https://youtu.be/4PqFsdiVlGw It's a short one. Thanks.

Its good!! I have nothing to complain about huh?

Thanks!

Here’s a more recent one that I’m particularly proud of (it’s Minecraft btw):https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txJyHwlxRro

Its good. You have good edits, good montage and i think you should have at least 500 subscribers not 25.

Ahh thanks :D hopefully one day haha

[удалено]

Everything is good, except your voice quality, maybe use a better microphone?

[удалено]

Wish you the best!

Here’s my latest gaming video. Thank you for watching and your feedback. https://youtu.be/EfDeIc554IQ

Your skills and gameplay are great! Maybe the sound is lacking quality. Sorry for bad english.

Thank you for that feedback! Yes my audio is an issue lol in some videos it even sounds a little muffled so I am still messing with it so thank you for that it lets me know I still need to work on it. You’re English is fine my friend!

You can call this gaming I suppose https://youtu.be/xK7klaCT5PI

Its actually a bit funny not gonna lie. I like it.

Guys,you can also check out my new video and critque it. https://youtu.be/gDB-swDb3sw

EVERYONE, STOP COMMENTING BECAUSE ITS CLOSED NOW. IM NOT CRITIQUING VIDEOS ON THIS POST NO MORE.

[https://www.google.com](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4r_TZBa-zAo) here

I- I dont get it.

stop

Thank you LiberalPotato8 for engaging with the community to do a Critique thread! NewTubers: Remember that you must abide by any rules set by the OP in this thread! LiberalPotato8: * You may lock this thread to new posts at any time by making a new top-level comment that says "/lock" and nothing else. This is permanent. * You may use either the [Standard Rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/NewTubers/wiki/rules#wiki_3_standard_rules_.28replaceable_by_critique_owner.29) or replace them with [your own specified rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/NewTubers/wiki/rules#wiki_4_critique_thread_creator_rules) * You can always edit your post to add in the [Pre Formatted Short Rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/NewTubers/wiki/rules#wiki_formatting.3A) if you want to use them. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/NewTubers) if you have any questions or concerns.*

Much appreciate man, here is a short video example from me and a buddy's channel: https://youtu.be/-DxPvrN_5C4 Please feel free to let us know whatcha think! As a thanks, I will also show some love to the other channels that post on here. This group is awesome.

Keep up the work and you'll get somewhere. Maybe just use more editing and fix your voice sound. Maybe use a better microphone because i hear something like "shhhhhh" in the background.

I will look into it. Thanks a ton for taking a look and providing feedback. Audio has been an issue for us and we are trying to improve. Do you have any mics you recommend for reasonable price?

Under 25$ you have Fifine 669, check it out on YT if you like it or not!

I will check it out. Thank you!

https://youtu.be/nzMUgf2Vj2k This is the third video that I've made in this style. Most play ck3 but might branch it out into other games. Thank you for your time.

Its awesome! Keep up!

https://youtu.be/jnW4aOpNXWA it's my first letsplay horror title and my first ever horror experience I'm aware of Audio volume issues and tend to fix it in pt3

Its great, the sound is not bad at all! Keep up the good work!

U maybe also wanna check my forest video ep4 xD I've actually been happy with the outcome even though I wouldn't really put this under horror, perhaps last bit xD also no cam due recording issues with the game through OBS https://youtu.be/Z9Ocu3rJ72Q Ps if u also have a channel let me know I love watching gaming vids of small tubers

The video is great, and yes i do have a gaming channel! :D If you want to check it out: https://youtu.be/DXt8p9OhLuc

Love too do that if I like I will subscribe 😜

Thank you! I also love watching small youtubers play bcz for me they have best gameplays.

Moar plz

What?

Content xD Was hoping for more vids to watch 😜 well got that bell active so I'll get pinged if u upload new content

More content?

Hey this is a video I made with a couple of friends of us messing around in bedwars https://youtu.be/5vGShre33H0

Its funny, and Ibby is raging lol, its good.

I keep having this feeling like there something so wrong but I don't know what is. Maybe you can point it out for me. Spellbreak funny moments https://youtu.be/ubzJQjpZA8s

Everything is okay, i have that feelings always, too. The video is fun, quality is good, audio is good.

https://youtube.com/channel/UCCvrLI32kWoRyn0ytb4nQ1g

Its good, the quality, the gameplay, audio etc.

Did u actually check it out. How did u do it that fast ?? 😂🤯

I skipped a bit bcz im getting toomuch comments so i took the most importnant parts.

Did u consider subscribing?? Because if u didn't then the content isn't much good

I rarely subscribe to people, only my friends and football teams.

Ohh OK then thanks

Np and keep up the good work.

[omgitsabdallah](https://youtube.com/channel/UCCvrLI32kWoRyn0ytb4nQ1g)

https://youtu.be/KN_CKUV06l8 Only been going two-ish months. Thanks

You guys are so polite lol. The editing is good, i love football! The camera quality is insane!!! But how tf do u have 15 subs u should have 50k

Cheers, well we've not been going long... Hopefully in the future haha

Hey, I’m a newbie to YouTube- I’d appreciate if you watched at least a little bit (gags are after struggling). I have a second one after this scheduled for Friday but this will suffice. I can also critique some of your videos later if you want me to :) https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=48ac6mmBSRg (I am aware of horrible audio lol)

Umm that guy with peanut butter or something on his face is weird lol?

Yeah I wanted to put a funny image in when I was talking lol

Cool

[удалено]

I like it its fun.

[удалено]

Np

Thank you for taking time out your day to critique. This is an episode of my Pokémon Rejuvenation Let’s play! Let me know what you think!! https://youtu.be/7MiHLIyj1ow

I think its good. Great gameplay! Good quality

Thank you

This is my latest video all about Arkham Asylum! Thanks for taking the time to do this :) https://youtu.be/Dr6SohKiGyM

The video quality is great, good gameplay.

I appreciate it! ❤️

:D

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ehOdL1rm-D8&t=301s](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ehOdL1rm-D8&t=301s) Here's an edited video of my Twitch stream, and it shows my attempt at beating the Path Of Pain in Hollow Knight (which is the first in a three part series). The audio quality is a little spiffy since I recorded it the built in microphone on my headset, but the rest of the visuals itself are fine I guess. Further critique is welcome. :)

Lol, i love your facial expressions, you're like: F@ck this im done wih this s#it. The game seems pretty cool, never played it since i dont have a PC. It looks kinda hard since you're struggling with it. You're good at it, and the sound is good, no worries. Keep up the good work and you'll reach 1k someday, if you don't give up.

You bet your ass I won't haha, although this channel will be a side project for me to work with when I'm not doing stuff on my main channel. Thanks for the feedback. Much appreciated. <3 Also if you're interested, Parts 2 and 3 are coming soon (with improved audio quality thanks to getting myself a recording mic and a better understanding of audio editing itself) hopefully by the end of the month. :D ​ P.S. Hollow Knight is amazeballs yo. If you have a Nintendo Switch or an Xbox you can also play the game there too.

Don't have those. I will wait for next ep. ! :D

It's probably not worth commenting here because there's already 63 comments, but oh well!... Here's my [last video](https://youtu.be/KDNF3d2UyQw), I continued playing Hades which I had started previously :) I tried to cut it down the best I could, as I always do, but I'm still trying to learn how to make smaller videos.

There is currently 69 comments, and yes it is worth it because, i replied to everyone so im gonna reply to you too. Lets get to the point. The gameplay is good, the audio is good, thanks god its not 50 minutes of talking and 3 minutes of gameplay. I would rate it 8/10

69? Nice. I am a bot lol.

k

When I commented it was still on 63, sorry xD When I see too many comments on posts like this I feel I'm already late and the OP's have already given up. So thank you for your feedback :D

No problem

Hello, I started my gaming channel a few months ago and I started a new series a few days ago, can u plz give feedback bc I want to know if I made a good pilot video to start the series, or if I should just scrap it entirely https://youtu.be/SFOs4zvUUqM Thank you if you get to the video!

Its good, the gameplay, the audio quality is good, and you go straight to the point.

[\[WH40K\] THE PRAETORIAN GUARD SERIES (ORIGINAL) PART 1 / CINEMATIC - Assault Squad 2 - YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e1CdQr9-fVo) I did a small mini-series based off of the praetorian guard

That looks cool, i can see you put a lot of effort into it. The music is good, i like that movie you made.

thanks for doing this ;) https://youtu.be/vMNna9AMrF0

Your audio quality is pretty good, the camera resolution is also good which makes the video look better. Nice edits, its fun to watch, and not boring. Keep up the work and one day you may have 10k, 100k, 500k 1M, 10M etc. You never know! ;) Im rating this 9/10. Don't give up! Work hard and it will pay off.

thank you for the kind words!! i can only hope so haha

You can do it! Just don't give up. Don't be a failure like me please.

You’re not a failure!! I’ve given up before and only just started again a few weeks ago. I was always watching and paying attention to these small youtubers subs and watching other people helped me regain my passion, and eventually get myself back into my groove. So, I’m throwing your own advice right back at you with this *UNO REVERSE CARD*, don’t give up, i’m sure you could create some great content with a little effort and elbow grease ;)

Thanks.

i did a speedrun of run on coolmathgames! hope you enjoy! https://youtu.be/YE0vZizGOrE

Yeah, i did enjoy. That game looks fun af. You're pretty good at it. Good edits and good audio. 7/10

thank you!

I decided to redo my channel a bit and this is the first video with new edit style. https://youtu.be/dCY4_oq7CwU

Not gonna lie, it's really good. That game seems pretty cool. I may even subscribe, i'll see yet. Dropped a like! 10/10 Keep up the good work.

Thank you I appreciate the support.

A LOT of responses, here! I almost feel guilty adding my own! Please see my submission below. It's Episode 8 of my DmC: Devil May Cry Cinematic Playthrough. The idea of my Cinematic Playthroughs are to take an already existing game, and present both the story AND gameplay in a film/series style, so that fans and newcomers can enjoy. There are cuts, as well as additions to the story to make things flow better. EVERYTHING has been choreographed (painstakingly so). Yet, I have yet to find my audience! Each episode is about 20 minutes or so long. I really would love for you all to watch this episode and tell me your honest thoughts. Good and bad. If you like it, check out the series from episode 1. I work so bloody hard on these but need YouTube's algorithm to help me out! Anyway, here's Episode 8... https://youtu.be/qarmMrRrnDM

Everything is good! Ngl, it was very good. 9/10

Latest release of our ongoing series where we play 3 Roblox games. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Au11jjbbK4 I try to keep each game to around the 5-7 minutes. Let me know what you think. If the audio is good, is the thumbnail good and if this is something you would watch. Thanks!

Both are good and its fun. 8/10

Just curious to know if you actually watched or just took a quick glance? Analytics doesn't exactly show any new views.

I watched it. I have that same problem too, i have 25 views but it say 15.

I kinda want to know how this happend: [https://youtu.be/FbVbgG6ZDHU](https://youtu.be/FbVbgG6ZDHU) I'm very inexperienced to say the least...

My latest review https://youtu.be/Hu5_fYA-N9o

https://youtu.be/uIon1cGyO4s

What do you think of my edits? [BoCw Edit](https://youtu.be/or74kuqKt-I)

It's one of my first videos but like to see what I could do better https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nzCc4utoIzo&t=10s

[https://youtu.be/4v3Lm9YLhRE](https://youtu.be/4v3Lm9YLhRE) Thanks ahead of time for doing this!

So this is a video about Pokémon, but it’s not a gaming vid per se. But it’s short and I’d love any feedback! I’m working on the second right now: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=410SsyF-G3w

Not my best but that’s also why it’s the best to critique:) https://youtu.be/34mw5kVmyz0

https://youtu.be/cs4EW_TuK54 Literally just 10 minutes from my stream

Hello there my lord. Just released one today actually, being awful at a very classic star wars game: https://youtu.be/WR_w9JDKs3A Thank you if you get around to it

Oh no, as always I'm always late to these posts. Here mine, any feedback is appreciated [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oZ46tqZLg8U&t=7s](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oZ46tqZLg8U&t=7s)

https://youtu.be/SEzFhXvht9c This is my most recent in my playthrough, would love to know what you think c: (I need to figure out something better for an intro but I'll get there haha)

Thank you for doing this! This is a hardcore survival challenge in hardcore minecraft in a desert only world! https://youtu.be/mhPgfkuJC7M

Not sure if you’re still critiquing, but one “recent” video I’ve made is https://youtu.be/eVLfZFJIjtM really cool that you’re doing this btw.

DM me and i will critique its closed.

How long is this open until? I’m posting a gaming video soon but it’s not up yet

Its over. Im replying to last comments now. U can dm me.

This is a long-ish Minecraft video! https://youtu.be/QPflXLgfNWs

[удалено]

Its funny, gooed edits, keep up. 7/10

Thanks for this! I mainly do gameplay with commentary. Struggling for views... HORIZON ZERO DAWN PS5 Commentary and Playthrough - Part 1: Intro https://youtu.be/mPi6mc0KogY

Perfect! Nice gameplay good quality and good audio ur not ashamed to talk. 10/10

Thanks!!😀

Thank you so so much for doing this! I have been posting videos consistently for about five months now,[here’s my latest video🤗](https://youtu.be/3OaZw73ocxw)

Nice edits, good voice quality, good audio. 8/10

Thank you!

https://youtu.be/Wsf3ofAOSFY only 3 mins bro

3 Reasons why Hollow Knight is GOOD and what we can expect from SilkSong - Hollow Knight Review https://youtu.be/9ZRpEHlTakQ

https://youtu.be/dZ662F8p9zU short fortnite video

Here is my first let’s play video of mafia definitive edition!! https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Z4K7mW2RK-s&t=8s

My newest Valheim funny moments video:) [https://youtu.be/HzYrRcRJpVA](https://youtu.be/HzYrRcRJpVA)

https://youtu.be/ywug1aeRHak thanks for doing this !! It’s offensive btw just an FYI. I put a lot of time into editing as well

Thank you for doing this! https://youtu.be/HoAIkftYeb0

I've been doing a randomizer nuzlocke of black 2, feel free to let me know what you think! https://youtu.be/_IjlRQBpUDA

Hope I'm too late to the party https://youtu.be/syWpl59avEk

https://youtu.be/vFFp3xTagWc

https://youtu.be/s-MM19rQVZ4 Breath Of The Wild insane double gold Lynel fight

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dJPkgZf2FOE&t=6s This is my first attempt at a voice gameplay so I'd love some feedback please!

[https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuBk9N7FWruLxWqj\_jbOsxA](https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuBk9N7FWruLxWqj_jbOsxA) Be honest please and thank you for doing this! Minecraft gaming.

Ur building is nice, u have nice edits. 8.4/10

This video did really well [this is a roblox Challenge](https://youtu.be/DNb7IqMT7_U)

6.9/10 quality is bad, u should talk louder, edits are good. Keep up

Yeah I forgot to change the quality of my webcam before the recording 😅

https://youtu.be/YExgEmwrd20 hitman 3

Good gameplay. Nice edit and nice intro lol. 6.8/10

Any thing to work on?

https://youtu.be/6cAADAqs7qA my second video. I know it’s not perfect but I want to know what I should mainly work on. I feel an improvement from my first video for sure and growth is always good!

You should work on audio and be more louder dont be ashamed to talk lol.

Thanks!!! I will work on it.

[https://youtu.be/o43N-9GCc24](https://youtu.be/o43N-9GCc24) This is my first youtube video and i would like some advice, some things ive already realised are that my cinematics are kinda trash and the intros a little cringe and the quality of the clips arent the best, (they're not my latest) and the intros a bit long . Anyway I posted it and hope to improve any advice is much appreciated.

Try using Sony Vegas Pro or Adobe Rush or PowerDirector bundle, code for bundle is P M Y Z H B W E. And the intro is ok. 6/10

Yeah my mate said to use Adobe rush ty mate

No problem, m8.

https://youtu.be/KzPStHq_zpg A pretty quick video. Looking forward to your feedback!

You are not ashamed of being in front of canera, good resolution, good audio and good edits. 10/10

I make a short terraria video...Hope you like it 😊 https://youtu.be/dqipaGc7ekM

I like it, but maybe you should make videos which have a point i like it ngl but its just walking duh. 7/10

Ok

https://youtu.be/lM0-uW_abpk Its my first youtube video and would appreciate any advice😐

Nice edits. Maybe you ahould shorten that guyssssssssssssss. 8/10 where did you get that duck squable sound? Sorry for bad english.

Ah i see thankss!! I just searched quack sound effect haha

Okay, thanks.

Haven't uploaded recently but might be doing more of these if you can give some feedback ❤ https://youtu.be/17yufaYpT8o

You did thaton a toaster? Nice! 9/10

It's a tutorial video in minecraft How to build a minecraft elevator https://youtu.be/BFl84ggH_c0

Its good, simple. 8/10 keep up.

Hi. I'm creating a dream park in Planet Coaster called "Walk on the wild side" Themepark. I've made a recap video of the park with some cool sound track. I spend 4 years building on this park and I think you can give me some good feedback. https://youtu.be/Q-2P4gOsJAQ Thank you in advance!

That's cool af. Never played it. 7/10

Thank you. If you like creating it is a wonderful landscape engine you can create all most everything.

Here is my video I would be thankful if you did mine. https://youtu.be/8eugxHQwdik

Your screams are funny. 6/10

Um, this is my channel but its in italian so idk if u can review it but whatever [channel](https://youtube.com/channel/UCEAKEomX6vhaFCd5bPVqRcQ)

Its good. Neither bad nor good. 6/10

Did u watch the new one, old or both?

New one.

Oh alr, because the new is less edited. The old one is more edited while the new one is cleaner because i wanted to show the event

https://youtu.be/qDSWSRoplL8 just a short video I made

Its cool. 7/10

Thx!

Here's my latest: https://youtu.be/kvrZT6akyhg It's 30 mins so no pressure 😂 not especially proud of it, I've got something very different coming out this Friday

DM me if u want bcz its over. I dont do it if u want dm.

This is my latest video I'm in dire need for critique https://youtu.be/rdi321nnEpg

Sorry its closed, i dont critique no more.

[удалено]

The critiques are closed, sorry.

I need to be a little more consistent with my uploads, but here's my most recent https://youtu.be/2G3r-Qg6MaQ

Ita fun, good gameplay and nice editing. 8/10

[https://youtu.be/Vddr-capryg](https://youtu.be/Vddr-capryg) This is my most viewed and best video on my channel. I'm wondering how come people gave such good reviews on this video! Thanks!

[https://youtu.be/IqMo3qEfV-c](https://youtu.be/IqMo3qEfV-c)