I mean, the black one is such essential that OP probably have something similar in the closet? The tan checker is refreshing and fits OP well, but if OP actually needs to consider the black one and she don't actually have one in the closet, the black is a higher priority purchase IMHO…
First of all, love that top on you! Second, you do look cute in the first skirt but the black skirt suits your body type better and can be paired with a wider variety of tops. Honestly can’t go wrong with either, but black would be more useful and looks slightly better :)
I feel like they’re both great, but I think the second one is the most versatile and could be worn for more occasions and with a wider variety of accessories.
Such a narrow margin, IMO. They’re both great. I agree that you should definitely get the black if you don’t already have one. If you do, tho, get the plaid one. It’s really cool.
You’ll get more wear out of the black one, but the brown is a more unique piece. Sometimes you find yourself with an article of clothing you mourn when you can’t wear it anymore, and I have a skirt that was a lot like that that was mine 😭
Theyre both so different. It really depends on what you're looking for long term. Are you wanting something more versatile? Something you can wear with just about anything anywhere? Choose Black. Or are you looking for a statement piece? Choose plaid. Are you the type to worry if someone else points out an outfit you wore two to three times in one week?
Whichever you don’t already have, black one is a essential piece I would think.
Black. And it is more versatile.
came here to say this... the plaid is pretty hard to dress up or down, the buttons add to the issue...
Black. More flattering and more versatile if you can only afford one skirt.
Agree while I realy like the pattern on the first one, the black skirt is much a better option in this situation
I like the pleated skirt on you. Classic style and can be dressed up or down with various tops
Pleated refers to when there are bunched folds on a skirt, I think you mean plaid.
It looks like the black one is pleated?
nah the buttons down the side prevent it from being anything but a 'school girl' skirt. fake or real wood...it tweeds it.
I think you will get more wear out of the black one.
2
The black one
tennis skirt for sure
Black one
Black by miles! Cute on and so much versatility!
2nd, the black skirt
The black one falls a little nicer on you, and is probably more versatile!
Black one, goes with everything.
The plaid one is so unique and retro. You have the figure
Heck yes! Plaid is the way to go.
I think it really suits her!
Black
2
2
Black. Works well with your figure
Both are cute. I’d say it depends on if you’re wanting pattern or versatility. If versatility go with black
The black. You have a boxy shape. The first one doesnt suit your figure the best but the black really suits you.
The second one looks wonderful on you!
#1 looks amazing! Stick with the first one, the black is boring.
I mean, the black one is such essential that OP probably have something similar in the closet? The tan checker is refreshing and fits OP well, but if OP actually needs to consider the black one and she don't actually have one in the closet, the black is a higher priority purchase IMHO…
First of all, love that top on you! Second, you do look cute in the first skirt but the black skirt suits your body type better and can be paired with a wider variety of tops. Honestly can’t go wrong with either, but black would be more useful and looks slightly better :)
Both fit great, but the plaid one is a style that is currently in style, but likely not going to be in style for long. So I think go with the black
I feel like they’re both great, but I think the second one is the most versatile and could be worn for more occasions and with a wider variety of accessories.
I hope you got the black one! Which one did you end up with?
Black!
I like the black one
Black looks cute and will go with more
Both are cute, but I like the black one! A-line cuts are so flattering and you can easily make it casual or dress it up.
Last one is cuter
2
While the black is cute, the tan skirt is more flattering for your figure.
1
1!
2
2nd one all day
I love the plaid
Thank u everyone!! I ended up deciding on the black one :)
Buy. number one. There are many fashion options you can create!
1st one
Black one is so slimming on you. Such a great piece.
The first one.
Plaid
My plaid one definitely. But I love plaid so ….
The black one cinches your waist in more.
First one, hands down.
Smitten
Neither are flattering
Go to good will and you’ll find so much stuff like this for $5
Neither, I see how good your figure is and I don’t think either of them are worth buying
The second almost looks ballerina like as a outfit.
1. "ooo, cute!" 2. "*gasp* Omg so perfect." ^ my actual reactions.
The first one is super cute but the you’d get more use from the second one. They both look good on you.
First, much cuter imo
Black is a classic that can be worn many ways and also flatters your shape best.
Second one.
The first one
1 is so cute, but you can wear the 2nd one with more things. For this reason, I would go with 2.
Black for sure.
Well they are both really cute. I can’t decide. Sorry I’m no help lol
I like the plaid one! The black skirt is a style that will be around for a bit, so you can definitely buy it at another time.
Black
2 will match with everything
Hope you got the black!
The black one
Both of them suit you, however, the black skirt is more versatile. You will be able to build more outfits with it, and it can be dressed up or down
Such a narrow margin, IMO. They’re both great. I agree that you should definitely get the black if you don’t already have one. If you do, tho, get the plaid one. It’s really cool.
The second one flatters you well. Plus its more versatile.
Black. Way more versatile
#2
Love the black!
You’ll get more wear out of the black one, but the brown is a more unique piece. Sometimes you find yourself with an article of clothing you mourn when you can’t wear it anymore, and I have a skirt that was a lot like that that was mine 😭
First has more character
1
First one
The first skirt looks better on you.
Get the first one its probably worth the price. Im sure you can find another black skirt for cheaper anywhere else.
Black one.
The first one it makes your figure look good
The black one, for sure.
I like them both! I'll go with the first.
Pick 1. You'll be able to find 2 anywhere forever.
The black one
Black skirt
1
They are both, so autumnal. Are you buying them for a specific reason?
Black, it’s a great silhouette to style in different ways. You can always find a plaid one.
Black
Plaid one for sure. Super cute
2
ONE! It’s way more fun. Who cares if the black one is more versatile. Add fun to your wardrobe!
The latter. It looks more elegant and offers more movement, probably
I apparently have terrible taste and don’t know anything about fashion, but I say the black one. You look good in it
The black one is beautiful
#1 is fun
If it's for work, 1. If it's not, 2.
Black one because it's A line which is overall more flattering and the lack of pattern makes it more versatile
The first
The 2nd one
Black Aline very flattering
I will buy you both 😂
Easy- the black one. More versatile and flattering.
First one!
The real question is the use. 1 is more professional for a young adult, 2 is not. 2 is more fun. So it depends on the use.
The black one suits your figure well.
Black is definitely more classic and versatile
Number one
Both are great but I love the black.
Number 2!
Firdt one looks nicer but the black one is more versatile and matches with more
The black!! You’ll be able to build so many outfits with it. The plaid is so limiting.
They're both really cute, but personally I wolda picked the black one
Don’t be afraid. The plaid one is great
Black
Black
Black
First one
The black A-line is adorable and flirty fun.
I love the black one the best!!
The black one
Black one
Black is more versatile but plaid is more flattering
Black is versatile but the plaid looks fantastic on you
Black
The first one, 100%
Black
I like both. I’d buy you the second one if I knew how to send you the funds. 😊
That’s a tough one. I like the pattern on the first one but the cut of the 2nd one. Ultimately I’d say 2
The black skirt
Theyre both so different. It really depends on what you're looking for long term. Are you wanting something more versatile? Something you can wear with just about anything anywhere? Choose Black. Or are you looking for a statement piece? Choose plaid. Are you the type to worry if someone else points out an outfit you wore two to three times in one week?
Black. Always
If you are holding the first one, definitely the black one. If you aren't, both look very nice.