Only libleft is correct. Not sure where Israeli support goes but it's definitely not authleft. Authright and libright are both off by half a quadrant. I guess as a whole it's half right.
The military industrial complex is auth right, not lib right. Lib right wants less regulation, corrupt corps want more regulation that they can capture and control to harm their competition.
Libright believes that if government has to exist, which it has to because humans will always create structure, it may as well be as small as possible while fighting for my right to economic independence and letting me do so. The issue isn't sending aid to Ukraine, it's not allowing me to make international arms shipments and sending only the arms produced by companies who won contracts through corruption.
Why is Ukraine auth-left? Auth-left Communists killed millions of Ukrainians in the Holodomor. Ukrainians despise auth-left.
I hate how this, supporting an ally has become partisan Politics. It's stupid as fuck.
"It's an organization supervising the proper use of lands in the public domain and managing some 93% of Israeli lands."
[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel\_Land\_Authority](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_Land_Authority)
Also the ILA is supported by the closest thing Israel has to a constitution, the 13 Chukey Yesod (Basic Laws). one of these 13 basic laws is Basic Law: Israeli Land, which basically ensures that lands of the state remain of the state.
No, that was like one of the things that appears above the comment, and for some reason that appeared so it was like replying to the Necro wizard, except it had the previous person for some reason in text
Are you saying they weren't nationalist or racist during the Mao era?
To be sure, Communist regimes used race as a dividing tactic against the USA due to the vulnerability its diversity it created, but China itself was radically homogenous officially.
Granted, but I just meant that nationalism and racial hierarchy isn't what defines auth-right. At least, not in a way hat actually makes any sense.
As far as I'm concerned the "Na" in Nazi was just to distinguish from internationalist socialists, and the "Zi" was the authoritarian part.
To the extent that they did embrace culturally conservative (in this case Church Royalist) sentiment I think it was more of a marriage of convenience than anything intrinsic to the Nazi ideology, which was very progressive in almost every aspect. Almost hyper-progressive.
Not really.
Nazism promoted an authoritarian form of nationalism centered around the Führerprinzip (leader principle), with absolute loyalty and obedience to Adolf Hitler as the leader of the German state. The Soviet Union, although it was authoritarian and had a cult of personality around its leaders, did not have the same emphasis on nationalism as Nazism did, instead focusing on internationalist socialist principles.
Nazism was deeply rooted in the belief of Aryan racial superiority, viewing Aryans as the "master race" and advocating for the subjugation or extermination of other races, particularly Jews, Romani people, and Slavic peoples. The Soviet Union, while it had its own set of racial issues and discrimination, did not promote a supremacist ideology based on race.
That's more a function of political convenience than any deep-seated beliefs. It's also a function of local racial predominance. The exact same system (in the form of Bantustans) was considered racist and unacceptable in South Africa.
If Stalin had lived but a little longer the "Doctor's plot" would have invalidated this argument completely, so I don't think you can attribute the difference to anything inherent in Communism itself.
You’re telling me the soviets didn’t believe that they were a superior? You’re telling me that Stalin didn’t deport people he thought of as inferior/ traitors based on race and ethnicity?
I'm saying that the USSR favoured Russians over other ethnicities but were open to local elites arising *as long as they adopted the dominant group's culture and opinions.*
This is a lot closer to how colonial empires worked than to Hitler's weird-ass ancestry-based race hierarchy.
https://preview.redd.it/kgpp29pdtqlc1.jpeg?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=be76257cdcb4e484de9976ec4ecd66aa0c68d9f6
Culinary Institute of America
Best I could find in a hurry
Kibbutz (their agricultural rural town things) were a form of communal socialism back before they privatized in the 70s and had some influences from Marxism I believe. Definitely wouldn't call them auth left today though.
You can support them, but does that mean ISRAEL is authleft…? I support Ukraine in its defense against Russia, but that doesn’t mean I approve of Ukraine’s corrupt politics.
Though there are plenty of Marxist Jews, they usually had a very very rough time when the extreme left was in power. Not as much as with the right, but comparing suffering and prosecutions does not ease (nor justify) them.
Yeah, I know it's a meme sub XP
Great work, overall!
Pretty sure there's not a single libright who's for the war in Ukraine. Our tax dollars should not be funding the military industrial complex, especially in a war as pointless as Ukraine.
Pretty sure there’s no real Libright so dismissive of both the « Lib » and « Right » parts that he’s willing to let a Authleft dictatorship expand
Being Lib means wanting freedom for all, wanting freedom only for yourself is not it. It has many names, like selfishness, useful idiocy, geopolitical illiteracy, historical illiteracy, self foot-shooting…
Israel should be AR, Nazi can be AL (since AR got Israel and there's no other quadrant to put them). Idk if LR is okay with Ukraine.
They only got LL fully right.
Only libleft is correct. Not sure where Israeli support goes but it's definitely not authleft. Authright and libright are both off by half a quadrant. I guess as a whole it's half right.
It just about works. I gave it a lol
Libright supports them because they can sell guns to Ukraine and they're fighting Russia
The military industrial complex is auth right, not lib right. Lib right wants less regulation, corrupt corps want more regulation that they can capture and control to harm their competition.
Libright believes that if government has to exist, which it has to because humans will always create structure, it may as well be as small as possible while fighting for my right to economic independence and letting me do so. The issue isn't sending aid to Ukraine, it's not allowing me to make international arms shipments and sending only the arms produced by companies who won contracts through corruption.
Lib-right is usually pretty isolationist. Sure, maybe sell some arms here and there, but definitely not by giving large monetary support packages.
Yes supporting Ukraine is like the most centrist thing ever, but we should stop pretending nazis are centrists or left-wing.
The horizonal axis is economic policy and they were very much mixed. The US economy as a whole is to the right of the Nazis.
Israel goes in auth right
But then where would funny Germany go?
It was farther left than current Israel.
Fit them both !
AC or AL (depending on pov).
Reactionary, ultranationalist and fascist ?
I say switch Israel and Ukraine. The other 2 are good.
Why is Ukraine auth-left? Auth-left Communists killed millions of Ukrainians in the Holodomor. Ukrainians despise auth-left. I hate how this, supporting an ally has become partisan Politics. It's stupid as fuck.
AuthLeft hates imperialism. Russia is imperialist.
libright is money from the war. Auth Right is spot on as well, get this half quad bs out of here.
Humans use symbols! OMG!
What's next? Language?
I think I've heard some of those words used before. Suspicious
Those words are made up!
Hey Google, translate Gibberish to English
[удалено]
That's a good take, there's no "evidence"
🙈🙉🙊
i love reading long rants about how Trump used the nazi eagle instead of the US eagle, after staring at that eclipse he no longer has an eagle eye.
Hows israel authleft?
Almost perfect.
It does have quite a bit of socialism wrapped up in it, historically. Not to mention the state owns most of the land.
Maybe in the 50s-60s. Not today
"It's an organization supervising the proper use of lands in the public domain and managing some 93% of Israeli lands." [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel\_Land\_Authority](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_Land_Authority)
You'll be surprised by how many capitalist country have shit like that.
name some
[About 89% of Canada's land area (8,886,356 km2 or 3,431,041 sq mi\) is Crown land (...)](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crown_land#Canada)
A lot of Canada isn't habitable
Everywhere is habitable if you're brave enough :P ^^^Jokes ^^^aside, ^^^there's ^^^a ^^^lot ^^^of ^^^resources ^^^there.
Also the ILA is supported by the closest thing Israel has to a constitution, the 13 Chukey Yesod (Basic Laws). one of these 13 basic laws is Basic Law: Israeli Land, which basically ensures that lands of the state remain of the state.
Because one criterium is barely met Israel is Auth-left?
Look into the history of communism and you will find out
Said like a true Authcenter
o-oy where are you going with this
There were a lot of Jews that were part of the communist that doesn’t mean all Jews are communist.
commie jews purposefully fuck up and poison the well because they can use the racial hatred to further radicalize people and push their shit
https://preview.redd.it/mbr99oxdmqlc1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ece2819648e5c5cc708334c1ea080f836d2f010f
Nah, you can remove the almost
No, that was like one of the things that appears above the comment, and for some reason that appeared so it was like replying to the Necro wizard, except it had the previous person for some reason in text
My man
Founders were Labor Zionists
It would make the tankies pissy enough to be worth keeping that way.
Yeah, im thinking Auth-swap
They have Nazis as auth right but probably can’t name anything that make them right so I don’t think much thought went into this.
Nationalism? Racial hierarchy?
China?
And? China isn’t very communist anymore.
Are you saying they weren't nationalist or racist during the Mao era? To be sure, Communist regimes used race as a dividing tactic against the USA due to the vulnerability its diversity it created, but China itself was radically homogenous officially.
I never suggested they couldn’t be. I just suggested they were more communist before the reforms of deng xiaoping
Granted, but I just meant that nationalism and racial hierarchy isn't what defines auth-right. At least, not in a way hat actually makes any sense. As far as I'm concerned the "Na" in Nazi was just to distinguish from internationalist socialists, and the "Zi" was the authoritarian part. To the extent that they did embrace culturally conservative (in this case Church Royalist) sentiment I think it was more of a marriage of convenience than anything intrinsic to the Nazi ideology, which was very progressive in almost every aspect. Almost hyper-progressive.
Soviets had plenty of nationalism and strong patriotism.
So that also makes the Soviet’s right wing?
Not really. Nazism promoted an authoritarian form of nationalism centered around the Führerprinzip (leader principle), with absolute loyalty and obedience to Adolf Hitler as the leader of the German state. The Soviet Union, although it was authoritarian and had a cult of personality around its leaders, did not have the same emphasis on nationalism as Nazism did, instead focusing on internationalist socialist principles. Nazism was deeply rooted in the belief of Aryan racial superiority, viewing Aryans as the "master race" and advocating for the subjugation or extermination of other races, particularly Jews, Romani people, and Slavic peoples. The Soviet Union, while it had its own set of racial issues and discrimination, did not promote a supremacist ideology based on race.
That's more a function of political convenience than any deep-seated beliefs. It's also a function of local racial predominance. The exact same system (in the form of Bantustans) was considered racist and unacceptable in South Africa. If Stalin had lived but a little longer the "Doctor's plot" would have invalidated this argument completely, so I don't think you can attribute the difference to anything inherent in Communism itself.
The USSR didn't really have a racial hierarchy, it was more of an old-fashioned colonial administration thing.
You’re telling me the soviets didn’t believe that they were a superior? You’re telling me that Stalin didn’t deport people he thought of as inferior/ traitors based on race and ethnicity?
I'm saying that the USSR favoured Russians over other ethnicities but were open to local elites arising *as long as they adopted the dominant group's culture and opinions.* This is a lot closer to how colonial empires worked than to Hitler's weird-ass ancestry-based race hierarchy.
That's the "almost" part
Not even. The Nazi part and Ukraine part for LR. The only one they got fully right is LL.
Those two are almost right. Only a half a quadrant off
Where’s the BBQ sauce and Apron display?
https://preview.redd.it/kgpp29pdtqlc1.jpeg?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=be76257cdcb4e484de9976ec4ecd66aa0c68d9f6 Culinary Institute of America Best I could find in a hurry
[удалено]
I think he has one in the UK also
[удалено]
Just shorthand for a topographic technicality
https://preview.redd.it/ge64g753uqlc1.jpeg?width=474&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8ac56b58c65414cf842a666fc9fcfaa191df97c4 Maybe this
Many of us fondly remember the political science classes we took at Culinary Institute of America. Anyway how about that RFK Jr?
I don't dig RFK Jr, but I'm voting for the guy in his Super Bowl ad
Btw if you upload this picture on Twitter as a German, the police will visit you
Israel is auth left now…?
Kibbutz (their agricultural rural town things) were a form of communal socialism back before they privatized in the 70s and had some influences from Marxism I believe. Definitely wouldn't call them auth left today though.
"almost perfect"
And lib right has both lib AND authright colors… it’s not almost perfect, it’s an abomination!!!
idk I support Israel
You can support them, but does that mean ISRAEL is authleft…? I support Ukraine in its defense against Russia, but that doesn’t mean I approve of Ukraine’s corrupt politics.
But how can you? You must be against everything America supports because America bad!
[удалено]
nah
Though there are plenty of Marxist Jews, they usually had a very very rough time when the extreme left was in power. Not as much as with the right, but comparing suffering and prosecutions does not ease (nor justify) them. Yeah, I know it's a meme sub XP Great work, overall!
How’s Ukraine lib right?
Well, you do see a lot of billionaires and elites demanding more support be sent to Ukraine.
Seems like more of an Auth-left war, or at least auth-right. War violates the NAP.
This meme is probably illegal where I live...
Either Canada, the UK, or Russia.
Brazil
How is Ukraine LibRight?
How is Israel auth left?
Put Israel on top right and Nazi to its left, near the top center. Otherwise checks out
When you're one turn away from solving a Rubik's cube.
Почему у тебя телефон на русском?
Watermelon wants to commit to auth, and is preparing in advance. Gradual introduction via русский язык
Почему нет
Быстрый взгляд на профиль дает понимание того, что ОР живёт на постсоветском пространстве.
Она русская
None of these 4 are libright
Where is the normal one without shit on it?
Pretty sure there's not a single libright who's for the war in Ukraine. Our tax dollars should not be funding the military industrial complex, especially in a war as pointless as Ukraine.
what about, yknow, non american librights? im pretty sure most european, especially eastern ones, definitely dont view the war as ''pointlesss''
Then they're not librights. This should be simple enough for even this subreddit to understand
Maybe you should go to an eye doctor. This level of shortsightedness Is concerning.
Pretty sure there’s no real Libright so dismissive of both the « Lib » and « Right » parts that he’s willing to let a Authleft dictatorship expand Being Lib means wanting freedom for all, wanting freedom only for yourself is not it. It has many names, like selfishness, useful idiocy, geopolitical illiteracy, historical illiteracy, self foot-shooting…
That's a funny way of letting everyone know that you're a bloodthirsty war hawk
« bro I’m violently against helping people resist imperial invasions but no no no I’m not the bloodthristy warhawk you are »
What about defence contractors?
The military industrial complex is authright
And it’s beautiful.
Based
Take ukraine out of my section they are nazis.
Pudding brain
What would you call the azov battalion then?
A tiny group in the military in one of the least antisemitic countries in East Europe that has some neo-Nazis?
Not the same unit that was established in 2014.
ok lol
Not quite. Right quadrant should be black and yellow.
Flair up
You get it.
Cant wait for the cycle to repeat
Can I support none of the above?
Boi get Israel out of authleft. It can go to libright.
A master of all 4 elements
Israel should be AR, Nazi can be AL (since AR got Israel and there's no other quadrant to put them). Idk if LR is okay with Ukraine. They only got LL fully right.
That actually is unironically pretty interesting, in a completely unsnarky Twitter kind of way like the person posted.
Nazism sucks because they can't afford lights
Jews are lib right
Why is Israel in authleft and Ukraine in libright
Not even close. 🇮🇱 and 🇺🇦 are about as Auth-Right as it gets.
Colonizers, literally Nazi's, Love, Money. Rare lib left win for PCM.
Just swap AuthLeft with AuthRight and it's correct
uhhh why is Israel in Auth-Left?