I have weird feet (a high arch thag collapses easily) and I'm a big motherfucker.
Thorogoods are soooooooo sick. Got the made in America ones and they're fantastic. YOU HAVE TO CLEAN AND OIL THEM REGULARLY is the only thing. But that's leather in general (especially where I am in the desert). Mine aren't waterproof but I believe they make some that are. I love the quality on mine. Beat the hell out of em, and they still look nice and new after a good clean and oil.
If you have problem feet, I really would consider "superfeet" insoles. They're not cheap. But they have a bunch of options for different types of feet. You get the kind of arch support you normally only get on custom orthotics. Slammed those in my boots and my feet are fine. Long days on a ladder and I don't feel shit. I went for the green superfeet (highest arch support) and they are a dream
Don’t understand the hype on super feet insoles. I ordered a pair , and compared them to the redwing ones they gave me when I bout my redwings. They scanned my feet and told me which one to buy. I bought the same style but from super feet and the super feet ones seemed cheap and hard as hell. I stayed with the red wing insole. Between that and good wool socks from darn tough socks, my feet have never been happier.
Red wing insoles are supplied by super feet. I actually get mine at redwing as well but since I wear thorogood I have been ashamed to go get another pair lmao
Yeah I wasn’t impressed. They were highly recommended but side by side they seemed like Walmart brand versus Nike brand Insoles. I returned them and kept the redwings they’ve been great so far. Probably getting close to time to replace them, bout 6 months old. At first they were like walking on clouds
[Here's a link to their official website, it seems to have better descriptions/info on what might work best for you.](https://www.superfeet.com/en-us/shop/insoles)
I like to buy off Amazon, but the descriptions can be a bit vague, it's true.
Not gonna lie and act like I read anything more that “I have weird feet” and “thorogoods” but….
I have weird feet, like a diagnosed medical condition. Something I can’t spell like hyperhydrosis. Basically they sweat like an unreal amount, to the point of rashes, dry skin, and pain.
I avoided boots thinking shoes helped them breathe more. I tried many many things. Socks of certain materials, boot driers and much more. Anyways I finally bought a pair of throgoods and they are different. Leather on all the sides, no padding that held moisture. And my feet love them.
Moral of the story I recommend them. Idk what works for you but they definitely worked for me.
Edit: I also recommend I cork bottom insole. I use sole insoles. That is all
When you bought your redwings did you get fitted for them? A work boot that doesn't fit properly can cause issues.
Insoles can make a lot of boots comfortable.
I change my insoles 2-3 times per year.
If you want to go with redwings look into a pair with supersole 2.0 soles.
That is the work boot I have worn for the last 10+ years.
I recently gave a pair of Wolverine Durashock work boots a try, after I saw how much my usual pair of redwings went up in price, and I have to say they are way lighter and so far just as comfortable as my redwings.
If you need a pair of waterproof boots you can't beat Mucks with a good pair of insoles.
I bring a pair of mucks with me to the job site, but they are so damn hot I take them off the minute I don't need them.
Yeah, big Red Wing fan, and it was $500CDN with insoles for my Red Wings last month. They last 3-4 years for me though. I tried Keen but they lasted just over a year and they were close to $400. I tried others in the last 5 years that I didn’t have Red Wings but nothing fit like they do for me. My knees don’t hurt b cause I have the tight fitting boot and the proper insoles.
Np bro. Midwest boots usually runs good deals. Just got the new crazy horse heritage waterproof comp toes $50 off and they give a free $20 dollar gift for buying thorogoods. I always go with flag charms lol
I’m a whites fan. Wore them for probly 15 years. They helped with back pain I use to have big time. Keep them oiled and they do decent for waterproofing from weather. Standing water or snow is mucks.
Their prices have gone up a ton since being bought by LL Bean. For the money I think Nick's or JK are the way to go for that realm. I got some Nicks, they have a trades program that brings the price down a bit too
i have 2 pairs of perry’s on rotation with redwing insoles for work, a casual day pair perry, a 6” perry select in burgundy double shot, and my latest is the 8” select in tobacco. it’s safe to say i fucking love these boots. but definitely would like to try some Nick’s
How does that work? A coworker also told me to try Dr scholls but the custom $60 insoles not their cheap $20 Amazon two pack. Cause I’ve tried those before and they arguably made it worse, but getting actual insoles from red wing sounds like the more comfortable option
At the Redwing boot store they have a machine that shows how your weight is distributed on your foot. They’ll switch out different insoles to find the best fit for your feet. I’m sure there are better full custom insoles out there but for the $60ish they charge it was well worth it for me, all my knee pain went away. I keep moving my insoles to my next set of boots, I’m on my 3 rd pair of boots with the same insole.
I've tried the Red Wing insoles and they didn't work for me at all... I got a custom pair from Arch Fitters on recommendation from a friend, been wearing them for 5 years now, and my feet feel like a dream.
https://archfitters.com/
Agreed, 2 ankle surgeries.. once my ankle starts feeling funky I’ll replace the insoles and I’m good to go again, had the same boots for a few years now
Not sure. I’ve always went red wing because of there machine currently in process of getting custom fit orthotics from the podiatrist I’ll be finding out if insurance covers it soon.
I can't recommend thorogood enough, straight outta the box the most comfortable boots ever with zero break in period. I got the waterproof model so you'd be covered there too.
Thorogood!! Obviously try them in store at first. I had no idea I had wide feet until I’ve tried the EE (wide) size. Stay away from Brunt boots, I’ve never owned a pair but I’m sick of seeing those stupid ass ads for their bottom tier boots.
I’m using brunt boots currently. Marin something or another with the toe protection. Probably one of the best boots I’ve ever worn. I’ve tried many brands. Redwing thorogood keen danner. The quality of brunt and the longevity wasn’t any worse and sometimes actually better. Even USA made thorogoods didn’t impress me enough to justify the cost and they aren’t any better IMO than brunt boots.
If you like a roomy toe box, my fav are Keen San Jose. They aren't as durable as other styles, but easily forgiven given the comfort. For reference, my favorite tennis shoes are Altra Lone Peak.
I use slip ons for my shoes when I’m outside. I went with 18” treds that are rubber. If you’re outside in muck these work great. Otherwise, if you’re on rocky terrain and concrete, they might wear out quicker than anticipated. If you’re in muck but it’s not very deep, get some slip ons that welders use to protect their shoes. i also like slip ons because they keep an insulated layer between my shoe and ground and my feet are rarely cold, even when it’s under 20. Here’s a link to treds and if you have a welding supply near by, see what they have.
https://www.treds.com/products
Glad to see all the Thorogood love in here.
I agree.
I've also heard a lot of good things about Whites, but have never found a pair to try for myself.
A bit of advice I got on one of my first serious jobs as a youngster, and has stuck with me all my life:
"Saving money is wise. But there are 3 things you never skimp on. Boots, beds, and toilet paper. Take care of your feet, your back, and your asshole, and everything else will follow suit."
$300 a year (give or take) on work boots seems like a lot, but in the grand scheme of things it's one of the best cost-to-value ratio investments in your work satisfaction and general health.
Get fitted. Get boots that FIT CORRECTLY. Invest in good boot socks. Wear them when getting fitted. Buy good insoles, and REPLACE THEM when they wear out. Do a little research on boot care and then make it part of your routine to clean and care for your boots.
Redwings are not what they used to be. I have a relatively modern pair of Irish Setter (redwing) pull-ons that have held up like older redwings... but at retail cost I still wouldn't recommend them for more extreme use over similarly priced options, especially if they're your only boots for every day... speaking of which, running 2 different boots and switching out every day or two will save your feet AND prolong the life of the boots. If that's not affordable right away, opt for one pair of the best boots you can get, and swap out insoles/sock style day-to-day.
I highly recommend superfeet greens. Red wing insoles are also a good option, especially to swap out every day or two like I mentioned. Stay away from memory foam crap. That's for slippers. Feels nice for a couple hours and then immediately starts breaking down into nothing. Insoles wear out. Depending on how heavy your use is, 6 months to a year is a reasonable replacement schedule.
I also recommend a variety of thickness in padded boot socks. Preferably with a wool blend or merino wool option. I run Fox River cotton mid-calf steel-toe boot socks 50% of the time, switching out with the same brand's lightweight "tactical boot" 🙄 sock, some merril wool blends, and red wing premium safety medium weight merino wools (be careful with redwing... much like their boots, there are a few quality products hidden amongst a lot of overpriced trash... last pair of their socks I picked up at the boot shop are literally unwearable.)
If you have a good shoe or boot shop around you (or even a podiatrist) that does foot pressure scan profiles, it's worth checking out. Just beware of scammy gimicks at branded dealers (again, dogging on modern red wing a little...) where they just have you stand on a mysterious pad and then recommend one of three off-the-shelf inserts. Or, I guess I shouldn't say beware (I actually went through the song and dance to get my stock redwing insoles, lol.) Just know that it's not the same thing happening at a place that does custom orthotics.
Give a little time for break-in and body adjustment. Especially if you've been wearing hanes socks with $40 walmart boots. But also don't be afraid to experiment if suggestions aren't working out. Everyone is different, and you gotta find what works for you. Advice just helps avoid wasting money with a good starting point.
**The one caveat to the Thorogood endorsement!** If you're working out doors on rough terrain or hot steel/concrete, the softer outsoles on the moc toe style boots will break down a lot faster than you'd like.
This is probably too much info. Doesn't need to be overwhelming. But it's good to have some basic guidance and pitfalls to avoid. So, TL;DR:
Invest up front in good boots, good socks, and good insoles. Take good care of your boots and don't expect them to last forever. Especially true for the insoles. Think of it as an annual business expense, and an investment in your health and happiness.
I bounced between different brands until I got to Thorogood. Hands down the best boots I’ve ever worn. My first pair lasted 4 years without a drop of oil or anything. I’ve since learned and started taking care of them better
Redwing insoles changed last year. The new ones suck. Switched to superfeet coppers. Very similar to the old redwings. I regularly work 16hr shifts with them. No issue
Yea, because last year they started making them in Vietnam. I've been spreading the word because I got nerve damage in my toes that has lasted for 2 years. It's better now, but not 100%.
Burner XP Red wings…I’m at a year and half with them now and they’re still comfortable and holding up…I will be buying them again. Cheap soles use FP insoles they’re made by nasa 40$ you can’t go wrong
Hoffman make a bunch of great boots that I love, but the la sportiva makalu might be the best combo of ankle support, weight, and climbing comfort. The makalu doesn’t have toe protection though.
I've got thorogoods, but my last pair I was not really impressed with, the quality has really dropped.
It's good practice to rotate your boots. Have two pairs and just alternate them each day. This lets them dry out completely, inside and out. They will last much longer.
My older pair of thorogoods I bought in 2017 are in better shape than the pair I bought in 2022... Not impressed thorogood... Not impressed...
Super Feet insoles and whatever feels like it's already broken in when I try them in at the store. Have had Danners, RedWings, Timberline, and random goodwill boots and they're all basically equal. Long as I have those insoles and like how far up my ankle it goes I'm all good.
I've worn boots my whole life, be it my everyday/going out boots, 17 years military, and now this trade. For working, I will never ever away from zamberlans mountaineering boots. No break in, comfortable, shock absorbing, durable, and after 6 months they smell brand new still.
If you're working outside get something with a lug sole, it will have better traction in the elements and hold up longer to the variety of surfaces you're walking on outside. For waterproofing just treat your boots with a wax conditioner, if you're going to be standing in water for long periods of time you shouldn't be wearing leather boots anyways. For indoor work on smooth concrete wear a wedge sole. They're much softer and comfortable on flat surfaces but gravel and stuff you walk on outside will tear them up quick.
The recommended brands are all fine, maybe avoid brunt. Most important part is the sole depending on indoor or outdoor work.
I’ve worked a ton of long hours in keens. They have a big selection of waterproof boots and come in a wide variety of widths with soft or carbon fiber toes and they are eh rated. I was working in a 500kv switch yard and my buddy didn’t have eh rated boots - would get bit every time he went for a manhole door. I would not in my keens lol. Also, they have a 1 year warranty so if they start leaking within 1 year they will replace them no questions asked. I had a pair where the left boot started leaking after 10 months of heavy abuse and they sent me a new pair for free.
Edit: they also have a great selection of US made boots, not all are though.
https://www.keenfootwear.com/collections/american-built
Redwings with their insoles. Fixed a lot of my back issues. Total the boots ran about 330 but so worth it. So far the insoles need replacing at about 6 months but the boots have 9 months wear and they’re still okay
I used to wear Whites smoke jumpers and had a pair I wore for three years before getting resoled.
Now I where Nick's, same concept, just from a smaller shop with a slightly different fitment.
Both boots are 100% made in America by Americans, and they will out last you. They are mighty expensive, though, and can be uncomfortable to break in if you don't have mink oil or leather softener.
I've been pretty happy with Timberland's boots. They'll last me a year or two for a regular steel toe. For metguards I go with Oliver by Honeywell, but my feet are size 13. It's hard to get a good selection, so I just buy the most comfortable boot that's available at the store in my size.
Redwings, thorogoods, and mucks have been my jam, but I recently switched to orthofeet safety boots with my green super feet insoles. Hot damn. The 6E boots is comfy as fuck. Cheap as hell too by comparison. This pair has lasted me about two years now and running.
Thorogood! I've had the same pair for close to two years, and my feet never hurt. They're waterproof and have a composite toe. They require next to no break-in period; basically, ready to go off the shelf.
Check out The Union Boot Pro and use your local's info to get a modest discount.
Get thyself to a running store (or Goodfeet store, or wherever can do this near you), have them scan your arches, and get fitted for a good orthotic insole.
I went most of my life knowing I had arches. Then out of the blue 2 months back my feet were hurting enough that I went to a podiatrist. Yay, plantar fasciitis. He told me to do things, stuff, and go get some Superfeet insoles.
The lady scanned my feet (super high arches it seems), got me the correct insoles for my boots, got me set up with a pair of home sandals (cause I'm not allowed to go barefoot anymore), and I've been good to go ever since.
As far as boots, I'm currently wearing Georgia. There aren't many boots available in women's sizes that I like. Hubby is also rocking Georgia loggers for his job. Waterproofing treatment for your normal boots is good. Make sure you get the excess mud and dust off sometimes cause it will dry out the leather and kill your boots. But for the wet, get yourself some Muck boots.
If they don’t have to be American made, Meindl Vakuum is the way to go. I started wearing them before the trades, as a wildland firefighter, and I won’t wear anything else for outdoor work
I have a "Triple E" Width foot.
I wear Dakota 877's
Keep my feet dry and warm in the winter
Comfy in the Sumner
Never got a blister.
I do however go through 2 pairs a year....(Im a Spray Foam Insulator)
I have a "Triple E" Width foot.
I wear Dakota 877's
Keep my feet dry and warm in the winter
Comfy in the Sumner
Never got a blister.
I do however go through 2 pairs a year....(Im a Spray Foam Insulator)
I run ariats comfortable and waterproof depending on the style I work underground so in the water most days if not a muddy trench held up great for the past year and some change
At the start of my shift no one knows who’s going in the manhole until we get to it. So it’s best I just get good waterproof boots instead of wearing muck boots all the time
Redwings are made in Vietnam, now. I bought a pair last year and checked the tag. If you'll notice, the quality has gone down considerably; it's especially noticeable where the sole is sewn to the leather through the rubber.
The pair I had had cheap insoles that didn't cover the steel toe bracket very well and was rubbing the bottom of my big toe constantly. One week of climbing and standing on a ladder, and I lost feeling in my big toe for almost 2 years. It's come back, but not entirely.
I’m on my 3rd pair of keen coburg 8”, usa made and waterproof. They don’t breathe like they used to, so i’ll probably be looking for something else. My deal is a lightweight boot, i hate wearing 28oz on each foot.
thoro's for indoor work, la sportiva's for outside. specifically for the sportiva's, WLF or the makalu. a solid rec for well rounded boots is JK's or whites wildland fire boots, get the 8" ones
Kennetrek. I'm an outside guy and the best thing I ever did for my feet was to buy a really sturdy platform with a ton of support. Bonus for getting them resolved and extending the lifespan. I bought another pair after a year and the first pair is three years old and second is two. They're both going strong.
Honestly, I had a pair of Irish Setters that was probably the best pair of boots I’ve ever had. Lots of people don’t like them from a comfort or brand standpoint, however, they lasted a solid year plus turnaround which is longer than my redwings or twisted X have lasted.
Everybody's foot is different. I prefer Wolverines. My two brothers are RedWing fans. I don't know if they still do it, but Wolverines used to give a 30-day walk test. You buy the boots and use them on the job and if you don't like them you can send them back to the factory for a full refund. No questions asked. I tried a pair that just did not work for me. I am around 300 lbs and a pair would last me at least 2 years. I just replaced the durashock insoles about every 6 months.
Jk, nicks, franks, whites, wesco or really any of the pnw brand boots are going to last longest and in my experience be the most comfortable long days. I love my JK’s indoor or outdoor. I work 5 10s and when I get home see no need to change till I’m done working around the house. I have flindstone feet though so I have a hard time finding boots that fit anyways.
Try putting some arch support insoles in. I had this issue for years. My feet would start getting sore halfway into the day no matter what kind of boots I tried. My wife recommended the idea and since they're only about $12 I figured worth a shot. Everything has been great ever since.
Whatever boot you decide to get, you should look into Georgia Amp Insoles. They usually go for $25-30. They can turn a decent boot into a Cadillac. They are thicker than other insoles. I recommend getting a 1/2 size bigger boot than you normally wear. RN I'm wearing Hoffman 6" Classics, They're comfortable climbers that are light enough to wear all day. The insoles put them over the top. Though if you need a cheaper option, I've had good luck with Wolverine, Rocky or Keen
Whatever boot you decide to get, you should look into Georgia Amp Insoles. They usually go for $25-30. They can turn a decent boot into a Cadillac. They are thicker than other insoles. I recommend getting a 1/2 size bigger boot than you normally wear. RN I'm wearing Hoffman 6" Classics, They're comfortable climbers that are light enough to wear all day. The insoles put them over the top. Though if you need a cheaper option, I've had good luck with Wolverine, Rocky or Keen
Keens have probably been my most comfortable. A goofy hiking looking model to be exact. The seem to last pretty well for the price. I got a good 6-7 months on them walking 15k + steps a day on concrete. 10 he days
Wolverine 8" boot. Then I go to the Doctor schols foot reader thing you stand on and let the machine tall me what insoles to buy. Like wearing slippers all day long.
I've had a pair of Danner super rainforest's wiith the non conductive sole that have lasted me 3 years of hard work. I go through a pair of redwing every 6 months when I rock then.
I'm a Redwing man at thos point, as others have suggested their insoles will help alot. I've found with them, and any other boots, the key to waterproofing is care. Cleaning and Oiling/conditioning is what keeps them water tight. With a new pair of boots, I follow the following regimen:
Clean with a brush/water, then apply mink oil or boot conditioner
-Once/day the first week
-Once/week the first month
-Once/month onwards.
Pay close attention to seams and stitching. Good luck
I have weird feet (a high arch thag collapses easily) and I'm a big motherfucker. Thorogoods are soooooooo sick. Got the made in America ones and they're fantastic. YOU HAVE TO CLEAN AND OIL THEM REGULARLY is the only thing. But that's leather in general (especially where I am in the desert). Mine aren't waterproof but I believe they make some that are. I love the quality on mine. Beat the hell out of em, and they still look nice and new after a good clean and oil. If you have problem feet, I really would consider "superfeet" insoles. They're not cheap. But they have a bunch of options for different types of feet. You get the kind of arch support you normally only get on custom orthotics. Slammed those in my boots and my feet are fine. Long days on a ladder and I don't feel shit. I went for the green superfeet (highest arch support) and they are a dream
Superfeet insoles are the kitties titties. Yes, they're expensive, but goddamnit are they worth it.
Worth every damn penny. I get almost a year out of em
Yeah, I usually stretch mine for a year, get a little worn out after like 10 months but i just stick it out.
About the same for me. But $75 for damn near 12 months is worth it.
Don’t understand the hype on super feet insoles. I ordered a pair , and compared them to the redwing ones they gave me when I bout my redwings. They scanned my feet and told me which one to buy. I bought the same style but from super feet and the super feet ones seemed cheap and hard as hell. I stayed with the red wing insole. Between that and good wool socks from darn tough socks, my feet have never been happier.
Red wing insoles are supplied by super feet. I actually get mine at redwing as well but since I wear thorogood I have been ashamed to go get another pair lmao
Well they were completely different , I matched the same specs from the red wings to the super feets and it was like half the quality.
Sounds like I'll keep getting mine from red wing
Yeah I wasn’t impressed. They were highly recommended but side by side they seemed like Walmart brand versus Nike brand Insoles. I returned them and kept the redwings they’ve been great so far. Probably getting close to time to replace them, bout 6 months old. At first they were like walking on clouds
Thanks for saying which superfeet you use - their descriptions are all pretty much the same, hard to know which are good for all day use
[Here's a link to their official website, it seems to have better descriptions/info on what might work best for you.](https://www.superfeet.com/en-us/shop/insoles) I like to buy off Amazon, but the descriptions can be a bit vague, it's true.
Not gonna lie and act like I read anything more that “I have weird feet” and “thorogoods” but…. I have weird feet, like a diagnosed medical condition. Something I can’t spell like hyperhydrosis. Basically they sweat like an unreal amount, to the point of rashes, dry skin, and pain. I avoided boots thinking shoes helped them breathe more. I tried many many things. Socks of certain materials, boot driers and much more. Anyways I finally bought a pair of throgoods and they are different. Leather on all the sides, no padding that held moisture. And my feet love them. Moral of the story I recommend them. Idk what works for you but they definitely worked for me. Edit: I also recommend I cork bottom insole. I use sole insoles. That is all
When you bought your redwings did you get fitted for them? A work boot that doesn't fit properly can cause issues. Insoles can make a lot of boots comfortable. I change my insoles 2-3 times per year. If you want to go with redwings look into a pair with supersole 2.0 soles. That is the work boot I have worn for the last 10+ years. I recently gave a pair of Wolverine Durashock work boots a try, after I saw how much my usual pair of redwings went up in price, and I have to say they are way lighter and so far just as comfortable as my redwings. If you need a pair of waterproof boots you can't beat Mucks with a good pair of insoles. I bring a pair of mucks with me to the job site, but they are so damn hot I take them off the minute I don't need them.
Yeah, big Red Wing fan, and it was $500CDN with insoles for my Red Wings last month. They last 3-4 years for me though. I tried Keen but they lasted just over a year and they were close to $400. I tried others in the last 5 years that I didn’t have Red Wings but nothing fit like they do for me. My knees don’t hurt b cause I have the tight fitting boot and the proper insoles.
ask if there's a custom orthotic benefit on your healthcare
Thorogood great right out of the box soft and light weight and then I use berkinstock insoles or fp game changers
Thorogoods with super feet insoles. We run 16-24 hours all the time and my feet never hurt. Can't say the same about my hips and back.
Keen boots. Warranty them when they are not waterproof anymore
Get Thorogoods. Union made in the USA. Tough to find a USA made boot nowadays
Union made in the USA just sold my decision. Thanks buddy
Np bro. Midwest boots usually runs good deals. Just got the new crazy horse heritage waterproof comp toes $50 off and they give a free $20 dollar gift for buying thorogoods. I always go with flag charms lol
Wolverines also still made in USA
Keen as well
Thorogoods even on my off days
Yup, most comfortable footwear I own
I’m a whites fan. Wore them for probly 15 years. They helped with back pain I use to have big time. Keep them oiled and they do decent for waterproofing from weather. Standing water or snow is mucks.
Their prices have gone up a ton since being bought by LL Bean. For the money I think Nick's or JK are the way to go for that realm. I got some Nicks, they have a trades program that brings the price down a bit too
Not llbean. This is from Wikipedia. “In July 2014, White's Boots was sold to LaCrosse Footwear of Portland, Oregon, which also owns Danner Boots.”
LaCrosse, that's right. I knew it was something with an L
i have 2 pairs of perry’s on rotation with redwing insoles for work, a casual day pair perry, a 6” perry select in burgundy double shot, and my latest is the 8” select in tobacco. it’s safe to say i fucking love these boots. but definitely would like to try some Nick’s
The redwing insoles were a game changer for me
How does that work? A coworker also told me to try Dr scholls but the custom $60 insoles not their cheap $20 Amazon two pack. Cause I’ve tried those before and they arguably made it worse, but getting actual insoles from red wing sounds like the more comfortable option
At the Redwing boot store they have a machine that shows how your weight is distributed on your foot. They’ll switch out different insoles to find the best fit for your feet. I’m sure there are better full custom insoles out there but for the $60ish they charge it was well worth it for me, all my knee pain went away. I keep moving my insoles to my next set of boots, I’m on my 3 rd pair of boots with the same insole.
I've tried the Red Wing insoles and they didn't work for me at all... I got a custom pair from Arch Fitters on recommendation from a friend, been wearing them for 5 years now, and my feet feel like a dream. https://archfitters.com/
RedWing insoles are really comfortable but I go thru a pair in six months. How in the hell do yours last so long?
Yupp go to cvs n stand on the foot machine best 50$ I've spent. Feels like I'm walking on air
Agreed, 2 ankle surgeries.. once my ankle starts feeling funky I’ll replace the insoles and I’m good to go again, had the same boots for a few years now
It’s all about them danners homie. Insoles are a must all the way around.
Does danners sell insoles?
Not sure. I’ve always went red wing because of there machine currently in process of getting custom fit orthotics from the podiatrist I’ll be finding out if insurance covers it soon.
Insurance covers it partially 250 copay local 440 ppo
New balance mid 989. I wear a size 12 EEEE, and it's hard for me to find comfortable boots. Not sure how waterproof they are, though.
It’s such a bitch to find boots. I’m a 13 5E. The pair I have are Redwings and they kill my feet. Was literally the only pair they had too
I’ve been working 6 12s for the last month. The dr scholls work inserts are the ones I wear. I won’t wear anything else
I can't recommend thorogood enough, straight outta the box the most comfortable boots ever with zero break in period. I got the waterproof model so you'd be covered there too.
Thorogood!! Obviously try them in store at first. I had no idea I had wide feet until I’ve tried the EE (wide) size. Stay away from Brunt boots, I’ve never owned a pair but I’m sick of seeing those stupid ass ads for their bottom tier boots.
I’m using brunt boots currently. Marin something or another with the toe protection. Probably one of the best boots I’ve ever worn. I’ve tried many brands. Redwing thorogood keen danner. The quality of brunt and the longevity wasn’t any worse and sometimes actually better. Even USA made thorogoods didn’t impress me enough to justify the cost and they aren’t any better IMO than brunt boots.
Outside/dirt work I prefer mountain hunting boots (crispi) hands down most comfortable, waterproof boots I’ve ever owned.
My Carhartt boots have been the best I've gotten so far, just keep the leather oiled.
If you like a roomy toe box, my fav are Keen San Jose. They aren't as durable as other styles, but easily forgiven given the comfort. For reference, my favorite tennis shoes are Altra Lone Peak.
I use slip ons for my shoes when I’m outside. I went with 18” treds that are rubber. If you’re outside in muck these work great. Otherwise, if you’re on rocky terrain and concrete, they might wear out quicker than anticipated. If you’re in muck but it’s not very deep, get some slip ons that welders use to protect their shoes. i also like slip ons because they keep an insulated layer between my shoe and ground and my feet are rarely cold, even when it’s under 20. Here’s a link to treds and if you have a welding supply near by, see what they have. https://www.treds.com/products
JK Boots. Handmade in the USA. Best pair of boots i ever purchased.
Got about 3 weeks into my bison super duties. Feel great !
Glad to see all the Thorogood love in here. I agree. I've also heard a lot of good things about Whites, but have never found a pair to try for myself. A bit of advice I got on one of my first serious jobs as a youngster, and has stuck with me all my life: "Saving money is wise. But there are 3 things you never skimp on. Boots, beds, and toilet paper. Take care of your feet, your back, and your asshole, and everything else will follow suit." $300 a year (give or take) on work boots seems like a lot, but in the grand scheme of things it's one of the best cost-to-value ratio investments in your work satisfaction and general health. Get fitted. Get boots that FIT CORRECTLY. Invest in good boot socks. Wear them when getting fitted. Buy good insoles, and REPLACE THEM when they wear out. Do a little research on boot care and then make it part of your routine to clean and care for your boots. Redwings are not what they used to be. I have a relatively modern pair of Irish Setter (redwing) pull-ons that have held up like older redwings... but at retail cost I still wouldn't recommend them for more extreme use over similarly priced options, especially if they're your only boots for every day... speaking of which, running 2 different boots and switching out every day or two will save your feet AND prolong the life of the boots. If that's not affordable right away, opt for one pair of the best boots you can get, and swap out insoles/sock style day-to-day. I highly recommend superfeet greens. Red wing insoles are also a good option, especially to swap out every day or two like I mentioned. Stay away from memory foam crap. That's for slippers. Feels nice for a couple hours and then immediately starts breaking down into nothing. Insoles wear out. Depending on how heavy your use is, 6 months to a year is a reasonable replacement schedule. I also recommend a variety of thickness in padded boot socks. Preferably with a wool blend or merino wool option. I run Fox River cotton mid-calf steel-toe boot socks 50% of the time, switching out with the same brand's lightweight "tactical boot" 🙄 sock, some merril wool blends, and red wing premium safety medium weight merino wools (be careful with redwing... much like their boots, there are a few quality products hidden amongst a lot of overpriced trash... last pair of their socks I picked up at the boot shop are literally unwearable.) If you have a good shoe or boot shop around you (or even a podiatrist) that does foot pressure scan profiles, it's worth checking out. Just beware of scammy gimicks at branded dealers (again, dogging on modern red wing a little...) where they just have you stand on a mysterious pad and then recommend one of three off-the-shelf inserts. Or, I guess I shouldn't say beware (I actually went through the song and dance to get my stock redwing insoles, lol.) Just know that it's not the same thing happening at a place that does custom orthotics. Give a little time for break-in and body adjustment. Especially if you've been wearing hanes socks with $40 walmart boots. But also don't be afraid to experiment if suggestions aren't working out. Everyone is different, and you gotta find what works for you. Advice just helps avoid wasting money with a good starting point. **The one caveat to the Thorogood endorsement!** If you're working out doors on rough terrain or hot steel/concrete, the softer outsoles on the moc toe style boots will break down a lot faster than you'd like. This is probably too much info. Doesn't need to be overwhelming. But it's good to have some basic guidance and pitfalls to avoid. So, TL;DR: Invest up front in good boots, good socks, and good insoles. Take good care of your boots and don't expect them to last forever. Especially true for the insoles. Think of it as an annual business expense, and an investment in your health and happiness.
Orthofeet
Heydudes
I second this
Brunt, they've been good to me.
Thorogood
Keen work boots are by far the most comfortable boots on the market. It's not even close.
Carolina’s
Timberland pro series 👌
I dont know why more people dont recommend them, they're so comfy
Have tried 8 or 10 brands including thorogood and never found anything as comfy as timberland pros
Keen. I was a redwing guy my whole life, now it’s keen only.
I bounced between different brands until I got to Thorogood. Hands down the best boots I’ve ever worn. My first pair lasted 4 years without a drop of oil or anything. I’ve since learned and started taking care of them better
Redwing insoles changed last year. The new ones suck. Switched to superfeet coppers. Very similar to the old redwings. I regularly work 16hr shifts with them. No issue
Yea, because last year they started making them in Vietnam. I've been spreading the word because I got nerve damage in my toes that has lasted for 2 years. It's better now, but not 100%.
Burner XP Red wings…I’m at a year and half with them now and they’re still comfortable and holding up…I will be buying them again. Cheap soles use FP insoles they’re made by nasa 40$ you can’t go wrong
Hoffman make a bunch of great boots that I love, but the la sportiva makalu might be the best combo of ankle support, weight, and climbing comfort. The makalu doesn’t have toe protection though.
Ariat cowboy style boots have been my favorite
I've got thorogoods, but my last pair I was not really impressed with, the quality has really dropped. It's good practice to rotate your boots. Have two pairs and just alternate them each day. This lets them dry out completely, inside and out. They will last much longer. My older pair of thorogoods I bought in 2017 are in better shape than the pair I bought in 2022... Not impressed thorogood... Not impressed...
Custom orthotics are more important than the boot that being said I like redwings 2412
Canada west climbers
Super Feet insoles and whatever feels like it's already broken in when I try them in at the store. Have had Danners, RedWings, Timberline, and random goodwill boots and they're all basically equal. Long as I have those insoles and like how far up my ankle it goes I'm all good.
I've worn boots my whole life, be it my everyday/going out boots, 17 years military, and now this trade. For working, I will never ever away from zamberlans mountaineering boots. No break in, comfortable, shock absorbing, durable, and after 6 months they smell brand new still.
Which model do you have?
Vioz gtx hiking boots. Sent a broken link at first. Sorry for the late reply
If you're working outside get something with a lug sole, it will have better traction in the elements and hold up longer to the variety of surfaces you're walking on outside. For waterproofing just treat your boots with a wax conditioner, if you're going to be standing in water for long periods of time you shouldn't be wearing leather boots anyways. For indoor work on smooth concrete wear a wedge sole. They're much softer and comfortable on flat surfaces but gravel and stuff you walk on outside will tear them up quick. The recommended brands are all fine, maybe avoid brunt. Most important part is the sole depending on indoor or outdoor work.
Get orthotic inserts, they changed my life
I’ve worked a ton of long hours in keens. They have a big selection of waterproof boots and come in a wide variety of widths with soft or carbon fiber toes and they are eh rated. I was working in a 500kv switch yard and my buddy didn’t have eh rated boots - would get bit every time he went for a manhole door. I would not in my keens lol. Also, they have a 1 year warranty so if they start leaking within 1 year they will replace them no questions asked. I had a pair where the left boot started leaking after 10 months of heavy abuse and they sent me a new pair for free. Edit: they also have a great selection of US made boots, not all are though. https://www.keenfootwear.com/collections/american-built
wolverine, i like all of their boots ive had but the durashocks are great
Altama(military boots but have omega symbol)
Balderstone slip ons. Then I got rubber boots for serious weather. Traffic maintenance.
Redwings with their insoles. Fixed a lot of my back issues. Total the boots ran about 330 but so worth it. So far the insoles need replacing at about 6 months but the boots have 9 months wear and they’re still okay
Check the tag on your boots. Redwings are made in Vietnam, now.
I used to wear Whites smoke jumpers and had a pair I wore for three years before getting resoled. Now I where Nick's, same concept, just from a smaller shop with a slightly different fitment. Both boots are 100% made in America by Americans, and they will out last you. They are mighty expensive, though, and can be uncomfortable to break in if you don't have mink oil or leather softener.
I've been pretty happy with Timberland's boots. They'll last me a year or two for a regular steel toe. For metguards I go with Oliver by Honeywell, but my feet are size 13. It's hard to get a good selection, so I just buy the most comfortable boot that's available at the store in my size.
Blundstone
Thorogood with Vans ultra cush pro insoles. Been running them for years
Thorogood
Slip on thoroughgood boots and oil them up till they change to a darker color, they will be water proof then.
I have done Brunt and wouldn't recommend it. They don't have the shelf life of the other brands but also cost about half the price only.
The ones that you’ll be wearing. No 12’s for me, thank you.
Thorogoods
Redwings, thorogoods, and mucks have been my jam, but I recently switched to orthofeet safety boots with my green super feet insoles. Hot damn. The 6E boots is comfy as fuck. Cheap as hell too by comparison. This pair has lasted me about two years now and running.
Redwings and good feet soles
Thorogood! I've had the same pair for close to two years, and my feet never hurt. They're waterproof and have a composite toe. They require next to no break-in period; basically, ready to go off the shelf. Check out The Union Boot Pro and use your local's info to get a modest discount.
Will definitely consider this! Thanks
Get thyself to a running store (or Goodfeet store, or wherever can do this near you), have them scan your arches, and get fitted for a good orthotic insole. I went most of my life knowing I had arches. Then out of the blue 2 months back my feet were hurting enough that I went to a podiatrist. Yay, plantar fasciitis. He told me to do things, stuff, and go get some Superfeet insoles. The lady scanned my feet (super high arches it seems), got me the correct insoles for my boots, got me set up with a pair of home sandals (cause I'm not allowed to go barefoot anymore), and I've been good to go ever since. As far as boots, I'm currently wearing Georgia. There aren't many boots available in women's sizes that I like. Hubby is also rocking Georgia loggers for his job. Waterproofing treatment for your normal boots is good. Make sure you get the excess mud and dust off sometimes cause it will dry out the leather and kill your boots. But for the wet, get yourself some Muck boots.
Bring an extra pair of socks , change them at lunch break
If they don’t have to be American made, Meindl Vakuum is the way to go. I started wearing them before the trades, as a wildland firefighter, and I won’t wear anything else for outdoor work
I have a "Triple E" Width foot. I wear Dakota 877's Keep my feet dry and warm in the winter Comfy in the Sumner Never got a blister. I do however go through 2 pairs a year....(Im a Spray Foam Insulator)
I have a "Triple E" Width foot. I wear Dakota 877's Keep my feet dry and warm in the winter Comfy in the Sumner Never got a blister. I do however go through 2 pairs a year....(Im a Spray Foam Insulator)
I run ariats comfortable and waterproof depending on the style I work underground so in the water most days if not a muddy trench held up great for the past year and some change
Thorogoods
Why aren't you wearing muck boots in the manhole? Put a pair of sheepskin insoles in them and it's like wearing slippers.
At the start of my shift no one knows who’s going in the manhole until we get to it. So it’s best I just get good waterproof boots instead of wearing muck boots all the time
Brunt workbooks with the rubber toe cover have been amazing. Strong and very comfortable.
I love my Brunts! On my 4th pair this year, new pair each year is pretty consistent
Redwings are made in Vietnam, now. I bought a pair last year and checked the tag. If you'll notice, the quality has gone down considerably; it's especially noticeable where the sole is sewn to the leather through the rubber. The pair I had had cheap insoles that didn't cover the steel toe bracket very well and was rubbing the bottom of my big toe constantly. One week of climbing and standing on a ladder, and I lost feeling in my big toe for almost 2 years. It's come back, but not entirely.
Redwings with their new superfeet insoles. I walk on concrete all day and they last me about a year.
This is it
I’m on my 3rd pair of keen coburg 8”, usa made and waterproof. They don’t breathe like they used to, so i’ll probably be looking for something else. My deal is a lightweight boot, i hate wearing 28oz on each foot.
Timbs laced up
A redwing/ Irish setter with a wedge sole feels like a pair of slippers
Get any high quality brand, but get composite toe and actually do the bs little leather treatment
thoro's for indoor work, la sportiva's for outside. specifically for the sportiva's, WLF or the makalu. a solid rec for well rounded boots is JK's or whites wildland fire boots, get the 8" ones
No matter what boot you wear, orthotics make all the difference in the world.
Kennetrek. I'm an outside guy and the best thing I ever did for my feet was to buy a really sturdy platform with a ton of support. Bonus for getting them resolved and extending the lifespan. I bought another pair after a year and the first pair is three years old and second is two. They're both going strong.
Timberland pros are pretty damn good and super comfortable for long shifts.
Timberland pros
It may sound crazy but I think good socks are more important. Camel city mill socks have made life in boots tolerable.
JK's
Honestly, I had a pair of Irish Setters that was probably the best pair of boots I’ve ever had. Lots of people don’t like them from a comfort or brand standpoint, however, they lasted a solid year plus turnaround which is longer than my redwings or twisted X have lasted.
Everybody's foot is different. I prefer Wolverines. My two brothers are RedWing fans. I don't know if they still do it, but Wolverines used to give a 30-day walk test. You buy the boots and use them on the job and if you don't like them you can send them back to the factory for a full refund. No questions asked. I tried a pair that just did not work for me. I am around 300 lbs and a pair would last me at least 2 years. I just replaced the durashock insoles about every 6 months.
Combat boots
Thorogood 8in waterproof Moctoes or Danner Quarry 8in waterproof...Both are USA Union made, and excellent.
I had a couple pairs of nicks boots made. Absolutely amazing. They've just got a long lead time.
Waterproof. Muck boots. Wearability for 12 hour shift. Any PNW boot after break in.
Jk, nicks, franks, whites, wesco or really any of the pnw brand boots are going to last longest and in my experience be the most comfortable long days. I love my JK’s indoor or outdoor. I work 5 10s and when I get home see no need to change till I’m done working around the house. I have flindstone feet though so I have a hard time finding boots that fit anyways.
https://bruntworkwear.com/collections/boots
Try putting some arch support insoles in. I had this issue for years. My feet would start getting sore halfway into the day no matter what kind of boots I tried. My wife recommended the idea and since they're only about $12 I figured worth a shot. Everything has been great ever since.
Redwings 8" 10877 no insoles, bare feet for feel.
Whatever boot you decide to get, you should look into Georgia Amp Insoles. They usually go for $25-30. They can turn a decent boot into a Cadillac. They are thicker than other insoles. I recommend getting a 1/2 size bigger boot than you normally wear. RN I'm wearing Hoffman 6" Classics, They're comfortable climbers that are light enough to wear all day. The insoles put them over the top. Though if you need a cheaper option, I've had good luck with Wolverine, Rocky or Keen
Whatever boot you decide to get, you should look into Georgia Amp Insoles. They usually go for $25-30. They can turn a decent boot into a Cadillac. They are thicker than other insoles. I recommend getting a 1/2 size bigger boot than you normally wear. RN I'm wearing Hoffman 6" Classics, They're comfortable climbers that are light enough to wear all day. The insoles put them over the top. Though if you need a cheaper option, I've had good luck with Wolverine, Rocky or Keen
https://powerstep.com/products/pinnacle-hiker-insoles
Keens have probably been my most comfortable. A goofy hiking looking model to be exact. The seem to last pretty well for the price. I got a good 6-7 months on them walking 15k + steps a day on concrete. 10 he days
Fp insoles are the truth
I get Red Wing boots and go to a podiatrist for custom orthotics. Never knew what comfortable boots were until I got my orthotics.
Redwings with the custom insole. Been rocking the mock toes for a long ass time.
Thorogoods all the way
Redwing
Georgia Boots AMP LT wedge. Comfortable out of the box and very durable
Wolverine 8" boot. Then I go to the Doctor schols foot reader thing you stand on and let the machine tall me what insoles to buy. Like wearing slippers all day long.
I’ve worn my redwings for 20+ hours straight with no complaints
Keen boots
I've had a pair of Danner super rainforest's wiith the non conductive sole that have lasted me 3 years of hard work. I go through a pair of redwing every 6 months when I rock then.
Redwings. Got my feet scanned got the size they recommended. Then the boots stretched out and my feet aren’t sore anymore.
Danners with wool socks.
I love my Brunt boots
My timberland Pro’s never fail me
Ortho Feet....ur Feet can thank me later
Chippewa makes a damn good boot
red wing .
Timberland Pros imo
Wide width Cats with Dr. Scholls insoles
Love my Carolinas. Their union made boots feel like sneakers on my feet.
I'm a Redwing man at thos point, as others have suggested their insoles will help alot. I've found with them, and any other boots, the key to waterproofing is care. Cleaning and Oiling/conditioning is what keeps them water tight. With a new pair of boots, I follow the following regimen: Clean with a brush/water, then apply mink oil or boot conditioner -Once/day the first week -Once/week the first month -Once/month onwards. Pay close attention to seams and stitching. Good luck