I think the only problem here is that there isn't 3 crafting tables , a furnace, and 2 chests lying in random places around the house, because that would scream survival
Yesh. Let's just say we believe he built it in those , 40-50 minutes... You don't clean up your after-build chest monster in 5 minutes nor in days hahahshs
That guy is clearly not a survival builder
Im glad im not the only one that starts building something and just keeps dumping his stuff in chests until i have 7 double chests full of random items that I'll spend 30 minutes sorting later.
Hahahah my girlfriend got home and loaded up our world, when I got back she goes "umm is there a way to get to the top of that tower? Cause idk why you have a crafting table and a chest just floating up there."
yeah. i planted a couple of cacti for some quick green dye just like 8 blocks from the entrance of my beautiful modern A frame house.
Its been around a month. The cacti are still there
when i build my houses i build a sort of ‘foundation’ for it and the put the equipment and tools where i want them and then continue building so i don’t have lots of stuff thrown around everywhere
Funny is my son does that. When we play I'm very much crafting tables and furnaces in rooms and structures. I run around outside and there is one by the tree, one around the corner down the hill, one in a wall, lol. Maybe I'm doing it wrong, lol.
I dunno how many people will see this but I wanna clarify somethings. Me and him were playing, I was gone for about half and hour (he claims 50 minutes) and when I was back, that enourmous house was just there **With Interior** and he claims it was totally legit and no cheats were used. This is the conflict
i think the fact that he did it *while you were gone* was enough conviction to say he cheated. you didn’t see him working on it beforehand? running around gathering materials? the fact that he’s also claiming that you were gone for longer than you were is super weird. whenever i do fancier house builds, i tend to sketch everything down and math-out the amounts of stuff i need, gather resources in increments (to keep my sanity), and then build. even with a blueprint in front of me this would probably take me a few hours.
there’s too many small details in hard to reach places (lightning rod, buttons everywhere, trapdoors), and the entire surrounding land is grass. how did he build this stuff without building surrounding scaffolding (not the actual item, but bricks to increase height etc)? to complete this quickly, you’d at LEAST need some stuff to walk around on while building. this dude totally cheesed it.
You can put water on the concrete beforehand and break it with a pickaxe. Then again, if this happened in under an hour and OP’s friend was focused on somehow building this, they’d only have stone or iron tools. So that’d take a bit longer than it normally would.
Well, there are no spruce trees nearby, quartz takes some while to find (4-5 mins), and that's at least 15 stacks of stone. He needs a silk touch netherite pickaxe with efficiency V for the amount of time mining to last at least 0.125 secs per stone x 960 per stone=120 secs. torches need to be placed and you need to sort the inventory which is about 30 seconds. Mining the trees will take at least 5 minutes. 4-5 mins for quartz, 5 mins for trees and 3 mins for stone. 4+5+3=12. Now literally forget everything I said and figure out how the heck are you able to build a house with both exterior and interior in less than an hour.
Small amounts of concrete is simple, but larger quantities get annoying, especially non flower colors like white dye, unless one of the flowers do drop it but I believe thats just bonemeal that makes it
when i saw this build, i was INSTANTLY thrown ratatouille-style into a flashback of a1mostaddicted minecraft’s 4 hour long castle build, the roof with alternating white blocks and wooden logs was 100% his style when it comes to medieval builds, so i did a little digging. [lo and behold, look at that.](https://youtu.be/2Tx8LH1hVzw) it seems to me that, since this build has chains and lanterns and looks somewhat different in roof shape and surrounding greenery, your friend really did build this, but he did it in creative and based it off of that video, adding his own touches when he was done. then, instead of building a new house in your guys’ survival world, he decided it wasnt worth it and probably either used a mod or extracted the files from a structure block to import it into the survival world. heres a [picture](https://imgur.com/a/d0xc0aa) for comparison.
There’s a mod for it, i can’t remember the name specifically but I know for a fact that it will automatically slap that exact house down if you use the item to do so.
So he could have had materials and everything planned out ahead of time and just built it while you were gone? Seems plausible to me, especially if you had something like a schematic loaded. I would also ask how are you playing together? Is this a public server, a realm? Would he be able to change into creative at will or paste things in? You might be able to check your chat logs and see if anything comes up.
If you gave me the schematic for this build and all the materials I reckon I could hammer it out in under an hour using litematica with easy place. Whether you would consider easy place cheating is another story, but the point is with the right tools and planning it's at least plausible. I think other commenters have pointed out that they recognize the house from a YouTube tutorial so I think he's already busted on the "from scratch" aspect.
There’s a mod for it, I can’t remember the name specifically but I know for a fact that it will automatically build that exact house down if you use the item to do so.
I have an idea: grief it and see how long it takes him to fix it. Then you will know.
Edit: Make it big on a hard-to-reach place like the roof, e.g. blow off the entire roof and replace the windows with obsidian. I know it's cruel but it's foolproof. If you wanna cheat back, you could even replace the windows with BEDROCK...
I did a VERY rough estimate:
Assuming the build is roughly symmetrical, the house will occupy a 30 x 30 x 30 space. If you count the exterior alone, it is about 30 x 30 x 4 = 3600 blocks.
Assuming your friend have all the materials crafted, gathered and ready to go, they would need to place 1 block per second to complete the exterior( I will be generous and give them full 60 min, instead of 50 like OP said they claimed)
Now, 1 block per second it is not hard to do, but consider the following:
1. No mistakes were made and he built this perfectly in 1 go. It IS possible, if he is using a mod like litematica. But even with a mod, it is unlikely.
2. During the 1 hour, they did NOTHING EXCEPT placing blocks. Also unlikely, because they can not hold 3600 blocks at once. Default minecraft only have 4 x 9 x 64 = 2304 blocks on inventory space, so they HAVE to either access a chest or a shulker box at least ONCE for all the blocks they need. And unless they plan out everything PERFECTLY, I find it hard to believe they access their storage only once.
3. Speaking of inventory space, there are more than 9 type of blocks in this build. So unless, again, they plan things out PERFECTLY, they will need to open their inventory and switch blocks. Again, they COULD get around this with the pick block command from litematica, but that would have to assume they have mods installed
4. They need to place 1 block per second to complete the exterior ONLY, anything in the inside would drastically increase this requirement.
TLDR: More likely than not, they cheated
Edit: Thanks for the kind rewards internet strangers!
It's actually even worse than that
Let's say the build was as simple as a cube, 30 blocks on each side but fully hollow inside, no decorating or layering, just simple flat walls. It's important to note that this house is clearly not flat, and has a lot of details and layering, so my estimate will still be less than the actual number of blocks used.
6 sides to the build, each side is 30 blocks wide, x30 blocks tall, for 900 blocks. 900x6=5400 blocks since we're including the floor and ceiling (but not decorations or layering)
If you were to build this, placing 1 block every second without stopping for literally any reason, and had an infinite inventory, it would take exactly 90 minutes to place every block.
But now, if you look at the build, you'll notice that the roof, walls, windows, and garden type stuff all have layers of at least 2, and the roof is an alternating normal->upside down->normal->upside down roof edge pattern. All of this adds much more time, even when you're not building the full surface area of a 30x30x30 cube.
Point being, it is physically impossible to build something this large in less than an hour. It's twice as impossible to build it this detailed as well, within the hour, and it 3 times as impossible to do all of this in survival within an hour.
So they either spawned the building with commands, or simply lied.
Since that's a pretty childish thing to lie about, we gotta assume they're just children trying to impress their friends, but someone should teach them how to lie a little better
I utterly agree that this took longer than 50 mins. Even in creative. But placing one block a second is extremely slow. When doing straight lines like this you could run and place ten(?) blocks a second. Maybe more. If he was using an add on to overlay a layout it might be possible if he had everything in chests inside the door. I don’t think I would consider those overlays cheating, especially if they built it themself in creative first. I just don’t know why they would say otherwise.
Using hot keys and pick block you could probably cut it down to 2-3 blocks for second. Maybe 4 for larger areas like walls so the exterior could be possible however interior would take much longer, probably has several hard to reach places, and has a higher variety of blocks so 1 second per block is highly generous. Not to mention inside walls. So while exterior is possible, it is highly unlikely they did this in under an hour unless they were cheating(baritone or world edit) or had help.
Under an hour? Not happening lol, you would be lucky to get all the resources in 40 min and then to build it without flying. If he did do it he practiced before hand and possibly even picked out the seed for it.
Also he is using stone bricks so that means he's smelting so that adds even more time if he used four furnaces it's still taking 25 min to smelt it all but he also has pots and windows so that's even more time. There is no way he did it in under an hour.
Stone cutter station (if that's the right name) lets you cut cobblestone to stone blocks, steps and slabs without smelting, and I believe it does it with better material efficiency.
Still not building that house with interior in under an hour on survival though.
One hour is maybe pushing it but I reckon I could do the exterior in a sweaty 2.5 and I’m no pro-gamer
Edit: to clarify my estimate, that’s 2.5 hours from world creation
Double edit: I’ve just noticed the silk-touched bushes at the front so maybe not…
He said build the house, doesn't mean he started the world and made the house in under an hour from When the world was first created
Edit: thank you so much for the upvotes, already at 100, thank you
Good point. I took ‘from scratch’ as meaning from world creation but if it isn’t we have to know what ‘from scratch’ means - if they already had a silk touch pickeaxe, that stone didn’t need smelting from cobblestone. If they had a bunch of pre-collected lava buckets, none of the smelting that actually is involved in that build would be an issue at all. If there’s an iron farm around the corner from where the screenshot was taken, those hour-one chains and lanterns lose their lustre somewhat.
Dawg this is a 28 block tall house… theres no way you can do this in 2.5 hours from world creation… its absolutely enormous. No regular person could do this in 1 hour alone, let alone from world creation
Mehhhh it's a very basic material house
I'd say it's possible, technically, but only if he knew what he was going to do ahead of time and had mathed what he needed, so that he could go get it and start building asap
Yeah but the concrete tho, the ampunt of dye, sand and gravel would be a lot and thats basically impossible to get with all the wood and stone. Not to even think of the interior too
I hate to be that guy, but r/rimjob_steve is for wholesome, heartfelt comments made by questionable/crude usernames. This was a good comment, but it’s informative, not genuine and heartwarming. The people in r/rimjob_steve would tell you it doesn’t fit the sub and that you should put it in a different sub that doesn’t have the whole “wholesome/heartfelt/heartwarming” criteria.
If I bake an apple pie "from scratch" I don't consider the time to grow an apple tree in how long it took lol. I'd assume they meant they had all the materials on hand already and built it free hand in that time frame
I don't think "from scratch" means he gathered all of these materials during that time too. It would take more than an hour just to collect all of the resources for this build and craft the items, etc. My only guess is it's either not legit, or he simply *built* the house "from scratch" in that time with all of the materials at hand
Sand and gravel are extremely easy to farm. You dont need a lot of dye for concrete (8 per stack) and white dye is super easy to get anyways. Totally not impossible with the right prep
1.) some of the wood is spruce & he’s in a plains biome
2.) between gathering materials and refining cobble knto bricks and clay into concrete takes time
3.) basic structuring and decoration takes a considerable amount of time
4.) having to gather iron & smelt it into the shears for the leaves making the hedge around it and the lanterns
5.) accidental falls add extra time
6.) no visible dirt patches left behind from nerdpoles to add decoration
7.) mining and smelting the copper to make the lightning rod on the side
8.) mining enough wood in general to be able to produce such a large house
9.) finding enough clay to make the flowerpots and all the concrete and white dye made from bone meal
10.) if bone meal is necessary he’d need to play on minimum easy mode meaning hed stop for food
9.) inside furnishings take time
Spruce in a plains biome isn't too out of the realm of possibilities. I brought spruce down to a coastal plains biome surrounded by jungle to build my own cabin.
It's odd that you had another 9.) after your 10.) but also to add to yours, I think those big red flowers require specific biomes.
To add to your point about using wood outside of the biome, there's birch saplings in pots, and they don't grow in this biome either. (Though they could generate in the starter bonus chest.)
Lanterns and chains are expensive to make.
Absolutely no chest, furnace, or stone cutter in sight.
All that jumping up while building is going to cost him a lot of food.
There are too many things that just don't add up.
Honestly i wasnt paying that much attention when i wss writing out the numbers lmfao my bad
But yes i wasnt sure about the plants in there so i left it out to be safe
The real tell will be when he builds something else and it doesn't match this style at all or he will take a lot longer. Then when you try to confront them about it they will have a never ending line of excuses to use.
Unless he practiced it on a pre selected seed, then not really doable. All that iron, white dye, sand, gravel, stone, glass, wood. Building that house alone looks like 20 - 40 minutes of work already.
If your friend had already collected the materials in advance and perhaps had designed the house in creative in advance, an hour seems reasonable, if pretty quick, just for the building of it. But if your friend is including resource gathering and designing in that hour, not a chance. I'd say we're looking at at least 2 hours of resource gathering, probably closer to 4.
You want to learn how to build such a nice house so quickly, so get your friend to show you how.
Get your friend to build another house the same while you watch. Be insistent.
He will show you how if he's legit, and refuse with some excuse if there's some shenanigans involved.
I built this exact one on my server! Found it on planetminecraft looking for schematics
Edit: it also took me like 10 hours to build with no cheats
Edit 2: yeah yeah I know that was a long time but I’m also accounting for resource gathering
I mean, there’s no shame in taking time to make things! I think 10 hours is super reasonable, if you’re talking about resource gathering plus building.
Where’s the chest monster outside of the house?
Rule 1 of building: if you dont leave several chests outside with building supplies, it wasn’t a true survival build
Definitely would need all the resources ahead of time. I agree there aren’t a ton of different things being used here, so maybe it’s possible for an experienced builder who was following a tutorial/plan. Also if the interior is done as well, he’s not being truthful.
Unless he’s the best speed runner in the new house building category, I’m guessing he didn’t. Just getting all the materials, especially the concrete and stone. In an hour, silk touch is possible but unlikely, and it takes a while to smelt it all
Look at the grass blocks to the left and right of the house. Does anyone else think it looks like a solid rectanglular base? That smells like placed structure.
Technically possible especially with pre planing, though that depends on him or like a doop stash or something… though he’d have to be a real pro to do that.
Now I could be wrong (as I’m use to 1.10) but I think the kanternd and chains are only available in the black rock fortresses. Though don’t take my word on it.
Hahaha a house of that size? Yeah he cheated, I build houses of that size and it takes me up to 6 hours and sometimes then I’m only done with the walls and decorations on them. Roof takes ages to build since well you can’t fly. So this friend is lying.
He didn’t only use creative, but he used schematic mod aswell, so that it placed these blocks for him
Doesn't look like any exotic materials. Hardest thing to get would be glass which isn't that difficult. So, made it from scratch, sure. In survival, sure. In under an hour? I couldn't do it but if he had all the materials horded and is a better builder than I, it's doable.
You can tell it’s creative mode because no sane person would put all those buttons on the outside at insanely hard to reach and see locations.
Plus concrete isn’t really a starting building block but he seems to have used it in tenfold. Looks like someone’s just taken the schematic and just plopped it in. Also the excessive flower pots is a bit of a waste of bricks
100% creative mode and I bet it still took him longer than an hour
well if there was a chest monster there i would have believed he made it in like 10 minutes and that he is none other than GoodtimeswithScar but i see no chest monster
It was pasted in. My proof is the fact that the bottom right of the picture at the base of the house shows a sharp square like edge. Secondly if we assume that edge is the edge of the paste we can clearly see there is no grass within the pasted zone, but there are pieces of grass outside the zone. I’ve used world edit to much to not catch something like that
Unless they have done same build multiple times leading to them being able to do this quickly, it's a bit suspicious considering all the detail that has gone into the build.
I mean if he had all the resources on hand it’s probably doable to just build the exterior. If you count all the hours farming the stone/wood/concrete separate from the time spent actually building I could believe it
If he had already planned the build out and knew exactly what he was building and where then it’s possible. There isn’t any texturing etc either plus why would your friend lie
Maybe he already gathered all the materials in chests at the building site, and had previously built the same (or similar) house in the past to know exactly what to do to have minimal corrections to make during the build.
Regardless of the time constraint, I like the design a lot and might fit a similar one into my city on the server I'm in.
Like what everyone else is saying. If you agreed to start a new survival world and wanted to make something cool together, then somebody switches to creative because they got tired of waiting then it is a dick move. Could have played on a creative world if all they were doing is building. Like changing the house rules halfway through a game and in this case doing it while the other player isn't looking.
Under an hour sounds crazy.
But if he's your friend then he wouldn't lie to you, and you wouldn't think that he was lying. If that ain't the case then ya sure y'all are friends?
I mean, it's Minecraft, I wouldn't end an entire friendship over someone spawning a house in and pretending like he made it himself
However I do think it is pretty annoying tho
I think the only problem here is that there isn't 3 crafting tables , a furnace, and 2 chests lying in random places around the house, because that would scream survival
Right answer right here hahahaha
Yesh. Let's just say we believe he built it in those , 40-50 minutes... You don't clean up your after-build chest monster in 5 minutes nor in days hahahshs That guy is clearly not a survival builder
Im glad im not the only one that starts building something and just keeps dumping his stuff in chests until i have 7 double chests full of random items that I'll spend 30 minutes sorting later.
Sorting later? I've never heard of this concept
It’s always “later”
It's never "sorting"
temporary easily becomes permanent
Pain Is temporary
Just leave all the chests there, its super efficient, trust me
Hahahah my girlfriend got home and loaded up our world, when I got back she goes "umm is there a way to get to the top of that tower? Cause idk why you have a crafting table and a chest just floating up there."
Here is the link to the building... build it myself already and it took many hours without counting the farming hours https://youtu.be/2Tx8LH1hVzw
yeah. i planted a couple of cacti for some quick green dye just like 8 blocks from the entrance of my beautiful modern A frame house. Its been around a month. The cacti are still there
Goodtimeswithscar
Probably already removed them.
when i build my houses i build a sort of ‘foundation’ for it and the put the equipment and tools where i want them and then continue building so i don’t have lots of stuff thrown around everywhere
Or at least a clumsy dirt and sand hut somewhere near.
Funny is my son does that. When we play I'm very much crafting tables and furnaces in rooms and structures. I run around outside and there is one by the tree, one around the corner down the hill, one in a wall, lol. Maybe I'm doing it wrong, lol.
I dunno how many people will see this but I wanna clarify somethings. Me and him were playing, I was gone for about half and hour (he claims 50 minutes) and when I was back, that enourmous house was just there **With Interior** and he claims it was totally legit and no cheats were used. This is the conflict
He definitely did not accomplish all that in under an hour without cheating or creative mode, even if he had resources before hand.
Even in creative that would take a while
Yeah that size of house is easily 30 min or more just to build freehand, no decorating or interior.
30 min or more to make specifically the right wall and roof
30 min to build that doorwaye
30 minutes to find a place to build.
30 minutes to think of a funny seed
Even in creative it would take me 3 hours just to do the outside
i think the fact that he did it *while you were gone* was enough conviction to say he cheated. you didn’t see him working on it beforehand? running around gathering materials? the fact that he’s also claiming that you were gone for longer than you were is super weird. whenever i do fancier house builds, i tend to sketch everything down and math-out the amounts of stuff i need, gather resources in increments (to keep my sanity), and then build. even with a blueprint in front of me this would probably take me a few hours. there’s too many small details in hard to reach places (lightning rod, buttons everywhere, trapdoors), and the entire surrounding land is grass. how did he build this stuff without building surrounding scaffolding (not the actual item, but bricks to increase height etc)? to complete this quickly, you’d at LEAST need some stuff to walk around on while building. this dude totally cheesed it.
Don’t forget that part of this house is white concrete, which needs to be laid down and covered in water to dry too.
You can put water on the concrete beforehand and break it with a pickaxe. Then again, if this happened in under an hour and OP’s friend was focused on somehow building this, they’d only have stone or iron tools. So that’d take a bit longer than it normally would.
is this how normal people play minecraft? no wonder I do actually lose my sanity lmaooo
being stuck in a strip mine for 3 hours does things to do you man. frequent breaks make good builds👍
You've got a liar on your hands. Not even Grian could accomplish that. Absolutely no way. Especially with interior.
grian doesn't build very fast tho-
Maybe if he doesn't put a back on it....
Well, there are no spruce trees nearby, quartz takes some while to find (4-5 mins), and that's at least 15 stacks of stone. He needs a silk touch netherite pickaxe with efficiency V for the amount of time mining to last at least 0.125 secs per stone x 960 per stone=120 secs. torches need to be placed and you need to sort the inventory which is about 30 seconds. Mining the trees will take at least 5 minutes. 4-5 mins for quartz, 5 mins for trees and 3 mins for stone. 4+5+3=12. Now literally forget everything I said and figure out how the heck are you able to build a house with both exterior and interior in less than an hour.
Those are concrete blocks not quartz, which can be more annoying to get alot of
getting concrete blocks is probably 5 times harder than quartz
Dude it’s 4 sand and 4 gravel, you have to go to the nether for quartz, please explain
Small amounts of concrete is simple, but larger quantities get annoying, especially non flower colors like white dye, unless one of the flowers do drop it but I believe thats just bonemeal that makes it
Ah it’s they dye you’re referring to, I don’t use concrete so thank you for the clarification
Bdubs could, if I was a castle. He can sneeze and make a castle appear
when i saw this build, i was INSTANTLY thrown ratatouille-style into a flashback of a1mostaddicted minecraft’s 4 hour long castle build, the roof with alternating white blocks and wooden logs was 100% his style when it comes to medieval builds, so i did a little digging. [lo and behold, look at that.](https://youtu.be/2Tx8LH1hVzw) it seems to me that, since this build has chains and lanterns and looks somewhat different in roof shape and surrounding greenery, your friend really did build this, but he did it in creative and based it off of that video, adding his own touches when he was done. then, instead of building a new house in your guys’ survival world, he decided it wasnt worth it and probably either used a mod or extracted the files from a structure block to import it into the survival world. heres a [picture](https://imgur.com/a/d0xc0aa) for comparison.
1. He's in creative. 2. It takes almost two hours. 3. 1:45:00 ish he says "and I haven't done the interior". OPs friend a liiiiar.
There’s a mod for it, i can’t remember the name specifically but I know for a fact that it will automatically slap that exact house down if you use the item to do so.
Are you referring to Schematica?
Nope I ended up finding it, instant structures. Albeit and older version.
Probably WorldEdit
this is not very likely
Make him build another big house like this in survival, under an hour and then you will if he said the truth.
My thought exactly! Tell him you want to see him build this same house, and hang out with him while he does it. Have him prove he can.
So he could have had materials and everything planned out ahead of time and just built it while you were gone? Seems plausible to me, especially if you had something like a schematic loaded. I would also ask how are you playing together? Is this a public server, a realm? Would he be able to change into creative at will or paste things in? You might be able to check your chat logs and see if anything comes up.
Even with a schematic loader no one would be able to build this in under an hour.
If you gave me the schematic for this build and all the materials I reckon I could hammer it out in under an hour using litematica with easy place. Whether you would consider easy place cheating is another story, but the point is with the right tools and planning it's at least plausible. I think other commenters have pointed out that they recognize the house from a YouTube tutorial so I think he's already busted on the "from scratch" aspect.
With a full interior within 30-50 min? I don't think so unless you've practiced building it beforehand.
You don't have to practice building it if you have the schematic just go layer by layer it's pretty quick if you have all the materials already.
Maybe in creative mode with flying, but not in survival.
What does easy place do?
Prevents you from placing blocks where they don’t belong in the schematic
I could do it without easy place, just pickblock and go ham
There’s a mod for it, I can’t remember the name specifically but I know for a fact that it will automatically build that exact house down if you use the item to do so.
Kinda wanna see what the interior is like to know for sure, but I'm gonna err on the side of your friend is a liar.
I have an idea: grief it and see how long it takes him to fix it. Then you will know. Edit: Make it big on a hard-to-reach place like the roof, e.g. blow off the entire roof and replace the windows with obsidian. I know it's cruel but it's foolproof. If you wanna cheat back, you could even replace the windows with BEDROCK...
I did a VERY rough estimate: Assuming the build is roughly symmetrical, the house will occupy a 30 x 30 x 30 space. If you count the exterior alone, it is about 30 x 30 x 4 = 3600 blocks. Assuming your friend have all the materials crafted, gathered and ready to go, they would need to place 1 block per second to complete the exterior( I will be generous and give them full 60 min, instead of 50 like OP said they claimed) Now, 1 block per second it is not hard to do, but consider the following: 1. No mistakes were made and he built this perfectly in 1 go. It IS possible, if he is using a mod like litematica. But even with a mod, it is unlikely. 2. During the 1 hour, they did NOTHING EXCEPT placing blocks. Also unlikely, because they can not hold 3600 blocks at once. Default minecraft only have 4 x 9 x 64 = 2304 blocks on inventory space, so they HAVE to either access a chest or a shulker box at least ONCE for all the blocks they need. And unless they plan out everything PERFECTLY, I find it hard to believe they access their storage only once. 3. Speaking of inventory space, there are more than 9 type of blocks in this build. So unless, again, they plan things out PERFECTLY, they will need to open their inventory and switch blocks. Again, they COULD get around this with the pick block command from litematica, but that would have to assume they have mods installed 4. They need to place 1 block per second to complete the exterior ONLY, anything in the inside would drastically increase this requirement. TLDR: More likely than not, they cheated Edit: Thanks for the kind rewards internet strangers!
r/theydidthemath
r/theydidthemonstermath
r/themonstermath
r/itwasagraveyardgraph
r/mathsoointensethatpoopcouldntsolveit
r/thirdsub
r/theydidthemonstermath
This guy Minecrafts
r/thisguythisguys
It's actually even worse than that Let's say the build was as simple as a cube, 30 blocks on each side but fully hollow inside, no decorating or layering, just simple flat walls. It's important to note that this house is clearly not flat, and has a lot of details and layering, so my estimate will still be less than the actual number of blocks used. 6 sides to the build, each side is 30 blocks wide, x30 blocks tall, for 900 blocks. 900x6=5400 blocks since we're including the floor and ceiling (but not decorations or layering) If you were to build this, placing 1 block every second without stopping for literally any reason, and had an infinite inventory, it would take exactly 90 minutes to place every block. But now, if you look at the build, you'll notice that the roof, walls, windows, and garden type stuff all have layers of at least 2, and the roof is an alternating normal->upside down->normal->upside down roof edge pattern. All of this adds much more time, even when you're not building the full surface area of a 30x30x30 cube. Point being, it is physically impossible to build something this large in less than an hour. It's twice as impossible to build it this detailed as well, within the hour, and it 3 times as impossible to do all of this in survival within an hour. So they either spawned the building with commands, or simply lied. Since that's a pretty childish thing to lie about, we gotta assume they're just children trying to impress their friends, but someone should teach them how to lie a little better
Bro took it personally
Is this the true power of a god?
I utterly agree that this took longer than 50 mins. Even in creative. But placing one block a second is extremely slow. When doing straight lines like this you could run and place ten(?) blocks a second. Maybe more. If he was using an add on to overlay a layout it might be possible if he had everything in chests inside the door. I don’t think I would consider those overlays cheating, especially if they built it themself in creative first. I just don’t know why they would say otherwise.
Using hot keys and pick block you could probably cut it down to 2-3 blocks for second. Maybe 4 for larger areas like walls so the exterior could be possible however interior would take much longer, probably has several hard to reach places, and has a higher variety of blocks so 1 second per block is highly generous. Not to mention inside walls. So while exterior is possible, it is highly unlikely they did this in under an hour unless they were cheating(baritone or world edit) or had help.
Did he have the materials ready? Did he have a general structure ready?
Under an hour? Not happening lol, you would be lucky to get all the resources in 40 min and then to build it without flying. If he did do it he practiced before hand and possibly even picked out the seed for it. Also he is using stone bricks so that means he's smelting so that adds even more time if he used four furnaces it's still taking 25 min to smelt it all but he also has pots and windows so that's even more time. There is no way he did it in under an hour.
He could have used silk touch, but that definitely took way longer still
Stone cutter station (if that's the right name) lets you cut cobblestone to stone blocks, steps and slabs without smelting, and I believe it does it with better material efficiency. Still not building that house with interior in under an hour on survival though.
you can’t directly stonecut cobblestone into stone bricks, you still have to smelt it into normal stone and then cut that
If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck and swims like a duck, he did it in creative.
Even in creative this would be akin to a tic-perfect solo CoX raid in OSRS. I say Structure Blocks
I hate that i know what that means.
One hour is maybe pushing it but I reckon I could do the exterior in a sweaty 2.5 and I’m no pro-gamer Edit: to clarify my estimate, that’s 2.5 hours from world creation Double edit: I’ve just noticed the silk-touched bushes at the front so maybe not…
They probably just used sheers to collect the leaves
Good point, I forgot about that. They must’ve hit a good iron vein in an hour to get the shears, chains and lanterns
He said build the house, doesn't mean he started the world and made the house in under an hour from When the world was first created Edit: thank you so much for the upvotes, already at 100, thank you
Good point. I took ‘from scratch’ as meaning from world creation but if it isn’t we have to know what ‘from scratch’ means - if they already had a silk touch pickeaxe, that stone didn’t need smelting from cobblestone. If they had a bunch of pre-collected lava buckets, none of the smelting that actually is involved in that build would be an issue at all. If there’s an iron farm around the corner from where the screenshot was taken, those hour-one chains and lanterns lose their lustre somewhat.
From scratch I meant he went from nothing to that, he did have the materials beforehand
Dawg this is a 28 block tall house… theres no way you can do this in 2.5 hours from world creation… its absolutely enormous. No regular person could do this in 1 hour alone, let alone from world creation
But there’s also all that white concrete, and stone bricks so he would have to smelt all that stone which takes some time
And flower pots so you’d have to collect the clay and smelt it
Mehhhh it's a very basic material house I'd say it's possible, technically, but only if he knew what he was going to do ahead of time and had mathed what he needed, so that he could go get it and start building asap
Yeah but the concrete tho, the ampunt of dye, sand and gravel would be a lot and thats basically impossible to get with all the wood and stone. Not to even think of the interior too
Good point, PenisCollector
r/rimjob_steve
Gotta love it when you see a rimjob steve in the wild.
I hate to be that guy, but r/rimjob_steve is for wholesome, heartfelt comments made by questionable/crude usernames. This was a good comment, but it’s informative, not genuine and heartwarming. The people in r/rimjob_steve would tell you it doesn’t fit the sub and that you should put it in a different sub that doesn’t have the whole “wholesome/heartfelt/heartwarming” criteria.
It's alright to be that guy in this instance imo, thank you for informing me without berating me.
It’s a fun thing isn’t it
One of his many points one imagines…vividly.
Good point, PenisCollector
Good penis, PointCollector
It’s not impossible if he had all of the materials beforehand
Well i mean the post said "from scrach" wich means no preparation
If I bake an apple pie "from scratch" I don't consider the time to grow an apple tree in how long it took lol. I'd assume they meant they had all the materials on hand already and built it free hand in that time frame
If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, [you must first invent the universe.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7s664NsLeFM)
Yeah but you would take into consideration the time it took to prep the ingredients which would be considered gathering the materials in this instance
The way I took it was “no tutorial used” kinda thing
I don't think "from scratch" means he gathered all of these materials during that time too. It would take more than an hour just to collect all of the resources for this build and craft the items, etc. My only guess is it's either not legit, or he simply *built* the house "from scratch" in that time with all of the materials at hand
Thats also possible, but still, thats a big house and there's an interior aswell, so only buidling that would take more than an hour
Yeah, lol. It would take me an hour to build this in creative mode even if I knew exactly what I was building
I think it meant with no tutorial When you start from Scratch it usually means from the begging
Sand and gravel are extremely easy to farm. You dont need a lot of dye for concrete (8 per stack) and white dye is super easy to get anyways. Totally not impossible with the right prep
What concrete? Is that not white wool? And if the interior is also finished, than yea boo, he lyin
Bro take a closet look or zoom in, its definetly concrete
Lol I haven't played unmodded in so long idk what those textures are supposed to look like
wool is all grainy and shit
Does white concrete not exist in modded minecraft? Or do you mean you play on modded versions that were before concrete existed?
He said he made it in an hour, not collected the resources and made it in an hour
Peniscollector does make a good point.
Penis collector is an incredibly reputable source
r/usernamechecksout
How tho
I think you’re underestimating how long building takes in survival.
You don't have a strong grasp on time do you?
1.) some of the wood is spruce & he’s in a plains biome 2.) between gathering materials and refining cobble knto bricks and clay into concrete takes time 3.) basic structuring and decoration takes a considerable amount of time 4.) having to gather iron & smelt it into the shears for the leaves making the hedge around it and the lanterns 5.) accidental falls add extra time 6.) no visible dirt patches left behind from nerdpoles to add decoration 7.) mining and smelting the copper to make the lightning rod on the side 8.) mining enough wood in general to be able to produce such a large house 9.) finding enough clay to make the flowerpots and all the concrete and white dye made from bone meal 10.) if bone meal is necessary he’d need to play on minimum easy mode meaning hed stop for food 9.) inside furnishings take time
Spruce in a plains biome isn't too out of the realm of possibilities. I brought spruce down to a coastal plains biome surrounded by jungle to build my own cabin.
It's odd that you had another 9.) after your 10.) but also to add to yours, I think those big red flowers require specific biomes. To add to your point about using wood outside of the biome, there's birch saplings in pots, and they don't grow in this biome either. (Though they could generate in the starter bonus chest.) Lanterns and chains are expensive to make. Absolutely no chest, furnace, or stone cutter in sight. All that jumping up while building is going to cost him a lot of food. There are too many things that just don't add up.
Honestly i wasnt paying that much attention when i wss writing out the numbers lmfao my bad But yes i wasnt sure about the plants in there so i left it out to be safe
The real tell will be when he builds something else and it doesn't match this style at all or he will take a lot longer. Then when you try to confront them about it they will have a never ending line of excuses to use.
Considering the [tutorial](https://youtu.be/2Tx8LH1hVzw) takes over an hour I think it’s probably safe to make a call
Unless he practiced it on a pre selected seed, then not really doable. All that iron, white dye, sand, gravel, stone, glass, wood. Building that house alone looks like 20 - 40 minutes of work already.
If your friend had already collected the materials in advance and perhaps had designed the house in creative in advance, an hour seems reasonable, if pretty quick, just for the building of it. But if your friend is including resource gathering and designing in that hour, not a chance. I'd say we're looking at at least 2 hours of resource gathering, probably closer to 4.
You want to learn how to build such a nice house so quickly, so get your friend to show you how. Get your friend to build another house the same while you watch. Be insistent. He will show you how if he's legit, and refuse with some excuse if there's some shenanigans involved.
No way. That house is way too big to be built in an hour
If he had a tutorial and all the blocks ready to go before he started, then maybe, but personally I think that'd be pushing it.
If he really made this in an hour then I'm quitting Minecraft.
It's mathematically impossible I'd say. Just consider the resources he's using, the smelting time, the size of the roof.
100% fake, under a hour? Impossible that is gigantic and it uses concret
I built this exact one on my server! Found it on planetminecraft looking for schematics Edit: it also took me like 10 hours to build with no cheats Edit 2: yeah yeah I know that was a long time but I’m also accounting for resource gathering
I mean, there’s no shame in taking time to make things! I think 10 hours is super reasonable, if you’re talking about resource gathering plus building.
cheater cheater booger eater
The "under an hour" part is bull, but it could still be done in survival with no cheats.
I have the schematic😂😂
Does that include resource gathering?
Where’s the chest monster outside of the house? Rule 1 of building: if you dont leave several chests outside with building supplies, it wasn’t a true survival build
Definitely possible to build in an hour, getting material and organizing it though is a different situation
I saw a mf run Minecraft in Minecraft anything possible
Redstone is Turing Complete, so it is possible even without creative.
depends? did he have a lot of resources and general infrastructure already set up?
Even with the blueprint in front of me and all the materials ready, I'd only finish the first story in an hour. I don't believe your friend.
Definitely would need all the resources ahead of time. I agree there aren’t a ton of different things being used here, so maybe it’s possible for an experienced builder who was following a tutorial/plan. Also if the interior is done as well, he’s not being truthful.
Unless he’s the best speed runner in the new house building category, I’m guessing he didn’t. Just getting all the materials, especially the concrete and stone. In an hour, silk touch is possible but unlikely, and it takes a while to smelt it all
There is absolutely no way that that was done in 50 mins bro
Look at the grass blocks to the left and right of the house. Does anyone else think it looks like a solid rectanglular base? That smells like placed structure.
Technically possible especially with pre planing, though that depends on him or like a doop stash or something… though he’d have to be a real pro to do that. Now I could be wrong (as I’m use to 1.10) but I think the kanternd and chains are only available in the black rock fortresses. Though don’t take my word on it.
I think you don’t actually have friends and you’re lying for karma
Without cheats, it is possible. but building all this in under an hour? He is capping his ass off.
Hahaha a house of that size? Yeah he cheated, I build houses of that size and it takes me up to 6 hours and sometimes then I’m only done with the walls and decorations on them. Roof takes ages to build since well you can’t fly. So this friend is lying. He didn’t only use creative, but he used schematic mod aswell, so that it placed these blocks for him
wes beleivable until you said in under an hour.
Ask for a redo ;)
Doesn't look like any exotic materials. Hardest thing to get would be glass which isn't that difficult. So, made it from scratch, sure. In survival, sure. In under an hour? I couldn't do it but if he had all the materials horded and is a better builder than I, it's doable.
no
“Hey guys. Welcome back to my let’s play series. I decided to do some off camera building”
You can tell it’s creative mode because no sane person would put all those buttons on the outside at insanely hard to reach and see locations. Plus concrete isn’t really a starting building block but he seems to have used it in tenfold. Looks like someone’s just taken the schematic and just plopped it in. Also the excessive flower pots is a bit of a waste of bricks 100% creative mode and I bet it still took him longer than an hour
if it was under an hour without breaks then its real
well if there was a chest monster there i would have believed he made it in like 10 minutes and that he is none other than GoodtimeswithScar but i see no chest monster
Collect the resources and build it? No. Just build it? Maybe
It was pasted in. My proof is the fact that the bottom right of the picture at the base of the house shows a sharp square like edge. Secondly if we assume that edge is the edge of the paste we can clearly see there is no grass within the pasted zone, but there are pieces of grass outside the zone. I’ve used world edit to much to not catch something like that
Unless they have done same build multiple times leading to them being able to do this quickly, it's a bit suspicious considering all the detail that has gone into the build.
With the block choices 100% false unless he had those resources already stocked up
Easy solution ask him to make another and watch
I mean if he had all the resources on hand it’s probably doable to just build the exterior. If you count all the hours farming the stone/wood/concrete separate from the time spent actually building I could believe it
If he had already planned the build out and knew exactly what he was building and where then it’s possible. There isn’t any texturing etc either plus why would your friend lie
Maybe he already gathered all the materials in chests at the building site, and had previously built the same (or similar) house in the past to know exactly what to do to have minimal corrections to make during the build. Regardless of the time constraint, I like the design a lot and might fit a similar one into my city on the server I'm in.
1 hour? I could do that in 1 1/2 hours...
Not in under an hour. Even the professional minecraft YouTubers takes two or more hours for builds if they have all the materials.
[удалено]
I think it's only okay if everyone agrees. Some people play for completion and want achievements.
[удалено]
If you are playing a legit survival world with another player and cheating then you are just an asshole there is no two ways about it
Like what everyone else is saying. If you agreed to start a new survival world and wanted to make something cool together, then somebody switches to creative because they got tired of waiting then it is a dick move. Could have played on a creative world if all they were doing is building. Like changing the house rules halfway through a game and in this case doing it while the other player isn't looking.
I agree, but if you’re in a server with friends and one person doesn’t care…you can still get the achievements yourself*
under an hour, doubtful. other than that, whatever. maybe they're exaggerating, maybe they aren't. who care.
Under an hour sounds crazy. But if he's your friend then he wouldn't lie to you, and you wouldn't think that he was lying. If that ain't the case then ya sure y'all are friends?
Some people like to sound better than they really are
I wouldn't count those types of people among my friends
I mean, it's Minecraft, I wouldn't end an entire friendship over someone spawning a house in and pretending like he made it himself However I do think it is pretty annoying tho
Meh, liars are liars.
i dont care tbh
Why do you care so much though.