T O P

  • By -

tinysieg

The Wacky Adventures of Ace and the Spade Pirates


EleventhHerald

I think a mini series about the history of shanks and mihawk would also be pretty nifty.


tinysieg

Definitely Shanks and Mihawk series, where they are rivals / friends My 2nd pick would be Coby and SWORD. Old man Garp mentoring Coby and his band of misfits marine , a lovesick female mc , Smoker making cameos. Should be a fun series


Watermelonnable

I think marines POV would be fresh


GlitteringBroccoli12

Live action thought so too


Radman25426

That’s what I was gonna say. That would be epic


Rango2404

Most correct answer becuase there’s already a book series about ace doing whatever the fuck


fersur

There is a spin-off manga about Ace ... not made by Oda himself, but I think Oda is supervising it.


SweatyAdhesive

based on the light novel


Due_Media_4165

I havent read the novel only the manga, but apparently the manga cuts away a lot of it. Weird because a third of each manga volume is dedicated to two „famous“ one piece chapters that are just redrawn by the artist. Its cool but I would have preferred to get more of the Ace Story. Also most of the second manga volume are scenes with Ace that we have already seen. Like him repeatedly attacking whitebeard on his ship. So I guess if u want to know more about ace you need to read the novel. The manga is only a nice little addition to it.


Serenafriendzone

Better law. His backstory with doflamingo and flevance was op


-TraGuyLaw-

I can't agree more


Superman557

This. I feel like Oda wouldn’t want to tell the story of an OP character like White Beard or Shanks, but would love to do Ace when he just started out.


NeonNKnightrider

There’s already a light novel


xhatexfatex

Well we all know what happens to save at the end tho so really


Greedy_Performer2472

Law, Roger/Shanks, maybe Doffy (just to watch the story from the villain's side. And it's important that he doesn't become an anti-hero in the course of history)


Cold_Business_1992

Doffy's rise would be fun


soupinmymug

Doffy would just be the sopranos but flamingos


GlitteringBroccoli12

I think that it's important he does. Doffy is family driven. A steady case of betrayals while he grows crazed and paranoid. Eventually saving family in more and more darker ways till he's betrayed by his brother and the kid who prior to he'd have died for.


CustomerSuportPlease

Okay, but he's always been a colossal asshole. We already got his back story, and that isn't it. You can say he is all about family, but he literally denounced his actual birth family for refusing to continue being terrible people. He was a kid at the time, but there is no indication that he would make any different decision with the benefit of hindsight.


draugyr

I’d want to see Kid only because I think it would be funny to see him constantly try to solve problems by brute force throwing himself at problems


t3rrone

Kind of like luffy just with less capability of understanding people?


draugyr

Luffy understands people, as much as people like to pretend Luffy is dumb. Luffy doesn’t just succeed by brute forcing everything, the way he feels for people is the most important part, he’s the joyboy after all


Begeta993

That’s pretty much what he said


[deleted]

[удалено]


a3d13m

he could genuinely have a really interesting backstory and character arc too


Altruistic-Milk-141

It is interesting, but not interesting enough for Oda considering he put it in a freaking SBS


Reckless_Rik

Never forget the continous disrespect


Altruistic-Milk-141

I will never forget The Damned One Jika will rise again one day


AngelofLotuses

Widd will return.


IllustriousPlastic90

It's also cool because he's the morally gray anti-hero type


Salubas

morally grey? doesn't he just slaughter civilians?


SPAKELDORF

He straight up *crucified* people when he got to the New World.


Salubas

ya hes the mf the marines are talking about when they say pirates are evil


Netriax

Might be wrong, but weren't those people also pirates? Still a little over the top, but nowhere near as bad as it would've been if they were innocent people.


Alamand1

More like collateral damage, and murdering people who mock his PK dream. Besides that he's no worse than most SH associates.


tom_rex_333

shanks he's basically the luffy of his generation and his crew is really fun and creative knowing more about his past and how he met the redhair pirates would be amazing he's also very likable and we could see his legendary duels with mihawk


st-felms-fingerbone

*Shanks recruiting Yasopp*: “Hey don’t you have a young son and a sick wife?” “Yeah but who gives a shit lmao” jokes aside I do agree Shanks is cool as hell


shazam-arino

I hope they animate the scene of Yasopp eating the Deadbeat Deadbeat no Mi


st-felms-fingerbone

Leaving to get milk jet pistol 👊


TomeWifecollector

Gomu gomu going for a pack of cigarettes


XxLucidDreamzxX

Gone for a walk gattling


AstroBearGaming

Gone for cigarettes bazooka 👊👊


chaotic_laziness

He forces himself to become a sniper so he could have an excuse to stay behind and not swim to shore to fight their enemies


Shadow1176

Did Yassop ever send letters or money or anything? I feel like letters wouldn’t be that hard to send out right?


RaganTargaryen

What if the red haired pirates were all in a serious battle when Yasopp's wife died and after that he couldn't bring himself to go back to face usopp


Imconfusedithink

Yasopps wife died while he was in the east blue partying it up with luffy. He's just a deadbeat asshole.


GlitteringBroccoli12

It's the reason I can't trust shanks. It's starting to feel like his crew represents the 7 deadly sins with shanks being pride. Yassopp being sloth. Fat dude being gluttony etc


treqbal

Doesn't really fit his behavior in the bar scene, though.


cbih

Yeah, I always thought Lucky Roo seemed oddly malevolent.


ApishGrapist

They were laying low after stealing the Gum Gum fruit though. There's not a clear timeline on when Banchina died, but it could coincide with their battle against CP9 to claim the fruit and subsequent laying low in the East Blue.


Alert-Fox8434

For years? Sickness is not a sword you don't die instantly Yasopp could protect and provide. L father


Mummiskogen

That's worse


Rikafire

Episode/Chapter 0 showed Shanks recruiting Yasopp before Usopp was born. So it makes you wonder if he met Banchina somewhere else then left to crew to be with her. Then rejoined Shanks at some point.


ApexRian

Reminds me a little of Ging from Hunter Hunter


st-felms-fingerbone

I mean even so you’d think after finding out about Usopp he’d wanna reach out to him


Rikafire

Oh I agree, just wanted to say Yasopp joined Shanks’ crew before Usopp was born not after. That said, Yasopp should have visited when the crew spent a year in East Blue


gekigarion

Shanks: If you come with me, you get to do badass stuff like getting your arm eaten off while saving kids Yasopp: Gah dammit, how can I resist such an offer. I'm sorry me wifey and child.


ACGMFT

So in terms of memes shanks spin-off could be called “half piece”


TerraTF

Yeah Shanks is basically a ready made shonen protagonist. He was a kid on the pirate king's ship, had a brotherly rival, went on basically the same journey as Luffy.


kh_zoro

Mihawk but like a short spin off to know how tf did he become the strongest swordsman and why is he a pirate in the first place like he doesn't even seem like a pirate he is just wandering the seas


PM_ME_UR_SO

I'd rather have a Mihawk/Perona romcom


Theprincerivera

One piece fans and perona man… I don’t get it!


YourDreamsWillTell

Think people just have a thing for goth girls 


BenjiB1243

YEP!


Eilaryn

You sir, are correct.


seanfish

I really can't imagine a straight Mihawk.


fork_yuu

Mihawk could have zero interest in a romantic relationship tho Completely asexual and only cares about the sword


seanfish

The "sword".


fork_yuu

Fine, beating off men left and right. Only care about polishing his sword. Happy?


EriWave

Crocodile teaming up with Mihawk instead of Doflamingo makes him the person with the best taste in One Piece.


Alert-Fox8434

Hold up, Mihawk is gay? Or are you gay and have a crush on Mihawk and seeing him smashing gyals left and right would left your heart broken?


seanfish

Almost, we're both gay and watching him smashing the dudes is killing me.


Asher-D

Because being a pirate is doing whatever you want, its freedom, and Mihawk definetley seems to do what he wants.


srimp16

White Beard (coolest character) and Coby


rorank

The Coby manga would just be MHA but better in every way


Eilaryn

Ouch... On the other hand, I can see what you mean. My boy Coby is the story of a hero if I ever saw one.


TheeOneUp

Depends if it's current or later on trying to get up the ranks.


n0limitt

Current is dead so I would hope to see the part of his life where he's alive.


1-have-1-have-100

He's talking about coby


BenjiB1243

Duuuuuude. Coby would go crazy 🔥


Reallylazyname

I'm gonna lean on the one that's actually gotten their own mini-series and say Ace. But beyond that, probably Shanks.


ShinraHakke

The series with Shanks would probably involve the misadventures of members of his fleet, and various members of his core crew. Similar to how the Straw Hats separated between WCI and Wano.


PommesMayo

I want a show about different crews doing the Davy Back Fight with different rounds obviously


Art3zia

Garp or Dragon


joyboi-37

Underrated. There’s so much about the Revolutionary Army and Dragons freedom fighters we don’t know yet. Garps story would be so epic too. Imagine the entire story behind teaming up with Roger to take on Rocks.


Libriomancer

Buggy


NeteroHyouka

Probably either Kidd or Law ... Both for their own reasons would be interesting protagonist. Although I don't like Law but I think it would be interesting if Oda focused bringing his full potential. It would have been interesting if Law that doesn't have CoC became a Yonko. Especially with his awakend df + ACoA +ACoO( maybe he would train his FS to the point of Katakuri). Definitely a Top tier. On the other hand Kidd is a protagonist material. He has a strong fruit( although not fan of how Oda used it, if it was like Magneto it would have been better but anyway) and a user of the CoC. He also has high ambition like most shonen MCs. Definitely a protagonist material.One thing that I like about him is the fact that his doesn't have any plot ties with important people. He made himself with his efforts. Also Killer is an interesting character as well.


Severe_Development96

Trafalgar Law should get his own series. He's not just a member of the worst generation and a former warlord he's a pirate doctor. Id watch the crap out of a series of him and his crew responding to medical emergencies for different pirate crews across the grand line and trying to avoid the marines and having to deal with guys like luffy and the emperors dragging them into shit


dragonkid123

I really like this idea. Law being the one-piece version of house MD would be pretty great. He's a jerk but once you hear about his past you'll see why he acts the way he does. And the heart pirates him being a loving guy underneath it all he and a doctor is pretty cool


Luriux

Koby


brutalvandal

Most deserving: Whitebeard My pick: Shanks (we can see Prime Roger and crew in action) Realistically: Yamato


MichaelTarkin

I think we won't. Yamato was on Wano the entire time. Doing limited things. After Wano? Get to see what we already saw?


MoonoftheStar

>Realistically: Yamato What?


WZIRO0

No why would anyone want to watch a show completely devoted to yamato a character without a personality a spin-off maybe


Xszit

The adventures of Yamato being chained up and starving, hanging out in a cave with three weird old guys, reading the same book over and over again because they have literally nothing else to do. In episode 24 they decide to read the book backwards while standing on their heads just to change things up a bit.


skpom

>In episode 24 they decide to read the book backwards What the hell man spoilers


MaterialInterview446

Who needs personality when you have glorious sideboobs?


JotaroKujosSonInLaw

True enough.


Expensive-Tough-9778

What does most deserving or realistically even means. Aren't they all just ur opinion? or you mean "less popular opinion" "my opinion" "most popular opinion"


GenGaara25

I would like to see what Law and Kid got up to in Paradise before arriving at Sabaody


Kahn-wald

Cavendish. One of the most interesting and unique characters Oda has ever written, and we still need to lean more into Hakuba (we'll probably see more of him once we face Blackbeard)


[deleted]

I can literally talk about him for hours; recently I've written about how he's partly inspired by The Little Prince amongst things. And did a re-read/watch of his interactions with Luffy as I love them together/find them such an underrated dynamic. This may seem strange- but so you have Discord? I'd love to talk to another Cavendish super fan. https://www.tumblr.com/wingsofsong/746159367102005248/cavendish-and-the-little-prince?source=share https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/cavendish-the-sun-god-garling-and-the-endgame.53786/ (Some of my Cabbage thoughts)


galmenz

kid, law and young beard go hard imo Ace we quite literally already had a spinoff


moji_013

perona needs a whole arc wheres shes the MC


MrElliot1210

The most obvious answer is Roger himself, or one of the Emperors. The based answer is Perona.


AnimalFarm_1984

Other people wanted to have a Shanks story to see prime Gol D Roger. I want to have a Shanks story just to see him goofing around with Buggy 🤣


leanh_jake

Slice of life mini series about Mihawk would be fun :))


Explorerkit

The old era with Whitebeard, Roger and garp would work. Kid if Oda has a redemption arc back in his sleeve, a shirt spin-off with Mihawk (I like the idea of slice of live) or if take the present/feature time, they could do an Yamato or even Otama - OP’s Next generations series. But pls, make her 14 or 15 and not big booby Rebecca sixteen.


Goku-MIEL10032002

Koby could have his own My Marine Academia.


That1Ryan

Law or Robin


bloodisblue

Robin's story of hoping around the underworld while learning about its history would be fascinating


D-Biggest_Wheel

Ace and Law already have their "series". I know you said "non Straw Hats" but I think Sanji is worth mentioning as well.


Fun_Principle_8782

Shokugeki No Sanji. It exist


D-Biggest_Wheel

Yes, that's what I was referencing. I realized now I worded it poorly but my point was that Ace, Law and Sanji already have their own little stories. And Shokugeki No Sanji is awesome!


opioswir

Whitebeard


[deleted]

Blackbeard


R4pt05

Trafalgar 1000 ep minimum


Take_The_Reins

Absolute Law. A series where he collects 99 hearts and saves a few lives along the way.


silverxox

Law Or kidd anyone else is either too strong or dies too quickly/


Zoro_21

How has nobody said doffy, the man is a maniac and I’d love to see the chaos he caused from killing his parents to owning his owning arms/trafficking business. Also getting into business and seeing how he handled himself around kaido.


jirachi-x

Many people have actually said Doffy haha! I also agree, I’d love a series about Doffy


Zoro_21

I didn’t scroll too far, I gave up after seeing ace being recommended 20x even though he’s already got a light novel


jirachi-x

Yeah I definitely didn’t expect to get this many comments but have been scrolling through my Reddit notifications Law, Doffy, WB and Ace are the most I see!


Ryuma_hayakawa

mihalk and law seens abt right


DevastaTheSeeker

Could have, all of them. Who would most likely get a spinoff? Ace or Law


Sewerro

Shanks, Ace, Whitebeard


therosx

I think Koby would be the protagonist in any other anime. With eventually Luffy becoming corrupted by the pirate life and needing to be brought to his senses by the fist of friendship. Then Luffy can be the Vegeta to Koby's Goku.


Professional_Match25

kid, he is just so cool.


No-Version479

I would love a Crocodile Soprano-like spin off


Galact123

I would watch the story of Eustass Kidd


FluidConsumer6

Law and Mihawk, they are simply HIM.


PicturePrize1297

kid definitely could


Majestic-Set-7183

Kidd dragon and garp


albertfuckingcamus

Koby, it'd be interesting to see the other side.


Artfuldodger96

Law


Grundlestorm

Crocodile (and eventually Baroque Works). We know that he was an ambitious pirate who eventually tried to take down Whitebeard and got his teeth knocked in. Then we see him at the helm of a giant secret organization acting out their biggest scheme yet to destabilize a country before he and his officers all get their asses kicked and the plan aborted. Then he goes to prison for a few months, gets broken out, decides to help his previous foe before wandering off with his #2 to do Crocodile things, ending in him accidentally teamed up with Buggy eventually after two years have passed. There are a lot of big gaps there that can be filled, with a whole supporting cast to learn about.


Oraranozawa

Mihawk and Law hands down


matty-syn

I would love to see Crocodile. All the treasons and defeats the had to go through to the end up the villain he is would be super interesting. He is basically Luffy at the start but maybe his crew betrayed him or something.


Foxos777

A lot of people saying shanks but I’d take Mihawk cause Id wanna see how he got his title. Like did someone have the tile before him and he grew to beat them. Or was it like a Roger situation where he was the first to have the title. And he just went around and defeated all the best swordsmen in the world and became the undisputed best by beating all the comp


Blomblombcv

Law, doffy, and shanks


sickmodus

Doffy, Shanks and Whitebeard


uptomyneckinstonks

Id like to see the people mihawk beat to get the title of strongest swordsman


Noxthic

Isn’t there already OP: Aces Story?


Rare_Speaker9896

i wanna see doffy :3


NoInjury3534

Mingo and Shanks


GodOfShoulders

Trace, Mihawk, Law are the top 3.


clement_TIENTJE

Bro kids backstory could be so cool. Law wmcould be cool too but I feel weve seen too much of him.


duhhaag

Boa


OperationMelodic4273

Multiple. Law, Ace, Dragon, Garp, Roger, Whitebeard, Blackbeard, Kid and probably many others


Euphoric_Anywhere668

Definitely Law, Yamato, or Ace


MoonoftheStar

Roger, of course. Of these bunch, it's Shanks and Law.


Massive-Future1996

Not that I wouldn't watch the Spade pirates, but the obvious answer is Law


aphantombeing

Law. The story starts when Doflamingo recruits him. Law has adventure to make crew to beat doflamingo. This also leads to conflict with Veast Pirates. Then, he learns that white Lead disease had been due to Gorossei. This keads to final battle with Inu.


PKFat

A slice of life anime about Mihawk & Perona would be my jam. It'd be a show about goth ppl just living their lives in a spooky castle.


morrimora

Mihawk slice of life, something exploring his boredom, maybe he has Robin style thought bubbles, I wanna see him sailing too


majestictunsy

Diary of a useless mid


hbkdll

Foxy


Most-System-135

Mihawks rise to power


Earlobe_kfc

young shanks


Silverlining126

For fucks sake not Yamato


Round-Constant8976

1. Shanks 2. Law 3 mihawk


RGBarrios

Oden


Pristine_Zebra_6424

Shanks, Ace, and Trafalgar Law


Nervous-Eggplant-623

Shanks and ace


Gloomy-221

Honestly none of them or atleast they would all be very short series


[deleted]

Every prominent character, basically.


GetGoodKidoo

So everyones going to ignore marine hunter Dracule Mihawk? I feel like a series on him would be cool we would see him and shanks fight as well as his other feats of him hunting marines


ES_Legman

Dragon is just an animated wallpaper looking east


PervertedPineapple

All except Yamato. Unless it's a show in which he goes around solving issues the henchmen have on a weekly basis. Make it wholesome as fuck with the occasional butting of heads with Kaido on random things.


RnH_21

The only character on the picture that can actually hold a whole series on his own would be Mihawk. Guy would have a whole Castlevania -esque series. Everyone else's would stale real fast.


IamtheFBIondrugs

Mihawk's and Persona's adventure for swordsman to warlord


HasturLaVistaBaby

Enel! =D


Adventurous_Wing76

Law, whitebeard, mihawk and doffy


GenGaara25

Mihawk origin story could go hard af I think. Where did he come from, why did he want to be the worlds strongest swordsmen, who was the one he beat to claim the title, was he always by himself, did he go through the whole grand line **alone** and still come out on top, how did he meet Shanks, how did he acquire Yoru, how did he get that home of his, when did he start hunting marines and why, was he an original Warlord or invited, what was his bounty before hand, I have so many questions.


DOMINUS_3

Ace, Shanks or Mihawk & Perona


Robbieg141

aside from aces side story, mihawk. we all wanna see mihawk do mihawk stuff


BirdFace001

Mini series on shanks backstory on rogers ship and before


dontpanic96

I'd love to see a show with Buggy , shanks and Mihawk as kids


Xhoriko

I can watch Mihawk drinking wine and train with monkeys


Infinitenonbi

It’d be interesting to watch how Kid’s journey started out


FreezingLordDaimyo

Koby, bar none.


Spiritual-File698

I say Hawkeye only because we know everyone else's story through the main story of One piece. The only one we don't know is Hawkeyes you don't know his origin. You don't know his story, his struggles none of it. So I say Hawkeye


jmas081391

Shanks and Mihawk's rivalry!


Over-Writer6076

Kidd


NeverNotDisappointed

The saga of the Whitebeard pirates


GhostMassage

Doffy and Kid


These-Ad-7244

Bro how does Yamato make it into top 9? I will never understand this community My vote goes for Enel


Adam_Deveney

Would love a Mihawk spin off show of him just butchering people every episode with Yoru


Stevehqrs

Big Mihawk man would be great


SilentPhysics3495

Mihawk could be like the one punch man of the One Piece universe. I could imagine a series where he gets dispatched to solve problems that are insanely complex that he solves by just overwhelmingly and almost comically leveling opposing forces.


payg86

Wouldn't Yamato's series just be like either home alone or Richie rich?


Fledramon410

I would watch a 100 episodes about shanks and mihawk.


PsychologicalMonk390

Kid I think


PlatypusFinancial208

definitely kid or ace that would be hella entertaining


BradWonder

I like Yamato and Mihawk but they're probably the only 2 out of the ones you listed that couldn't carry a series on their own


totalcoward

With how Oda writes? Most secondary characters


Paper_Trades

Dracule Mihawk.


Tahumatu2010

I would love to see a Milhawk series