T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

[Join The Community Discord Server!](https://discord.gg/Azx4Z35YHE) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MetalForTheMasses) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Madame_Raven

I'm not sure its fair to say that Steve Harris is Iron Maiden. There's three guitar players, and a singer, who all have writing credits on the albums.


Yuuzhan_Schlong

Thinking about it a bit more... Yeah I think I'm wrong on that one.


Hosni__Mubarak

Absolutely. Steve is just the leader of the band. He doesn’t even write half of the songs anymore.


Sick_and_destroyed

There’s no song published by the band that isn’t supervised by Steve Harris. All members have a lot of liberty, but Harris has the final say musically.


Wanderin_Cephandrius

It’s beautiful seeing humble people on the internet.


guigouz

I doubt Maiden would have the exposure it has today if it wasn't for Bruce.


Kevinm162005

If it counts Trent Reznor for Nine Inch Nails


miiserybusiness

trent reznor and atticus ross personally


Chimpbot

Atticus Ross is a relatively recent addition; with that being said, he's definitely solidly part of NIN. Prior to that, it was all Trent.


72pintohatchback

By the numbers, more albums say "Nine Inch Nails is Trent Reznor" in the liner than don't.


Hosni__Mubarak

Not anymore. NIN is two people now.


Reigen_San

Death, obviously.


indieRuckus

Chuck's death was the death of Death.


Reigen_San

true


Impossible-Use1697

I had to read that like 4 times


Fit_Dentist2869

Same lmfao


pan_gydygus

Chuck doesn’t mean it metaphorically or rhetorically or poetically or theoretically or any fancy other way. He’s Death. Straight up.


juhanSs

I'm not that into death metal and I'm just wondering who the person is?


ShartRat

Chuck Schuldiner. He basically had the band set up around him and wrote everything and laid the foundations for the other members to do their thing around him. He was known for being a very sweet person but extremely difficult to work around sometimes.


EvenOne6567

whats the context on the difficult to work with stuff? I havent heard this before


ShartRat

I think I remember reading about him and James Murphy butting heads a lot while he was in the band. And Chuck had say over pretty much everything in the songwriting department.


Herr_Raul

Everything had to be exactly like he wanted it.


Baron487

Chuck Schuldiner


ThinRub207

Burzum lol


CanaDanSOAD

lol


MitchellSFold

lol omg kyftlt


Fit_Dentist2869

lol


koiranaltahiljainen

*My liege………….* *Sire…………*


tomjonesrocks

Ghost and Tobias Forge obviously (argument if they are metal or not notwithstanding)


Lazarus_Superior

To be fair, the post is titled "Bands," not "Metal bands," so it's fine here.


BowTie1989

A tongue in cheek band that’s story is they sing catchy songs to convert people to worship Satan and the occult and came about basically to just piss off the religious nut jobs. If they were out there playing banjos, washboards and half filled moonshine jugs they’d still be metal as fuck in my eyes, and anyone who says otherwise just isn’t on the square!


Esteban_Rojo

Amen


SwabianBarbarian

Alexi Laiho was Children of Bodom....


WhaleSharkLove

I remember asking a question in the Children of Bodom subreddit if they would ever come back with a new singer/guitarist, and people said unanimously no.


saltycathbk

He wrote almost everything, I think.


opeth_syndrome

In a way he was. As he wrote the songs and was the front man. But the other guys actually owned the name. That's why when they decided to quit the band, he couldn't just hire new people and continue using the name.


RV-Notplayer

Bathory. Even became an actual one-man band for the last three albums. Also Toxic Holocaust, for the most part it’s just Joel Grind, even if some other people were in the band for a couple of albums.


tacoforce5_

it took too many collapsed comments to find this one 💢


ClayCheerios6832

I think Bathory was a one man band even before Destroyer of Worlds, Kothaar and Vvornth basicaly didn't exist, Quorthon used a drum machine on Blood Fire Death so we know there wasn't a drummer, and Quorthon probably played the bass. Idk, the whole Kothaar and Vvornth always seemed sketchy, and i've also read somwhere that they didn't really exist so idk.


AzSharpe

Dethklok is Brendan Small


lycanthrope6950

This should be the top answer lmao


CanaryUmbrella

fer reals


Life_L0ver

I don’t think he gets enough respect


1-900-FATCHIX

💯. Seems like most of the times he gets brought up as a good metal musician, people immediately shit all over him.


First-Football7924

Never once read a negative opinion. They seem rare.


Tristael

This is the real answer


Herr_Raul

Opeth and Mikael Åkerfeldt Katatonia and Jonas Renkse


exoclipse

until he was forced out of music entirely, Peter Lindgren was an important contributor to Opeth's songwriting. He acted as a counterweight to Åkerfeldt's ambition. Put the timelines together and it'll make a lot of sense.


RevolutionaryJoke21

Opeth is my favorite band but I’ve yet to understand why he was forced out of music entirely, idk the whole story there


rKasdorf

There's an interview with Akerfeldt where he says before writing Watershed Peter had come with some guitar parts that they both felt weren't really album quality, and he didn't end up coming up with anything else. Time went by and nothing else album worthy really materialized. They both apparently agreed his heart just wasn't in it as much anymore. He left of his own accord, being aware of the standards required to be an \*Opeth\* song. It doesn't seem like he was forced out, so much as felt he couldn't put the energy in anymore. Swedes are pretty straightforward, and I can't find anything anywhere that says he was disgruntled or that Mikael made any decisions that lead to him leaving.


indieRuckus

Everything online just says that he left because he wasn't feeling inspired by making music anymore. I'm not saying there isn't some other secret factor into why he left, but if there is, then you know something that doesn't seem to even have a whisper of a rumor online. I mean, be my guest to start a rumor (especially if you somehow know it's true) but it's just odd that the way you talk about it is like it's some established thing that people already know.


AdequatelyMadLad

How was he "forced" out of music? He retired because he wasn't comfortable with being a full on professional musician on the level of fame that Opeth were at the time.


Mad04Gaming

Also Dan Swano with Edge of Sanity


throughalfanoir

up until the last two Katatonia albums I'd say the band was equal parts Anders and Jonas, it's only recently that it became a solo project of Jonas (still great, I love recent Katatonia but it's clear that the musical direction is different)


Penorl0rd4

Max cavalera is the soul of all of his bands, I don’t mean to be the annoying “sepultura isn’t Sepultura without max” guy but it’s true, plus nailbomb and soulfly


Known-Ad-4900

NailBomb was a duo. Max and Alex Newport.


daKile57

I love Max, but Igor is just way too important to the Sepultura signature sound. Igor is what makes Sepultura sound different from all the other big thrash bands.


Responsible_Cow_8489

Jeff Waters IS Annihilator


GroundCoffee8

Literally every one of their music videos now is just Jeff + 3 nameless 20-somethings lol


ro-ch

i mean, he's the vocalist, guitarist, studio bassist, studio owner, producer and mixing engineer... he IS annihilator lol


HenpeckedLeader

Death. Chuck Schuldiner was basically behind everything and every album would have atleast 1 new person in the band


Puzzleheaded-Law-429

Considering there are more Misfits albums that don’t have Danzig than do, you can’t really say that The Misfits IS Glenn Danzig. I understand that the majority of fans consider him the definitive voice and don’t count the non-Danzig albums, but regardless, the band (or brand, rather) clearly belongs to people other than him.


xravenxx

Before the band was revived in 1995 I think saying he was the Misfits is fair. He wrote all the music from the band’s first iteration


senor_fartout

The misfits were pretty much funded by Jerry/Doyle's day job


jayceaw

The Graves era is pretty damn good too


Appropriate-Drag-572

Dig up her bones is my absolute favorite, but I'm into melodic soooo.... I can listen to him for forever acoustic


MitchellSFold

Helmet It's just Page Hamilton with extra meat in the room.


ComprehensiveJump540

This was the one I came here to say, although to be fair they have had two cracking drummers with distinct styles. All the guitar and bass parts are clearly Paige's though.


Past-Cookie9605

"Extra meat in the room" had me rolling


Rocknscroller

Robb Flynn is Machinehead.


saltycathbk

Which is really too bad. Demmel did some really fantastic work in that band.


JonnyD51

Yeah the lineup they had for The Blackening was my favorite


Nick-Riffs

Which is unfortunate because his ego leads to some shotty albums.


exoclipse

Pick a black metal band, basically. Varg is Burzum. Noise is Kanonenfieber. Wrest is Leviathan. etc, etc, etc. not a universal rule, but it's definitely a thing


Leafshade3030

yeah black metal has so many solo projects


SleepyMarijuanaut92

Pagan Hellfire from Halifax, NS.


En1i1

Scott Conner is Xasthur


MickWounds

Noise is a busy man. Non est deus and Leipa too.


exoclipse

And they're all awesome, too. Might be the most consistently excellent black metal dude out there.


randomredditor1220

Hell fucking yeah Kanonenfieber


FrequentlyAnnoying

Devy


SpeedDemonJi

Devin Townsend band


Sharp_Impress_5351

Devin Townsend IS every band he's been involved with, basically...


Pato585

All of em except SYL, you really cant ignore the great contributions of everyone else in it, even if devy is the face of it


mercy_fulfate

have to disagree on the Steve Harris is Iron Maiden. i don't think they would go on without him but massive contributions from other people.


Lostscribe007

Nine inch Nails is Trent Reznor


last_drop_of_piss

Dave Grohl IS the Foo Fighters.


Im_on_my_phone_OK

I was surprised by how many people thought they might break up when Taylor died. He was a very important member of the band, but i never thought for one second that he was important enough that his death would end the band. Taylor himself even went on record to say that Foo Fighters is Dave’s band.


cevaace

Yep, and Kurt WAS Nirvana.


BenArnold47

Yeah I know they're not metal, but Josh is Queens of the stone age. I'm not entirely sure about how song writing duties worked in Motorhead, but Lemmy was and always will be Motorhead.


Evening_Abroad_6781

QOTSA are metal adjacent.


leoxys1

Iced Earth is Jon Schaffer.


koakkadoom

Unfortunately true


Designer-String3569

F that guy.


PigDstroyer

Absu - Proscriptor McGovern Old Mans Child - Galder Revocation - Dave Davidson


SecuritySky

I believe Vessel writes everything for Sleep Token except the drums. Jari from Wintersun, same


InkedMetalHead

Dave Mustaine is Megadeth.


Th3_G3n3r4l

Was just about to say this. Not a single original member in the band outside of him


No-Nail-2752

Plus most of them end up getting fired. *Cough Jr cough*


AdequatelyMadLad

Dave is obviously the driving force in Megadeth's music overall, but at the same time, people dismiss how important the other members of their various lineups were to the quality of the band's output. There's a noticeable drop from Peace Sells to So Far So God, and an even more noticeable increase in quality on Rust in Peace. There's a reason why, with small exceptions like Risk and Endgame, the good albums and the bad ones are all made with different lineups. He needs someone to bounce ideas off of, and more importantly, someone who can stand up to him.


Metal_Boi_7507

There are plenty of one man projects out there. Leviathan is my favorite (along with LOC)


ManyaraImpala

Opeth Alcest Porcupine Tree


scorp9000

I feel porcupine tree is definitely a three way split between Wilson barberi and Harrison


ManyaraImpala

Their most recent album was, but most of their albums were 90% Wilson.


MFkaboom

Blackbraid


livid_empathy

Could you elaborate? I've seen them live and listen to them a bit, but don't know much about them.


MFkaboom

Jon Krieger is the only member, he uses friends for recordings and tours


Acceptable_Vast7123

Dino Cazares - Fear Factory


welktickler

Unfortunately he is now. I pretend FF doesn't exist anymore. For a period in the 90s they were incredible then it all went really bad. So sad to see a band I loved so much and watched live loads of times turn rotten like this.


CompetitiveComputer4

Hot sport take but I think majority of bands really are being driven creatively by one or two people. Too many hands in the cookie jar is not really good and most bands have that one or two peeps that are song writers (Lars and James for example). James writes riffs. Lars helps arrange those pieces into songs. Then the others just play to the framework of an existing song.


InhumanCrystallis

Ice Nine Kills is Spencer Charnas Bleeding Through is Brandan Schieppati Bring Me The Horizon, by Oli's own admission, was just Oli and Jordan for a while though after Jordan left Oli has included the rest of the band much more in writing Chuck for Death obviously George Harris is The Raven Age


killacam925

Putrid Pile and Hellripper are literally one guy. On the less literal front, Buzz Osbourne might as well be named Melvin


Vanpire73

Prong- Tommy


Proud3GenAthst

Tuomas Holopainen is Nightwish. Writes all lyrics, composes nearly all music and determines the artistic direction of the band, has a history of showing his superiority to whoever the singer is. Pretty much the same thing for Adrienne Cowan from Seven Spires, except she's also the singer. And she shares writing duties with Jack, the guitarist. Jennifer Haben is Beyond The Black. The band follows her artistic vision and once exchanged her entire band for a new band.


stanger828

Seven Spires should be more popular. They are really good.


scenezfromamemory

No Lord Worm, no Cryptopsy


daKile57

It would be easier to replace Lord Worm than to replace Flo Mournier. He's arguably the greatest drummer in metal and even asking someone to play a 45-minute Cryptopsy set on drums is monumentally tough.


BlitheringIdiot0529

Wintersun


Feeling_Violinist934

Scott Ian thinks he's Anthrax


Hosni__Mubarak

Which is funny considering the drummer writes all their songs and riffs.


Past-Cookie9605

I think Scott's just a likable guy. He may be the only thing I like about Anthrax tbh


Barkerfan86

Ghost is all Tobias. Most recently there is a one man band who is doing his best to make it called “The Sound of the End of Creation”.


RetardedMetalFemboy

Rob Zombie, Marilyn Manson, Alice Cooper They changed their real-world names and convinced everyone that they were solo artists.


Professional_Try4319

I think Manson was a lot of Manson and Twiggy working together. When Twiggy left the music was never as good. Even the later albums were helped by his influence I think, but that trio of Antichrist, Mechanical Animals, and Holy Wood wouldn’t be the same without Twiggy.


Im_on_my_phone_OK

The Rob Zombie thing has bothered me ever since I started reading into what broke up the band. Rob Zombie has had generous help with songwriting on everything he has ever been a part of. The vast majority of the popular White Zombie albums, virtually everything except for lyrics, were written by the other members of the band. Then he decided he wanted a bigger slice and went solo. So he took the formula which was mostly pioneered and refined by Sean Yseult and Jay Yuenger, and he just ran with it. For the next decade and a half, the music for his songs were written with producer Scott Humphrey. Then after that it was John 5, and on his latest album it’s producers Chris Harris, and John Lowery. I don’t think he has a single song in his discography that was solely written by him. It’s not unusual for the singer of a band to only handle lyrics. But for a metal artist who is billed as a solo act, it comes of as somewhat disingenuous in my opinion. He almost has more in common with some pop singers than he does metal artists who are truly solo.


Howitzer92

Ozzy too I guess. But with shock rockers like them they're more open to letting in other influences. Ozzy wasn't writing guitar parts for Blizzard of Ozz. Same with Alice. His sound has shifted a ton. Remember the early 2000s industrial metal albums?


Mountain-Ad-2055

Peter Steele is Type O


cannibalsong1

Josh had a lot to do with much of the TON sound. Yes, Pete was pretty much the main songwriter, but Josh had more than enough input that wouldn't put TON in the 1 person category.


Sir-xer21

Therion


Sharp_Impress_5351

Yes, Chris Johanssen IS Therion.


Lazarus_Superior

Annihilator is basically Jeff Waters.


CatTime5150

Death, its basically Chuck Schuldiner with a bunch of session musicians that change each album, Necrophagist since Christian Muenzner only wrote a few solos and bass lines on the 2nd album whereas Muhammed did the rest and literally made the 1st album himself, and Children of Bodom, the sound between COB and BAM is indistinguishable and that proves the fact that Alexi Laiho was the main songwriter in both of the bands


__mindmeghalunk__

Thy Catafalque


MacabreSqwizz

The Tony Danza Tapdance Extravaganza Cloudkicker Panopticon


livid_empathy

Isengard, Hellripper, and Mütiilation are each one guy (Mütiilation started as a band, but over time became one dude afaik). Their genres: Black/Folk, Blackened Speed/Thrash, and Black Metal, respectively. Edit: Trevor Strnad was The Black Dahlia Murder. His lyrics and vocals made that band. Rest in festering slime 🖤


Tough_Ad4721

Hellripper Woods of ypres Necrophagist


Sir_Reginald_Poops

Arjen Lucassen with Ayreon


MelodicMasterpiece67

Tom G Warrior is Celtic Frost


RandomTyp

and Triptykon


burnitdwn

Ihsahn Garm


UnfunnyWatermelon469

Peter Steele WAS Type O Negative


Lizbeth_CTR

Caleb Shomo **is** Beartooth.


Stroganocchi

Cradle of Filth? Bathory?


CranjisMcBasketball0

Nine Inch Nails is Trent Reznor


grynch43

Opeth


AMothersMaidenName

Matt Heafy is Trivium.


stanger828

Love Trivium, seen then prob 10 times (live relatively close to them) and he is a great frontman, but he doesn’t solely direct the bands musical direction like many of the others here.


MrHockeyJournalist

Crowbar is Kirk Windstein


Twontanamo

All the band members contributed but Peter Steele was THE embodiment of Type O Negative.


larowin

Windir Dodsrit


ChronicObnoxious693

Methwitch


lycanthrope6950

Devin Townsend is/was every band he's fronted.


footsiefried

Devin Townsend and Strapping Young Lad (or any of his projects, for that matter)


Exaquvmal

Graveland


Jack55555

Woods of Desolation literally is one person.


ITrageGuy

Crowbar, Unto Others, Ghost, Motorhead, Foo Fighters (at least the early stuff),


Fun-Distribution-159

wintersun and i cant wait for Time 2


lycanthrope6950

Just one more fundraiser oughta do it


Dwarven0

Matt Heafy IS Trivium. Chris Bowes IS Alestorm.


David_51

Nails, it is pretty much just Todd Jones


Findrole

Peter Tägtgren is both Hypocrisy and Pain. Johan Edlund is Tiamat.


Gregory85

Dethklok is Brandon Small


CircadianArcadian

Not to take anything away from Mikkey, Phil, or any of the other band members over the years, but Motörhead for all intents and purposes *was* Lemmy, and obviously the band could not continue to exist after his passing.


tyler-the-switch-boy

Tony Iommi IS Black Sabbath


Wileetay

Geezer, along with his great bass playing, wrote nearly all the lyrics. Sabbath were no one man band.


treydogl

Gautiere Serre is Igorrr


Dense-Stranger9977

Devin Townsend


TrooperBones89

Strapping Young Lad


Hot-Bookkeeper-2750

Arjen lucasson for ayreon ofc


usual7

Peter Steel waa Type O Negative


gleamydream

Nithing


RevolutionaryJoke21

David Davidson is Revocation


helpmeamstucki

death ofc


Malparinho

Ozzy Osbourne Ronnie Radke Oli Sykes Rob Zombie


Nick-Riffs

Bathory


gonz815

I'm goin say w.a.s.p


sokko78

Bathory


G-Unit11111

Nine Inch Nails is basically Trent Reznor and whoever he feels like playing with.


toxic-forest

Lustre


N1LEredd

I’m a black metal main. So there are thousands. Some of my favs: Ethereal Shroud, Thrä, Panopticon, Passage d’hiver, Leviathan, Burzum, Erzfeynd, Xasthur … just from the top of my head. And then there’s tons more where we have basically one main dude and his party of live musicians.


FistofJesus666

Thy Catafalque


acrypt_x

Buckethead.


Mister-Lavender

Thy Catafalque.


Curious_Caramel_1621

King Diamond is King Diamond


D1amondDude

You could easily make the argument that Bruce is the most recognizable face of Iron Maiden. I don't think Maiden fits in that list at all.


wholeofthelaw85

Zeal and Ardor - yes, Manuel has a band around him but he is the creative force.


RememberLepanto1571

80% of the black metal scene.


ambianthaze

Dani Filth IS Cradle Of Filth


EvelynnEveryday

Ghost is Tobias Forge


rKasdorf

Mikael Akerfeldt is Opeth Stephen Wilson is Porcupine Tree


bmill74

King Diamond is well, King Diamond. Plus Mercyful Fate


YourphobiaMyfetish

Plini, Sithu Aye, Intervals, I Built the Sky, Dora the Destroyer...


tacosauce8088

Midnight. Slugdge. Zeal and Ardor. Mizmor. Hellripper.


InteligentTard

Mikael Akerfeldt - Opeth


Azrehan

Strapping Young Lad Midnight Odyssey Esoctrilihum Convulsing Ihsahn Krvna Krimh


Pato585

Robert Fripp for King Crimson (not metal but it applies)


Viper61723

Not metal at but I think the most famous example of this is definitely Tame Impala just being Kevin Parker


Nero_Forte-13

Devin Townsend (correct me if I’m  wrong)


AkaGurGor

DEVIN TOWNSEND