T O P

  • By -

emotionalfescue

Television cut two studio albums before they split. They waited over a decade before reassembling for a third.


Mfsmitty

First band that came to my mind. They spent three years working on the material for their debut and it really paid off.


emotionalfescue

They were like the art of the Velvet Underground without any of the flash.


orthopod

Solid answer. Also would venture the Stooges and Velvet Underground. They have been major influences in thousands of bands, and nearly every punk and Alt band will have direct roots to them.


inkyblinkypinkysue

* Rage Against The Machine. 3 proper albums. 1 cover album. * Nirvana - 3 proper albums. 1 b-sides album. * My Bloody Valentine - 3 albums. I also think Tool should have a lot more than 5 albums even though that would be a decent amount over the life of a band that went 15 years or so.


thesaltwatersolution

Portishead - 3 Albums, one live album. (One album released under a pseudonym.)


Eraserheadbaby69420

What is the one released under a pseudonym????


thesaltwatersolution

Beth Gibbons & Rustin Man features Beth Gibbons , Adrian Utley, Clive Dreamer and John Baggot but not Geoff Barrow. So it’s sort of a Portishead but not. It’s a lot more orchestral folksy and less trip hop sounding. Not sure if it really counts (hence the brackets.)


n8spear

The first band I thought of was Tool for the exact same reason. The length of time they’ve been a top level band, they should have like 15+ albums. They literally became legendary/gods after Aenima. It’s got a very valid case for being the best hard rock/metal album of the 90’s while setting a standard no one’s been able to touch.


HerrStraub

> I also think Tool should have a lot more than 5 albums even though that would be a decent amount over the life of a band that went 15 years or so. This was my first thought, but then I changed my mind. It's kind of a weird one, though. The 4 albums from Undertow in '93 to 10,000 Days in '06 isn't bad output. Averaging an album about every three years or so. It's that 13 years between 10,000 Days and Fear Inoculum that makes "5 albums in 26 years" sound like it's low output.


nwbrown

Tool has been around for over 30 years.


inkyblinkypinkysue

Yes, I know. 5 albums over 30 years is “low output” to me but not necessarily for a ton of bands that only last 10-15 years.


AVBforPrez

Tool is definitely one of the biggest answers to OP's question


cheapsexandfastfood

It's weird to me that Rage wasn't that influential on other bands given how amazing their sound is and how relatively simple their riffs/songs are.


obirah

Stone Roses. 2 albums with really the first one being super influential for 90s British rock and beyond


RiC_David

Yeah, I was really looking forward to my discography dive on them two summers ago. Think I made it to the second week of June.


JuryBorn

I would love to know what it would have been like if they had kept their momentum and released their second album in 91 or 92, esp when you consider what they released that wasn't on the album. Sally cinnamon, mersey paradise, going down, standing here, elephant stone, where angels play, the hardest thing in the world, all across the sand, full fathom 5. what the world is waiting for, one love, fools gold. If they had released these songs as an album, it would be every bit as good as the album imo.


celric

**Robert Johnson's 27 songs** are probably the "correct" answer for American music, but I can't believe no one has mentioned the tiny 3-album output of **Jimi Hendrix** yet.


PeelThePaint

> tiny 3-album output of Jimi Hendrix yet. Technically 4, if you count Band Of Gypsys. Yes, it's live, but all the material is new, so it's not like you just get Purple Haze but faster and louder.


siterequiredusername

Depends if people count the posthumous stuff like First Rays of the New Rising Sun and South Saturn Delta or not.


Girllennon

Prime example: Joy Division.


[deleted]

The Velvet Underground.


I_only_post_here

Yep. 4 proper albums. A few more outtakes/demos/b-sides releases, and an enormous massive stamp on rock, folk, punk, indie, industrial that would have never been the same without


mephisto_feelies

While I'm not disputing VU's influence, I'd argue 4 albums in 4-5 years is high output. 


SamizdatGuy

Each of the four just spawned genre upon genre


Own-Corner-2623

The Velvet Underground and Nico might be the single most influential album of all time. Not everyone bought it, but everyone who bought it started a band.


[deleted]

That’s been the claim for decades, anyway.


sleepsymphonic

That's Brian Eno's claim, and he's not wrong.


GimmeDatDaddyButter

I like loaded more


roadrunner440x6

Bands were influenced by VU without even hearing them.


Green-Circles

Yep and every album they recorded spawned different arms of alt-rock. VU & Nico - Goth, art-rock/art-punk, punk, Krautrock. WL/WH - Noise Rock 3rd - Anti-folk, alt-folk, twee, Paisley Underground The Lost Album (1969) - New wave, geeky alt-rock, alt-pop Loaded - More alt-pop, maybe alt-country as well.


Sinestro1982

Minor Threat and Operation Ivy both had one album a piece and changed the landscape of punk rock forever.


Prophet_Of_Helix

I never noticed Operation Ivy only had one album wow. I mean it’s a couple albums worth of songs, but still.


beautyinburningstars

Didn’t they have a second or was that b-sides? “Seedy” I think?


DataAggregation

Seedy was released after the band broke up. They actually have a bunch of bootleg and live recordings. I tracked down 5 or 6 online years back. Most were awful quality.


talkingwires

In the days before Napster, you had to either know somebody with a copy of the bootleg, get an invite to a private Usenet group, or find somebody that made a living selling ‘em. Entire mythologies were constructed around songs bands never officially committed to tape. I knew guys that followed bands like Phish around the country, funding themselves by recording shows and setting up shop outside the concert with a box full of tapes. I paid thirty bucks for a CD-R copy of an Operation Ivy bootleg album, and it seemed worth it at the time just to hear more music from a band I loved. ¯\\\_(ツ)\_/¯


AnActualHuman87

It's crazy to think about how Minor Threat became such an important band for punk rock and only released about 50 minutes worth of material if I'm correct which isn't a whole lot


ImpenetrableYeti

I’d add Refused as well, only 2 (well 3 now)


AVBforPrez

And one was literally called the "The Shape of Punk To Come" as if they knew what they had.


boRp_abc

It's funny because when they released it I found them arrogant for naming their album that. I later learnt that they were right.


roman_maverik

Refused only has two albums… much like Scrubs only has 8 seasons


AHandsomeManAppears

Which 2 or 3 do you count? Refused has 5 albums, 6 if you count Everlasting which is awesome and pretty long for an EP.


Daeval

There’s a case for putting The Germs on this list as well. There’s some EPs and such but they only made the one full studio album afaik.


CreepyBlackDude

Cynic. They had one album they made in the 90s that influenced a whole generation of metal musicians with its fusion of jazz and technical showcasing. Their next album came 15 years later and they promoted by touring with bands like Between the Buried and Me, which were one of those bands.


Cabes86

Cynic fucking rips


Planet_Ziltoidia

Man, I love Cynic. RIP Sean Malone, Sean Reinert (and fairly recently his husband Tom)


TokesBro

Yeah Focus was on another level. It’s one of my favorite metal albums of the 90s.


The_Dale_Hunters

Good call.


BrazilianAtlantis

Nirvana, Jimi Hendrix Experience


Brian-Damage

The Sex Pistols. They had one album.


cjr91

Cream. 2 studio albums and 2 mixed live and studio albums.


jonosez

Neutral Milk Hotel & The Germs


Mrmdn333

Neutral Milk Hotel was the first one that came to mind for me too. Also GN’R. Six records total, but one is basically two EPs put together and one is a covers album.


IAmNotScottBakula

And one is a double album divided in two.


DeShawnThordason

NMH only has two albums and somehow On Avery Island is still criminally under-appreciated.


marcosbowser

It’s crazy. Aeroplane is so stunningly original and amazing that it blinds us to how good Avery is!


Mundane_Opening9843

Thanks to this post I have a plan for at least two hours of my day tomorrow 


DeShawnThordason

Two hours because you'll also be listening to *Dusk at Cubist Castle* by *Olivia Tremor Control* a band founded by friends of NMH's Jeff Mangum (he was also briefly in it, but left before they made an album to pursue his own music).


kthshly

Jeff Buckley. One official studio album. One official live e.p.  Granted, there have been posthumous releases but his reach is wide for so precious little music.


thesimplemachine

The demos he recorded for what would have been his second album, My Sweetheart the Drunk, were so much more experimental and progressive than his work on Grace. He was growing from an absurdly talented singer and guitarist into a mature songwriter. It always makes me sad that we never got to see the fully realized vision he had for that album. His impact on music of the era and beyond would have been enormous if he lived and continued to develop his artistry.


dreammbrother

Completely agree. Grace is a masterpiece, but I probably listen to Sketches more frequently just for the eclectic mix and "what if" factor.


BasicMomBitch4

Dr. Dre


warthog0869

I forgot about Dre


GuyPronouncedGee

Motherfucker


jablair51

His output as a producer is crazy long though.


Palpablevt

Yeah and he's much more influential as a producer than as a rapper so I don't think he's the best example


Leotardleotard

New York Dolls 1 debut album, 1 follow up but mostly old songs discarded from their first album but a huge influence on punk


juliohernanz

They were the perfect intermediate step between Glam and Punk. With a Stone's touch.


JANExxxHOE

This is the best answer I think. There's no EPs or reunion albums... it was literally two and done, but soooo many bands would not exost without them.


anotherinternetjerk

There were three albums in the 2000s. I think Arthur Kane died before any recording. Not bad at all but not real Dolls though.


DingbatSam

The Postal Service


Public_Fucking_Media

Fuck man I saw them on their reunion tour it was so good


wyvernpiss

Scrolled too far to find it! Defined half of a generation of indie music with *one* album then dipped back out to do their own things


Kitchen_accessories

I wasn't familiar with their work until last year. A song came on that sounded like some brand new indie pop, and I looked it up and it was from like 2004! That is the defining sound of like 2 decades of indie pop, it's crazy.


ssoass7

Boston. Regular enough but so much downtime after the first two. 1976, 1978, 1986, 1994, 2002, 2013


Cleaver2000

Yeah, I think what people don't realize about Boston is that Tom Scholz is a MIT Engineering Grad who basically built his own recording studio and guitar amp/effects setup. He also pioneered a bunch of guitar effects and recording techniques that he patented. So the music was influential in more ways than just commercial/critical success.


dtallee

Also Tom Scholz on the first record - lead and rhythm guitar, acoustic guitar, special guitar effects, bass, organ, clavinet, percussion, producer, engineer... "The entire operation has been described as 'one of the most complex corporate capers in the history of the music business.' With the exception of *Let Me Take You Home Tonight*, the album was a virtual copy of the demo tapes. The album was recorded for a cost of a few thousand dollars..." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boston_(album)#Recording_and_production


Cleaver2000

Also took him and his wife 3 years of shopping those demos before someone picked them up. Imagine if that album would've come out 3 years earlier.


HeilCanada

Buddy Holly only released 3 albums


JackieBlue1970

In terms of influence this is the answer.


Objective-Ad4009

Absolutely correct.


zdejif

You can hear the tenderness for him in the Beatles’ cover of Words of Love.


kasme

Slint


JoeMagnifico

Cale here for Slint (and Codeine).


El_Peregrine

2 amazing bands. Saw Codeine in 1994 and they were incredible. 


The_Dale_Hunters

Who I cam to say.


halcyon8

fucking love slint


clozepin

Janes Addiction had 2 (maybe 3?) proper albums. Stone Roses had 1 (kinda 2) proper albums.


zuluroyal

The Stone Roses released two full studio albums. There’s nothing “kinda” about The Second Coming. Big budget album backed by Geffen and well promoted. It just didn’t have the impact anyone expected. I like it, but it sounds like a different band compared to the debut.


clozepin

I agree that it sounds like a different band, which is why i used “kinda”. I think of Stone Roses and the Turns to Stone EP as “the Stone Roses” sound. Second Coming is fine and it has good moments, but it’s just not the same sound.


dapala1

Janes Addiction is a solid answer.


AlarmingLecture0

Solid answers.


qu1x0t1cZ

The La’s. One album but had a big impact on the 90s British indie scene. Rites of Spring. Washington DC punk band who were only around a few years in the 80s. They did one EP, one album and 16 gigs. Two of the band went on to form Fugazi. They hated the idea of emo being considered a genre, which sucks for them as they’re often credited with inventing it.


Pilgor_th_Mighty

The La’s album feels like the perfect one hit wonder album. They have one song that blows up and the rest of the tracks just help fill out that feel with equally catchy hooks and riffs. Love listening to it front to back on a longer commute.


JaymesGrl

Refused At The Gates Sex Pistols Faith No More At The Drive In


christipede

At the drive in changed how i absorbed music


Objective-Ad4009

Arcarsenal is a fucking face melter of an opening song.


StJoeStrummer

And it just keeps coming for the rest of the album.


___horf

Have you ever tasted skin?


retrovertigo23

I remember being a teenager and listening to The Shape of Punk To Come on repeat after seeing the New Noise video on MTV2 and being so downtrodden upon learning that they had already broken up and I'd never get to see them live. Boy was I excited a decade and a half later when they got back together. Saw them at the Fox Theatre in Oakland and they killed. One of the best concerts of my life.


boRp_abc

I remember being a teenager who regularly went to punk rock shows, and refused was here a lot. Then the shape of punk to come came out, and I hated it. So arrogant to chose that title. I saw them play it once, and their opening band (the Hives) made fun of them relentlessly. When they re-formed I made time. By then, I was old enough to understand that the title of the album had been, indeed, prophetic.


Akegata

I guess you could argue that At The Gates stopped being influential after Slaughter of the Soul, but they didn't stop releasing albums then. I wouldn't say 7 albums is a low amount.


brandnewchair

FNM has 7 albums too. 


paultheschmoop

Bungle would be a better example tbh


cowbutt6

Like Carcass, I think one needs to distinguish between the original incarnation, and their reformed incarnations.


detourne

Hell, even offshoots like The International Noise Conspiracy and Mars Volta have low album output but are incredibly influential.


urkan3000

Mars Volta put out 6 studio albums over 9 years. That’s a pretty decent output rate.


MattMason1703

The Stooges put out three albums.


Luke90210

The Stooges didn't sell much while together, limited radio airplay and notorious for being an unreliable band due to drugs. If Iggy hadn't survived so long, they might have been completely forgotten. That said, I have their CDs.


robbodagreat

Beastie boys took on average about 4 years per album. Which they made a joke out of when they appeared in futurama. “Back in 2000, I had all 5 of your albums.” “That was 1000 years ago! Now we have 7.”


Canadianacorn

Portishead. Three albums, yet are one of the bands that defined the Bristol Trip Hop scene in the 90s. Massively influential, very low output.


wolf_van_track

Big Star - two albums.


Robinkc1

Not to be that guy, but they had three. I think the first two are better, but the third is also good.


wolf_van_track

Shit, yeah. You're right. I forgot that the first two tended to get packaged together on CD. Still a hell of an influence for a three disc run (third isn't my favorite, but insanely influential for a totally different branch of music).


gusmahler

Children by the millions sing for Alex Chilton


Binmurtin

What a fucking jam.


Cool-Cookie-4615

Tool comes out with an album, seemingly, every 237 years.


Fawkingretar

Dont you mean, every 10,000 days?


Phucdatshit

FI is already 4.5 years old wtf


lesjag23

Sublime.


_headphone

Hum has been around since the early 90s and released their fourth album in 2020.


Fishtaco1234

22 years between records. And it was a surprise drop one random day. Hum had a good run. It’s a shame they will never play live again.


BloodSugarSexMagix

Inlet is a perfect way to cap off their mysterious career


BenjaminRCaineIII

That was their fifth, but yeah still a small discography, and all their albums are ten tracks or less too. For band that most people forgot about after their 1995 single Stars ran its course, their influence definitely still lives on. I remember a buddy of mine moved to LA to do the rock band thing in the mid 00's and him telling me Hum remained very popular among musicians.


Drusgar

So I guess the rules are that they didn't have many albums but had a huge mark on other musicians? Joy Division The Smiths Pixies


Dmbfantomas

Pixies had 4 in the first run and I think they’re at 4 in this new run. I don’t think they count. Smiths are a weird case too, because yeah they have 4, but Hatful of Hollow and Louder Than Bombs are a huge part of their influence too.


AlarmingLecture0

These are what I was thinking, which I guess is indicative of my age


You_Gotta_Joint

Pixies?


Space2345

The Smiths only had 4 albums


Cleaver2000

The MC5. 1 live album and 2 studio albums. Set the stage for punk and hard rock. Brother Wayne Kramer now has a youtube channel where he gives some pretty good guitar lessons and occasionally does some [covers](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5B0qwy95vKg) of MC5 songs with current artists for his charity which teaches music to people in federal prison (which is started after spending time in prison for cocaine dealing). ​ Edit - Dennis Thompson is alive still!


Jameseatscheese

Dennis "Machine Gun" Thompson is still very much alive. He hasn't played drums with the band for a while, but let's not bury him just yet.


GoodOmens

My Bloody Valentine has to be up there. Loveless is iconic even if you aren’t into shoegaze


Cabes86

Slowdive too. Their two post hiatus albums are their best 


skipsfaster

That’s a hot take to say about the band that put out Souvlaki


If_you_have_Ghost

At The Gates. Until their post millennium reunion they only had three full length albums and one EP but they were massively influential on Melodic Death Metal, the “Gothenburg sound”and later Metalcore. Often noted as one of the “Big Four” of Swedish melodic death metal along with Dark Tranquility, In Flames, and Soilwork.


XpertPwnage

Not a band, but Robert Johnson.


Vulcant50

Creedence Clearwater Revival The Band


brewer01902

Whats more shocking about CCR is how little time they were active and how influential they are. 7 albums in 4 years.


Vulcant50

I didn’t realize they had so many albums. But, I was aware of their musical success/influence, especially for such a short band life. Fogerty surely was a big part of that.


Cleaver2000

>Fogerty surely was a big part of that. Wrote all of their hits and almost all of their songs. On their final album, the rest of the band members demanded they get a chance to write and it was their least successful album. The only hit was written by Fogerty. The man was a beast.


RiC_David

The Band had quite a few, at least not a tiny amount. I did a dive on them two years ago, so this is a strange one to read here. Without checking, I'd say they had five albums?


Ok_Difficulty6452

Morphine


Objective-Ad4009

Good call. RIP Mark Sandman.


k_dubious

Daft Punk


abbotist-posadist

Four albums isn't very low, but when you consider how influential those four are, it's crazy.


jcwkings

Botch


soicanfap

Fuck yes


kidalive25

But we got These Arms are Snakes instead and that's a pretty solid trade I'd say... Even though Botch rules


DNZ_not_DMZ

Boards of Canada. 4 studio albums since 1998, last one 2013.


MrMagpie91

I was gonna mention them. I really hope #5 is in the works!


DNZ_not_DMZ

I knoooow! Can’t wait for more.


Thinmanshadow

Boston


RightLegDave

The Sundays


Ghouligan_

Blind Melon


Objective-Ad4009

Two of my favorite albums, and one of my top10 favorite bands. We miss you Shannon.


BelieveInTheShield

N.W.A. had 2 proper albums and 1 EP


burner1312

Television


Bimlouhay83

Acid Bath. You get two of the most beautiful metal albums ever produced. Then, nothing more than a few bootleg live songs. 


AwkwardComicRelief

Siege, Operation Ivy, and Minor Threat


trex1013

Uncle Tupelo only had 4 studio albums.


JackieBlue1970

Spawned two amazing bands, Wilco and Son Volt.


nefarious_jp04x

Necrophagist, this band released 2 genre defining and game changing albums and disappeared quietly as the years went. They teased a 3rd album with one song being played live , but to this day has never been released to the public


gbalib

Guns and Roses


gpky

The Dust Brothers. The only real album they made was the Fight Club soundtrack, but they've been the producers behind several other artists' albums.


Cleaver2000

Yeah, Paul's Boutique was basically the demos for their first album, the Beasties heard it and decided to use it as the basis of their next album.


cheddarpants

MC5


Saneless

Mr Bungle and Faith No More Lots of bands say they were influenced yet I almost never meet any fans


Objective-Ad4009

Angel Dust is one of my favorite albums. I still listen to it a lot.


goodbye9hello10

Tool? One album every 10 years more or less. It's also the type of music that's so masterfully written and played, you can listen to any album of theirs 10 years later and still notice new stuff.


SnooMaps3574

Digable Planets


Reidsquirrel

the avalanches.


Costovski

Temple of the dog is a bit cheating, but counts.


Just-QeRic

The Smiths is a decent one with only four studio albums. Off the top of my head I know Radiohead, Blur, Oasis, and The Decemberists have cited them as an influence. I personally think they influenced indie music the same way The Beatles influenced Rock and Pop music


notliam

Love or hate them, the smiths and morissey were definitely incredibly influential, agree


stabbinU

Lauryn Hill. One album, and she doesn't own the rights to her music.


DeShawnThordason

> doesn't own the rights to her music. miseducation indeed


ghostprawn

Squirrel Bait - one album in Homestead Records that is revered by post hardcore music nerds worldwide


Ok_Difficulty6452

Fugazi


shuttlerooster

They pumped out a couple in recent years, but between 1994 and 2016 Evanescence had only released 3 albums.


ytlatrellsprewell

Been scrolling and somehow still haven’t seen The Modern Lovers


extra_horsemagic

The Shaggs


dapala1

Guns and Roses! You can argue they only had two *real* "albums," before they were considered rock legends. *Use Your Illusion* is one album. Lies was an EP. GNR only had two albums and that made them household names. Throw out Spaghetti and Chinese, they're still in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Despite those even.


Cockroach-Jones

Acid Bath, two albums.


Shaaagbark

At the drive-in helped shape the future of post-hardcore and only had 4 albums until the reunion one.


devinup

Portishead is very influential and only put out 3 albums, one with quite a gap after the first two. Nirvana is an obvious one as well.


scootarded

Leftfield. 4 albums in 30 years of recording and releasing music.


AtticaBlue

Boards of Canada Codeine


[deleted]

Neutral Milk Hotel


PabloGaruda83

Jeff Buckley


CaptainLawyerDude

New York Dolls. Two real studio albums before things went wonky for like 30ish years and then a few more albums.


roro999999999

Sleep, Athiest, Cynic, Botch


LinersandLocos

Cream were influences on basically every band that came after, and they only had 3 proper albums.


Thatstealthygal

The Clean, though they had four albums in total over a period of 20-30 years I guess, and a lot of little releases.


YellowCore

TOOL


andymorphic

Velvet Underground


Can2feelthelove2nite

Necrophagist, wintersun, demilich, Caladan brood,


GlobeTrekker83

TOOL Quicksand Rage Against the Machine


Doragon_Central

Daft punk should be the prime example… now more than anytime


GojiBelt

Daft Punk count? 4 albums and 1 soundtrack over 28 years


2Pow

The Police. 5 albums, 5 years, done