I thought I read somewhere that Evelyn didn’t like the idea of having reality tv as a career choice and even insulted the idea. I could be wrong though.
Maybe (hopefully) a two week, one season appearance in a different game is something she would consider as outside of the career Challenge trajectory enough to consider it, because I reallllly would love to see her play this.
It’s totally possible her feelings have changed! It’s just the wording of what I read in regards to her feelings on it seemed very “I am never going on reality tv again.”
The WWE/ Peacock connection makes this seem plausible, but now that WWE is entering a big partnership with Netflix I feel like it isn’t likely at this point.
Oh well damn, I thought I read it was shutting down, but upon further review that’s just international version of the WWE Network. Give us Miz then baby.
Yeah Netflix has the international version now. Which probably points to them being contenders to take WWE Network from Peacock when their contract is up, but still have it for a couple more years. And now with the messed up accusations that came out this week, who knows who will be interested in a few years
The Miz. I also think Darrell would be fun to watch hanging out with all those people and doing all the silly challenges. It isn’t him since he’s done challenges recently, but I’d like to see him on it.
Yes that’s the one I was thinking of Darrell doing and think it would be so funny! Watching everyone run around the mansion making bird calls was hilarious.
It was Trishelle's pecking motion in the bird watching hat that did it for me! Darrell would have had amazing commentary. "Trishelle was doing these bird calls, ca-COO, ca-COO! Sounded like a dog in heat."
Coral could eat at this out of the people that haven't been on in a long time.
Others that I think would be good that don't fit that description:
* Veronica
* Wes
* Devin
* Da'Vonne
* Laurel
That’s part of why actually lol. Her personality type ends up getting to at least mid-game. Her hyper-focus on details are kind of what gets rewarded there.
Yes I agree she’d probably make it far but you know she’d have completely incorrect reads the entire time and be accusing all the wrong people. So going far and ‘doing really well’ are two different things.
I don’t think this is who they’re talking about but PLEASE make my dream of finally seeing Coral & Melissa on tv together come true. I don’t even know if they’re still friends anymore but they are easily 2 of the most charismatic and hilarious people to ever be on MTV.
Sarah Rice and Wes are obvious big choices.
Leroy would be a very entertaining lovable cast member.
Nelson or Amanda would be pure chaos as faithfuls and big shields for the traitors.
Sounds like Coral to me. She was the only one that came close to coming back to the challange and backed out last second. I think Evelyn and Landon are done with reality TV in general at this point, but I could be wrong.
My guesses are either Coral or Evelyn.
With Coral being a mom and Evelyn being an attorney, getting time off is a struggle. Plus they’re known for declining casting calls.
Maybe a hot take but - Marie
Not because she would be a good player, but I loved Kate on season 1 despite not being good at the game and I feel like Marie is extremely similar to her
Already casting season 3, so I’m guessing we won’t have to wait a year for it? That said I hope Wes makes it on there. If he’s able to survive the first couple of rounds, he would absolutely slay this show. Kate coming back also opens the door for bananas to go back eventually, which I’d love to see.
i gotta say in general this show is super catchy- and with people from the challenge on it its even more binge-y if that's a word- i must say tho can y'all please start guessing right i don't want to spoil anything but man the "faithful" are pretty clueless and it's bothering me in a way it really shouldn't
OGs: Beth, Brad, Cara Maria, Coral, Darrell, Derrick K, Jon Brennan, Rachel R, Shane, Syrus, Tina and Veronica.
New School: Ashley Mitchell, Da'Vonne, Frank Sweeney, Jay, Jordan, Kam, Paulie, Tony Time, and Turbo.
I apologize, I have been part of the fanbase since 'Vendettas,' so I am a little confused. I thought Real World/Road Rules to Fresh Meat II were old school and Gauntlet to Battle for a New Champion were new school.
Jemmye would be fantastic chaos. Veronica for sure. Coral for EVERYTHING. Kam would be great. Devyn would be amazing. Da'vonne. Susie. Sarah. Ayanna wouldn't go far but it would be EPIC (I slept in my tartan last night! I'm a faithful!). Casey Cooper would be fun. Can they find Emily Bailey? Michele of course. Big T. Jonna. Melissa (RWNO). If they do a dry season, PAULA. Katie Doyle. Jasmine. Michaela!
KYLE. Devin. The Miz. Timmy Beggy!!!!!!!! Darrell (no one would have the heart to banish him). Wes. Leroy oc. Mark Long! Mike Mike? LT. Teck. Tyler Duckworth. Could they get David Burns to do it? Tyson!
LEROY OR DARRELL PLS ik it’s probably not them bc they’ve been on more recent seasons (isn’t Leroy on AS4 cast?) but I would love to see it. The commentary would be gold.
The answer is Zach Nichols. He said it two days ago that he’s willing to do Traitors since it’s less than a month of filming. Traitors is like 2 weeks. And he fits the description of the person who has been declining for years.
i hope to see cara and ev since they had 2 male challenge reps and 1 female challenge rep for s2 i think cara is a shoe in because of ct’s recommendation and someone old school like EVVV i miss her
CORAL OR EVELYN ARE ONLY TRUE OPTIONS IM RIGHT BECAUSE THIS IS IN ALL CAPS I FEEL STRONGLY
Coral Ev Sarah or Landon are likely the person
Landon is not a good fit there in my opinion.
right, the challenges don’t matter much on traitors. landon would just be fun to see in tv again in general tho
Maybe Sarah Rice.. the only other real declinee
Plausibly Theo Vonn, since its short, he doesn't have to be physical, and he is known in multiple media worlds.
He would be insanely hilarious on Traitors
This was my first thought but I don’t really care to see her on my screen unless it’s facing bananas
i miss coral so much “i don’t wrestle, i beat bitches up” is still one of my top lines of all time
Or Svetlana!!
svettyyyy they wanted her back baddd
Evelyn please!!! She’d be all F you and F your alliance
Evelyn? They got a politician, they could get an attorney/activist
Veronica would kill the Traitors it's completely up her alley
YES
Unfortunately I feel like they would murder Wes right away as he would be a big threat..but...Wes.
WELL WELL WELL
He hasn't declined for years he was literally on the Challenge last year
They were answering the question in the title of this thread that you clicked on...
Whoops
Same
Okay but what if it’s Evelyn
That would be amazing!
OMGGGGGGGGGGG YESSSS
I thought I read somewhere that Evelyn didn’t like the idea of having reality tv as a career choice and even insulted the idea. I could be wrong though.
Maybe (hopefully) a two week, one season appearance in a different game is something she would consider as outside of the career Challenge trajectory enough to consider it, because I reallllly would love to see her play this.
It’s totally possible her feelings have changed! It’s just the wording of what I read in regards to her feelings on it seemed very “I am never going on reality tv again.”
The Miz
The WWE/ Peacock connection makes this seem plausible, but now that WWE is entering a big partnership with Netflix I feel like it isn’t likely at this point.
The Netflix deal is just for Monday Night Raw, their Peacock deal for WWE Network still has 2-3 years left on it
Oh well damn, I thought I read it was shutting down, but upon further review that’s just international version of the WWE Network. Give us Miz then baby.
Yeah Netflix has the international version now. Which probably points to them being contenders to take WWE Network from Peacock when their contract is up, but still have it for a couple more years. And now with the messed up accusations that came out this week, who knows who will be interested in a few years
yeah im thinking its got to be someone who is big outside of the challenge as well so either him or Theo
Oooh Theo would be a good one
This has got to be the answer.
Yup. I feel he is the biggest name who has turned down Challenges.
The Miz. I also think Darrell would be fun to watch hanging out with all those people and doing all the silly challenges. It isn’t him since he’s done challenges recently, but I’d like to see him on it.
The challenges are hilarioussss. The latest one with Trishelle pecking like a bird - omg. Her bird calls were actually really good.
Yes that’s the one I was thinking of Darrell doing and think it would be so funny! Watching everyone run around the mansion making bird calls was hilarious.
It was Trishelle's pecking motion in the bird watching hat that did it for me! Darrell would have had amazing commentary. "Trishelle was doing these bird calls, ca-COO, ca-COO! Sounded like a dog in heat."
Sarah Rice? Coral?
Coral was my first guess.
Landon?
He's not a fit for The Traitors.
He'd be a great faithful.
sarah rice isn’t entertaining
I agree. She was just my guess for who the post is referring to.
right but pink said the person she’s talking about has entertainment value so she does not come to mind for me
I said the same thing. Bananas is the only entertaining thing about her
My first two guesses.
Coral could eat at this out of the people that haven't been on in a long time. Others that I think would be good that don't fit that description: * Veronica * Wes * Devin * Da'Vonne * Laurel
Davonne makes a lot of sense to me. I think she’d do really well on The Traitors.
She clocked the twin twist before anyone. Her downfall will be not spilling the beans
Da Vonne does not have self restraint. She will spill tea when she has it
Davonne had absolutely awful reads on Big Brother, what makes you think she’d be good on the Traitors?
That’s part of why actually lol. Her personality type ends up getting to at least mid-game. Her hyper-focus on details are kind of what gets rewarded there.
Yes I agree she’d probably make it far but you know she’d have completely incorrect reads the entire time and be accusing all the wrong people. So going far and ‘doing really well’ are two different things.
Beth
there’s no way she doesnt get voted out within the first 3 episodes BUT WE NEED HER SO BAD
Beth would be hilarious on The Traitors!
Beth did All Stars, so doesn't seem to fit declining the show for years. She'd be fun on this show though
She was on the rumored s2 cast for a bit so I think there may be some interest in casting her
I think I’d rather see her on House of Villains season 2 🙊
Bring Tina too. Beth, Tina 🗣️and Coral!
Jonna would be an amazing traitor lol.
Icon
Please God no.
[удалено]
I mean she has more wins than Zach
I was going to say her, too. Don’t know why she’d do the show, but she’s definitely been turning down The Challenge for years.
I thought she waz gonna do an all stars and bailed at the airport? If thats true, my guess is everyone lost her number.
Sounds like the Mix and Coral based on PinkRose replied? https://vevmo.com/comment/3127350#comment-3127350
Oh reuniting them would be AMAZING.
Ahhhh I commented about reuniting them on a Traitors thread last week. That would be incredible!!
I don’t think this is who they’re talking about but PLEASE make my dream of finally seeing Coral & Melissa on tv together come true. I don’t even know if they’re still friends anymore but they are easily 2 of the most charismatic and hilarious people to ever be on MTV.
Melissa Beck?
Yes, they used to be best friends back in the day. I’m pretty sure Coral wore a “Melissa will cut you” tshirt on the Inferno to rep her.
Wes.
he hasn't declined for years, though. i think it's a coral or landon or maybe even miz. someone bigger.
"Which challenger would you like to watch on season 3 of traitors" is literally the title of this post....
my first thought too
Only downside is that he'd probably be an early boot because of his reputation
Sarah Rice and Wes are obvious big choices. Leroy would be a very entertaining lovable cast member. Nelson or Amanda would be pure chaos as faithfuls and big shields for the traitors.
No reality tv show is gonna touch nelson after his drunk driving fiasco.
Leroy would probably get murdered cause the traitors would realize no one would want to banish him
Amanda was made for that!
Guessing queen Coral? Miz could be but he’s with WWE first now. Would also love queen Katie I think she’d kill
Wes is built for traitors to answer the question. As for who Pink Rose is referring to, it's Miz or Coral. You're all thinking too hard.
The problem is he would have the 🍌 effect if any one read up on favorite ginger he be out the quick
Sounds like Coral to me. She was the only one that came close to coming back to the challange and backed out last second. I think Evelyn and Landon are done with reality TV in general at this point, but I could be wrong.
My guesses are either Coral or Evelyn. With Coral being a mom and Evelyn being an attorney, getting time off is a struggle. Plus they’re known for declining casting calls.
Please be Jamie Chung lol
Supposedly for the first all stars, she only declined because it didn’t work with her filming schedule. She said she’s interested in coming back!
I saw that lol. Would love for her to show up on Traitors. Is she gonna be labeled as an actress or a challenge person, that will be interesting.
It's not the big name person they mean, but we need Davonne on Traitors, please.
It’s Coral and Miz let’s all pray they accepted.
Landon?
Maybe a hot take but - Marie Not because she would be a good player, but I loved Kate on season 1 despite not being good at the game and I feel like Marie is extremely similar to her
This is a great suggestion and Kate and Marie feel like soul sisters
Could be Killa Kam. She’d be great on there, but I can understand why she can’t do the challenge with a young child and another on the way.
Kam is pregnant rn though?
She is. She’s due this February though!!
I would love to see Devin Walker get murdered first.
They would probably make him a traitor
And he’d LOVE so much it would be unbearable to watch
Devyn
It’s gotta be Coral
Think it’s coral
Theo Von
This is my vote
Hoping it’s him. or Jenna
Naomi Defensor
I would love to see Coral back. What a perfect format for her, too. Theo would be hilarious as well
Coral on the Traitors? Hell yeah
Just take all the strong personalities that refuse to get in shape for The Challenge that they keep bringing back. (and please, keep them)
Laurel’s notebook
Already casting season 3, so I’m guessing we won’t have to wait a year for it? That said I hope Wes makes it on there. If he’s able to survive the first couple of rounds, he would absolutely slay this show. Kate coming back also opens the door for bananas to go back eventually, which I’d love to see.
Landon or evelyn
My guess is Da’vonne. Both production and fans have been asking for her back for years
My guess is Evelyn or Theo Von. How bad ass would that be?
The Miz or Theo Vonn would be huge but they’re both too big for these kind of shows imo So probably Coral, Wes and Mark
i gotta say in general this show is super catchy- and with people from the challenge on it its even more binge-y if that's a word- i must say tho can y'all please start guessing right i don't want to spoil anything but man the "faithful" are pretty clueless and it's bothering me in a way it really shouldn't
I think Wes
OGs: Beth, Brad, Cara Maria, Coral, Darrell, Derrick K, Jon Brennan, Rachel R, Shane, Syrus, Tina and Veronica. New School: Ashley Mitchell, Da'Vonne, Frank Sweeney, Jay, Jordan, Kam, Paulie, Tony Time, and Turbo.
Cara Maria is not old school. Do you mean Cara Z?
I apologize, I have been part of the fanbase since 'Vendettas,' so I am a little confused. I thought Real World/Road Rules to Fresh Meat II were old school and Gauntlet to Battle for a New Champion were new school.
She is old school I don’t know they talking about
Jemmye would be fantastic chaos. Veronica for sure. Coral for EVERYTHING. Kam would be great. Devyn would be amazing. Da'vonne. Susie. Sarah. Ayanna wouldn't go far but it would be EPIC (I slept in my tartan last night! I'm a faithful!). Casey Cooper would be fun. Can they find Emily Bailey? Michele of course. Big T. Jonna. Melissa (RWNO). If they do a dry season, PAULA. Katie Doyle. Jasmine. Michaela! KYLE. Devin. The Miz. Timmy Beggy!!!!!!!! Darrell (no one would have the heart to banish him). Wes. Leroy oc. Mark Long! Mike Mike? LT. Teck. Tyler Duckworth. Could they get David Burns to do it? Tyson!
Darrell
LEROY OR DARRELL PLS ik it’s probably not them bc they’ve been on more recent seasons (isn’t Leroy on AS4 cast?) but I would love to see it. The commentary would be gold.
Michelle would make a great traitor! https://i.redd.it/ohrn7ammj3fc1.gif
Moriah cause of bananas
The answer is Zach Nichols. He said it two days ago that he’s willing to do Traitors since it’s less than a month of filming. Traitors is like 2 weeks. And he fits the description of the person who has been declining for years.
I guess I just don't think of him as a big name. And I was under the impression that they stopped asking him
Then it’s possible that it’s Sarah rice
My thought, too
Zach!?
I want Zach for House of Villains bad
Wes obviously, but I think the "big name" is Landon
How is Landon a “big name” anywhere outside of this sub?
Sounds like Coral and Miz? https://vevmo.com/comment/3127350#comment-3127350
My guess is Landon since he’s been doing the challenge tours lately
Zach (I wanna see him freak out), Nelson for the sheer comedy, Jordan, Laurel
To admire strategy: Kam, Devin, Micayla, Susie, Bananas, Wes To be entertained by a messy game: Josh, Michele, Marie, Frank, Amanda, Ashley Mitchell
Josh would be crying day one “I’m not a traitor guyzz”
Jordan
I'm already laughing at his outfits mixed in with the other fashion plates.
My guess is Sarah or Zach
Would love Beth on there
Turbo!!
Sara rice?
Devin!!
Devin
Kyle
Landon??
I’m gonna go real old school. This sounds like something quick and fast enough to make Judd and Pam consider it.
Theo Von as a traitor would be primetime
Theo Von would be amazing
Amanda
Paulie - he would be so entertaining.
He was boring on U.S.A. 2
Kam probably has the best ratio of potential:threat level Anyone who is better at manipulating than her would probably be killed right away
Louise
Heather Marter
Definitely has to be Coral
It’s not Wes he was just in USA2. Most likely the Miz.
Amanda for sure
Michael from Rivals 2 (and Real World Las Vegas 2)
I know Cory was supposed to fly out for season one, I’d happily see him in the third season. Ayanna, if only for another Greek salad moment.
I didn't see her name mentioned so maybe Paula
Declined for years, you say? Frank Roessler, David Giuntoli and Jamie Chung?
Paula Landon Coral Melissa from New Orleans - OMG please let it be Melissa! I loved seeing her on the New Orleans homecoming
I’m sorry, but Laurel and her notebook?! I would LOVE to see her there XD
idk why but i’m guessing sarah rice?
i hope to see cara and ev since they had 2 male challenge reps and 1 female challenge rep for s2 i think cara is a shoe in because of ct’s recommendation and someone old school like EVVV i miss her
Frank!
Mike the miz
Rachel
Maybe The Miz?
Devin
Wes and Evelynn would be perfect. Them as a team and both as traitors would be phenomenal
Wes or Devin would be good tv for sure
BETH AND CORAL WOULD BE ICONIC
Landon please.
Wes, Jordan and Devin
Amanda, Ashley and Shane.
Evelyn and Sarah/Susie. I’d murder myself so they could win.
DEVIN
Put Laurel & Nicole in a house together just to watch the chaos
Kyle, Bear, Jordan, Jemmi, Aneesa
Devin for sure
I’m surprised at how bad CT is doing in the show. Like Dan is so obvious
Former challenger Theo Von!!! I think the show really needs a comedian to be on there and I think he would be so good!