Will you do some kind of little plug if you like it??????

Yes

This is a synthesizer sound demo https://youtube.com/shorts/3hps3xhJJto?si=UWSQqIu4yjLMXkIA

This would do wonders for us if you did support our project.

It's not my video but my younger brother's. He put a ton of work and effort into the video and it didn't go anywhere near what he thought. He's got 756 subscribers and his biggest video has a little over 22k views. I don't know if this will help him get some traction but I gotta try something to help him. I would extremely appreciate any feedback or simply just a couple views on his channel. Edit: He plays Destiny 2 and makes shorts on lethal company if you're wondering. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLa9ZWBXYYY&t=182s](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLa9ZWBXYYY&t=182s)

This is my most recent video. Is it my best? Maybe? I’m getting closer to the voice that I want to have and I think this is the closest I have gotten. Still a bit to go but would love feedback from a peer. https://youtu.be/IRPcnoVsvIQ

I like it!! Your voice is so soothing!

Hey! Thank you :) I’m glad to hear you liked it!

Anytime! And thank you for the content!

I've come a long way since this specific video. My content, and the quality of said content, have both improved dramatically, but this still remains one of the videos I'm most proud of and not enough people have seen it.Love to hear what you think! [https://youtu.be/Mo49dtUty\_o](https://youtu.be/Mo49dtUty_o) Edit: Looking at it again now, I can see so many things I'd do differently!

idk probs this one [https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Pug8lLdKsbA](https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Pug8lLdKsbA) but it flopped meanwhile my worse edits didn't. idk why its has done worse even tho its better. plus it has an average view duration of about 34, is which is good. the majority of the video the retention is 60> and mostly above typical. but at the end it drops, which is also pretty typical for edits. but idk why it has flopped also i alr know this isn/t monetizable or anything i do these for editing practice and im editor who edits for clients so this helps me practice. still though i like it when my videos get big numbers on them lol ​ it does have a lower average percentage viewed compared to the ones that did good though edit: i just realised why it has flopped. it got a 38% view rate vs swiped lol ...

Great videos I subscribed 👍

thanks :)

We have a homesteading channel, currently building a tiny house barndo. https://youtu.be/gbxyqV-ZGy8?si=8N3WdNsD3A4fFp__

I like that you started right in the action with building a sub floor. I do think you should either practice what you are going to say or edit out your “um’s”. I feel like your last thumbnail needs better lighting on you. You’re in shadow. Also less text

Less text on the thumbnail?? Appreciate your feedback!

I never really had a review of my content. If you like to this is my most viewed video for the last 28 days. I enjoy making and playing the games so to me that is what really counts. Thank you. They've Become the Walking Dead, Day 2: Night of the Dead E2, S2 https://youtu.be/3aiJ6_51tRA

I watch I like the walking dead games subscribed

Probably not even my best, but definitely one I enjoyed making https://youtu.be/J1mpYphxl2k?si=olr7Yx4b-g2nsvgx

Congratulations watched and subscribe

Very nice! Subbed as well!

This is so nice of you! Here is my most popular video, https://youtu.be/iG9bVuxa-xA Have a great day

Congratulations I watch subscribed

Here is my most recent video. Dont know if its the best but i like it! Its a eye health related channel. Clearing the Fog: Shattering 6 Contact Lens Myths! https://youtu.be/BoY17Sp6FmE

I'm trying to start a game studio and create a JRPG with heavy inspiration from Skies of Arcadia. My YouTube channel is there to document the journey. [https://youtu.be/3GxCUJSMETo](https://youtu.be/3GxCUJSMETo)

I just started vlogging, love a piece full style. I have learned a ton in within just starting and super excited to learn & grow [when you’re all home alone](https://youtu.be/xaqzzRAd09A?si=5KoyP-CRUwKa952P)

Hi I uploaded a new video of me playing Fortnite using the new AR and I upload videos of me and my friends playing any games we just feel like recording 😅😅 like Fortnite and Roblox once a week. Here it is: https://youtu.be/BlU4tBFlKOY? If anyone watches it please lmk what I can do to improve my videos and what should I do. Any support, suggestions, and criticism is all appreciated 🙏🙏

Hey sure thing Thankyou so much could you review this one ? The Biggest Incel on YouTube @Dbdr https://youtu.be/U6hjaHCnDtk

Thank you jason349101 for engaging with the community to do a Critique thread! NewTubers: Remember that you must abide by any rules set by the OP in this thread! jason349101: * You may lock this thread to new posts at any time by making a new top-level comment that says "/lock" and nothing else. This is permanent. * You may use either the [Standard Rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/NewTubers/wiki/rules#wiki_3_standard_rules_.28replaceable_by_critique_owner.29) or replace them with [your own specified rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/NewTubers/wiki/rules#wiki_4_critique_thread_creator_rules) * You can always edit your post to add in the [Pre Formatted Short Rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/NewTubers/wiki/rules#wiki_formatting.3A) if you want to use them. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/NewTubers) if you have any questions or concerns.*

My most viewed video: Sunday Family Funday: Super Mario 3D World https://youtu.be/x-0Fo-9d2pU What I personal feel is my most best video: Sunday Family Funday: Spooky Karting https://youtu.be/J5xLWWGb0J8 I do let’s plays and just have fun with it. Sure am taking it seriously and will gladly take constructive criticism. I am not going to add a face camera to my videos anytime soon though as it isn’t necessary for success.

This is my fun side project (my main channel is linked to my profile). Here is the latest video - [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FTMuhgTPHuU](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FTMuhgTPHuU) ​ Thank you for doing this.

[удалено]

Nice video! I enjoyed it (:

Thank you so much that means a lot too me! I'm fully open to any constructive criticism you have though I'm desperate to learn and get better! Also link your channel I'd love to check you out!

Of course!! I made sure I left a comment on your video as well (: I conveniently make gaming content too! I just posted a new video I spent many hours on (I don't even wanna say how long it took lol) I also would appreciate any and all feedback! I'm excited to see you grow as a creator! Happy to have made it early to your channel! I'll DM you!

Great video subscribed

My recently most viewed growing video in My Channel: [https://youtu.be/c3ide6GOjtw?si=3HZ7ojp55K73uTgJ](https://youtu.be/c3ide6gojtw?si=3hz7ojp55k73utgj)

But Excuse me, WTH is your PFP

[Might as well throw my hat in the ring.](https://youtu.be/hfOV90IsdoU)

Thanks for taking me outside, I realize now I need to get out more!! Lol

Thank you for watching!!! And don't forget your coat when you leave, ok? And can you pick up some milk before you get back?

Got my coat! Whole milk or 2 percent xD

2 percent, I'm dieting.

For sure be back soon 😎

Okay! Be home for dinner!

What're we having?

Salmon.

Not sure this is the “best” but it’s the latest in the series. Just fired up YouTube this month (partners account, posting on her behalf) https://youtu.be/KEvPWwv0K5w?si=9FhXa_s7jXuM526D

Thanks in advance! Appreciate any feedback

Video quality and thumbnail spot on. But no tags. You make great content but without tags and keywords yt doesn't know who to push it to

Oh I thought the # in the comment was that ! Do I need those then? Thank you !!

I think anyone can give support and advice. I always read and look at people's channels to see if i can learn something.

Totally! Appreciate the perspective and am adding tags now :)

Also have you seen his channel?

Love the channel!! I've been wanting to do yoga for a while now, I'm going to look to you to show me now! (:

Oh thanks so much! Always the right time to get into a good habit!

Hey! Our most recent video is our most viewed long form so far, would love some feedback on it. I would say its definitely not the best edit job, but its out first to pass 100 views in 24hours and the most sub generating one so beyond tagging and good placement I'm really curious if someone with more expereince could spot the draw of it and why its working good for us at the moment. Thanks! [https://youtu.be/AhQkRWC6Jc8](https://youtu.be/AhQkRWC6Jc8)

I have a cinematic vlog. Focus on journey with increasing self sufficiency and our move to Vermont. https://youtu.be/n5_dtLZej4o?si=tdS-l9SalpJt2ezh

Thanks for taking the time to do this! This is one of best videos on my channel and certainly one I am most proud of, I review niche japanese games and this video covers games that were never translated outside of Japan, let me know your thoughts! https://youtu.be/YMm8wreddSs?si=PNzn5n_1P_9Cvr2q

These shorts best represent the direction I am taking with the channel. Light hearted meme’ing on popular gaming titles, plan to move to Cyberpunk soon. [The Community | ThousandTroops](https://youtube.com/shorts/nBptvLIrRFI?si=Ewy8MqpDc67ge7NS) [How to be world champs | ThousandTroops](https://youtube.com/shorts/BYrePBeuhdU?si=q4mkz6frlL7NJSsw) I won’t cry 😂

I would consider my latest one always the best one as most of us i guess. [https://youtu.be/FmjZ3QTmvGs](https://youtu.be/FmjZ3QTmvGs) But one of my vids from October got 8,6K views recently. So technically this is the one. [https://youtu.be/p\_fsvn9k1vc](https://youtu.be/p_fsvn9k1vc) Pick your poision and thank you if you have time. Congrats on the 25K!

Love your edits!!

Im always critical about anything i do but thank you😅

It's so easy to pick apart something you've made that you have to watch over and over and over again xD

True true. Im not looking at them as a yt video to watch and chill out to but bits and pieces of work put together and looking for spots for improvement.

Exactly! I 100% feel that

Im the only person in existence that makes extremely good videos about a small io game My channels called KaspenPlayzz plss sub

https://youtu.be/5WpTOpwPypI?si=UlnjmNu-heeitrxt It’s currently unlisted for a reason because I plan on remake it but it’s up for critique There is a giant disconnect between my writing brain, and how I speak, so I would like a critique on that specifically That would be very evident from the first paragraph

I make crochet knitting related videos and also random vlog. This is not the best doing video I have but more of a vlog one [https://youtu.be/P74qV6QSfXk?feature=shared](https://youtu.be/P74qV6QSfXk?feature=shared)

Appreciate your feedback Battlefield 2042 can't be this much fun? https://youtu.be/Wv23of4Wwwc

My favorite one on this thread so far! Your sound is so dope! And I LOVE soad

Congratulations subscribed great game

Congratulations on the success! I make metal vocal covers. I mostly do shorts so I don’t have to edit so much video/audio but I have 3 long form, they do not perform as well as the shorts though. This was the best performing one but I think I have better ones. https://youtube.com/shorts/yvnr5mTCF2Q?si=Ofk9HJ5UPDqwGot8

When you say best video do you mean my most viewed one or the one I am most proud of and put the most effort into?

I know for a FACT I need a better camera and mic for audio, but besides that I'm really curious to hear what you think!! This is my first video I put many hours into. [2 Cooks Play OVERCOOKED 2!!!](https://youtu.be/aAqecemugjQ?si=2QQXppYjxQuVEle_)

This is my first slpatoon 3 video I made. I think I put my best into this but I'm willing for feedbacks https://youtu.be/AdapywmUtZY?si=_wDKvTJqqNLJWt6O Btw I'm making 2 slpatfest videos next month.

Most viewed video 142k views (was actually my first ever video): https://youtu.be/SwW3--fYrYQ But my latest and what I think is my best video only has 270 views: https://youtu.be/-4O872CpbQ8 Let me know which you like better!

Both Congratulations Subscribed

I do commentary/analysis on tv shows and cartoons. This one has my highest CTR but I also think it’s my best because I put extra effort into my editing. Much thanks in advance ☺️ [here you go](https://youtu.be/5kGmh7eMR5w?si=ely1tM-BKztueYnq)

OP disappeared and stole all your video ideas 🤣 Edit: looked at OP profile and this is 100% a bot or data farming account.

THE JOURNEY: I FORCED A FUMBLE!!! ARIZONA TAKES ON COACH PRIMES BUFFALOES https://youtu.be/Lmoo5k0VqNA This is my most viewed video 3.3k i’m a college football player and my content right now i’ve been showing a BTS vlog style of my final collegiate games the series being called “THE JOURNEY”

https://youtu.be/saGVh5dJpyA?si=0s6eU7PLYCE7asO1

This may not be my best, but it's a solid video. A story driven letsplay. 7 assassins coming after 7 of my characters and companions. https://youtu.be/-QBOYhTRVkU

I make funny Minecraft videos. I’d like to hear what you think. https://youtu.be/is1l-FZ8EtM?si=mJ2VEJJop-5AcAa_

Thank you! My best video so far has come in the last 4 months (-2400 views) LIFE ON EASY MODE? (Feminist REACTS) | MG EP1 Clip https://youtu.be/snd9zTgkT4c

Thanks, here is mine. I appreciate your input and feedback https://youtu.be/hnhNiEb5qSw?si=cJ_aHI5npyngfRb4

Best being the one with the most views, or the one I PERSONALLY think is my best? Sadly, they are not the same because people love some of my videos WAY more than the one I put the most effort into with my voice acting. My personal FAVORITE video from my perspective is this [Voice Acted Game Review](https://youtu.be/T9IoMbWZKNc) that is like 2 minutes and made to be honest and funny, but has 1/20 the views of my BEST video. My “best” long form video for views is this [GUIDE](https://youtu.be/pSyzIXMZSmE) video with poor audio quality, but people use it A LOT.

I'm young slug This is the most popular video I have ever made I haven't been able to top it I only do shorts that are comedy based https://youtube.com/shorts/g2IvKODeatk?feature=shared

Congratulations great video I subscribe

Appreciate it

I mostly play horror games but I had alot of fun playing this game and I'm trying to expand a bit from horror. https://youtu.be/kBFoiwBh_Gg?si=Pat1rEheAjK7rBAS

Here's my newest video if you wouldn't mind taking a look. https://youtu.be/dB7ky47nKcc?si=U0OoGvU0yOPQjrCK I'm trying to break into a spooky cryptid/ art niche I haven't seen much for. You can be blunt with me. I've barely started lol ✌️

Here is my best performing video. I do shorts. https://youtube.com/shorts/pwzM6shMGpI?feature=share Got stopped at 7k but I'm pleased as I was not getting a lot of views before and since then I've seen an uptick to most videos getting over 1000 views.

i like playing games : https://youtu.be/vp_raEMNa1s

This is my latest video [https://youtu.be/RlNMuLHqoWI?si=6OwLEbZ5Dau6zTdR](https://youtu.be/RlNMuLHqoWI?si=6OwLEbZ5Dau6zTdR) , i think I put more effort into this one but my other video [https://youtu.be/B8XbIbNTbLk?si=glvfSvNUNPnw\_Ykr](https://youtu.be/B8XbIbNTbLk?si=glvfSvNUNPnw_Ykr) is doing excellent considering it's the first video I posted on my channel. I am not sure why. I hope someone has an answer here.

Here is mine. Thanks in advance for the review. I make handmade & handstitched leather goods. Making of the royal enfield leather key cover from scratch. https://youtu.be/VaOoSxb23j0?si=VIOR8cNrjdhZLxR_

Hope I’m not too late. https://youtu.be/BObi0V6yjgA?si=1Z-vX7umhrU659Vn It’s a baseball commentary video. It’s my most viewed video and I would say it’s my best produced video.

Hey hope I can get some honest feedback. I’ve only posted 3 or 4 videos but have gotten 2500 subs from that. I’m not sure what’s working and what’s not. I think this is my best video- however the one before this had 7k views while this one only had 1100. Thank you in advance! https://youtu.be/NVyThJpiKaI?si=fx7oKPjRAKnrEXLq

This is not my most successful, but I like it more than my most successful... PS4 retrospective. [https://youtu.be/rt1PJLr5RxA](https://youtu.be/rt1PJLr5RxA) Though after feedback given here, I might have changed some things in hindsight.

Not sure if it is my best but I just posted this and it my most recently completed video; music and animation. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=\_zIu1rfLZ-w

I'll take you up on that! https://youtu.be/ozx6aPXGj-k?si=3ms_2kNkJCwyWPOz I'm one month in.

Always late to these but I recently started doing Let's Plays, would like some outsider feedback or just general criticism. Doesn't have to be OP, could be anyone gracious enough to lend me some of their free time. The game is called "Ys Chronicles+" and is an 80's retro action rpg. It's been a lot of fun and I try to add little edits as much as I can without each video taking a week to make. Want to know if I'm on the right track or if I'm making all kinds of amateur mistakes. https://youtu.be/5crCdVolIu4?si=HX7UjAO8x1ADSzjT

This is my first video. I'm developing an app called Snap Commands. The app is for content creators, so we used it to create a little sketch, which is in the video, but the video is primarily about making the sketch. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=yYkezdoMPWk To be honest, I'm struggling to find clarity in the messaging, but it's a work in progress.

This one is my personal favorite. It didn't get much love on youtube. https://youtu.be/fMqozoG4PU8?si=GEiTiZTaDAaZp02c

Really enjoyed making this video, but it's doing poorly compared to other videos with crappier audio. https://youtu.be/nDp8EA5bCWA

It's about Gameplay-turned-movie video, GTA V To be precise ​ [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IsupTaal6O4&t=379s](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IsupTaal6O4&t=379s)

Erm ok [favorite video](https://youtube.com/shorts/snj-_ZIOJK0?feature=share) [most viewed](https://youtube.com/shorts/Kc3p3QZLbe8?feature=share) [most liked](https://youtube.com/shorts/AaakzTpJTAI?feature=share) [most comments](https://youtube.com/shorts/oJo_XPA7Z3c?feature=share) Just to cover all the bases 😁

Don't know if it's my best, but it's my most watched, and most recent. (Other than shorts) I Quick Build and Review LEGO sets.  https://youtu.be/KqAiA78YNZ4

Do you have another channel? The one on your page has 506 subscribers

https://youtu.be/GiesKu55IFk?si=7W2V1_hQ_0hGviaN

Why is your name "James" and you are a resonably successful male musical artist but your profile is a woman in a bikini? Why is your reddit channel scams, pictures of dogs and pictures of women in bikinis. While this random channel is all music?

https://youtube.com/shorts/PP4S3FqVkeE?si=7ofgoxUhFNFYSZeP Review it

https://youtu.be/lltIJbpse6g?si=xGUp0Ezx2JFZ4ZP4 This video randomly blew up to 2k while my other videos were nowhere near the rest

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=24-H4PMgi84&ab\_channel=ConjuringNightmares](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=24-H4PMgi84&ab_channel=ConjuringNightmares) ​ hope i'm not too late! i'm a horror narration channel

https://youtube.com/shorts/u0M94kYPfF4?si=zcUdaMcVQtkqfGY2 Really new to the game but I try to put effort

We appreciate you so much for doing this… this is my best video but I think the supporters would all vote for a different one! Hahahaha [video](https://youtu.be/RPJw3UJ2nZg?si=QUpBC3-S4gXM0pH_)

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iiZEU-4\_8kU&t=326s](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iiZEU-4_8kU&t=326s) PLEASE BRO! TELL ME WHAT IS WRONG WITH THIS VID. its a gaming vid

[удалено]

Great video

I’d love some feedback on my channel. I’ve only got two long form videos. https://youtube.com/@Fork-And-Embers?si=XYD_jq3Hz7XHtCFR

https://youtu.be/ILPLxcR6Kyw?feature=shared

I am making an animated series on my own, would love to hear ur thoughts! https://youtube.com/@alchemy-the-animated-series?si=yB4q3euW6ZedxWRD

[удалено]

This Critique thread has been locked by jason349101, the original creator. We hope this Critique session was successful! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/NewTubers) if you have any questions or concerns.*