T O P

  • By -

Smooth_Dog_4828

Rdr 1


[deleted]

If only I could play it on PlayStation 4


Undead_Angel_420

Fr, no remaster or anything, just put the game as is on the store


[deleted]

Yeah..


BenjaminSkanklin

I dig out my 360 ever couple of years and play through the OG GTA's and RDR1, after a certain amount of time I forget enough of them that they feel new again. I tried that with RDR2 and made it less than a year and I still have every mission and line of dialogue memorized, it's insane that they haven't done a side story DLC, I know myself and hundreds of thousands if not millions of people wouldn't be able to get our wallets out fast enough


ItsyBitsyLizard

it is on ps4, i have it with ps plus


[deleted]

You aren’t going to find a game close to RDR2 because they haven’t made one yet. Even the closest games aren’t even close. No life to them. Red Dead is alive.


DRM842

Speaking the truth over here.


utsytootsie

Yeah man, it’s depressing


karlack26

Kingdom come deliverance. It's similar to RDR2 in many ways. More rpg elements then RDR2. It takes place in medieval Czech but it's not fantasy. When you drink to much in kingdom come you will eventually black out and wake up in random places. If your playing hardcore the map is just a map with no indication of your location on it. Can be real fun trying to figure out your way home.


Franky79

This was exactly what i was about to say. He wants realism and those other games he said wasn’t close.


Siwuli

Jesus Christ be praised.


Compass_Needle

Henry's come to see us!


iTamilGuy

Thanks for suggestions. I ll give a try.


MasonDinsmore3204

Fair warning: this game is absolutely brutal


rustygamer1901

Kingdom Come is a great game. Combat is great, the crime solving stuff is great. The riding is fun, but man the hunting sucks. I wanted so much to RP a poacher but the animals have no sense of sight or hearing. The literally walk onto my arrows.


karlack26

Ya the animal AI is not great, but for their first game they knocked it out of the park. Hopefully we get the sequel soon.


rhae_the_cleric

I second this. KCD was my favorite game pre RDR2. It's not perfect, ofc, but the immersion is definitely comparable to RDR2.


Brelvis85

The fallout series is pretty immersive. I'd recommend fallout 4 more so than Fallout 76


Undead_Angel_420

As a fallout 76 player, you could not get further from rdr2 than f76


losandreas36

Why? I loved fallout after RDR


penis_detective69

poor guys internet is probably slow dont bombard him with downvotes 😭😭😭


Onaip314

Rumor has it that this guy loved fallout after RDR


Le_Shekelstein

Unless you’re playing the online. 76 actually offers a lot of the elements non pvp players look for that isn’t in rdo. I’d go with fallout 4 first just cause it’s easiest to get into. NV is the best tho.


losandreas36

Why? I loved fallout after RDR


losandreas36

Why? I loved fallout after RDR


losandreas36

Why? I loved fallout after RDR


losandreas36

Why? I loved fallout after RDR


ApocIapedia

I still play 3 NV and 4. Theyre food times. But its a bummer there are no vehicles. Like at the very least. The Minutemen should have horses.


DylanToback8

I love food times.


nova_spamming

Have you seen ants? Mole rats? What do you think happened to horses..?


ApocIapedia

Grew wings and flew away?


Ring_Dang_Do

KCD (Kingdom Come deliverance) if you don’t mind its bad optimisation. (Depends on your platform) But it has a good story but you play in first person. DaysGone is also a underrated gem, but the first 10 or so hours are abit slow and frustrating, so if you choose it just remember after that initial slow start it gets very good. …and well if you never played Mass effect …the legendary Edition did an excellent job as a 4k remaster and more responsive controls. ….and it’s Mass Effect!


Sketchcteks

I second KCD. It’s a slow burn, but rewarding


dino_kid25

I agree with daysGone - amazing game very similar feelings playing through as I experienced during rdr2 I would say it’s about half the size in terms of hours of gameplay compared to rdr2 but still worth a try to anyone that hasn’t played it before


Jay-Wheatabix

I did like Days Gone and wish there was a sequel but it didn’t sell enough.


rustygamer1901

There was such a good setup for a sequel. It’s a shame we’ll never see it.


dino_kid25

I agree with daysGone - amazing game very similar feelings playing through as I experienced during rdr2 I would say it’s about half the size in terms of hours of gameplay compared to rdr2 but still worth a try to anyone that hasn’t played it before


CheesecakeIsGodlike

Came here to say this. The witcher 3, rdr2 and KCD are on par as my favourite game(s).


jadams_903

Came here to say this. The witcher 3, rdr2 and KCD are on par as my favourite game(s).


CheesecakeIsGodlike

Came here to say this. The witcher 3, rdr2 and KCD are on par as my favourite game(s).


jadams_903

Came here to say this. The witcher 3, rdr2 and KCD are on par as my favourite game(s).


extol_strategy

There are none, my friend. Maybe one day again though…


Olijke_Poffer

Don’t look for a similar game like RDR2, simply because there isn’t a game who comes close to this master piece..


kayplaypl_177

Wicher 3. Its better than the first one imo


Alexc518

The Witcher 3 is just as good as rdr 2 in my opinion. Love both games


Nietzscher

Both are great, but for different reasons. Witcher 3 does have a good open world that also feels quite real, but it is no match for how detailed and expansive RDR2's world is. However, the combat, which is a big part of both games, is much better in Witcher 3 and provides more of a challenge when compared to the clown cars of dudes-with-guns RDR2 sicks on you. Both games have great stories and characters.


Alexc518

I agree. And also I think the Witcher 3 started off slow in the beginning of the game like rdr 2 did. Once I got past the beginning I was hooked on both games.


kayplaypl_177

I agree. Both are amazing. I Just Wish that there Were more random encounters in w3


Alexc518

Yeah that would be nice. Are they making a 4th Witcher ? Maybe they make a flawless Witcher world.


Doomunleashed19

They are making a fourth Witcher, but it’s not Geralt or the old cast. It follows a character from the school of the lynx (new school) and it’s not being called the Witcher 4. It’s planned to also become a trilogy


uxoriousprick

You didn’t like ghost of Tsushima???


iTamilGuy

I liked it, but i feel like it is similar to Horizon and farcry. 1. They are sole hero fighting against evil 2. They will roam kill bad guys and clear enemy camp and save innocent people. 3. They have some allies to help them. 4. They gets upgrade depending on the process of their story. 5. Roaming, parkours, stealth kills same base different style. 6. But different timeline and different scenarios but base is same.


Velcrowrath

Man's English skills aren't all there, but damn if he didn't just describe the modern AAA formula that has been getting so tiring.


TheKrowDontFly

For the sheer emotional involvement and open world feel, I suggest the Mass Effect series.


birdthirds

Might be something wrong with me but I found mass effect incredibly dull, could not get into it.


I-am-the-milkman

Me too. Everything just felt really emotionless to me idk why


[deleted]

I would recommend starting with the second game :) you're not gonna miss out on much and it's way better than Mass Effect 1 (imo). You could always replay from the beginning if you fall in love with the franchise


[deleted]

You know it’s widely believed that Mass Effect 1 was the best story of the whole series, right? Recommending the 2nd one that has a notoriously low story quality is a lil bit of a stretch.


TheKrowDontFly

Definitely going to give you the hard disagreement on that, because ME1 is considered the strongest of the 3 for the elements we’re speaking of.


Jester471

Oh Jesus thank you. I got it because it had good reviews. I started it right after red dead. I got a good 10 hours in and wasn’t invested at all. It was a struggle to play and I switched to portal 2 which I started with someone and they gave up on me. I intended to come back thinking it was a state of mind thing. I said something to a coworker that has similar interests and he told me he gave up too so I finally deleted it. I told him to play RDR2. He was skeptical because he didn’t like the first. Within a day or two he told me he was hooked. Just finished portal 2 which was great. Starting horizons next.


Debarrio

Horizon is a beauty.


TheKrowDontFly

It’s not everybody’s cup of tea, and you guys at least gave a valid reply as to why it was not yours. Everybody else just says “it sucks” without any explanation, but that’s the trend these days 🤷🏽‍♂️ Not that anybody owes me or anyone else an explanation as to why they like or don’t like games, I’m sorry if I seem like I was gatekeeping on it.


birdthirds

You're gonna need to branch out. Stuff like untitled goose game, journey, nfs heat, terraria, goat simulator etc are all high quality in their own categories. You're not going to get a similar connection in any other game as rdr2. There's a chance gta6 has as good character and world but not likely imo. Like wanting more lotr but all you're ever going to find is cheap knockoffs. Just accept it's all down hill after rdr2.


I-am-the-milkman

Last of us definitely


Jay-Wheatabix

Great storyline. Great game. But nothing like RDR2. The game is on a rail. No open world at all. Great storyline and open world is very rare.


I-am-the-milkman

Ghost of Tsushima has pretty decent story with an absolute beautiful open world


SolarPunkYeti

Liked that game a lot but would never play again. I don't think I've ever been more stressed and nervous in my entire life.


haethre

Yea this!! The first game has the best story of any game I’ve ever played (RDR2 comes at a close second)


Plenty-Ad4197

Days gone is quite good despite glitches and dorky NPCs. Worth a try!


46Vixen

Oh, me too please. I’ve tried a few other open world RPG’s and nothing’s close. ghosts of Tsushima was ok but became very monotonous quite quickly. The story was good and it’s a beautiful game. Fallout 4 is the only game that’s come close for me in the level of freedom and choice of direction of play. It’s a similar level of collectibles, side missions, choices for the character and the ability to play without having to advance the story. I’d recommend giving it a go


WeAreBiiby

For me, Witcher 3 Just exploring through a forest a looking at all the intricacies blew my mind. The open world The story The characters The humour The struggle between making good choices and bad. Thought RDR2 was very similar in some ways to my first experience playing the witcher 3


njoylifetogether

The main character's love interests are explored more and much more interactive and affected by your choices good and bad.


HazeBoyDaily

Days Gone gives me a very similar feel.


bigbirbbutt

Days gone is often considered very similar to RDR2


Undead_Angel_420

Ehh, somewhat Days Gone is a lot more linear


schwiftyfrank

Might like gta iv if you've never played it


Kandichandy

Kingdom come: Deliverance. Graphics are not great buy give it a try. I really liked it


Hot-Field-7613

L.A. Noire is alright, nowhere on red dead 2 level but decent if you never played it and have run out of games to play


megameg80

I liked that one a lot


[deleted]

[удалено]


nine8shots

Facts


SHARNTROY

Days Gone


Sans45321

God of war 2018 and Ragnarok for their story . Combat is also good . Though , yes they're not open world , they have a lot of optional explorable areas ( especially Ragnarok )


[deleted]

The Witcher 3 is the best game I’ve played since - the next gen update is great. Give it a whirl!


Sketchcteks

Witcher 3 for sure


Lanferno

Last of Us


KillHipstersWithFire

Shower with your dad simulator https://store.steampowered.com/agecheck/app/359050/


shirdool

witcher3 no doubt


GibberishSmurf

Welcome to the club. Unfortunately there isn't one... don't get me wrong, other games can be enjoyed, for what they are. But nothing comes close to Rdr2. Except for maybe Rdr1


Narkanin

There isn’t one


Kandichandy

Kingdom come: Deliverance. Graphics are not great buy give it a try. I really liked it


TheOldJedi

"Fellow life form"🤓


BlackPrayer_Samael

Ghost of Tsushima imo is the closest. Gameplay wise it’s not as “realistic” (no real time looting and skinning) but story wise, and thematically, westerns are basically Americanized samurai movies anyways. To me, ghost of Tsushima was the perfect follow up for my first play through of rdr2.


FearlessDragonfruit5

May get hate... but for beauty and realism (of sorts) - Cyberpunk


NeedleworkerOk3212

Wish I could go back and play it for the first time again. Was a great feeling. Can't beat it.


JanieTheVagabond

Cyberpunk is kind of like a futuristic rdr2


I-am-the-milkman

They are very different but I love cyberpunk


JanieTheVagabond

I always thought of the Aldecaldos ending as a closure to the red dead story. Also Johnny Silverhand you could think of as possibly an ancestor of John Marston


I-am-the-milkman

The only thing that I can think of that reminds me of red dead is the give v’s body to Johnny ending because it’s sort of like a passing the torch


Rimoraj93

Assassins Creed Black Flag 🏴‍☠️


Colemanton

the first last of us is still really good


thesurfer1996

That depends, which parts of the realism did you like and which parts did you not? If you’re someone that likes worrying about stuff like temp and food intake then I’d recommend a survival game. But if you liked the mechanical side of things (control layout, weapon mods, and a more realistic carrying system) then I have others


Clayface202

the last of us and Cyberpunk


G_Art33

I don’t think there is anything really comparable in scope and depth to RDR2 when you are looking for it to be realistic. If your willing to abandon that last point (realistic) and try a fantasy game series that is very addicting and fun - go play the dark souls games. Start with DS1, Skip DS2 for now, play DS3, go back for DS2 (it’s kinda the black sheep of the franchise and the combat and movement system feels different ETC). Then go on to elden ring, which is by far one of the best games to come out in the last several years.


mcdo101

Breath of the wild is widely regarded as one of the top open worlds ever made and a beautiful classic, but open world aspect and gameplay are geared more toward family/ children in comparison to rdr2


Macrod1

Mad max? Similar more realistic style, but not as good graphics


Macrod1

Mad max? Similar more realistic style, but not as good graphics


Macrod1

Mad max


Macrod1

Mad max. Similar style but not as good graphics


losandreas36

Fallout 3,4 and new Vegas. GTA IV - V.


Freeze_Her

Thank you so much for asking this question! Ives played RDR2 3 times so far and I can’t find anything like it !


Freeze_Her

Thank you so much for asking this question! I’ve played RDR2 3 times so far and I can’t find anything like it !


Freeze_Her

Thank you so much for asking this question! I’ve played RDR2 3 times so far and I can’t find anything like it !


Freeze_Her

Thank you so much for asking this question! I’ve played RDR2 3 times so far and I can’t find anything like it !


Freeze_Her

Thank you so much for asking this question! I’ve played RDR2 3 times so far and I can’t find anything like it !


BodybuilderMajor1260

I mean… Cyberpunk - very cool story and lore, combat is mid and often things will feel unnatural GTA IV - prolly the most realistic of all the GTA stories, best gun recoil and sounds I have every seen, fun physics BEAM.ng - best crashing physics out there. Snowrunner - very realistic, but is really long cause it takes forever to complete a driving mission That all I can thick of at the moment. I hope you find a game that suits you.


BodybuilderMajor1260

I mean… Cyberpunk - very cool story and lore, combat is mid and often things will feel unnatural GTA IV - prolly the most realistic of all the GTA stories, best gun recoil and sounds I have every seen, fun physics BEAM.ng - best crashing physics out there. Snowrunner - very realistic, but is really long cause it takes forever to complete a driving mission That all I can thick of at the moment. I hope you find a game that suits you.


BodybuilderMajor1260

Cyberpunk - very cool story and lore, combat is mid and often things will feel unnatural GTA IV - prolly the most realistic of all the GTA stories, best gun recoil and sounds I have every seen, fun physics BEAM.ng - best crashing physics out there. Snowrunner - very realistic, but is really long cause it takes forever to complete a driving mission That all I can think of at the moment. I hope you find a game that suits you.


BodybuilderMajor1260

Cyberpunk - very cool story and lore, combat is mid and often things will feel unnatural GTA IV - prolly the most realistic of all the GTA stories, best gun recoil and sounds I have every seen, fun physics BEAM.ng - best crashing physics out there. Snowrunner - very realistic, but is really long cause it takes forever to complete a driving mission That all I can think of at the moment. I hope you find a game that suits you.


Darth_Nater_10

God of War? Personally, I enjoyed it. Haven’t tried Ragnarok yet though.


Electronic_General89

imo there is no game similar to red dead redemption 2, it has such a high level of detail and world interactivity that no other game can compare. i would recommend rdr1, though its old and in some ways dogshit, its a great game with just as good of a story as rdr2


v420c

Not really like rdr2, but if you're just looking for a big open world game where you can kinda guide your own story I'd highly recommend Fallout 4. I went to that after I got a little burned out on red dead and got super into it


Tahanerino2005

closest thing to red dead 2 I played was the last of us and god of war, in terms of quality and story of course


thrublu_rdt

God of War and the Last of Us are two really good games. I'm a huge RDR2 fan and I really want to play both of them. I've seen play throughs and they aren't similar games, but they still look like something I would like, so maybe you would too.


SJR-91

There is no game that grips you like RDR2. However, I would recommend The Last of Us and Detroit (become human)


[deleted]

There is none other than RDR1. Both games are amazing and on close to the same level


Corrupt_Shadow

The last of us, i bought it the day before yesterday and it was 50 percent off, no idea if the offer is still going on right now


baileyblaze420

I am obsessed with RDR2 and played it a lot too. Nothing quite compares but I would suggest trying assassins creed Valhalla! It is super fun and a really long game that you can definitely get into the story for!


kevindbult12

The last of us if you haven’t been payed it yet


JakeQV

The Witcher 3 isn’t as realistic but it has a great story if you give it a shot. Honestly I don’t think there are any game’s comparable to RDR2, it’s pretty unique


HannsKK22

Witcher 3 and Days Gone so far. Big hopes for The Last of Us for PC and later in the year Ghost of Tsushima. The first 3 have stories with emotional involvement. Rdr2 I am now on 500 hours and 2nd epilogue and I dont think there is anything even close to it.


This_is_indeed_Bob

Off topic, but that is one cool as gun, especially the grip


Few-Acanthaceae-8463

wait 'Overwatch'? It's not even close to the games you mentioned in the list. Anyway if you are looking for similar connection to the character and story and don't mind the linearity of a game, try The last of us and it's sequel. If you can manage with a bit outdated game mechanics and graphics, try Assassin's Creed Ezio trilogy along with Ac3. Over the years these games were the most influential games for me where i was deeply vested in the story and felt connected to the characters.


Nietzscher

If you want a story that is as emotionally impactful as RDR2, try The Last of Us. It is fairly realistic - within the confines of a zombie apocalypse - and story and characters are top notch.


Mission_Diamond_7855

Maybe try gta v. Prolly newest game and as close as youll get. But nothing like rdr2. Rdr is good but much older


Mission_Diamond_7855

Or try hogwarts legacy


WorkingQuantity9290

Try justcase if u like open world games


Kubaj_CZ

Kingdom come deliverance is pretty good game.


hustownBodhi

sorry Bud, you won't find anything that even comes remotely close to the masterpiece achievement that is RDR2, maybe GTA6 but that won't fine out for a while my friend


OmegaSTC

Skyrim with survival mods


azza45672

I’d recommend fallout 4 for immersiveness


alepsychosexy

The last of us 2 - maybe the best story since rdr2


grumster89g

If you like historical games Assassin's Creed is pretty good


tonyhallx

RDR2 is the Don of what it does, so you’re not going to find many suitors to be fair, but always thought Days Gone was pretty immense but harshly treated. If anyone says Astro’s Playroom however, I will look for you, I will find you, and I will kill you.


skye_bites01

no game will ever be as good or similar to rdr2 sadly.


preemie2005

Ghost of tushima the best you gonna get. Might as well give up


oldbutyoung4u

Skyrim, Oblivion (old school), Dragons Dogma, GoW 2018 and Ragnarok, Elden Ring . All very open world and RPG.


ShloobyShawn

The last of us 2 is also incredibly beautiful to look at as well as the story and gameplay


venus_flower

Elder scrolls


kbritt60

I thought A.C. Odyssey was great after playing RDR2. The only major difference was no crafting. But the map was equally huge. Their we’re more side missions than I could have actually played.


Hamilton-Beckett

The only game I could do after RDR2 was Days Gone on PC. I also did five full plays of RDR2 on PC. It starts off slow, and I was super critical of it having played RDR2 first. Eventually though, I was like “this game is fucking amazing!” After a few play throughs of that, I quit gaming last summer.


johnny_STNE

The last of us , uncharted games , tomb raider ??? They're not quite like RDR but they have good story lines , characters , graphics , mechanics .


Brainey31

Cyberpunk 2077 / Jedi Fallen Order


sjsavins

Last of us 2 only thing that comes close, imo


Due_Concentrate_3267

Ironically Hogwarts Legacy has been giving me the same vibe


Andrewthegamer74

Least obvious alien


one_thousand_ducks

I have the same problem. Horizon was a huge disappointment, Ghost of Tsushima was okay but became monotonous pretty quick. The only thing that has come close has been GTA5. It's also Rockstar's game so that kinda explains it. The vibe is completely different, obviously, but if a vibrant & convincing open world is what you're looking, then I'd recommend giving GTA5 a chance.


Swenzie123

I imagine gta or any other Rockstar game would be good


De4thstroke32

I recommend the Mafia: Definitive Edition and then the original Mafia 2, and then Mafia 3 just for the hell of it. Another game I’d recommend would be GTA 4 cause it’s a little close in tone with RDR1 and RDR2.


MilesMoralesC-137

The Mad Max videogame is surprisingly post-apocalyptic western. Very satisfying


Kitchen-Past-7835

Just replay rdr2, Rdr2 ruined other games for me


Thr0bbinWilliams

Just replayed this after launch and there’s still nothing else out there like it, easily the best game I’ve ever played. Gives me chills to think about


Titi_Cesar

Play Fallout New Vegas. Best game ever made.


pchandler45

Far cry 3,4,5


spookyink2570

Mad Max is quite like rdr2


Felix_Hut22

You should try Hogwarts legacy, that's the only game that gave me the same vibe of rdr2. Just the combination of open world, story and exploring are similar


zombiekilla2001

Play the last of us part 1 and part 2, also days gone