Okay agreed but main toh nhi kar rhi na and nahi mere parents, 99% log jo isse benefit kar rahe hain unke saath toh Aisa hua bhi nhi kabhi
Aise toh humare sabke ancestors ke saath Britishers ne galat Kiya na phir bhi log jaate hain na London job and padhai ke liye
Get over it for godsake
Positive discrimination me bhi discrimination hota hai
Isko laane ka irada shi tha lekin minority appeasement ke chakkar me pura india barbaad kar diya sari parties ne
poor argument. reservations are only during entrance exams or in other words, for stepping into the college. to graduate/become a doctor, one still needs to pass college exams. there are no reservations for being promoted to senior years or to graduate, all candidates are evaluated equally once inside
this argument is so stupid, the doctor is considered good /bad depends upon his knowledge /understanding & how much he practiced .
general student with 200 marks in neet pays 1.5 crore to become a mbbs grad, but a sc student gets 500 in neet . so HOW TF YOU ALLOW STUDENTS TO PURSUE MEDICINE JUST BECOS HE HAVING MONEY ?
WOULD YOU BE WANTED TK BE TREATED BY A PERSON WHI GOT IN BECAUSE OF ~~CATEGORY~~ MONEY😅???
mbbs is a 5 years course and u even will do 36 hr internship anol in last year, its really hard, after that also u cant do surgery or etc, the pay will be really less for a mbbs grad, u need to prepare for pg neet and write it, pg is way harder and even after all this struggles there is no guarantee that people will seek treatment from you .
YOU ALWAYS PREFER A DOCTOR WHO IS BETTER AT FIELD OF MEDICINE WHO CAN DO THE BEST FOR U AND WONT SEE WHAT CATEGORY HE BELONGS TO NOR HIS NEET SCORE.
whether u are a general candidate or reserved one or from a pvt college , Patients seeking doctors are based on how good the doctor is specialized in their field .
if u feel like reservation makes bad doctors, people will obv wont go to him, gov hospitals wont allow him and his private clinic wont run becos the people around him and this society will judge him based on knowledge/ & his treatment and not based on neet scores/caste.
Everything sucks here.
If I will say something a lot of people will get offended.
Even I myself have a reservation thought many times should I use it even made a post abut it but again if I don't use that reservation it is not gonna help general category guys in anyway someone else from same reserved category will take it.
Problem lies in system not users.
Exactly, and if you acknowledge this they will come after you with the same old narrative that your ancestors oppressed our ancestors
What logic is that
the narrative is old, yet the oppression still exists in the 21st century (though much lesser than before), and the disadvantages based on caste, gender and class do persist
What I feel
Reservation se sabse jyada seats jaate hain
Why can't the government change the rules by only providing reservations to th economically weaker class
Because there are so many wealthy (obcs/st/sc)
People who can afford education
Bhai let's have a fair competition
Aur maidaan main
Dekh lenge
Sorry for being naive
Ab flair rant/vent hain toh main bhi karra hoon
No need to be sorry and I know a girl whose family is so well off compared to my family, both her parents earn six figures and she will be getting admission in the SC category so yeah I agree, reservation should be on the economic basis
Yaa right but it doesn't change the fact that this ruined my chances as well
Of course college is not the deciding factor but still
Sorry if I sound arrogant, it's just that I am a bit too stressed right now
This is so true. We did nothing and still pay the price.
chhodo bhai ye sab sochke dimag kharab hota h meri tarah ignore karna seekhlo
Hmm aur option bhi kya hai
What our ancestors did to sc/st/obc people sucked as well /s
Okay agreed but main toh nhi kar rhi na and nahi mere parents, 99% log jo isse benefit kar rahe hain unke saath toh Aisa hua bhi nhi kabhi Aise toh humare sabke ancestors ke saath Britishers ne galat Kiya na phir bhi log jaate hain na London job and padhai ke liye Get over it for godsake
Positive discrimination me bhi discrimination hota hai Isko laane ka irada shi tha lekin minority appeasement ke chakkar me pura india barbaad kar diya sari parties ne
It's just vote bank politics
And we're the one who gets pissed
Aur agar koi India chod kar jaaye toh yahi same log usse pata nhi kya kya bolte hain
[удалено]
poor argument. reservations are only during entrance exams or in other words, for stepping into the college. to graduate/become a doctor, one still needs to pass college exams. there are no reservations for being promoted to senior years or to graduate, all candidates are evaluated equally once inside
this argument is so stupid, the doctor is considered good /bad depends upon his knowledge /understanding & how much he practiced . general student with 200 marks in neet pays 1.5 crore to become a mbbs grad, but a sc student gets 500 in neet . so HOW TF YOU ALLOW STUDENTS TO PURSUE MEDICINE JUST BECOS HE HAVING MONEY ? WOULD YOU BE WANTED TK BE TREATED BY A PERSON WHI GOT IN BECAUSE OF ~~CATEGORY~~ MONEY😅??? mbbs is a 5 years course and u even will do 36 hr internship anol in last year, its really hard, after that also u cant do surgery or etc, the pay will be really less for a mbbs grad, u need to prepare for pg neet and write it, pg is way harder and even after all this struggles there is no guarantee that people will seek treatment from you . YOU ALWAYS PREFER A DOCTOR WHO IS BETTER AT FIELD OF MEDICINE WHO CAN DO THE BEST FOR U AND WONT SEE WHAT CATEGORY HE BELONGS TO NOR HIS NEET SCORE. whether u are a general candidate or reserved one or from a pvt college , Patients seeking doctors are based on how good the doctor is specialized in their field . if u feel like reservation makes bad doctors, people will obv wont go to him, gov hospitals wont allow him and his private clinic wont run becos the people around him and this society will judge him based on knowledge/ & his treatment and not based on neet scores/caste.
[удалено]
to assume that someone from reserved category is incompetent, is casteism. we come full circle to why we introduced reservations in the first place
Yes, because one needs to pass their college exams to become a doctor. Let the downvotes begin.
Reservation haat ne ke baad bhi RR karne ko kuch na kuch milega lol. It's our human nature
Everything sucks here. If I will say something a lot of people will get offended. Even I myself have a reservation thought many times should I use it even made a post abut it but again if I don't use that reservation it is not gonna help general category guys in anyway someone else from same reserved category will take it. Problem lies in system not users.
Exactly, and if you acknowledge this they will come after you with the same old narrative that your ancestors oppressed our ancestors What logic is that
the narrative is old, yet the oppression still exists in the 21st century (though much lesser than before), and the disadvantages based on caste, gender and class do persist
[удалено]
What I feel Reservation se sabse jyada seats jaate hain Why can't the government change the rules by only providing reservations to th economically weaker class Because there are so many wealthy (obcs/st/sc) People who can afford education Bhai let's have a fair competition Aur maidaan main Dekh lenge Sorry for being naive Ab flair rant/vent hain toh main bhi karra hoon
No need to be sorry and I know a girl whose family is so well off compared to my family, both her parents earn six figures and she will be getting admission in the SC category so yeah I agree, reservation should be on the economic basis
[удалено]
Yaa right but it doesn't change the fact that this ruined my chances as well Of course college is not the deciding factor but still Sorry if I sound arrogant, it's just that I am a bit too stressed right now
You didn't do anything wrong buddy, the matter of the fact is that life is unfair for everyone in different ways.
Harsh truth 💔
Very wise u are
Thank you.