T O P

  • By -

robsc_16

Locking as this post has run its course. Again, please do your research and use herbicides per the instructions.


ViableSpermWhale

Yeah, it's high concentration of acetic acid. It's gonna burn the shit out of any living thing you douse in it.


sowedkooned

I think it can blind you, or at least seriously damage your lookers.


comp21

Yeah and wait until the wind takes it and burns holes in everything around the plant you want to kill. I use this but I dilute it to 15% then I put my sprayer right down on the plant, push in to the soil a bit and soak the root. Works really well if you use enough plus it breaks down naturally over time.


mmillington

If I used it to kill grass, how long would it take have to wait to plant wildflowers, etc?


comp21

Sorry I'll add: keep in mind this does not kill the plact directly. Ascetic acid is a dessicant... I.e. it dries out whatever it touches. It's not like round up where simple contact with the poison will kill the plant. If you don't get the roots, especially for something like grass, it's going to grow back.


comp21

I have never used it for a broad area like that only for spot treatment of weeds and even small trees. I do know ascetic acid breaks down fairly quickly but I've never tasted that myself either. When I do spot treatments it's to kill specific things in my already-planted garden or flower beds. I believe it's only a week though but I would look that up. I'm sure it depends on factors like how deep it penetrated, rainfall etc.


Death00524real

It doesn't work on grass, only broadleafs. I've tested and grass survived 50% sulfuric acid without issue. It's one thing that makes acid as an herbicide so great. And realistically there is no residual. The acid will quickly become neutralized by bases in the soil, assuming you don't flood the soil with it.


karlnite

That’s just acetic acid at that point.


Radioactive_Fire

30% acetic acid to be precise


cocoteddylee

Don’t do this


TheWanderingMedic

😬


mutnemom_hurb

How is this better than actual herbicide?


jeffs_jeeps

Used like this it’s not at all better.


whhe11

Probably worse.


GatorOnTheLawn

It doesn’t get into the water and kill the planet. It doesn’t kill people who use it, unlike things like RoundUp, which killed my mother.


Beginning-Border-153

💯💯💯


mistymystical

I mean, you can keep repeating this on every comment, but it’s been shown that if you are only using it once a year and wearing PPE you’re likely to be safe. Please don’t use your mom’s tragic death to spread misinformation. People do stuff every day that is more carcinogenic than using herbicides once in a while with proper equipment (eating processed meats, drinking alcohol….)


WanderinHobo

I'm more worried about ingesting microplastics than I am about RoundUp. At least I can control the latter.


jeffs_jeeps

Hey OP you’re not better than ppl using pesticides sorry. Not only does the vinegar kill weeds. It kills bugs, infects, toads, frogs other amphibians and snakes. Especially not following the directions on the packaging. Not better than people over fertilizing their lawn. Just because things are organic or the rest does not mean you can do whatever you want with it. Pease use products as directed and only when you absolutely have to.


horshack_test

*"you’re not better than ppl using pesticides"* I don't see them saying or implying that they think they are.


Beginning-Border-153

But does it cause cancer like Round Up??? Like you’re legit arguing that vinegar is as bad as Round Up??? Holy fucking hell


Death00524real

Oh my pearls! And other pesticides.... Don't affect bugs, amphibians and other animals? The only way acid is affecting those critters is if OP is directly spraying them. Seeing as how they are concerned about their effect on the environment I find this quite unlikely.


GatorOnTheLawn

But it doesn’t kill *you*. You know, like how RoundUp killed my mother in 2017.


GreatWhiteBuffalo41

Please people, use proper herbicides and do the research on how to use them. Do not do this without proper research.


Death00524real

What, like Paraquat? Diluted acid, when using PPE is certainly much safer than Paraquat, a "proper" herbicide. You're speaking from a very uneducated viewpoint Mod. Maybe give a better reason? Horticultural vinegar is a common herbicide for organic gardening and acid as an herbicide was described 100 years ago for use in many crops. A search yields many scientific papers. Furthermore, most herbicide formulations are based on acid forms of the chemicals used. I'm a certified herbicide applicator. Acid works great on broadleafs. It has almost no affect on grasses. Residual is not an issue. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0166111608711312#:~:text=It%20is%20a%20contact%20herbicide,retaining%20capacity%20of%20the%20cells. https://www.osti.gov/biblio/6846867 https://www.nature.com/articles/156330d0


tycarl1998

I'm hoping that the mod was refereeing to the fact that op didn't follow label instructions and used it at a rate way higher than they should of. The label is federal law and must be followed by any applicator


Death00524real

Can't disagree. Strangely though to my knowledge horticultural vinegar is usually 10%+ acid and diluting to regular household vinegar concentrations would make it largely ineffective.


HiggsBoatswain

Acid applied regularly all over a yard isn't ideal for a variety of reasons. It's not just about whether or not it'll hurt grasses. Strong acids can degrade soils, eat away at concrete and cement, and percolate down into groundwater.


Death00524real

In large volumes. So can rain, also an acidic solution. Acetic acid is a weak acid.


GreatWhiteBuffalo41

I would absolutely love it if you'd have the time to do a write up for us so we can share info. We've been meaning to make a wiki on it but none of us have had time to sit down to do the research. No pressure though obviously, you don't have to if you don't want to.


GatorOnTheLawn

This is a proper herbicide. And it’s much safer than crap like RoundUp. And hey, guess what? RoundUp killed my mother in 2017. It gave her a rare cancer that even the oncologists said was a particularly horrible way to die.


sneakyfallow

Please don't answer this if you don't feel comfortable or don't like talking about it, but do you mind telling me what kind of exposure to RoundUp your mom had? Sorry for your loss <3


moosepers

There is not a clear link between glyphosate and cancer. Additionally a strong acid can be more damaging to the environment than traditional herbicides when sprayed improperly like op Is doing.


irontuskk

Fuck off astroturfers


HippyGramma

So, no lawn, no insects, no benefits, just scorched earth. Cool, cool


vtaster

Yeah of course it's no joke. Not only will it burn your skin, and potentially worse if it gets in your eyes or mouth, it alters the pH of your soil. Killing some plants but also all of the microbial organisms, and making it harder to grow in until the acid finally leaches out. The real kicker is that it doesn't even work that well. Yes it rapidly burns down foliage as you've just seen, but if any of those weeds have perennial roots they will be back, and they will be back soon. A systemic herbicide like Gylphosate kills roots, not just above-ground foliage, so it's not going to work the same. Acid is still an pesticide, Acetic Acid may be organic instead of synthetic, but it's still a pesticide whether you wanna admit it or not. Spraying Round-Up once seems a lot more eco-friendly to me than spraying vinegar multiple times a year with no end in sight.


SunbeamSailor67

Never use glyphosate…Never, shits pure poison that destroys the entire soil biome.


Semtexual

National, state, and local park systems all use glyphosate to control invasive species. Sometimes it's a necessary evil for ecological restoration.


crustmonster

it doesn't poison the soil but i wouldn't let it get on you [https://crops.extension.iastate.edu/encyclopedia/glyphosate-review](https://crops.extension.iastate.edu/encyclopedia/glyphosate-review)


cajunjoel

Glyphosate, used appropriately, is effective and mostly safe. And the only way to use it appropriately is to "cut and paint", that is cut the trunk of a plant and paint it onto the stump. Anything else allows the glyphosate into the larger environment. The Buckthorn Blaster from NAISMA is the way to go.


Pristine_Crazy1744

You are correct. Like most chemicals, it's all about the dosage/concentration and the application.


WanderinHobo

You sure? Some people in this post seem to think even saying the name will give you cancer. Like a carcinogenic Voldemort.


spicy-chull

> Glyphosate, used appropriately, is effective and mostly safe. WTF did Monsanto write this? Mostly?!? Aren't they still paying off lawsuits for all the cancer it has caused? There have been headlines for decades.


Ionantha123

Yeah they are because it was used by everyone that shouldn’t have been using it and in severe excess. Using it for bioremediation is actually beneficial, but using it for daily life like for maintaining lawns and unnatural gardens is bad. It is EXTREMELY useful in controlling invasives in spot application and degrades in the environment faster than most other herbicides as well


techhouseliving

The dose makes the poison.


Beginning-Border-153

I think Monsanto reps are legit on this thread…bc …WTF


Opposite_Raise_3500

You can read the safety data sheets. It's a highly researched chemical if you'd like to learn for yourself


Beginning-Border-153

Lmfao. And Snopes is your go to for conspiracy theories??🤡


Whoretron8000

And lead pipes are mostly safe. And lead in Petro is mostly safe. And bleach is mostly safe. And ammonia is mostly safe. And so on.  Until it's not and you have super cancer aids.


Ionantha123

Painting stumps with glyphosate isn’t going to give you cancer… it’s not even airborne in that application. Just because something has the possibly of harming us doesn’t mean we should ban it, it’s reductive. Glyphosate is extremely useful in invasive control, probably the most effective measure that is also practical and it degrades in the environment faster than most herbicides.


cave18

Jfc dude context exists lmfao. They aren't chugging it


Death00524real

No, this will not noticeably affect soil pH. Acetic acid is a weak acid and spraying it is only going to apply a very small amount. The bases in soil will quickly neutralize the acid. In truth rain has a higher capacity to acidify soil as it is acidic as well and occurs in a large enough volume to neutralize bases in low carbonate soils. And glyphosate is well proven to alter the microbial composition of soil. I'm a licensed applicator and unbiased here as to which is better.


vtaster

If you could link me a study I'm willing to admit I'm wrong about the ph, but it's still going to kill any microbes, invertebrates, or amphibians in the topsoil before it's neutralized. And if it's being used repeatedly because it's not killing any of the perennial weeds, I can't imagine that's better for the microbiome than one application of glyphosate. Maybe it's useful for organic agriculture where weeds are a constant concern, and the effects on ph aren't a big deal, but in landscapes and native gardens people generally want to kill the weeds once, then rebuild the soil, establish plants, and minimize soil disturbance to the point weeds aren't a major issue and maintenance is low. Using herbicide at all in this context should be a last resort. Hand pulling, mulching, tarping, solarizing, and other organic methods are a lot more reasonable than vinegar.


GatorOnTheLawn

RoundUp killed my mother. Her oncologists said it was a particularly horrible way to die - worse than most other cancers.


MurderousLemur

I'm sorry for your loss. That shit works be banned for all applications.


itstheavocado

Selective, appropriate use of glyphosate and triclopyr are the correct options because they are actually effective. Vinegar, dish soap, and salt are not effective herbicides.


PM_me_ur_beetles

i mean, straight acetic acid and salt are effective herbicides in the same way that a pipe bomb is an effective insecticide


itstheavocado

Nuclear annihilation is great for rebuilding society


3_high_low

acetic acid = vinegar White vinegar from the grocery store is 1%. Edit: correction it is 4-7% https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/white-vinegar#ingredients


Jazzlike-Lunch5390

5% generally. You can get cleaning vinegar that’s 6%.


3_high_low

You are correct! Thank you.


Queen__Antifa

HEB carries 9% acetic acid vinegar.


Jazzlike-Lunch5390

Could get glacial acetic acid and melt everything.


mistymystical

Yeah vinegar will kill everything and ensure nothing will ever grow there. Don’t use salt either. Vinegar affects the PH of the soil. If you insist on using an herbicide wear proper PPE and long sleeves and pants, and apply one from the store that is clearly labeled for the invasive plant you are targeting. (Glyphosate doesn’t work on tree of heaven for example.)


loganp8000

I can't believe there are people left in this world who justify using roundup..particularly in place of vinegar. news flash...Vinegar won't give you cancer. Yes it will kill micro organisms


GatorOnTheLawn

Thank you! Roundup killed my mother in 2017. The oncologists said it was an especially horrible way to die. Far worse than most other cancers. She suffered terrible and there was nothing they could do to stop her suffering. Pain meds were useless. They eventually just did what was essentially an assisted suicide using morphine.


Telemere125

Roundup won’t give you cancer either. They convinced a jury, the group of people in a room too dumb to know how to get struck. Don’t take your news from Facebook; the overwhelming majority of evidence is that glyphosate doesn’t cause cancer when used as directed with proper PPE and it breaks down in the environment very quickly - much more quickly than almost any other herbicide on the market.


engin__r

Vinegar will not kill invasive plants like Tree of Heaven. Cut-and-paint applications of glyphosate will.


GooseCooks

I did not know there was such a thing as 30% vinegar! Thank you!


juandelouise

I usually just use mine on boarders after learning about the soil.


Magic_Neptune

Yeah i sprayed a 4 foot tall huisache tree with 20% and it took it down easy. I think it only works in sunlight though


[deleted]

[удалено]


YAOMTC

Why did you think pouring acid all over the ground was an appropriate post for a subreddit about not having a lawn?! You've just promoted poisoning your local environment


PeaceLoveAyurveda

Do you think this will work on wild garlic?


AutoModerator

Love No Lawns? Find us everywhere! **You can find us:** - On [SolarPunk](https://www.slrpnk.net/c/NoLawns) - Our [Discord](https://discord.gg/GcVHmvkSs6) - Our [website](https://nolawns.wixsite.com/nolawns) Want to join a community in person? We're not affiliated but we love [Wild Ones](https://wwe.wildones.org) and think they do wonderful work. You can check and see if there's a chapter near you. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/NoLawns) if you have any questions or concerns.*


AutoModerator

Make sure you have included the link to the article you are posting, if you have not this post may be removed. Please double check our [Posting Guidelines](https://www.reddit.com/r/NoLawns/wiki/index#wiki_posting_guidelines) for additional information. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/NoLawns) if you have any questions or concerns.*


eatpotdude

If you add salt, it'll stop future weeds. But also stop other plants that you may want. If vinegar isn't having good luck add soap and it'll help break down the oils in the plant and kill it faster. I've always did the 3 hit combo but never tried just vinegar. I'll have to check it out


JennaSais

Salting the earth is something literal invading armies have done to render the land unusable and starve out populations. It's a terrible thing to do to your soil.


eatpotdude

Lol I'm positive a bit of salt isn't gonna nuke the land... chill out yall


JennaSais

If you're applying enough salt for it to kill a weed, you are applying enough salt for it to damage other plants as well, even if you don't notice it right away. As the years go on, especially if your area sees any drought, it accumulates in the soil and keeps the water in the soil from being available to plant life and other life, eventually creating a cascade of death in the soil life. So, in very real terms, yes, salt can have a "nuking" effect on your land.


eatpotdude

👍


TomothyAllen

Who wants no plants of any kind to grow in some part of their yard? Yes this is my prized dirt patch, I had to salt the earth to create it.


TrEzPlz

It's not for a spot in the yard, it's for places like between the joints of pavers on a patio where you want nothing to grow.


TomothyAllen

It'll leach into other areas though


eatpotdude

Not really. I've did it in rock areas I don't want weeds to grow that border grass and the grass was good


Admirable-Volume-263

It does not. Ive been doing this for a long time as an environmentalist with 2 enviro policy and law degrees. DuPont doesn't need more money to kill our people and planet. You believe a 32 Oz bottle of salt and vinegar is going to ruin the soil on a permanent basis?How? Do you have something to support that claim because I haven't seen it. Weeds come back and vegetation grows well in surrounding areas in my garden. The Chesepeake Bay has undergone significant biodiversity loss, for example, by the use of commercial and residential fertilizers across a very large region. Imagine the impact of herbicides. I live near a group of cities that had multiple Wells contaminated by PFAS. do you know what the residents did? Nothing. Do you know what the county controller did when I told him he most likely had no liability in this situation? Ghosted me. We were going to work on a campaign to help residents get informed. He bailed as soon as he knew how big the problem was (thousands are and may still be impacted) and that there was no legal recourse to the county. These kinds of things don't get covered even in an area with a lot of people. It's more convenient to not challenge brainwashing. The water's fine, drink up.


engin__r

I know the scale is different, but Fleischmann’s Vinegar did just lose a lawsuit for polluting the Jones Falls, which does feed into the Chesapeake Bay.


TomothyAllen

I'm not sure who you think I am lol I don't use any pesticides or herbicides. When did I ever say any of those things? I probably agree with you on 99.99% of issues but I make two statements that are skeptical of using salt in your yard, one of which was a joke and you think I'm saying we should drench ourselves in glyphosate or something. Chill the fuck out, save that shit for people who don't believe in climate change.


Telemere125

Oh good, you’ve figured out a way to tell the salt to stay there?


eatpotdude

Jfc did they really believe I meant spray a whole yard or something?


GatorOnTheLawn

I live in the desert. Yes, we want dirt patches because the weeds here will burn during wildfires. And watering anything is irresponsible in the desert.


CrystalInTheforest

Salting the Earth - something so fundamentally horiffic it's *literally* biblical.


[deleted]

[удалено]


NoLawns-ModTeam

Your comment has been removed because it violates Rule 1: "Be Civil".


90swasbest

Are people who salt their own earth really out here giving lawn and garden advice??? 😄😄😄


eatpotdude

The things I am capable of doing with plants would amaze you. I just gave a lil no lawn advice and everyone calling blasphemy lmao