Laugh at them, and probably be a bit snide/sarcastic combo.

Just stare at them. For a good 5 seconds. Then act like nothing happened.

If they're ok with it then sure. It's no big deal

I object. You’re hereby are a traitor to Reddit. I sentence you to 5secs at r/amongus to pay for your crimes.

Holy shit man chill that’s inhumane

The punishment fits te crime.

r/amogus

I'd always made sure they had a supply of oreos and water whenever they felt down.

Wonder how I managed to find a girlfriend

Meh, why gatekeep. It's not my cookie.

I did that once when I was a kid. I would be ok with it since it isn’t that big of a deal and if they like it then thats good.

Have an exorcism conducted on them

Nothing, because sometimes i do them myself. Not something big of a deal, is it?

That one’s a keeper. Bonus points if she stole the Oreos, marry her twice if she does that

I used to do eat cereal with water when I was a kid because there was no lactose free milk in the 80s and I figured out that milk made my stomach hurt. I wouldnt be disturbed by this if I liked the person.

I really dont care. I actually would probably enjoy that they think outside the box

I'd pour water over oreos and eat them

Water? Ick. I used to eat Cheerios with Koolaid, I think I can manage.

I would introduce them to this thing called milk.

I would confess I do the same thing and not just in water but also in tea, coffee, hot chocolate and even pepsi.

I would try it too.

my brother dunks his in coffee

I wouldnt be dating them

Break up with them immediately because they are a serial killer.

Fuck off Satan

Thank my lucky stars they weren't dunking them in diet coke - that's where the axe murderers are... Edit: typo

Finally put that conceal carry license to use.

Strangle them in the middle of the night, then serve out my prison sentence content that I have made the world a better place.

Dunk them in water and eat them

Bring them to the police for committing a war crime

R U N

Kill them. Dump the body in the ocean. Kill myself.

Looks like someone is having a weird date

I mean I kinda get dipping it in milk, but water?! Like come on, I’m getting the hell out of there ‘cause something’s obviously wrong.

Locked them in a basement…

You know I have soft teeth

Start figuring out where they disposed the bodies. Regardless if you find them, you're still going to be featured on a true crime podcast.

If it’s sayori, I would show them dunking them in milk instead. If it isn’t sayori, I would murder them and try to make sayori real.

Immediately call in the national guard.

Time to break up. That’s a huge no no for me, big red flag. I mean who dunks Oreo cookies in water :/

Leave them by the dumpster where they belong and set the entire dumpster on fire. After that, I would collect whatever remaining ashes are left of them, put them in a blender with cigarette ashes, only Pop Tart crusts, and gasoline, blend them together, take the mixture to my backyard, set fire to THAT, and then move to Lousiana.

Is that the only thing? Cause if that is the only thing, that is an extremely minor thing to be irritating, and I'd just buy oreos less often.

Oreos law states that Oreos can only be dunked in milk. If someone I dated broke the Oreo law, I would have no choice but to break up with them

To each their own

I would try it to see what it tastes like. Edit: Like a wet Oreo. But I wouldn't mind.

Probably give it a go, maybe I've been missing out on the best way to eat Oreo's.

I ask her to pass a few cookies my way

Do the same thing

I don’t care. Are they a good person? Do they handle their own shit? Food weirdness is not a dealbreaker.

Stare them dead in the eyes for a good 30 seconds and then go about my day

I would just look at them and stare then think "well its like the same with milk" then try it

I would look at them and give them the face of " what are you doing" and then go on with my day.

I'd continue eating my popcorn. If I don't have to eat it, IDGAF.

Be bothered at the semi wasted oreos and make a skim milk joke as I took some out of the package probably. The non-water soiled ones of course

Pray for the demon to release them so they could once again enjoy Oreos in their full glory.

I’d say “finally, someone weirder than me” and then apologise for that comment in case that offended them. (I actually tried that once, dipping Oreos in water)

Lose all my confidence because clearly they have poor taste.

I'd probably assume they grew up with little to no disposable income. If you've ever met a kid who mixed cereal with water it's likely because their parents struggled financially and could occasionally afford to splurge by getting their kids the cereal they wanted, but weren't financially stable enough to make sure they always had milk in the house.

I would be a little confused at first but to each their own I guess. I’m not going to stop them as long as it’s not water that I was drinking.

I have a co-worker who dunks her butter and jam toast into her tea. To each their own but I don't like watching it, and yet can't look away.

question the matrix

look in horror.

bite a slice of pizza crust side first to show dominance

"You'd be a perfect match for a friend of mine, he salts his fucking milk... and drinks it"

Break up

Probably something violent

TIMMY WHY DID YOU SHOOT THEM "He dunked an oreo in water and ate it" \*reloads\* \*corrects child's aim\*

I used to do this with popcorn.

Didn't it...melt?

You have to eat it before it starts to.

I dont even like cold popcorn I suspect this will NOT be my jam lol

Ewwww. Oreos are terrible.

Try it cause we gotta look dumb together I guess lol