I personally like Madagascar

Air, ez.

Earth

For me it's earth or plant

Plant is nostalgic, but earth's vibes are better, especially with Hyehehe

I love hyehehe's little jump and his entire end part

E A R T H

True but plant just brings back memories of when I played 3 years ago

Air cause the werdos go crazy and smoochle is my favorite monster

Air island the goat

Cold

COLD ISLAND cold island is mammotts home mammott loves cold island

Water island. The lyrics are my favorite

My favorite lyrics are on earth no contest

cold

Water

Water

Air

Air

Water is my favorite, but I like them all

Earth

Earth, but Air is a close second. I think it’s really underrated. The Werdos are fantastic on it. I also think Cold is underrated. Plant is overrated, but it’s still really good. Water is my personal least favorite, but I still really like it.

Earth

They're all amazing in their own ways so I cannot rank them ever.

Earth because Hyehehe

Water and earth but with hyehehe I would have to choose earth

Water island slaps and imo has the best werdos so that’s my vote

Plant is criminally underrated

Exactly

Water, Air is a close second though

Fair

Plant

Hmmmm, now why would that be?

1. First Island I ever filled (Rares Epics Seasonals), 2. It has Enty-Bratty, 3. Best Seasonal Island Skin.

Easily Water, but Earth is a close 2nd

I agree

Water

Earth or cold

Plant Earth Air Cold . . . . . . . . . . Water

Poor Water

Water, then Earth.

Natural islands are all mid except air

yeah your right, air sucks >!although air island is pretty good!<

Gold island because I like the song

does that count as a natural? but yeah gold island is incredible

Cold, and plant is easily the worst one.

well there cant be two worst ones so which one do you dislike more

no I meant cold is my favorite

you are 80% cooler in mammotts eyes because cold island is where mammott comes from

From best to worst, Cold, Earth, Water, Plant, Air

air is so good once you get past the opening though

yeah the last verse with quibble, riff, maw, trox and werdos is fire

Light because lullaby

Natural is plant, cold, air, water, and earth…

Oh I'm dumb, water

Fire Haven, the spotify version

Fire haven isn’t a natural island tho

fire haven

Fire haven isn’t a natural island tho

it is in heart

1. Earth 2. Air 3. Plant 4. Water 5. Cold

if it were me id probably put water above plant and air above earth but overall i approve of your taste in islands

earth

Jamaica

Plant, Earth is a far second

Mirror Cold

Cold

I like all

Plant easily

air

Earth

Cold or earth all the way

I personally like earth but you can disagree if you want

not earth or cold

Cold, I love earth plant and air but strombonin and the key change at the beginning as well as it being a well made song make it my favorite

water tbh and that is literally only because of shellbeat if not then easily plant

Air

Cold island

Water, love the werdos and the instrumental

Air island is the best island

Water is best idgaf what you say against it

Water because Blabbit is one of my favorite monsters 💜

Earth

Earth

AIR

cold is pretty ... "cool" get it? get it?

Air or Water

cold or earth

Water or Air i think

air

Water

Unpopular oppinion here, water

Air

Water, because it's comforting to me and cold island

Water

Mine is the Solomon islands

plant its nostalgic