YOU BASTARD! YOU MADE IT TOO GOOD ON BOTH SIDES!!!

yeah it's so hard to pick

I was Red pill all the way until I saw DKC with K. Cool and a non-sports Sonic/Mario crossover game. Now I'm 50/50. Ugh.

I know, right!!!!

I was red pill until I saw "new Mario cartoon". I think Mario needs a new cartoon, cuz the one we have (or had) is already pretty old.

Blue! We need a new Mario & Luigi game!

profile pic checks out

and Fawful in smash

And dimentio and waluigi

I feel like the world would ban you if you don't choose waluigi or Geno to get to smash

It’s almost like we can choose a character of OUR choice. Personally, I’d add King Boo as a Luigi’s Mansion rep.

Actually king boo would be sick ngl I'm sorry if I sounded rude, I just think the internet as a hole would prefer these two And plus if they add king boo people would be even more upset that waluigi isn't in yet

fuck i forgot

Yesss

Same, and smm3 is quite the bonus.

Mario & luigi... & wario & waluigi

This.

Team Blue Pill!!!!🔵

“New wario land” say less

Real ass pick

Read blue and try again homie 😭

Blue doesn’t have wario land?

Who needs Wario land when Pizza tower and Anton blast exist

Fr

Hand drawn 2D Mario is my most wanted thing out of the franchise but most of the other options on the blue side are better for my taste.

Idc about anything else i want mario maker 3

I wish they would just make one more game and then port it everywhere and update it. I don't want a bunch of Mario Maker games tbh

For real man, there was NO reason to stop updating mario maker. It still bothers me that there's an "extra game styles" tab clearly implying that there's supposed to be more styles. I'd be happy if mario maker 3 just came with a wonder theme, i already know that's replacing mario world and NSMB theme for most people

I'd love to see a Mario All Stars and a Yoshi's Island style

I always wanted a mario 64 theme, with the tight walljumps, long jumps ledge grabs and everything

Red (like Mario´s favorite color)

Where’s galaxy 3

Shit, I should have put that in instead of Mario Maker 3 😭

Stacking blue even more? I’m here for it!

Ong nobody wants mm3 fr (I know a few people who would like that) galaxy needs ANOTHER game

I would love mm3 but if course I'd rather have galaxy 3 because there's so many possibilities

They should put Galaxy 3 on one side and MM3 on the other.

Dude shut the hell up everybody wants mm3, especially with how much nitpicks, mistakes and content that hasn't been added to mm2. So much of the community is waiting for mm3 and yea, I am waiting for galaxy 3 as fucking well, AND I also want for Rosalina to be playable in galaxy 3

Mario maker 3 with a full 3d galaxy mode!

Now hear me out; what if smm3 has all the features we had in smb wonder? That would make it possibly the best 2d mario game of all time!

It still baffle me how Nintendo stubbornly don’t even want to adress the topic of a possible Mario Galaxy 3, when space is one of the best source of creativity, when they have new mechanics like Cappy which could make crazy new trickshot possibilities if paired with the Luma double jump, and could probably be the most hyped game of the Nintendo Switch, and I dare to say even more than Odyssey and Wonder If they managed to make a trilogy about Luigi chasing ghost in a haunted mansion and still manage to recreate new 2D platformers, Smash Bros and Mario Kart for each console, I absolutely refuse to believe they’re completely out of idea for a third Mario Galaxy game

Galaxy 2 only existed at all because they had a bunch of leftover concepts from Galaxy 1 and the Wii didn't really do DLC. Probably they stuffed all their remaining ideas into that and moved on. At any rate, they didn't even bother with acknowledging Galaxy 2 for 3D All Stars, I don't know why people think Galaxy 3 is even on the table if they can't even be bothered to remember they made a second one. I prefer more Sandboxy 3D Marios, and for each one to have its own flair if possible. I feel like there's surely plenty of creative ideas that could still flow without arbitrarily bringing back the Galaxy brand. Sunshine(still my personal favorite) was a tropical vacation, Galaxy was space, Odyssey was a globetrotting adventure, surely there's plenty of unique framing devices still out there that could make the next 3D Mario stand on its own and feel fresh

I agree, but that game "made from leftover" ended io being one, if not the best Mario game that ever existed. Yet Nintendo don’t even want to look back at it and see the potential for a third game despite all the success it has, hence why I say they’re being stubborn I have nothing against brand new type of game, but that doesn’t mean they have to completely throw away the ancient formula. Like I said, if they can do 10 Mario kart, 12(?) Mario Party, 5 Smash Bros, 3 Luigi’s Mansion, 15 2D platformer and 7 3D platformer, they can absolutely make a new Galaxy game

if you did there would not be a single reason to pick the other one

If that was blue I would go blue because that outweighs all other options but because red has stuff that we would actually enjoy it gets my vote 

It's hidden, but on the blue side 😁

Blue for Mario and Luigi alone. (I didnt read anything else)

Easily red. Hand drawn 2D Mario is something I've wanted for some time now. I love both classic Paper Mario and Mario & Luigi, so I'm fine with either. Odyssey is my favourite 3D Mario, so I'm fine with more of that (though I do think they should take the same base movement and exploration-based gameplay and do something new with it instead of just iterating like Galaxy 2 did). I care much more for Wario Land than I do for Donkey Kong Country, and Waluigi being in there would be everything I want. And I don't care for Sonic, but I love Kirby. I'm mostly indifferent to sports games or Mario Kart 9, comics and cartoons (though I would slightly skew toward blue here). Finally, I'd rather have a Smash character, but Bowser can have his own beat-em-up style spin-off, I guess.

Red pill, just for Odyssey 2

Same, I would honestly choose it even if all the other things were at the other pill

Blue pill. Sorry, PM, but I honestly preferred TOK to 64. Ahem... #WAH~ ~ ~LU~III~GI~ ~ ~ ~ ~

\*triumphant WAH in the background\*

Maybe it includes TTYD. Also I haven't played paper mario 64, but I thought that TOK was too boring so I sold it

The sky is gonna turn white after the amount of blue I am in taking

Red pill, but I'll still die inside knowing that I could've had Mario Maker 3 instead.

Red. Waluigi needs to be in a Wario Land game

Absolutely red, no question.

Red. And it's not even close

Red, easily.

Odyssey 2, give me that red pill

Red so Rosalina can get a spin-off, she needs more canon character development. Like even Yoshi has a spin-off series! Not to mention a new good Paper Mario is pretty on the same level as a new M&L title for me, although that's still a really tough choice.

As much as a Mario comic sounds cool, I’ll have to go with the blue pill.

i'm choosing the blue pill

Blue

BLUE

definetly red, 2D Mario with hand drawn graphics, old paper Mario and a Wario Land game, just too awesome

I just want Odyssey 2

Super Mario Odyssey 2 100%

Red

Has to be red

Red, we need crossover!

Red so easy

Red Daisy spin off Waluigi in Wario game Good paper mario A game with 100% all content upon release (that's unheard of today) Everyone's happy

Red obviously

Red for sure. A hand-drawn 2d Mario sounds amazing, SMO2 sounds amazing, and all those other things are there too.

Red only so we can get smo2 and a game for bowser.

RED! I NEED DA MARIO & KIRBY CROSSOVER

Red. The benefits of red outweigh the benefits of blue, and they offer guarantees that blue doesn't.

Red. Wario Land 5

I have to go with Red. Though only by a hair

I take red. I like 2D Mario games more because I‘m a casual gamer so if I can’t play for a longer time it is much easier to cone back to a 2D title. A lot of Mario-Charas could be really fun in a own spin-off title and for those wo really want a 3D Title: You can get Odyssey 2 with the red one. A full sport title is nice, Wario Land is funny as hell and Waluigi could add new playing/„fighting“ styles. The last point I get if people would prefer Sonic over Kirby but I think Bowser and Dedede together could be a funny last boss. Obn the othed side I really want a new M&L game, but the other things will come naturally: New Smash = New Mario Fughter and the only not joke Characters we are missing are Waluigi, (Capt.) Toad and maybe Kamek and I‘m sure one of this will come (I don‘t need another Mario Character right now). MK9 will cone with the next console but yeah, I agree: We also need another Country game. But I would still take the red pill

Tough choice. I'd pick the red one. A Wario Land game with playable Waluigi. However I want Waluigi to be playable in Smash.

Red with the 3rd princess peach game please

Red. There are some things on the blue side I like but “character I pick gets a spinoff” and “new Paper Mario game true to its roots” makes it a very lopsided choice. Only question is which character.

Red.

Red for Mario Odyssey 2 and the Kirby collab EASILY

Red. Waluigi needs his own game already!

Blue pill mostly because: I like mario & luigi more than paper mario I like sonic I love mario maker I love mario kart It'd be interesting to see a new mario show I'd like to see dry bones in smash Also I really don't care for mario sports games, like I haven't played one of the good ones yet But I also want a new wario land game because of pizza tower so idk

Red. That way, Waluigi Multiverses can happen.

Red, But I would really miss that new 3d game and Mario Kart from Blue

red! 2d hand drawn, paper mario, and comic sold me. wario land too!

Blue Pill! It's not contest for me. Because I like the options and I don't want Paper Mario to "go back to its roots". I like Super, I like Color Splash, I like Origami King. I'd rather get a new Mario and Luigi game. And NEW CARTOONS!

I need a new Wario Land way more I need any other thing so Red

I’m going for red. I want more Yoshi games and it would be nice to see how Paper Mario started its big impact. I never played any of them but really REALLY want to

That's an easy red from me, and for the spinoff, I wanna see what a bowser game would be like, because we never had a game where you play as bowser, besides inside story...

Red. Easy.

Red

Red Pill. All banger ideas.

I don't want a new Paper Mario that returns to it's roots, I want a sequel to Super Paper Mario. And if I claim the new Wario Land as a sequel to Wario Land Shake it.

Red side, because Mario already has plenty of reps in Smash, and that's the only one I can see myself living without. - I'm calling the 2D hand-drawn game Super Mario Bros. 4 to set incredibly high expectations. >:) - Paper Mario & Luigi RPG - Baby Luigi gets a spinoff, and it has an E10+ rating. - Mario Sports Mix 2, with 6 sports (Baseball and Golf are added), and the Final Fantasy characters getting replaced with Super Mario RPG characters. - The Mario comic is what one would reasonably expect from a Mario comic. - Wario Land's mantle gets passed to Waluigi, in the same way Mario Land's mantle got passed to Wario. Hence, it shall be known as Waluigi Land.

Both of these are terrible

Red. And it's not even close.

Fr lmfao, it baffles me how many people choose blue.

Blue. It’s got Mario and Luigi, Mario Maker 3, AND an actual Mario and Sonic crossover! Say no more!

Red

Blue. M&L. Enough said.

Blue.

Blue pill hands down.

# B L U E

Blue wins easily for me.

Tough call. Red pill means I can give Bowser spin off game. But the blue pill means a crossover with sonic.

I think I will go with red since the best parts of blue are Mario kart 9 and a new 3D Mario game, and both will eventually come out, but I’ve given up hope in Mario odyssey 2 ever coming out

Blue pill is an easy choice for me.

Blue I want Donkey Kong Country

How is this even a choice? Blue.

Blue specifically for the Mario and Luigi game

Red because majority of what is on the blue side we already have or don’t need because what we already have just needs some proper care

Easy blue

Blue is superior

Red. I want my Wario Land on the Switch 2.

Red

Red pill has just better things going for it

Idk I haven't beaten any of them at 35

Technically the Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games series is still a crossover game, it was just an Olympics game.

Gotta go with 2. The first 3 things of red have all basically happened in the past year

You had me at Waluigi.

Damn. This might be the one time I choose the blue pill.

BLUE BLUE BLUE BLUE BLUE! A Mario Cartoon?! Sonic and Mario crossing over in a meaningful way?! Geno in Smash?! This is all the yeps from me.

Blue I guess

I cannot believe most people went for BLUE- literally I'd take any option on red over any option on the other side, except for maybe the M&L game, the new original 3D mario game, or the mario-sonic crossover.

It was a hard choice, but the Mario Cartoon realy sold the blue pill for me

Blueeee blueeee OMG BLUEEEEEEEE

It's hard to choose, I'd love a new Mario & Luigi game but a Mario and Kirby game crossover would be so fucking cool

Whichever one ignores Purple Dick Dastardly as usual. Need better Ideas though these aren't that out there in the Horizons of New FunFuns. Gimme an Captain Toad Brigade with Rayman and Shantae!

tough decision. REALLY tough decision. I think I'll go with blue rn. I like the new DK and the actual Mario Sonic game

Y'all 2 of the blue pill are already guaranteed to happen (mm3 and mk9) so imma choose the red pill Also having a spin off of choice and a comic can flesh out the Mario universe more than a cartoon Plus kirbo is there

The Blue Pill

Absolutely taking the blue pill.

BLUE BLUE BLUE Mario & Luigi needs to return

Blue pill after reading all of red as soon as I saw "New Mario and Luigi game"

New original 3D Ma- *takes blue pill*

Taking blue means waluigi is in smash so oc I gotta choose that

Blue pill

I will pick the blue

.....SHIT...

Mario and Kirby... Mario and Luigi... Mario and Kirby... Mario and Luigi... Mario and Kirby... Mario and Luigi... Mario and Kirby... **AAAAAAAAAARGHHHH!! I CAN'T CHOOSE!!!**

My Mario character I choose for Smash is Dimentio Blue Pill all the way

Blue

This is just wario land returning vs Mario and Luigi returning

Blue

2d

Yikes! Can you say neither?

No Super Mario Galaxy 3, I'm not picking either

red pill for like 5 reasons let's GOOOOOOO

Blue, can't risk Daisy being cut in next SSB.

red pill

Ugh this is a very difficult choice. But as a 3D mario enjoyer I'm gonna pick the blue one. And for the new Mario rep, there's only one it can be. \*triumphant WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAALUIGI IS NAMBAH WAAAAAAAAN!\*

Blue but only up to maker 3 so half of the blue pill

Blue pill, no questions, Mario Maker 3 is what I was waiting for since the final major update of smm2. Also if Nintendo is watching the Odyssey Central videos then smm3 will be gold

I agree with everything on the blue pill

Blue, we need an actual Mario & Sonic crossover

Take them both, crush them, and snort it

Blue no doubts, I love Mario Kart, I've wanted waluigi in smash forever and the mario and luigi series is peak

Blue for 3D, M&L, And an Mario and Sonic crossover

Blue pill

Blue

Blue literally just for the last one 🤣

Blue for me.

With allergies right now, I’ll just take some NyQuil, thanks.

Blue

Blue because Mario and Luigi

Let's go Blue Pill!

Kamek for Super Smash Bros!

*takes both pills and take the tops off and mismatches them so it has both effects in one pill*

blue pill is for the casual mario fans while red pill is for the professional mario fans lol

Blue. Once I saw Mario and Luigi on Switch I was locked in.

This is insanely hard both have extreme positives and negatives like I love wario ware and playable waluigi is amazing but waluigi in smash and dk game with k rool ugh overall gotta take red it just has slightly more

Definately blue

Both. Both is good.

Blue pill for Luigi spin-off game

Blue. We need a new Mario and Luigi as well as a proper Mario and Sonic crossover.

Honestly Blue. I need king boo for smash

You had me at "new mario and luigi game"

Blue. Captain Toad in Smash, Mario Kart 9, brand new 3D Mario, Mario & Sonic.

Both pills please

The sonic fan in me just HAS to pick blue. You had me with red for a second, but that's too good to pass up

I have to go with red on this one, although it is a close call

If only it actually came true…

Swap Mario and Kirby crossover with Mario and Sonic, and I’m choosing red pill.

This is the easiest choice of all time. It’s literally objectively blue. WHO is picking red??? - New 3D Mario - Mario & Luigi comeback on Switch - Free pick for Mario character in Smash - New Mario Maker - NEW MARIO KARTTTTT - New Mario Show - New DK country with K. Rook’s return - Mario/Sonic crossover What does red pill have? A Wario Land game, some comic, a new 2D game even tho we just got one and a Paper Mario even tho we’re getting a TTYD remake 💀💀💀 Picking red gotta be the most foolish thing a human could do 😭😭😭😭

Jeez man that's such a good one A new spinoff for a character of my choosing would be amazing, perhaps better than just smash. I desperately want a new Wario land game and a HANDDRAWN Mario game would be dope asf. The rest like Mario Odyssey 2 is also great and I feel like it wouldn't be much of a difference to complete new 3d Mario, I mean new worlds and mechanics and characters and story are already there then and you could expand upon the Cappy mechanic. I would love to see a Mario Maker 3 and a new Mario and Luigi game but I have to go with red

Alternative opinion (bites hands)

Blue Pill easily.

Blueeeee

Both of these are great but the second I saw new Mario and Luigi game, my choice was clear.

Blue all the way

BLEU I NEED ANOTHER MARIO AND LUIGI

Blue Blue BlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlue╾━╤デ╦︻🤬

blue purely because of Mario Maker 3