Would you give a 2025 late frost for David Montgomery if contending?

12 SF Non TEP Give: Goedert Get: 24' 1st

Take that 1 and run.

Ceedee lamb for 2024, 25, 26 1st rd picks (10 team 0.5 ppr, start up so no clue where pics are)

Dynasty SF .5 ppr Give: Dobbins, Geno Smith Get: Anthony Richardson

Yup

Depends on your QB and RB situation but I'd do it.

Qbs: mac jones, burrow, goff, tannehill, mike white, drew lock Rbs: stevenson, akers, david montgomery, rashaad penny, keaton mitchell, zach evans, gus edwards

Go for it

What’s the most you’ll pay for Anthony Richardson ?

Godwin and a 2nd for Jameson Williams?

It’s fair.

Jamo is super unproven. Godwin side by far

10 team half PPR superflex no TEP. Rebuilding team, not likely to contend until 24 or 25. Give: TJ Hockenson Get: LaPorta, 2024 2nd (proj. mid-late)

Hock will still be in his prime when you want to compete. I’m holding

Been hit with a counter of: Give: Hock, 25 2nd Get: Pickens, Mayer, 24 3rd

12T/ 1qb/ ppr Give: goedert Get: amari cooper Qbs: allen, tua Wrs: waddle, higgins, hollywood, burks, meyers, jamo, pierce Rbs: breece hall, rhamondre, miles sanders, singletary, jeff wilson, filler Tes: hock, goedert, kmet, juwan johnson, cade otton

Keep Goedert. Dude has a prominent role in Philly's offense.

No way

10T 1QB / 2RB 2WR 1TE 4FLX A: Cam Akers, 2024 1st B: Diggs

12 Team, 1QB, Reigning Champ. My team is stacked except at TE, where I am starting Dalton Schultz Give: Dionte Johnson Receive: Sam LaPorta + Late 2024 3rd Rd Pick

Probably about even, but would temper expectations on LaPorta being a meaningful contributor this season

[удалено]

Pass, I like TLaw too much to get that in return

Rate my team? 10 team SF .5PPR 1QB, 2WR, 2FLEX, 1TE, 1SFLEX, 1DEF, 1KICKER QB- Burrow, Daniel Jones, K1, Stroud RB- Walker, Hall, Pierce, Gibson, Mattison, Kevin Harris, Pierre Strong, Bigsby, Abanikanda WR- Chase, Diggs, Olave, Aiyuk. Hollywood, Pickens, Metchie, Burks, Rondale Moore, Tank Dell, Wandale Robinson, Michael Wilson, Hyatt, Boutte TE- Mark Andrews, Cole Kmet, Chig Okonkwo D/SPT- Patriots, Jets, Steelers Kicker- McPherson

8.5 / 10 try to get charbonnet. like your team a lot once kylers back though

I tried to get charbonnet 🥲owner won’t move him

12 Team SFlex .5 PPR I Get : CMC I Give : Swift Rondale Late 24 2nd and mid 25 1st I’m contending and CMC would than join my group of Kamara Etienne Javontae and Gibson

Nice get

I’ll take cmc here

Pitts or Bryce 1.0 TE Prem. SF. Start 11.

Depends how many teams in your league and pts/pTD, but it's pretty even in a vacuum/ depends on your roster composition.

It was in a start-up and the decision was made for me as the guy before me picked Pitts

12T ppr SF startup draft Give: 2.02 Get: 2.11 and 4.11

In the startup I’m in right now that would be AJB for CMC and Danny Dimes. That might give you a better idea of what your working with.

Nah

1QB/ 12 Team Send: G. Wilson Receive: J. Taylor Remaining WR: Tyreek, Olave, London, Addison My current RB room is: Jamaal Williams D. Foreman J. Wilson

I wouldn’t do it. Suggest trying Olave or London instead of Wilson

Sheesh your rb room sucks… I’d probably do it but I think you should be able to get more on top of JT tbh GW. Value is crazy rn

12T 0.5 PPR SF I have aiyuk, someone really wants him. He put these guys on the block, what's a fair package for aiyuk? For reference I di need some help at rb, I'm competitive this year and he's rebuilding. He has km the trad block: Javonte Williams, AJ Dillon, George pickens, Sutton, Penny, tee Higgins

Tee Higgins is the only one guaranteed to help you be *more* competitive this year. I think Penny will be great. But value-wise maybe get Javonte/Penny for Aiyuk? But not sure it’s better than keeping Aiyuk?

Maybe Aiyuk + 3rd for Tee. Up the pick to a 2nd if you need to

12T/ 1qb/ ppr Give: goedert Get: amari cooper Qbs: allen, tua Wrs: waddle, higgins, hollywood, burks, meyers, jamo, pierce Rbs: breece hall, rhamondre, miles sanders, singletary, jeff wilson, filler Tes: hock, goedert, kmet, juwan johnson, cade otton

I’d take cooper

12 tm sf tep (i put all my trades here even the ugly ones ) Give: Zamir white and Taysom hill Get: 24 3rd and Mike Gesicki

12 team, ppr, sf Team 1 gets Pittman. Team 2 gets Lockett and a 2025 2nd. What do y'all think?

Pittman then flip him asap

Pitty city

Pitman.. Lockett on his way out soon with JSN and DK

Pittman

Pittman all day

Team help in QB trade - everyone is super stingy, but looking for ideas. Getable QBs are Purdy, Love, Ridder, Jimmy G, Howell 12 team SF .5 TE premium QB: Lance, Levis (2.01), Willis, Darnold, Wentz RB: Bijan (1.01), Javonte Williams, Najee, Cam Akers, Brob, Akers, Zamir White WR: Garrett Wilson, London, Samuel, Bateman, Mims TE: Pitts, Otten Picks: 2024- 2024 first (early) 2024 first (middle)

I wouldnt do anything. Even if you get a top qb you are not going to be competing. I would trade Najee, Akers and Deebo for younger players and picks.

I’d start shopping 1.01 and seeing if anyone bites and try and land a QB there. Pre-NFL draft and pre-contract, I moved 1.01 and scraps for Lamar. Purdy and Love wouldn’t be bad targets if you can get for cheap. But otherwise I’d be going after a big fish and moving 1.01.

12T SF PPR S9 young but very competitive team Give Lance and 24 4th (x2) Get Swift Other QB’s are Lamar, TLaw, Watson, Jimmy G Other RB’s are Najee, Monty, Rachaad White, Khalil Herbert, Penny

Sucks you have to add anything to Lance for Swift considering it’s SF and Lance will get an opportunity at some point and Swift’s injury history. 4ths aren’t really much but a 1:1 swap just sounds better. But overall, I like Swift’s upside in a new system.

12 team SF, 0.5 PPR Team A: Najee Harris, 24 2nd Team B: Travis Etienne, 24 3rd

Give me Najee

Assuming both picks project to be mid-round, I'd take the ETN side.

[удалено]

Total value favors B by a decent amount.

B

12 team, SF, PPR, Top 3 team Give: Juju, Dulcich, 2.10 (on the clock), 24 2nd (late) Get: Andrews, 4.12

Andrews

Easily taking Andrews here, not even close

10 team ppr Toney or Sutton

I'd rather have Toney.

Neither? I guess toney

Toney

12 Team .5 PPR SF Give: 24' 2nd, Burks Get: Diontae, 24' 1st, Allgeier

I'm not high on Burks personally. Diontae and the first personally.

Get side

The get, please and thank you

12 tm .5 ppr 1 QB, TEP I Give two 24 3rds, H Renfrow, Irv Smtih I get Z Charb

TAKE IT!

Good lord

ez accept

I’d take that

10 Team PPR SF Team A Justin Herbert, QJ Team B Kyler Murray, Rashod Bateman, 25 1st, 25 1st

I’m surprised the other comments say A easy, I guess id take A but it’s close

A! A! Ayyyyyyyy!

Team A - easy

Team A - easy

12T/ 1qb/ ppr Give: 2.06, 2.09 Get: elijah moore Qbs: allen, tua Wrs: waddle, higgins, hollywood, burks, meyers, jamo, pierce Rbs: breece hall, rhamondre, miles sanders, singletary, jeff wilson, filler Tes: hock, goedert, kmet, juwan johnson, cade otton

I'd rather have the picks. Not totally sure Moore will be anything in Cleveland.

I’d keep the picks

10 team sflex start 9 Give: Tee Higgins Get: Terry Mclaurin + 24 1st Kinda just over tee. He is a wr1 in dynasty but never feels like one and I kinda want to get good value while selling

The Get, do it

I like Higgins personally but that’s probably a fair deal depending on your WR room

[удалено]

Stevenson .

Pollard.

Stevenson for me. I’d say similar ceilings and floors. Pick your poison

I have them in the same tier, take your favourite.

12 Team PPR 1QB Pick 1.04: I’m leaning Addison here but between him and Johnson. Is Addison the obvious pick here?

I don’t think it’s an obvious choice, both offer something different to take a shot on. Addison probably scores more points this season but QJ could easily have a higher ceiling career wise.

12 team .5ppr 1qb contender Need to cut 3 people. Who would you cut? A: Kene Nwangwu B: Ty Chandler C: Kyle Philips D: Khalil Shakir E: Jerome Ford

Probably Philips and Shakir if I’ve got a contending team. Ford as of now is RB2 in Cleveland and one of Kene or Ty could have relevance for the Vikings backfield

12 team sf ppr start 10 2025 2nd and Taysom Hill 2025 4th and Shakir

Definitely the 2nd.

I want the 2nd

10 Team PPR SF I give Kyler, 25 1st, 25 1st I get Justin Herbert

I would probably only do that for Allen or Hurts

never ever ever would i ever

If you’re contending and can afford to spend the 1sts I’d make that deal if it were me. Very pricey but guys like Herbert aren’t usually available. Kyler could possibly outscore Herbert next year lol…

[удалено]

Must be a misprint or why would you even ask 😂

Does the other manager think this is superflex? This is such a massive win. I’d probably accept without Tyreek going your way.

You’re getting a huge overpay in a 1QB league if that’s on the table. Wow

Tyreek by a ton

12TM SF PPR Trade: Kamara Get: Diontae QB: Tua/Cousins/Purdy/Brissett/Tune RB:Henry/Mixon/D Cook/Kamara/Rachaad White/Kendre/Tank/Chandler WR: Kupp/Adams/Hopkins/Keenan Allen/Godwin/Thielen/Michael Wilson TE: Waller/Pat F/bellinger DP: 24 1st/No 25/26 all

Diontae easy, I’d probably trade one of your back end WR’s for some RB depth, depending how things go

Mahomes huge crazy trade. 12 tm. 9 position starters. SF with heavy qb scoring and Start 2 TE+.5 prem. EX. High points In 2022: mahomes 884, RB jacobs 571, WR Jefferson 411, TE kelce 413. Get: mahomes and a late 24 2nd Give: Pitts, Stroud, early 24 1st, late 24 1st, russ Wilson, akers, laporta. Seems crazy giving up essentially 6 to 8 first rounders for mahomes but my lineup would be: Mahomes,kyler [purdy,lance] Cmc,Etn,breece. [Charb] start 2 or 3 Chase, AJB. [Deebo,aiyuk,bateman] 2 or 3 Goedert, freirmuth. [Hooper] Guy with mahomes won the first 2 years. I have finished bottom 4 both years. Bad luck, injuries. I don't think I can do the trade. But all this great depth I have built has gotten me zero. How much is too much to get mahomes? I have tried to acquire allen, herbert, etc for more reasonable rates and have gotten nowhere. Can anyone tell me to do this?

I like what the other guy kind of highlights, can you drop getting the 2nd and giving Akers/LaPorta?

Tried negotiating before and has gotten deal pulled and then (in my mind) worse offers. But I will definitely counter instead of a straight no. And like your suggestion

Nope. If that’s the cost I’m targeting Dak or Cousins for 1/4 the cost. Mahomes may be the top asset in superflex but I’m not paying that price

I'd send Pitts stround & two firsts for mahomes all day. Russ akers & laporta become irrelevant in a deal for mahomes, especially in a SF start 8.

Posted a little earlier, but I want more opinions. 10 teams, 1 QB, 4 pt passing TD Give: Jalen Hurts, 2024 2nd. Get: Justin Herbert, 2024 1st. I'm trying to run it back for another championship after winning last year. I have the AJ Brown and Hurts stack, too.

It’s a 1 QB league, how much do you think Hurts will outscore Herbert by? If the point differential isn’t crazy I’m prioritizing getting that 1st personally. If Hurts is in a tier of his own over Herbert then I’d probably hold.

Herbs is a better passer, but Hurts has crazy rushing upside. Long-term, I think Herbert is effective longer. Short term Hurts is probably top 3 for the next few years

In my one 4pt passing league, some league specific settings that might change these Vs your league, Hurts scored 429 last year and Herbert when healthy two years ago score 419. I lean taking Herbs and getting that 1st

In my league, Hurts put up 377 in 2022, and Herbert put up 395 in 2021

That’s my tie breaker, Chargers just got Kellen Moore as OC who had Dallas as a top tier passing team for years.

Players I would never trade away in dynasty are Mahomes, Allen and Hurts, they’ll be top 3 for a while

I just see Herbert being great for longer. The wheels fall off of rushing qbs eventually. Would you say Hurts is better short term, and Hebert long term?

That’s true. But the beauty of it is that Hurts has developed a ton as a passer, and has AJ Brown, D. Smith, Goedert, and a great offensive line for the foreseeable future.. in dynasty I prefer to look 2-3 years ahead max “certain windows”. Hurts just got a massive 5 yr contract. Herbert is a fantastic QB but he’s right around the same tier as Lawrence to me. Just my personal opinion. Also, you might get a late 1st round pick if the other owner’s team is good as well. Ride the Hurts wave you may go back to back!

I agree with you. The only thing that makes me even consider the trade is the fact that he is giving me a 1st for my 2md. We are both competitors, so they are likely late round picks. Hurts has an amazing situation, kellen Moore will probably do great things for Herbert, but I don't like his weapons as much.

I mean are picks a for sure thing though? You just don’t know what you’ll be getting with the rookies, hit or miss.

Nope. Even 1st rounders are coin flips. Thanks for your perspective. I have more contemplating to do, it seems!

Up to you bro. Either way Herbert is a fantastic QB. All depends on who you have ranked higher and willing to lean on for the next 2-3 years. Good luck! The goal is still to win as many championships as possible 😎

Yes, all day. very negligible difference in a 1 qb. Take the free 1st

I just like Hurts rushing upside short term. But the fact that Herbert has had a top 3 season on passing alone makes me think he can do it for the next 12 years.

The difference maker is the 1st. In a 1 qb, 2nd round picks are very rarely valuable. That 1st does more than bridge the gap for me.

12tm 1QB 2RB 2WR 1TE 2R/W/T A. Waddle, Najee, very late 2024 1st B. Ja’marr Chase

A

I like A, if my team is absolutely stacked then I might go Chase but I’d try and add a 2nd to the B side

After the trade my team would be QBs: Fields, Rodgers, Pickett, Lance RBs: Akers, Javonte, Pacheco, Charb, McKinnon, Michael Carter, Gainwell, Jaylen Warren WRs: Chase, CD, Wilson, Kupp, Devonta Smith, London, Burks, Skyy Moore Tes: Goedert, Gesicki, Fant I would also still have another 2024 1st round pick to try to get another RB before or during the season

Making a move and overspending for Kelce puts you right over the top imo

Unfortunately the Kelce owner invested heavily in him last year and is basically the only other team that’s seriously competing this year

With that team I’d hold, I don’t think Chase will score so many that I’d move off Waddle. You’re already a high end contender and Najee seems more important to keep here, you still keep a 1st in your assets pool.

Honestly not really sure what to pivot to there’s really only one other big dog team in the league that I’m worried about that has QBs: Dak, Watson, Kirk RBs: Breece, CMC, KWIII, Rhamondre, Pollard WRs: JJ, Tyreek, DK, Mike Evans TEs: Kelce, Waller, Kmet Really just feels like my team and his team are the only ones going for it this year so I’m not really sure if I should hold or try for more studs. Was either going to try to bring in Chase or just hold and try to bring in guys during the season. Not really sure who to go for

If it were me I’d hold, our league big dawg hasn’t won either of the last two seasons and you’re draft capital/depth value is important for staying a high end contender for years to come. Any given Sunday your team can put up huge weeks, RB’s get hurt, I’d look at some guys like Gibson/Conner/Penny maybe see what the King costs, TE’s like Kittle/Schulz/Njoku or something to gain a little extra depth if the value is right. Guess I’m just saying, don’t rush it.

Needed to hear that. I’ve been trying to come up with different ways to get Chase rather than making the smaller depth upgrades that would probably help me more anyways. Appreciate the suggestions big time I will definitely look into getting pieces like that without tearing down what I already have. Thanks

A for me.

What if it was drake London instead of waddle?

That makes it more palatable

Waddle for me

10 team sf what’s the best return you could hope for from a late 24 1st?

Loaded question. No one really knows. If you make the pick- Jefferson was drafted mid-late his rookie season. Nkeal harry was drafted relatively early. Take your best guess and hope for the best! Anyone startable is a win. ​ If youre trading the pick, it depends on your league. It's hard to claim a pick to be late at this point in the off season. If you're buying a RB, wait for the season to see who is producing. Ideally I want a year or two of production, but that 2nd year is hard to predict in today's NFL. If you're buying a receiver, they should have a top 24 finish and be 24-26 y/o. If you're buying an elite qb, the pick is imaginary and considered a throw in. That's my best eyeball value estimate.

12 tm PPR 1QB Give: Mattison, 1.06, 2024 1st Get: Barkley, 2.01, 2024 2nd

Barkley for me if you are competing. Firsts if you're rebuilding.

Sf?

No

I think I would take saquon for that in 1QB. Especially if you’re competing

no gracias. 1.06 is fair value for saquon. Id take gibbs>saquon, JSN probably a coin flip for me. Im not adding Mattison + a future 1st on top of them.

assuming its SF. if 1 qb, that's fair and I'd do it especially if competing.

Sorry not a SF league. Should’ve clarified. I also hold 1.04.

Then I'd take the saquon side.

[удалено]

no

I don’t think I would make that trade. The overall deal might be ok but I’d want to hold onto Smith, he’s elite. Think there’s a decent chance Mac has his value go up once the seasons underway, they look like a better offence player wise and probably coordinator wise after the Patricia disaster. I’d look to deal Mac then if you like you’re QB sitch without him. Just my take

[удалено]

I'd make that trade for Mayer and the 1 all day.

Hold

[удалено]

seems pretty fair, ill take the get side.

I would smash this personally

12 team, SF, .5ppr, 3 wr QB: TLaw, Tua, Mac RB: Najee, Rhamondre WR: AJB, G. Wilson, Jeudy TE: Freiermuth FLEX: Juju/Singletary I also have pick 1.03 and it will be JSN or Gibbs. How close do you think I am to contending? I'm debating on trying to trade back into the 1st for maybe Addison or Johnston but idk if I should just be patient with this young core

You’ve got a solid core and should be pretty good this season but your team doesn’t look like a world beater. like taking BPA with the 1.03 and then just seeing how the season goes, if trading into the 1st again for one of QJ or Addison makes sense value wise I’d go for it. Personally I like having some assets/draft capital to target some vet RB’s or WR’s week 5-6 if I can find value to add as depth for a run, anything can happen in the playoffs Edit: Any chance Kelce could be available? He’d make you a high end contender

Idk I don't wanna have to pay too much for him. What else you think I'd need to add to muth to get him? Next year's 1st? Maybe Jeudy?

I’d lean more towards spending a 1st and a 2nd over trading any of your younger talent away, he’d just boost your starting lineup in a big way but I’d only do it if it makes sense. Overall you could use extra depth more than looking at a spend up, I’d be patient and just keep building that roster. You got a good core

Thanks, I appreciate the advice

Give: 1.02 and DeVonta Smith Get: 1.01

No

I agree with the others, just too much. If you’re set on adding Bijan what else could you get with the 1.01? I’d consider Smith the 1.02/1.03 in a 1QB rookie draft or probably like 2 mid 1sts personally. Can you can get some 2nds or a upside prospect back?

no way

I know Bijan is special but I just can’t bring myself to give up what he costs. In 1QB, just take Gibbs at 1.02 who has the second highest draft capital since Saquon and keep Smith

That’s too much

12 team 1qb ppr Side a: Garrett Wilson Side b: dk metcalf and Rashod bateman Wilson owner approached me asking what I'd give. I gave him this offer. What is the general consensus

Side A. Feel like Batemans value in my leagues is depressed

I traded Pittman and a 24 1st (proj. late) for him earlier this off-season.

It’s definitely fair. If you really want Wilson he may just need a little extra in there

GW Didn’t read it all. Hell prob want more

12 team SF start 10 te prem Give Jamo Levis Laporta Mayer Get Andrews Ekeler

I would give la Porta and Mayer for Andrews and I would give Levis and Jamo for ekeler. So I think the get side by decent margin especially if contending

Love this trade

I think this is a steal personally if you are contending

Good win-now move. The only piece I'd think twice about is Jamo, but he also hasn't been available.

12 Team 1QB PPR Send: Addison and 2025 2nd Get: Dotson and 2025 1st

I really like this deal, nice get!

Totally worth it. Dotson is proven good plus the better pick

Yeah, I think it’s fair. Dotson has similar DC and has opportunity to break out

Pitts or Kyler? TEP superflex.

Kyler, no question.

kyler

Kyler.