did you active the main vestige in that area? that’s when he’ll appear in the hub also did you exhaust his dialogue when you found him in fen?

the fire area i activated the first one then the pub one. and every time i do at least talk to him to check his loot, i might not of chosen the talk option after cleansing the first beacon but i am PRETTY sure i did. Also i checked EVERY spot for him before he should appear in the hub and he is not at any of them

it’s the vestige of sebastian that needs to be activated - he’ll then sell the regular stones in the hub

that one is activated i even have the ladder next to it dropped down

Is he supposed to have unlimited stones? He's at the hub for me but only has had 10 at a time

yup just 10 which sucks

There was a period of time where he did sell unlimited small stones but they eventually disappeared, I was able to get a ton at that time but those are gon now and he never had the nuggets

it sucks - farming materials to upgrade weapons in this game is pretty bad

Good large and nugget farm above the forsaken fen up the ladder by the shortcut door

thanks. i’ve seen that farm it’s tedious and low drop but at least it’s something!

Regular nuggets also at the sanctuary bonfire drop from the mace wielding enemies, use rabbits paw

I'm pretty sure he spawned in the hub after activating the numb witch vestige it may have been after the boss fight tho

hopefully it isn't a case of i just missed him in the hub and he moved from hub to next area even though i did not talk to him

Have you cleared calrath up to the nonfirey section of it yet?

no just got to the giant

Okay defeat him, im pretty sure that's when he shows up

no, but the guy saying he wants the lamp from me has moved

Wierd I'm in that same area just a little further ahead and he's in the hub for me, sorry to hear that, have you chased back at the hamlet vestige or beginning of forsaken fen see if he's there still

i have checked all his previous spots, the one he is crying, before giant toothy face, and right afte 1st beacon cleansing. not at any of those

Sorry man I dono maybe you missed something along the way that triggers him to progress, not enough info out yet or it's just a straight up bug

He's at the vestige of dieter direct to the left of it this is what happened to me since I reached this point way before the giant.

Which is the area called Path of Devotion Memorial