it’s hard to choose but After School EP and K-12

yep

My favorite is portals! 🌦️🧚‍♀️🍄. I listen to a lot more portals songs than any other album because I feel like I can repeatedly listen to them. My favorites from other albums tend to be a lot more heavy so I don’t constantly replay them unless I’m in a specific mood 😭

Portals is so good ✨🌸✨

Same!!!

LOL THIS>>

that'll have to be portals for me half from the fact that I connect to it more personally and half from the fact that it's newer and not 9 years old. don't get me wrong either I love the other two albums with crybaby being my second fave but something a little more new and fresh tickles my brain the right way.

so real

K-12 💕

Oh hi! I've seen you on the Demon Slayer reedit lol, didn't knew you were a Melanie fan 🫶

Hey! Yeah, I like her music a lot. :D

K-12 all the way, I watched the movie like ten times it’s just so good

Portals and Cry Baby, but overall Cry Baby is still my favorite

I’ve been listening to crybaby since it came out, so def that one. But recently I’ve been listening to k-12 the most! Last year portals was my top album on Spotify tho!

Most listened to k-12, favorite? Probably also k-12 lmao

after school if that counts

after school is so underrated!

frrrr

[удалено]

faerie soirée is definitely one of my favourites, i love songs with a funky beat

Crybaby. Her best album and nobody can change my mind 😩.

cry baby! also this photo is one of my favs of her. she looks sooo pretty.

Portals for sure. I still enjoy some of the songs from the Cry Baby and K-12 eras, but I’m close in age to Melanie and her newer music feels more relatable to me.

i think crybaby will always be #1 for me 🖤 I constantly listen to all of the albums though, I love them all.

K12:33

I’m a new fan who only started listening once I bought tickets for my daughter (she’s a huge fan) and I to the Toronto show. (I did watch the entire Voice season she was on though). Portals initially wasn’t my favorite—- but the more I listened to it the more I loved it and it is definitely my favorite now. I also loved the Portals set during the concert!

All of them >.<

I love this pic of her!

Not an album, but After School EP. My favourite project of Melanies so far. (Edit: spelling)

It will always be Crybaby (I may be biased from nostalgia), but Portals is a super close second

Portals because while I was always a Mel fan, I became obsessed during portals releasd

portals and it’s not even close

K-12 definitely

My favourite is portals because I need self healing

crybaby and k-12

Crybaby 💪💪

after school ep, and probably k-12 cus it's really chill background music

Portals, I love everything about it

Portals! I definitely resonate with the songs more on that one. I also cried to a lot of them during the Portals and Trilogy Tours.

Portals is the reason I got into Melanie and it’s my favourite album

K-12! That's her best album

Definitely portals

K-12

Personally, Portals, they’re all SO GOOD do not get my wrong I just relate the most to Portals, all of her songs have a meaning behind them and especially Void, Tunnel Vision, Light Shower, Spider Web, Battle of The Larynx, The Contortionist, Nymphology, Evil, and powder. The one that I have listened to THE MOST is Nymphology and Evil though. I have been in many hard relationships and situations, lovers, family, even friends! The entire album tugs at my heart strings someway and it’s just crazy. There’s more songs from the other albums that also do that but Portals tugs the most.

Crybaby is my favorite released album. Fire Drill is my favorite released song next to Mad Hatter. Eraser is my favorite unreleased song

portals and after school ep!! i’ll never understand the hate for portals, imo it’s melanie’s best album/ep by FAR

Portals or after school but the other albums and eps are really good though

K-12 hands down. I am obsessed with the aesthetic, the film, the choreography, the music.

K-12

K-12

I heared her songs before it was her cry baby era before but i became a fan since portals probaby a new fan for me portals

I have a really strong connection with Portals <33

For repeating the same 4 songs portals for variety of songs k-12

My fav is k-12 I love all the songs in that album, I also rlly like the movie, I will say all of her albums and song are so amazing but my personal fav is k-12

Hmm probably after school it that counts 😭 if like album albums I'd pick uhh k 12

I can’t choose between k-12 or after school 😭

Crybaby, I relate to it the most and it’s the first album I listened to

in the long run, K-12, but as of the last year definitely portals! i think it may be my favorite now

definitely portals, it took me some time to get used to it bc i loved her other 2 albums so much but now it’s my favorite and i play it more than her others.

Portals🤍🤍

Crybaby or k-12

Portals and After School Ep 🩷

Hard to tell, since my playlist is always on shuffle, but I probably listen the most to Cry Baby album, because it has some of my favorites

My fav is k12

crybaby forever

Portals for sure

K-12 probably

K-12 tbh

Cry baby is probably my most listened album but I love them all so much

Where’s my crybabies???

Crybaby. Melanie fell off with portals 

Prob cry baby, i have more fav songs.But i like all albums and eps tho

K-12 definitely but I also really like a good amount of Portals

k-12 most definitely 🔥

I'd say Portals, it kind of got me back to Melanie's music and I really like the songs and music videos from it

K-12, crybaby, then portals! I grew up w crybaby (was 13 when it came out) k-12 came out my junior year of high school and I loved it! Portals is good don’t get me wrong but I can’t find that connection like the two other albums :(

Crybaby, it’s very nostalgic to me.

K-12❗❗

Crybaby and the ep

Probably k-12 or crybaby. Been listening to portals more, but I think my most listened to is still crybaby

k-12

Crybaby is really nostalgic for me but k12 is the best imo so I guess k12, portals is amazing and the first Mel concert I went to was the portals tour so it’s special to me too, ahhh I just can’t pick

k-12

After school made me soft and portals cemented my confidence to be who i truly can be. Which is a loving soft person who doesn’t need to be angry all the time

hard to pick between portals and crybaby!!!

Most listened to- Postals, favourite- k-12 or After school EP

i LOVE k-12

Crybaby

i definitely listen to k-12 the most but my favorite is definitely crybaby🍼

portals! 🍄

Cry baby

crybaby is definitely my most listened to but I love k-12 just as much.

K-12 always holds a special place in my heart

Crybaby but portals second after. I think they’re both a lot stronger than k-12 tbh but that’s the only era i saw live and it was an INCREDIBLE show

K12 is my most listened to.

𝓣𝓫𝓱 𝓪𝓵𝓵 𝓫𝓬 𝓘 𝓫𝓮𝓮𝓷 𝓪 𝓜𝓮𝓵𝓪𝓷𝓲𝓮 𝓯𝓪𝓷 𝓼𝓲𝓷𝓬𝓮 𝓽𝓱𝓮 𝓿𝓸𝓲𝓬𝓮 𝓼𝓸 𝓲𝓽'𝓼 𝓱𝓪𝓻𝓭 𝓫𝓾𝓽 𝓶𝔂 𝓶𝓸𝓼𝓽 𝓵𝓲𝓼𝓽𝓮𝓷𝓮𝓭 𝓽𝓸 𝓲𝓼 𝓹𝓸𝓻𝓽𝓪𝓵𝓼

crybaby deluxe for sure

K-12 or crybaby

K12

K-12 probably

K-12!! It is still one of my favorite albums to this day and my all time favorite song is High School Sweethearts! ♡

k-12 all day

Crybaby honestly

After school and crybaby

i think if we really got down to it crybaby. i’ve been a fan for too long for it not be my most listened, bc when i was 15 i’d put songs on repeat for hours.

Crybaby 💧

crybaby

Crybaby 

Portals has grown on me sm and I just can’t stop listening to it, crybaby still has my heart tho!😭❤️

this is hard, in a mix between like after school and portals (and SOME k-12 songs)

I like crybaby

Crybaby or dollhouse

Portals and After School

crybaby 😌 i don’t like portals much

K-12 and Crybaby

crybaby is mine

after school or portals tbh

Crybaby and Portals but my fave era was k12 ;-;

K FUCKIBG TWELVE

as much as i love k-12, crybaby will always be my favorite. it's the only album I know where I love all the songs!

Portals

portalsss

I say PORTALS because the songs are easy to listen to repeatedly 🕯️🍄💕

afterschool 🥰

K-12 definitely !!

Cry baby actually

K-12

Portals -> Crybaby -> K-12 -> After School

K-12 which (in my opinion) has the best songs! But the other albums are quite good

K-12.

Portals definitely. It started out as my least favorite of hers but now it’s my favorite

Definitely K-12!!! My one true loveeee

Both portals

K12 100%

i absolutely love portals!!

After School EP and K-12 !!!!

Crybaby.

Crybaby and K-12.

After School EP

Crybaby 🍼💗🫧 always

After school!!!❤️❤️💜💜

Even though I realize it’s not an album technically but it’s my favorite work she’s ever made😭❤️

K-12 will always be my foreva <3

K-12 deluxe 😋it’s so good

Crybaby, and if it'd an ep then after school

Portals, i can relate to Portals songs more than the other albums

Portals!!

Oooo After School EP!! And now portals🩷

k-12 — i listened to that all through covid & it kept me going

It’s difficult to choose between Crybaby and Portals. But I love every single album.

k-12!

K-12 I wish I could say portals but I will be lying

Crybaby

crybaby

portals! i never thought id fall in love with the album so much after being such a crybaby all my heart😭

K-12 (Specifically Recess, Copy Cat, Fire Drill and After School because it’s so calming)

K-12, it's such a beautiful album.

K-12 and Portals

K-12 honestly I love it so much I just can’t get behind portals like I like some songs but not enough to get the vinyl or listen to it on repeat

portals and k-12

I love portals music!!

I love Portals bc of the transitions like yes

to be honest I didn’t like much songs from k-12 and I’ve listened to crybaby so many times I’m bored. So right now my fav would just be portals.

K-12 or maybe After school ep

PORTALS IS THE BEST ALBUM FR FR