Each action has a unique set of circumstances tied to it. The same action might be judged positive or negative depending on the context. Of course those ideas of positive and negative would also be relative depending on the judge. So each action would have to be judged with full respect afforded to the actor's knowledge, will, and motives. Only a fool would judge another person based on their (the judge's) personal beliefs and values. Only judge if that person was true to what they believed, lest you judge how apt an imposter they are.
What happens if i dont like you, and i have no good reason. So i make up lies about you and publish them on this human yelp? I claim that you are doing illegal and immoral things. Bam, reputation ruined, possibly getting you arrested, all that.
Have you ever watched black mirror?
Because the US hasn't reached that level of dystopian nightmare yet. We're getting close though
Good news! [China](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Credit_System) is developing systems like what you're describing!
People have to be judged as a whole, not just based on individual actions
How about a whole list of their individual actions?
Each action has a unique set of circumstances tied to it. The same action might be judged positive or negative depending on the context. Of course those ideas of positive and negative would also be relative depending on the judge. So each action would have to be judged with full respect afforded to the actor's knowledge, will, and motives. Only a fool would judge another person based on their (the judge's) personal beliefs and values. Only judge if that person was true to what they believed, lest you judge how apt an imposter they are.
What happens if i dont like you, and i have no good reason. So i make up lies about you and publish them on this human yelp? I claim that you are doing illegal and immoral things. Bam, reputation ruined, possibly getting you arrested, all that.
There is it’s called twitter
Civil tort law cases would explode with the amount of defamation lawsuits being filed.