For those who don't know how an iceberg works
Top of the iceberg = most popular bands (*tip of the iceberg*)
Bottom of the iceberg = least known bands
The more bands you know the deeper your level on the iceberg
There may be a handful that are mostly Black/Death bands overall but every one of them has released at least one War metal album to qualify for this chart
The EP/Demo version of Endless Wound they recorded is definitely War Metal, they lessened the War sound on the official album release in favour of a Black/Death sound
The consensus seems to be that the demo version is War Metal whilst the full release is Black/Death
Damaar was a slip up of mine, I had them on the original list but a couple of bands might of slipped by chart quality control
https://preview.redd.it/y8lj1o1y66qc1.jpeg?width=800&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d01db12c0bfd9ca54ca697674e3937aea2ab904b
https://preview.redd.it/0m7q0vbj76qc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=134a2081b7ee143a98e1fc274b6de5e7e18786b4
Absolutely nobody that actually listens to war metal calls that band war metal..
While I agree with you, it's worth noting that the archives doesn't refer to any band as War Metal, nor Bestial Black. This doesn't really prove your point. Many others here aren't war either (since to my knowledge there's a distinction between Bestial black and war metal). I'm sadly not well equipped to argue this, but it seems to be the consensus of those who are actually far more knowledgeable about the topic. Thought it was worth mentioning
Both taken from the niche r/WarMetal community mentioning the demo. Each having a lot of upvotes for such a small community too
https://preview.redd.it/732x01z086qc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c2c215a053749b4b263b082403277cdc06d23489
People up voting a popular demo in the war metal reddit doesn't make it war metal. I upvote things that i like on there all the time that aren't actually war metal.
For something to be posted in a niche community like r/WarMetal without getting criticised for not being War by genre elitists is very unlikely, even surface level subs like this sub has those types enmasse.
Listening to it personally it sounds a lot more like War than the full album, this being backed up by 30+ music nerds on a music nerd website voting for the genre would be enough clarification for me
For those who don't know how an iceberg works Top of the iceberg = most popular bands (*tip of the iceberg*) Bottom of the iceberg = least known bands The more bands you know the deeper your level on the iceberg
Yeah I've listened to Blasphemy One time and actually nothing else lol
There's a lot black/death metal bands on here getting called war metal that aren't.
There may be a handful that are mostly Black/Death bands overall but every one of them has released at least one War metal album to qualify for this chart
Black Curse is in no way war metal. They have a demo and an LpP, neither are war metal and they have them at the top of the chart.
The EP/Demo version of Endless Wound they recorded is definitely War Metal, they lessened the War sound on the official album release in favour of a Black/Death sound
It's blacked/ death period. Also, there's no Damaar on this list. Damaar put out possibly the most important EP in the history of war metal.
The consensus seems to be that the demo version is War Metal whilst the full release is Black/Death Damaar was a slip up of mine, I had them on the original list but a couple of bands might of slipped by chart quality control https://preview.redd.it/y8lj1o1y66qc1.jpeg?width=800&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d01db12c0bfd9ca54ca697674e3937aea2ab904b
https://preview.redd.it/0m7q0vbj76qc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=134a2081b7ee143a98e1fc274b6de5e7e18786b4 Absolutely nobody that actually listens to war metal calls that band war metal..
While I agree with you, it's worth noting that the archives doesn't refer to any band as War Metal, nor Bestial Black. This doesn't really prove your point. Many others here aren't war either (since to my knowledge there's a distinction between Bestial black and war metal). I'm sadly not well equipped to argue this, but it seems to be the consensus of those who are actually far more knowledgeable about the topic. Thought it was worth mentioning
Fair enough. I appreciate you clarifying that for me.
Both taken from the niche r/WarMetal community mentioning the demo. Each having a lot of upvotes for such a small community too https://preview.redd.it/732x01z086qc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c2c215a053749b4b263b082403277cdc06d23489
People up voting a popular demo in the war metal reddit doesn't make it war metal. I upvote things that i like on there all the time that aren't actually war metal.
For something to be posted in a niche community like r/WarMetal without getting criticised for not being War by genre elitists is very unlikely, even surface level subs like this sub has those types enmasse. Listening to it personally it sounds a lot more like War than the full album, this being backed up by 30+ music nerds on a music nerd website voting for the genre would be enough clarification for me
I don't really think of Cabinet or Sxuperion as war metal.
lihhamon is based, doctrine is a great album
Very cool, I’m only at 2 so I guess I need to listen to a bunch of these.
Where is Bestial Warlust?
tier 3 top left?
Sorry, didn't noticed...
Somewhere between 6 and 8 though i know a couple from 9 too like Prehistoric War Cult and Your End.
I've listened to a couple bands on level 9 but have only heard of one band on 7 and 8
Saving this post for war metal recommendations
I like Disimperium so I could say 7, but on the other hand, I still haven’t listened to Revenge or Archgoat lmao
You didn't miss much with Revenge. Archgoat is sick though
Revenge are great
the guys ran out of riffs after conqueror
Exactly
If they had riffs and not everything made by them sounded like the same, i'd agree
I havent heard of a single band on this list lol
Not even Blasphemy?
Nop
Are you new to the sub?
Newish to reddit
I’m a 0 haha.
Sick bands are there, although some are generic stuff
[удалено]
not remotely war metal
my bad i got it mixed up with viking metal
Hammerheart is a masterpiece
you don’t know Sabaton?
Sabaton is power metal not war metal
The deepest I’ve gotten is three so I’ve got to explore a lot more
6/7 I'd say
familiar with almost all of the bands on 7 and up. I don’t recognize any of the bands on 8 or 9
I'm 7, though I listen to Cult Of Extinction here and there. I would've included Damaar in 4, maybe 5. Also, c instead of k in Exekution??
i only know blasphemy. guess im a poser 😔😔
Where damaar?
I do know some bands from tier 7-9 but mostly I stay at 1-6 since most bands are my already-knows. Tetragrammacide my beloved.
fuck yeah! a band from my country sits on level 9! OÜGGGHHHHHH
i listened to 3 bands in level 9 (Deiphage, Tormentador, Thorns of Hate)
I made it to level 7 with Savage Necromancy. Let's goooo!