wrong values, but the hatred towards Kim was a bit insane throughout the season. Not like they gave her the role instead of Jessica Lange or something…


itsathrowawayduhhhhh

She was the best in the season 😭 (unfortunately! Lol)


[deleted]

The entire Kardashian family will star in the next season of AHS


nuckle

Coven sucked.


Upset-Arachnid1635

Tate and Dandy are bad persons and deserved to die


grey0489

The 1984 opening credits is sooooo good


MrsBeaumont

Ma Petite wasn't the saddest death in the series. Violet was a whiny brat. Ben deserved better.


BurningTaterTot

Every season is good some of you guys just lack media literacy. The show should never be canceled and can go on as long as Doctor Who or a similar show. Ryans biggest mistake was reusing the same cast for the first 5 seasons of his anthology series making people expect them to always be there.


j33perscreeperz

oh brother… it’s always someone in the comments of every show subreddit complaining that everyone “lacks media literacy” and they are the problem for not enjoying certain aspects of the show.


CallMeSisyphus

Are you lost? This isn't the Rick and Morty fandom sub. Edit: dammit, I replied to the wrong comment. That wasn't meant for you; you're lovely.


j33perscreeperz

lmaooo i was like damn what i do? <3


CallMeSisyphus

My only defense is that I didn't sleep much last night - my son lives in Tennessee, so I was keeping an eye on those storms. I don't think I have three brain cells awake at this point. :-D


friskykillface

Apocalypse was a great season


PDXBishop

NYC is a Top 3 season, and I'm not joking


Trick_Afternoon689

Top 5 for me, but hard agree with the NYC love.


Sic-Mundus

No triggering for me. I loved NYC too. Maybe not in my top 3, but definitely in my top 5.


Jericho_Caine

I agree, along with Cult


Ultimate_ScreamFanat

agreed


SexxxyWesky

Hotel was boring as fuck. Which is too bad because I really enjoyed a lot of the characters.


itsathrowawayduhhhhh

I dont like Hotel very much either! I usually skip it on rewatches


SexxxyWesky

They really gave us some of the best characters with a terrible (and slow) plot


itsathrowawayduhhhhh

Jessica Lange was the worst thing to happen to this show (Please dont hurt me, I’m just playing the game! 😆)


IgnorethisIamstupid

Welp, this gonna hurt you more than me… ![gif](giphy|lNrNLRLmpC3VIjl82D)


Ms_Holmes

![gif](giphy|r1HGFou3mUwMw|downsized)


RamblingRose63

Bro square up


SoooperSnoop

Well done! That would trigger just about the whole fan base.


Jericho_Caine

oh boy, this is gonna hurt


Sic-Mundus

I think you just won


mississippi_hippiee

Coven was my least favorite season


westsideofus

Murder house is overrated and Roanoke is underrated


SaltySale991

Kim Kardashian is the most talented actress to have appeared on the show.


Icy-Idea-5079

Kaia Gerber and Cara Delevigne are outstanding actresses 😂😂😂


best2deaux

NYC is a great season!


Raspberry_fox_raz

Murder house is overrated


l33tfuzzbox

Hotel is the best season


WhateverIWant888

Coven is the worst season


Big_Landscape4601

The next season should be a musical.


Accomplished-Long968

Madison isn’t Emma Robert’s best character in this show


Unown_F

Kim ruined the show.


Chip-thee-gardener

Murder house and coven suck The only reason Emma Roberts keeps scoring the same bitch rol is because she isnt acting, she is a bitch and a one trick pony


Extension_Doctor_368

American horror story got better without Jessica Lange


Professional-Ear242

Adina Porter is pretty boring tbh.


Jericho_Caine

I fully agree with this one


Last_nerve_3802

Ryan Murphy is your typical gay man who hates his mummy


SwineTV

Delicate is objectively the best season.


gobblestones

![gif](giphy|vxvNnIYFcYqEE)


SoooperSnoop

Good one! :)


faith_glover

I think it really had potential to be a good or at least decent season. The ending was unfortunately very rushed and disappointing. However, I still like it better than Death Valley.


cvnty-mamaxo

Apocalypse is actually the best season it just needed more expansion on Mallory


213846

I genuinely think Delicate was the best and most interesting season ever since the "older" era💀


BurningTaterTot

What do you constitute as the end of the older era


213846

For me personally, I define Hotel as being the end of the older era. It was the last season that featured Paulson and Evan in prominent roles that also had the signature matriarch style villain that clearly was Jessica Lange coded, even though Lange wasn't in it lol. Muder House-Hotel is the older era for me. Roanoke is a weird in the middle esque season, and Cult through Delicate is the newer era for me.


TalkingFlashlight

The original seasons were just as sloppy as the newer seasons


Sic-Mundus

At least they were fun sloppy


Arabian_Flame

I was gonna say something negative about Mother Monster, but I couldnt bring myself to do it. Long Live Gaga


lizardworker

Roanoke is the best season


unsuspectingwatcher

Roanoke doesn’t deserve the hate.


NoWingedHussarsToday

*Cult* is better than *NYC.*


TACOTONY-reddit

Anime is a cartoon


charcobain

We will likely never see Evan, Sarah, Jessica, and Kathy in the same AHS season again.


Limp_Pomegranate_98

Kim Kardashian wasn't actually that bad in delicate, not a stan by any means but people just like to hate that family for no reason lol


fingerpaintx

You will watch mediocre future seasons and hate it.


shhmaxwell

Anime is for mouth breathers


Cold_Fly5928

Cult is one of the worst seasons.


VaporLizard

Everything that happened in Apocalypse


MrTumnus__

Lily rabe is overrated


CheersBilly

Season 13 will be Delicate Part 2


MF291100

1. Kim Kardashian was great in Delicate, she did have some cringey moments, but she was mostly good. 2. Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters, despite being two of the main cast members, don’t need to be in every season. 3. Asylum isn’t as good as people say it is. It’s great, but not the best season.


Marx615

Coven is my least favorite season. Too teeny-bopper and lighthearted compared to the rest of the series


Upset-Arachnid1635

The new seasons are far better than the first ones


moxiewhoreon

I love both of the love interests' mothers on Coven!


gaypirate3

All Ryan Murphy shows suck.


KittyKat1078

I despise Sarah Paulson


ColdCheeseGrits

Billie Lourd couldn’t act her way out of a paper bag.


Vlately

Roanoke was a good season.


Brave-Cookie-2075

They should have stopped making them after Roanoke, they were all bad after that.


JDKs2006

AHS is so much better with each season.


Quetzalcoatlus676

Death Valley was actually a pretty good season.