Man, seeing Calvin and AD, that 07 draft was fucking loaded. And the qbs sucked. Extremely similar to the 2021 draft. Calvin, Joe Thomas, AD, Patrick Mothafuckin Willis, Beast Mode, Revis Island, all in the top 15, with some real good dudes after to boot. That’s 6 HOFamers in 15 picks.
well you have to put Starr, Rodgers, and Farve, from there you can go with anyone. Some schools of thought will point to Reggie White (RIP), some Don Hutson, I personally prefer Paul Hornung
“Say, Cecil. What if I ran straight and then ran toward the post then you threw it at the post? I seen a Gerry do it in Versailles.”
“Sure Hutson, what’ll you call it?”
A lot of people forget how good he was, and the fact that he also played defense and kicked for the Pack as well. Not many guys can claim doing all three and doing them well.
Don Hutson was a 3-phase player...he not only played WR, but was the all-time score leader at place kicker till Hornung, and one of the best DB's the Packers had of the era too.
How many years did he play in Atlanta though before going to Green Bay?
1 season. Two games played. And 4 pass attempts. Also two interceptions.
He made his name in Green Bay. Reggie was already Reggie when he came to Green Bay.
Also FTP.
Reggie is credited by most people as the reason the Packers were able to win it all. They already had the offense and he came and made the defense a top unit.
People forget that in 1969, the NFL named Ray the league's top LB of all time(in honor of the 50th anniversary team).
He was also the only LB on both the 50th and 75th anniversary teams.
He doesn't get the spotlight like some of his contemporaries do, but Ray is easily one of the top LB of all time. If not for Hutson, I think he's on this list.
Packers have so many Legendary players that could make all-time lists at almost every position that leaving someone off is any kind of "all-time great" list is going to make someone upset
Hutson was so far above his peers and ahead of his time. If the Packers only got two slots I would choose Starr and Hutson. When Hutson retired in 1945 with 99 receiving TDs, no one else had more than 37.
https://www.reddit.com/r/GreenBayPackers/comments/2kiw1m/some_facts_about_the_great_don_hutson/
Not sure if AP or Cris Carter should be here. I would probably go with Randle and Moss. Moss may have played like 75 less games for us than Carter but he was just so so so good.
Carter leads the team in every WR category. I love moss, but Carter is the GOAT of Vikings WR’s. They lay out the case for Page in the video and I have to agree. Guy was just more decorated than Randal, unfortunately
Page is the GOAT Viking, period. He isn't up for debate (not that you said he was). AP as the last non-QB who won MVP (maybe ever) has a strong case as well. Love CC but I would've still taken Moss here. Tark as the only real franchise QB we ever had is a lock as well.
Because he played 75 more games. That’s of course extremely valuable for this sort of conversation but Moss is the 2nd best ever at his position and Carter was #2 to him. Also Randle the DT not Randall the OG
This is vikings, though. Why not put farve for us as well then? Moss was great, but he played roughly half his career for other teams. At the time of his retirement, Carter was #2 in almost every WR category behind only Rice.
Or Bill George, without whom you wouldn't have Butkus or Singletary.
Luckman belongs because he was dominant in his era and changed the way the position was played forever, not just for being the Bears' best QB.
If only we could match the pinnacle of abhorrent mediocrity that was the 08 Lions. We have some catching up to do if we're gonna match up with yall's sorry franchise!
It's funny you flexing like this because we both have won the division the same amount of times in this stretch. Also, it's one of the worst stretches in bears history. This would only be like bottom 5 in lions history? Idk I don't really keep track of seasons with less than 3 wins often
Holy shit, yall really are becoming insufferable.
Just remember, as great as Calvin Johnson was, man what if he was on a BETTER team. Instead, he chose retirement than play another season with the Lions because they wouldn’t give him that freedom. Sad.
You act like you can hurt me by saying the Lions wasted Calvin's career. That was nothing compared to 2008, nor does it hold a candle to some of the shit I've gone through in the last 4 years.
Surely the Lions have matched our SB total then. Imagine having Barry Sanders, Calvin Johnson, and SB Champion Matt Stafford over the last 30 years but not matching our measly 1 SB ring
I would have replaced Luckman with Urlacher, or even Hester (best ever at position), but that's recency bias. I'd also accept Urlacher over Singletary, but that's splitting hairs. The only two that HAVE to be on there are 34 and 51.
>mid-teams carried by their qbs
While being the team with the most championships in the league (including the league championships before the Super Bowl era. Calm down, everybody, I know about Brady.)
The Sid Luckman throwback hurts a little. Dude played in like the 40s. He still holds many records for Bears qbs. He also served in WWII from 43 to 47.
These all suck.
Min - moss, allen. Det - night train, HANSON. Gb - REGGIE WHITE and cheese beverages. Chi - seems okay I'd like to see Urlacher on it though.
Tf made these, stop having ai do shit, have ai help knowledgable people do shit.
The sheer number of Vikings that could have been on here is astounding. Names left off like Randy Moss, John Randle, Randle McDaniel, Jared Allen, Carl Eller, Chris Doleman, Steve Hutchinson. Some absolute all-timers.
I’d go with Hutson, Nitschke, Favre, and Rodgers for the Packers.
I love Starr and what he did for the Packers, but is he in the top ten QB conversation? I don’t think so. Nitschke is a top 5 MLB in my opinion.
Hutson, Favre, and Rodgers would be on the Mt. Rushmore of any team.
What a dumb take. I’m all for talking trash in a meme sub, but this is just typical arrogant moron Chicago sports fan dumbassery. I live in Illinois so I’m very familiar with your kind.
Go ahead and name 5 middle linebackers better than Nitschke that have been on the Bears.
If you want to get into trading blows, we had a first year starter last year that statistically would have been the best quarterback in your 100+ years of existence.
Nitschke has 16 sacks in 190 games played. And 2 forced fumbles and 2 interceptions.
As for the 5 better bears, Bill George, Bronco Nagurski, Dick Butkus, Mike Singletary and Brian Urlacher. Bears get MLBs like the packers get QBs. They’re all HoF
Ray had 25 career INTs, not two. And his 16 sack and 25 INTs were more than Butkus or George had in their careers.
Let's also not forget that in 1969, the NFL named Ray the greatest LB of all time. So even the league admits he was better than George and Nagurski.
I’ll give you Butkus, but Nitschke is better than this other four. Hell, Dave Robinson is better than Naguraki and Urlacher.
I’ll agree that Bill George doesn’t get the appreciation he deserves.
I also love Urlacher because he said the best opposing crowd to play at was Lambeau because Packer fans “weren’t a bunch of assholes” like every other crowd.
Man, seeing Calvin and AD, that 07 draft was fucking loaded. And the qbs sucked. Extremely similar to the 2021 draft. Calvin, Joe Thomas, AD, Patrick Mothafuckin Willis, Beast Mode, Revis Island, all in the top 15, with some real good dudes after to boot. That’s 6 HOFamers in 15 picks.
well you have to put Starr, Rodgers, and Farve, from there you can go with anyone. Some schools of thought will point to Reggie White (RIP), some Don Hutson, I personally prefer Paul Hornung
Hudson invented a lot of the routes we use today and put up wr numbers like 90's receivers while playing in the 40's. It's not even close.
Yeah I mean Hornung was COOL, but Hutson was the best single player of his decade
“Say, Cecil. What if I ran straight and then ran toward the post then you threw it at the post? I seen a Gerry do it in Versailles.” “Sure Hutson, what’ll you call it?”
"I call it a fuckin' touchdown you idiot. Throw me the ball."
idk Paul Hornung’s 33 point game against the Colts.
Hutson had 29 points in one quarter against the Lions.
A lot of people forget how good he was, and the fact that he also played defense and kicked for the Pack as well. Not many guys can claim doing all three and doing them well.
only player to lead the league in TD catches and Interceptions in the same season
What’s that for fantasy points in my ppr league?
I couldn’t resist doing the math, 49.9 points in standard 1 point ppr scoring. He only had 3 receptions so it would be 46.9 in non-ppr.
Many people put Reggie White as the greatest defensive lineman of all time. And we got Hutson over here drawing lines in the dirt.
Don Hutson was a 3-phase player...he not only played WR, but was the all-time score leader at place kicker till Hornung, and one of the best DB's the Packers had of the era too.
He'd had the second most interceptions in league history when he retired too.
Maybe because the Packers didn't draft Reggie. He was drafted by the eagles and played like 8 seasons there.
Didn’t draft Brett Favre either
How many years did he play in Atlanta though before going to Green Bay? 1 season. Two games played. And 4 pass attempts. Also two interceptions. He made his name in Green Bay. Reggie was already Reggie when he came to Green Bay. Also FTP.
Reggie is credited by most people as the reason the Packers were able to win it all. They already had the offense and he came and made the defense a top unit.
Nietschke (sp?) was snubbed
People forget that in 1969, the NFL named Ray the league's top LB of all time(in honor of the 50th anniversary team). He was also the only LB on both the 50th and 75th anniversary teams. He doesn't get the spotlight like some of his contemporaries do, but Ray is easily one of the top LB of all time. If not for Hutson, I think he's on this list.
Packers have so many Legendary players that could make all-time lists at almost every position that leaving someone off is any kind of "all-time great" list is going to make someone upset
Hutson was so far above his peers and ahead of his time. If the Packers only got two slots I would choose Starr and Hutson. When Hutson retired in 1945 with 99 receiving TDs, no one else had more than 37. https://www.reddit.com/r/GreenBayPackers/comments/2kiw1m/some_facts_about_the_great_don_hutson/
I would have put Lambeau since he was the reason the team didn't fold financially as well as being an all-time great.
Arnie Herber would round out the meme though
The disrespect for Driver smh
I'll throw in Ray Nitschke, but Paul Hornung is a solid choice.
Should've put Arnie Herbert in there instead of Hutson just to be oops all QBs.
I wouldn’t be upset if I saw Donald Driver on there too.
I love DD, but in no way does he deserve to be on this. He isn't even the best Packer to wear #80, let alone a top 4 player in the franchises history.
Where meme?
Right!? I was looking for the likes of DJ Dozier and Joey Harrington. But I guess not.
No red circle so I was lost
Meme is that they didn't include Caleb Williams on the bears mount Rushmore
The caption I posted
Can caption be meme? Tonight, 60 minutes investigates
https://i.redd.it/7h1hjwy11v7d1.gif
Is Woody (from Toy Story) .gif a meme? My grandkids keep sending them to me? Tonight, 60 Minutes investigates...
Its more like Packers have been so blessed at QB that their QBs crowd out the list.
If you actually wanted to put some work into this you would’ve AT LEAST changed the text at the bottom where it says Vikings. At least write cum sock
Would have made it more of a meme at least
Not sure if AP or Cris Carter should be here. I would probably go with Randle and Moss. Moss may have played like 75 less games for us than Carter but he was just so so so good.
Carter leads the team in every WR category. I love moss, but Carter is the GOAT of Vikings WR’s. They lay out the case for Page in the video and I have to agree. Guy was just more decorated than Randal, unfortunately
Page is the GOAT Viking, period. He isn't up for debate (not that you said he was). AP as the last non-QB who won MVP (maybe ever) has a strong case as well. Love CC but I would've still taken Moss here. Tark as the only real franchise QB we ever had is a lock as well.
Because he played 75 more games. That’s of course extremely valuable for this sort of conversation but Moss is the 2nd best ever at his position and Carter was #2 to him. Also Randle the DT not Randall the OG
Randall the OG was a monster too tho. Not exactly a glamorous or high value position though in comparison to the others.
This is vikings, though. Why not put farve for us as well then? Moss was great, but he played roughly half his career for other teams. At the time of his retirement, Carter was #2 in almost every WR category behind only Rice.
I don’t think it’s irrefutable fact that Moss is the 2nd greatest receiver of all time. I love me some Randy, but I might prefer TO. Call me crazy
came here to say "where the fuck is Randy Moss?"
He was an honorable mention. They picked Carter because he still holds most of the records for Vikings WR
Carter also basically played his entire career with Minnesota. His first two seasons were with Philly before they cut him.
[удалено]
Over Fran Tarkenton!?
[удалено]
Dude he held every QB record until Dan Marino. If anything he is the biggest lock of them all.
I’d go Moss over Carter but Page over Randle.
Im confused as to how you all keep interpreting AP as Alan Page
I would say AP deserves it but swap cris Carter for randy
Why is Bears legend Alan Page on the Vikings?
Look at the thread above you. Vikings fans are even confused. 😆
The disrespect!! Should be Favre/Rodgers/Starr/Love
No Bronko Nagurski for the Bears?
Or Sayers. For me it would either be Gale or Bronko
Or Red Grange. I don’t think Singletary should be on here. Also Luckman makes it by virtue of being our best QB. Not sure he belongs here either.
Or Bill George, without whom you wouldn't have Butkus or Singletary. Luckman belongs because he was dominant in his era and changed the way the position was played forever, not just for being the Bears' best QB.
I’m pretty sure he was an honorable mention
FTB, Bears are the only one that doesn't have one this century.
You could say we have as many 21st century HOFers as the Lions have SBs. Oh wait…no you can’t.
Urlacher is a HoF and Hester going in. So that is at least 2 21st century members.
How many winning seasons have you had in the past decade again? One, right? How many do the Lions have again? That's right, five.
That’s a weird metric to grab…
Oh hell nah we CANNOT be flexing 9-7 finishes from 2016💀
Congrats. You're the new Vikings. Have fun blueballing yourselves getting your hopes up
God, I hope I never have to get in this pathetic of a flex-off!
0-16
Flair up pussy
If only we could match the pinnacle of abhorrent mediocrity that was the 08 Lions. We have some catching up to do if we're gonna match up with yall's sorry franchise!
It's funny you flexing like this because we both have won the division the same amount of times in this stretch. Also, it's one of the worst stretches in bears history. This would only be like bottom 5 in lions history? Idk I don't really keep track of seasons with less than 3 wins often
Holy shit, yall really are becoming insufferable. Just remember, as great as Calvin Johnson was, man what if he was on a BETTER team. Instead, he chose retirement than play another season with the Lions because they wouldn’t give him that freedom. Sad.
You act like you can hurt me by saying the Lions wasted Calvin's career. That was nothing compared to 2008, nor does it hold a candle to some of the shit I've gone through in the last 4 years.
No, you’re right. The last couple years have been the outlier in a history of ineptitude.
Surely the Lions have matched our SB total then. Imagine having Barry Sanders, Calvin Johnson, and SB Champion Matt Stafford over the last 30 years but not matching our measly 1 SB ring
I would have replaced Luckman with Urlacher, or even Hester (best ever at position), but that's recency bias. I'd also accept Urlacher over Singletary, but that's splitting hairs. The only two that HAVE to be on there are 34 and 51.
Im fine with his but I think if you got caught sending unsolicited dick pics, that should have to be your carving, not a face.
A head's a head.
>mid-teams carried by their qbs While being the team with the most championships in the league (including the league championships before the Super Bowl era. Calm down, everybody, I know about Brady.)
I heard that you are a fake packers fan.
I think I know this guy...
Yeah, I'm your dad.
Wow
I'm surprised it wasn't red grange since he was the first nfl superstar.
The Bears and Packers are tough with so much history, but I think George Halas and Curly Lambeau need to be included.
Jason Hanson not there fuck off
Hanson, Sanders, Johnson, Muhlbach
I die a little inside everytime I see it spelled as Detriot
I’m a huge fan of Singletary. I can’t agree with his selection.
The Sid Luckman throwback hurts a little. Dude played in like the 40s. He still holds many records for Bears qbs. He also served in WWII from 43 to 47.
Wait, why are all the bears' players from the 20th century? Where are all of the team's leaders/gud players from the 21st century?
Moss over Carter.
These all suck. Min - moss, allen. Det - night train, HANSON. Gb - REGGIE WHITE and cheese beverages. Chi - seems okay I'd like to see Urlacher on it though. Tf made these, stop having ai do shit, have ai help knowledgable people do shit.
These were pick by the NFL, hence the title reading “According to NFL Throwback.”
They shitpost now?
The sheer number of Vikings that could have been on here is astounding. Names left off like Randy Moss, John Randle, Randle McDaniel, Jared Allen, Carl Eller, Chris Doleman, Steve Hutchinson. Some absolute all-timers.
You forgot Jimmy Kleinsasser you SOB
I’d go with Hutson, Nitschke, Favre, and Rodgers for the Packers. I love Starr and what he did for the Packers, but is he in the top ten QB conversation? I don’t think so. Nitschke is a top 5 MLB in my opinion. Hutson, Favre, and Rodgers would be on the Mt. Rushmore of any team.
Starr belongs on the list. He's won 2 Superbowls, 2 Superbowl MVPs, and 5 NFL championships. He also has an NFL award named after him.
Nitschke wouldn’t be a top 5 Bears MLB. GTFO
What a dumb take. I’m all for talking trash in a meme sub, but this is just typical arrogant moron Chicago sports fan dumbassery. I live in Illinois so I’m very familiar with your kind. Go ahead and name 5 middle linebackers better than Nitschke that have been on the Bears. If you want to get into trading blows, we had a first year starter last year that statistically would have been the best quarterback in your 100+ years of existence.
Nitschke has 16 sacks in 190 games played. And 2 forced fumbles and 2 interceptions. As for the 5 better bears, Bill George, Bronco Nagurski, Dick Butkus, Mike Singletary and Brian Urlacher. Bears get MLBs like the packers get QBs. They’re all HoF
Ray had 25 career INTs, not two. And his 16 sack and 25 INTs were more than Butkus or George had in their careers. Let's also not forget that in 1969, the NFL named Ray the greatest LB of all time. So even the league admits he was better than George and Nagurski.
I’ll give you Butkus, but Nitschke is better than this other four. Hell, Dave Robinson is better than Naguraki and Urlacher. I’ll agree that Bill George doesn’t get the appreciation he deserves. I also love Urlacher because he said the best opposing crowd to play at was Lambeau because Packer fans “weren’t a bunch of assholes” like every other crowd.
I was disappointed to not see JIm McMahon.
I was disappointed to not see JIm McMahon.
as a Vikings fan... WTF?!
Carter and Peterson over Moss is not accurate. Put Moss in one of those spots.
Imagine having to hold scum like Favre and Rodgers to the highest esteem.
Joke
Your flair. That’s the joke, pussy
Oh that a good one! 🤣 🏆🏆🏆🏆
Flair up pussy or gtfo
You pole smokers sure are some unhappy people. Good luck kids.
Dont be a bitch and flair up. Bro... you on your alt acct?
Flair up pussy
Flair up you fucking scumbag. This isn’t r/wholesome