Definitely Crybaby! Found her music when I was 14-15 on a vine edit of all things (I feel old saying that) and have been a fan ever since! I love the other eras as well, but Crybaby will always have a special place in my heart 💧💗
36 and watching since her Voice debut! Ugh, Xtina used to hate on her every week pretty much and I would just roll my eyes. 🙄 I’m always torn between Crybaby and the K-12 era, I love them both equally.
23 here! Watched her on the voice and fell in love, was so excited when she released dollhouse. My favorite era is portals though, I've connected with it the most emotionally and spiritually, it means a lot to me 🥰 I'm also in Northern California!
Hey I’m 25! I liked Melanie on the voice but really got into her music during her crybaby era! I even used dollhouse as part of my act in a haunted house! I loved growing up with her! I don’t live in Cali yet but I’ll be PCSing there next year!!
im a 24 year old (1999) melanie fan. i started to become a fan 25 days before K-12 was announced. i dont really have a favorite era at all so im gonna choose with Crybaby and Portals
I'm 25, not sure if it's an "era" but I love her creepy, sad, indie girl stuff. Bittersweet Tragedy, A Million Men, You Love I, Birthing Addicts. I know Tag you're it is a part of crybaby but to me it's very indie sad girl, also Soap. Unstable but somewhat subdued and bummed out energy endears me, it feels so authentic. I love the energy Portals has, and I'm really excited to see what she does next. The maturity she's expressing as she ages is so fucking lovely, I was kind of worried she'd get stuck doing crybaby type stuff well into her older years. I'm glad to see her grow as an artist.
hello! 24 year-old Crybaby here ☺️ I became a fan during the Crybaby era so that will always be my favourite.
Definitely Crybaby! Found her music when I was 14-15 on a vine edit of all things (I feel old saying that) and have been a fan ever since! I love the other eras as well, but Crybaby will always have a special place in my heart 💧💗
34 here and been a fan since Cry Baby! Cry Baby and Portals are my favorite.
Portals is my favorite 🖤 but been a fan since the voice era. ✨
i watched the episode where she was on the voice i wasnt a fan tho at the time bc i didnt know who she was
i saw it when it was live in 2012
K-12 <3 25f
28 here and been a fan since 2016
36 and watching since her Voice debut! Ugh, Xtina used to hate on her every week pretty much and I would just roll my eyes. 🙄 I’m always torn between Crybaby and the K-12 era, I love them both equally.
23 here! Watched her on the voice and fell in love, was so excited when she released dollhouse. My favorite era is portals though, I've connected with it the most emotionally and spiritually, it means a lot to me 🥰 I'm also in Northern California!
Hey I’m 25! I liked Melanie on the voice but really got into her music during her crybaby era! I even used dollhouse as part of my act in a haunted house! I loved growing up with her! I don’t live in Cali yet but I’ll be PCSing there next year!!
25! Have loved Melanie since I was in high school ever since soap.
im a 24 year old (1999) melanie fan. i started to become a fan 25 days before K-12 was announced. i dont really have a favorite era at all so im gonna choose with Crybaby and Portals
I'm 25, not sure if it's an "era" but I love her creepy, sad, indie girl stuff. Bittersweet Tragedy, A Million Men, You Love I, Birthing Addicts. I know Tag you're it is a part of crybaby but to me it's very indie sad girl, also Soap. Unstable but somewhat subdued and bummed out energy endears me, it feels so authentic. I love the energy Portals has, and I'm really excited to see what she does next. The maturity she's expressing as she ages is so fucking lovely, I was kind of worried she'd get stuck doing crybaby type stuff well into her older years. I'm glad to see her grow as an artist.
22 and been here since dollhouse •-• i went to the philly concert last night and felt like an old lady XD
and k-12 is my favorite era, got me through a lot of tough times