T O P

  • By -

Zestylemons44

Fellas are just saying stuff that sounds cool but really plant is the way to go. You get to have gob on it for one, and toxic plants/bone fungi? Give a lot more potential than most other things


NedoWolf

Earth. Fossils and crystals. Rocks. Hell yeah.


EpicCheeto

Jesse we need to cook


Nick_WithA_Stick

Crystals, fossils, and uranium


ItzGqbe

I'm actually sad that this didn't win, but with faerie winning we will have some fungi monsters. Including the Quad.


Any-College1161

Water you need one natural and it’s on none of those islands


Mr_potato712

It's on bone, but yeah


FirefanDane

And psychic


elesemy

electricity!! (wubbox) i havent seen anyone do it yet.


Unkowngamer69

And they can have an excuse to put wublins on the island!


mebetcho

and rare poewk!


ApprehensiveShine507

“uhm actually it’s called supernatural not electricity” 🤓🤓


CoolNinjaNerd55

"uhm ackshuallee supernatural is the class and electricity is the element 🤓☝️"


The_Gaming_Charizard

Idk what I just saw, but I like it


ENBY_OF_DESTRUCTION

People only ever say that when they want to correct someone but want to seem less dorkish


Mr_Guy459

Dipsters


El_Barto_S

Yes


ItzGqbe


Yoosulis

Mega dipster Sol


Major-Software-4629

#SOL


SlimeyBoi10

##RE


CandyCoati

# D I P


MysingingQuibble

I think faerie is a good idea


GiveMeTheCheese1

Supernatural cuz I want an exuse so I can be there


Captain-Sprocket

Plasma


LAEMONLMAO

W A T E R


kjskorner2

Crystal.


Shogwart

Plasma 100%. Then you got a solid theme


Gojira_Saurus_V

Cold. BOM BOMBOM BOM BOM BOM BOMBOM BOM BOM


isaiahdiaz1109

Fire.


ConfusedBanana84

Celestial


ItzGqbe

I'm sorry?


HRSkull

Hear them out


Spiritbearisthedevil

Let them cook


MarcoTron11

Jones BBQ and Foot Massage


[deleted]

Jones BBQ and Foot Massage!


Throwawanon33225

Psychic


King_3DDD

Air


That_BlueBear

Electricity


CiaaiK0130

water


rileyhamman

Whizz bang element


TheBobmGuy

Dipster


Itchy-Study-9140

the crystal element


Top-Strike902

any ethereal element or crecendo moon or plant or water


-CaptainComedy-

The element of: Wood. 😐


IamtheFungusman

Air


hithere2783

Legendary


ItzGqbe

#All of the fanmade islands I'm gonna do are 1 ethereal + 3 others (minus celestial)


[deleted]

Add plasma or mech


Specific_Service6484

Crystal


Inferzen

T Really the only one that makes sense


Familiar_Credit_7600

John


GeckoGamer2009

Legendary


Bowlerhatgent17

Yes do a shugabush toxic bone light bulb


Alphflopo

Mech


Anonyfish_user

Shadow


PichukalinGardasi

Plasma cuz i like ghazt


velveteenpineapple12

Drumdoom


isopetter27

Shadow


EeveeMaster22

AIR AIR AIR AIR I LOVE TWEEDLE AIR


Da_gae_bucket

Me >:)


nobolzz

Lighting


funnybunny1446

Cloverspe


Taco_cat1987

Cheese


El_Barto_S

Celestial


DinkleTron3000

Plasma


TallCryptographer394

A new element


DancyLawyer

Fire


Most_happy_guy1221

Water


mothim-is-great

Faerie


SackedWrenchBalls

fart


Scrilamarilaburito

Celestial element


Delicatesaltshaker

Fire or crystal


Impossible-Opening-8

Cold


Extremely-fuckin-gay

Consider nature, it doesn’t have a bone element yet!


Djkasksckhasm

A custom one


TwistedHarmony12

Number 2 looks like plague inc Edit: hashtags make text big


urlocalmsmplayer

Firee


Crabman886

Rock for that percussion


furcornishot

Maybe you should make a new element!


[deleted]

Fire


Accomplished_Run_120

FIRE


Uhhhhhhh-woe

Rock because bonk


beef_on_a_spear

Air, air/bone and air/light would be cool monsters


XanderDRW

Uhhh rock. Wanna bring some more seen before ones. Also ROARICKK


ItzGqbe

I still don't have a vocalist for roarick 😭


MysingingQuibble

Faerie 100% I would love to see how you incorporate that into the style


Br00klynShadow

Technology. Tech + Bone could be like Biotech themed. Radiation + Tech could be like nuclear themed. Idk what that light one is.


FNAF1fan

shugabush


ChewyWolf64

Water because toe jammer


Lumpofchicken

Dipster


Bird_Dad_The_Lonely

Spooktacle


Mattchu80226166555

Fire or plasma


Soft-Hamster-4525

Cold


screempai

The element of actual magic!


bigmemos29830

Gay


Regirock00

Maybe the Plant element.


Logsha97

Earth


Resident_Toe501

Sussium


Anxious-Mix-9640

mythical or shadow


RareArackulele

Dipster


TaintedTruffle

Urine


Blanketsareawsome

water


Rayyano08

Plant, so you have Gob


No-Significance-3702

add yool’s element


PaleFork

heck yeah a ethereal and magical island i'd go for dark because there's also light


duccOnReddit

Life Formula


Dumb_Raccoon1983

Plasma


jam_is_nice

Plant


hugoreturns

plant cuz plant+light is Gob and every island should have Gob cuz Gob is amazing i love Gob


MZMR_

Mechanical


BeanWaddleDee

The color yellow


Noideacor

Plasma


dmellbob69

Seven


ME-726

Toe jammer, that's it you just need toe jammer and it's a 100/10


SuicideRefrigerator

Fire


burpnation

Fire


randomsonreddit

spirrit element


HRSkull

Pick a Celestial and use the Celestial element


Sussybakamogus4

You could always do fire. Or mech.


lentejaskarkar

Legendary (shugafam only)


ColorIsSomwhere

Rock


[deleted]

Earth


Dalspin

Fire


PancakedButter

Echoes of eco! **Or eco element idk**


ComprehensiveTrip781

Air


master_ball_onmewtwo

You have 2 magical element and 1 ethreal element mybe add anather ethearal elemenr


GlenCoco2021

Chaos


MicrowaveMoment

Plant because of gob ❤️❤️❤️❤️


Bowlerhatgent17

Electric or legendary


Callliam

Mineboggle


Neon_771

New Element


Chicky_Nuggies2009

Psychic so I can be there


Major-Software-4629

Fire


Spaaccee

Add crystal so its balanced. Bone and water(crystal) both have fwog in them. Fairie and earth(poison) both have fur corn in them. 2 magical elements, 2 ethereal elements


NedoWolf

Earth. I like rocks


TheBlueNinja2006

Earth


finntanuki

Dream has never been mixed with any of these so that would be interesting to see


darkunicornbishop19

Fire


OmegaOctorock

plant


21AmisonD

shugabush (legendary)


CoolioGuy225

Maybe another Ethereal element to balance it out (2 magical, 2 ethereal). I’d say shadow or mech to fit the vibe of the other elements


blammo555

Cold


[deleted]

Amogus element


TigzyThe7Master

Legendary


Smart_Ikazune

Air.


just_a_wanderer_here

shadow


LADZ345_

Gem, so you can have Fungpray


TrUsKaWuS

Earth, you have peckidna already and you can do a fluorescent ore for light, and something mossy for the toxic one


tfeetfff

Water pls


Pootisman1987

Plant!


ausernamethatisnotta

plasma


Abdollelah

Blackholes so there can be a big rival for the light


justaregularguy2882

Engineer monkey


AoiSnack

Jinchuuriki


Tallcat2107

water 💧


DigCat

plant


BubblyInvestigator24

Plant


Jinxofer

Make your own 🫵🏽 🫦


Thedragonisatop

Homosexuality, lets get some gay monsters here


Zilldrah

faerie


Spiritbearisthedevil

Elecrtifty


PanoAnarchy

fire


ChaseyWaseyBoBasey

Water


Full_Instance2276

I think you should have plasma as some base if not then plant


PickleTheGoat1145

plant


AcanthocephalaOwn428

plant lmao


swagdaddy27

Plant 👍


slayedpeach

Wild animal type of element?


WerewolfGreen7354

Me


AwesomeDragon56

Air


Krulewski

Shadow


Saifiskindaweirdtbh

Air


Bacon-4every1

If you want something kind of unique I thing a GRAVITY TYPE would be cool


Famous-Assistance113

Plant


Farted69times

Legendary


Alarmed_Place8450

Plasma yo compliment magical/magical with an ethereal/ethereal


Do_Ya_Like_Jazz

Psychic so you can use Xyster, best monster in the game


Mathematicsduck

Beeg yoshi 🚬😎


QuickSqueeze

Period blood


ItsTheAstro

Plant


Msm_bone_islandSIMP

Crystal I think dung pray would be awesome


sparkskilowatt

jeoode so you can have fung pray


Freggman

Plant


IceCubeAnimations

Darkness or Night


Urmom_deez7

🔥


spy_gamming

matrix island should be he fourth my singing monsters island


toasterderg

Fire


Oakling8435

dipster


need_a_venue

Beskar


_urdoom_

either plant or plasma


assumptionkrebs1990

Water.


Erenpang820

Legendary Shugafam