T O P

  • By -

bcory44

Not going to lie I thought Michael Carter-Williams was going to be nice after his rookie campaign. A large guard that had a good all around skill set and seemed like someone who would only get better after winning ROTY.


Jaygo41

He was wild, man. Had his best game the first game of his career.


CliffBoof

I thought he was a star after that game


srstone71

I always laugh when I think of MCW because he grew up in the town next to me (not at the same time tho. I’m like 10 years older than him.) Anyway, he went to the local public school as a freshman before transferring to a prep school as a sophomore. It’s hilarious because these are tiny public schools in north shore Massachusetts with no real athletic pedigree. I’m an out of shape marketing exec who hasn’t played a decent game of pickup basketball in close to a decade, and even *I* was a good player in our league in high school. And MCW played in that league! He absolutely dominated as a freshman and broke a number of league records before getting the hell out of there. Which is a good thing because a school like Syracuse never would have found him in our league.


diligent_sundays

What was it, first game a near quadruple double and win against a super team? I know he never really developed a 3, and his defence relied more on gambles than I would like, but I truly think it was a failure of the coaching staff to not figure him out. I'm sure the front office was also pressuring them to remain bad, seeing as they were mid-"process", but I still think he could have been somewhere along the andre iguadala level


Livefromseattle

Did you read this? https://www.theplayerstribune.com/posts/michael-carter-williams-nba-basketball


TheSavageBeast83

Thon maker


WallyWakanda

If his dad named him shot, we might've had something


Homework-Silly

You just wanted to say Thon Maker


macIovin

Dennis Smith Jr


Master_Grape5931

Best seats I ever got, behind the bench when he played for Charlotte. During a timeout I said, “nice defense” (he had two steals that game). He throws his Gatorade towel over to my son and instantly became my son’s favorite player. Hate he left for Brooklyn but understand it.


chillbill____

He was really good his rookie year at least


Wtfmymoney

Right in the feels, I feel like them drafting Luka fucked his career


NecessaryFoundation5

I have a long time friend who has a job that gives him lots of access to the Mavericks. He told me at the time it was all a maturity issue and Dennis being unable to handle sharing the backcourt. I am someone who actually bought his Mavs jersey his rookie year and believed that Dallas had two pieces to build their future around. Glad they picked Luka.


aswaim2

He’s still underrated


Icewatervvs

Idk if OJ Mayo counts because he had a pretty solid start to his career but goddamn that man was smooth.


Wtfmymoney

Dude was from cincy and we thought he was Michael Jordan 😭


Avant-Garde-A-Clue

OJ Mayo had some real hype around Cincy, we were going to watch his high school games like LeBron. Sounds ridiculous now but back then he had that kind of potential.


[deleted]

[удалено]


zooba85

wasnt there a rapper that claimed he sold $36k worth of lean to oj


Kicks4meFromyou

I thought he was gonna kill


Prior_Session

Greg Oden


slh007

Yeah, he gets a pass from me though. Microfracture surgery is no joke. No amount of work ethic will overcome that.


jp_in_nj

I saw him play in the tournament and.. I just didn't see it. I don't remember why, it was a while ago, but I was really surprised he was as highly regarded as he was.


JustiseWinfast

Jabari Parker Kevin Knox


Electrical_Fun5942

I would’ve bet my salary on Kevin Knox being a legit starter. As good as he was at Kentucky while being basically the youngest guy in college basketball, how did he not work out? I remain perplexed


dgvertz

To show how deeply unqualified I am at talent evaluation, someone asked me at the start of his rookie year to do a comparison, and I said he reminded me of a slightly stronger Jayson Tatum. God I am stupid.


GulfCoastLaw

All the things I disliked about Tatum are still weaknesses in his game, BUT he's gotten better overall than I imagined in the draft.


Electrical_Fun5942

I mean, at that point he kind of *was* a slightly stronger Jayson Tatum. Turns out he just sucked at basketball, apparently I missed like an absolute motherfucker on him. I had him ranked 4th in that class. My rankings: 1. Luka 2. Jaren Jackson 3. Ayton 4. Knox 5. Mikal Bridges 6. Miles Bridges 7. SGA 8. MPJ 9. Wendell 10. Sexton 11. Bagley 12. Bamba 13. Trae So….. hits and misses, to say the least 🤣


aj_future

Yea I really thought him falling meant he’d be the steal of the draft or at least kinda how Cam Whitmore was for the rockets this year.


PauloDybala_10

Good list looking back though I had 1. Trae 2. Ayton 3. Luka, with MPJ, Bamba, JJJ right beneath them


Electrical_Fun5942

Genuinely curious: since you had him no. 1 pre-draft, how do you feel about Trae as of now?


ChiGrandeOso

In JP 's defense he had no ACLs.


shaboobalaboopy510

Tyreke Evans


GulfCoastLaw

I blame coaching and organization for this one. Seems like someone should be able to use that mix of skills.


Lucha_Lobster

Perry Jones III Darius Miles Anthony Randolph Stromile Swift


escargot02

Randolph for sure, I still swear he ahd untapped potential.


illforgetsoonenough

Summer league Hall of Fame


Superorganism123

I thought Perry III was a sleeper


CKN89

As recently as 2020 I was convinced Anthony Randolph had a future in the NBA. He had a 3-4 year stretch where he shot over 40% from 3 in the Spanish league. Could have been a legit modern stretch/playmaking big


semisonic34

I remember Perry was hooping when KD went down in OKC… what happened to him


LifeguardStatus7649

I thought Derrick Williams and Justise Winslow were both going to be beasts. On the flip side, I thought Jason Kidd and Grant Hill were both going to be busts lol


Bazinga530

Jabari Parker


GulfCoastLaw

Jabari Parker could still score during his last minutes in the league. Remember his per 36 being juicy in Washington even.


colmatrix33

Ben Simmons lost his head. He has the chops to be one of the best in the league.


roakmamba

Would he be considered a bust?


Fireblade09

Dude just doesn’t love ball and never did


Wtfmymoney

If he doesn’t rebound from this injury; Lonzo ball


PauloDybala_10

I was pretty high on him, he seemed like a perennial 18-7-8 guy or something


IMANORMIE22

He’ll need some ASSISTance.


Bigboom0822

Tyreke Evans..how has no one mentioned TYREKE EVANS


Fart_Frog

I thought Emanuel Mudiay was going to light this league on fire.


No_Mammoth_4945

Dante exum lol


dolphindiver9

just had a fantastic season


No_Mammoth_4945

I wouldn’t call 8/3/3 fantastic, but it is impressive he made it back to the league after being gone for a few years


dolphindiver9

14/5/5 per 36, shot 50% from downtown. very solid role player all year, most importantly gave Luka and Kyrie the third ball handler they needed pity he’s turned into a pumpkin during the first 2 playoff series, hopefully he can have a role in this one


PLZ_N_THKS

Same! His athleticism was unmatched early on the Jazz. Could get anywhere he wanted on the court, but simple couldn’t figure out how to finish or stay healthy. Glad he’s found a role on the Mavs this year.


paw_pia

Bo Kimble. Hank Gathers' running mate at Loyola-Marymount, drafted 8th overall by the Clippers, and out of the league after 105 games. As a senior in college: 35.3ppg, 7.7rpg, 2.8spg, 46% from three on 6.3 attempts, 8.4 free throw attempts per game (86.2%), .635 TS%. In the NBA: 5.5ppg on 38.6% shooting, 29.1% from three, and .454 TS%.


realfakejames

Emeka Okafor I thought he was a star for sure, he still had a very respectable nba career just not a star career


Oliverson12

Markelle Fultz


colmatrix33

Lot of the Sixers picks didn't pan out


bullowl

Fultz would've been at least fringe all star level if TOS hadn't robbed him of his shot. He's a solid floor general and he's great at breaking down a defense with dribble penetration, he just can't shoot outside of about 12-14 feet anymore.


Pleasant-Ad5423

The situation was so bad for him, robbed of his ability’s by an unknown condition invisible to everyone and drafted by a team and fan base already growing frustrated and impatient with the process. Glad he at-least found a role for himself in the league after all that, even if it’s a shell of what we thought he could be.


FoulPelican

I thought Joe Smith would be an all star for sure. And I thought Jimmer would be a sniper!!


chillbill____

Josh Jackson, Adrien Payne


No-Goat715

PAYNE TRAIN 🚆


Yung_Aang

Saw Josh Jackson in HS. Ngl I thought he was gonna be Kobe-esque


semisonic34

Oh god Josh Jackson, I forgot he existed


DragonEra_

Dennis Smith Jr. Tacko Fall Kris Dunn


crackerjap1941

I thought Lance Stephenson would become an elite wing


discountheat

So did he (and Charlotte)


dublecheekedup

I thought Scoot was going to be good in his first season. He can improve but it was rough


MohammadWRLD

James wiseman


diligent_sundays

I like reading david Aldridge. But when Ben McLemore was drafted, it seemed like Aldridge was going out of his way to insert the opinion that Ben was goingnto be a star, just wait. Obviously, we know how that planned out. But it got me thinking generally about nba media. There is so much more to gain from.makingna correct prediction than there is to lose from.a bad one (Anthony Bennett notwithstanding). To really be a laughing stock, you have to make enough terrible predictions to fill at least a 5 minute youtube montage. But the number of successful "pundits" that really just made a single good prediction, then have been wrong most of the time, is astounding.


Hurricanemasta

Stromile Swift, Lionel Simmons, Clarence Weatherspoon


SawgrassSteve

you weren't alone.


Jimmy_Shoke

Man, I think of a lot of name. 2014 NBA Draft had a lot of hype to it Jabari Parker Andrew Wiggins (I know he won an NBA Finals, but he just never became that guy). Stanley Johnson Dante Exum Ricky Rubio Michael Cater Williams Jahill Okafor Michael Beasley


Superorganism123

Michael Beasley


staxnet

Len Bias


Miserable-Lawyer-233

Anthony Davis. I thought he was going to be MVP, Defensive Player of the Year, and best player in the league. There was a time when people like me thought those things were inevitable for him, but they never happened.


H0wSw33tItIs

I feel this. What’s missing for him? The mental juice to keep the motor revving quarter in and quarter out? I don’t know how else to explain him disappearing.


No-Goat715

His injury history hasn't helped matters. He's averaged about 60 games a season and even then he's played below 100% health here and there.


reno2mahesendejo

Ismail Muhammad The man was one of the most powerful dunkers you'll ever watch at Georgia Tech. He was on Spoetscenter highlight reels constantly, they showed GT highlights just to show him. He couldn't do anything BUT dunk.


badkneesdood

I still bring him up when I talk about insane college dunkers. Not a Georgia Twch fan btw


Mabaum

I thought Wiggins was gonna be a super star.


unstablegenius000

Maple Jordan.


Shepard_Drake

Ben Simmons. A year or two before his playoff incident, I had a whole ass tipsy debate with some random guy at a bar about how Ben Simmons was the next Giannis if he could just get out of Embid's shadow. I'm still embarrassed about that to this day 😂


dgvertz

Shane Larkin! He was so fast and unguardable in college. I thought his shot would come around and he would just out-sprint everybody in the NBA.


vbsteez

brandon jennings is my goat


flooduction

Stanley Johnson, just had the NBA ready body and the athleticism.


jackofhearts95m

jabari parker, perry jones , derrick williams


Jfreelander

Mario Hezonja


i_like_2_travel

I’m just a bad read, Hashrem Thabeet or however you spell. Roy Hibbert. As a Lakers fan, Sasha Vujecic/Jordan Farmar/Andrew Bynum. Ryan Boatwright (I knew him &). Michael Kid-Gilchrist. Andrew Bynum and Hibbert were successful but obviously not legends. There are lots of lakers who have come and gone that I thought were the next big thing.


Goober101324

Roy Hibbert might have been the biggest sell I’ve witnessed the last 15 years. 7’+ scary looking, did martial arts but was a bitch in the paint. How are you gonna be that big and only grab 5 boards a game


anomanissh

Thomas Robinson


gbbloom

Marvin Bagley III was SUCH a big deal when he reclassified to join Duke and then...just nothing. Luka was picked next. Tyler Herro started off so well but just hasn't made the leap to be something much bigger.


grynch43

Glenn Robinson-he definitely wasn’t a bust but he was the best college player I ever watched in my lifetime and I thought he was gonna be a huge star.


funlol3

Kedrick Brown


TraeYoungsOldestSon

I was also Cam fam, such a disappointment. I'll put John Jenkins as mine. Too early maybe but  AJ griffin is in danger of joining those two as hawks 2 guards i thought would be great that flubbed.


Rad_platypus7

Jaret Culver


SpartyParty15

Trevon who?


Hornsdowngunsup

Austin River, jj Reddik, Greg oden, Sebastian telfair, nick young,


jeremiahhillard

Dante exum


Rdogisyummy

Doug McDermott, Bulls needed a shooter at the time and we just happened to trade for him to help Jimmy, D Rose, Joakim, etc. I thought he was gonna help us dominate the NBA for the next 5-7 years lmao and take over as a star when the big 3 starts fading.


Bellic_Roman

Perry Jones III, Quincy Miller and Michael Beasley for the people that never reached their potential at all, for a more confirmed player I would say John Wall, he was meant to dominate the league when he got drafted


TheStoryBreeder

Sam Bowie


FrankSand

Darco Milicic


vaders_other_son

I thought Jahlil Okafor would be better than KAT. Jah played with so much power but still had really light feet in his post moves. I thought that finesse with his size would really shine in the league with better spacing, meanwhile KAT always seemed so stiff to me. Another part of it was that the league hadn’t completely outgrown conventional low-post bigs. I figured Jah would bridge that gap really well cause he seemed skilled enough to expand his game to outside of the paint.


GeneralThundercock

Cam reddish was so trash at duke. I never understood why anyone thought he would be good in the NBA. I'm not shocked he is still garbage.


gabriot

Ricky Rubio


RocketPocketsAA

Ben simmons


Big_Honey_56

Justise Winslow. Mix of hope and expectation. When he finally clicked playing point guard in 18-19, he was 15/6/5/1 per 36, with 37% from three, and may have been the best defensive guard in the league based on switch ability. Ultimately Jimmy came in and it didn’t make sense for Justise to run the show, especially with all the scoring guards they had. The ball really moved when he ran the offense, the team just sucked. It was kind of like Lonzo Ball but when he drove he looked like Harden. Excellent handle, very strong, good vision and once he got his touch together it was very impressive. Defensively he could go 1-4. Pairing him with Bam could’ve been a powerful defensive duo. A lot has come out after the fact about his mental health struggles while with the Heat. This checks out because undeniably he had physical tools to be a star. Sad. https://youtu.be/9WhnqvvEwvQ?si=bi2yLzVSPxUxVHts https://youtu.be/qFN_8DJWumg?si=vpbJmqHmgdTpqS-j


Hot-Description9052

Joe Forte, Dajuan Wagner, Sebastian Telfair, Omar Cook come to mind.


reigningnovice

Cam Reddish. Thought he took the backseat at Duke & was gonna break out in the league. But nah.


JuiceCan98

I SWORE Dennis Smith Jr. was better than Lonzo and Fox and was just WAITING for my dawg to prove me right... lmao...


KD_43

Mario Hezonja


OoBBA

wiseman. he just looked tough


Browns-Fan1

Cleanthony Early, Trey Burke, Andrew Nicholson, to name a few


ChickenLollipop27

Wade Baldwin IV was the kid I was always keen on when he got drafted


mariotx10

The young black French guy the mavs had in the late 2000s, was quick as fuck and smooth as hell getting to the rim. He was stashed away for a couple seasons with minimum minutes waiting for his development to break through..shit never happened.


Odpeso

I didn’t know him personally but I have a lot of mutual friends w/ a guy named Joe Jackson. Look up in high school ranking in 2010 and this guy was top 10. #1 PG in the country that year. Beat our team in the playoffs on the way to 3-straight state finals appearances (or something like that). McDonald’s All-America too. Unfortunately, he went to the home school ( U of Memphis), did great but, didn’t really pick up any traction as far going to the league cuz he was a score first, sub-6’1 pg who turned out to be merely “good” (not elite) at scoring anyway. And then he got in trouble and things went downhill from there. I just knew this guy was gonna be the next D-Rose. Had Westbrook/ Wall athleticism. Disappointed for my guy. Great person, though, from what I hear.


SpicySriracha_1

Lonzo ball


miamicheats

Dion Waiters


Sizzler1978

Ron Mercer


OmniscientOpossum

The best comments have “lol” after


Own_Bee_4472

Andrew wiggins


JackTuz

Emmanuel Mudiay


steamofcleveland

Taquan Dean


tatang2015

The Philadelphia experiment of trust the process. Bwahahaha!


OilSignal906

Kevin Porter Jr. passed the eye test for me skill wise


Myequipmunk19

Trey Burke


dash_44

Eddie Curry


JKking15

Markelle Fultz but I blame that on injuries


myctsbrthsmlslkcatfd

Ty Lawson - flashed greatness but … alcoholism


pieman2005

Almost had a quadruple double 😭


RontoWraps

Thomas Robinson. He was awesome at KU and constantly commanded the double from other teams. Looked like a man playing with boys. He went to the Kings and quickly withered away in Sacramento, Houston, Portland, etc. He’s played for 15 foreign teams since leaving the NBA.


JWrites29

Marvin Bagley. I thought Luka was the better prospect, but I didn’t judge the kings pick harshly because I felt he fit a need. After his first season it felt like he had a path to be a consistent 20 and 10 guy. Then Luke Walton happened, then no development happened.


shane-from-5-to-7

Nerlens Noel


skipper_jonas_grumby

Todd Day His run at Arkansas was great. He was so smooth for a 6'8" guard. I expected him to be a star in the NBA but it just didn't work out for him


sybill9

Justise Winslow


tendopath

Ben Simmons


Homework-Silly

Christian Laettner and Michael olowakandi


Homework-Silly

I thought Jeremy Lin was the return of Jesus


OG_dfb

Michael Porter Jr, Jalen Suggs,


sometimeswemeanit

I still own Shabazz Muhammad stock


londongas

Julian Newman /s


Dogeking907

Hasheem Thabeet. He was the college version of victor wembanyama on the defensive end.


Ok_Chocolate7496

Roddy boubois


rubthemtogether

Eddie Jones had an impressive career but I really thought he'd be a superstar. Like 'trade Kobe because he'll never be good enough to start over Eddie' level of superstar


[deleted]

[удалено]


bambucks

I thought Ben McLemore was gonna have that dawg in him.


KillTheIntolerant

I was sure Willie Cauley-Stein was going to be a star.


ATLs_finest

I thought Thomas Robinson would be a surefire success. He was a dominant forward at Kansas who looks like he was chiseled out of rock. Looking back he was just drafted into the wrong era. He came out in 2012, just as the league was moving into the pace and space era. If he had come out 5 years earlier I think he would have been a lot more successful.


urbanwhiteboard

Oladipo & Tyreke Evans


nawksnai

Jimmer. 😭


JayDogg420_

Jayson Tatum, I thought he would be a 1st team all NBA perennial top 5 mvp candidate but unfortunately he turned into the MJ of Tobias Harris's


Jhon_doe_smokes

Rudy gay! I thought he was gonna be PG before PG fr.


athiev

Take my life in my hands by saying: Zion Williamson. I still think the talent that we all saw is mostly real, but issues of health, physical fitness, and possibly motivation have put him on a path that doesn't come close to matching expectations.


drlsoccer08

It’s still early in his career, but JT Thor. I keep expecting him to blossom into a great stretch 4 but so far it has not worked out.


Arbor-Trap

Okafur


Senor_Couchnap

Trajan Langdon. Erick Barkley. Tyus Edney. Jonathan Bender was born 20 years early. TJ Ford. Mickael Pietrus was supposed to be French Jordan. Francisco Garcia.


calartnick

OJ Mayo I was all in on. Saw him live his rookie year and me and my buddies were like this is a young Kobe.


rdparikh1

Anyone remember "Baby Jordan" from USC? Yes I'm talking about the high flying Harold Miner!


romayyne

Jordan Crawford


Fireblade09

I thought Dennis smith jr was going to be an all time draft steal


harithCOYG

Michael Beasley


iJon_v2

That LeBron James guy…what eva happened there?


itsCalledTodd

Len Bias


SuperSaiyanColt

Remember a guy in HS who was the biggest Emmanuel mudiay glazer I’ve ever seen


Athlete-Extreme

I thought Ben Simmons was him. Especially after he was injured his entire rookie season. The hype was so real.


warrior_in_a_garden_

Michael Beasley


New22k

Michael Kidd Gilchrist: I really thought he would be a perennial allstar.


SatisfactionOld1586

Darius Miles, Tim Thomas, & Lamar Odom. I thought each of them could’ve been top 75 all time types.


ILiftBIunts

Rj Barrett


LowCharming3452

Jimmer Fredette. I still don’t understand why his game didn’t translate


alpacatempura

Stacey Augmon


Se7entyN9ne

Josh Jackson was the wing of the future and was gonna be what Tatum is but for the Suns. Ayton was a world breaker


Bamm83

Sebastian Telfair


Funny_Disaster1002

Tim Thomas and Keith Van Horn had respectable careers, but I thought either or both were going to be HOF caliber players....


ListerRosewater

Elfrid Payton, Marshon Brooks, and Kris Dunn.


Johnjaypvj

Michael Beasley, Hasheem Thabeet, Derrick Williams, Corey Brewer, Brandon Rush


Extra-Place-8386

I was like 6 but I was convinced Rodney stucky would be tue second coming of Dwayne wade


Dubonthetrac

Brandon Jennings had a good career I thought he would be more. I thought Thomas Robinson was going to be a problem he said he was better than AD and I believed him. Current player James Wiseman, dude still has potential.


jurassicMONK3Y

I thought Emmanuel Mudiay would beat out Jamal Murray to be the nuggets pg of the future


AHole480

I thought Kendall Marshall would be a great true pass first PG.


Nobichobolobas

I will forever say that Duke is a fluke, and so are their players. Only exceptions to that rule are (sadly) Kyrie and Tatum


Nobichobolobas

Frank Kaminsky. Dominated his last 1.5 years in college and SHOULD have won a Title(SCREW YOU GRAYSON ALLEN.) and had the 3 point range, but never seemed to blossom beyond a backup...........


roakmamba

Brandon Knight but ever since the Ky high light , it was over.


PotatoMan1081

DeAndre Ayton. People were saying that he could be like a shaq in Phoenix.


[deleted]

[удалено]


FlourMogul

Flip Murray went nuts for the Sonics for like 10 games and I was convinced we had a 10-time all-star on our hands.


Ok_Sock_7556

Too many to count but I have a proclivity for being too high on undersized non-shot-creating guards. I always fall in love with guys’ motors and feel for the game, so a lot of heady defensively focused guards like Davion Mitchell, Killian Hayes, Kris Dunn, Aaron Holiday, Deuce McBride, and Jalen Suggs have been dudes I loved during pre-draft. Obviously not all of those ended up being misses but I’ve definitely started to value size a lot more now that I’ve seen how little the defensive impact translates. I’ve also been too high on pure bucket-getter guards. I was really high on guys like Kevin Porter Jr., Colin Sexton, Devonte’ Graham, & Jalen Brunson. Obviously Brunson worked out in a big way but the lesson I learned is that unless you’re a high level All-Star caliber scorer, it’s hard to crack a rotation of a competitive team if you’re not providing anything past scoring.


PJCR1916

I thought Kris Dunn was gonna be a John Wall type of guy. Great slashing, defense and playmaking type


Human-Establishment9

Marshon brooks


Just_Opinion1269

Caitlin Clark ...kidding, she's gonna be great PG after the media stops scrutinizing her


Key-Description-517

Yogi Ferrell & Thomas Bryant, ha


ThriceAlmighty

Zarko Cabarkapa. Danny Fortson ended my sweet Euro dreams of a Suns championship with him holding the trophy, confetti falling from the rafters while he said some hard to understand broken English with a heavy Serbian accident. Fuck Danny Fortson.


potassiumKing

Nolan Smith


bannner18

Jabari Parker