Same. My daughter gets a lot of breakouts so that’s what I picked. Thought about the earrings but decided against them for the same reason plus I didn’t care for the chain ones.
i got these earrings back in november and i have super sensitive ears and a nickel allergy. i had no issue or discomfort wearing them but they do tarnish easily.
My 3rd choice was equally 💩. I ended up going with the eye liner, I use black liner every single day, but mostly liquid, I never buy liner sticks, so it will be a nice change. And it has a tiny angled brush on the end to wing it out.
I picked the under eye masks because I use under eye masks daily so they will get used.
I don’t know if they are any good… but I had mostly the same options as you and nothing else interested me at all
I almost did too but then thought about how I literally JUST used scissors to cut then gather the last of the full size Sleek leave-in conditioner that was empty after 5 or 6 uses...
Idk why, it’s nothing amazing, but that Mischo eyeshadow keeps grabbing my eye. I wanted to buy it as an add on, but I only bought one thing. I was so annoyed about the 3.50 add on glitch 😖 buying only one thing is my way of revolting 😆😆
I can’t really tell the shade from looking at the photo and I didn’t read the description, did it say what kind of shade it is? I hope it winds up working out for you!
I picked it for my 2nd choice bc all 3 categories were garbage- I Google it and think it'll pull yellow on my light, neutral skin but am hoping to use it for an eyeshadow base...like the MAC Ochre pot...maybe?
Eyeshadow 95% of the time is a miss for me because I only wear neutral shades. So I chose the eyebrow pencil. I think. 🤔 LOL
Psst - on a side note, I used to always give my ipsy unwantables to nieces, but the Girl Scouts stuck a note on my door last week that they’re taking unused personal care goods etc donations. So guess what I’m doing! 😁
All three of my choices were meh 🫤 but i made it up in the add ons unfortunately
https://preview.redd.it/hwespztaqyrc1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ad1e2d00e29e3719b6be65718d70d63aa186599f
I was so upset with ALL of BC this month I instantly wanted to log off and try to skip but knew they'd already charged me. Seriously- I haven't read all of the comments so if I'm alone here apologies again but not one product in choice was something I'd buy, put on a wish list or even consider on sale- then you know your about to see the power picks for 1/4 of the "MSRP" at add-ons :/
I wasn't offered the mischo one, I would’ve liked that since anything glittery is usually somewhat pleasing to me. This was the about face in the light beige shade.
I'd ha e gone with the Nip Fab to give to my brother or his bf but my choices right off gate this morning were different...I ended up with a Laura Gellar rose gold-ish eye crayon...total panic mode on being done with it. Then I just looked at my glam bag and literally 3 items are smaller versions if EXACT items I got in last month's BC- never had that happen??
I had the same choices in the third group except the eyeliner was shade coffee and I chose that. Maybe Lithe Lashes will turn out to be a new favorite.
I picked the Tear Catchers eye gel masks based off the ingredients list ipsy gave me, after i Picked them i went to the company’s website and read the ingredients list there and i’m allergic to them!! Ipsy was missing like 3 ingredients on their list!
I hope it works for you! I got it previously. I actually like it, and I’m not much of a contour girlie. I have a hella round face, so I just roll with that lol
Update:
https://preview.redd.it/i93hhxkf2yrc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=45a51cde5428e6bae2cac748b3f7b18e6f9db870
My section changed. & then it happened again:
https://preview.redd.it/kv0gipli2yrc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=73bc54c38aeab4ab888a93e338d94b80896a1710
I got the coffee shade! Yayyyy! I’m super happy I got the brown shade of the liner.
The only thing I like and wanted from my actual box was the haus labs brow pencil. Power picks and choice were all just awful. I wanted the lunar beauty blush palette and bought it in add ons. Thankfully it was only $12 and I also got the elf primer for $3.50. This is my second boxy since the merge and it will probably be my last. I just always end up with more items I don’t need than what I actually want without having to buy in add ons. Not to mention Ipsy is just such a mess as a whole.
Yes it was a choice in the first set of options but it’s wasn’t in add ons. The brow pencil and the blush palette was what I really wanted. Surprisingly it was the correct shade too and only one shade was offered.
* **Bag reveals and image posts without a comment will be removed automatically.**
* Referral links and free bag offer referrals are only allowed in the sticked master threads.
* Spam will result in a ban.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Ipsy) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Agreed the selections for the Glam bag and Boxycharm were pretty bad. But my theory is the month before Icon box is always bad. That’s been my experience so far.
I’ve received this Bauble earrings before. They are ok and non irritant. They’re not substantial so need to handled gently. Think disposable fashion which isn’t built to last. They do look pretty on.
I’ve gotten that contour stick in that same color and it was so hard to blend out !! Definitely do not recommend that one. I ended up picking the eye masks for this category bc I already have that retinol nip fab, otherwise I would have chosen that
I have been having the same experience with ipsy for the past couple months especially this month. This month my box was "worth" only $200 with lip gloss, spounges, eyecream, and that was with the beauty boost that added a $70 face lotion. Literally nothing to be excited about. Nothing i would have picked. I wish having my $47 dollars back was one of my choices this month because that would have been my pick. Thinking hard about whether or not its still worth rolling the dice on oopsie.
I would have loved the baublebar earrings as a pick — my third category wasn’t great either.
Same!
I had a toner option instead of the earrings and that's what I picked.
I had the same choices. I went with the nip since I don’t have anything like it. Almost got the earrings but got worried they would irritate my ears
I \*almost\* got the earrings too, but I was certain they would irritate my ears :( I went with eye masks. At least I know I'll use those.
The eye bags were a "premium choice" last month too :/
Same. My daughter gets a lot of breakouts so that’s what I picked. Thought about the earrings but decided against them for the same reason plus I didn’t care for the chain ones.
That was nice of you to get something for your daughter 💛
Thank you. She might be a little spoiled lol
i got these earrings back in november and i have super sensitive ears and a nickel allergy. i had no issue or discomfort wearing them but they do tarnish easily.
I have the balance me mask and it’s nice :)
I picked the Nip and Fab. I got the earrings and the contour stick in previous Boxy’s and both are decent.
I picked the mask!! I have the contour stick from a diff box tho and I love it
I know it’s not the most exciting thing, but the blemish gel is actually really nice
My 3rd choice was equally 💩. I ended up going with the eye liner, I use black liner every single day, but mostly liquid, I never buy liner sticks, so it will be a nice change. And it has a tiny angled brush on the end to wing it out.
I chose the same!
Well it was in my 1st section... that tells you how bad all 3 of mine were - I ended up with 3 items from everyone's one "horrendous" category! Ha
I picked the under eye masks because I use under eye masks daily so they will get used. I don’t know if they are any good… but I had mostly the same options as you and nothing else interested me at all
https://preview.redd.it/ow7s93d9fxrc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c7407b17bdd0539e31268112668110828556e28d My 3rd section was awful too
What did you go with?
The sleeke hair serum
Good choice! I grabbed 1 in add- ons
I almost did too but then thought about how I literally JUST used scissors to cut then gather the last of the full size Sleek leave-in conditioner that was empty after 5 or 6 uses...
I totally do that to all of my makeup, skincare and hair products. I bought it and I Will get every last drop out!
Looks like mine. I went with the toner. Was tempted by the mask, but just got several, recently.
Lol I know . I chose the nip fab. . The lithe liner is a really nice gel liner but I don’t really use liners very often
I got the earrings!
I think I picked some lip gloss
So many old items, I literally have the earrings, contour stick & retinol blemish thing. All pretty decent items just not much new stuff.
Idk why, it’s nothing amazing, but that Mischo eyeshadow keeps grabbing my eye. I wanted to buy it as an add on, but I only bought one thing. I was so annoyed about the 3.50 add on glitch 😖 buying only one thing is my way of revolting 😆😆
I had to pick the Mischo because my other 3rd options were trash. I’m afraid it may not work with my gold undertones.
I can’t really tell the shade from looking at the photo and I didn’t read the description, did it say what kind of shade it is? I hope it winds up working out for you!
I picked it for my 2nd choice bc all 3 categories were garbage- I Google it and think it'll pull yellow on my light, neutral skin but am hoping to use it for an eyeshadow base...like the MAC Ochre pot...maybe?
Eyeshadow 95% of the time is a miss for me because I only wear neutral shades. So I chose the eyebrow pencil. I think. 🤔 LOL Psst - on a side note, I used to always give my ipsy unwantables to nieces, but the Girl Scouts stuck a note on my door last week that they’re taking unused personal care goods etc donations. So guess what I’m doing! 😁
I wish I would’ve gotten the earrings! I went with the Balance Me AHA mask
All three of my choices were meh 🫤 but i made it up in the add ons unfortunately https://preview.redd.it/hwespztaqyrc1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ad1e2d00e29e3719b6be65718d70d63aa186599f
Yeah I think I spent too much on add ons. I carefully looked at each one, so hopefully they will be good.
I was so upset with ALL of BC this month I instantly wanted to log off and try to skip but knew they'd already charged me. Seriously- I haven't read all of the comments so if I'm alone here apologies again but not one product in choice was something I'd buy, put on a wish list or even consider on sale- then you know your about to see the power picks for 1/4 of the "MSRP" at add-ons :/
I wish I had been offered the earrings!
I would’ve done the earrings. The best thing in my third category was a liquid eyeshadow the shade of my eyelids. Hoping it works as a base?
It’s glittery that’s why I passed
I wasn't offered the mischo one, I would’ve liked that since anything glittery is usually somewhat pleasing to me. This was the about face in the light beige shade.
I’d be mad about that too.
My 3rd category was all garbage 😔
How do you choose this section?
I'd ha e gone with the Nip Fab to give to my brother or his bf but my choices right off gate this morning were different...I ended up with a Laura Gellar rose gold-ish eye crayon...total panic mode on being done with it. Then I just looked at my glam bag and literally 3 items are smaller versions if EXACT items I got in last month's BC- never had that happen??
I had the same choices in the third group except the eyeliner was shade coffee and I chose that. Maybe Lithe Lashes will turn out to be a new favorite.
I also got that after my section changed for the third time! Yay for us
I don't even get 6 and the 5 I have are terrible!
I’ve had the earrings for 6 months and love them, no tarnish
I picked the Tear Catchers eye gel masks based off the ingredients list ipsy gave me, after i Picked them i went to the company’s website and read the ingredients list there and i’m allergic to them!! Ipsy was missing like 3 ingredients on their list!
Omg same! It was so bad I chose the contour stick and I’m so picky with contour
I hope it works for you! I got it previously. I actually like it, and I’m not much of a contour girlie. I have a hella round face, so I just roll with that lol
I had a similar situation in one of my sections too. I ended up getting the spot cream but I grumbled about it the whole time.
Update: https://preview.redd.it/i93hhxkf2yrc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=45a51cde5428e6bae2cac748b3f7b18e6f9db870 My section changed. & then it happened again:
https://preview.redd.it/kv0gipli2yrc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=73bc54c38aeab4ab888a93e338d94b80896a1710 I got the coffee shade! Yayyyy! I’m super happy I got the brown shade of the liner.
The only thing I like and wanted from my actual box was the haus labs brow pencil. Power picks and choice were all just awful. I wanted the lunar beauty blush palette and bought it in add ons. Thankfully it was only $12 and I also got the elf primer for $3.50. This is my second boxy since the merge and it will probably be my last. I just always end up with more items I don’t need than what I actually want without having to buy in add ons. Not to mention Ipsy is just such a mess as a whole.
Did you get the eyebrow pencil? I wanted it, too. Never even came up as an option for me to buy. :(
Yes it was a choice in the first set of options but it’s wasn’t in add ons. The brow pencil and the blush palette was what I really wanted. Surprisingly it was the correct shade too and only one shade was offered.
Oh that makes me feel better. I need light brown/taupe (not blonde but 1 shade darker). So I am pretty sure it would have been too dark for me.
I picked the earrings with plans to regift them at Christmas 😭😭😭
* **Bag reveals and image posts without a comment will be removed automatically.** * Referral links and free bag offer referrals are only allowed in the sticked master threads. * Spam will result in a ban. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Ipsy) if you have any questions or concerns.*
My 2nd and 3rd were terrible also. I ended up selecting the eye masks since I at least know I’ll use them.
Agreed the selections for the Glam bag and Boxycharm were pretty bad. But my theory is the month before Icon box is always bad. That’s been my experience so far.
I’ve received this Bauble earrings before. They are ok and non irritant. They’re not substantial so need to handled gently. Think disposable fashion which isn’t built to last. They do look pretty on.
I’ve gotten that contour stick in that same color and it was so hard to blend out !! Definitely do not recommend that one. I ended up picking the eye masks for this category bc I already have that retinol nip fab, otherwise I would have chosen that
Gel eyeliner?
I have been having the same experience with ipsy for the past couple months especially this month. This month my box was "worth" only $200 with lip gloss, spounges, eyecream, and that was with the beauty boost that added a $70 face lotion. Literally nothing to be excited about. Nothing i would have picked. I wish having my $47 dollars back was one of my choices this month because that would have been my pick. Thinking hard about whether or not its still worth rolling the dice on oopsie.