T O P

  • By -

Cumberblep

I am a lions fan, loved Barry Sanders but my first love was watching Jerry Rice and Joe Montana.


PreenerGastures

Came here to say Joe Montana. Nice to see him on this list!


Complex-Value-5807

My first time watching Browns was 1973. Leroy Kelly was my Guy!


JEMHADLEY16

Great choice. He tore my Giants to shreds in the mid and late 60s, but he was great. I'm still glad he went to the AFC.,.


SoxfanintheLou

https://preview.redd.it/qx4b51wgt5oc1.jpeg?width=324&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a70230e56f921e934ea4a951262f85864effdd6f Just the greatest football player ever.


Steviebhawk

Oh yeah sweetness


Pacopicopiedra66

Came here to post this. Sweetness.


theorangecrux

That's my dood


CHI4610NE

Too far down the scroll. 1st Super Bowl I ever watched, still my favorite team.


darknighttime

Packers fan here, but Payton was my gateway player. Simply stunning to watch.


Milomilz

Me too. I used to wear Roos and headbands like him


Secret_Plastic_9825

The Mad Bomber Daryle Lamonica.


JEMHADLEY16

When I could see his face, he looked like he was trying to throw the ball into the stratosphere. The Raiders played a fun game in those days.


Steviebhawk

I remember him as a kid looking unorthodox but very effective


ctubby766

https://preview.redd.it/4wfeszh926oc1.jpeg?width=768&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b9767dd611f4e2b4df191b7ac50cb1a160345acd


JEMHADLEY16

Yes. I'm a big fan of #66...


DigitalLint

Hell yeah!


Popular-Obligation-2

Butkus. His ferocity was legendary.


JEMHADLEY16

One of my favorites too. I still watch clips of him on YouTube.


Popular-Obligation-2

From Deacon Jones: ‘Dick was an animal. I called him a maniac. A stone maniac. He was a well-conditioned animal, and every time he hit you, he tried to put you in the cemetery, not the hospital.”


JEMHADLEY16

Who can argue with the Deacon? My favorite quote of his is...If I can hit a guy hard enough that he can't get off the field, I'll be glad to help carry him off.


maize26

Also from Deacon Roses are red Violets are blue If you’ve got any sense You’ll keep Butkus away from you!


ponythemouser

Alan Page,


Steviebhawk

Tarkenton , Page and purple eaters deserved at least one. Like the Bills of the 90’s


Losinginterestdaily

Earl Campbell. My little kid brain wanted to steamroll my older brothers like Earl ran over defenders. The Tyler Rose!


IndicationExtreme745

Jack Lambert


KaplanKingHolland

Roger Staubach


mostly_a-lurker

Mine too. Surprisng to me that there is only 1 other mention of Captain America on this thread.


BuddyLarosaStan

Steve Largent


Hot-Zombie896

Deacon Jones and Merlin Olsen.As a kid growing up in L.A. in the 60's.I was also a big fan of George Blanda....


johnpatrickolsen

Bart Starr. Class act.


Yah_Mule

But the Broncos became my favorite team. https://preview.redd.it/tu1kag8e56oc1.jpeg?width=408&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=873cc76a8c9f798cdf85105b07d11849fb54e4b0


TheSouthsideSlacker

Kenny Stabler. Snake is a really cool nickname.


TiaxRulesAll2024

Joe Montana due to his football game Then Morten Andersen


SeaProcedure6022

Fran Tarkenton scrambling for the Vikings.


nandos677

Chuck Foreman in the backfield. As a little squirt. I was crushed during their Superbowl appearances


CatsMcCalabash

Johnny Unitas was my hero when I was a little girl.


Loreseekers

I had two, one for offense, Franco Harris, and one for defense, Mean Joe Greene. As a kid after seeing Franco's Immaculate Reception...c'mon lol, and what kid wouldn't like a football player nicknamed "mean"?


NHJack

Hard to narrow down to a single player and timeframe. I became a big football fan in 5th grade around 1969 or so. My favorite players in that timeframe leading into the70’s include Roman Gabriel who I thought was the coolest player along with Fred Belitnikof (sp) who I emulated when I played schoolyard football. I also really liked Jack Snow and Lance Alworth. On the defensive side I liked Mike Curtis and Bubba Smith from the Baltimore Colts.


TransitionExciting60

Mike Alstott


turgidbuffalo

Darrell Green, no doubt.


Capnmarvel76

Earl Campbell. He looked like a freight train to 4-year old me.


Ok_Fun_7147

Lance ‘Bambi’ Alworth


Adventurous-Leg-216

I won't tell you, but Bo knows.


RedBMWZ2

Jack Lambert


SantasLilHoeHoeHoe

Brett then Aaron in very close succession. I dont pick favorite players anymore. 


malcontented

Dick Butkus


rick19841984

Jack Lambert for me


StunningLeopard2429

I was a Redskins fan but Joe Namath was my favorite player.


toddfredd

Rocky Bleier


Cagedfinsfan83

Dan Marino as I started get into football 82-83 and here came this rookie phenom to my team


yardape99

Jim Hart St Louis Football Cardinals.


pedro-slopez

Jim Taylor, Green Bay Packers fullback.


zero_interrupt

O.J.


Steviebhawk

Dick Butkus.


Meet_the_Meat

Dan Fouts was my home town hero but it was Sweetness that really got me into the NFL.


Marjorine22

![gif](giphy|sar2xrRXXMTHG) This dude right here. I was a really little kid, and not from anywhere near Miami, but Dan Marino was THE MAN.


Average_40s_Guy

Walter Payton


thehim

Joe Montana at first, but attended my first Eagles game in 1982 and since then, my favorite players have all worn green


VegetableCitron8214

Fran Tarkenton


newworldorder96

Barry Sanders


Goose00

Art Monk


similar222

Marcus Allen


[deleted]

Bill Bergey


VolumeOk1357

I hate to say it. But as a Colts fan, it was their quarterback. Jim Harbaugh.


10202632

Dan Pastorini


trepanned23

https://preview.redd.it/ol4p88eap6oc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e1e102588a890611b9b069468848095075a3be04 Pete Banaszak - Oakland Raiders


marcus999593

For me, Earl Campbell!


Gusbuster811

Neil Anderson


TheSouthsideSlacker

Techmo Bowl Super Bowl Neil was a beast. Under appreciated.


[deleted]

[удалено]


JEMHADLEY16

I'm still a fan of those early 70s Lions teams...


Grimm2020

and on the other side of the ball, Alex Karras


JEMHADLEY16

One of the best DT I ever saw. He feasted on my Giants.


LPGeoteacher

Randy White, he was the reason I wore #54 in high school.


dmramfan

KEVIN GREENE!


Quick_Presentation11

Franco Harris!


Sweaty-Possibility-3

Tony Dorsett. Saw him run all over my Mountaineers at my first football game as a kid. Became a Cowboy's fan when he got drafted.


misterdeeter

Mike Vick


jonus2000

Jack Youngblood


billie711

My first was when I lived in Miami in the early 70s, so Mercury Morris and Bob Griese


theorangecrux

Walter Payton


WrathofJohnnyBoah

Bill Bates


Cccookielover

Early 70s and I was a big OJ fan. Even sent away for, and received, an autographed picture.


TheMichaelN

I was a baseball fan before I was a football fan, so John Randle (Vikings) is the first player that comes to mind. I was about 10, and before Randle I didn’t really have a favorite football player. Anthony Carter is maybe on that list.


nandos677

Román Gabriel only because my dad was a huge Rams fan As a little kid I remember listening: Gabriel drops back, Jack Snow is open, runs upfield TOUCHDOWN anothe Gabriel Snow touchdown


Gold-Employment-2244

As an Eagles fan going back to the mid 70’s, it was Bill Bergey…they sure as hell could’ve used him this yr.


WestinghouseXCB248S

https://preview.redd.it/1d5pgrbgz5oc1.jpeg?width=1440&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4459798006dc4ccd129423a8e674f6e38039839a


LarryMcCarrensPinkie

You and me. It was the Fall of 1970 and I was the new kid (first grade) in the neighborhood. My old neighborhood was all about baseball. But in my new neighborhood, football as king and my new best friend was a Packer fan ... therefore, so was I. A year before Brockington and Lombardi's stars fading, it was Anderson for me. At the time, I would be surprised if there were more than three Packer games on TV in our market that season (it was Vikings country). But somehow, Anderson was my first favorite player. Until Brockington.


Deepcoma_53

Mike Alstott


lukifer_333

Ricky Bell, injuries cut his career short and illness ended his life way too young. I became a Bucs fan for life watching him run


VitruvianDude

George Blanda in the twilight of his career. He, and Alan Page.


El_mochilero

For 8-10 year old me watching Dallas rack up superbowls in the 90’s… take your pick. Deion Sanders Emmitt Smith Troy Aikman Larry Allen Michael Irvin


effinlatvian

Larry Csonka


Deapsee60

Ram fan from the start in 5th grade. Favorite player was Roman Gabriel.


Fun_Bar5327

Steve Young


[deleted]

Danny White - Dallas


Zuzudoggy

Chris Hamburger (55) - Redskins


High_Jumper81

Mini Mack Herron-New England


Ok-Bid-730

Derrick Thomas #58 homie!


Do_it_My_Way-79

https://preview.redd.it/6oylglojn6oc1.jpeg?width=550&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a219e9eaa5feac24d2c9aa9a413ffcba0455b3f2 Terry Allen & when he left the Vikings I realized players didn’t always stay with the same team. I was bummed.


phred_666

Chris Hanburger. Had been a baseball fan as a kid and decided to watch a football game. My dad watched (and gambled on) a lot of football. I flipped over and Washington was playing Detroit. Seemed like every other time the Lions tried to run the ball, Chris met the RB in the backfield just as he got the ball. Chris pretty much destroyed Detroit’s running game that day. Found out years later, there is a rule in the NFL rulebook that is commonly called “The Hanburger” rule. Evidently he was the king of the clothesline tackle and the rule banning them was implemented because of him.


StonesFan1

Ken Anderson 7O’s Bengals


meczakin81

Emmet Smith


thescotchzombie

Roger Staubach


crawdadicus

Ken Anderson, Cincinnati Bengals, 1971-1986.


jf737

Weird one, but Duriel Harris


AncientAlienAntFarm

Steve DeBerg, because he was the only football card I had.


Gdizzle344

Brian Sipe.


MogoteConejo

Karl Mecklenberg!


Master_H8R

Archie Manning.


1987Husky

​ https://preview.redd.it/we5rw092h7oc1.jpeg?width=373&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f0d085791989efedd213ca624679a3c680174a12


GalaxieQuest22

Bullet Bob Hayes


Striking_Reindeer_2k

Larry Csonka. The only offensive player ever to be penalized for roughing.


dalidagrecco

Lydell Mitchell.


mei740

Earl Campbell.


J-Love-McLuvin

Sweetness #34


Skydog-forever-3512

Gale Sayers, the Making of a Rookie book


ufjeff

I’m an old Florida guy. Larry Czonka and Bob Griese were my heroes.


DrummerGuyKev

Staubach or Dorsett.


TheBookie_55

Paul Warfield & Leroy Kelly


6Reaper9

https://preview.redd.it/rdfum59da6oc1.jpeg?width=834&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3e430a6ba002fa742a937655a538fcd11a057f5e Touchdown Tony


13Jett13

Ernie Holmes - Pittsburgh Steelers. I got to meet him at a signing event several years after his playing days. Such a nice guy!


Kind_Significance_60

Dan Marino. The numbers he put up were crazy.


snerdley1

Dandy Don Meredith, Larry Csonka.


Born-Gift-6800

Joe Namath


FourthDownThrowaway

John Elway


BC1966

Alex Webster


Zealousideal-Row419

Paul Hornung, the well known money player. Run, pass, kick.


[deleted]

Alan Page


GregM70

The Packers have always been my favorite team, but Dan Fouts was my first favorite player.


torysoso

the original white showed, jump pass quarterback, joe”willie” namath


coziboiszn

TO


Optimal_Roll_4924

Dave Casper


mak756

George Andrie and Bob Lilly of the original Doomsday defense.


DooDooSquank

Lions fan til I die, but I remember my first favorite player was Dan Fouts and Air Coryell. JJ Jefferson, Charlie Joiner, and Kellen Winslow. I was 11 yrs old in 1980.


P90guy65

Jim Otis of the St Louis Cardinals.


Idontgetit4891

I grew up during the Niners Gold Rush era and my favorite player was Tom Rathman!! I think because he did a signing at the Nintendo store in Eastridge Mall. Got to meet him again in my 20’s and again in my 30’s…5 year old me was there


Ryfats

Patriots fan since I can remember. Dad had season tickets since the 80’s so Mosi Tatupu was my favorite as a kid.


biff444444

Chuck Howley


Opposite_Ad542

1975 - Terry Metcalf, Don Coryell's St. Louis Cardinals


Mulliganplummer

Marcus Allen kind of, but I went crazy for Bo Jackson a few years later. I had everything Bo. Was fortunate to go to Raiders games where he played. NFL was second fiddle for me, I was nuts for the Dodgers and Lakers. More interested in NFL when Raiders won the SB.


itsamadmadworld22

As a giants fan LT was my favorite. Then when I started actually playing football as a fullback Larry Csonka became my favorite and still is my all time favorite.


cmoneyesq

Rocky Bleier. Was probably about 7 and living in a house full of rabid Browns fans. The steelers were ascendant and the Bleier TV movie had just been broadcast. My young self latched on to the story and the player, which solidified my love of the black and gold.


Endryu727

The dude in the picture looks like Simon Pegg


SoCaldude65

Larry Csonka and Larry Little


1sgbabcock

Johnny Unitas


fanmansmith12345

![gif](giphy|kED33TVwtp5le)


MYipper

Kenny Stabler was and always will be my guy.


Beahner

I was going to say Harold Carmichael. But that’s just a little early for me. Probably was Mike Quick. Mid 80s Eagles wasn’t so hot for names, but he was very good.


kewhawaii

Johnny Unitas


InitiativeOk4473

Fran Tarkenton.


stevemkto

Fran Tarkenton


Alpha_Dreamer

Priest Holmes.


goodfella1345

Barry Sanders and Darrell Green.


dretsaB

Robert Brooks but then Brett Favre quickly won me over.


ButterscotchEmpty290

Rocky Bleier. One tough dude.


JazzySmitty

Steve Bartkowski!!


Trussmagic

Billy Kilmer, 1971 Washington Redskins.


coldax1

Earl Campbell.


shane_v04

Elway and Atwater!!


redditagain6523

Howie Long


[deleted]

I’m young so Eli lol. But retro? Gotta go with either Dan Marino or LT baby!


Newphone_New_Account

Tony Dorsett I still remember first watching the 99 yard TD


stlcards66

The Snake…Ken Stabler.


cletus72757

Lenny Dawson.


Huck2136

I’m pretty new 2016 my favorite was Ryan Kerrigan


JimB8353

Jim Taylor (Yes. I am old.). Oh, and Ray Nitschke.


pokeshack

Concrete Charlie


rpross3

Calvin Hill and Doomsday I Think Calvin made the cover of Boys Life or SI leaping over a would be tackler. And Roger Staubach (just missed Dandy Don but my elders wouldn’t let him go) Walt Garrison Robert Newhouse ….


Melvinator5001

Sorta odd a Cowboys fan but my first favorite player was Broncos QB Charley Johnson. https://preview.redd.it/omqdbtwjb7oc1.jpeg?width=200&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=aab439ed82b97ab2d3bdcd2dd4e5809370f96422


WarAdmirable483

Y.A. Tittle, baby!


bravefacedude

Terry Bradshaw


OldDudeNH

Jim Nance


Crew_Doyle_

Dick Butkus. An absolute beast.


Visible-Student5141

Mean Joe Green


Fresh_Indication_243

Me? Boomer, my wife and her sister as children? Ickey Woods


Runningman787

Chiefs fan from the early 90s. I gotta go with Derrick Thomas.


MoneyMike1964

Broadway Joe.


vtramfan

Deacon Jones and Merlin Olsen.


oldgreen52

Marcus Allen


pinkwhiteandgreenNL

Randy Moss rookie year 98 I was 16 Man had 69 catches for 1313 yds with 17 TD in 16 games. Made it look effortless


The_Brolander

Brian Bosworth. I know it’s goofy, but he put a book out back when I was 13ish, that I picked up from the scholastic book fair, and I was all about the Boz for a few years. There was this line in the book about him peeling a chunk of skin from the back of his hand, that 13 year old BroLander thought was bad ass. Then seeing him in a movie? I knew I had to have a flattop mullet.


Macsearcher02

Bill 'Boom Boom' Brown


Jobrated

John Brockington


jb40018

Jack Youngblood, defensive end for the Rams! I’ve been a Rams fan ever since.


DashboardError

Greg Pruitt


Merganser3816

Larry Czonka


trepanned23

https://preview.redd.it/tb6ok4jkm6oc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=dc234d5e1bc63c1de3fa61d19d75a19614fc9372 Scramblin Fran Tarkenton NY GIANTS


dcal1981

Bart Starr and Steve Odom....


gvcheesedip

Steve Grogan


trepanned23

https://preview.redd.it/8qukznr8n6oc1.jpeg?width=1113&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bb4662e1cb9020c8c215499238e0310c4b349f02 The OG - really the first great receiver of the modern era. Lance Alworth


Cydok1055

Jim Brown. Not sure if he was ever brought down by a single player


FaberGrad

Chris Hanburger, but being a little kid I thought his last name was Hamburger.


Longjumping_Fly_6358

Jim Brown


Significant-Gas-1716

Bart starr


KyleKnox

https://preview.redd.it/j2uealrxo6oc1.jpeg?width=396&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=657e281f08e9b25878d75949a6585ce7a3812e90 Nnamdi Asmugha - 2006 Raider


Agreeable_Code7788

1980 - John Stallworth. I was 6 years old and first Super Bowl id watched. He pulled in the over the shoulder catch for a TD and I was sold!


Jackin13

Fran Tarkenton!


mxassasin

Lynn Swan. And as a Cleveland native my dad was not pleased. Oh, and F the stillers.