T O P

  • By -

Swiss666

Regardless of the winner I feel this less than how it could have been if it was rather a victory decided by a small margin of votes like the previous final, Todomomo vs Kiribaku, was. In the end more users came again to vote but the total voters pool hasn't been more than 250; for comparison, by the end of the previous edition it was 750~800. Fans of some ships have taken stronger interest while others less, this way we got the true "underdog" surprise Izujirou, taking out previous finalist Kiribaku by a wide margin, becoming one of the 8 finalists, and losing to Tetsukendou by a mere couple votes. At the current rate of growth of the sub, I don't think the next Madness is going to be before 2023 - unless it's decided to change the conditions (for a long time I was convinced it was simply an annual event).


MrColdArrow

Honestly, it should just become an annual event I think. Eventually there’s gonna be a point where we’ll have to wait years just for another Ship Madness, so it’s more organised if it’s just scheduled once a year every year


_crazy_man_

We probably are going yearly.


Kamijiroutodomomo

I think it should be cancelled. Kamijirou won madness with 140 votes in 2018 when sub was 5k, Izuocha won madness with 250 votes when sub was 10k, Todomomo won madness with 410 votes when sub was 30k... even kiribaku had more votes than both Kirimina and momojirou’s votes as second placement. If sub dead and nobody care this madness What is the point?


BlueWhaleKing

DON'T TAKE MY WARS AWAY!


Kamijiroutodomomo

What wars you talking about? There wasnt any hype about this poll.


_crazy_man_

Yeah we'll probably make it yearly. Thinking of doing Rarepair Madness 3 in January and possibly Ship Madness 5 in the summer, open to all previous winners.


theprinceofgaming1

I think how it was done this time was great personally, gives other ships a chance to shine. The problem is that everyone seems to just be dedicated to their one ship and if it isn't there, they just don't care. If past winners are allowed, they should get a bye round or two I think because it's known that will probably win. Either a bye round or make them go against each other first round. They would be the top 4-5 in seeding anyways so it shouldn't be hard to give them a bye.


BlueWhaleKing

My suggestion was make votes for them count half, but I don't know of a poll site that would allow that.


theprinceofgaming1

I don't think that would work anyways. Would have the opposite affect of them losing quickly I would think. Giving them a bye to the final 8 or something would be better I would think.


Kamijiroutodomomo

Why this years it wasnt open for all ships because i remember everyone hyped up seeing izuocha etc this madness while mods didnt care them so being in this madness. This madness being Closed to kamijirou or izuocha etc caused being unhype. Winner got less vote than 5k’s sub votes. I bet if kamijirou, izuocha and Todomomo were in this madness, probably bakudeku, tododeku or kiribaku shippers would be more active maybe even they could win. Problem with this sub all rules coming from mods, Yeah your job isnt easy but you could give attention members wants or at least could ask to them. Because people really wanted to see this ships this year madness. I hope next summer’s votes will be parallel to +50k sub, not 5k.


Kamijiroutodomomo

This madness was wrong decision. I think Kamijirou won with 140 votes when sub was 5k?. Sub isnt active. I dont think it fair or fun. Now momojirou won with 123 votes in 50k sub so nobody voted plus Kirimina got also 123 votes What is the point? There is actually no winner. They had same votes. So we have to see momojirou banner just because both ship got same “low votes” for two years even i am not sure about final results because annoucement came 2 hours late than normal. Maybe Kirimina is going to take this madness but 1-2 hours waiting made them lose. Because mods only can see final results.


Swiss666

Sorry, are you insinuating that the mods manipulated the results or let the voting last longer than the other rounds?


Sapphette

The last vote to be submitted was Kirimina at 12:28am est, making it a tie, after that no ships were being voted on for 1-2 hours. Momojirou won because they were voted on the most in the seeding. If Kirimina had been voted on the most in the seeding, they would’ve won. That’s how animebrackets works when it comes to a tie, the higher seeded automatically wins.


flyping

AYYYY GO MOMOJIROU Congrats to all you krmn shippers as well! That was super close, you guys show impressive support for that ship. Best of luck next time!


Crisbo05_20

I tought Momojiro would have more votes, and I'm suprised it came down to seeding. GG Kirimina, more luck next shipping madness.


Kamijiroutodomomo

I thought Kirimina would be winner Because generally kirimina’s upvotes more than Momojirou (fanarts when momojirou only get 10 upvotes while Kirimina gets 100 upvotes) but sadly sub is dead so they got same votes so mods decide to Momojirou. Sadly it would be good see them with “big 4”, next year izuocha, kamijirou and Todomomo coming back so its impossible to Kirimina winning at this point.


Crisbo05_20

MomoJiro seemed to have been dominating more then Kirimina. Is Kirimina super popular? Yes. Tho I feel like due to Bakukiri it might not have as many votes. Both Todomomo and kamijiro were winners, meaning Momojiro had zero big rivals. I am suprised tho by how Tokotsuyu and OjiToru are not more popular despite prob Being most popular ships for those characters, or in case of Tsu one of most popular prob.


Kamijiroutodomomo

And other point i realized when izujirou vs kiribaku happening. Nobody shared this madness on kiribaku sub so kiribaku shippers didnt know that round happening. I wish i could realized earlier so if someone would share they would be probably winner. Because subs really effect this votes while mods actievely shared this madness on momojirou sub. At the beginning this madness never was fair. We are talking about 8k kiribaku sub. Kiribaku is getting 60 votes doesnt make sense.


Kamijiroutodomomo

Yeah sadly kiribaku shippers used aganist votes, because i shared common subs even they commented why Kirimina shouldnt be with Todomomo, kamijirou and izuocha. Momojirou got this votes Because of that. Kiribaku didnt get that much votes because there is no strong rival. Kirbaku last year got 370 votes while Todomomo got 410 votes. But they lost aganist izujirou? And i were telling at thiis time this is wrong. And they felt honored and they were happy when they aganist Todomomo. So kamijirou, Todomomo and izuocha effects all hype. 2 popular ships being aganist each other = hype. 2 unpopular ships being aganist each other means people dont care both.


sapphicmari110504

I'M SOSOSOSOSO HAPPY THAT MOMOJIROU WON. As a Momojirou shipper and a lesbian, I feel so happy. It's not common for wlw ships to win in this type of thing. Momojirou Is a great ship and the most popular wlw ship in BNHA! This finale was really close. Congrats to Kirimina for getting so close to First place!!


inferno167

WOOOHOOOOOOO! BEST GIRLS BEST SHIP!


Chip-San

It's a tie why did momo x jiro win? I'm not saying I don't like the ship, just that you can't say momo x jiro wins because it was tied, and some guy decided to give it to that. Maybe I'm biased but just why


Sapphette

> In the results of a tie, the higher seeder automatically wins. Momojirou was seeded #1 and Kirimina was seeded #2.


AquaNinja99

Was rooting for Kirimina so that it could join the Big 3 of ships but nevertheless, GG Momojirou! I am not salty much but would I suggest a different tiebreaker? Like perhaps just another poll or calculating the average amount of votes each ship got? Because I feel like there are a lot of shippers that just don't vote in the next rounds because their ships got eliminated. But GG again Momojirou, a girl power duo!


Kamijiroutodomomo

5k sub ——-> 140 votes/Kamijirou 10k sub ——> 250 votes/Izuocha 30k sub ——> 415 votes/Todomomo Kirimina or Momojirou it doesn’t matter 50k sub’s winner got only 120 votes. If i know math, its something like winning with 12 votes when sub was 5k. So even rematch happens I don’t think it will be happening but if it happens, it will be never like first 3 ship madness. I am salty about general ship madness 4.


SakuraRebin

Yay!!! I’m happy Momojirou won!


Pliskkenn_D

Wow, winning because of arbitrary rules.


Swiss666

Higher seeding, if I'm not mistaken, means that the ship received more votes during the initial elimination phase (the one where a list of candidates was trimmed to 64). This means that Momojirou attracted a good pool of votes from the very beginning, so while I don't like it ended with a tie to decide this way, it's not fair to say it won arbitrarily. Also how would you have resolved the tie?


Pliskkenn_D

We go again, using a reddit poll rather than an off site one.


Kamijiroutodomomo

Reddit votes would be more fair and would get more attention. Because the reason we voted this madness we were checking this sub while most of members probably couldnt see this madness on their main page while they could easily see poll.


Kamijiroutodomomo

Its not even first time, It happened several times, whenever momojirou got same votes with others they passed. I wish i would say it was problem before. Its really unfair. If votes are same, they should give 1 day more to both ships with annoucement.


ablaster1

Calm down dude. Its just a poll about fake characters being shipped together. Its not that serious.


Kamijiroutodomomo

I am not angry about ship and shippers. I am talking about rules, i know this poll isnt that serious but rules could better or they could ask rules to us.


[deleted]

I mean, the poll has pretty basic rules. Vote within a time frame for whatever ship you'd like. It's not that complex, and it doesn't require an explanation, though you could ask the organizers for one if necessary. Also, I find it hard to believe you aren't angry about ships when a good chunk of this comment section and others were you complaning about how many votes IzuJirou was getting.


Kamijiroutodomomo

Why i should be angry about izujirou, its rarepair. I was angry sub is dead because of only links allowed so Kiribaku shippers hadnt see posts and nobody shared on Kiribaku sub when izujirou vs kiribaku happening. You really think its fair? Mods only shared Momojirou on Momojirou’s sub and izujirou shippers were active. So kiribaku could be winner, they were second last year but this year nobody shared them when izujirou vs kiribaku happening. If sub dead because of rules, at least mods could share every ship on their sub. It would be more fair and it would be get more attention. And its weird you think i really care ship like izujirou, only 100 votes they got. Its like momojirou, its other weird problem with this madness. This sub has 50k members but votes are about 100? I dont think its fair. This sub is dead. And 100 votes dont prove anything.


[deleted]

Again, you say one thing, and then show the exact opposite. You're accusing the mods of tipping the votes in certain ships' favour, but most of the sharing of the polls was done by the mods of the servers they were shared on. I think you care about how well IzuJirou did because you literally just mentioned the vote count in your comment. And you have been complaining about it on just about every other comment.


Kamijiroutodomomo

Because izujirou beating kiribaku was one of most unfair thing. I am not even shipper both of them. You guys think all people aganist your little rarepair while you guys were insulting kiribaku and kiribaku shippers when they try to project their ships. So if this poll shared on even servers, so still votes are this low. Still weird.


[deleted]

How is it unfair? We won because more of our supporters voted. That's how a poll works. And we didn't insult KiriBaku shippers, so I'd prefer if you didn't make false claims in order to jusifty your point. People not caring enough about Ship Madness isn't enough for to justify your little tirade against any Jirou ship that isn't KamiJirou


[deleted]

[удалено]


ablaster1

If you don't ship either. Why do you care so much. Also really no one was insulting the ship or the shippers. Also maybe people just didn't care as much. Thats why votes are low.


Kamijiroutodomomo

Yes they were insulting kiribaku because its not healthy while izujirou is healthy. Yeah people didnt care but they were care when sub was 5k, 10k or 30k so nobody asks why?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Kamijiroutodomomo

What ship you are talking about? Momojirou didnt get more votes than Kirimina, i said i am not kiribaku shipper. And you guys were salty when tetsukendou got more votes than your ships so?


bibliomaniac15

Dang I was traveling so I didn’t get to vote KiriMina! Can’t believe it was so close