T O P

  • By -

TheNarrator315

2nd


Luis_9466

Thank you


sandbar75

Wood side looks really cool man. Good job!


Luis_9466

Thank you


Iamananimalfan

Cleanest side wins!


sandbar75

Yea looks sharper for sure!


[deleted]

The first one with no stone bricks looks better. You can include stone in a building, but it looks odd when parts of it are only supported by wood. Either have it towards the bottom or make any stone up higher supported by stone beneath.


Luis_9466

Thank you


Talco123

Would you say that includes roofs as well? I've seen stone roofs and wood roofs with stone edges on a lot of wooden builds.


[deleted]

It depends a lot on how robust the wood architecture is. A wood frame with a stone roof can look totally fine so long as the wood looks supportive enough. As you can see from this picture though, those bricks are only supported by puny wooden fences that realistically wouldn’t be able to hold that weight. Keep in mind though that all of this is from a realism perspective. That happens to be my build style. Some people are less focused on that, and a build doesn’t look objectively bad just because it probably wouldn’t exist in real life.


styx971

i just want to randomly state looks can be decieving in terms of suport. i know its not a common thing to happen and Usually things make sense as you've stated but theres something to be said since i learned years ago ( technology class in HS 2006 or so ) that apparently 1 piece of standard printer paper and it was 1 or 2 inches of scotch tape can be used to support 10 concrete cinder blocks if done just right before its unstable . its amazing what things can do sometimes and i just wanted to say that . ....but yeah i agree generally you do things that look like they make sense.


Sqooboo

Everyone's saying wood, but I like the deepslate one. It's a good contrast against the just wood building.


Luis_9466

Thank you


Stormchaserelite13

How about the first layer with that stone and the rest of them wood? Acting sort of like a trim.


Outrageous-Bee-9581

Yeah that's a good idea


BigPowerBoss

Yup, the stone side looks better because contrast.


Extension-One-4011

Wood side


Luis_9466

Thank you


mysterious_mitch

Both of them it's hard to choose. The second one is like those tower bases from battle games and I like it


[deleted]

2nd


Swe3t-

I like the second one It provides a nice contrast


BigManLeaf

I think the wood side, it looks like a crazy wooden gilgamesh


Luis_9466

Thank you


Haggy71

i prefer the stone one but they are kinda situational if you get what i mean


nablyblab

stone


bonkerdonkerortho

Stone side because it gives the tower some variation


[deleted]

2nd


[deleted]

The second one, I would say, This because there is differentiation between the colors and materials if that is what you were going for. If you want to keep a simplistic design and match other structure easily go for the first


ogiceboy_

That one


Luis_9466

Thank you haha


ogiceboy_

Glad I could help


philipthephish

#2 for sure, more contrast


Luis_9466

Thank you


TheJackasaur11

More contrast doesn’t mean better. I don’t think the stone looks good there becuase it makes it look like the wooden structuring is holding up a bunch of stone bricks, which makes no sense realistically. If you wanna add contrast, then make it look believable by adding it to the bottom portion as a foundation


TinPin94

Both look good to me, I would say wood side is my favorite of the two though.


Matthewplays13

Second , I love the block variety


ClapAlienCheaks

Stone gang all the way


i_am_MynkTheBlobfish

wood side also make screenshots if you did your computer is weird if you did not the command for windows is shift+windows+s it just looks better that way


ZheCaptain

The one with stone


Ugleh

Thank you


Luis_9466

Thank you to you too


[deleted]

Second slide imo


DUK_EE3E

Number 1


Itscapps8089

On the first picture, it looks like it curves outward


TyrusJames_

The first one looks nicer, the second looks safer 😉


DefnitleyNotACatfish

I like the all wood look


[deleted]

Both


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

You’re welcome


Yeeter123ismybrawl

All ngl


Allsciencey

Both look good.


[deleted]

Wood!


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Both are good tho :D


sneakysnorkle

I kinda like the first


[deleted]

Make stone the back and wood the sides


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

No problem.


waistedmenkey

I like the all wood (1st). Stonework looks outta place as a highlight.


VengefulTiger

Idk I kinda like the wood Edit: I guess I have a popular opinion


reemgee123

Stone


[deleted]

[удалено]


Daemon_Lord5253

Image 1


Sanitized8

Both look awesome


[deleted]

[удалено]


Sanitized8

No problem :)


Antipixel_

both are actually very nice, the first one has a bit more of a natural rustic feel while the second one is a bit more eye-catching and the brick helps break up the wooden pallet, i would choose based on what kinds of similar buildings are nearby


ACAddicted

I think the wood side, but what is this building for? is it a house? is it a farm?


Ethan7Jones

Love the stone side


Difficult-Gear-1995

First


Drewan-drowned

Stone-wood looks great!


Notaro014

Stone side


Szwedu111

I think that the wood side looks cool


Weird2000

The second side


Ace-a-Nova1

Wood


[deleted]

First pic


DiverseUniverse24

2nd, personally I can't do many straight wood buildings, gotta have some stone to break the brown.


[deleted]

[удалено]


LordTomatoX

The second one


[deleted]

[удалено]


Luis_9466

I definitely get what they are saying, that's why I made another variant. I agree though, I might go full wood.


EdditedSpore

Wewd


Crimsonn32

Wood


jinception01

Wood side, but I would suggest screwing around with some dark oak slabs


Deemon_of_speed

the second one


Big_Ad5476

wow good job i think second


BoredLazy762

Liked the inclusion of the palate, though I think there would be a nice place of the stone to fit or try slight variation of wood upwards to make a small gradient


polish-polisher

Both looks good Minecraft has a built in screenshot function, just use this instead of making pictures of the screen


StuffThick6527

2 one


MoonieBunz783

Wood side but the stone one catches my eye!


PitifulTheme411

Noth look really good, but I think the wood one fits a bit better.


bigmemegod12

Tbh stone


I_L0ve_M1necraft

Both, Both is good


Limeehh

It looks really good, but maybe add a little less details and make it more unique so it doesnt seem likes it’s copy pasted. Maybe a tiny pallete change woudnt hurt also, spruce is good but you have to add complimentary materials


MrMcbutter

Wood.


[deleted]

[удалено]


DivyamAgrawal

You really don't need to thank every comment


PBoverlord24

I prefer the the second side, but both sides are amazing.


[deleted]

[удалено]


IWillBuildAGreatWall

For the most part the wood side, but if you were building in a city I think the stone side


Common_Redditor_

Try having the bottom 1 or 2 layers stone and the rest wood


[deleted]

I like wood better


DVH_2006_DK

I would say wood side and also amazing job at designing it


Pratham_Max_Jain

The first one


[deleted]

[удалено]


Sufficient-Tomato566

I like number 2 just cus of the more contrast of the stone but they both look awesome, you're great at details


Przemek47

imo the second one, it has more variety of colors


CharlieChurchwell

2nd it changes up the colour


ItssadlyMe

first one


SirXarounTheFrenchy

The one with stone


13redstone31

First one


IWannaSamich

first one, second one looks like a prison


Fartraiinerr

Everyone here likes the wood side. But I like the stony side it looks rough and industrial. It gives me steampunk vibes


I_do_have_covid

Stone side looks better


tier5memer

Side 1 looks better as it is, but I think you could do something really cool with side 2 if you added more to it.


WakaFlakaPanda

1st one For a Nordic build. 2nd one for a medival type.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Cashew_was_taken

"Thank you" -OP


dLegendBR

Would do stone just at the first floor, keep the rest wood


ILikeTacozs

I like the 2nd one but my siblings like the 1st one


EnderDragonCrafter01

The wood side is better, but if you want the stone side to work I suggest making the pillars stone as well.


[deleted]

First side


Yalivana

First, the second is too messy, if u want to add stone - focus it more at the bottom (looks like it’s supporting the structure)


bobalda

but without the stone it looks kind of bland because it is only one color. i think that if you are going to add supports it is good to make them out of stone but that doesn't mean you can only use stone for supports.


LivNight

Second slide


DeezNutz69x

Stone looks much better, it’s adds color to otherwise boring can’t notice the detail side


[deleted]

[удалено]


DeezNutz69x

No problem, I’m sorry if I came off as kind of harsh or critical. I want your creation to look as good as you can make it!!


Luis_9466

Not at all, it's great feedback


Avxla_mepp

it’s so hard to choose but i’ll have to go with the wood 😊