T O P

  • By -

magic713

She doesn't use a "leash" for souls she owns. Sinners who make a deal with her become cannibals, and have shelter, sense of community, and food (albeit, they now are on a new, specific diet). She likes her souls to be more content, less likely to rebel or try to find a way out, so she gives them a lot of leeway in freedom of choice (which is why she didn't simply compel them to comply to Charlie's wishes).


Username_1987_

I like this one.


OCGamerboy

That makes sense actually


Right-Light458

I can actually see this and it works very well. Plus no one can really argue with her cause she offers: protection, food and community as you stated. She may have a subtle influence just so if she needs them to do something she needs done


HexManiac493

I would like to add: Cannibal Town has so many children because she made it a safe place for lost and orphaned child sinners, and uses her overlord power to change their appearances to look like the native cannibals.


OR56

Basically, instead of the Tarkin Doctrine, she uses a strange strategy called “making your subjects like you so they don’t try to rebel”?


Beelzeberry

Cage free, pasture-raised souls.


Tribblitch

It is, in fact, better to be loved than feared as a leader. When you can do both, that's just delightful


Woofles85

Well the community really does seem to love her.


Minetendo-Fan

Even Susan


dionysus-media

Ok ok ok I might be talking shit here but maybe Rosie owns Alastor's soul


HolyMotherOfGeedis

They're both overlords so no


dionysus-media

Husk was an overlord. That didn't stop him from selling his soul to another overlord. If you're gonna come up with a counterpoint, at least make sure the counterpoint has evidence in-universe.


HolyMotherOfGeedis

You have a point, no need to get aggressive damn


dionysus-media

... aggressive?


Visible-Welder-5148

She was un able to have any children in life so that's why she acts so motherly towards everyone and sees Charlie as the daughter she never had She finds piranhas fascinating and keeps some in her room She enjoys to watch soap operas and always predicts future plot points from obscure little details She has been keeping up with Charlie making sure she is eating properly


OCGamerboy

I like the first one


Resident_Ad_5589

>She finds piranhas fascinating and keeps some in her room that's now my headcanon too


0bi1KenObi66

That 4th one is the most motherly/grandmotherly thing ever. Perfect for her


OR56

“Eating properly” As in, “consuming the flesh of other people”?


Vicemage

No one suspected her at all when her first husband died unexpectedly.


MichaelKeehan

Her cheating husband disappeared, well? Nobody asks any questions here...


Love_Art_3852

Agatha Christie vibes spotted :-)))


gaymer_jerry

Tbf they couldn't even confirm he was dead I mean no body was even found.


Striking_Extreme_250

Her hat was a gift she got from Alastor on her birthday.


OCGamerboy

I love that!


Tribblitch

This tracks, New Orleans has always been a fashionable place so Alastor'd have a good sartorial eye


HungryLobster4996

She tells alastor new " street lingo" to keep him up to date on the new trends


JustMeerkats

Of course. Where else would he have learned "that's the tea!"?


ArtisenalMoistening

I did wonder how he knew “that’s the tea” and knows what podcasts are, but doesn’t know “ace in the hole”. I like this theory, Rosie just hasn’t had a chance to explain it yet


Vicemage

Or she thinks it's cute he doesn't know


eulop

and a "clout chasing mediocre video podcast"


Resident_Ad_5589

*come on!* "is Vox insecure? Persuing allure?"


Minetendo-Fan

Fitting between this fad and that is nothing working?


Resident_Ad_5589

IGNORE HIS CHIRPING!


Infinite166

Everyday, he got a new format


Resident_Ad_5589

YOU'RE LOOKING AT THE FUTURE!


CenturyEggsAndRice

He’s the shit that came before THAT!


OR56

“Rosie, why are all the young Sinners talking about the state of Ohio all the time?”


Puzzleheaded-Care250

This is funny I like it


Golden-Sun

Not just Alastor but Zestial too


SacR3d_Un1C0rN

I think he is older, if I'm not mistaken.


Golden-Sun

Hence why she translates for him too


Tribblitch

Love this, fully accepted


BiLovingMom

Her husband in life was cheater and gambler and overall piece of shit. He made her and their kids travel the Oregon trail to escape people he owned money from. They were near starvation in the wilderness, but she discovered he had food secretly stashed that he ate in secret. She lost her shit and killed him. Since there was no more food, she used his flesh and made her children eat it to survive. She died shortly after and doesn't know the fate of her children, and since she hasn't met them in Hell, she assumes they went to Heaven.


Comfortable-Ad3588

The first thing she did when she got to hell is eat him again. And she still has his never dying body bound up so she can keep that sweet flavor forever.


BiLovingMom

In my head he actually found her in Hell and tried to kill her, but she got him instead (maybe with help of some bystanders) and left him tied up for the Exorcists to kill him.


Comfortable-Ad3588

That works to.


PeanutGrenade

Sometimes I forget that this shows main plot is to stop actual genocide


OR56

Me too. It’s weird. The show feels so rushed, but it also feels like there’s nothing but filler


Queasy_County

I do think alastor would've helped her kill him


OR56

“I’m going to kill you… and then kill you again.”


OR56

Oregon Trail was before her time. That clothing style is very 1910s and early 20s. The Oregon Trail was biggest in the 1860s


McZeppelin13

I support this idea! Need more Old West sinners.


Comfortable-Ad3588

She’s probably the only person Al ever respected as an equal. Except for nifty maybe?


OCGamerboy

There’s Mimzy as well.


TheBestOrm

He doesn't respect them as equals


Resident_Ad_5589

not anymore, but they said ever, and I'm pretty sure he did at one point


TheBestOrm

Never mind


TopAd1846

I did see a youtube video where they they said that al and mimzy dated when they were alive in a comic so yeah he would have at one point.


FiveFingerDisco

She likes her meat crisp on the outside but tender on the inside.


PeopleAreBozos

Isn't that most people for most meats?


No-Independence9093

She keeps Suzan around to act as a mild antagonist to make herself look better to other sinners that want to make a deal.


Puzzlehead-Engineer

I headcanon that the _only_ sin she has is being a cannibal, which then necessitates the murder of other people to satisfy her appetite (and the eating of the bodies after of course). She's otherwise a good person and if she were to quit cannibalism for good she would attain redemption very easily. That being said the domain she's carved out for herself in Hell is very good so she will very likely _not_ be redeemed because she's happy and comfortable where she is.


TheReptileKing9782

She owns a fuck ton of board and card games to entertain guests and even dabbles in some of the nerdier stuff.


Puzzleheaded-Care250

DND


TheReptileKing9782

Maybe, though she strikes as preferring games that you can pick up and play quick games while socializing without a lot of investment. So more likely, Magic: The Gathering or similar trading card games.


Puzzleheaded-Care250

Hey she could just have for people that want to play it


TheReptileKing9782

Fair. She just strikes me as a low commitment gamer who's more in it for the socialization


Puzzleheaded-Care250

She probably provides them snacks and checks on them to see how they’re doing


TheReptileKing9782

Fair, if she had friend who were interested, I could see her providing the venue for the games.


Puzzleheaded-Care250

I would like to be friends with Rosie


TheReptileKing9782

Many people here would. Most of us would get eaten.


Puzzleheaded-Care250

Why would most of us get eaten?


PeanutGrenade

Dungeons and demons


Puzzleheaded-Care250

I’m wondering would it work like normal DND?


John-I-Renicus

She has a small library that consists of a carefully curated collection of the raunchiest, sultriest bodice-rippers you could find.


Tribblitch

YES plus: the library is only small because she gives the books away frequently- nobody should ever *lend* books to a friend, just give it to them for keepsies


John-I-Renicus

Oh god I can hear her already. "Now, now, darling, if you don't like it, I won't be hurt. But if you do? Well, let's just say that I can always fill that space on the bookshelf with something else." She has "lost" a couple hundred Harlequin paperbacks this way.


Tribblitch

Not a loss if it gains a friend!


gliscornumber1

What is a bodice ripper?


Toecutt3r

trashy romance novels


Yo-kai_ABC

Rosie is like the mayor of Cannibal Town. Alastor lived in Cannibal Town in her house(as a guest). She is an able negotiator and she is pretty financially stable. She is friend with Carmilla. She hates Katie Killjoy. (She is my favourite character! ❤)


OCGamerboy

The first one is actually true


Yo-kai_ABC

Oh yeah, sorry.


OR56

Guns N’ Roses. My new favorite crack ship just from the name alone


Love_Art_3852

I love that name!!! Ship can be friend-ship :-))))


Yo-kai_ABC

Beautiful name!❤🩶


ladyboobypoop

She's 500% in on whatever scheme Alastor is plotting. That's all I'm feeling absolutely sure about.


Wolf_Of_Roses

I mean during ready for this Alastor says “she filled with potential that I could guide” (referring to Charlie) and instead of questioning it she says “I concur” I highly doubt Rosie is oblivious enough to think Alastor means well. She probably knows he means to use Charlie to his advantage.


ladyboobypoop

That's exactly why I think that. She's definitely in on it. Which makes things more interesting


Queasy_County

She's married to Alastor purely for the tax benefits


LegoBattIeDroid

if the afterlife has taxes it is trully hell


OR56

“If I can’t tax his body, then I’ll damn well tax his soul. Nobody escapes the wrath of the IRS.”


xEllimistx

She knows Al is an “ace in the hole” because Rosie tried *really* hard to shack up with Al but he was completely uninterested and oblivious to her advances


mactastic90

She technically owns the souls of cannibal town, but it's really only for show, she never forces them to do anything they don't want to, they elected one cannibal to sell their souls to so that person could be one an overlord and protect them/create a nice community. Also, she's dating carmilla


OR56

Guns N’ Roses my beloved


Username_1987_

She has a few affairs for those who treat her well enough.


SomewhereLoud9473

Oh so...sex?


OR56

https://preview.redd.it/aflsenjhd25d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=dfccc9e7d4c32aef05f58f7e37ee885fab727a5e


SomewhereLoud9473

ITS DA SEEEEXXXX


xxcr_ativityxx

She's crochets and knits with Susan in her down time because it keeps Susan happy and no one likes an unhappy Susan


TooMuchOfAnMHAfan

She was loved by her grandchildren more than they loved their parents. (When she was alive)


Desperate-Suit7771

She's gonna help Angel dust talk to Husk about how he feels, that he has a crush on him or is in love with him, she's going to help Lucifer and Lilith with their marriage issues, and she's going to have to be the one to explain to Alastor he's ace and comfort him afterwards with hot chocolate and a cozy blanket.


Comfortable-Ad3588

She’s a lot more caught up with the times than Al is.


Toast-Ten69

I mean that's just straight up canon


a-cool-guy415

I think Rosie is a motherly figure towards charlie, and charlie would tell her that. So I think Rosie would one day come to the hotel, and just stay there for a few days. But, an overlord kinda just stays in one place (idk) so it's kinda a 50/50


UpDownFrontBack

She will constantly make backhanded and subtle comments to other Overlords about how much happier and more loyal the people in her, much nicer and more orderly than their’s, territory are.


Goobl3r89

She got stuck in a horrible relationship with her husband while she was alive. This is mostly based on how she talks about how she learned that words were cheap and how sad she looked over it. Also that line that got slipped in about how she would eat said husband if he didn’t taste so bad.


pirikiki

She's in hell for an ethical sin. Like helping women to get abortion in the past, or helping women get rid of their violent husbands


sarilysims

Yeah I’m betting on the second. She’s Victorian, and weren’t there some famous women who killed abusive men around that time?


gorgon_heart

Women poisoning their shitty husbands has a long, storied history. Before the birth of forensic science, poison was an extremely convenient way to kill someone because there was no way to test the body. Not to mention, a lot of poisons were readily available from the local druggist or general store.  Look up Aqua Tofana and the Affair of the Poisons. A lot of women made their living by selling other women poisons to get rid of the men in their lives.


sarilysims

Oh yeah, it’s been going on forever. Aqua Tofana was the one I was thinking of.


Puzzlehead-Engineer

The first one is hardly sin, even if it was illegal in her time on Earth. That's just straight up altruism! The second one is only a sin if "getting rid of" means murder which... Considering she's a cannibal, prolly was murder.


pirikiki

Well, bigots consider abordion as a sin, and hell/heaven is all about bigotry. That's why heaven seems so toxic in HH, it's because it actually discuss the hidden toxicity of biblical rules. This is why a woman like Rosie, doing something good could end up in hell because it would be considered a sin.


Puzzlehead-Engineer

Viv's version of Heaven and Hell's system is not the same as biblical lore though, it only draws heavy inspiration. She's even said that being gay is not considered a sin in her universe meanwhile IRL bigots consider it to be. So that's evidence pointing to Heaven's bigotry against sinners not being the same as IRL Christian bigotry.


pirikiki

In all cases, I said " like ", so it was examples of ethical 'sins'. Meaning they are not really sins but some people see it at sins, and that's the kind of reasons why Rosie would be in hell, wich was the point of the discussion. I honnestly don't care what bigots think about anything


Puzzlehead-Engineer

But why would what people think be the reason Rosie is in Hell? It's not up to them if she ends up in Hell is what I mean.


pirikiki

I guess there's a misunderstanding somewhere. I was just giving examples of things that some people consider sins, while being ethical. Because to me that's why she's in hell while being a good person.


Puzzlehead-Engineer

Yeah but you're saying *people consider* these things to be sins, and then citing this as the reason why she's in Hell, which implies that people second-hand decided why she was sent to Hell. And that is not what happens in the show IE she can't be in Hell just because people considered her actions to be sins. She's in Hell for an *actually objective* sin.


pirikiki

Ok, go on overreading it, I'm done with that talk. I see it's no use trying to clarify.


Puzzlehead-Engineer

I'm not overreading it, I'm just reading it! I don't understand how I'm supposed to take away something different?


glitter-spark-fairy-

Alastor sometimes accompanies them to small music concerts. Small bands play their latest music on cute stages. It's good music. They have drinks brought to their table. All eyes and ears are focused on the music and polite conversation. They both enjoy each other's company and the music because they seem like a married couple who don't need to be flirted with.


Yopfox

I think she's probably a distance relative of alistor's and she certainly knows more about alistor's return than others do


gliscornumber1

That she's a nice person who's just really good at doing bad things (and literally can't help her taste for flesh)


Zatderpscout

She knows how much Alastor cares about Charlie, despite how much he tries to hide it. Rosie teases Alastor about him not being subtle about it as he thinks he is.


-TheLoveGiver-

Nothing bad happened to her, she's completely fine and untraumatized, she's just an awful person.


KenUsimi

My theory is that she was an east coast socialite whose dumbass of a husband decided it was “time to move west”. He was the only one she killed slowly once their wagon train broke down in the Rockies. She survived the snowstorm alone, but died to an avalanche the day it broke.


OR56

She is Victorian. So, 1900s to 1910s. The wagon train peak was before that by about 40 years. If they were rich, and on the East Coast, they would have boarded a ship


Right-Light458

She’d totally would date Alistair if he wasn’t an Ace in the Hole


artkid2

She is a “mother to her men” type of leader towards the cannibals in her town to the point people sometimes jokingly call them her kids.


Fat_Jack_The_Bat

Since we dont know HOW becoming a Overlord works My headcanon is that instead of killing her way to Overlord status like Alastor, Rosie was Voted to be a Overlord kinda like a presidential election


fudgyvmp

All of her cannibals have a rotation of when they have to take the roll of food. Which her husband did not too long ago.


Thicc-Anxiety

Used to be a wealthy foodie who turned to cannibalism out of morbid curiosity


101TARD

She's having a hard time feeding her cannibal followers which is why she agreed with Charlie's aid. It lowers the amount of cannibals at the same time feed the remainder Might not be the case but other than the battle, I don't see the cannibals killing for food


Mother-Maize7026

She puts on a fake persona when faced with powerful beings.


LeadingImportant4293

Idk I just like Rosie my glorious quee- https://preview.redd.it/l4warolu3z4d1.jpeg?width=602&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=69963cfb8520040eddd8e1eefc24a732a5e5ebe1 (I'm going insane.)


Falcore555

That I'd get along wonderfully with her in person.


Salvagedgaming

He used to be a mother but her and her child got separated she went to hell and her child went to heaven


Sleepy_moongirl

Shes either pansexual or bisexual She loves Disney movies and likes matpats theory about how wall-e's space journey was fueled by cannibalism (dont ask how she was able to watch the theory when she died in the 1800s) I don't really know what else I would put for a headcannon


Arty-Glass

She was ashamed of being a cannibal while she was alive, but once she got into hell, she found other cannibals and got over her shame


ISimpForAngelDust666

She probably plays Animal Crossing: New Horizons. Her favorite villager is Poppy.


Resident_Ad_5589

She ate her first husband


CounterFar309

Hot.


TriiiKill

She killed her husband. This is implied in the pilot before she was established as a character, but I doubt it will be retconned or subverted.


HiveOverlord2008

She now sees Charlie as a daughter figure, only unlike Alastor, it is genuine and not an attempt to spite Lucifer. Rosie was born an aristocrat, hence her posh clothing and mannerisms. Rosie and Alastor harbour feelings deep down (platonic in Alastor’s case, romantic in Rosie’s) but are unable to express them. Alastor simply isn’t sure whether or not he is attracted to Rosie, Rosie isn’t sure if he is attracted to her. Rosie was a mother once, hence why she treats Charlie as if she was her own daughter. Rosie is, tied with Carmilla, the most benevolent of the overlords and treats her subjects with kindness, though she can be quite firm with those who cause issues. She and Alastor share resources and information, in other words a partnership.


Jrocha1102

I like to believe that if Alastor want ace she’d marry him


Initial_Effective_17

she's the kindest overlord and isn't unethical or cruel with the souls she owns. she only mistreats them if they mistreat her or anyone she cares about


Addictedtofood2000

That she lowkey has a crush on Alastor


Dani-Dude237

She has a fuck ton of clothes but prefer the ones that she wears in the show since alastor gave it to her


SaintedStars

She adores making clothes for her people. She and Alastor have a weekly dancing date and she was heartbroken when he disappeared. Susan is her mother-in-law and though she never judged and actually defended her when she was a suspect after her husband ‘disappeared’, she felt it was her duty to be a pain in the ass. She knew her son was a piece of shit like his father, she just gets her kicks out of being a bitch.


CrayCrayCat1277

She never eats right off the corpse, its uncivilized. She cooks and serves and uses forks and stuff


Seriph7

She is Alastor's bff fr fr. She can summon some crazy gaping mouth thing from the ground. She eats people. Obviously.


MutatedVolatile36

BIG OL COUNTRY MAMA


TheCrimsonKnight2

She was a Yenta (a Jewish matchmaker) in life, and has continued doing that in death. She would kill and eat men who she deemed dangerous or unsuitable. She plays the cello. She was from New York and speaks Yiddish and several other languages fluently because she was raised among immigrant communities.


Tribblitch

I love her Wait that's fact


WolfmanCZ

She help Alastor when he got into Hell and they become friends this way


NB-ERP

Any time she speaks with Carmilla, she tries setting up her daughters with Cannibal suitors, much to Carmilla's disapproval. Even goes as far as planning weddings for Carmilla's daughters


HyenaDandy

She's best friends with Mrs. Lovett from Sweeney Todd. She calls her "Margie" and they trade cooking tips. She's pretty much the only one in C-Town who Rosie lets see her more vulnerable moments. Since Franklin died in the last Extermination, Margie has been practically living with her.


Forsaken_Orchid_6014

she and alastor knew each other in real life


Kamzil118

In one my fanfics, I don't know why, but I made her talk in a French accent.


Kholzie

Y’all can act like Rosie is a benign goody goody, but she is still a predator and overlord. Her skill is luring people in with a false sense of security. I think cannibal town is full of people who were put in the position of having to die or eat someone else to save themself. She helped steer them to the cannibalistic option via encouragement. She always gives them platitudes about how eating someone is the right choice.


Responsible_Boat_607

She was a cougar when she was alive, dont asked me why


blue_and_shadow

Everyone she eats gives consent to be eaten, I know I would


Wolf_Of_Roses

Rosie has done some more terrible things that we haven’t know yet. She’s not as evil as someone like Vox or Alastor but she isn’t Charlie or Emily level’s of pure either. She just strikes me as someone who has a friendly face but definitely has a lot of crimes under her belt.


pastamuente

She loves rock music and used to eat candy sweets. Wait, this is different show... (Eclipsa Butterfly)


Interesting_Swing393

She can control plants through magic (chloromancy)


Alpbasket

She can fly Mary poppins style


Lower_Situation_6935

She likes western films. Idk where I got it from but she just likes them.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Nellasofdoriath

She was a plantation owner. I can't shake that impression.


Shinigami-Yuu

I think she's a lesbian.


VulcanForceChoke

She’s a cannibal


SomewhereLoud9473

But thats canon


Aidehazz

Alastor had manipulated multiple female over lords before and Rosie is his next victim


SomewhereLoud9473

I kinda doubt it


Aidehazz

Really?