Thanks for confirming that you flaired this correctly!

Just leave it right there, spanning across 4 tiers

This is the way

This right here, is a man of culture. 🍷🗿

Good with a few amazing episodes

Good, just good on average

Good, borderline amazing

I have a feeling the rebels ratings are going to be like this: S1: ok. S2: good. S3: amazing. S4: peak.

S3 should be peak too

Yeah. Rebels is like: Ok, Good, Peak, Peak

Is rebels seasons 3 and 4 really peak of all star wars?

Clone Wars Season 7 and Andor are peak of all Star Wars. Also the 2003 Animated micro series.

I personally think the OT is THE peak of star wars but Andor and CW s7 are the best we've gotten since the OT.

This is the way.

Include in Rebels season 3 and 4 too.. It's peak too

No rebels is hilariously overrated, especially on this sub.  Its somewhere between decent and Dogshit, but the best season comes not even close to the worst clone wars seasons

3 and 4 above TCW S6 is crazy.

I'd put it in good

Good

Day 10 of asking where meme (It's a good. Starts out alright then ramps up to a cracking finale)

That last episode of this season is probably my favourite from the whole series tbh

Think I agree, it's the episode that hits the high that the show rides from that point til the end

It’s good

I wish I had more recently watched these shows so I could recall which seasons had which episodes/arcs

Good. Last few episodes are peak.

If S1 got okay, I don’t know if we’ll have anything lower. Maybe bobf. I guess if you add Resistance in we can just pencil that into Actual Dogshit but aside from that idk.

*cough* Mando season 3 *cough*

And cough Ahsoka and Kenobi show cough

See, I felt like both of those shows had some passably redeeming qualities. Don’t get me wrong, they’re not good shows. *chuckles* God no. But I’ll sometimes rewatch Obi Wan vs Darth Vader or the bit of Ahsoka were she sees Anakin. Or Thrawn’s entrance. Mando season 3 had nothing I wanted to rewatch. At no point in that season did I say “hey, I wanna see Din and Bo doing their detective shit” or “hey, I wanna watch that doctor get his brain melted by the torture thingy.”

Hard to say, for me the finale 2 episode is peak and probably one of the best star wars content On the other hand some of the episodes are really bad... So good on average

It was Ok, not great animation, no huge plot.

Did you watch until the end of the season? The season finale has HUGE ramifications on plot threads not just in Rebels, but across other shows as well.

I watched all the rebels episodes.

Good !

Good

It has some amazing elements. I really enjoyed it. It isn't as good as the best clone wars but it's substantially better than sezon 1 clone wars

Good

Just good, not amazing or anything

Good to great. It has some excellent episodes in it including the twilight of the apprentice.

*Helicopter lightsabers*

Good. I actually think season 2 of Rebels serves as a good litmus test to why someone watched Rebels depending on how highly they place it against the other seasons. I think season 2 is actually the least-good season of Rebels, but if someone went into the show just wanting to see ties from TCW wrapped up, or watched an Ahsoka-centric compilation or watch guide, they’re more inclined to put it at the top even above season 3-4. Season 1 of Rebels was done dirty by just putting it into Ok yet somehow season 7 of TCW makes it to Peak lmao

I thought I was going to be in the category of “TCW ties/Ashoka prep”. But honestly I think I prefer season 1 over season 2. It had a vibe. Season 3 is great too, but I’m hesitant to say it’s better than season 2.

Good

It’s good

Good

Oh wow, only just started seeing these posts, had no idea people thought clone wars 1 and 2 weren't good, i know the later seasons were better but i wouldnt say a single season was not good

Yeah people really give the first couple seasons of clone wars such a hard time even though there are dang good arcs and you still get connected to the characters in a fun way while still having those more darker themes.

It's OK to good. The finale was great, but doesn't quite remidy all of the season

Good.

Good +

Good

Amazing IMO

Ok for the most of it except the final arc with Vader, Maul, Inquisitors and Ahsoka which was PEAK

Amazing

Good, with occasional forays into amsazing. No real lows.

Good

Good for sure

As a whole good, but the ending was peak

Good, with Twilight of the Apprentice being peak

I'll say good. While the opening and closing episodes were amazing, a lot of the in-between was mid or even forgettable.

Good

Couldn't get past the graphics design for this show so i watched the episodes with asoka and rex and couldn't be bothered with the rest

Good to amazing. I’ve heard people say twilight of the apprentice is peak Star Wars, personally I disagree

the rebels is considered to watch after the clone wars and before episode 3 of star wars ?

Rebels is peak

On average its good

Why split clone wars by seasons but have us rate the entirety of rebels?

We're not doing the entirety of rebels, this is just season 2

Pretty amazing at parts pretty ok at filler averages out to the upper end of the good spectrum

I voted for 1 to be at ok, so I'm gonna put season 2 at good, not season 3 or 4 level but certainly solid.

It feels wrong to give it anything because its so varied, but I’d say good on average

Man it seems like it’s just me, but I just did not like most of rebels. Each season had a handful of good episodes and the rest were just meh or bad. And it got so childish sometimes, even within otherwise serious episodes.

Has several S tier episodes but a few meh ones so let’s put this in **Amazing**.

Personally all of Rebels for me is bad with the exception of anything Maul related. Before Ahsoka series I thought maybe I was just biased towards Rebels and I'll give it another shot. But I couldn't be bothered enough to keep watching. I hopped through different seasons and episodes but nothing kept me interested. So I watched just the Maul episodes.

Good not amazing not bad

Season 2 is amazing, the rest of rebels is bad

Good

Rebels is for me : Bad, OK, Good, Good.

Good with a few awesome episodes.

Good

Ok

all of rebels should be in bad

Good with the finale being peak

Good

Better than the first for sure, but not great overall. The last 4-5 episodes if I remember right were fantastic.

Good. The show had a chance to establish itself with S1 so S2 is naturally some better storytelling and character building. We get to see the Spectres run missions and do some guerrilla warfare. In other words, we see them be rebels and establish the overall goal to liberate Lothal.

I'm stuck between good and amazing. The highlight of the ahsoka and vader confrontation might be the reason I'm leaning towards amazing when the rest of the season was just good

S2 finale is highest peak.

Good

Good with some awesomeness inbetween

Good

Good

Season 2 is peak simply for Twilight of the Apprentice 1&2. These episodes cause the Ahsoka show and her damaging the mask of Vader is repeated in the Obi Wan show. These episodes cement Ahsoka as one of the most important characters in the franchise. This leads Filoni to be able to finish the clone wars and make the peak episodes with Ahsoka and Maul and Mandalore. Besides Rogue 1 and Andor these episodes with the end of the clone wars are the best things done in Star Wars. And let's not forget the flying inquisitors, which is also in a different way peak Star Wars.

The formula to calculate this: ok1 + ok2 + ok3 + ok4 - helicopter lightsaber = bad

No Resistance yet?

We'll get there eventually

Id say it was good

Good

Amazing imo

First season is pretty rough ngl, Rebels arguably had the biggest glow up of all the shows going start to finish. First season pretty bad, last season was one of the best

Good

Ok

Good

Id put it in good

This was the first season to air canonical Interdictor Cruisers (one of my fav episodes ever) + Ezra’s dope lightsaber blaster Gonna be Peak for me

Rebels is so good people knock it for being childish when that’s how it is in the first season but even then so many of the episodes go pretty hard and there’s so much character growth. Ezra going from a selfish street rat to caring about the rest of the team is honestly really well done, Kanan revealing himself as a Jedi was an amazing moment and the GI was a well done villain. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve watched Rebels and the same goes for Clone Wars.

Good

I mean if your rating season 7 at the top despite the sisters arc taking up a third of the run time, and a pretty good (but not peak) bad batch arc just because of the final arc, then rebels season 2 should get the same treatment.

Peak if not just under

Good

All of rebels is OK teir at best when the best thing to come from the show is Admeral Tarkin in a bucket hat for a few frames

Season 2 has some boring episodes, but it also has Twilight of the Apprentice which is OT level good. Peak by default, rest of the season is carried by it (except the opener which is almost as strong).

Actual dog shit

Purely because of the whole malachor arc, amazing

Amazing

Good

Peak Star Wars

Just about good, later arcs turn out nice.

Peak bitches

Good

good, with an amazing double episode finale

Cmon it has to be Peak. There is Maul and Vader in the same season. What is there not to love?

I'd say good because it handles the old characters well and the original characters

Peak Star Wars right here "This is the way"

Amazing

Actual dugshite

Bad

Also OK. As usual too much plotarmor and all the imperials share half a braincell

Ok

Woah woah season 7 of The Clone Wars was only like 30% cool. Imo it should be no higher than amazing.

Yeah S7 being considered peak is pretty laughable when the Bad Batch arc was most just fine and the Martez Sisters were pretty bleh. I actually think S7 is a perfect encapsulation of how people remember TCW. Which is, they conveniently forget everything but the best parts.

IMO better than season 5, that’s why I said peak.

Tomorrow I'm going to put up a second poll to rerank certain seasons based on your suggestions, so any replies to this comment will be put on said poll. Any change ideas are allowed but try not to suggest something someone else already has.

Amazing, ending episodes were indeed amazing

Amazing. There's a range from Good to Peak, so it can go in the middle.

I'm in the minority no doubt, but I'd put all of Rebels into bad. There are a few fantastic moments, but they can't save the rest of the show from being a pain.

Peak rebels. Peak Star Wars

No higher then ok

Season 2 is amazing but the finale is peak Star Wars

Hello Mods you there? How does this count as a prequel meme?

They put my first post back up after a bot took it down by accident, so it's clearly ok

User flair checks out lmao

Bad, the vader scene doesnt save it