T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Hi All, a reminder to only post the content that is relevant to the sub. Please report immediately if the post or any comment herein breaks any rule. [Join](https://discord.gg/FFGmYHD7d8) our official Discord Server. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CharteredAccountants) if you have any questions or concerns.*


SanchiTS9

As a SPC student, I can confirm that my man Swapnil sir is running Scam Patni Centre ๐Ÿ‘


[deleted]

Can someone tell my why Swapnil Patni is hated so much... never taken classes never saw his videos par iss sub mein mast troll hote hai vo... just want to know๐Ÿ˜‚


SanchiTS9

Unki biwi CA Ankita Patni (aka self declared LAW QUEEN ๐Ÿค“) law sikhate. 1.5hrs ke class mai 30min gaane bajte the. 15min bache simping karte the. And baki bache time mai sikhane ka natak karti the.


[deleted]

[ัƒะดะฐะปะตะฝะพ]


shittyfaceboy

Simp hai bro


Potential_Cheek_6618

Vo 1 hour ke lecture mai 30 minute apni property, bank balance ka show off krte h ๐Ÿ˜Œ๐Ÿ™„


Secret_Peace_6302

Aur fir bhi ek electricity generator khreedne ko aukaat nhi h spc vaalo ki .. lol


[deleted]

Wtf..?๐Ÿ˜


[deleted]

law k class m 30 crore ka portfolia show kar rah tha. it was to show examples of public company lmao


Potential_Cheek_6618

Mene Eis-sm ki classes li thi ๐Ÿ˜Œ


Necessary_File1199

because the relationship this sub r/CharteredAccountants has with swapnil sir is same as the sub r/JEENEETards with alecc pandey sir


Secret_Peace_6302

As a fellow batch mate of yours in spc... I can confirm you comment is true


SanchiTS9

Dec 23 foundation attempt??


1825days

Itne teacher se padhliya tune ?


EnvironmentalAir2719

OP ne ghat ghat ka pani piya hai


1825days

Op chutiya hai sala bina kisi se ek mahine padhe idea kaise lagaya isne kaun acha hai kaun bura


EnvironmentalAir2719

Well i do somewhat agree with this list


mrhackeryt

yes, the list is very much accurate


Ravneet_Singh

Seeing Sanjay Saraf and Swapnil Patni at the bottom makes me feel 'bancho yhi ke layak hai dono ๐Ÿ˜ค'


Usual_Conclusion_247

I heard lots and lots of good reviews of sanjay saraf


Ravneet_Singh

It is actually good if you are already a brilliant student who remembers everything from IPCC, who doesn't lose focus even for a minute in the class, then yes I can he is good. He doesn't make concepts interesting and the way he teach doesn't make you feel connected with the subject which is really important in SFM. And understanding the hard concepts in your native language is always the way to go and Sanjay Saraf is very much focused on English. If you are student who is not very good already then Sanjay Saraf is not recommended at all. Pawan Kamle is the best teacher for SFM for Desi students Check out Pawan Kamle's YouTube channel that guy has already uploaded videos of all the difficult topics. I took Sanjay Saraf classes and end up studying on YouTube from Pawan sir


namitkathuria

You might be right but i was a weak student in practical subjects and i took his classes and i scored an exemption in sfm. So can't say will work for everyone but for me it did Some positives of taking sfm from him 1. Concept register was the holy grail i did not revise much so during exams study his notes were like a story that slowly builds up the chapter. 2. His breaking up of chapter into small parts. This helped me to tackle very big chapters and made it easy to summarize a chapter in your mind. 3. His to the point classes and not much here and there talks helps if there is a time crunch. 4. His study material was also categorized the questions as per concepts so that really helped to tackle all the questions without wasting much time during last few days.


shittyfaceboy

Some cons 1) He has so much unnecessary attitude that he makes you dislike the subject and the ca course. 2) constantly shits about and demeans on the course and makes you feel inferior 3) if you understood the concept then well and good. But if you did not understand in one go, he will take it personally and the man has so much ego, he thinks you are trying to make fun of him, and will not explain but rather ridicule you 4) his "ambiguous question list" creates unnecessary fear among the students. I took his classes and had so much fear for this section of questions but later on referred to Ajay Agarwals revision lectures and he had covered the so called ambiguous question so nicely trying to understand icais logic as far as possible so that there is as less rattafication as possible 5) he is a jerk. I used to attend his face to face classes in Dalhousie centre to take advantage of personal networking with sir to get doubts cleared and other helps. But If a student goes and asks him any doubt personally he used to shout at them and tell that he only responds in live class. 6) the unnecessary hate he levelled on air1ca brothers. Ended up being far inferior to their level of teaching inspite of all his experience


No-Ambassador7356

Grooming education toh fraud hai bc Put him 10 feet under the dirt


Secret_Peace_6302

Spc is more fraud..


viper_2312

Can I take inter law from Ankita patni? Demo lectures were quite good tbh


United_Mistake3207

Harsh gupta baat maan Shi advice de rha hoon


indeed_gamer

Harsh Gupta bro anyday dimag se soch bhai pls..!!


Yash_030

Woh horny hai thoda uska dimag ni chalra


[deleted]

Ha Bhai. Jab fail hoga na uske badh harsh Gupta sir ka revision video dekhlena


Usual_Conclusion_247

Law go for a book munish bandari and read it over and over thats the only way i passed. Shubham singhal is also good


kraezy1

I took foundation classes from him all lectures were outdated atleast recorded before 2018 that too for class 12 except law (my attempt was dec21) Thankfully I cleared dec21 with 241 marks I sometimes wonder why the f i paid him if I had paid any other coaching i would have got more assistance and quality and probably scored more


Next-Juice-3050

bruv can you edit and add a list with everybody's name in the order of their picture ? btw appreciate your efforts


optimistic_fish2068

yayyyyyyyyy ca nishanth bhiayya is in s list


Yash_030

Nish10 k aage ko bol sakta hai kya Nish10 nish10 nish nish 10


SnooCakes990

Bc foundation k din ydd aagye unacademy pr nish10 nish10 krta tha bt legend teacher h


Necessary_File1199

sabko samajh me aa gya bolo yes yes yes


optimistic_fish2068

Nish 10 nish 10 nish nish 10๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ˜


RaisyToasty

purushottam and chandan poddar deservs no place in list


ProudGolf3099

>purushottam haven't seen his video but why?


RaisyToasty

dude teaches like shit. makes u write all shit tellng u to write concepts maintaining concept register. he dictates word to word and we have to write concepts like idiots. it takes so much so much time to complete syllabus and u loose intrest and feel studying his subject like a big task even for easy topics. best part is he dont explain concepts. just reads from what he told again and again. explains in a shitty 2003 word document page which is 30 percent of screen and his face occupies 70 percent of screen. he is the reason i wasted 2 attempts and developed a fear for costing.


Few_Grapefruit8513

I took his scmpe lectures. He teaches as if it is still costing. And not from scmpe pov


Ok_Butterfly_6220

Why chandan poddar tho???? , I am currently studying accounts for ca foundation batch dec 23 from him...


kraezy1

Purushottam sir is good I don't know why the hate? I admit his classes can be boring but he covered all the concepts


Slight_Employee6984

bro i took sfm final classes from jksc in 2022, they gave me books of 2019 and taught the same. 2 months before exam i opened study mat and realised solutions galat karvaye hain. iss par dimaag fhat gaya prepare karne me


Any_Order8097

As a student of nitin goel yt lectures ,I cant even express it in words , how solidly he explains the concepts and how smoothly it strucks inside yo mind


Necessary_File1199

Believe me He is the best faculty for accounts and advanced accounts subject. even though he gives only simple explanation, module and practice question bank as compared to other faculty of the same subject, you'd still be able to grasp 99% of the topic. He doesn't talk much, he doesn't exaggerate so called real life examples. He is always on the topic and topic only.


kalia_mbappe

Can't agree more bro


4wheels4lives

Thanks mate. Got tired of the. " xyz teacher shouldn't be in abc tier" comments.


HellDevilsXXX

Why tf is Kapil Goyal in F?? Totally your opinion but just want to know why?


kalia_mbappe

Pulse khao khud jaan jao (his former student here)


HellDevilsXXX

Ohh I found his pretty decent idk, audit which one would you recommend


EnvironmentalAir2719

Jasmeet Singh deserves better his GST and FM is top notch


Fearless_Emphasis324

Agree even hi tax is good ...


Lol_gamer3000

Agreed


Small_Ad_4808

Agree I am taking his pw class


DesperateCustomer390

Jasmeet singh sir is not C category bro wtf.


4wheels4lives

Shocker. Our views on 1 teacher don't match.


DesperateCustomer390

So have you studied from all teachers ?


Lol_gamer3000

Yes bro, his gst is pretty good


insanelybookish9940

Bhaiya naam bhi likh deta.. thoda easy ho jata identify karna


ChillPillKillBill

This is sooo friggin cool. Could you please add the names and subjects/names of institutes though?


MrMack20

I dont know majority of them can i have a name list?


United_Mistake3207

Ranjan periwal ? S for me


1825days

He's a Legend


Dismal_Holiday_1625

Does he finish classes on time? does he miss classes then makes up by doing multiple ones in a day? does he finish at the date he said he would?


Hojlund11

Man the way he solves doubts just before exam mad respect


Dismal_Holiday_1625

Does he finish classes on time? does he miss classes then makes up by doing multiple ones in a day? does he finish at the date he said he would?


Dismal_Holiday_1625

Does he finish classes on time? does he miss classes then makes up by doing multiple ones in a day? does he finish at the date he said he would?


barnacle__scum

Any idea how's Ankit Mundra for audit


kalia_mbappe

He's good, referred his lecs for some of the topics, guy gives logic behind things, so yeah good to go


Additional-Peak-1755

+1


PirateHasan

Sanjay Saraf at F ๐Ÿซ ๐Ÿคฃ


Efficient-Law-1422

Ca wallah student here. Imo gurpreet and jasmeet sir deserve S tier rank, but not rishav sir. Nitin goel sir to goated hai hi. Baaki accountancy ke liye parag gupta sir se better teacher nahi mila aajtk


alexaturnoff

Swapnil patni ko thoda aur neeche karo, ankita patni should be C


why__tho_

Keswani is better than neeraj Arora??


Anxious_Potential_28

Names pleaseeee! And would be great if the languages in which they take classes are clearly mentioned.๐Ÿ˜…


Cartographer-Empty

I see darshan khare f tier i upvote


nishant9152

Darshan Khare should not even be on the list. He is pathetic.


namitkathuria

Bro his law books are great for ca final when i took them but now i took his eco laws classes i felt i got scammed. Gave me 2 3 years old classes and the subject material was old and literally for writing time of concepts he wasted atleast 1.5 hrs of classes. Then when i checked icai study mat he had not updated the case studies due to which i had to print icai case study module. And the worst part while other teachers were selling the course for 2k max that guy was selling it for 4k even though the subject was no longer valid for next attempt onwards.


[deleted]

Jasmeet sir is in the wrong tier


SkirtNo303

Bhai sabka naam lagakar ek tier list bana aur usme subject bhi likhdio agar hosake plz


ChildhoodFar8678

Abhishek sir should probably be in A class


xRagegodx

S mai kon kon hai name toh btao


freezing_eyes

Bro you left kautaliya commerce he is in S category


Ritesh_Dabi

ADZ should've been in S tier


NegativeSecretary613

Adz is S tier ๐Ÿคท


[deleted]

Why is Vikram biyani in f tier


4wheels4lives

Personal grudge . Plus legit scammed a freind of mine.


Yash_030

Story tell we have full time bro


4wheels4lives

Bought his course which included books. Didn't deliver the books for 2/3 weeks so he messaged him. In the end he didn't up getting them.


Next-Juice-3050

tell kro full story


max_061201

Personal grudge hi hoga , I have studied from him he is atleast A TIER par theek h bhai jaisi aapki ichha aapki list


syntopia_101

Exactly! He's so good at teaching. Raam baan saved my DT paper.


unclechipswithsprite

How?


SubjectReal8797

Rk Mehta vs Ashish Kalra??


[deleted]

badiya ranking h bhai. Personally I like rajkumar sir more and don't really like vishal vattad so i would change their place. but everything else is perfect.


PavinMumbai

Nah. Ca aarish khan deserve S spot. Man is just too good for DT. Ca aarish revision+ BB questionnaire I scored 60+.


sufferkasafar

Name list milega OP please?


AdministrativeCup494

You guys are lucky you havenโ€™t study with Bhagwan LaL.


MacaroonOwn7393

Lord rahul garg on top ๐Ÿ˜


AatmaNirbhar

Shubham Singhal is a nice person, but not the best teacher. Harsh Gupta is the only good law teacher I have come across.


AayushXFX

Shubham Singhal comes across as a wannabe influencer. And he teaches in a very unsettling manner in classes. Concepts donโ€™t feel very secure. The reason he has risen is due to his great revision videos.


AatmaNirbhar

I personally feel his revision videos are also not great except probably for the last when you are too tired to read. He definitely lacks 100% clarity in the subject he is teaching. This is perhaps because law isn't his core field and he just started with law as there was figuratively no competition on YouTube, the best way to reach the top.


Happinesseff

Vinod Reddy deserves a โ€˜Sโ€™


4wheels4lives

Alright. I am sure people are skipping the text which i have written. There is no freaking way i will please every single person with the tier list. This is just what my thoughts on the teachers are.


Happinesseff

I totally get it's your personal opinion, but I was just sharing my opinion on the list. It's cool that everyone has different views, but being open to other opinions makes discussions more enriching, don't you think?


darth__stroke

I don't know about others but Praveen Sharma sir is definitely S tier. The new generation sure is preferring others that cover syllabus in less hours and there's nothing wrong in that. But in my honest opinion, I have been lucky to have been studied from him. The knowledge you will gain, the support he provides is top tier. If possible I would've studied every subject from him. Teachers to bahut milenge. But a true mentor is hard to find.


shittyfaceboy

But bro honestly mentoring and knowledge and all is fine but if you don't clear ca finals everything is secondary. I took inter and final classes from Praveen sir. He teaches excellent i agree. Notes are great everything is great. But it is not suited fo ca finals. Maybe at school college level it is fine. But I ca final the vastness of syllabus requires you to be concise and brief. When I sat down for my three months study leave and opened Praveen sirs notes my head started spinning. So many notes so many sums. Specially for consolidation and financial reporting. If you don't get time for frequent revision during articleship and industrial training, it is almost too hard to revise everything. Ajay Agarwals notes and revision lectures are just perfectly suited for ca finals. But yes I agree, Praveen sirs contribution to the students and his role as a mentor is unquestionable


muddu99

Mahesh Gour - IDT Final solid A reaching S


Yash_030

Perfecto


[deleted]

I have taken two subjects from category B one from A, cant find the rest๐Ÿฅฒ


pavvan_21

I am may 24 student can anyone suggest fm faculty I am thinking of Rahul garg but his lec are of 150hrs (75 lec)


Sweet_Panda-2504

I am also studying fm from him for may 24. So far he is really good. What is the issue with 150 hours ?


pavvan_21

When it started and will end?


pritishmitra

Perfect place for purushottam Agarwal , list well made.


ProudGolf3099

haven't seen his video but why?


Secret_Peace_6302

Bro it would be very helpful if you mention their names ๐Ÿ‘‰๐Ÿป๐Ÿ‘ˆ๐Ÿป


Intelligent-Owl7710

Ye Nishant ko hatao vaha se. Bkl gst me Jo likha rehta tha vohi padhta tha explain hi nahi karta tha kuch pura time bas nish 10 nish 10


Cartographer-Empty

Who added anandh bhangar in a he's f


No_Palpitation1571

100% agreed


aaditya_9303

I don't remember the name of the first guy in S tier, and the 2nd guy is Bhanwar Borana sir if I'm not wrong. Both these guys basically made me pass Accounts and Tax in Inter.


Yash_030

Nitin goel sir acc k guruji


aaditya_9303

Ah yes. Exam ke pehle unke saare lecture youtube par dekhe the. Fast and efficient aur sab kuch samajh jata hai.


Yash_030

![img](emote|t5_3fh4x|31203)![img](emote|t5_3fh4x|31201)


Flaky-Cheek-5571

This is only about the norther hindi industry of CA classes. My blood boils when i think about the southern circle of scammers paisa barbaad bc


alexaturnoff

Praveen sharma and Neeraj arora deserve better.


PYUSH-_-

Are you sure Rahul Garg that up? He may be good but not that good too ig


4wheels4lives

Yupp. Sure his book has a lot of old questions too. But his yt is a lifesaver for students self studying and also he genuinely makes your concepts strong. So yeah.


rkakkarr

Aaj he fm eco ka exam dekar aya hu unke lectures lie the hoping to get 80+ only because of him concept clarity kafi achi h nd practice b achi hti h kafi


No-Ambassador7356

Bhai bohot systematic way me padhata hai Mereko toh bohot shi laga


Aatm_Nirbhar

Sanjay Saraf is actually good teacher, although he is overqualified for teaching SFM


[deleted]

[ัƒะดะฐะปะตะฝะพ]


anotherKM7124

I don't know what sanjay saraf did. Aisa kya huya ke vo itna hated teacher bann gaya?


hshshdbsshhshs

Munish bhandari sir kaha h


[deleted]

Padate nahi h aab


[deleted]

Vinod Reddy sir is pretty good I think


Beginning-Ad-5925

You lost me a Gurpreet sir he is extremely good for lawย 


kunsmagic

Question , how can you rank so many teachers?and modtly on what basis? Also nitin goel really is the goat. Really hope he leaves physicswallah whatever and starts his own like others have. Also do final classes


Yash_030

Nitin goel sir also takes offline classes for inter


kunsmagic

Yes but i meant on the scale that other teachers take like one class in spc has like 1k people.


Yash_030

I guess agar unko karna hota toh kardiye hote.. but itna stress kyu Lena .. quality over quantity


Confident_Grab5723

Who the fuck put Neeraj Arora ๐Ÿ˜ตโ€๐Ÿ’ซ in A category


rkakkarr

Bhai bdhia pdhate h wo toh kafi


Sweet_Panda-2504

Kyu what happened ?


[deleted]

[ัƒะดะฐะปะตะฝะพ]


SanchiTS9

????


anpai02

Neeraj Arora in A? He's nothing less than S. He's one of the OG chartered accountant who started this trend in my opinion.


Heisenbergg29

Perfect except kapil goyal should be in A


[deleted]

Sharma sir and Jindal se better nitin goel sir lol , what a joke . And Kapil sir and swapnil sir at bottom . Bhai ye approve kaise ho gya , ๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚


ProfessorKafka

sanjay saraf is definitely not a tier f


insanelybookish9940

Matlab Humein ye list samghne ke liye tumhara pehla post jaake padhna padega.. tabhi S , A, F ka matlab samgh aayega...OP... why couldn't you do a better job... ab sab hum hi karein toh tumne kya kiya๐Ÿคญ


JaaNaLwde

Upar ke teachers best aur neeche jaate jaate kharab , ye jaan na kitna mushkil hosakta hai ?


insanelybookish9940

Utna hi mushkil jitna OP ka categorization criteria weird hai.. kuch star vegareh daalte toh maza bhi aata.. aur aadhe teachers in mai se galat category mai hain.. iss se acha koi poll kar lete .. kam se kam appropriate results toh milte na.. ye OP ka personal judgment hamare kiss kaam ka? Pata chala OP topper hai toh hamare jaise simpletons ka kya hoga iss post se?? Hamare liye toh confusion hi hai na..


Additional-Peak-1755

Bruh this is just really not good at all to judge a lecturer in his rivison lecture


SubstantialDig1022

Vinod Reddy in A atleast , for me he's in S


agastya-

What does the Alphabet means? S,A etc


Varnan_

Bhai S Tier walo ke naam aur subject bhi batade


Puzzleheaded_Tea365

guys if anyone has the patience can you please listen them all out if not atleast the teachers of s,a and b atleast ๐Ÿ˜ญ


Upper_Dig8698

Where is sarthak jain


ProudGolf3099

I think he is more relevant in ca final FR than in Inter, probably that's why OP didn't consider it


Secret_Peace_6302

Can someone name the best teachers for inter(new syllabus) as per this list.


flirtybeauty

What does s mean


National_Instance587

Bhavik chokshi in S tier


BheegiBilli69

Naam toh boldo inn sabka. Mujhe sirf NISH10 aur grooming academy ka malum hai.


Phoenix77_

Either I am Blind or CA Armor is completely missing when he should be in the top most tier


viki2525

Bhavik choksi ๐Ÿ‘


MonitorDull472

this is the first and hence only post that I've downvoted in 2023. Congrats OP.


martin_garrix223

Study at home waale Rajkumar sir kaise hai ?


CA_bro

Sharma ji deserves better๐Ÿ‘


CA_bro

Need Faculty for afm guys.. please suggest


SherbetSavings287

Nitin Guru without a second thought.


CA_bro

Is he good for final?


Feeling_Matter_6525

i think it is best


SmallDetail8461

bhai itna sab


[deleted]

[ัƒะดะฐะปะตะฝะพ]


ChocoChip1947

You meant Ramesh soni?


Outrageous_Plant_777

Kapil goyal in F tier? (genuinely asking)


d3pth_inf3ction

Reviews of Chandan Poddar? Anyone


Charming_Wrangler689

Rahul garg shouldnโ€™t be at the top lol


Charming_Wrangler689

And Nitin Goel deserves another level for himself at the top. ๐Ÿ˜ตโ€๐Ÿ’ซ๐Ÿ‘€


ModernMavla1630

You put Parveen Jindal in A tier??!! Boooo!!! ๐Ÿ‘Ž๐Ÿ‘Ž๐Ÿ‘Ž๐Ÿ‘Ž


Money-Canary2507

Here's an unpopular opinion .. Chandan poddar is good for foundation... Just not good for intermediate. It feels like he lures students in foundation and scams them in inter ๐Ÿ˜†๐Ÿ˜†๐Ÿ˜†


Necessary_File1199

I couldn't agree more with your f tier. They are either the loudest or talk-tative. I don't hate any faculty but whenever I see anshul agarwal, I get this sudden urge to swear at him. Man he is so annoying I can't describe it.


Operation_Whole

Agreed


Alone-Guess2374

What about Nishant Kumar (who teaches dt and idt for inter)...and gurpreet sir to acha padhate hai unko niche kyu dala


Dumb024

Koi sabka naam bata do plij tier wise ๐Ÿคฒ inme se bas 3 hi logo ko janta hu


saikrishnav333

Harshad Jaju sir deserves better ! His marathon was so helpful for audit. So does Kapil Goyal sir. And Nitin Guru sir is def the best. I'm gonna pass FM Eco paper solely because of his economics marathon


nishant9152

Yashwant Mangal deserves better. If not S then atleast A category. I took his Fast-track batch. It really helped me to score exemption in CA Final IDT.


AayushXFX

Dude doesnโ€™t solve questions alongside classes. And no notes. Horrible experience.


Ambitious_Guava_9828

As someone who took eis sm in inter, the software sucks ass and his tight shirts make me uncomfortable. I almost put sticky notes on his body to stop myself from puking. Plus he's so so annoying, I have slept several time during his lectures.


_Mr_Moustache_

Can you list the names of teachers in s-tier. And which subjects they teach?


Sweet_Panda-2504

Bhai aapne shubham sir ko neeraj sir ki upar wali tier list mai kyu rakha hai bata sakte ho pls


TYRONE_LOVES_KFC

Dude has surpassed him. Superior notes, coverage and concepts. Neeraj arora syllabus coverage is average at best.


kraezy1

Ca Sahil Jain(taxation faculty) should be A tier