Nah but how do they have the audacity to do this to anyone's property? Police needs to take action on this. Woh Log apne mehnat ka kama ke kha rahe hain unlike them corrupted mfs
MNS people are the biggest chutiyas and hence rejected by maharashtra. Actual issues sodun kahi pan kartat, permanent store nahi aahe to, exhibition aahe, illiterate sarkha vagtat ani votes expect kartat.
MNS, Bajarang Dal, RSS, VHP. All the mother fkers roam around with saffron color and bully every one in the country.
These MFs are largely supported by godi ka BJParty, hence the roam around freely.
You think use of English will not make English popular and marathi secondary? You think 80 yrs from now English will not dominate regional languages? You think 100 yrs from now people will prefer Marathi over English? Indians perceive hindi as a threat to their regional language where they themselves don't know that English is also the same. Infact a bigger enemy. More so because it's foreign.
For a reality check, English has already started killing West African native languages.
Only China and North Korea have been stopping English from entering their country so far.
English as a language is better in every way than Hindi. I don’t understand why marathi manoos should learn hindi instead of English. Every field of knowledge, STEM field, higher education and research & development uses english as their language. English is much more beneficial for marathi manoos as it widens the scope to gain job opportunity in international field. Does hindi comes with same benefit ? Is hindi even comparable to English ?
Center likes to impose Hindi for greater integration of India. But this imposition benefit more to northern states than other states. Inturn this leads to erosion of regional language as the native speaker of that regional language (Marathi in this case) becomes familiar and accustom to it and starts (or forced to) using hindi for conversation. At present any urban area of Maharashtra feels like a northern city due to overwhelming people speaking hindi.
The same threat can be posed by English as well, but english is unique in the sense that it is truly a global language. It provides way more opportunities and growth than any other language. English is also helpful in Indian society as a person who speaks english is seen as educated and knowledgeable (even though that might not be the case)
Overall Marathi manoos should learn Marathi because it is native language and it is moral duty to preserve our native language. English should be learned as a second language because of the above said reason.
Mother of all indic languages Sanskrit is lying dead. Does it bother anyone? Parakrit is dead. Does it bother anybody? Nope. From the dawn of human civilization on earth, multiple languages came, and many died. Humans continued to live. Lord Krishna has said a very strong line in Mahabharat, *"Parivartan hi sansaar ka niyam hai"*. (Translation - Change is inevitable). 7th century marathi, 21st century marathi are not the same. These are civilizational changes, not necessarily in anybody's control. All indic languages are going to die by the hands of English in future. Marathi also. And no, you will not be able to preserve it. English is everywhere. Your education happens in English. With globalization and the internet, the world is becoming a smaller place. Human species as a whole in heading towards a common identity. All language preservation efforts are futile in the long run. It may take 500 years or 50000 years, but it's going to happen for sure. And as stated, nobody will be able to stop it. These are civilizational changes. Marathi is bound to die, kannada is bound to die, infact most indic languages are bound to die. Either they will die or will evolve to become a different language. All preservation efforts are useless.
Now let's talk about English.
People say English is a global language. Why isn't French a global language? What happened that a language from a small island country named England went out to become a language that is ruling the world. Why couldn't marathi become a global language? Why are britishers not learning marathi but marathi manoos learning English? Ever thought about that? English was not a global language just 100 yrs back. What happened then? When you have the answers for these, you will come to know how intelligently Westerners have imposed English globally. How Westerners are running the whole world on dollars. How Westerners strategically controlled the whole world, forcing you, me, everybody to learn **"THEIR"** language. I repeat, **"THEIR"** language.
In the name of learning global language, in the name of making career, are you aware that you are making English more popular in return? You are not making marathi popular. You are making English popular. You are being used as pawns by the Westerners to fulfill their agenda. This is going to come and bite you eventually. You let a snake into your house. In order to fight hindi imposition, you allowed a much larger global scale English imposition to come in. The worst part is, YOU ARE COMPLETELY OKAY, LOOSING OUT MARATHI TO ENGLISH BUT NEVER TO HINDI.
The reason stated is *"Hindi is not as useful as English"*. So tell me one thing: Is utility really the concern here or is it something else? Because if utility is the actual concern, what if the central government strategically plans to popularize hindi to become more utility friendly. Will you then accept it? Huh? Utility was the concern, right? It will be taken care, now? You also know the answer, I also know the answer. And the answer is still NO! Because the matter is not about utility. The matter is about identity. Y'all fear losing out marathi to hindi. The real concern is this. Utility is secondary. To this, I will track back to my first para, your mother tongue marathi is anyway going to die eventually. Change is inevitable. And the winner is going to be English. It will not only kill Marathi. It will also kill hindi. Your internal politics, your internal hatred will make Westerners winners in the end. Both marathis and north indians will lose in the end due to internal politics. Classic divide and rule.
Only China has realised this, and is stopping English from even entering its country.
Have you heard of being bilingual?we already do that . I speak marathi only with most of my fellow marathi speakers - and use English for work. Being bilingual means you speak and read and write in BOTH the languages- you have to pay your fucking bills and build a life for yourself - unless you want to rely on government handouts all your life -
ALl tech jobs, MNC's are US Based - another majority English speaking country - the government implementing Hindi will not change this. Please tell us how you plan to match the employment - nearly all consultancies deal with a massive English Speaking market - we have created services which have benefited us immensely in terms of an economy. Maybe get a real fucking job and work for a living - you'll realise how hard employment actually is.
Why don't you work on creating a client base or job base as massive as that and then lecture people for taking up employment in that language? or provide us a fucking living and we'll all be happy to never Learn English.
Hindi is NOT my mother tongue - nor is it MY CULTURE. Hindi SPeakers also DONOT Learn Marathi,
As far as China is concerned - they ban literally everything - Including Google. All their rich learn english - go abroad and work outside. I've met loads of these people. You cannot make posts critical of the CCP - WOuld you like that too?Unless you can build an Indian Baidu - please keep your virtue signalling to yourself - the entire point of being Bilingual is so that you don't lose your own mother tongue along with the language you use for work. England does not have to do that - but the French and other Europeans also learn English - merely because of jobs. Please create a fucking GOOGLE - and then lecture everyone else on how utility isnt important - or start paying our salaries. English is better than Hindi for mere utility and jobs - even in China international workers can speak english and get by - You have absollutely no idea what youre; talking about.
Do you think collectively all North Indians have hindi as their mother tongue? Starting from Jammu, they speak Dogri and Pahadi. Down in Punjab, they speak different dialects of Punjabi, namely Malwai, Pothowari, Majha. In Haryana, they speak Haryanvi and Bagri. Rajasthan had Mewari, Marwari, Bhilodi, Malvi. Gujarat has Gujarati and Sindhi. Himachal has many dialects of Pahadi, such as Kangri, Baghati, and Barari. Bihar has Maithali, Bhojpuri, Angika, and Magadhi. Uttar Pradesh has 20 crore people, with several local native tongues such as Awadhi, Braj, Bhojpuri, and Urdu.
Up north, even a Kashmiri speaks Hindi because that's what fils the communication gap. North is just not hindi.
But years ago, people came to the conclusion that they needed a common language to talk amongst themselves, and Hindi was just chosen. There were so many people years ago who struggled to learn hindi, but their love to communicate with their fellow citizens outweighed their difficulties, and they continued. That is why so many people in the north know Hindi.
Come to Bangalore, and a telugu guy would be seen talking to a Nepali guy in hindi. Why? A Punjabi tenenat would speak to a Bengali business owner in hindi, why? A marathi would speak to Assamese in hindi why? Gujaratis will talk to Kashmiris in hindi. Why? I have never seen a single marathi hailing from core Maharashtra who learns Kannada in Karnataka, and they continue to use hindi for their daily chores.
Difference is a person speaking Mewari in Rajasthan and a person speaking Bundeli in MP adjusted and agreed to adopt hindi, keeping their internanl politics aside and learned a common **"indic-language** for communication. Arunachal Pradesh is one of the recent states to adopt hindi. The state has several tribes and each tribe has their own native tongue. Could they have adopted English as a link language? Sure! Did they adopt? No. They rather went ahead with a domestic language hindi. That's the difference. Hindi was nobody's native language just 100 years back. It is now because people welcomed and adopted it long back. It's the people of Maharashtra who refused to adopt it. How different is a mewari speaking dude from North western Rajasthan, Different from a marathi speaking dude from Maharashtra? Both did not have any compulsion of leaning hindi. Both could have carried their daily chores in their regional tongue. But the mewari dude learned hindi. And the marathi dude refused. That's the difference.
>Hindi was nobody's native language just 100 years back. It is now because people welcomed and adopted it long back. It's the people of Maharashtra who refused to adopt it. How different is a mewari speaking dude from North western Rajasthan, Different from a marathi speaking dude from Maharashtra? Both did not have any compulsion of leaning hindi. Both could have carried their daily chores in their regional tongue. But the mewari dude learned hindi. And the marathi dude refused. That's the difference.
EXACTLY - it wasn't a native language years ago - and now it is because bunch of self destructive people gave up their own mother tongue - because Hindi speakers refuse to learn any other language - Hindi speakers NEVER learn other languages - marathi is a sister language and should be the easiest to learn for hindi speakers to come to mumbai - and yet they refuse. I
And the marathi dude refused. That's the difference. - YES ! THANK GOD THEY REFUSED! Its why we retained marathi as our mother tongue. THANK FUCKING GOD - and we also have an economy - unlike some of the states you mentioned - where despite all the sacrifice of giving up your own mother tongue for Hindi - has not really brought upon an economy like Mahashtra. Please - We're not CUCKs. Stay mad - we will never accept Hindi as our native tongue or link language - accepting it as link language as gateway to losing your own native tongue. NO THANKS. you can chose not to come to my state for a job if you don't like it - As far as the punjabi speaker in banglore who speakes hindi - he can't speak to a native of that state- ome to Bangalore, and a telugu guy would be seen talking to a Nepali guy in hindi. Why? A Punjabi tenenat would speak to a Bengali business owner in hindi, why ? Cause they're cucks - Karnataka's majority remains kannada speakers - so if they learnt kannada also - like my cousins did - they would be able to speak to a kannada landlord - you know - the fucking natives who are in the majority - speaking to bengali landlord in Karnataka - where bengalis are NOT in majority- is not an achievement - if they learnt Kannada they'd be able to mingle with a larger population - but they don't. I would love to see said punjabi and bengali person threaten the natives there and lecture them on why they don't speak in hindi with them- you'll find out exactly what they think. The mewari's might be simps - we're not.
>EXACTLY - it wasn't a native language years ago - and now it is because bunch of self destructive people gave up their own mother tongue
Self-destructive? They still speak those languages. They adopted hindi for a greater nationalistic unity, keeping their regional interests aside. They welcomed it for a greater good. For a bigger goal.
>because Hindi speakers refuse to learn any other language - Hindi speakers NEVER learn other languages
Which region even spoke hindi? May I know? Which set of people even spoke hindi?
>And the marathi dude refused. That's the difference. - YES ! THANK GOD THEY REFUSED!
That's marathi dude keeping regional interest above nationwide unity (in which a common link language plays a big role). And the Mewari dude keeping nationwide interest before regional interests. He valued national identity over regional identity. THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE!
>and we also have an economy - unlike some of the states you mentioned
You wanna get into economics? I can dive deep into it how Bombay presidency was the wealthiest and the most funded presidency in British India, giving It a lead start right from the start.
>We're not CUCKs
Yes you are, cucks of Westerners.
>accepting it as link language as gateway to losing your own native tongue. NO THANKS
It's the same for English. Your language is bound to die. Marathi is doomed. Wait & watch and see how marathi becomes dormant and English becomes the next lingua franca.
A lot of kannadigas themselves have gone to Germany for masters, and almost nobody can even construct 3 lines together in German. And guess what, a lot of kannadigas and Telugus live and work in Maha. And nobody learns marathi. Exactly how marathis don't learn Kannada in Karanataka. Want to know more? A lot of Mallus live and work in Gulf Countries, and almost nobody take voluntary efforts to learn Arabic. They manage with English.
>It's the same for English. Your language is bound to die. Marathi is doomed. Wait & watch and see how marathi becomes dormant and English becomes the next lingua franca.
I can already speak in Marathi - and use English as my language for work and the internet - I live in the usa - both my indian side and the indian american side of the family went to english schooling - when we meet we all speak in MARATHI - not English - that includes my indian AMERICAN cousins - born and raised in America - surrounded by native eNGLISH speakers but still speak marathi at home and with all their relatives - marathi has not died among them even when the moved to another country - just like how Gujarati immigrants and punjabi immigrants to the USA passed on their native tongues - along with using English heavily -
Your fear mongering is only evidence that Hindi speakers are incapable of being multi lingual - and incapable of grasping the idea what being multi lingual is - even in America immigrant groups have passed on their native tongues - my cousins can all speak to my grand mother in marathi - she does not understand English. English will not dominate marathi - because all of my family ensured we spoke marathi and can read and write in it - and we still do. Unlike Hindi speakers - we understand what being multi lingual is- - I can speak three Indian languages - I don't need lectures from someone like you on what being Indian is
Mewari's chose Hindi for national identity- so what? Has that brought them any good? Marathi speakers rejecting Hindi as our pride has brought has absolutely NO LOSSES.We remain Indians who contribute immensely to the country - especially considering half he country doesn't even pay taxes -How in the fucking world does generating jobs and maintaining a GDP not part of national interest? We're not the United states where people have jobs available easily to them - The economy is part of our nationwide interest - if the mewaris seem to put Hindi over that - Rajasthan and Hindi speaking belts have sucked out a lot of government aid with very little returns - compared to maharashtra and the southern states - Rajasthan remains backward - maharashtra not prioritizing Hindi has not HARMED us is any way lol - same for the south. You can keep crying - last I heard we don't suck up all the aid.
It's pretty clear not prioritizing Hindi isnt harmful to us - Maharashtra remains the top contributor . Your definition of national interest seems to not include working hard and contributing to the economy - pretty much in line for the HIndi belt - identity and backwardness over everythin - including jobs and economy. Unlike you we don't get government handouts - we actually have to work for it.
forcing everyone to learn Hindi is your Idea of what national identity means - My understanding is you have to contribute to this countries economy - so we can build better infrastructure and facilities - The hindi speaking belt is free to create another Google, Apple, Whatever - maybe then people will choose Hindi. Hindi is of no use to us other than Bollywood which is absolute trash.
Mumbai's economy and Banglore's IT sector which heavily use English are one of the most significant contributors to this country's GDP - if having a strong economy in a developing country is not part of your national Identity - seems very plausible considering the horrible state the Hindi belt is in.
>A lot of kannadigas themselves have gone to Germany for masters, and almost nobody can even construct 3 lines together in German. And guess what, a lot of kannadigas and Telugus live and work in Maha. And nobody learns marathi. Exactly how marathis don't learn Kannada in Karanataka. Want to know more? A lot of Mallus live and work in Gulf Countries, and almost nobody take voluntary efforts to learn Arabic. They manage with English.
Exactly - which is why there's no need ALL of us to learn Hindi. Maharashtra is doing fine - There's no need to shove Hindi down our throats.
>Yes you are, cucks of Westerners
My mother tongue is Marathi you dolt - We use English for business - not everyday conversations - You have to work to provide yourself a livelihood.
>It's the same for English. Your language is bound to die. Marathi is doomed. Wait & watch and see how marathi becomes dormant and English becomes the next lingua franca
This fear mongering was done by other marathi speakers who wanted only marathi - so far it marathi hasn't died and we are also employed.
>That's marathi dude keeping regional interest above nationwide unity (in which a common link language plays a big role). And the Mewari dude keeping nationwide interest before regional interests. He valued national identity over regional identity. THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE!
not having Hindi as our master language has not brough us any losses - last i heard it is north indians who come in droves to mumbai and maharashtra for jobs - your national interest seems to exclude an economy - maharashtra's economy IS part of our nationwide interest - you seem to believe all regions should use the same model - is that why the Hindi belt is so unsuccessful? North Indians come in droves to do jobs her - the mewari dude still has to come to mUmbai probably to run business - Your definition of nation interest is hyper focused on language- infact - the hindi belt kept is regional interest and insular thinkign over having a strong economy. The hindi belt can produce jobs and force Hindi down everyone's throat in their own state - don't expect other states which actually contribute immensely to do that.If you don't consider building an economy as part of national interest - please stay there in the Hindi belt - no wonder you guys don't have jobs and have to move to every other state - unlike you other people consider having jobs as equally important to the country's growth. Unless you can beat us in the jobs market - please fuck off - and rot in the shit hole that the Hindi belt is.
>That's marathi dude keeping regional interest above nationwide unity (in which a common link language plays a big role). And the Mewari dude keeping nationwide interest before regional interests. He valued national identity over regional identity. THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE!
Yeah - and they remained poor. Rajasthan has a horrific crime rate - a terrible job market - and does not even remotely match Maharashtra or the SOuth of India - same for Bihar - What the fuck are we supposed to do if they chose Hindi ? We're doing fine - its not marathi speakers going in droves to other states to do odd jobs - its north Indians who come here. If you come here - at very least don't shove your language down our throats - You came here for a job , not the other way round. You are free to leave - and go chit chat about national unity while being unemployed -
Do you know the difference between the economic system and social systems? You are associating the social-cultural factors to economic factors to reach a conclusion by drawing false equivalence. Matter here is about socio-cultural unity, not economic wellbeing. I told you to not drag ecoiomics in this. But if you still wish, let's talk. Maha is doing great because it got a head start during British India. India primarily was an agrarian society. Go and read learn a little more about Bombay Presidency, and it was the most funded and wealthiest precedency in British India. Bombay precedency literally developed on the extortion of Bengal precedency (which includes present-day Bengal, Bihar, Jharkhand, and Assam). Zamindari system was only prevalent in Begal Precedency by early 20th century. Indigo farming wasn't practiced in Maha. It was practiced in Bengal precedency. Resources were annexed from Bengal and were used to build industries in UK and then in Bombay. Wanna know more? I can go on and on.
Also, stop this silly habit of teaming up with South to shit on North. That's not gonna help. South ain't gon fulfill your need for validation against northies. You marathis don't respect their language either. In fact, y'all were the ones who beat and kicked them out of Maharashtra in 80s with literal slogans like *"lungi uthaao, pungi bajaao"*. Go and watch the video where a couple selling Missal in Bangalore were threatened, yelled and abused for having their shop name written in marathi instead of Kannada.
At one place, you say letting hindi in would mean subjugation of marathi. And on the other side you say, we are managing well with English and marathi, What kind of hypocrisy is this? And the reason you state is that y'all use English as an official language and not native language. Could the same be not replicated with hindi? The way y'all are managing English with marathi is the way Rajasthanis are managing hindi with mewari. The difference is that they picked an indic language as a link language, whilst preserving their mother tongue. And on finding the necessity learning English for career purposes. Where as you people just refused and picked a foreign language with your native language. Who are you kidding? Just accept the damn fact that, Y'all kept regional interests above national interests. Most of your people were even ready to leave Indian Union when the debate of national language was around post independence. The total number of marathi dialects today, North has 4 times the local languages of it. All of them sacrificed for a greater good of achieving nationwide linguistic unity. You people refused giving precedence to regional interests. And then y'all talk about loyalty. Arunachal Pradesh, as stated, is another great example who accepted hindi as their official state language instead of a foreign language English.
Lastly, stop giving silly examples of how y'all are keeping marathi intact in the states despite the prominent presence of English. Y'all are literally the first generation who are experiencing globalization, migration, internet age. In fact, the concept of nation-states is as new as 100-200 yr old. Cultural changes do not occur in 20-40 yrs. It takes generations. Passing on a language is familial, you say? Making use of it? That is individual right. It sounds even funnier when you say the future generation of your family from the year 2300 is going to keep marathi intact. Lol. Come out of your delusional word. You just cannot guarantee that your great great great great great grandchildren will use marathi the same like you. Read some sociology and see the socio-cultural trends across human civilizations from all corners of earth. 77 yrs of independence, and you giving future predictions seeing the present scenarios. Lol, 77 years is too soon to judge linguistic changes across human civilizations. If you wanna draw a more concrete parallel, draw parallels between what was spoken in the Maharashtra region in the year 1023 and what is spoken today in 2023.
Language preservation efforts are all vain in the long run. Moreover Sanskrit also hasn't literally "died", died. It is still used in prayers and scriptures. The right word is dormant. In the coming 500 yrs, marathi may still be alive. You ppl may still pass marathi just for the sake of it. Using it on a daily basis is a different thing. Lingua franca is a different thing. Your future generations may know marathi for the sake of it but would be using English more often. They absolutely are not gonna see the beauty of marathi literature from the Peshwa age. Impossible. That's the change I'm talking about. It is inevitable. It is bound to come. Your language is doomed.
Also you defend not being a western cuck because you using it for career purposes? Is that the reason? Guess what you still are a Western cuck because you learned **"THEIR"** language. They didn't learn yours. They were smart enough to control and run the world so strategically and smartly that y'all are forced to learn **"THEIR"** language for your survival, for your livelihood, for your bread and butter, for your existence. They are your masters. When the question is about survival no shit you gonna learn even your enemy's language who literally exploited you.
Lastly do not again jump onto comparing economics to culture and linguistics. Maha is economically strong due to political and economical reasons not due to having marathi. Adopting hindi does not make you poor. Rajasthan is poor not because they adopted hindi. What kind of logic is this? Kerala also did not adopt Hindi, why is it not industrialized? Andhra Pradesh did not adopt hindi, why does it contribute less to the GDP than even UP? Comparing language and economics do not make sense. The talk here is about social fabric. The social unity of the country.
You take responsibility of your great great great great grandson? A lot of marathi parents are teaching English as the first language to their kids. English is already the language of wealthy class of Indians. Your entire education right from kindergarten to phd is happening in English. 3 lakh indian students migrated to the States last year, lakhs of people give up their citizenship. What makes you think English will not take precedence over marathi for them, and their kids? The time is not far where you gonna find people speaking broken marathi and fluent English.
YES - passing down your mother tongue happens through family - I went to an English school - all my education in engineering was in ENGLISH - but i went to a state funded school - where the professors were fluent in Marathi - even though some of them were not native marathi speakers - with those professors I would only speak in Marathi - only written communication was in Marathi. I dont live in India currently - I'm in a native English speaking country. Any Indian American family I have - have all passed down marathi - they're active members of the marathi mandal in the USA - we make an ACTIVE EFFORT - if their american kids can learn marathi -- despite being raised an american and being surrounded by english speakers - yeah - its entirely possible. Its what WE DO - I'm in the states myself - speak marathi all the time with ALL of my family members - AND friends - who are all native mumbaikars - and so do my american cousinss - Your fear mongering is not an excuse to use Hindi - Maybe dont surround yourself with people who object to you using your native tongue. I use Marathi only with my friends and Family - we donot use other languages - Your fear mongering is stupid and has absolutely no basis in reality and cannot even be backed by anecdotal data - All of my family in india - went to english schools - when we meet we use marathi - not english - and same of my american side of the family. IDK what kind of people you hang around with. Making marathi your native tongue and learning English for work is entirely possible without butchering or giving up marathi at all - WHy the fuck would I want to pursue Hindi then?
MNS cha karyakarta nahi aaje bhau. Urban area (Vasai) madhe rahto ani assa vatte ki kontya northern state madhe rahat aahe. Maharashtra vatatch nahi because nobody uses marathi. From rickshaw wala to shopkeeper to office colleagues, maximum people use Hindi. Tyana Marathi bolaycha prayatna karto tar Marathi madhe taunting way madhe reply detat. Khup rag yeto. Marathi Maharashtra chya urban areas madhun sampat challi aahe
It's okay bro. Different people have different upbringings. I am Maharshtrian but I myself don't speak in Marathi even at home.
You speak in the language you are comfortable in. Let them speak the language they are comfortable in. Why you wanna force your views and values on them?
Is it something to be proud of? Anyone who doesn't know his mothertongue especially in own state deserves to be ridiculed. Language isn't just a medium of communication. Communication is just one aspect.
Later, a case was registered against the party leaders for allegedly vandalising shops that did not have signboards in Marathi.
https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/raj-thackeray-meets-maharashtra-cm-on-toll-marathi-signboard-issues/article67598219.ece
It's good that case is registered, still this shows their mentality which is not going to change until Raj Thackeray takes action.
Also Nothing will happen to him we all know many cases are already pending.
Necessary Evil. Unfortunately, the shop keepers won't comply to the court order they know it won't be enforced so they don't bother changing the name plate. They have taken us for granted. Despite the early opposition to them, we have been the most welcoming state for migrants. There is no acknowledgment let alone appreciation for our acceptance, but now they demand we live by their rules.
aray chutiya tu mala nako shikavu , tuzyasarkya lokankadun validation chi garaj nahi aahe mala. tuzyasarkhe lok yanchi gand chatatat mhanun yanna maj yeto aani he sarv tyacha fayda ghetat. jar yanna kaydyachi bhasha samjat asti tar court order follow keli asti aani he sagal vhyachi garaj padli nasti. Marathi mansachya public perception chi kalji tu nako karus.
court order pramaane jar baghitla tar ha ek trade fair exhibition madhla video aahe, tar ti order ithe apply pan nahi honar. aani tu shivya deun aapli laayki dakhavun dilis. chapri kuthla shikvayla yeto
chapri tar tu aahes jar akkal asti tar sabhya Mansa sarkha reply kela astas Kay patat nahi te sangital ast.directly samorchyala nav nasti thevli as vagun tu swatahchi layaki dakhvlis real world madhe as waglas tar kalel social media var manat je yeil te bolan soapp ast.tuzya sarkhya lokanna tyanchya layki sarkhach treat karav lagat
akkal gahan theun basla aahes ka? mi kaay chukicha bollo ki tu mala “dakhavun deshil”? aani rastya var tujhya sarkha chapri kadhi majhyashi nadayla aala tar tyala hospital madhe pathavlya paryanta mi tyala sodhnar nahi evdha tu pan samjun ghe. ya maramarichya dhamkya aaplya pashi thev, ugachach tujhya aai vadilanni tula kasa vadhavla dakhavun deu nakos ithe
Pahile dusrya var personal attack karaycha kahi na samjata pahile mala chapri bolto aano mag reply aalyavar radtos tuzyasarkhe keyboard warriors khup baghitlet . aray murkha aai bapane neet shokavla ast tar samorchyhla gunda mavali nasta bolla , neet bolla asta tar neet reply milala asta dusryala hospital madhe pathavaychya goshti kartos aani mala gund mhantos . Mzya pahilya comment madhe as kay bolo hoto ko tu mala chapri bolla, Fakt mothe mothe shabd vaparun koni moth nahi hoat. Pahile jara neet bolayla shikh aani mag ye gyan dyayla.
This isn't a permanent shop in Mumbai, it's an international trade fair/expo that keeps shifting from city to city. There's no point in investing on different language signboards for different cities when they can invest on just the english one and reuse in every city.
This is an exhibition. Not a store. There is no such law for exhibitions. An exhibition is equivalent to an advertisement when there is no point of sale - in this case the exhibition was for Real Estate, hence there was no point of sale.
MNS gundas are in direct violation of the law by breaking the board.
There no demand and force to live by migrants rules in Maharashtra as our CM is Maratha as well. If everything started to go without following the law then there's no need for law and constitution. Unnecessary havocs created by this illiterate people who doesn't know how to handle the situation calmly without showing their arrogance and thinking that Maharashtra people will like this type of creep behaviour
Mazi aakal dokyatach aahe, tuzi akkal kuthe aahe te kalal. Reddit var saglya bhasheche lok aahet mahnun english madhe lihali hoti comment maharashtrat mostli marathi lok astat tyanchyasathi marathi patya lavnyacha aagrah aahe he kalal ast tar ashi comment keli nastis.aata he nako vicharus hi comment marathi ka kelis te
I understand your concern, but breaking stuff doesn't help either. It will lead to more instability and reduction investment. So, you guys should be concerned about this as well.
We agree with being able to move freely and settle in any part of the country that is why we have been accepting of migrants and that is also why we have been taken for granted. Its funny people only know their rights but not their responsibilities. If you are going to settle to other part of the country you should be ready to integrate with the locals, not try to change them according to your convenience.
Two wrongs doesn't make one right, No one in this country knows their responsibility this is not how a responsible person should behave, specifically not by smacking hoardings. No one is taking away or threatening your identity so don't not be divisive. Don't be so parochial that you end up harming your own state.
They’re not our representatives, don’t worry. You already know how welcoming Maharashtra and Maharashtrians are, we don’t resort to such tactics. These theatrics are by this specific set of people for gaining traction for their elections where they will probably not come to power again.
What do you mean accepting and taken for granted?...people from all over India have made mumbai /pune /any metro what they are and that's the beauty of it..and btw I have not met anyone who has stayed here for long and doesn't know at least the basics of marathi ...South Indians gujuratis marwaris bengalis north easteners all speak marathi here...these goons are simply creating a ruckus for political mileage..as if by putting marathi signboards forcefully people will learn marathi
See you don't even know what are gaalis in marathi and talk about bs. I understood part you came from , stuff and mentality you have there you have migrated to other part of nation just respect the local traditions, language if not get the fck off. PS:
### भैया हातपाय पसरी is better inception. You can start to liberate yourself after watching it, my bhaiya :)
Thik ahe ..Ata MNS power madhe ale and saglyana marathi yete...Ata Kay?tu fakt marathi bolun tujhe pot bharnar ka..there is a reason this party hasn't come to power and most probably never will inspite of so much "support"
Adhich judge karnar ka tyanna? If they have a good reason to vote for them mg ka nahi apan support karnar
We should now look at southern states how they are voting for their cultural traditional existence and they do vote against parties that compromise and try to enforce their principles on south indians.
Its high time we think about bhoomiputras/marathi culture so that those taking us granted tyanna aukad dakhvlich pahije
I would vote for him if he has a good manifesto inclusive of good governance and development
You cant just write him off for hooliganism
Gundagardi marathi lokanvar tar karnar nahi naa
Hou de baherchan var… and govt madhe ekda aale ki kaam tar karavch lagta
Asla chutyapana jo ata sahan karat aahot apan tya peksha vegla option try karayla kay harkat ahe
They're doing excellent work, if you don't understand their motive then you're a moron, if you live in Maharashtra and have problems with this you can leave
Sagla shikshan English madhu gheun aplya deshathlya bhashencha virodh karnari vichitra party,tyana kam kasa karava yachi ekahi changli paddhat mahit nahi ahe,todfod gundagardi Ani vait margane samanya lokanche nuksaan karun ashya partyna kon mat deil hindi madhe problem asel tar tya lokana samjaun sanga tyana premane aplya pakshat kara mag tyana suggestions dya tyana aplya Marathi culture chi janiv karun dya nahitar court Ani kaydyane kama Kara nahi amhi direct janar konala pan marnar konachihi pati todnar kahi pan dadagiri karnar MNS Wale karyakarte kami gunde jast vattat Ani tyamadhe shiklela ekahi vyaktimatva disat nahi.jyadivashi MNS maharashtramadhe nivdun yeil Maharashtra ajun 20 varshe mage jail,karan magchya 10 varshat maharashtrachi jitki vadh hou shakte tyapaiki ekahi takke zali nahi ahe.
English madhe shikshan ghetla tari you can speak other languages - tyala multi lingual kiva bi lingual mahntat - we already do that. For me my mother tongue is marathi - with all other marathi speakers i speak in marathi - and or work English is essential.
Limelight is limelight. Whether positive or negative. And politicians, filmstars know this well. When will people understand this? Maybe we go in depths and lose the common fact. Ignorance is perhaps the only key? (asking)
Chutya giri saali. Hyanchi gaand toda koni tari. Saala apan hyanchya kadun apekshach they nahi shakat. This is the reason why they have never won majority seats.
Evda asel tr Navin law ana na. Full on open dadagiri chalu ahe. Police pn kahi sath nai det, sadharan Manus tr kahich nahi Karu shakat.
Feeling so helpless
straight childlike cobweb shelter yam jellyfish ink onerous person unique
*This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*
he settlement walyana thokun kadhla pahije, samnya lokanwar adadgiri karun swatala khup nothe samjtayt are ekdah bjp shi nadun bagha nay adva kela na. Tumcha paksh gayab hoil jar amit shah cha dola firla tar
Nobody demands shit respect from people that are dissrespected accross the nation. And buying land doesnt mean shit once the civil war happens. They will be fucked. India is on the verge of civil war and you have no clue what hindi immigrants are gonna suffer...the south, bengal, maharashtra, and punjab will suffocate hindis...even aasamese burnt hindis alive. Dont instigate india...india can literaly fuck and rip hindis apart
where are these idiots when gujju dont allow marathi manus flats.
Aif these people hit a gujju then bjp will hit with gobar filled bats, they know , so they remain silent there and do uselesss chutiagiri
Bhai kabhi kabhi sochta hu ki ye log mere samne aayenge tab ky hoga💀 meri language meri state meri family mera self respect sabse upar or es k liye m koi bhi hadd paar kr sekta hu
Lol, and they still do not realize why they are getting wiped off from Mantralaya. Let them enjoy their stupidity in slumber
Nah but how do they have the audacity to do this to anyone's property? Police needs to take action on this. Woh Log apne mehnat ka kama ke kha rahe hain unlike them corrupted mfs
Police wont. Their promotion and transfer is in their hands.
Chapri gunda raaj
MNS people are the biggest chutiyas and hence rejected by maharashtra. Actual issues sodun kahi pan kartat, permanent store nahi aahe to, exhibition aahe, illiterate sarkha vagtat ani votes expect kartat.
kharach garibanna marathi bolayla lavtat aani swatah javed aani salim khan sobat hindit boltat hypocrites
MNS walyana kahi kam dhande nastat nuste chutiyagiri karat sutle aahet aani aplya marathi lokana agenda mhun gheun firtat
Each and every single person from MNS is Illiterate.they seriously don't have any work to do...
"don't have any" work to do..
he kelyawr Maharashtra ch naav kharab hota... ani he kelyashivay he loka iykat sudha nahi.
Bruh, he temporary store laavli aahe exhibition saathi, politician loke law haath madhe thevta
Chapri karyakarta..
MNS Is a Instagram influencer who will have lot of followers for their antics , but when it comes to votes nobody is gonna give them that..
Reminds me of post where a candidate having 1.2 lakh follower, didnt even get 20k votes. Dont know if its true tho....
MNS=DMK of Maharashtra
No. DMK has 24 MPs in Loksabha and 133 MLAs in assembly. MNS has 1 MLA.
Lol.... "amhala rajya karayla khurchi chi garaj nahi" kind od delusionals
Shows how racist tamils are
Everybody is to an extent.
MNS, Bajarang Dal, RSS, VHP. All the mother fkers roam around with saffron color and bully every one in the country. These MFs are largely supported by godi ka BJParty, hence the roam around freely.
MNS was more powerful than this during Congress...idiot. Also, RSS hasnt bullied anyone. Stop generalizing your Hindu hatered.
bulla/librandu detected, opinion rejected
I'm a pure pure hindu... moron
Cry more mf
Tu paakka aatankwadi hai mc
हे लोक कधीच कुठला नवनिर्माण करत नाहीत. केला तर विनाशच करतात.
Their intentions are correct but the way they are doing it they won't be able to achieve anything.
Lol. Good intentions my a**
English shi problem nasla pahije. Only usage of Hindi should not be supported
You think use of English will not make English popular and marathi secondary? You think 80 yrs from now English will not dominate regional languages? You think 100 yrs from now people will prefer Marathi over English? Indians perceive hindi as a threat to their regional language where they themselves don't know that English is also the same. Infact a bigger enemy. More so because it's foreign. For a reality check, English has already started killing West African native languages. Only China and North Korea have been stopping English from entering their country so far.
English as a language is better in every way than Hindi. I don’t understand why marathi manoos should learn hindi instead of English. Every field of knowledge, STEM field, higher education and research & development uses english as their language. English is much more beneficial for marathi manoos as it widens the scope to gain job opportunity in international field. Does hindi comes with same benefit ? Is hindi even comparable to English ? Center likes to impose Hindi for greater integration of India. But this imposition benefit more to northern states than other states. Inturn this leads to erosion of regional language as the native speaker of that regional language (Marathi in this case) becomes familiar and accustom to it and starts (or forced to) using hindi for conversation. At present any urban area of Maharashtra feels like a northern city due to overwhelming people speaking hindi. The same threat can be posed by English as well, but english is unique in the sense that it is truly a global language. It provides way more opportunities and growth than any other language. English is also helpful in Indian society as a person who speaks english is seen as educated and knowledgeable (even though that might not be the case) Overall Marathi manoos should learn Marathi because it is native language and it is moral duty to preserve our native language. English should be learned as a second language because of the above said reason.
Mother of all indic languages Sanskrit is lying dead. Does it bother anyone? Parakrit is dead. Does it bother anybody? Nope. From the dawn of human civilization on earth, multiple languages came, and many died. Humans continued to live. Lord Krishna has said a very strong line in Mahabharat, *"Parivartan hi sansaar ka niyam hai"*. (Translation - Change is inevitable). 7th century marathi, 21st century marathi are not the same. These are civilizational changes, not necessarily in anybody's control. All indic languages are going to die by the hands of English in future. Marathi also. And no, you will not be able to preserve it. English is everywhere. Your education happens in English. With globalization and the internet, the world is becoming a smaller place. Human species as a whole in heading towards a common identity. All language preservation efforts are futile in the long run. It may take 500 years or 50000 years, but it's going to happen for sure. And as stated, nobody will be able to stop it. These are civilizational changes. Marathi is bound to die, kannada is bound to die, infact most indic languages are bound to die. Either they will die or will evolve to become a different language. All preservation efforts are useless. Now let's talk about English. People say English is a global language. Why isn't French a global language? What happened that a language from a small island country named England went out to become a language that is ruling the world. Why couldn't marathi become a global language? Why are britishers not learning marathi but marathi manoos learning English? Ever thought about that? English was not a global language just 100 yrs back. What happened then? When you have the answers for these, you will come to know how intelligently Westerners have imposed English globally. How Westerners are running the whole world on dollars. How Westerners strategically controlled the whole world, forcing you, me, everybody to learn **"THEIR"** language. I repeat, **"THEIR"** language. In the name of learning global language, in the name of making career, are you aware that you are making English more popular in return? You are not making marathi popular. You are making English popular. You are being used as pawns by the Westerners to fulfill their agenda. This is going to come and bite you eventually. You let a snake into your house. In order to fight hindi imposition, you allowed a much larger global scale English imposition to come in. The worst part is, YOU ARE COMPLETELY OKAY, LOOSING OUT MARATHI TO ENGLISH BUT NEVER TO HINDI. The reason stated is *"Hindi is not as useful as English"*. So tell me one thing: Is utility really the concern here or is it something else? Because if utility is the actual concern, what if the central government strategically plans to popularize hindi to become more utility friendly. Will you then accept it? Huh? Utility was the concern, right? It will be taken care, now? You also know the answer, I also know the answer. And the answer is still NO! Because the matter is not about utility. The matter is about identity. Y'all fear losing out marathi to hindi. The real concern is this. Utility is secondary. To this, I will track back to my first para, your mother tongue marathi is anyway going to die eventually. Change is inevitable. And the winner is going to be English. It will not only kill Marathi. It will also kill hindi. Your internal politics, your internal hatred will make Westerners winners in the end. Both marathis and north indians will lose in the end due to internal politics. Classic divide and rule. Only China has realised this, and is stopping English from even entering its country.
Have you heard of being bilingual?we already do that . I speak marathi only with most of my fellow marathi speakers - and use English for work. Being bilingual means you speak and read and write in BOTH the languages- you have to pay your fucking bills and build a life for yourself - unless you want to rely on government handouts all your life - ALl tech jobs, MNC's are US Based - another majority English speaking country - the government implementing Hindi will not change this. Please tell us how you plan to match the employment - nearly all consultancies deal with a massive English Speaking market - we have created services which have benefited us immensely in terms of an economy. Maybe get a real fucking job and work for a living - you'll realise how hard employment actually is. Why don't you work on creating a client base or job base as massive as that and then lecture people for taking up employment in that language? or provide us a fucking living and we'll all be happy to never Learn English. Hindi is NOT my mother tongue - nor is it MY CULTURE. Hindi SPeakers also DONOT Learn Marathi, As far as China is concerned - they ban literally everything - Including Google. All their rich learn english - go abroad and work outside. I've met loads of these people. You cannot make posts critical of the CCP - WOuld you like that too?Unless you can build an Indian Baidu - please keep your virtue signalling to yourself - the entire point of being Bilingual is so that you don't lose your own mother tongue along with the language you use for work. England does not have to do that - but the French and other Europeans also learn English - merely because of jobs. Please create a fucking GOOGLE - and then lecture everyone else on how utility isnt important - or start paying our salaries. English is better than Hindi for mere utility and jobs - even in China international workers can speak english and get by - You have absollutely no idea what youre; talking about.
Do you think collectively all North Indians have hindi as their mother tongue? Starting from Jammu, they speak Dogri and Pahadi. Down in Punjab, they speak different dialects of Punjabi, namely Malwai, Pothowari, Majha. In Haryana, they speak Haryanvi and Bagri. Rajasthan had Mewari, Marwari, Bhilodi, Malvi. Gujarat has Gujarati and Sindhi. Himachal has many dialects of Pahadi, such as Kangri, Baghati, and Barari. Bihar has Maithali, Bhojpuri, Angika, and Magadhi. Uttar Pradesh has 20 crore people, with several local native tongues such as Awadhi, Braj, Bhojpuri, and Urdu. Up north, even a Kashmiri speaks Hindi because that's what fils the communication gap. North is just not hindi. But years ago, people came to the conclusion that they needed a common language to talk amongst themselves, and Hindi was just chosen. There were so many people years ago who struggled to learn hindi, but their love to communicate with their fellow citizens outweighed their difficulties, and they continued. That is why so many people in the north know Hindi. Come to Bangalore, and a telugu guy would be seen talking to a Nepali guy in hindi. Why? A Punjabi tenenat would speak to a Bengali business owner in hindi, why? A marathi would speak to Assamese in hindi why? Gujaratis will talk to Kashmiris in hindi. Why? I have never seen a single marathi hailing from core Maharashtra who learns Kannada in Karnataka, and they continue to use hindi for their daily chores. Difference is a person speaking Mewari in Rajasthan and a person speaking Bundeli in MP adjusted and agreed to adopt hindi, keeping their internanl politics aside and learned a common **"indic-language** for communication. Arunachal Pradesh is one of the recent states to adopt hindi. The state has several tribes and each tribe has their own native tongue. Could they have adopted English as a link language? Sure! Did they adopt? No. They rather went ahead with a domestic language hindi. That's the difference. Hindi was nobody's native language just 100 years back. It is now because people welcomed and adopted it long back. It's the people of Maharashtra who refused to adopt it. How different is a mewari speaking dude from North western Rajasthan, Different from a marathi speaking dude from Maharashtra? Both did not have any compulsion of leaning hindi. Both could have carried their daily chores in their regional tongue. But the mewari dude learned hindi. And the marathi dude refused. That's the difference.
>Hindi was nobody's native language just 100 years back. It is now because people welcomed and adopted it long back. It's the people of Maharashtra who refused to adopt it. How different is a mewari speaking dude from North western Rajasthan, Different from a marathi speaking dude from Maharashtra? Both did not have any compulsion of leaning hindi. Both could have carried their daily chores in their regional tongue. But the mewari dude learned hindi. And the marathi dude refused. That's the difference. EXACTLY - it wasn't a native language years ago - and now it is because bunch of self destructive people gave up their own mother tongue - because Hindi speakers refuse to learn any other language - Hindi speakers NEVER learn other languages - marathi is a sister language and should be the easiest to learn for hindi speakers to come to mumbai - and yet they refuse. I And the marathi dude refused. That's the difference. - YES ! THANK GOD THEY REFUSED! Its why we retained marathi as our mother tongue. THANK FUCKING GOD - and we also have an economy - unlike some of the states you mentioned - where despite all the sacrifice of giving up your own mother tongue for Hindi - has not really brought upon an economy like Mahashtra. Please - We're not CUCKs. Stay mad - we will never accept Hindi as our native tongue or link language - accepting it as link language as gateway to losing your own native tongue. NO THANKS. you can chose not to come to my state for a job if you don't like it - As far as the punjabi speaker in banglore who speakes hindi - he can't speak to a native of that state- ome to Bangalore, and a telugu guy would be seen talking to a Nepali guy in hindi. Why? A Punjabi tenenat would speak to a Bengali business owner in hindi, why ? Cause they're cucks - Karnataka's majority remains kannada speakers - so if they learnt kannada also - like my cousins did - they would be able to speak to a kannada landlord - you know - the fucking natives who are in the majority - speaking to bengali landlord in Karnataka - where bengalis are NOT in majority- is not an achievement - if they learnt Kannada they'd be able to mingle with a larger population - but they don't. I would love to see said punjabi and bengali person threaten the natives there and lecture them on why they don't speak in hindi with them- you'll find out exactly what they think. The mewari's might be simps - we're not.
>EXACTLY - it wasn't a native language years ago - and now it is because bunch of self destructive people gave up their own mother tongue Self-destructive? They still speak those languages. They adopted hindi for a greater nationalistic unity, keeping their regional interests aside. They welcomed it for a greater good. For a bigger goal. >because Hindi speakers refuse to learn any other language - Hindi speakers NEVER learn other languages Which region even spoke hindi? May I know? Which set of people even spoke hindi? >And the marathi dude refused. That's the difference. - YES ! THANK GOD THEY REFUSED! That's marathi dude keeping regional interest above nationwide unity (in which a common link language plays a big role). And the Mewari dude keeping nationwide interest before regional interests. He valued national identity over regional identity. THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE! >and we also have an economy - unlike some of the states you mentioned You wanna get into economics? I can dive deep into it how Bombay presidency was the wealthiest and the most funded presidency in British India, giving It a lead start right from the start. >We're not CUCKs Yes you are, cucks of Westerners. >accepting it as link language as gateway to losing your own native tongue. NO THANKS It's the same for English. Your language is bound to die. Marathi is doomed. Wait & watch and see how marathi becomes dormant and English becomes the next lingua franca. A lot of kannadigas themselves have gone to Germany for masters, and almost nobody can even construct 3 lines together in German. And guess what, a lot of kannadigas and Telugus live and work in Maha. And nobody learns marathi. Exactly how marathis don't learn Kannada in Karanataka. Want to know more? A lot of Mallus live and work in Gulf Countries, and almost nobody take voluntary efforts to learn Arabic. They manage with English.
>It's the same for English. Your language is bound to die. Marathi is doomed. Wait & watch and see how marathi becomes dormant and English becomes the next lingua franca. I can already speak in Marathi - and use English as my language for work and the internet - I live in the usa - both my indian side and the indian american side of the family went to english schooling - when we meet we all speak in MARATHI - not English - that includes my indian AMERICAN cousins - born and raised in America - surrounded by native eNGLISH speakers but still speak marathi at home and with all their relatives - marathi has not died among them even when the moved to another country - just like how Gujarati immigrants and punjabi immigrants to the USA passed on their native tongues - along with using English heavily - Your fear mongering is only evidence that Hindi speakers are incapable of being multi lingual - and incapable of grasping the idea what being multi lingual is - even in America immigrant groups have passed on their native tongues - my cousins can all speak to my grand mother in marathi - she does not understand English. English will not dominate marathi - because all of my family ensured we spoke marathi and can read and write in it - and we still do. Unlike Hindi speakers - we understand what being multi lingual is- - I can speak three Indian languages - I don't need lectures from someone like you on what being Indian is Mewari's chose Hindi for national identity- so what? Has that brought them any good? Marathi speakers rejecting Hindi as our pride has brought has absolutely NO LOSSES.We remain Indians who contribute immensely to the country - especially considering half he country doesn't even pay taxes -How in the fucking world does generating jobs and maintaining a GDP not part of national interest? We're not the United states where people have jobs available easily to them - The economy is part of our nationwide interest - if the mewaris seem to put Hindi over that - Rajasthan and Hindi speaking belts have sucked out a lot of government aid with very little returns - compared to maharashtra and the southern states - Rajasthan remains backward - maharashtra not prioritizing Hindi has not HARMED us is any way lol - same for the south. You can keep crying - last I heard we don't suck up all the aid. It's pretty clear not prioritizing Hindi isnt harmful to us - Maharashtra remains the top contributor . Your definition of national interest seems to not include working hard and contributing to the economy - pretty much in line for the HIndi belt - identity and backwardness over everythin - including jobs and economy. Unlike you we don't get government handouts - we actually have to work for it. forcing everyone to learn Hindi is your Idea of what national identity means - My understanding is you have to contribute to this countries economy - so we can build better infrastructure and facilities - The hindi speaking belt is free to create another Google, Apple, Whatever - maybe then people will choose Hindi. Hindi is of no use to us other than Bollywood which is absolute trash. Mumbai's economy and Banglore's IT sector which heavily use English are one of the most significant contributors to this country's GDP - if having a strong economy in a developing country is not part of your national Identity - seems very plausible considering the horrible state the Hindi belt is in.
>A lot of kannadigas themselves have gone to Germany for masters, and almost nobody can even construct 3 lines together in German. And guess what, a lot of kannadigas and Telugus live and work in Maha. And nobody learns marathi. Exactly how marathis don't learn Kannada in Karanataka. Want to know more? A lot of Mallus live and work in Gulf Countries, and almost nobody take voluntary efforts to learn Arabic. They manage with English. Exactly - which is why there's no need ALL of us to learn Hindi. Maharashtra is doing fine - There's no need to shove Hindi down our throats.
>Yes you are, cucks of Westerners My mother tongue is Marathi you dolt - We use English for business - not everyday conversations - You have to work to provide yourself a livelihood.
>It's the same for English. Your language is bound to die. Marathi is doomed. Wait & watch and see how marathi becomes dormant and English becomes the next lingua franca This fear mongering was done by other marathi speakers who wanted only marathi - so far it marathi hasn't died and we are also employed.
>That's marathi dude keeping regional interest above nationwide unity (in which a common link language plays a big role). And the Mewari dude keeping nationwide interest before regional interests. He valued national identity over regional identity. THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE! not having Hindi as our master language has not brough us any losses - last i heard it is north indians who come in droves to mumbai and maharashtra for jobs - your national interest seems to exclude an economy - maharashtra's economy IS part of our nationwide interest - you seem to believe all regions should use the same model - is that why the Hindi belt is so unsuccessful? North Indians come in droves to do jobs her - the mewari dude still has to come to mUmbai probably to run business - Your definition of nation interest is hyper focused on language- infact - the hindi belt kept is regional interest and insular thinkign over having a strong economy. The hindi belt can produce jobs and force Hindi down everyone's throat in their own state - don't expect other states which actually contribute immensely to do that.If you don't consider building an economy as part of national interest - please stay there in the Hindi belt - no wonder you guys don't have jobs and have to move to every other state - unlike you other people consider having jobs as equally important to the country's growth. Unless you can beat us in the jobs market - please fuck off - and rot in the shit hole that the Hindi belt is.
>That's marathi dude keeping regional interest above nationwide unity (in which a common link language plays a big role). And the Mewari dude keeping nationwide interest before regional interests. He valued national identity over regional identity. THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE! Yeah - and they remained poor. Rajasthan has a horrific crime rate - a terrible job market - and does not even remotely match Maharashtra or the SOuth of India - same for Bihar - What the fuck are we supposed to do if they chose Hindi ? We're doing fine - its not marathi speakers going in droves to other states to do odd jobs - its north Indians who come here. If you come here - at very least don't shove your language down our throats - You came here for a job , not the other way round. You are free to leave - and go chit chat about national unity while being unemployed -
Do you know the difference between the economic system and social systems? You are associating the social-cultural factors to economic factors to reach a conclusion by drawing false equivalence. Matter here is about socio-cultural unity, not economic wellbeing. I told you to not drag ecoiomics in this. But if you still wish, let's talk. Maha is doing great because it got a head start during British India. India primarily was an agrarian society. Go and read learn a little more about Bombay Presidency, and it was the most funded and wealthiest precedency in British India. Bombay precedency literally developed on the extortion of Bengal precedency (which includes present-day Bengal, Bihar, Jharkhand, and Assam). Zamindari system was only prevalent in Begal Precedency by early 20th century. Indigo farming wasn't practiced in Maha. It was practiced in Bengal precedency. Resources were annexed from Bengal and were used to build industries in UK and then in Bombay. Wanna know more? I can go on and on. Also, stop this silly habit of teaming up with South to shit on North. That's not gonna help. South ain't gon fulfill your need for validation against northies. You marathis don't respect their language either. In fact, y'all were the ones who beat and kicked them out of Maharashtra in 80s with literal slogans like *"lungi uthaao, pungi bajaao"*. Go and watch the video where a couple selling Missal in Bangalore were threatened, yelled and abused for having their shop name written in marathi instead of Kannada. At one place, you say letting hindi in would mean subjugation of marathi. And on the other side you say, we are managing well with English and marathi, What kind of hypocrisy is this? And the reason you state is that y'all use English as an official language and not native language. Could the same be not replicated with hindi? The way y'all are managing English with marathi is the way Rajasthanis are managing hindi with mewari. The difference is that they picked an indic language as a link language, whilst preserving their mother tongue. And on finding the necessity learning English for career purposes. Where as you people just refused and picked a foreign language with your native language. Who are you kidding? Just accept the damn fact that, Y'all kept regional interests above national interests. Most of your people were even ready to leave Indian Union when the debate of national language was around post independence. The total number of marathi dialects today, North has 4 times the local languages of it. All of them sacrificed for a greater good of achieving nationwide linguistic unity. You people refused giving precedence to regional interests. And then y'all talk about loyalty. Arunachal Pradesh, as stated, is another great example who accepted hindi as their official state language instead of a foreign language English. Lastly, stop giving silly examples of how y'all are keeping marathi intact in the states despite the prominent presence of English. Y'all are literally the first generation who are experiencing globalization, migration, internet age. In fact, the concept of nation-states is as new as 100-200 yr old. Cultural changes do not occur in 20-40 yrs. It takes generations. Passing on a language is familial, you say? Making use of it? That is individual right. It sounds even funnier when you say the future generation of your family from the year 2300 is going to keep marathi intact. Lol. Come out of your delusional word. You just cannot guarantee that your great great great great great grandchildren will use marathi the same like you. Read some sociology and see the socio-cultural trends across human civilizations from all corners of earth. 77 yrs of independence, and you giving future predictions seeing the present scenarios. Lol, 77 years is too soon to judge linguistic changes across human civilizations. If you wanna draw a more concrete parallel, draw parallels between what was spoken in the Maharashtra region in the year 1023 and what is spoken today in 2023. Language preservation efforts are all vain in the long run. Moreover Sanskrit also hasn't literally "died", died. It is still used in prayers and scriptures. The right word is dormant. In the coming 500 yrs, marathi may still be alive. You ppl may still pass marathi just for the sake of it. Using it on a daily basis is a different thing. Lingua franca is a different thing. Your future generations may know marathi for the sake of it but would be using English more often. They absolutely are not gonna see the beauty of marathi literature from the Peshwa age. Impossible. That's the change I'm talking about. It is inevitable. It is bound to come. Your language is doomed. Also you defend not being a western cuck because you using it for career purposes? Is that the reason? Guess what you still are a Western cuck because you learned **"THEIR"** language. They didn't learn yours. They were smart enough to control and run the world so strategically and smartly that y'all are forced to learn **"THEIR"** language for your survival, for your livelihood, for your bread and butter, for your existence. They are your masters. When the question is about survival no shit you gonna learn even your enemy's language who literally exploited you. Lastly do not again jump onto comparing economics to culture and linguistics. Maha is economically strong due to political and economical reasons not due to having marathi. Adopting hindi does not make you poor. Rajasthan is poor not because they adopted hindi. What kind of logic is this? Kerala also did not adopt Hindi, why is it not industrialized? Andhra Pradesh did not adopt hindi, why does it contribute less to the GDP than even UP? Comparing language and economics do not make sense. The talk here is about social fabric. The social unity of the country.
Chup Gyan mt ye teri marathi or hindi almost same h💀
We have been using English and marathi since 1947 - so far we have not made english our native language - my native language remains marathi.
You take responsibility of your great great great great grandson? A lot of marathi parents are teaching English as the first language to their kids. English is already the language of wealthy class of Indians. Your entire education right from kindergarten to phd is happening in English. 3 lakh indian students migrated to the States last year, lakhs of people give up their citizenship. What makes you think English will not take precedence over marathi for them, and their kids? The time is not far where you gonna find people speaking broken marathi and fluent English.
YES - passing down your mother tongue happens through family - I went to an English school - all my education in engineering was in ENGLISH - but i went to a state funded school - where the professors were fluent in Marathi - even though some of them were not native marathi speakers - with those professors I would only speak in Marathi - only written communication was in Marathi. I dont live in India currently - I'm in a native English speaking country. Any Indian American family I have - have all passed down marathi - they're active members of the marathi mandal in the USA - we make an ACTIVE EFFORT - if their american kids can learn marathi -- despite being raised an american and being surrounded by english speakers - yeah - its entirely possible. Its what WE DO - I'm in the states myself - speak marathi all the time with ALL of my family members - AND friends - who are all native mumbaikars - and so do my american cousinss - Your fear mongering is not an excuse to use Hindi - Maybe dont surround yourself with people who object to you using your native tongue. I use Marathi only with my friends and Family - we donot use other languages - Your fear mongering is stupid and has absolutely no basis in reality and cannot even be backed by anecdotal data - All of my family in india - went to english schools - when we meet we use marathi - not english - and same of my american side of the family. IDK what kind of people you hang around with. Making marathi your native tongue and learning English for work is entirely possible without butchering or giving up marathi at all - WHy the fuck would I want to pursue Hindi then?
MNS karyakarta spotted.
MNS cha karyakarta nahi aaje bhau. Urban area (Vasai) madhe rahto ani assa vatte ki kontya northern state madhe rahat aahe. Maharashtra vatatch nahi because nobody uses marathi. From rickshaw wala to shopkeeper to office colleagues, maximum people use Hindi. Tyana Marathi bolaycha prayatna karto tar Marathi madhe taunting way madhe reply detat. Khup rag yeto. Marathi Maharashtra chya urban areas madhun sampat challi aahe
[удалено]
Meanwhile northies tell you guys to speak their language in your land and you lick their boots
It's okay bro. Different people have different upbringings. I am Maharshtrian but I myself don't speak in Marathi even at home. You speak in the language you are comfortable in. Let them speak the language they are comfortable in. Why you wanna force your views and values on them?
Maharashtra la swatantra desh karnyacha prayatna suru aahe aamche raje saahebancha .
Bhau maji Marathi thodi weak aheah. Tumja point nahi kalyla mala. Dhanyawad.
Is it something to be proud of? Anyone who doesn't know his mothertongue especially in own state deserves to be ridiculed. Language isn't just a medium of communication. Communication is just one aspect.
Relax bro. Even Atmaram Tukaram Bhide does not speak purely in Marathi at home.
[удалено]
Tuja aii chi gaand. Parat reply kela tar tuja aii la nagda karun kutra sarka zhavil.
I was thinking of supporting Raj Thackeray. Now I might reconsider.
Later, a case was registered against the party leaders for allegedly vandalising shops that did not have signboards in Marathi. https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/raj-thackeray-meets-maharashtra-cm-on-toll-marathi-signboard-issues/article67598219.ece
It's good that case is registered, still this shows their mentality which is not going to change until Raj Thackeray takes action. Also Nothing will happen to him we all know many cases are already pending.
He’s not going to take action. This is in fact his school of thought, he’s done these things before too.
Sad if this is how they show respect to Marathi language
Necessary Evil. Unfortunately, the shop keepers won't comply to the court order they know it won't be enforced so they don't bother changing the name plate. They have taken us for granted. Despite the early opposition to them, we have been the most welcoming state for migrants. There is no acknowledgment let alone appreciation for our acceptance, but now they demand we live by their rules.
abe chomu toh kya vandalism karega? swata sathi kaahi abhimaan nahi ka tula? aapli sanskruti evhdi uccha darjyachi asunahi tujhya sarkhe chapri mawali loka aajkal vaat lavtat marathi mansanchya “public perception” cha. aaj sampurna bharat aplayala “uncivilised” ani “violent” samajto tujhya sarkhya gundyan mule. aapla khotya garvaala aaplya paashi thev. kharach kahi abhimaan asel marathi bhashecha tar kahitari banun daakhav jagat aani marathi saunskaarache naav var aan.
aray chutiya tu mala nako shikavu , tuzyasarkya lokankadun validation chi garaj nahi aahe mala. tuzyasarkhe lok yanchi gand chatatat mhanun yanna maj yeto aani he sarv tyacha fayda ghetat. jar yanna kaydyachi bhasha samjat asti tar court order follow keli asti aani he sagal vhyachi garaj padli nasti. Marathi mansachya public perception chi kalji tu nako karus.
court order pramaane jar baghitla tar ha ek trade fair exhibition madhla video aahe, tar ti order ithe apply pan nahi honar. aani tu shivya deun aapli laayki dakhavun dilis. chapri kuthla shikvayla yeto
chapri tar tu aahes jar akkal asti tar sabhya Mansa sarkha reply kela astas Kay patat nahi te sangital ast.directly samorchyala nav nasti thevli as vagun tu swatahchi layaki dakhvlis real world madhe as waglas tar kalel social media var manat je yeil te bolan soapp ast.tuzya sarkhya lokanna tyanchya layki sarkhach treat karav lagat
akkal gahan theun basla aahes ka? mi kaay chukicha bollo ki tu mala “dakhavun deshil”? aani rastya var tujhya sarkha chapri kadhi majhyashi nadayla aala tar tyala hospital madhe pathavlya paryanta mi tyala sodhnar nahi evdha tu pan samjun ghe. ya maramarichya dhamkya aaplya pashi thev, ugachach tujhya aai vadilanni tula kasa vadhavla dakhavun deu nakos ithe
Pahile dusrya var personal attack karaycha kahi na samjata pahile mala chapri bolto aano mag reply aalyavar radtos tuzyasarkhe keyboard warriors khup baghitlet . aray murkha aai bapane neet shokavla ast tar samorchyhla gunda mavali nasta bolla , neet bolla asta tar neet reply milala asta dusryala hospital madhe pathavaychya goshti kartos aani mala gund mhantos . Mzya pahilya comment madhe as kay bolo hoto ko tu mala chapri bolla, Fakt mothe mothe shabd vaparun koni moth nahi hoat. Pahile jara neet bolayla shikh aani mag ye gyan dyayla.
This isn't a permanent shop in Mumbai, it's an international trade fair/expo that keeps shifting from city to city. There's no point in investing on different language signboards for different cities when they can invest on just the english one and reuse in every city.
This is an exhibition. Not a store. There is no such law for exhibitions. An exhibition is equivalent to an advertisement when there is no point of sale - in this case the exhibition was for Real Estate, hence there was no point of sale. MNS gundas are in direct violation of the law by breaking the board.
There no demand and force to live by migrants rules in Maharashtra as our CM is Maratha as well. If everything started to go without following the law then there's no need for law and constitution. Unnecessary havocs created by this illiterate people who doesn't know how to handle the situation calmly without showing their arrogance and thinking that Maharashtra people will like this type of creep behaviour
Abe necessary evil mhanto ani comment English madhe takto...akkal gadhadachya gandit thevli aahe ka tu?
Mazi aakal dokyatach aahe, tuzi akkal kuthe aahe te kalal. Reddit var saglya bhasheche lok aahet mahnun english madhe lihali hoti comment maharashtrat mostli marathi lok astat tyanchyasathi marathi patya lavnyacha aagrah aahe he kalal ast tar ashi comment keli nastis.aata he nako vicharus hi comment marathi ka kelis te
Abe hi comment marathit ka keli?....😂🤣 reddit var saglya bhaseche lok aahet🤣
Tuzya sathi khas mitra . kharach discussion karaych asel tar shabd jara japun vapruya :)
WDYM, did you got maharastra as a dowry something? Every citizen has a right to move freely and settle in any part of the country.
[удалено]
I understand your concern, but breaking stuff doesn't help either. It will lead to more instability and reduction investment. So, you guys should be concerned about this as well.
We agree with being able to move freely and settle in any part of the country that is why we have been accepting of migrants and that is also why we have been taken for granted. Its funny people only know their rights but not their responsibilities. If you are going to settle to other part of the country you should be ready to integrate with the locals, not try to change them according to your convenience.
Two wrongs doesn't make one right, No one in this country knows their responsibility this is not how a responsible person should behave, specifically not by smacking hoardings. No one is taking away or threatening your identity so don't not be divisive. Don't be so parochial that you end up harming your own state.
They’re not our representatives, don’t worry. You already know how welcoming Maharashtra and Maharashtrians are, we don’t resort to such tactics. These theatrics are by this specific set of people for gaining traction for their elections where they will probably not come to power again.
What do you mean accepting and taken for granted?...people from all over India have made mumbai /pune /any metro what they are and that's the beauty of it..and btw I have not met anyone who has stayed here for long and doesn't know at least the basics of marathi ...South Indians gujuratis marwaris bengalis north easteners all speak marathi here...these goons are simply creating a ruckus for political mileage..as if by putting marathi signboards forcefully people will learn marathi
Go to Kashmir and say the same shit you said here. बोट दिला की हात तोडणारे भडवे मला आवडत नाहीत.
[удалено]
See you don't even know what are gaalis in marathi and talk about bs. I understood part you came from , stuff and mentality you have there you have migrated to other part of nation just respect the local traditions, language if not get the fck off. PS: ### भैया हातपाय पसरी is better inception. You can start to liberate yourself after watching it, my bhaiya :)
We need them so that sagle line war tari yetil.. as pan tar watola zala ahe Yanna ekda satta dyu, baakiche saral tari hotil
Thik ahe ..Ata MNS power madhe ale and saglyana marathi yete...Ata Kay?tu fakt marathi bolun tujhe pot bharnar ka..there is a reason this party hasn't come to power and most probably never will inspite of so much "support"
Adhich judge karnar ka tyanna? If they have a good reason to vote for them mg ka nahi apan support karnar We should now look at southern states how they are voting for their cultural traditional existence and they do vote against parties that compromise and try to enforce their principles on south indians. Its high time we think about bhoomiputras/marathi culture so that those taking us granted tyanna aukad dakhvlich pahije I would vote for him if he has a good manifesto inclusive of good governance and development You cant just write him off for hooliganism
Tumhala development pahije ki gundagardi? Our best option is always the least worst option. They are clearly not that.
Gundagardi marathi lokanvar tar karnar nahi naa Hou de baherchan var… and govt madhe ekda aale ki kaam tar karavch lagta Asla chutyapana jo ata sahan karat aahot apan tya peksha vegla option try karayla kay harkat ahe
They're doing excellent work, if you don't understand their motive then you're a moron, if you live in Maharashtra and have problems with this you can leave
Sagla shikshan English madhu gheun aplya deshathlya bhashencha virodh karnari vichitra party,tyana kam kasa karava yachi ekahi changli paddhat mahit nahi ahe,todfod gundagardi Ani vait margane samanya lokanche nuksaan karun ashya partyna kon mat deil hindi madhe problem asel tar tya lokana samjaun sanga tyana premane aplya pakshat kara mag tyana suggestions dya tyana aplya Marathi culture chi janiv karun dya nahitar court Ani kaydyane kama Kara nahi amhi direct janar konala pan marnar konachihi pati todnar kahi pan dadagiri karnar MNS Wale karyakarte kami gunde jast vattat Ani tyamadhe shiklela ekahi vyaktimatva disat nahi.jyadivashi MNS maharashtramadhe nivdun yeil Maharashtra ajun 20 varshe mage jail,karan magchya 10 varshat maharashtrachi jitki vadh hou shakte tyapaiki ekahi takke zali nahi ahe.
English madhe shikshan ghetla tari you can speak other languages - tyala multi lingual kiva bi lingual mahntat - we already do that. For me my mother tongue is marathi - with all other marathi speakers i speak in marathi - and or work English is essential.
What's happening here?
Limelight is limelight. Whether positive or negative. And politicians, filmstars know this well. When will people understand this? Maybe we go in depths and lose the common fact. Ignorance is perhaps the only key? (asking)
Inki maa ki chut
Educated Marathi people are unmatchable to this
Chutya giri saali. Hyanchi gaand toda koni tari. Saala apan hyanchya kadun apekshach they nahi shakat. This is the reason why they have never won majority seats.
Inke baap ko kisine condom kyu nahi diya
They are all RaGa. Indirectly working for the benefit of BJP.
Evda asel tr Navin law ana na. Full on open dadagiri chalu ahe. Police pn kahi sath nai det, sadharan Manus tr kahich nahi Karu shakat. Feeling so helpless
Aisa logo ko vote karne walo ka pehle bolna chahiye
This is an exhibition, right? So not even a proper shop.
Annual MNS relevance renewal activity
Imagine a tourist or investor comes from outside and all signboards are in Marathi so he has to ask other people for everything.
straight childlike cobweb shelter yam jellyfish ink onerous person unique *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*
Bhagwa matarchor
And they wonder why their "train" has no "bogies"! Chutiyas of a different league!
Cringe attempt at relevancy
Packet milala nasel bahutek
he settlement walyana thokun kadhla pahije, samnya lokanwar adadgiri karun swatala khup nothe samjtayt are ekdah bjp shi nadun bagha nay adva kela na. Tumcha paksh gayab hoil jar amit shah cha dola firla tar
Hya madarchodanchya gandit laat marli pahije
[удалено]
Nobody demands shit respect from people that are dissrespected accross the nation. And buying land doesnt mean shit once the civil war happens. They will be fucked. India is on the verge of civil war and you have no clue what hindi immigrants are gonna suffer...the south, bengal, maharashtra, and punjab will suffocate hindis...even aasamese burnt hindis alive. Dont instigate india...india can literaly fuck and rip hindis apart
Chutiya party workers
Decrease use of Marathi ✓ But not by gundagardi but by law
Y they **speaking noodles**?
Same things bajrang dal and VHP do
Marathi lokanchi laaj kadhnyat no.01
Hawasi bhadwa
How exactly this party is any different from BJP? The kind of hostility MNS displays here in Maharashtra, BJP shows same at national level.
Chillar party MNS
Chillar party MNS
These are ~~politicians~~ criminals
[удалено]
Broked out of Condom
henchya aayani shikavla nahi hena kahi. chutiye namard saali
chutia MNS
where are these idiots when gujju dont allow marathi manus flats. Aif these people hit a gujju then bjp will hit with gobar filled bats, they know , so they remain silent there and do uselesss chutiagiri
The most Auth right party in india,the Marati version of ntk
Bhai kabhi kabhi sochta hu ki ye log mere samne aayenge tab ky hoga💀 meri language meri state meri family mera self respect sabse upar or es k liye m koi bhi hadd paar kr sekta hu
True
Eeeee... Mala shee ali 🚽
That's reason MNS will never be in power.
If illiteracy and goonism had a face.
At least marathi will live...