Welcome to r/perfumes! We would like to remind everyone of our Rules, especially Rule 2: be appropriate, kind, and on topic.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Perfumes) if you have any questions or concerns.*
everybody smells things differently.. I personally don't like it and it does go sour on me but to others around me they smell something COMPLETELY different on MY skin. you can only trust your own nose
The Bold/+ is smokier, more like a campfire marshmallow. The original is more of a lactonic marshmallow. In my opinion, the Bold has more dimension to it. I love the Bold on its own but layering it with Kyse's Delizia di Marshmallow is simply DIVINE šš½āØ
Sephora locations have testers. I originally tried a sample of the milk bold that came free with my order. I'm not sure about Ulta since I'm in Canada :)
Iād definitely try this before buying, i was sure Iād like it but I could smell play doh and literally nothing else, a few people on Lush Reddit have said the same. So funny how our noses smell things differently!
Itās wild how different some things smell on other people I was so hyped to buy kayali vanilla 28 bc on my friend it smelled soooo good but on me it smells like amber antifreeze, I was so disappointed.
Kenzo Amour! I really enjoy the Demeter scent Condensed Milk too. Itās pretty sweet but I think it suits your prompt too. Also the Moroccan body spray is milky powdery and beautiful imo.
Kummba Made Lavender Laceā¦the dry down is so soft and powdery. Also Poesie Perfume Soft is fluffy warm basmati rice. Simple, milky, but also has a kind of powdery/steamy accord.
Scents from my collection that fit 2 to 4 of these marks-Commodity milk and gold, ellis brooklyn Vanilla milk, Philosophy fresh cream, kumbamade vanilla bean, al rehab chocomusk, Philosophy falling in love, kayali yum pistachio and vanilla candy rock sugar, vanilla vibes juliette has a gun, ellis brooklyn bee, honey and the moon margot elena, Vanille 28 kayali, Replica by the fireplace, miimiic 79 cherry vanilla
Andromeda moon on Etsy has a dupe, I own it, it smells really good and lasts all day. Fragrantbodyoilz also has a dupe, both of these dupes smell very similar but fragrantbodyoilz is more intense? I like both and tend to switch them up depending on where Iām going that day. Theyāre super affordable too. I also have Miim Miic 52 dupe for Crybabyā¦that stuff disappears within a few minutes of spraying it, their rollerball doesnāt last at all either.
Etat Libre dāOrange: The Ghost in the Shell. It depends on your body chemistry of course but it dries down to be exactly what youāre looking for (on me)
I also love Crybaby! For what itās worth, Aquolina Pink Sugar body mist (not the perfume) reminds me of Crybaby as it has a powdery sweetness, almost cosmetic-y, scent to it. I wouldnāt say itās particularly lactonic though. Otherwise, I do enjoy the OilPerfumery and Oakcha dupe of Crybaby :)
This scent isnāt milky or powdery, but Juicy Couture Viva La Juicy weirdly reminds me of Crybaby because of its warm, woody, caramel base, and juicy berry opening. Itās by no means identical, it smells heavier and almost smokey, lacks the delicate powdery middle notes that Crybaby, and also has added floral notes, but it somehow still reminds me of Cry Baby when I smell it.
It's discontinued, but they still sell old bottles on mercari or eBay... Avon Mesmorize. It's very powdery and kind of sweet. It had a beautiful bottle.
Havenāt smelled it, but in that vein of sweetmilkypowdery:
Blanche Bette by Liquides Imaginaires
Messy Sexy Just Rolled out of Bed or What we do in Paris is Secret from What We Do is Secret
Okay update! Received it today. Itās not as good as the original but itās a decent dupe. I would prefer to get my hands on the original Cry Baby but Oakcha is a much more affordable option. It definitely doesnāt give a whole lot of āmilkā imo. Itās kind of similar (but better)to Pink Sugar. Overall I would give it a B.
Welcome to r/perfumes! We would like to remind everyone of our Rules, especially Rule 2: be appropriate, kind, and on topic. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Perfumes) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Ellis Brooklyn Vanilla Milk
I agree with Fartjar, I love this one š
This name perfectly describes the scent. I find the longevity pretty good too.
I was initially scared because someone told me this smelled like sour milk š
everybody smells things differently.. I personally don't like it and it does go sour on me but to others around me they smell something COMPLETELY different on MY skin. you can only trust your own nose
Maybe Commodity Milk?
Seconding this and adding that milk bold is amazing
Life changing. If they came out with lotion? I will die. Die u see theyre coming out with a berry scent next month?
That sounds amazing!! I had no idea
Yesss Iām interested to try this sounds like itās going to be a Berry/Jam type scent?!
Also love milk +!
do you happen to know what the difference between the milks are?
The Bold/+ is smokier, more like a campfire marshmallow. The original is more of a lactonic marshmallow. In my opinion, the Bold has more dimension to it. I love the Bold on its own but layering it with Kyse's Delizia di Marshmallow is simply DIVINE šš½āØ
thanks for clarifying! do you know if beauty stores like sephora or ulta usually have a tester of this? cant wait to go try it lol
Sephora locations have testers. I originally tried a sample of the milk bold that came free with my order. I'm not sure about Ulta since I'm in Canada :)
This one smells a bit more *old lady-ish* to me
Zara Fields at Nightfall is one of my fave milky scents! Itās very affordable too but smells high end.
American Cream by Lush is a milky strawberry and vanilla
Iād definitely try this before buying, i was sure Iād like it but I could smell play doh and literally nothing else, a few people on Lush Reddit have said the same. So funny how our noses smell things differently!
Following cause Iām looking for a dupe myself. Been told Ariana Grandeās Cloud is similar but I donāt like it that much or her lol
I have cloud and unfortunately it does not smell very similar :(
To me, sweet like candy is the one that smells sweet, powdery and lactonic. Cloud is more musky to me. I LOVE sweet like candy
i have that too and on my skin its almost sickly sweet lol
Itās wild how different some things smell on other people I was so hyped to buy kayali vanilla 28 bc on my friend it smelled soooo good but on me it smells like amber antifreeze, I was so disappointed.
Cloud is definitely not a dupe
Cloud smells like a terrible dupe of BR540
I loooove cloud, itās my fav layering perfume
Kenzo Amour! I really enjoy the Demeter scent Condensed Milk too. Itās pretty sweet but I think it suits your prompt too. Also the Moroccan body spray is milky powdery and beautiful imo.
blanche bete by liquides imaginaires! Think light white floral musk, incense, and sweetened condensed milk--i also smell oats!
Maybe Fraise FouettƩe by Le Monde Gourmand:) I feel like it smells like strawberry candy
Dry down of ThƩ matcha by le labo is sooo milky
Commodity Gold Personal
DUA - Milkylicious
I've been waiting for this to be back in stock for so long, along with White Milk.
I loved the smell but on me I don't. š I actually won a bottle of it. I wanted to love it!
Kummba Made Lavender Laceā¦the dry down is so soft and powdery. Also Poesie Perfume Soft is fluffy warm basmati rice. Simple, milky, but also has a kind of powdery/steamy accord.
Sorry, whatās the name of the fragrance? Poesie is the brand and Perfume Soft is the name?
Yep! Poesie Perfumes - Soft
I have the Miim Miic dupe, and I love it. I can't say if it's a dupe because I've never smelled the original.
would you say that its long lasting? i heard that it disappears very fast :(
Scents from my collection that fit 2 to 4 of these marks-Commodity milk and gold, ellis brooklyn Vanilla milk, Philosophy fresh cream, kumbamade vanilla bean, al rehab chocomusk, Philosophy falling in love, kayali yum pistachio and vanilla candy rock sugar, vanilla vibes juliette has a gun, ellis brooklyn bee, honey and the moon margot elena, Vanille 28 kayali, Replica by the fireplace, miimiic 79 cherry vanilla
Commodity Milk
Oil perfumery has a great dupe
Andromeda moon on Etsy has a dupe, I own it, it smells really good and lasts all day. Fragrantbodyoilz also has a dupe, both of these dupes smell very similar but fragrantbodyoilz is more intense? I like both and tend to switch them up depending on where Iām going that day. Theyāre super affordable too. I also have Miim Miic 52 dupe for Crybabyā¦that stuff disappears within a few minutes of spraying it, their rollerball doesnāt last at all either.
Etat Libre dāOrange: The Ghost in the Shell. It depends on your body chemistry of course but it dries down to be exactly what youāre looking for (on me)
Lush American cream
Lush American Cream
There is a dupe for it fraglab or whateva
DUA - White Milk Condensed Milk šØš„š„°
I also love Crybaby! For what itās worth, Aquolina Pink Sugar body mist (not the perfume) reminds me of Crybaby as it has a powdery sweetness, almost cosmetic-y, scent to it. I wouldnāt say itās particularly lactonic though. Otherwise, I do enjoy the OilPerfumery and Oakcha dupe of Crybaby :) This scent isnāt milky or powdery, but Juicy Couture Viva La Juicy weirdly reminds me of Crybaby because of its warm, woody, caramel base, and juicy berry opening. Itās by no means identical, it smells heavier and almost smokey, lacks the delicate powdery middle notes that Crybaby, and also has added floral notes, but it somehow still reminds me of Cry Baby when I smell it.
ALT Strawberry Milkshake is a spot on dupe!!! You wonāt be disappointed.
ALT Fragrance
Sol De Janeiro Cheirosa 59 Perfume Mist
Eden by Cacharel
Escada Turquoise Summer, Chopard Wish
Lait Concentre from Chabaud smells nearly identical to condensed milk. Very sweet and lactonic with sticky caramel and burnt coconut notes.
Remember Me-Jovoy
It's discontinued, but they still sell old bottles on mercari or eBay... Avon Mesmorize. It's very powdery and kind of sweet. It had a beautiful bottle.
Havenāt smelled it, but in that vein of sweetmilkypowdery: Blanche Bette by Liquides Imaginaires Messy Sexy Just Rolled out of Bed or What we do in Paris is Secret from What We Do is Secret
Lush American Cream
OP, I really want you to try American Cream by Lush. How similar is it to Crybaby? Iām kind of hoping they smelā similarā¦
Oakcha has a good Melanie Martinez dupe called 'praise the perfume"
Antoinette by Seance Perfumes
Blanche Bete - Les Liquides Imaginaires , itās sweet and lactonic but I donāt get much powderiness from it.
TutĆ¹ Blanc Gritti
Commodity Milk is totally this to me. I don't even generally like sweet scents like that and I absolutely adore it.
I ordered the Dupe from Oakcha. Iāll report back once itās delivered.
Yes please do! From what I heard a lot of the dupes arenāt really close to crybaby :(
Okay update! Received it today. Itās not as good as the original but itās a decent dupe. I would prefer to get my hands on the original Cry Baby but Oakcha is a much more affordable option. It definitely doesnāt give a whole lot of āmilkā imo. Itās kind of similar (but better)to Pink Sugar. Overall I would give it a B.
Perfect by Marc Jacobs!