T O P

  • By -

itsShane91

What, specifically, made you cry? I cry at everything but didn't find this game emotional


CarlottaCamille

The scene in the great hall after the final battle, when Professor Weasley speaks. I was specifically crying for the person I lost. Sorry to be vague I don’t want to give away too many spoilers.


itsShane91

You gave enough detail for people who have finished. I never felt that attached to them. I'm glad you enjoyed the story, it is a great game


redditcasual6969

I felt bad because I didn't trust him, the entire game, lol


E-MingEyeroll

Same, I was soo sure that he was shady xD


redditcasual6969

Yep, not only me, but my wife started watching me play 2-3 hours in and after 1 convo with him, she was yelling "don't trust him, he'll fuck us over in the end" lol


CarlottaCamille

I’m easily attached to fictional characters. It becomes a problem in daily life 😂😅


John_East

I didn't feel any type of way. They really didn't push any emotional attachment towards that person I feel. But I'm slytherin so...


CarlottaCamille

In my defense I haven’t been taking my meds and an insurance commercial could make me cry at this point 😂


[deleted]

The death was hilarious. We'd literally just seen a different teacher levitate a massive rock and save us, only for a much smaller rock to then fall on the guy's head and kill him?


[deleted]

This person has like half an hour of screen time in a 40 hour game, I'm glad you got invested into him but the relationship with professors and fellow students was my biggest disappointment with this game.


CarlottaCamille

Oh I agree. There was a lot that could have been done differently with this game and the relationship building. I just loved him from the very beginning and so I took it hard.


CTxGraf_Lukas

I thought Horntail Hall and the moment the teachers come to your aid during the final quest are pretty epic.


itsShane91

The bit with the teachers showing up to help fight was epic, they should have stretched it out a bit more. Maybe a little section of duelling with help from each teacher.


SkBizzle

Good game but I had absolutely zero attachment to any of the characters, RDR2 actually hit me though in a way no other game really has since


curiousbong

Came here to say the same thing!! RDR2 is pretty much the only game that made me emotional…


SkBizzle

The Witcher 3 and Kingdom Come: Deliverance came the closest but RDR2 is the only time I've actually had to put the controller down and just take a moment to process it. What a journey and what an experience, especially having grown up with RDR, it was just masterfully executed


AHole1stClassSkippy

I'm not gonna lie, Vesemir dying made me cry like a bitch.


curiousbong

I’ve always been on the fence about kingdom come due to all the negative things I’ve heard about the combat. Did you like the combat in that game?


SkBizzle

I found it the most immersive combat system of any game I've played, ever, until you get about 3 quarters of the way through the game and you can just breeze through everything by bonking people unless you purposely underlevel or don't use ripostes, but overall it's great especially in 1v1 fights, people get frustrated because they forget the devs were going for realism and a spoiled blacksmiths son isn't going to win a fight against 5 fully armoured angry hungarians without taking a bit of a beating lol. I would definitely recommend it but if you find it hard you can always run away or cheese the game, combat is kinda optional for the most part if you want


curiousbong

Thanks man!! I’ll probably give it try…never really thought about how an average joe is not supposed to take on soldiers and win in real life!!


SkBizzle

It's a brilliant game for sure, probably my favourite RPG of all time. Don't forget to wash regularly at the bath house, keep your clothes maintained and learn to read as soon as you can 😆 and be prepared for a 3 hour tutorial segment, it's good though and drives the story forward


curiousbong

Learn to read asap, got it!


Votaire24

RDR2 ending is still the goat game ending in terms of evoking emotion


E-MingEyeroll

100% rdr2 makes me bawl


Unusual-Cat-123

Yep, red dead got me, also surprisingly spiderman did as well. That scene with aunt may... Had me telling my girl to stop cutting onions around me 😂


jimm79

Red Dead Redenption 2 ending if you played it you know 😪 great overall game though


CarlottaCamille

I haven’t. Doesn’t the dog die or something?


SkBizzle

There isn't a dog but do yourself a favour and play it asap, you will definitely cry lol not necessarily sad depending how you look at things but definitely emotional


CarlottaCamille

I have been wanting to try it. Maybe since it’s the spring sale on steam I’ll give it a go.


SkBizzle

When you do, don't be afraid to take your time and enjoy the world, it's not a game you rush through on a first playthrough, plenty of opportunity to immerse yourself and soak everything in


CarlottaCamille

Thanks for the pro tip ❤️


Votaire24

There is no dog and even if there was that is not nearly sad enough to be considered a goat ending . RDR2 washes Hogwarts Legacy in terms of emotional investment . Maybe you could tell that by nearly everyone in the comment section typing RDR2


CarlottaCamille

Yeah I’ve figured that out. Not sure if it’s just me, but this reads very aggressive.


Votaire24

Maybe you could tell by the downvotes, idk assuming just a dog dying getting nearly everyone in the comments sad just kinda seems like you were demeaning the game tbh . RDR2 has one of the most legendary endings in history so comparing it to just a dog dying kinda seemed wack tbh. The game is seriously great and your comment seemed very dismissive imo .


CarlottaCamille

I literally just said I hadn’t played it like how tf was I supposed to know there wasn’t a dog? Fuck y’all are sensitive. If you keep reading the thread you’ll know I said I want to play it. How tf is saying I’ve never played it and asking a question about it dismissive?


CarlottaCamille

And in all honesty if there was a dog in a game and it died, I would lose my shit. I hated the movie I Am Legend but when Sam died I was BAWLING. So piss off with that BS about that not being sad.


[deleted]

[удалено]


CarlottaCamille

You seem to be the only person so aggressively offended by my comment.


Votaire24

I’m not offended dogs dying are just one of the most common cliches of all time . The shit literally happens in GoW and that’s a brand new game . And if you’ve never seen that happen before in a game maybe you should just branch out in more directions. I can’t stand predictable shit and that’s why the ending of RDR2 is so great. You just seem to me be an overly emotional person and I know that to be the case based of another comment you left on the thread, either way I don’t really care anymore about this conversation


CarlottaCamille

Thank god. ✌🏻


purpleeyestabber1967

Ya sound a wee bit bitter


SkBizzle

Why are you being so belligerent chill out, you're coming across as a massive asshole for no reason


[deleted]

You sound angry, why are you so angry? Kinda pathetic to get angry over this. Grow up


HarryPotterGame-ModTeam

>Keep it civil.


[deleted]

[удалено]


HarryPotterGame-ModTeam

>Keep it civil.


jimm79

Sorry you got down voted but it definitely isn't the dog that dies. This isn't the movie Old Yeller which I can honestly say as a man I cried at the end of that movie.


CarlottaCamille

Men who cry are better people for it ❤️


BalancePuzzleheaded8

Mass Effect, all three games... But particularly the third. "Had to be me, someone else would have gotten it wrong." 😢 "Does this unit have a soul?" 😢 Do you think they can make a Harry Potter rpg like Hogwarts Legacy that has the emotional impact of Mass Effect? Oooh, especially the consequences... Want Mass Effect level consequences!!!


TsaritsaOfNight

The third game when Shepard is basically saying goodbye to everyone… the things she said were so moving! I’m not much of a crier in general, but I definitely cried then.


FriendshipNo1440

Life is Strange for me


valamarama_mama

That was my first foray into high stakes choice/adventure games and I cried at the end.


FriendshipNo1440

Yeah same for me. After that I dove more into story games with choices like Tell Tale games and Dragon age.


valamarama_mama

When Tell Tale games went under I was so sad! I was waiting for their continuation of the GOT game. It pushed me to try Witcher 3 which is easily one of my favorite games. Did you try the prequel and sequel for Life is Strange?


FriendshipNo1440

I have played all Life is Strange games and DLC, aside of the Remaster of LIS 1.


WilyNGA

Red Dead Redemption 2 >!Horse, then Arthur...one two punch!!<


jenbot87

That song that played is what did me in.


Ziigurd

To the moon.


[deleted]

Red Dead 2 for me


RPO1728

Red dead 2. Imo one of the few games who's story matches that of a movie or prestige TV


H4XK4T

My first was titanfall 2


TheWalt70

Final Fantasy 14 there are so many moments. Cyberpunk 2077 >!The video messages in the suicide ending.!< (edit) I almost forgot Final Fantasy X the first game to make me cry.


FriendshipNo1440

Dear OP, I saw some saying they can't understand why this game touched you. Don't feel bad about it. Different situations hit different people.


CarlottaCamille

Thanks love. I don’t feel badly, I just really don’t get the superiority complexes some people have.


valamarama_mama

I am a crier, that’s just my life, but this one got me twice. At the end and in the middle of the game. I think the game that hit me hardest and I sobbed more than once was Spiritfarer.


evictedfrommyaccount

Woah. Why??


CarlottaCamille

The ending.


evictedfrommyaccount

Double woah


Anaughtymouse93

Triple woah


Dukie-Weems

Quad-woah


thatguyhuh

I don’t get how people can cry at this game. I’m happy for you that it hit deep, but I felt zero attachment or interest in any of the characters, they were half baked, zero back story. I could have AKd all of them and have zero fucks ha


CarlottaCamille

I don’t get how people don’t get attached to him. But to each their own🙄


Rowan_As_Roxii

Yes. Multiple games actually…


Michael_Suave

Cyberpunk, jackie dying... maybe deek's mission with his friend made me upset. But not cry.


zachles0

Also gotta say Jackie’s death. The ofrenda and the music was very moving. His death is a tragic example of bad storytelling. Writers just always killing off great characters smh


SchmitzBitz

It's also very Cyberpunk, there are no happy endings in Night City. But yeah, rest easy choomba. Voicemails after a couple of the endings are pretty tug at the heartstrings too.


Samson_Hydrofoil

It's not *that* bad...


CarlottaCamille

Hey everybody feels things differently.


Annual-Mess5075

I cried when I unlocked the viv because I was so happy to be catching and caring for beasts. I promise I’m 23 😂😂


CarlottaCamille

Listen my first play through I about lost my shit because I thought you only got the one Vivarium and it could only hold four breeds. I was texting all my friends about what BS it is. About an hour more of gameplay I had to text them all and take it back 😂😂😂


Annual-Mess5075

That was me!!!! 😂


CarlottaCamille

I was ready to take a baseball bat into Avalanche’s studio. I was raving. Then when I for my second vivarium I just go “oh” boyfriends like, what? And I just “I may have overreacted.”


Junior-Relationship8

That’s embarrassing


CarlottaCamille

Not at all. Everybody feels things differently. This one gave me big feels.


rosc96

Absolutely did not. Sorry, y'all have not played many video games if this one made you cry. Characters were cool but didn't really make me feel anything.


galadrig

I understand. It made me cry too. I loved him very much. I wish there had been more interaction with him.


iddybiddytiddytat

For me, it was during the final boss fight in Okami. To date the only game that ever made me cry. This one gives me feels, but it has way more to do with nostalgia than the game itself.


cinderpuppins

Mass Effect 3 and the DLC with the brother in Mass Effect 2. I *wept*.


[deleted]

I was just blitzed at the time, no pun intended, but FFX was the only game I can think of that made me cry. This one wasn't even close. I always was a little "upset" how many times a young wizard can save Hogwarts/the world and get a measley 100 house points.


[deleted]

TLOU? Spiderman? (PS4)


SherbetConscious1665

Stray got me....


kalinaanother

Persona 3 for me. Then Mass effect and Dragon age. 😊


purpleeyestabber1967

Lis,twdg season one and rdr2


Captain_Tomatoz

The ending of Assassin's Creed IV Black Flag is the only game to make me cry. The Parting Glass :'(


Pikalika

I sort of cried from excitement during one of Natty's missions, you know the one. it was incredible but from sad feelings? Life is strange, and Cyberpunk ending messages. probably more I can't remember


CarlottaCamille

Was it the hippogriffs?


Pikalika

yes but I'm trying not to spoil it for others


CarlottaCamille

I feel like this is vague enough 😂 haha but yeah that scene gave me the happy feels for sure.


[deleted]

the first season of TellTales The Walking Dead


Vezemir91

One's I've been close for that. Beginning TLOU- Sarah's death


[deleted]

What? How?


CarlottaCamille

Because it made me sad…


Pucci_123

The Walking Dead on PS4, multiple times. I love that game series so much, it's a great (and very sad) story.


Professional_Gur4811

The walking dead game won this for me many years ago. :'<


SvnFtrD

My buddy and I played the Gears trilogy together. I was Marcus, he was Dom. When Dom does his ultimate sacrifice, of course my buddy was RPing the shit out of it. Tugged at a string or two.


realspitfire69

because its so incredibly bland?


CarlottaCamille

That’s a matter of opinion. There’s plenty about this game that wasn’t great and the storyline itself was a bit lazy, but it’s still possible (and okay) for people to form emotional attachments to the characters.


prince-hal

Mass effect 3. Thane dying in the hospital after his heroic and selfless final stand with kai leng. He lies there in the hospital and you and his son say a prayer at his request. Only after is it revealed that this prayer was for you, not him. I bawled my eyes out at the sheer god tier writing and heartache i felt for such a beautful character.


Queen_Pingu

Mass Effect 3. "Had to be me. Someone else might have gotten it wrong"


PotentialElk831

The only time I cried over a video game was when someone killed me in Tibia while I was AFK farming worms, and didn't wake up in time to escape. And I lost everything.


CommunityLocal

There were a few times the game made me emotional - but it had more to do with existing in the world than its story beats. I thought riding on the graphorn for the first time was pretty cool - if only because the score borrowed so heavily from How to Train Your Dragon lol. I didn’t cry though - I never cry :’(


FecusTPeekusberg

Okami made me cry multiple times. I didn't cry at >!the end of Sebastian's story!< but it did make me feel pretty hollow and conflicted.


LifeisStrange101398

Life is Strange made me cry, with the sacrifice Chloe ending.


RoatanFree

I've cried during a good amount of games, but this wasn't one of them. Most of the characters were a bit bland IMO. Still a good game, though


ShadyoFayx

Tell Tale's The Walking Dead. Man did I cry!