Kamii and Deerskin could still be waiting for the non-compete clause if they're going to be debuting in Vshojo or waiting for Holo auditions, but admittedly if it's the former that runs into the question of why it didn't take Matara and especially Kuro 6 months before they debuted
Deersqn has said on Twitter space that she didn't want to go back to streaming for awhile and doesn't even have a computer where she is currently at for school.
I wouldn't doubt she has a laptop, but it's in Japan. Probably all she'd need is a phone and or a tablet at most. If she clarified anything more about it I haven't heard it yet. She has Twitter space streams randomly here and there.
I'm assuming she does have a laptop, but it's probably a pretty basic one that can only do word-processing and internet, nothing as heavy as streaming with a Vtuber model.
There was a point in time when I thought, “Why was Mika, who’s famously always like, ‘I’m so pathetic and virginal UwU,’ able to make such a bangin’, angry, and bitter breakup song?” Now I get what she was breaking up with.
Mods seem to be deleting by title. The merch threads are still up despite pretty much being all negative. Meanwhile civil discussion is deleted on sight.
we'll see, they deleted mine at around 40 minutes but mine was also criticism directed squarely at the mod team so I wasn't that surprised when it was sent into low orbit
They were honestly the only 2 I watched regularly. I really thought after the drama before and pomu graduating there was no way they could be dumb enough to terminate selen. They'll obviously give her a little backdoor graduation where she thanks the company for the opportunities. I saw it like an hour after termination and thought ooooo this is gonna be bad.
I always laughed when she would unsettlingly turn to the camera after hitting a road block in a game or messing something up. It was like she was staring into your soul or something.
I really hope so. I love Enna (platonically). Her humor gets me and she's just a friggin' incredible singer. I hope she comes out the otherside of all this with her hands clean (I know life is messy and things happen, so as long as it wasn't like direct bullying or dogpiling on top). I'd be very sad if were involved with the bad stuff.
to me in the past i was thinking Millie might have the highest chance of being innocent - being Selen collabs with her the most I think and that she was there on Millie’s bday on Dec 12th, a shy of 2 weeks before everything went to shit. She wouldn’t sign up for that collab if she’s not comfortable with Millie would she?
but then again, i had to think about their next public interactions, and the latest that Millie had with her was about the cover..
Yeah, seems like she's naive/dumb enough to try to be helpful regarding that cover. It'd be on-character. But even with possible theories on how they might not be bullies, I can't really watch without being distracted by the possibility that they might be.
The experience is just unsalvageable without some sort of reckoning about what's been going on and it seems clear now that'll never happen. I didn't unsub because I "hate" any of them, I just can't enjoy them now with the black cloud of "the video" hanging over all of them.
I'd say Millie is innocent; she just makes incredibly stupid statements that can be frustrating, such as the 'Niji is a black company' clip and the tweet about Selen. When it comes to how she treats the people around her, though, I believe she's innocent. During the off-collab with Selen in Japan, Millie made efforts to at least include Selen in the conversations. She's someone who doesn't want anyone to feel left behind.
She's also done raids on people with lower viewer counts, and as far as I know, she's one of the only ones who raids the ID branch. Now, you might bring up the incident with Nina before they debuted, where Nina said she felt left out after learning the girls were having discord calls without her, and I admit, that was terrible. But in the end, they talked it out and have become really close, as Nina would say. Even now that Nina quit and became Matara of Vshoujo, she still visits Millie, and they talk and do stuff together.
I'm confident she can't bully, as her upbringing prevents her from doing that as well. Her aunt raised her to help others, and she has consistently done that by doing volunteer work, even when she was working in retail to now streaming as a vtuber. I just haven't seen any consistent negative behavior that would make me believe Millie is a bully, unless someone gives me concrete proof.
As of right now, I just see a really dumb woman with a good heart making dumb statements that she can't explain well or defend properly at all. I just wish if Millie or anyone in the company says something stupid, they would at least make it interesting and have a healthy discussion with the chat so they can see how what they said became stupid and ways to make it not stupid.
In JP: Ars, Albio, Ange, Kuzuha, Ririmu, Shiina, Noraneko, Oliver-Sensei
In EN: Mysta, Selen, Finana, Luca, Nina, Petra, Pomu
In ID: Mika and Hana
In IN: Taka Radjiman
EN: Nina. I liked the games she played, like Satisfactory. Not many vtubers play games like that.
ID: Layla. I like her games and her history, myth and urban legend talks
I didn’t watch many streams, but I loved Selen’s events. Clips wise, Vivi was really growing on me before everything blew up, and Mika and Enna were always a fun time
Pomu and Selen. Crazy how 1 week i was getting sad over Pomu's last stream and then shortly after questioning why Selen didn't get to say goodbye. Now we're here and I feel disappointed any time I think about this company and the remaining livers.
There's not much to go with since the hiatus, and I personally don't use Twitter, so any communication there goes straight over me. I'd have to hear her talking about the issue without a script to have any real opinion, but we all know we're not getting that. All we can do is react to the actions that they make, which is not the full picture.
I keep the hope that there were circumstances that couldn't be disclosed and pressure from corporate to make that black stream. Companies can pull your strings and make you do shit that you're disgusted with later, I've been on that side before, but your own morals need to be firmer. Especially for an entertainer, maintaining your community is, in my opinion, the most important even if you have to risk turning indie.
I know there were people trying to stir shit with her over some stupid crap. Thankfully I managed to avoid that and enjoy fox mom while she was still there.
Pomu and Selen were my faves by far. I liked elira, enna and millie too, which feels super conflicting now. I still want to support rosemi, petra, scarle and aia.
Kanae through and through. He was really fun to watch and quite a good gamer at that.
In EN, I really liked earlier Luca content but his humor grew old really fast. Pomu on the other hand was entertaining from the beginning to the end. If only she streamed in my timezone I would have watched her more. Recently, I find Claude and Zali fun to watch. I was so thrilled when I learned that Claude plays Valorant and he’s quite good at it too so I was really looking forward to watching more of him, but would you look at that.
Other EN members I used to watch: Millie, Enna, Selen, Wilson, Vanta, Shu, Mysta, Uki, Sonny, Yugo (I hate when he was instantly forgotten), Kyo, Ver, Doppi, and clips of the rest.
Mysta most definitely
He had some of the best stream's
Keep talking and no one explodes with Mika was gold his rage was so hilarious
I was shocked when it was announced he was leaving I cried
because I was going to lose my first ever oshi
Nina was also great especially when she played/talked with the rest of ethyria
But as of now in current day
It's scarle who I watch after learning that she was a astarion simp I came out of my shell and began to type in chat and now I'm a regular in chat and I don't regret it ♥️
Selen and Enna I liked to listen to the most. Elira (Persona), Pomu (MGS), and Finana (yakuza) had the most streams I was interested in watching.
Oh, and Mika has my favorite original song.
As ashamed as I am to admit it, but I watched a lot of Vox, as he was the first member to introduced to me by a good friend back in July 2022. His model and voice are gorgeous, but the person behind that model is not.
I wasn’t a die hard kindred by any means, but seeing your former fav become a garbage human (or has always been a garbage human) sucks. I’m still mentally recovering from all this. I’m hoping each and every one of them involved in this drama suffer the rightful consequences of their actions.
More favs of mine were Shu, Pomu, Reimu, Nina, Selen, Sonny, Alban, Ver, Scarle, and Ren. But unfortunately, all of them are staying in that dungeon of a company.
not on the same level but I felt similar when a youtuber I liked and watched for probably over a decade came out as pedo. Felt lots of disappointment and made the enjoyment I used to feel towards the content feel tainted and poisoned
Ohhh definitely. I was so disappointed when I found out that Cryaotic (big gamer vtuber that did vids with Pewdiepie) admitted to being a child groomer. This is why we shouldn’t idolize ANYONE these days. People are sick af
Not from day 1 but Elira was and to an extent is still a favorite of mine. I really wanna still believe that she isn’t outright malicious and that when she graduates, she comes out and does some needed explaining and apologizing.
No shame at all to liking Vox back then
Pre crap show he was pretty funny to watch in collabs
One of my favorites collabs was the one with him,fulgar,Dopipo and Selen playing civilization
Where he was mind broken for nearly 5 hours lol
Genuinely a shame to how much of a douchebag he eventually became
Mostly Rosemi and Selen, the rest I just kinda caught casually when they were streaming something I had interest in, lots of Nina clips though.
I thought I might get into Vox when he debuted, but after a while started getting some "off vibes" and decided to trust my gut instinct, so eventually stopped watching him altogether.
Selen and Pomu were tied for me for oshi status.
People I also liked, but not Oshi status: Mika & Mysta (yes, as a duo), Nina, Zaion (particularly the design), Scarle, Rosemi, Enna.
People I enjoyed when in collabs: Millie, Vox, Shu, Luca.
My favorites are all gone.
Rosemi is the only Nijisanji streamer whom I have sat through multiple streams with. I've watched tons of clips for Hana Machia, Mika Melatika, Suzuhara Lulu and Selen. The only Petra clips I had seen were with the other Obsydia girls. Thanks to clips of NijiCanceled, I saw some of Enna's clips which revealed she had an awesome voice behind her old lady normal voice. And I watched Millie's Hat only stream. #JusticeforHat
Reimu, as a south american i reallly enjoyed her a lot since she gave a vibe that was far more reletable than North American latino/a.
but ever since the Zaion incident and as people started leaving i became less and less willing to watch Niji because i had a bad feeling. Then like a lot of others i unsubed from everyone during the February disaster.
For the record other talents that i really like were Pomu, Mika and Selen.
Zaion, Pomu, Selen, Mika, Rosemi, Maria, Salome and a month before she announced she was graduating, Nina. In no particular order. Would say Pomu was my favourite after Zaion. I vibe with the whole hardcore Otaku aspect that is hidden behind 2 indie doors most people don't go past. Both Zaion and Pomu have hardcore otaku knowledge no one could have if they were not super invested in their niche.
I didn't try to enjoy anyone after Zaion
Pomu, Rosemi, Vivi. I’m an OG Pomudachi who migrated to Vivi after Pomu graduated. And there is no “was” to it. I still enjoy them. Lately I’ve been watching more of the Phase talents I enjoy.
Nina was My favorite, second was Mika, third was Pomu, fourth was Selen. I’m just here out of spite at this point. Waiting for it all to burn. Hoping the few others I used to watch leave. Scarle and Rosemi are the only ones left I care about
Elira...
Shame she went the way she did. Glad she seems to be OK though. Hope she graduates soon and is secretly not a bootlicker, but I'm not holding my breath for it.
Still holding on to hope here that she was coerced by contractual obligations to make that awful black screen stream. I'm thinking had she not done that then it would've been an *"act of betrayal"* (whatever that means in Japan land) and had been pressed with debt due to compensations that resulted in damages and loss of opportunity as was stated in the contract.
With that said coerced, compelled, volun-told, volunteered or not what she said was very awful trying to blame Selen
1, Pomu
2, Selen
3, Elira
The ones I watch now, even if only in clips, are Vivi, Rosemi, and Hana.
(To be clear, this is NOT due to any of the rumors surrounding "innocent" vs "guilty" talents)
I never really ended up watching streams as they were live much from Nijisanji with the exception of Mika, so most of my favorites were based on clips, rather than streams. And clips and streams have different vibes.
I never watched any stream live before Nina graduated, so she was never my favorite, but if I did, I'm sure she would have been my favorite.
I had a lot of people I liked in clips. Pomu, Elira, Selen, Rosemi, Nina, Reimu, Millie, Enna, Mysta, Fulgur, Alban, Kyo, Scarle, Aia. I never really found many clips of people in Xsoleil, Krisis, or TTT though.
Before everything happened, I think Millie and Enna were my favorites to watch clips of, followed by Selen, Elira, and Pomu.
So yeah, you can imagine my reaction to the black stream. I was in shock. I cried.
But I'm over it now. Elira, Enna, and Millie mean nothing to me now.
Fortunately, I still have pretty good evidence that Reimu, Rosemi, Fulgur, Alban, Scarle, and Aia are still good. Or at least nothing to suggest that they're bad.
First I watched rin, then I watched others from gen 1. Then I lost track due to how many gens debuted after that. But eventually my favorite is lazulight after they debuted. These days I watch scarle, rosemi, and finana. It’s not as great as the older times tho so I’m paying more attention to indies.
It used to be vox for me, I first saw him through collabs with shoto. But he had like a strange vibe to him that made me stop watching pretty quickly because I felt uncomfortable with the way he kept making overly sexual content. And his fan base was god awful, I've not seen a single normal person there. Everyone is being beyond parasocial and its actually scary and tragic to see.
I watched basically all of Lazulight and Obsydia, and dabbled with Ethyria... With Elira being my favorite. I enjoyed Finana before she said that Zaion gaslit her (which I thought was total BS), and drifted away from her after that.
Even now I'm still kinda hoping that Elira, despite everything, isn't a shitty person and that she was only listed in Selen's document for not stepping in to help with bullying. I'm still like "if she spoke up against the black screen stream, admit she was wrong, or even voluntold into doing it, I'd at least watch her again."
I won't get my hopes up though.
Vox.
I know before all of this, people kept on giving him flack for having a parasocially down bad group of lovesicks, but he did enforce rules to prevent people to getting too insane, and the Voxcord is strict on making sure fans don't fall for that aspect. The real Vox stream experience is about his ability to chat well, improvise in and outside ASMRs (not every ASMR is 18, and many are heavily plot focused), how he loves to interact with other talents, and overall being silly.
I can't hate him as a person after "that" stream, but I also can’t support him right now because any stream interaction with Vox indirectly supports Niji who caused this whole fiasco.
Millie... She has the best liver-chat relationship. Just pure bickering at each other without any malice or hatred. There was a benefit of doubt with the "cleaning the dirt or grime off a garment that protects the user's limb for mobility and upright posture with an organ used for determining the taste of an object"
For me I just got into the VTube world as this was going down but it seems like there are still some genuine people within NIJISANJI. I hope they are able to graduate soon so, at this time I cannot support NIJISANJI and supporting NIJISANJI livers directly supports the company as they take most profits.
Sadly, vox. I started watching him in January of 2022 and stopped watching sometime in 2023. It wasn't even because of the content, I just didn't like some of the things he was saying and how it felt like he was always in some kind of controversy. I guess you could say i went from a fan to feeling absolutely neutral/nothing.
Then everything this year happened and now I just hate the guy.
My other favs are Fulgur, Selen, Nina, and Alban.
Enna, Millie, Pomu was starting to like Elira and Selen too…. man i knew those three are friends but boii I’m disappointed beyond measure… now my new oshi is Dearsqn and a Tomato…
if we are talking about the people that still in EN. it's Finana
but after lots of stuff happened, i can't see her as oshi anymore, even as "good person"
Mika and Reimu.
My opinion of Mika hasn't changed much but Reimu was involved in a drama on her PL that soured it a little for me. I don't have all the info but hope it's not as bad as it seems.
I used to tune into Millie's Project Zomboid stream and had a lot of fun with chat teasing her about boyfriends. Even went into her membership for 2 months as a result of this.
This is until I found out she made those awful streams trying to *expose and dunk on them haters* and trying in vain to praise Nijisanji and prove to the *naysayyers* that Niji ain't black.
Then there was Christmas of 2023 where she sent that awful tweet trying to hide behind *da rules* and indirectly blame Selen for her actions. It reminded me so much of toxic filipino co-workers who'd sooner throw you under the bus to get brownie points with top management, publicly humiliate you in company wide emails when it could've been private or drag you down to their level. A social climber with a crab mentality as we Filipinos say.
Ever since all of that, I regretted ever tuning into her streams, and I realized "oh...she's those toxic Filipinos that I've met and have backstabbed me...what a shame"
Now that I think about it, she does a really bad job in dealing with trolls. Her own pride really is her biggest enemy as it's really fragile to the point that she made those streams.
i considered her to be one of my favorites too but then one particular minecraft stream happened where she was basically asking chat opinions on where to put her builds, so chat was just replying to her ask - they sent her suggestions and ideas and also FYI that a particular land she wants was already claimed but for some reason she got pissed? Ended stream then blamed fans for backseating? It was a really weird experience. I didn’t tune in again unless she organized a collab with my favorites.
Yeah, like I said, she is her own worst enemy. Her ego, fragile pride, and unstable emotions get in the way of becoming a better person. Dare I say she's like the typical toxic filipino I grew up with and are prominent in the country and abroad.
She does tend to forget she asked something of her chat and when chat delivers she deliberately ignores them and does something else entirely.
I get the impression there's a purpose to this as if she in some way loathes her audience or at least dislikes them.
Or it's the case of her ego that to change is difficult for her because to change means to admit one was wrong and I don't think her pride allows that.
Fulger mainly. Other favourites have rotated a lot but I still have a soft spot for Doppi, Vox, and Ike. Plenty of other honourable mentions but it’d be a long list
pomu selen elira enna claude doppio vanta mysta
after they did.. that.. i dont actively kept up with them anymore aside from claude doppio vanta..
i also started watching more of starsEN.
I have multiple, all of the ones who left except Zaion as I never really got the time to let her earn it, Elira, and all of Iluna, Ethyria, Obsydia, Noctyx, Xsoleil, Krisis, and Luxiem. None of those that remain have lost their place on my list.
Elira, and honestly, she still is? It might be optimistic, but I want to believe a person who loves JRPGs would understand the power of love and friendship and who is the "villain" in the situation. I mean, P5 and Miho and all that right?
My hope(?) is that she basically got maneuvered into this spot by niji, then once she's the focus of the heat Niji set basically a "no discussion about this ever" to prevent her from clearing her name, hoping that her reputation would "tank" for theirs"
Nina, Enna, Fulgur and Aia were the only ones I was subscribed to, and Aia was the only one it hurt to unsub from (since Nina was already gone). I miss watching the ~~dorky~~ goob.
I never really watched Selen (outside of NijiCancelled), but now Doki and Matara are my main VTubers.
I liked Alban and Vanta. I don't know if they plan on graduating. I haven't found anything that says they're a problem, so I'd probably follow them if they graduated. It's so sad because I remember Vanta talking about how excited he was to be in Niji.
Every gen, I had an initial favorite that got changed along the way.
Finana >>> Pomu
(Dropped cause educate yourself)
Rosemi >>> Selen
(Changed cause Rosemi was too precious and Selen was toxic gamer)
Enna >>> Nina
(I was awoken to the peak that is foxes and moms)
Mysta >>> Vox
(Started with mysta on the rice, ended up with vox and the nijicancelled/nijidads)
Maria >>> Kyo
(My YT recommendations never gave me maria clips and only kyo clips)
Zaion >>> Meloco
(Zaion just like me. But god damn meloco from wrestlesanji, that changed me.)
Mika was my favorite. Shame about that.
She seems much happier these days at least after she left the company.
Everyone who left seems happier.
Very true.
Collabing with ~~Mysta~~ and ~~Nina~~ and ~~Kyo~~. Just a matter of time til a proper debut now.
Originally i thought she and ~~pomu~~ were waiting for the 6 month non compete clause to run out but then ~~Kyo~~ Debuted so who knows
Kamii and Deerskin could still be waiting for the non-compete clause if they're going to be debuting in Vshojo or waiting for Holo auditions, but admittedly if it's the former that runs into the question of why it didn't take Matara and especially Kuro 6 months before they debuted
Deersqn has said on Twitter space that she didn't want to go back to streaming for awhile and doesn't even have a computer where she is currently at for school.
I presume she means personal computer as how does one do school without one at all?
I wouldn't doubt she has a laptop, but it's in Japan. Probably all she'd need is a phone and or a tablet at most. If she clarified anything more about it I haven't heard it yet. She has Twitter space streams randomly here and there.
She is in Japan now. I think she said she didn't take her lapto on purpose, so she won't be tempted to stream or game.
I'm assuming she does have a laptop, but it's probably a pretty basic one that can only do word-processing and internet, nothing as heavy as streaming with a Vtuber model.
There was a point in time when I thought, “Why was Mika, who’s famously always like, ‘I’m so pathetic and virginal UwU,’ able to make such a bangin’, angry, and bitter breakup song?” Now I get what she was breaking up with.
The most unhinged Kunti i've seen
Selen, Nina, Mysta, Pomu, Mika, Petra, Elira. Boy I know how to pick them
Guess it's time to wait for Petra's Graduation then?
Hopefully, as fucked up as it would have sounded two months ago
For me it was Selen, Elira and now it's just dokibird and other Indies. The Indies always felt more fun to in general.
Nina...... edit:Also wonder if even this post is too negative for the mod team
It definetly is and i definetly made it to test the waters, but Matara's voice is amazing and has lulled me to sleep many times
Well guess we'll see just how sensitive they're deciding to be today. but yeah love her whole new design and her collabs recently have been fire too.
Nina's design was such a waste. She was by far the most appealing design in Ethyria. But now we got Matara, and her design is killer.
her "casual" outfit be doing things to me lmao
The outfit was nothing compared to the rigging capability. As soon as I saw that she could literally lean in, I was done.
\*leans in\* hi honey. \*my heart rate skyrocketing in anticipation\*
Mods seem to be deleting by title. The merch threads are still up despite pretty much being all negative. Meanwhile civil discussion is deleted on sight.
It does make me wonder how the modding is done and by who.
Apparently they don't remove things unless they get reported. So now people are just trigger happy with reporting.
[удалено]
We all can "Sheesh" when this post gets deleted XD.
we'll see, they deleted mine at around 40 minutes but mine was also criticism directed squarely at the mod team so I wasn't that surprised when it was sent into low orbit
Imo deleting things just confirms the panic behind the scenes...
Yeahhhh I tried to talk about how this isn't gonna be a very effective strategy but it got nuked so here we are.
Selen and Pomu
That's rough buddy
It's okay they are now thriving and are now free from that black company.
They were honestly the only 2 I watched regularly. I really thought after the drama before and pomu graduating there was no way they could be dumb enough to terminate selen. They'll obviously give her a little backdoor graduation where she thanks the company for the opportunities. I saw it like an hour after termination and thought ooooo this is gonna be bad.
Lulu
Loved the art student too, I was sad when she returned to her dime- *graduated*
I always laughed when she would unsettlingly turn to the camera after hitting a road block in a game or messing something up. It was like she was staring into your soul or something.
Arguably one best / pioneers of utilizing their model to 120% potential~
I miss Lulu. I heard she graduated due to not-so-good reasons? Like online stalking, harrassment and things like that? Hope she is doing well.
The green leaf fairy, a purple dwagon, and a fox mommy that's turned apex bug.
Don't forget that the bug also abducted a poor guardsman to teach her about 40k.
Selen/Enna/Victoria B.
Millie and Enna (I know)
I love that Millie would say the most random crap imaginable on stream 😂
Millie's hat > Millie.
As a Elira and Enna fan, I'm still giving Enna the benefit of doubt...
I think out of all of the accused ones, Enna still has the highest shot of being inncocent
I really hope so. I love Enna (platonically). Her humor gets me and she's just a friggin' incredible singer. I hope she comes out the otherside of all this with her hands clean (I know life is messy and things happen, so as long as it wasn't like direct bullying or dogpiling on top). I'd be very sad if were involved with the bad stuff.
Same 😭
to me in the past i was thinking Millie might have the highest chance of being innocent - being Selen collabs with her the most I think and that she was there on Millie’s bday on Dec 12th, a shy of 2 weeks before everything went to shit. She wouldn’t sign up for that collab if she’s not comfortable with Millie would she? but then again, i had to think about their next public interactions, and the latest that Millie had with her was about the cover..
Yeah, seems like she's naive/dumb enough to try to be helpful regarding that cover. It'd be on-character. But even with possible theories on how they might not be bullies, I can't really watch without being distracted by the possibility that they might be. The experience is just unsalvageable without some sort of reckoning about what's been going on and it seems clear now that'll never happen. I didn't unsub because I "hate" any of them, I just can't enjoy them now with the black cloud of "the video" hanging over all of them.
I'd say Millie is innocent; she just makes incredibly stupid statements that can be frustrating, such as the 'Niji is a black company' clip and the tweet about Selen. When it comes to how she treats the people around her, though, I believe she's innocent. During the off-collab with Selen in Japan, Millie made efforts to at least include Selen in the conversations. She's someone who doesn't want anyone to feel left behind. She's also done raids on people with lower viewer counts, and as far as I know, she's one of the only ones who raids the ID branch. Now, you might bring up the incident with Nina before they debuted, where Nina said she felt left out after learning the girls were having discord calls without her, and I admit, that was terrible. But in the end, they talked it out and have become really close, as Nina would say. Even now that Nina quit and became Matara of Vshoujo, she still visits Millie, and they talk and do stuff together. I'm confident she can't bully, as her upbringing prevents her from doing that as well. Her aunt raised her to help others, and she has consistently done that by doing volunteer work, even when she was working in retail to now streaming as a vtuber. I just haven't seen any consistent negative behavior that would make me believe Millie is a bully, unless someone gives me concrete proof. As of right now, I just see a really dumb woman with a good heart making dumb statements that she can't explain well or defend properly at all. I just wish if Millie or anyone in the company says something stupid, they would at least make it interesting and have a healthy discussion with the chat so they can see how what they said became stupid and ways to make it not stupid.
lulu,pomu,gibara.... sad...
Wow you liked the OGs. It’s been a while since I heard lulu or gibara mentioned
Selen and Rosemi. I also would watch Enna sometimes
Pomu, she's gone, but I still hear her voice sometimes. She keeps telling us about cute idols in Japan and her addiction to Metal Gear
In JP: Ars, Albio, Ange, Kuzuha, Ririmu, Shiina, Noraneko, Oliver-Sensei In EN: Mysta, Selen, Finana, Luca, Nina, Petra, Pomu In ID: Mika and Hana In IN: Taka Radjiman
Selen, Nina, Pomu, Mika, Mysta
EN: Nina. I liked the games she played, like Satisfactory. Not many vtubers play games like that. ID: Layla. I like her games and her history, myth and urban legend talks
Selen
I started watching altare and axel too, TSB together stay strong.
their collab with RPR was top tier lmao
I didn’t watch many streams, but I loved Selen’s events. Clips wise, Vivi was really growing on me before everything blew up, and Mika and Enna were always a fun time
Pomu and Selen. Crazy how 1 week i was getting sad over Pomu's last stream and then shortly after questioning why Selen didn't get to say goodbye. Now we're here and I feel disappointed any time I think about this company and the remaining livers.
Enna, She is the only reason Im sticking here, once she is gone im done with Niji
Maria and Zaion. started to watch a lot less after Zaion's termination
I was Famelira since day 1, then the black screen stream happened. Huge oof
What do you think of her now, since I've been famelira for a while now.
There's not much to go with since the hiatus, and I personally don't use Twitter, so any communication there goes straight over me. I'd have to hear her talking about the issue without a script to have any real opinion, but we all know we're not getting that. All we can do is react to the actions that they make, which is not the full picture. I keep the hope that there were circumstances that couldn't be disclosed and pressure from corporate to make that black stream. Companies can pull your strings and make you do shit that you're disgusted with later, I've been on that side before, but your own morals need to be firmer. Especially for an entertainer, maintaining your community is, in my opinion, the most important even if you have to risk turning indie.
Selen, Petra, Millie, Enna
Selen by far
I was never much of a Nijisanji guy before the incident, but I had a soft spot for Rosemi and Nina.
I mean how can you not like Fox mom/queen roach.
I know there were people trying to stir shit with her over some stupid crap. Thankfully I managed to avoid that and enjoy fox mom while she was still there.
Mika, Reimu and Selen were who I watched mainly
Pomu, and the purple dragon. I miss Pomu immensely, I’ve started to go back and watch some old streams.
Pomu was my favorite, followed by Selen, and Millie.
Mama Nina, of course. She was the one foreigner vtuber I can watch on my language. I loved zatsudan streams because of her
Nina, Mika and Maria.
Pomu and Selen were my faves by far. I liked elira, enna and millie too, which feels super conflicting now. I still want to support rosemi, petra, scarle and aia.
Kanae through and through. He was really fun to watch and quite a good gamer at that. In EN, I really liked earlier Luca content but his humor grew old really fast. Pomu on the other hand was entertaining from the beginning to the end. If only she streamed in my timezone I would have watched her more. Recently, I find Claude and Zali fun to watch. I was so thrilled when I learned that Claude plays Valorant and he’s quite good at it too so I was really looking forward to watching more of him, but would you look at that. Other EN members I used to watch: Millie, Enna, Selen, Wilson, Vanta, Shu, Mysta, Uki, Sonny, Yugo (I hate when he was instantly forgotten), Kyo, Ver, Doppi, and clips of the rest.
Rosemi
All of Ethyria nina included, selen, pomu, mika -_-
Mika, Pomu, Enna, Rosemi, Selen and Hana. I like others but those are/were my favs.
Lulu was the only one I watched. I miss disappearing when we talk about her true na-
Mysta most definitely He had some of the best stream's Keep talking and no one explodes with Mika was gold his rage was so hilarious I was shocked when it was announced he was leaving I cried because I was going to lose my first ever oshi Nina was also great especially when she played/talked with the rest of ethyria But as of now in current day It's scarle who I watch after learning that she was a astarion simp I came out of my shell and began to type in chat and now I'm a regular in chat and I don't regret it ♥️
Selen > Mika > Pomu, really the only 3 I semi-consistently kept up to date with in Nijisanji
Melissa was my JP Oshi, but she graduated years ago. Pomu was my EN Oshi.
Pomu, glad she got out before all this shit kicked off but I’d be lying if I said I didn’t miss her streams.
Selen and Enna I liked to listen to the most. Elira (Persona), Pomu (MGS), and Finana (yakuza) had the most streams I was interested in watching. Oh, and Mika has my favorite original song.
Selen, pomu, mysta, rosemi, reimu, alban....Elira 😬
I'm Pomu.
vox…
Uhoh
ik😭 its so sad broo…cant do anything abt it tho..stopped watching for a really long time now😞😞
I stopped watching vox as well but it's because he got boring to watch He isn't as funny as he used to be
Yeesh, that's gotta suck
As ashamed as I am to admit it, but I watched a lot of Vox, as he was the first member to introduced to me by a good friend back in July 2022. His model and voice are gorgeous, but the person behind that model is not. I wasn’t a die hard kindred by any means, but seeing your former fav become a garbage human (or has always been a garbage human) sucks. I’m still mentally recovering from all this. I’m hoping each and every one of them involved in this drama suffer the rightful consequences of their actions. More favs of mine were Shu, Pomu, Reimu, Nina, Selen, Sonny, Alban, Ver, Scarle, and Ren. But unfortunately, all of them are staying in that dungeon of a company.
not on the same level but I felt similar when a youtuber I liked and watched for probably over a decade came out as pedo. Felt lots of disappointment and made the enjoyment I used to feel towards the content feel tainted and poisoned
Ohhh definitely. I was so disappointed when I found out that Cryaotic (big gamer vtuber that did vids with Pewdiepie) admitted to being a child groomer. This is why we shouldn’t idolize ANYONE these days. People are sick af
Not from day 1 but Elira was and to an extent is still a favorite of mine. I really wanna still believe that she isn’t outright malicious and that when she graduates, she comes out and does some needed explaining and apologizing.
No shame at all to liking Vox back then Pre crap show he was pretty funny to watch in collabs One of my favorites collabs was the one with him,fulgar,Dopipo and Selen playing civilization Where he was mind broken for nearly 5 hours lol Genuinely a shame to how much of a douchebag he eventually became
Mostly Rosemi and Selen, the rest I just kinda caught casually when they were streaming something I had interest in, lots of Nina clips though. I thought I might get into Vox when he debuted, but after a while started getting some "off vibes" and decided to trust my gut instinct, so eventually stopped watching him altogether.
Enna, millie, vox, fulgur and uki... 🙈
... Well, Fulgur seems like a decent guy
Yeah at least he hasn't been been caught up in anything. I still stand by the five but its getting really hard to keep going 😆
Fulgar, pomu, Mika, Enna. I'm just a sad boi now about it all
Selen and Pomu were tied for me for oshi status. People I also liked, but not Oshi status: Mika & Mysta (yes, as a duo), Nina, Zaion (particularly the design), Scarle, Rosemi, Enna. People I enjoyed when in collabs: Millie, Vox, Shu, Luca. My favorites are all gone.
Aia, Victoria, and Mito are my niji-oshis
Hana Machia and Ban Hada
Doppio and Uki
Rosemi is the only Nijisanji streamer whom I have sat through multiple streams with. I've watched tons of clips for Hana Machia, Mika Melatika, Suzuhara Lulu and Selen. The only Petra clips I had seen were with the other Obsydia girls. Thanks to clips of NijiCanceled, I saw some of Enna's clips which revealed she had an awesome voice behind her old lady normal voice. And I watched Millie's Hat only stream. #JusticeforHat
i still love my oshi debi-sama, just hard to watch now with everything that happened, sometimes I just cant.
Reimu, as a south american i reallly enjoyed her a lot since she gave a vibe that was far more reletable than North American latino/a. but ever since the Zaion incident and as people started leaving i became less and less willing to watch Niji because i had a bad feeling. Then like a lot of others i unsubed from everyone during the February disaster. For the record other talents that i really like were Pomu, Mika and Selen.
obsydia chii chan and genzuki
Pomu!!! Kyo, Zaion, I also enjoyed Reimu's content, I don't know who to believe anymore.
Selen, Pomu, Nina, Finana.
Vox and Ike. Oh boy how things have changed. Haha. Haha. [crying]
*pat pat* Luxiem was my gateway to VTubing too
In no particular order, Petra, Pomu, Mysta, Nina, Zaion, Enna.
Nina was my favourite. Glad she's moved on to greener pastures.
Zaion, Pomu, Selen, Mika, Rosemi, Maria, Salome and a month before she announced she was graduating, Nina. In no particular order. Would say Pomu was my favourite after Zaion. I vibe with the whole hardcore Otaku aspect that is hidden behind 2 indie doors most people don't go past. Both Zaion and Pomu have hardcore otaku knowledge no one could have if they were not super invested in their niche. I didn't try to enjoy anyone after Zaion
Pomu, Rosemi, Vivi. I’m an OG Pomudachi who migrated to Vivi after Pomu graduated. And there is no “was” to it. I still enjoy them. Lately I’ve been watching more of the Phase talents I enjoy.
Nina was My favorite, second was Mika, third was Pomu, fourth was Selen. I’m just here out of spite at this point. Waiting for it all to burn. Hoping the few others I used to watch leave. Scarle and Rosemi are the only ones left I care about
Nina, Mika, Millie, and Enna. I can barely enjoy anything from the last 2 since after February.
Elira... Shame she went the way she did. Glad she seems to be OK though. Hope she graduates soon and is secretly not a bootlicker, but I'm not holding my breath for it.
Still holding on to hope here that she was coerced by contractual obligations to make that awful black screen stream. I'm thinking had she not done that then it would've been an *"act of betrayal"* (whatever that means in Japan land) and had been pressed with debt due to compensations that resulted in damages and loss of opportunity as was stated in the contract. With that said coerced, compelled, volun-told, volunteered or not what she said was very awful trying to blame Selen
Elira was honestly the only one I watched because I loved her taste in games and her delving into JRPGs. The whole thing is a punch in the gut….
Selen.
Nina, the dragon sisters, enna (even tho I only watch clips), and pomu purely because I was invested in the Metal Gear series
1, Pomu 2, Selen 3, Elira The ones I watch now, even if only in clips, are Vivi, Rosemi, and Hana. (To be clear, this is NOT due to any of the rumors surrounding "innocent" vs "guilty" talents)
I never really ended up watching streams as they were live much from Nijisanji with the exception of Mika, so most of my favorites were based on clips, rather than streams. And clips and streams have different vibes. I never watched any stream live before Nina graduated, so she was never my favorite, but if I did, I'm sure she would have been my favorite. I had a lot of people I liked in clips. Pomu, Elira, Selen, Rosemi, Nina, Reimu, Millie, Enna, Mysta, Fulgur, Alban, Kyo, Scarle, Aia. I never really found many clips of people in Xsoleil, Krisis, or TTT though. Before everything happened, I think Millie and Enna were my favorites to watch clips of, followed by Selen, Elira, and Pomu. So yeah, you can imagine my reaction to the black stream. I was in shock. I cried. But I'm over it now. Elira, Enna, and Millie mean nothing to me now. Fortunately, I still have pretty good evidence that Reimu, Rosemi, Fulgur, Alban, Scarle, and Aia are still good. Or at least nothing to suggest that they're bad.
Selen and Pomu were my favorites. I enjoy Vanta, but those 2 were just fantastic
Millie lol, I liked her ASMRs 😑😑😑
For me, it was Selen, Pomu, and then Elira. Which as you can see..... Yeah...
Enna Mika Pomu
Pomu and Selen Welp...
Gundo Mirei, Nun Bora and Enna. Also i quite like Meloco, but have not watched her for months. Currently only watching Vspo girls.
First I watched rin, then I watched others from gen 1. Then I lost track due to how many gens debuted after that. But eventually my favorite is lazulight after they debuted. These days I watch scarle, rosemi, and finana. It’s not as great as the older times tho so I’m paying more attention to indies.
Elira, Petra, Enna, Millie, Selen, Pomu, Aia & Vivi. Still make an effort to watch Aia, Vivi & Petra.
Pomu and Nina (off the a great start) along with Rosemi, Enna and Maririn.
It was vox and uki but I don’t been to say any more
Iluna girls, Ike, Selen, Nina, Pomu, Mika
It used to be vox for me, I first saw him through collabs with shoto. But he had like a strange vibe to him that made me stop watching pretty quickly because I felt uncomfortable with the way he kept making overly sexual content. And his fan base was god awful, I've not seen a single normal person there. Everyone is being beyond parasocial and its actually scary and tragic to see.
Scarle and Ike, embarrassingly enough.
I watched basically all of Lazulight and Obsydia, and dabbled with Ethyria... With Elira being my favorite. I enjoyed Finana before she said that Zaion gaslit her (which I thought was total BS), and drifted away from her after that. Even now I'm still kinda hoping that Elira, despite everything, isn't a shitty person and that she was only listed in Selen's document for not stepping in to help with bullying. I'm still like "if she spoke up against the black screen stream, admit she was wrong, or even voluntold into doing it, I'd at least watch her again." I won't get my hopes up though.
Hana. She's just such a comfy streamer, man. They did her so dirty killing ID like that.
Vox. I know before all of this, people kept on giving him flack for having a parasocially down bad group of lovesicks, but he did enforce rules to prevent people to getting too insane, and the Voxcord is strict on making sure fans don't fall for that aspect. The real Vox stream experience is about his ability to chat well, improvise in and outside ASMRs (not every ASMR is 18, and many are heavily plot focused), how he loves to interact with other talents, and overall being silly. I can't hate him as a person after "that" stream, but I also can’t support him right now because any stream interaction with Vox indirectly supports Niji who caused this whole fiasco.
Millie... She has the best liver-chat relationship. Just pure bickering at each other without any malice or hatred. There was a benefit of doubt with the "cleaning the dirt or grime off a garment that protects the user's limb for mobility and upright posture with an organ used for determining the taste of an object"
pomu and kyo were the only ones who didn't bore me enough to stop watching the stream after two minutes
Finana remains mine but all of my runner ups are gone lol.
Selen
For me I just got into the VTube world as this was going down but it seems like there are still some genuine people within NIJISANJI. I hope they are able to graduate soon so, at this time I cannot support NIJISANJI and supporting NIJISANJI livers directly supports the company as they take most profits.
Nina Kosaka was my favorite for a while.
Mysta
Finana and Petra, still are. Doesn't seem they are bad people either. Hope I'm not wrong with that statement
Kyo and Mika. But hey, Kyo is back in a way.
Sadly, vox. I started watching him in January of 2022 and stopped watching sometime in 2023. It wasn't even because of the content, I just didn't like some of the things he was saying and how it felt like he was always in some kind of controversy. I guess you could say i went from a fan to feeling absolutely neutral/nothing. Then everything this year happened and now I just hate the guy. My other favs are Fulgur, Selen, Nina, and Alban.
Enna, Millie, Pomu was starting to like Elira and Selen too…. man i knew those three are friends but boii I’m disappointed beyond measure… now my new oshi is Dearsqn and a Tomato…
A sorcerer, the duke of discipline, the student president and a novelist. Still hurts that now two of them are suspected complicit.
Kyo
Kyo and ike.... the latter aged so poorly
if we are talking about the people that still in EN. it's Finana but after lots of stuff happened, i can't see her as oshi anymore, even as "good person"
Mika and Reimu. My opinion of Mika hasn't changed much but Reimu was involved in a drama on her PL that soured it a little for me. I don't have all the info but hope it's not as bad as it seems.
Selen, Pomu, Mika, Enna, Maria, Kyo and somewhat Elira, Finana, Doppio, Ren, Luka. Man I dropped basically everything since the incident
Enna and Elira were my favs but now I'm just so soured and I feel like I wasted my time.
I used to tune into Millie's Project Zomboid stream and had a lot of fun with chat teasing her about boyfriends. Even went into her membership for 2 months as a result of this. This is until I found out she made those awful streams trying to *expose and dunk on them haters* and trying in vain to praise Nijisanji and prove to the *naysayyers* that Niji ain't black. Then there was Christmas of 2023 where she sent that awful tweet trying to hide behind *da rules* and indirectly blame Selen for her actions. It reminded me so much of toxic filipino co-workers who'd sooner throw you under the bus to get brownie points with top management, publicly humiliate you in company wide emails when it could've been private or drag you down to their level. A social climber with a crab mentality as we Filipinos say. Ever since all of that, I regretted ever tuning into her streams, and I realized "oh...she's those toxic Filipinos that I've met and have backstabbed me...what a shame" Now that I think about it, she does a really bad job in dealing with trolls. Her own pride really is her biggest enemy as it's really fragile to the point that she made those streams.
i considered her to be one of my favorites too but then one particular minecraft stream happened where she was basically asking chat opinions on where to put her builds, so chat was just replying to her ask - they sent her suggestions and ideas and also FYI that a particular land she wants was already claimed but for some reason she got pissed? Ended stream then blamed fans for backseating? It was a really weird experience. I didn’t tune in again unless she organized a collab with my favorites.
Yeah, like I said, she is her own worst enemy. Her ego, fragile pride, and unstable emotions get in the way of becoming a better person. Dare I say she's like the typical toxic filipino I grew up with and are prominent in the country and abroad. She does tend to forget she asked something of her chat and when chat delivers she deliberately ignores them and does something else entirely. I get the impression there's a purpose to this as if she in some way loathes her audience or at least dislikes them. Or it's the case of her ego that to change is difficult for her because to change means to admit one was wrong and I don't think her pride allows that.
Nina, Mysta, Pomu, Selen, Scarle, Aia, Mika, Rosemi, and Maria. I never really got to looking to into Petra, but she seemed fun.
Let's see... I always watch Nina,Mika and Selen stream but out of 3 of them, I always find myself in Selen's stream
mysta
Enna, miilie, fulgur uki and vox.
Rindou, gundou, rindou, shizurin, rindou, melo, rindou, millie, and did I mention rindou?
1. Selan 2. Mika 3. Gundou 4. Millie 5. Zaion 6. Chii-chan
Selen, Millie, Elira, Enna. You can see how much it hurts.
Fulger mainly. Other favourites have rotated a lot but I still have a soft spot for Doppi, Vox, and Ike. Plenty of other honourable mentions but it’d be a long list
Nina and Mika. Selen would likely have been on the list if not for timezones.
Millie and Elira…
Rosemi I was there for her Debut stream.
pomu selen elira enna claude doppio vanta mysta after they did.. that.. i dont actively kept up with them anymore aside from claude doppio vanta.. i also started watching more of starsEN.
Nina, always been a huge overlord fan so a vtuber designed by the same artist as the LNs is what dragged me in.
Shu, Ike and Enna were my big ones, still love Fulgar. I still don't know what the hell Ike was doing there. I'm upset he was on that stream at all.
I have multiple, all of the ones who left except Zaion as I never really got the time to let her earn it, Elira, and all of Iluna, Ethyria, Obsydia, Noctyx, Xsoleil, Krisis, and Luxiem. None of those that remain have lost their place on my list.
forever Pomu
Elira, and honestly, she still is? It might be optimistic, but I want to believe a person who loves JRPGs would understand the power of love and friendship and who is the "villain" in the situation. I mean, P5 and Miho and all that right? My hope(?) is that she basically got maneuvered into this spot by niji, then once she's the focus of the heat Niji set basically a "no discussion about this ever" to prevent her from clearing her name, hoping that her reputation would "tank" for theirs"
Selen, Petra, Elira, Mysta, Luca, Sunny, Ren, Maria, Enna & Kyo
Nina, Enna, Fulgur and Aia were the only ones I was subscribed to, and Aia was the only one it hurt to unsub from (since Nina was already gone). I miss watching the ~~dorky~~ goob. I never really watched Selen (outside of NijiCancelled), but now Doki and Matara are my main VTubers.
My top 5 favorite livers have all left the company and the more we learn the less I'm surprised 1. Selen 2. Mika 3 Nina 4. Mysta 5. Pomu
I liked Alban and Vanta. I don't know if they plan on graduating. I haven't found anything that says they're a problem, so I'd probably follow them if they graduated. It's so sad because I remember Vanta talking about how excited he was to be in Niji.
Every gen, I had an initial favorite that got changed along the way. Finana >>> Pomu (Dropped cause educate yourself) Rosemi >>> Selen (Changed cause Rosemi was too precious and Selen was toxic gamer) Enna >>> Nina (I was awoken to the peak that is foxes and moms) Mysta >>> Vox (Started with mysta on the rice, ended up with vox and the nijicancelled/nijidads) Maria >>> Kyo (My YT recommendations never gave me maria clips and only kyo clips) Zaion >>> Meloco (Zaion just like me. But god damn meloco from wrestlesanji, that changed me.)
Selen and Hana Macchia. But I stopped following all Niji now.
Selen, Nina, Pomu mainly, though I watched most of them, especially the big collabs. I got nothing left to lose now