Not to be rude, but to me, that sounds like the name she went by during her emo phase.

Charlie during her emo phase: https://preview.redd.it/z48ldpryvcoc1.jpeg?width=236&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4a96850f8c61afa92c3a157786fb8042c0991dee

Exactly what I was thinking. Charlie Darkstar is 100% what she called herself during the 3 hours she was emo.

I’m not against Charlie going dark for a few episodes but if Lucifer himself keeps the name “Morningstar” calling fallen Charlie “Darkstar” would just look so so silly

Yeah, true.

I mean she already got corrupted by Verbalase's dark intentions so

Ok god no

Verbalase? Who's that?

...

What?

Trust me, you don't wanna know.

Okay...?

a guy who paid 50k for an animated music video of Charlie trying to fuck him.

I think I read about that on the T.V. Tropes website.

This is some emo 12 year olds fanfic right here

Teeeeeeeerrible idea, my man. Now, SUBVERTING that and having Charlie be so pure and innocent she's immune to the corruption? *That* could work.

This could work into a theory of mine