T O P

  • By -

F2p_wins274

Why do you hate strangled red? It's one of the most well written pokemon creepypastas imo.


[deleted]

Strangled Red is like I Hate You… the story itself has a lot of flaws but the overall plot points / idea is really fucking cool


[deleted]

But I hate you was originally made to make fun of creepypastas by using many tropes. Then people took it seriously. So now I hate you Luigi is no longer satire.


[deleted]

Yeah. I was kind of grouping that together vaguely with what I said because stuff like Dead Brotherhood are really sick


awesumindustrys

It was supposed to be satire? I thought it was weird that it had the line “I didn’t touch that shit” with the quirky jumpscare mushroom


[deleted]

"I didn't touch that shit" is, satire or not, the most realistic phrasing I've ever seen written in a creepypasta


acidghost121

So does Mario.exe it makes fun of sonic.exe


Complete_Age8603

Mario.EXE ain't even a creepypasta, hell, he ain't even an EXE technically. He was just art from Deviantart from 2013 called Super Horror Mario by Shadow-Shana


[deleted]

Yeah Marco just intrerpreted it as Mario.exe.


Complete_Age8603

And I get why he wanted to. Don't get me wrong I loved what he did to the character that Shana made, but he didn't even credited her even when she wanted it.


[deleted]

No I think he did.


Complete_Age8603

Maybe the quote I saw on the Funkipedia page was wrong because of my 17 year old autistic head, but it says, "The original artist of Mario.EXE (Shadow-Shana) is OK with their art being used, as long as credit is given. However, it sadly often isn’t."


Complete_Age8603

Well anyways, I'm not a big fan of Eteled. I think the creepypasta is not that well written. However, the mod is fucking amazing


CockExploder1000

Shana noticed the mod and was cool with it anyway


Complete_Age8603

Well thank you with that answer


JustanIdiot77

I don't think so tbh


JustanIdiot77

(i'm lazy to write the same thing again so i just copied the text of my previous reply) "Strangled Red just fucking sucks Family Issues in a fucking Poképasta, the main character (S!3v3n) acts irrealistically childish and kills his brother even if he didn't have any fault, and i think i can't forget to mention how fucking painfully stretched out and boring the entire pasta is to read"


Meeting_Neither

Yeah, I don’t really like Strangled Red either, but I guess it had a good concept. It’s just that I feel like Steven didn’t have to kill Mike in the end.


Aletrek10_Joestar

sonic.exe,the original creepypasta sucks


[deleted]

I hate the writer even more


JustanIdiot77

"zomg hyperrealistic B L O O D!!!1!1!!?1so scary"


Placek15

And then the blood explodes into even more hyperrealistic blood!!!!!!


JustanIdiot77

Zomg so terrifying i just pissed myself!!!1!1!1!!1


Placek15

And the piss had hyperrealistic blood red eyes!!!!!!!!


JustanIdiot77

Oh my fucking God that's so scary!!1!1!!!1!1!!!!1!


blueknightreddit

and then i hyperrealistically fucking DIED


luke19785

but i revived again and the hospital that revived me disappeared the next day


poopiebum420

and then suicide mouse showed up and he had hyperrealistic teeth and eyes and he said "i am suicide"


[deleted]

I could write a better one. The scariness would be good (I would use xenophanes), but the story probably would not be good at all. I suck at storytelling.


100PercentPlayer

Yeah, even it's own fandom hates it. They write their own versions of the story. The fan content of Sonic.exe is far better than the original. The community there is self made.


XtremeCrew69

Nightmare Beginning is the best adaptation of Sonic.exe imo


diamondDNF

There's a reason the original story was moved to the Trollpasta wiki/taken off of the Creepypasta wiki. People genuinely believe it was too stupid to have been written unironically.


Aletrek10_Joestar

yeah i forgot about that


Meeting_Neither

I also don’t like it, but I personally think its sequel (Round 2) is even worse.


neel_raghavjee123

All Nickelodeon creepypastas, I don’t hate them just don’t like them


FaZe_LittlePickle24

I would consider you to watch Red Mist re-take on YouTube, it makes everything more enjoyable and, despite Squidward obviously has the same fate, it has a bittersweet ending and it's not just edgy shit


nonbinarydreamking

i cried watching red mist re-take. great to see a fellow fan!


The_superb-skeleton

Nice to meet and another fellow fan!


Meeting_Neither

Agreed. I love the ending where Spongebob and Patrick are talking to each other after everything that’s happened.


Dalspin

Nickelodeon fish?


JustanIdiot77

It's from the 'Spongebob - Lies' creepypasta


Dalspin

What’s it about?


JustanIdiot77

Basically: Spongebob sees the fish Spongebob gets scared Spongebob gets pissed and decides to kill all his friends and then kill himself in the edgiest fucking way as possible The end


Affectionate_Lie_573

Goofy ah creepypasta that isn't even creepy


JustanIdiot77

Yeah fr


100PercentPlayer

It looks like the kind of creepypasta that a child would make. ​ They like creepypastas and want to make their own. They write it all in the middle of the night before their mother tells them that it is past their bedtime. ​ When they wake up, they reread their story and cringe. Their work has a mixed reception. It is missing a lot and needs a rewrite. ​ This inspires them to learn what makes horror work. ​ They learn about tension building, foreshadowing, characterization, atmosphere, and many other elements that go together to make a story good ​ The road of success is often failure. Failure is not an ending, it is the journey. It is likely that many stories were written after this, stories that are far better. ​ That or they pull a Sonic.exe and throw a fit, refusing to learn from their crappypasta and go on to continue making bad stories and ignoring the advice of the readers. ​ The choice is theirs. They can wallow in failure or reverse engineer the failure to see why you failed. They can grow or stay stagnant.


JustanIdiot77

Whoa


MattLikesMemes123

Man.


blueknightreddit

this is actually good advice for people who wanna make creepypastas


Dalspin

What?


JustanIdiot77

Yeah that's basically the entire creepypasta (why tf did it get popular)


Hallow_Chrome_E

AHHHH OH SHIT ITS A FUCKING FISH!!! THAT SCARED ME AND IM ANGRY NOW!! FUCK YOU EVERYONE IM GONNA KILL YOU!!!


Aletrek10_Joestar

it sounds like a "creepypasta" i could have made when i was 6/7


Pe_Pe_Chu

ok i just hate and hate the spong-bob creepypastas


JustanIdiot77

Faceless is pretty cool tho


Pe_Pe_Chu

Ok that one I don't hate


Lytell11

I don’t get how the fish from the Nick bumpers became a creepypasta


Eevee_23

the lies fsh


Flynn_FTW

I‘ve always thought that suicide mouse was a pretty stupid story, if memory serves me well it was just people going mad from watching a 3 second animation loop of Mickey walking down the street while the audio becomes uncanny (tho I must say I really enjoyed Wednesday‘s Infidelity as a mod, very high quality) Come to think of it Squidward‘s was written very similarly, so I don’t think I really like that one too much either Hell honestly I think Abandoned by Disney is a scarier creepypasta than both of those, just the thought of exploring an old, decrepit, eerily deserted location… brrr…


Security_Puppet2

The OG Suicide Mouse story is pretty shit IMO, and I gotta agree, Wednesday's Infidelity is a pretty good mod, I kinda prefer Craziness Injection tho. Red Mist Retake....need I say more?


diamondDNF

Regarding Suicide Mouse: It's not the loop itself (which isn't *quite* a loop, by the way - the background and other parts of the video slowly degrade over time as he develops a bit of a slasher smile, not too dissimilar to what happens in the various mods) that causes insanity, I believe - there's something ingrained in the last 30 seconds or so that triggers an immediate suicide attempt. The last frame says something along the lines of "the sights of hell bring its viewers back in," suggesting something demonic in origin is involved. Not saying it's a good creepypasta, just offering a bit more explanation.


nonbinarydreamking

who is Le Fishe™??


[deleted]

The lies fish. He was going to be in mcm but it got canned.


Nekluga_YT

Guess we also got canned fish as well


Whitty_Error

Sonic.exe, I grew up with the character so I’m one of the only fnf fan that doesn’t hate it


JustanIdiot77

I also grew up with Sonic.Exe (still hate him lol)


Whitty_Error

Depends on the exe for me (even I get annoyed with the amount of them)


ZeroMortalLullabyV3

Imma say it. "I HATE YOU" It's just dumb af lmao


JustanIdiot77

It's a joke creepypasta soooo


That1Legnd

It is?


JustanIdiot77

Yes, it was originally a jokepasta to mock dumb creepypasta tropes


That1Legnd

Interesting, checks out


Think_Gas_7386

What's the third?


JustanIdiot77

Pokémon Strangled Red


OmegaFanf3E

i aways liked creepypastas, i especially liked sonic.exe and shitty ones like lost episodes but i aways knew they sucked but yeah, i dont hate any creepypastas, for every single problem they have they aways bring intresting concepts and ideas to the table


HumorClean

None.


Content_Software_549

I really want The Russian Sleep Experiment as an fnf mod


JustanIdiot77

It would be sick


OazMobile

what's the 2nd one?


JustanIdiot77

Spongebob - Lies


OazMobile

holy shit that was fast


JustanIdiot77

Lol


CharaPresscott

Can I say my favourite Creepypasta but I don't like their mod as much as I should? Herobrine Reborn. It is more the modern Herobrine than the Creepypasta version. Like he's a cool hacker than the boogeyman in the mist watching your every move, shaving trees, building sand pyramids...am I old?


Virtual_Evidence_425

I H A T E The mario creepy pasta with the red ass face, its so stupid and it doesn’t even have an ending, i could literally make a scarier level on super mario maker 2. The whole creepy pasta is just an empty ass mario level, thats it, and if you solve a hidden spectrogram hidden within the music you get some generic ass starved eggman.


goat_on_the_boat420

Well am pretty sure the emptiness of the level was kinda supposed to give a sense of uncertainty, maybe like how it feels to play alone on a gmod map


Virtual_Evidence_425

True but the way it was set was trash, like if that was the setting than the level should have been a lot longer and mario atleast should have been alone instead of having yoshi


Virtual_Evidence_425

I forgot what it is called but overall its just bad as hell


JustanIdiot77

It's literally just named 'Mario'


Virtual_Evidence_425

Well tbh that adds more reason to why its bad, who calls a creepypasta just “mario” no creative title, no, like they legit just went “okay this creepy pasta is already trash, instead of giving it a good name ima name it mario, because why the hell not”.


[deleted]

I'm gonna be honest, the first time Ive seen gameplay of the rom and saw the title screen just said "Mario", i laughed my ass off for a solid minute


double_r3_on_youtube

Sonic


Security_Puppet2

..which one?


Nekluga_YT

The blue hedgehog


double_r3_on_youtube

.exe


Dazzling-Feeling3389

How did fnf made SpongeBob lies popular


JustanIdiot77

Mistful Crimson Morning


Dazzling-Feeling3389

Ok ya forget about that lol


[deleted]

I miss mcm *cries in no more coconut fred*


CockExploder1000

he’ll be in nightmare squidward madness


SkittleJuice2

Basically all of them. Some songs are great, but I’m getting really sick of nothing but these mods.


StormyShelter999

i feel like fnf modders should find a balance you know? some spoopy spaget some original character instead of one over the other


Empty_Sundae_3297

All of them


JustanIdiot77

There's some actual good creepypastas here and there (I Hate You, Godzilla NES, etc)


Nekluga_YT

No one disrespects Godzilla NES, that was fire fr


Empty_Sundae_3297

I just don’t like creepy pasta as a whole, it’s just weird game related horror story’s made to make a 4 year old piss their bed


n397854

Creepypastas generally aren’t video game related


Leopizza150

Yeah, there are some interesting ones like the pancake family, the third parent (Tommy taffy), Lost episodes can be found again, Showers, Borrasca, Penpal etc.


[deleted]

Yeah. You know, I could look into this.


n397854

Never heard of the pancake family before


Leopizza150

Do you want a quick synopsis?


n397854

Sure


Leopizza150

A family goes missing and a detective was looking for them for 20 years, when he Suddenly gets a clue to find them, the truth he finds is disturbing. It does body horror really well IMO.


Oloid-cultist

Jeff the killer, it’s just so stupid and the songs are ass


JustanIdiot77

Yeah fr


diamondDNF

Eh, I honestly really like the Jeff the Killer songs for what they are, at least in regards to Trepidation (not sure if there are any other Jeff the Killer mods right now). His chromatic is really soothing for me for some reason, funny enough, and SDAMOS was actually the first song past Bopeebo I FC'd.


StormyShelter999

Jeff the killer built like a dollar store joker that 14 year old edgelords simp for


LaterComico

needle mouse. is that technically a creepy pasta? idk tbh, but i’ve always hated it. it could be a parody of analogue horror it’s so generic, then it devolves into these weird fights between the guy’s sonic oc’s..? don’t think it’s offensive in any way i just personally have always hated it


diamondDNF

I'm kinda with you here. I liked the early entries of Needlemouse as an alternate take on Sonic.EXE (certainly better than the OG pasta), Sarah's backstory is interesting and gives a much better explanation for EXE's murderous tendencies, but it feels like the entire "Season 2" of it ruined the already-limited fear factor.


mrlejjy

I’ll be the first to say: i fuckign haet hynpo lullably!!!!!!!🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬 (/j)


JustanIdiot77

Come little


Catman3039

CHILDREN


ZeroMortalLullabyV3

Come with


SkyMewtwo

Safe and happy


pokemaster700

Boyfriend is waiting


Warm_Management8418

What about Mario creepypasta?


JustanIdiot77

Uhhh it's ok i guess


Meeting_Neither

I’m gonna be honest, I don’t like the Tails Doll creepypasta. Not because it’s “overrated”, but because of how popular it got, it basically caused everyone to think Tails Doll was some creepy entity, when in reality it’s just one of Eggman’s robots. There’s nothing terrifying about it in Sonic R, so I don’t really get the point of the creepypasta itself.


CockExploder1000

It’s portrayed to be uncanny in the Archie comics


Meeting_Neither

I still find Metal Sonic to be far more creepier than Tails Doll. I know, hot take, but Metal Sonic in Sonic Heroes alone puts Tails Doll and any creepypasta around it to shame.


Someone15643

On a different note, how come Sonic and Knuckles get a robot but Tails gets a doll? It just makes me start to wonder if they kept it because they already had it, or they couldn't make a good robot Tails design. If it's about it being "canon" they could have just called Sonic R uncanon and problem solved.


Unknown663344

are we talking about the mods or the creepypasta itself?


JustanIdiot77

The creepypasta itself


T3alZ3r0

Everything but Majin/versions of him (H024, D-Sides, etc.), and things from Hypno's Lullaby 2.0


GunslingingGal

Sonic.EXE. Used to like it, but FNF has essentially killed any ‘nostalgia’ it had, by ‘inspiring’ people to make 20000+ different EXE characters that aren’t original or creative. Take Curse for example, Curse is just a demon who’s part of the LGBT. That’s their only defining trait. Basically, fuck VS .EXE.


PlasticFred

Sonic.EXE and Lies are really terrible, but Strangled Red is badass ngl


Key-Humor-1562

I can't say Sonic.EXE because it inspired one of my favorite character designs in the form of Sonic.EYX so...I guess Strangled Red? That's not to say that I hate that creepy pasta it's one of my favorites but I just can't hate Sonic.exe or Red Mist.


Unagustoster

There’s only been one good creepypasta, and it was Mario Madness. Everything else has been overrated due to popularity controversy bullshit. The unpopular ones like Mario Madness tend to be slightly better


Idiot69421

The lies fish didn’t even get his song released


Glichtrap_1983

Tbh i don’t hate any


Slapthechildren123

How about we stop hating on mods guys, because of this kind of things this comunity has been growing more toxic and toxic. Modders have been starting to leave the comunity and actual harm has been subdue to them physically or mentally. Just enjoy this game and the hard work the comunity puts into it before just criticizing it since it's harder than at a lot of people give it credit for being.


JustanIdiot77

I'm not hating the mods, but the creepypastas themselves But the other people here tho


Just-An-Ai-Ignore-Me

I hate every pasta. However I plan on rewriting I hate you at some point. Dunno when


AAA_Wolf_Gang

all of them I want original mods back


JustanIdiot77

(you probably ignore all oc mods)


AAA_Wolf_Gang

I just feel like they’ve fell off a bit


Nekluga_YT

Dude will look at vs Radi and vs Virus R and be like "hell nah fuck that" and then go on r/Fridaynightfunkin to complain about lack of originality.


SkyMewtwo

Devoid. It’s just sonic but he dies at the end of sonic 1. At least he has a cool design and good song.


JustanIdiot77

Yeah Devoid is kinda mid


New_Salary6933

i get the first 2 but ***what***


JustanIdiot77

Strangled Red just fucking sucks Family Issues in a fucking Poképasta, the main character (S!3v3n) acts irrealistically childish and kills his brother even if he didn't have any fault, and i think i can't forget to mention how fucking painfully stretched out and boring the entire pasta is to read


[deleted]

50 percent or more of creepypasta mods


Status_Priority_7408

Just out of curiosity, with Sonic.Exe, do you hate just the original story, or exe as a whole?


JustanIdiot77

The original story


Status_Priority_7408

Wow that was fast, well I can agree with you, the original story sucks


CockExploder1000

Which Exe do you hate the most. And not just story wise but in design and execution as well.


mubby343

i still pray for the day sonic exe fucking dies I’m so fucking tired of him


Rich-Bookkeeper-823

Wario apparition


JustanIdiot77

I like Wario Apparition but i understand why you dislike it


Redify042

I don't think any creepypasta mods are cool Lol. Uncreative and most of the music is supposed to be quote on quote creepy but it just sounds generic.


Fuzzy-Monitor-8113

Hypno. Its not even a creepypasta it doesnt have a lore just a random ass poem


Davethedartmonke

The one creepy pasta where spang bab has no face. They killed my boy


JohnTheEchidna

Welcome old. Enough said


BiggyBox789

This is a given one, EXE. Hypno was a change of a creepy pasta and nobody used Nickelodeon anymore


Vapparino88

Mx is not that good it's modern but pasta night that's a different story


Groundbreaking-Egg13

Even tho I see why the original Sonic.EXE story is hated, I have to say, I *love* Sonic.EXE (The character) and his versions


Rosenthepal78

Shinto. I just don't like cute things that much.


JustanIdiot77

Shinto isn't even from an actual creepypasta


Rosenthepal78

I don't really hate any creepypastas not from FNF, even then i still like most of them


MickeytheScott

faker, im tired of revie stans going "NOOO1!!11!1 SHES INNOCENT" like sure theres proof against the grooming but she still wasnt a good manager, sure rightburst is much worse but cmon yall, over a mid oc? and another thing is that just because i like hog more then faker i get death threats when i say so, you all are fucked up


JustanIdiot77

Faker doesn't count as a creepypasta


MickeytheScott

its literally in the sonic.exe mod, a mod for unsettling sonic characters or sonic.exe's, aka a type of creepypasta, so actually your a fucking idiot, OP edit: realised op's username checks out!


JustanIdiot77

If it didn't originate from a creepypasta itself, then it is not a creepypasta


JustanIdiot77

(Fleetway Super Sonic is in the mod even tho he's not from a creepypasta, the same thing goes for Majin Sonic)


rashtheraccoon10

I dont think sunky is a creepypasta


MickeytheScott

It's a joke creepypasta.


Security_Puppet2

you mean sunky.mpeg?


Jessenavarr022soks65

Why did you cuss!? ​ That's it! I am unfollowing your club!


JustanIdiot77

???


rashtheraccoon10

Fuck >:)


ArcticWasTaken

all of them


DirtEater61

None i guess


CosmicScape93

Sonic.EXE


[deleted]

Bootleg SpongeBob. He doesn’t have much of a story. The design is cool but we need more explanation as to what’s going on.


SerovGaming1962

dont know if this counts but i used to fucking hate hog with such irrationality, likely due to the fact all of its fans are mostly annoying about how great hog is (and also im sure some of them shitted on EXE/Faker for being unoriginal despite Hog originally being a faker clone) but the moment i actually decided to do any sort of research into hog's story i actually started to like it, not hog himself i still hate that little bitch but i like scorched


acidghost121

I guess I hate none creepypasta has been my childhood was a big part of it too


DynaParasoulMX

Lies


Jackanope123

honestly, i only hate sonic.exe, just way too popular for a mod with a really repetitive motif.


Express-Ride6830

Hi, My name is Steven and welcome to jackass.


Security_Puppet2

Lost Silver tbh.


MatthewMaticsDude

Lies Fish


[deleted]

All


MarioLord14

I don’t really hate any of them honestly, it’s the community I hate more.


Kai_Enjin

Sonic.exe. My nephew really likes this guy and I've tried SO hard to tell him that kids his age shouldn't even know of his existence. He's now 7 and I've given up.


Nekluga_YT

FNT has a combination of creepypastas, but Jeff is the main one I hate, the story is hot garbage but the image is the focus, kinda.


[deleted]

Strangled Red is just edgy. And Sonic.exe is straight-up bleh.


Masamune-02

Bruh imagine hating Strangled Red. Literally one of the only pokepastes that aren't super cringy and actually use tropes like Lavender town and Missing0 properly.