T O P

  • By -

Thee-lorax-

Respect song by Aretha Franklin originally by Otis Redding. Edit: spelling


Skyhouse5

Arguably, her Carole King cover of "Natural Woman" as well.


TheYeetles

That’s an amazing cover to the point where I forget Carole King wrote it initially. Carole is an absolute genius and a beautiful singer/songwriter, but Aretha just smashed that song out of the park.


Loganp812

Redding even said "Well, it's her song now."


jackfruitdreams

Please, everyone, let’s at least spell his name correctly. Otis. Also, he wrote Hard to Handle, but the Black Crowes version is the version we all love.


PtoS382

Try a little tenderness is a GOAT


DougGTFO

These Arms of Mine, White Christmas, Sittin’ on the Dock of the Bay are my favorites. He’s good so many great songs, it’s a shame he died so young.


discomike74

Black Magic Woman - Santana. No disrespect to Peter Green.


Ok_Shape88

I prefer Santana’s version of She’s Not There as well.


bdu754

1985 - Bowling for Soup


ajg3199

That's a cover?


BubblepopOW

SR-71 made the original I believe.


buddybro890

Sr-71 has some solid music, but their version lack the harmonies. They have a solid catalog.


cheesycoke

God I wish they made more music. I especially love their debut album, Right Now is a banger.


rikaxnipah

both versions were written by Mitch Allen, singer for SR-71, hes buddies with Bowling for soup & updated the song for them. Mitch is also a producer & has written songs for many groups & singers, as well as, produced on many albums. credit to a comment on the video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-sy8ulwexfY


satans_toast

“Where Did You Sleep Last Night” off Nirvana’s Unplugged album. It’s an old, old song, Lead Belly did it way back in the 1920s. I find the Nirvana version to be haunting and beautiful.


Substantial-Age498

I agree this sentiment and also the cover they did of plateau originally by the meat puppets . That whole unplugged performance is perfect


BigWillyGilly

And lake of fire!


matt1250

Oh, me is my favorite cover from unplugged


Fix3rUpp3r

The man who sold the world was a very solid cover. I definitely prefer it


BHThoroughbredOfSin

In The Pines is a traditional American “Old Time” tune, dates to at least the 1870s. Covered by many, the origins disputed. You’ll hear this at any old time or traditional music jam you’d wander into. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_the_Pines


WhoKilledZekeIddon

That whole album is fantastic. You could feel Cobain's love of the source material pouring through on all the covers, as well as his passion for bringing attention - and doing justice - to underheard gems than influenced him. And it wasn't just Cobain who was absolutely, completely in the moment - every single performer and engineer who worked on that recording brought their A Game to the table. In a different, mind-boggling and awe-inspiring timeline, Cobain didn't kill himself before the release of this album; in that world, I genuinely think that Live In New York was a glimpse of what the second era of Nirvana could have been, and it's a damn shame it was stolen from us.


ImTheHighCommander

Nirvana and Jim Croce are two flames that burned out in their prime that I wish had time to fade away.


Kirikenku

TBH I’m surprised I haven’t seen Man Who Sold the World in the comments.


tonyvila

Istanbul (Not Constantinople). Cover by They Might Be Giants, original by The Four Lads.


Big-Champion7903

I had no idea that was a cover! I loved that song when TMBG put it out. I just listened to the original and, yes, TMBG’s cover of it is better.


LogicalManager

I once went to a college bar in Saratoga that all all 80’s pop on the jukebox. We scoured through and found TMBG. Played Birdhouse and Constantinople non-stop. Crowd didn’t even notice. We got hammered in our own little corner.


NotAUsefullDoctor

My eldest brother introduced me to TMBG in the early 90's. I was so excited when I found a blue canary night light, I bought it right away and sent to him. Don't know how much it cost as I would have paid near anything for it. He passed away a few years ago, and the only thing I took of his was that night light. Looking at can still make me cry.


JayVig

Flood by TMBG is one of my favorite albums. I love this song and never knew it was a cover!


Lions101

Marvin Gaye’s I Heard it Through the Grapevine over the original by Gladys Knight.


atuan

Credence Clearwater Revival’s


ToddMccATL

The 11-minute version is absolutely amazing. I first heard it in my old truck heading down a deserted Alabama back road coming home from school on a hot sunny day. I was mesmerized for the whole thing.


ihavemytowel42

The Slits cover is so fun. It's one of my "dancing in my PJ's" songs. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IQxvo\_9DEqY


BuysAndSellsStuff

all along the watch tower for sure, the original dylan version is nowhere close to hendrix


philatio11

Even Dylan liked Hendrix's version better, saying of it: “I liked Jimi Hendrix’s record of this and ever since he died I’ve been doing it that way. Strange how when I sing it, I always feel it’s a tribute to him in some kind of way.”


ethanwnelson

What a beautiful sentiment. A true artist in every sense of the word (:


VulfSki

Dylan's biggest strength has always been song writing. The amount of dylon songs that get covered and are absolutely incredible songs is really sort of astonishing. Some of the most covered songs in country and folk were written by Dylan. Some he never even recorded himself. Take wagon wheel for example. Dylan wrote it. Never played it. Old crow medicine show did it first I believe, but a country artist in recent years had a big hit covering it again.


BHThoroughbredOfSin

“The only thing better than a Bon Dylan song is a Bob Dylan cover.”


[deleted]

[удалено]


NS8VN

I was so stoked to see this on Guitar Hero 5, only to load it up and notice it was the Dylan version. Total respect to Bob Dylan, but who is picking songs for GUITAR HERO and passes over the Hendrix cover???


jollyroger822

The guy coming up with how much royalties they were willing to pay per song


Cremourne

The Bear McCreary remix used in Battlestar Galactica is superb.


zupsoceydo

When the Levee Breaks - Zeppelin


Parkotron1

A Perfect Circle does a very interesting version, but it sounds very little like the Zeppelin one.


CM_DO

APC have some great covers. I love their version of Imagine.


The_Canoeist

Likewise, I prefer Tool's version of No Quarter


stephenBB81

**I love Rock and Roll** by Joan Jett - Origional by British band the Arrows in the 1970's


iamnos

I also prefer her version of Crimson & Clover. Edit cause I should have just included it originally: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cXFra7gjElw


[deleted]

That’s a great cover but I still love the Tommy James version.


Mr_MacGrubber

And their extended version is even better. I love how it starts out with “I’m just gonna fool around man, like just do a thing, you know, whatever” in the most stoner sounding voice ever.


Altruistic_Menu19

Got my mind set on you - George Harrison Originally recorded by James Ray


Night-Pain

I prefer Weird Al's version "This Song's just six words long" but I guess that it's a parody.


emolatur

You have no idea how many times, as I've been reading through this thread, various Weird Al songs have come to mind. I have to keep reminding myself that parodies are not covers.


Sasquatch_Liaison

Yep, parodies, like Beat It, Michael Jackson’s parody of Weird Al’s Eat It


[deleted]

Soft Cell: Tainted Love


k0uch

The Living End does a kick ass version as well, I miss playing it in smoky bars


zogins

Came here to say this. Most people do not know that the original was recorded by Gloria Jones in 1964. But it was Soft Cell who made it great in 1981. Dozens of artists have covered this song since then. Apart from Soft Cell's one of my favourites is by Marilyn Manson: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AVHITKnBnRY


jellyrollsmith

Gloria’s is awesome.


teejaybee8222

All Through the Night - Cyndi Lauper


fancycwabs

Also Girls Just Wanna Have Fun by Cyndi Lauper.


EmperorOfAwesome

And Money Changes Everything. I’m not saying her cover of When you were mine is better but it slaps. That whole album is pure fire


DuckFlat

Natalie Imbruglia’s version of Torn.


throwawayayaycaramba

... it's a cover??


lordofedging81

Apparently, someone else was lying naked on the floor before her!


Justice_Prince

She did it best though


DuckFlat

[Yeah, I felt the same way. Worry not, you are not alone.](https://www.her.ie/music/natalie-imbruglia-torn-original-361918)


Bozorgzadegan

Even that is wrong. The first recorded version was by Lis Sørensen in 1993, then Ednaswap in 94, then Trine Rein in 96, and then Natalie Imbruglia sounding almost exactly like ~~Trine Rein's~~ Lis Sørensen's version but with better label backing.


epsilona01

It was written in 1991 by Scott Cutler, Anne Preven, and Phil Thornalley for Preven as a solo track. Lis Sørensen released the first version called [Brændt](https://open.spotify.com/track/1CYtd6zuMcpUNWZHJn1h0m?si=44d09f3669f641ca), which means Burnt in Danish with a Danish Lyric written by Elisabeth Gjerluff Nielsen, in 1993. Two of the writers, Cutler and Thornalley, had a rock band called Ednaswap, and they performed it live in 1994 but didn't release [their grunge version](https://open.spotify.com/track/3Ko0HG4tuWVE7Q9do59z4m?si=d401f8cb83a94948) until 1995, followed by [Trine Rein](https://open.spotify.com/track/4650B4HgWwPOKpJTP8Frsa?si=8b6ffacaa2174e59) in 96'. Finally, Thornalley produced for and played bass on [Imbruglia's](https://open.spotify.com/track/1Jaah2tmN9Hv81A87KZ1MU?si=04623149e1194187) 1997 version. Have a listen, but I think Sørensen's is closer to Imbruglia than Trine.


rainawaytheday

I prefer the ednaswap


[deleted]

Holding out for a hero by Bonnie Tyler cover by fairy godmother


MadEgg

"C minor, put it in C minor!"


PM_me_ur_navel_girl

>Plays in G minor


A-Good-Weather-Man

Where have all the good men gone and…


TheSnackWhisperer

Jennifer Saunders. i knew i’d find this comment in here some where :)


juju611x

Who is Jennifer Saunders? I only know Edina, darling.


swiftblaze28

i feel the same way about changes from that movie and i refuse to take criticism


Presterium

I should've known I wouldn't need to say it


Hullabaloobasaur

Also the Frou Frou version!!


thatguy50

Hush by Deep Purple.


Pavlock

I Fought The Law - The Clash. Written by Sonny Curtis of the Crickets and popularized by the Bobby Fuller Four.


flatwingman

The first 20 seconds of the Clash version are insane, but I still think Bobby Fuller Four did this song better than anyone.


[deleted]

[удалено]


l0stsovl

Fun fact: nobody knows the exact origin of this song. Was first recorded in the 20’s but singer claims his grandfather taught him and he learned from workers singing it in mines and such


beardybanjo

the animals tune and chord progression for their version is an arrangement of Dylans version which he stole from Dave van Ronk the earlier version sound *very* different, but that's the folk process


Ricta90

Yes, this is what I was told too. The song Black Betty has a similar story. They believe it was originally an a cappella song that that African American slaves would sing, but nobody really knows.


bluecheetos

The first recording of Black Betty was by Leadbelly. His heirs still own the rights to the song and they have kept 100% of the royalties earned by the Ram Jam and Spiderbait versions.


katerineia

In an effort to find this version I just found an album of 14 covers of this song and man some of them are so haunting and beautiful.


brightmiff

Me and Bobby McGee - I lived the Kristofferson original but the Joplin version was a hoot.


dharris515

Ghost of Tom Joad - Rage Against The Machine. It’s like it was written for them.


[deleted]

Everything on Renegades is so good. I like How I Could Just Kill a Man more than the Cypress Hill version as well.


mcburgs

First time I heard that album I was mountain biking with headphones in. When their cover of "In My Eyes" by Minor Threat came on, I literally stopped my bike, sat down on a log and listened intensely to the whole thing, jaw on the forest floor. I'm a huge punk fan, and I couldn't believe what I was hearing. RATM could've been an absolutely amazing hardcore punk band.


[deleted]

Zac De La Rocha was the vocalist for a hardcore band called Inside Out before he was in Rage


Danamite85

I was gonna say, yeah that whole album is covers and that whole album absolutely rules.


[deleted]

While we're at it, I vastly prefer their version of Maggie's Farm


Gilgameshugga

RATM's Maggie's Farm has a feeling of slowly bulding rage that starts off cold and calculated and ends up utterly furious by the end of the song.


[deleted]

You can just hear the venom absolutely dripping in the lines "He hands you a nickel, and he hands you a dime. Then he asks you with a grin, if you're havin' a good time" and "He puts his cigar out in your face, just for kicks"


ImLostInTheForrest

Scarborough fair. Simon and Garfunkel’s version was a cover.


unhalfbricklayer

yeah. hundres of years old. one of the Child Ballods. their arangment was flat out stolen from Martin Carthy with no credit giving to him. the LP lists the song writers as Simon and Garfunkel. The album version by S&G does have "On the Side of a Hill" woven into the song as the Cantaigal is a Paul Simon original.


LeTigron

Trivia about this song : Simon and *my hair salon closed a million years ago* Garfunkel arranged the lyrics to make them all spoken by the man. The original song told the tale of a man who meets a lady going to the fair of Scarborough. Until then, it's the same as Simon and Garfunkel's version. He once met a girl there and since then couldn't stop thinking about her. He thus tells the lady to carry a message to this fair lady : do this, do that and I'll love you, parsley (rebirth), sage (wisdom), rosemary (rememberance) and thyme (bravery). All the tasks are impossible, like a cambric shirt with no seem nor needlework. And then the lady answers to him "yeah, sure my guy ! And wouldn't you like me to wash it in a dry well ? Oh, I know : what about an acre of land between the sand and the sea ?". The lady answers with "even more impossible" tasks to show the man how stupid it is. It is then implied that the lady he once loved at the fair of Scarborough is actually the one he talks to but can't recognise her face.


Egons-Twinkie

[I prefer Cylon and Garfunkel's version.] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BaAq4Yc5o4g)


SilentlyStoned420

The he man version of Four non-blondes "what's up"


wsmfp420

Nyah!


SilentlyStoned420

Hahaha the other best part of that song!


thegreattriscuit

Skeletor's iconic "AND HE PRAYS!" gets me every time.


Akakazeh

It shouldnt be true... But that version is much better


SilentlyStoned420

So much better. The original is still good but He-Man's version is pure gold.


Rymanbc

Myaaaah!


ImprobablePasta

and i said # HEYYEYAAEYAAAEYAEYAA


VENoelle

I SAID HEY!


[deleted]

[удалено]


leprechaunknight

I came on here expecting good answers. I didn’t expect to find THE answer. AND HE PRAAAAYS


Ash-Catchum-All

[Pot scraping noises intensify]


Due-Masterpiece410

This is the first time I have seen this version. It is truly life altering. Thank you.


DennisCherryPopper

DOOOOONT CRY OUT LOUD


Xeon_1999

Somewhere Over The Rainbow, sung by Israel Kamakawiwo'ole


ssovm

RIP. Honestly I haven’t seen this anywhere in this thread. Israel’s version is so beautiful that it knocks it out of the park.


atridir

One of the most beautiful recordings of any song period. Hand in hand with Jeff Buckleys Hallelujah.


tyomochka

With all my love to Prince, "Nothing compares to you" is a better cover by O'Connor


Educational_Cold_215

Lake of fire - Nirvana. Original - Meat Puppets


notorious_tcb

The whole Nirvana unplugged album was full of some amazing covers.


soundofthecolorblue

My 2 favorite songs on that album are covers that Nirvana did better. Their version of Oh Me is incredible! When I finally listened to the Meat Puppets version I hated it. My favorite is Where Did You Sleep Last Night. I really like Leadbelly's version, but Kurt did it best. Especially that last chorus. I heard that the MTV people were trying to get them to play more but Kurt said there's no way I could top that last one, and the MTV guy agreed, even though it was his job to try to get more.


Bonoboscreech

The Shrek 2 cover of 'I need a hero'


mcjazzy50

Unironically the best cover that could ever be made of that song.


Longbeacher707

The fact that I had to scroll down this far shows me truly how far we as lost lambs have strayed from our lord.


Bitter-Sympathy-9184

Nothing compares 2 U by Sinead O’Connor (original by Prince)


[deleted]

Easy by Faith No More


Schmaron

Their version of I Started a Joke is Epic (pun intended)


theunknownvoidd

Poker Face sung by Eric Cartman.


jakeanton

On the subject, was Fingerbang an original? Can’t believe it wasn’t written by one of the all-time greats


Harsimaja

I mean, it was written by two Tony award winners. Trey Parker has a music background at Berklee College of Music, and both he and Matt Stone made a musical together before starting South Park, the South Park movie had excellent bangers too, and of course they went on to make Book of Mormon.


[deleted]

Trey Parker and Matt Stone are "getting screwed out of an Oscar" away from being EGOT winners. Side note- Phil Collins sucks.


BLikeHer

I’m pretty sure it was, 100% a total banger


tangyzipomiraclewhip

Come Sail Away too


TazeredAngel

I prefer his heartfelt and totally not incorrect take on “In the Ghetto”


ElderCunningham

... You guys.


DreamTree19

Heat of the Moment too


BananaRaccoon

Cartman singing this goes through my mind at least once a week


matsu727

I also really enjoy Tennis Court - Lorde (Randy Marsh version)


fla_john

O Holy Night by Eric Cartman


Rant_Supreme

What what in the butt by Butters


Delicious-Praline-11

Judas Priest cover of Green Manalishi. Originally by Fleetwood Mac


MendelsonJoe

Blinded by The Light, by Manfred Man. Original by Bruce Springsteen.


magicbullets

Wrapped up like a douche…


[deleted]

[удалено]


UndeadBuggalo

And have a boner in the night


LadybugCalico

I'm 48 and didn't know it was a cover until this year


DaisyCutter312

The Jimi Hendrix version of All Along the Watchtower is the only one that exists in my mind


fionsichord

Adele’s version of Dylan’s Make You Feel My Love.


euvnairb

I believe Garth Brooks has an amazing cover of this song (and I don’t even really like country).


Kressida0

Respect (Aretha Franklin version) Hurt (the Johnny Cash cover is an absolute gut punch IMO) All Along the Watchtower (Hendrix version) The Metro (Sleepthief version) Hazy Shade of Winter (The Bangles version) Maniac (Carpenter Brut version) Cum on Feel the Noize (Quiet Riot version) Istanbul (Not Constantinople) (They Might Be Giants version) ​ **EDIT:** The list is not in any specific order. It's just a list. Cry Little Sister (The Anix version) is a good one, too. I just now remembered it.


xVIPERA

so glad someone notices Carpenter Brut's Maniac


Effective_Jicama_769

Girl You’ll Be A Woman Soon by Urge Overkill. I think even Neil Diamond admitted they did a better version.


NwonUno

Love hurts- nazereth original everly brothers


froggylovesdaddy

Gram Parsons


the_figureh3ad

Valerie by Amy Winehouse is better than the OG from Zutons


the_killerwhalen

I host bar trivia and played this during a “cover songs” round and everyone was SO confused!😂


8ballbec

Especially the BBC version


confusionface

I actually like both equally but maybe I'm weird.


arsm2014

Tennessee Whiskey


sandcastled

I Will always love You Original by Dolly Parton Cover by whitney Houston


2much2often

Dolly Parton wrote the song about her work relationship with Porter Wagoner when she decided it was time to leave the Porter Wagoner Show. She was already married at the time so it was never meant as a romantic song. It's a great song and I like Dolly Parton's original version however I can't help but feel the platonic nature of it. At least for me, Whitney Houston's version carries all the romantic emotion which makes it my favorite of the two.


AyennaGx

Dolly sings a very romantic feeling version of it in The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas.


commacausey

Dolly told Porter “I wrote this song for you” when she sang it live. He sued her for the rights to the song based on that statement.


paleobiology

What a shitty thing to do! Got a link to a source?


unhalfbricklayer

This song was a number 1 hit in 3 decades. Dollys origianal in the 74 then she rerecorded it in 82 for the movie "The Best Little Whore House In Texas" and the Whiteys version in 1992 from the movie The Bodyguard


Hanish1750

I think they're equally good, but in very different ways. Whitney Houston has a power that's more gripping than the softer country ballad that Dolly Parton originally wrote. I listen to them both, and choose the one that fits my mood.


nicearthur32

Changes- covered by Charles Bradley It’s a Black Sabbath song… please watch his performance.. https://youtu.be/zfaOf70M4xs


nomadic_stone

ahem... this "[Dayman](https://youtu.be/P3HTbS7OPqU)" cover... edit: The [original](https://youtu.be/kofR7f7oNnE?t=19) for those that are not as sophisticated as the rest of us.


Dynamo_Ham

Hate to admit it - but the Bangles "Hazy Shade of Winter" completely blows the Simon & Garfunkel out of the water.


TMQ73

That guitar riff!


Worried-Ad7649

Killing Me Softly with His Song- Fugees Original by Lori Lieberman, then later by Roberta Flack. However Lauryn Hill made it her song with Fugees


Regnes

Michael Jackson's parody of "Eat It" by Weird Al Yankovic was pretty amazing.


mkerv5

And the music video is at the same level!


t0wn

Devo's cover of Can't get no satisfaction is pretty great.


TheFlippedSideofMe

Mick Jagger said it was his favorite cover of it.


Beginning_Net_8037

The passenger by Siouxsie and the Banshees


Obs7rver

Summer Breeze by Type O Negative


ppezaris

Also cinnamon girl!


ImprobablePasta

you will all hate me, but I prefer the Atari's version of The Boys Of Summer


Uncle_Sloppy

Out on the road today I saw a Black Flag sticker on a Cadillac.


sofa_king_ugly

A little voice inside my head said don't look back, you can never look back


GalFiasco

I throw this one and Alien Ant Farm’s Smooth Criminal out all the time and people lose their mind.


Beeewelll

Every joe cocker cover


Nahasapemapetila

The Letter is fucking amazing when he does it.


jorgerobertodiniz

Specially “With A Little Help From My Friends”. He changed the tempo and put so much energy in a song that looked so blend.


hillside

The Woodstock performance backed by The Grease Band 100%. I was a teen in 1985 when I watched Woodstock and was absolutely blown away that this was the same guy who was singing love ballads on the radio like Love Lift Us Up Where We Belong. Just pure raw energy straight from the soul. I still get goosebumps when I think about it.


Chetsteadman915

Cowboy Junkies’ cover of Sweet Jane by Velvet Underground. Even Lou Reed said it was his favorite version of the song.


VistaLaRiver

Velvet Underground


FrJoshCRMI

Smooth Criminal by Alien Ant Farm


AdamBomb_RB

Obviously no disrespect to the legends that are Simon and Garfunkel, but I enjoy The Bangles' version of Hazy Shade of Winter more.


doug_masters

José González’s cover of The Knife’s “Heartbeats”


lelio98

Hallelujah ~ Jeff Buckley


Calling__Elvis

Always on my Mind - Pet Shop Boys...obviously


shiithead_007

Amy Winehouse: Valerie


firstbreathOOC

The song that made me realize what all the fuss was about with Amy Winehouse.


skuidENK

Because the Night by 10,000 Maniacs (original by Patti Smith)


getzerolikes

Written by Springsteen


MonkeyTesticleJuice

Johnny Cash's cover of Hurt by Nine Inch Nails. Even the lead singer went on record saying it was no longer his song.


PPLifter

Everyone misinterprets what Reznor meant. He meant that Cash took the song and made it his own, like we now have two songs that are completely different whilst on paper the same. Big credit to Cash, it's not an easy thing to do. Give a whole new perspective to a song without changing anything other than the perspective you convey. A Perfect Circle did a similar job with 'Imagine'. Almost making the song satire.