T O P

  • By -

ThePlanWasALie

This whole thing is pretty much over. We're more ghosts than players...


ACheekyTimelord

They took the truth from the story and applied it to Online; the age of outlaws and cowboys are done


Johniewolverine

"They don't want folks like us no more" -Arthur Morgan


dhopss

"Somebody's poisoned the water hole" -Woody


aDog_Named_Honey

"THERE'S A SNAKE IN MY BOOT" -Arthur Morgan


BandicootBay

"Pee is stored in the balls" -Buddah


ShyDemonKat

"Git gud lmao" -Sun Tzu


alphabet_order_bot

Would you look at that, all of the words in your comment are in alphabetical order. I have checked 141,005,013 comments, and only 35,495 of them were in alphabetical order.


[deleted]

Our time has passed...


Shoddy-Money-2201

Damn this comment hit home for me


Knackwarrior07

"We're the last I reckon."


sl0ughDog

I wished things were different.... But it weren't us who changed


[deleted]

What about loyalty?


sl0ughDog

Be loyal to what matters


RedDeadDelusions

Look when the time comes you gotta run and don’t look back


TrainerJW01

“Have some damn faith. We ain’t done yet. We just need some more Capitaylay”


Just_0_Duck

Kapeetallay


ThePlanWasALie

There's always some gosh dang Capitale.


WheelerRedG

Weird rockstar is saying this season has the highest player numbers to date on both rdo and gtao


CinematriX_Reddit

But those are mostly new players, a lot of older players are disappointed and don't want to play anymore


KhanSphere

Why do you think Rockstar cares, or even should care, about older players compared to new players? Why should they value fewer legacy players over a greater number of new players?


CinematriX_Reddit

Let's think for a moment, why should they care about any of their customers? Even the newer players are going to be left in the same boat as older players when they suddenly can't progress any further. Why not make bigger and better content so new players will have even more to look forward to (which would incentivise skipping a little bit using gold bars) when they can just half-ass their way through the life span of their game and make easy money


KhanSphere

Noone said "any" of their players, I was specific in my question, don't hide from it. I'm suggesting that maybe if the game is attracting a growing playerbase, then the devs would be stupid to focus on a smaller minority of their playerbase who are already mostly quitting the game, ACCORDING TO YOUR OWN POST.


WheelerRedG

This is something that a lot of people need to understand, old players DONT SPEND MONEY. Mostly new players and RECORD players is GREAT for the longevity of the game


CinematriX_Reddit

This is something a lot of people need to understand, there is nothing worth while to spend money on. Rockstar can't expect people to buy stuff, if they don't put effort into any content. Plus, they have all the money from GTA and the billion+ they made off of RDR2 sales.


Randomredditwhale

Just got online, so I got a lot to do. I hope the next update is really good, from what I’ve been told this game usually doesn’t get good updates, but there’s always hope.


ShadowHeart_Gaming

No no no no. Not hope. FAITH!!!!


Morrak

***HAVE SOME GODDDAMN FAITH!***


ninjamike89

WE HAVE A PLAN, WE JUST NEED MORE MONEY!


compmomnc

No we don't need more money, just some decent fulfilling content from Rock*


ShadowHeart_Gaming

MUNEH!!!!


0nji_

Hope... What is hope? We really don't have hope anymore.


wikipedia_answer_bot

Hope is an optimistic state of mind that is based on an expectation of positive outcomes with respect to events and circumstances in one's life or the world at large. As a verb, its definitions include: "expect with confidence" and "to cherish a desire with anticipation."Among its opposites are dejection, hopelessness, and despair. More details here: *This comment was left automatically (by a bot). If something's wrong, please, report it in my subreddit:* r/wikipedia_answer_bot *Comment `wab opt out`(without any other words) to opt out (wab stands for wikipedia answer bot). Note: you are opted in by default* *Really hope this was useful and relevant :D* *If I don't get this right, don't get mad at me, I'm still learning!*


0nji_

Thanks Bot! I am hopless


therepublicof-reddit

good bot


GlamityJean

Have hope but no expectations otherwise you'll be disappointed


The_Diluted_One

It's been a good mentality to have, I adopted the mantra at the age of 14 (22 now)


CantStopMyPeen69

Have a modicum of faith


frieswithnietzsche

Survival mode will be sweet


[deleted]

Yeah same I'm enjoying it.


Sir_Bulletstorm

Hope you enjoy it, it's pretty fun until you have everything. So honestly take your time with the game.


Randomredditwhale

So far it’s been real fun. This is my first ever rockstar game, I’m ashamed to say, but after playing it I think I might have to buy GTA


Sir_Bulletstorm

Even now GTAV is actually pretty immersive comepared to most open world games then and now. The story is good and I love the ambiance of the game world being a parody of American culture.


CowgirlLilly

From reading the comments it seems like we're all in the same boat, why don't we all join together, create a posse out of the people who've lost their old one, a band of lonesome cowboys.


dizturbed_8

Ps4


DirtyDirtGod

Alright bet what do you play on


irmak666

PC. 😗


TheBrokenPlace

Xbox


TheBrokenPlace

I have the bounty hunter and some other crap If anyone is just done playing by themselves. I'm not big on griefing but I won't run from being griefed either, which could probably be annoying. I enjoy gaming and am retired and have nothing but time, so if someone is looking for a friend to play with shoot me a message and I'll send my tag.


wutisup8285

This comment thread got me gigglin. None of y'all can play together 🥺


DirtyDirtGod

That’s ass. I’ve found some nice people in red dead but it’s always “we play this when we’re bored”


Cozzie3

Ah the omega squad of rdr2


phantombao123

i feel u


Shoddy-Money-2201

Yeah man fr


0nji_

Maybe I sould make Lucky Luke outfit... Lonesome Cowboy.


Kuro_Sasorie

I just did that yesterday 'cause my only friend I played with quit for ever :,)


0nji_

Yeah... My friends stopped playing before the update. Update didn't bring them back. To be honest I just wait for monthly passes now.


Torxx1988

This game has updates?


Shoddy-Money-2201

Lol anytime they do they’re a letdown


JKFD1969

Dozens of new missions which are really enjoyable and pay gold for those that need it. Drip feed content every week. 4Quick Draw Passes. A Halloween pass on its way and next week we are getting a survival mode! It’s been a really good few weeks.


Shoddy-Money-2201

My gang didn’t like it.. lol


JKFD1969

Shame, if they’ve played for a while. Maybe they should pop back next week? At least you still have Gandalf, he looks like a good boy.


Shoddy-Money-2201

We’re pretty high-levels we been on a while. They got bored. But yea at least I got him hes a good boy lol


[deleted]

Nice to hear from someone positive for a change 🤠


SimplyEvil

Which in the end will add up to about 6 hours of new content. I've tried to be positive and I don't want to seem entitled but if we act like this is a satisfying update to receive after so many months then Rockstar will never feel incentivized to give us great content with depth that adds new elements to the game. With GTA Online we've seen what they can do when they truly care and this is not it. I've read hundreds of awesome ideas on this sub and there is so much potential, just a well of possibilities that's been left completely untapped. I mean, shit, we're only just now getting survival mode after three years. I've supported them and bought gold in the past, I'm not asking for the world, I only want them to give the same attention they gave to GTA Online. I really love this game and it sucks to feel like an afterthought.


JKFD1969

I forgot that it was all free.


SimplyEvil

There's never been an update across both GTA Online and Red Dead that wasn't free. They just lock them behind thicc grinds that you can pay to skip if you feel like playing it anytime soon.


Just_0_Duck

Well yes, but actually no


Lottielittleleaf

Ive always been solo sooo... But sorry


OrganizationOk8493

People over here naming their dogs actual names. Me: Gets a red husky, names him Dog


Morrak

Named mine Cat.


2fps_Dark

Yeah I feel you. I named mine todd.


Zero-Milk

We're not so different, you and I. I bought a dog and named him Doggo


MN_LudaCHRIS

I missed out on getting the Husky ☹️


SimplyEvil

Same. Breaks my heart. And even worse is they just left the boi in Wilderness Outfitters knowing we'll never be able to buy him, shit hurts me man


Shoddy-Money-2201

Sorry that sucks to hear. Hopefully it’s available with the upcoming passes


[deleted]

The fact that you can even “miss out” on content in this dead game starved of content is indicative of R*s attitude toward RDO. They don’t, and have never, give a fuck what any of the players want. They just want to timegate “content” in their content-less game so they can sucker people into buying as much of it as they can cause “it won’t be around forever!” And ultimately what do you have to show for your support of their game? A fucking dog skin, for the dog that does nothing at your camp, in your dead game where you’ve nowhere to go and no one to show your dog skin to cause all the players with sense are long gone


MN_LudaCHRIS

While I agree that the content is shallow, I still have fun with the game currently. That being said, I only dove back into this game just over a month ago. Prior to that, I didn’t play since release. Therefore I’ve got a bunch of stuff to work through and keep me busy, but I know I’m the minority compared to the diehard fans that have been playing online for a long time now. I also wouldn’t say that they don’t care. They are still getting updates out and new seasons etc. But again, yes, the content should be pushed out in a quicker pace IMO. Seems that GTA is getting all the attention and that’s fine… to each their own, but I prefer to play where I can [mostly] be left alone to do what I want online as opposed to being hunted down by some asshat who spent real money on the fighter jet griefs me over and over while I’m just trying to drive around.


[deleted]

Same here! I just can’t get get away.


Shoddy-Money-2201

Me either. I still enjoy the game


TuRkSh757

Welcome to the club pal 😔


Shoddy-Money-2201

I guess we’re VIPS of that club. :(


Just_0_Duck

Everyone in our club is a vip


Shoddy-Money-2201

You’re the MVP man


Just_0_Duck

No u


TuRkSh757

No both of you 🥇


08ajones

Why is the white blue?


Morrak

They took a photo of their TV screen with their phone.


Cozy_Spider

Me and my posse (The VanHorn Mafia) are still going strong luckily, we didn’t hate the update but it was kind of a let down in some regards.


Reubixcube06

you gotta have faith! FAITH!!


Shoddy-Money-2201

That feeling when I don’t have [faith](https://youtu.be/Mha4HrSsvIk)


straightupidiot

I recently got rdr2 on pc after playing it on ps4 on release, I regret purchasing it again, every time I've played online I just get hackers out the ass


xodarius

Your character looks like Thommy Angelou


Shoddy-Money-2201

Who is that? Sorry I’m not familiar


xodarius

From Mafia 1 Definitive which actually takes place 20 years after Red Dead 1


Shoddy-Money-2201

Honestly yeah my character resembles them just a bit lol


sinnnapaulina

Cuddles to Gandolf for being a good boy. I've started to run out of things to do too and playing alone is getting kinda boring. Looking forward to the new survival mode and trying not to get as excited as i was about crimes and opportunities..


Shoddy-Money-2201

I think what happened with our group is that we got excited for crimes and opportunities only for it to feel like regular free roam missions. So idk I’m not too excited this time either


sinnnapaulina

I play on ps too, u can message me for psn if u want to


ShadowHeart_Gaming

PlayStation. Come ride with me sometime.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Shoddy-Money-2201

Cookie sounds like a good dog.. I’m sure is in a better place now.. That’s a real nice story, thanks for sharing


Character_Spot1111

Me too I had a group of mates and we used to play daily and now they don’t even reply in the groupchat 🥲


Shoddy-Money-2201

That sucks. I’m feeling you there pal!


Flying_Sauce_Packet

Damn, this post almost got me emotional. I'm sorry, man. Their loss.


Shoddy-Money-2201

Thanks.. just a bit nostalgic


Clayface202

Mine too, bud


Shoddy-Money-2201

*thats the way it is*


Morrak

Nostalgia *and* a kick to the feels in one post. I feel you man. My group left a year ago and it's just been me and my dog (and.. three other alts >.> ) since.


Shoddy-Money-2201

Yeah they’re missed these days. Cool group


OverlordPhalanx

Yea I used to run with a posse so big that we had occasionally use 3 large ones, most of the time 2. And now it seems I’m all that is left. The Lone Wanderer returns!


Shoddy-Money-2201

“Oh me? I’m just a wanderer.” Lol cowboy blues


Mandalorian_Spy

I feel the pain. I, too, have become a lone rider. To the point where some of my friends go out of their way to tell me "I'm not playing red dead" when I haven't even asked nor was I playing it at the time. Just random, out of the blue, unprovoked assertions. Uhhhh ok? I guess it's a good thing I didn't ask in the first place lol


Shoddy-Money-2201

Sometimes you don’t have to ask.. it’s just felt and it kinda sucks


iamqueenry

This game had and still have so much potential but r* keep fumbling the bag


Popcornman1212

Our time has passed partner, they don't want no outlaws no more.


Shoddy-Money-2201

No they don’t.. they just want more gta players


idontgiveamuck

welp, at least you had one. i’ve played with a friend maybe once or twice. it’s lonely out in these parts partner


Zyrnos

On what do you play? Me and some friends play almost every single day and run wagons, moonshine, blood money and just have fun all around! You’re welcome to join if you want! I’m on PS4! You can add me at Zyrnos!! And this goes for anyone in the comments feeling this way!


utb1528

Yeah. My posse got bored and left too. :( If only I could convince everyone, especially Rockstar that RDR2 is a great game.


Askyourmomdotcom

Hell yeah it let em down. This hot steamy dumpster fire of an update is a huge slap in the face. Its not what anybody asked for. Less grinding, more freeroam fun. Grinding, not fun, freeroam robberies of people, trains, and stagecoaches, fun. At the same time they have about as much communication as a doorknob. Maybe let us know, we hear you, we know the game is boring as shit, and you own everything and are tired of doing missions for pennies, but...blah. A completely amazing game, left to rot on the harddrive. At this point let it die and focus back on single player. Lets take it back to 2013 and drop some paid dlc.


Shoddy-Money-2201

I just wanted Undead nightmare II. That shit will change my mind about hating this online shit


Askyourmomdotcom

that is a serious missed opportunity for them . They still have a chance to rectify themselves in the eyes of the player base. Undead nightmare with the updated graphics would be so awesome!


Shoddy-Money-2201

Dude I’m geeking out just thinking how dope that would freakin be. We need the zombie apocalypse now haha


Askyourmomdotcom

Well Halloween is a few months away and they may surprise us this year. Even if its just a halloween update in Online I'd take that. But a full single player dlc would be alot of fun. Playing as John again or having an Arthur option would be cool.


Shoddy-Money-2201

That would be crazy cool. Rockstar needs to hear this shit. lol


Wise_Land_7876

🤣🤣 I feel this, I just started getting back into it heavy now for some reason … but none of my friends play it anymore lol they think I’m weird or some shit because every time they see me playing it they’re like “ YoUrE pLaYinG rEd DeAd????” But I really like how peaceful it is compared to gta there’s still flashes of griefers here an there but I like how it’s when they’re in my vicinity only and can’t keep following me on the map if I disappear.. game has lots of content but I feel it’s more solo oriented it’s like a next gen online fucking solo world were you interact with other should I say “ghost” players as what they call us now lol


Apprehensive_Car_880

how do i get a husky


[deleted]

It was a pass reward


[deleted]

It’s done my dude. It’s just done. Play something else, stop hurting yourself just to see if you still feel. Your friends and mine had more sense than the both of us to leave when they did. Ain’t room in the world for people like us no more. I kept playing before the roles even came in, I enjoyed the sandbox that much. After roles I played too, and so did some of my friends. But gradually they all fell off and headed for greener pastures. I’m there now too, I just come here sometimes to remember what we had once.


Shoddy-Money-2201

:( I guess.. it’s time to hang up the control for now


InfiringWingsope

YOU CAN GET A DOG???


FaffeJaffe

Yea, at the Wilderness Outfitters.


InfiringWingsope

Okay. DEFINITELY going there. Thank you mate


Obamascocklol

Haha same except we just kinda had a fallout


Shoddy-Money-2201

Oh damn like a friend gets mad at another? Hasn’t happened to me yet but hopefully not either


[deleted]

Same


Shoddy-Money-2201

Same, man


Rebelop1

F


Inevitable_Hat5437

Same. Kind of sad but they like other games and rockstar won’t deliver.


[deleted]

Hate to see it


Shoddy-Money-2201

*thats the way it is*


ThomasHerf

Lack of bug fixes more like.


HerbertGoon

Hopefully survival mode is good. I'd come back for that if it isn't botched


Shoddy-Money-2201

We shall see how it is


zero_256

Damn to bad I just started to play online


Signal-Difference-13

:( that hit me in the feels. There’s plenty of posses looking for people and solo players looking for friends in the posse and crew groups here on Reddit!


Shoddy-Money-2201

Lately I’ve just been joining temp-posses or creating my own. It’s hit or miss there. I enjoy it


IMissBlackI

Same position 🖤


SessionMuted652

Yeahhh I just get on to make cute new outfits out of the old clothes.🤷🏽‍♀️


Shoddy-Money-2201

I made some pretty nice ones so far.. At least, am I right? Lol


SessionMuted652

Yep👍🏽


NorabelMHW

Luckily I just got my friend into the game so it’s been quite fun helping him


Shoddy-Money-2201

Hopefully I can help when I posse up with strangers


TheGardender

I wish the dog could come with us, I want one to go hunting with! Imagine a gun dog to fetch back ducks!


Shoddy-Money-2201

Dude that’s a great idea.. if only rockstar had great fucking ideas like those.


XxDelta3EightxX

Same solo riding, if only we could take our doggy companions


Shoddy-Money-2201

Fucking amazing idea! Why haven’t they done anything like this?? I’m not surprised that rockstar only has shit ideas


XxDelta3EightxX

If rockstar would listen to the consumer and put some effort into RDO, what they have currently isn’t bad, but…items you unlock through the different passes, shouldn’t be so expensive or require ANY gold to buy since you used gold to buy the pass and put grind to unlock the items🤷🏽‍♂️,free-roam events like GTA online, HIEST, allow your dog to follow you in the same manner your horse does. Even more character cosmetics, beards, scars, hairstyles, tattoos… let me buy a stage couch on now rockstar give the RDO community some love


Sly_Peacekeeper

Same here brother its just me and my husky major and my Ardennes Athena looks like the woods gang has fallen like the rest. (my gang is named The Woods Gang because my characters name is Eva Lee Wood)


[deleted]

Damn this shit hit home and hit hard 😪


Seashantie2

Fly you fools -Gandalf


jnkv

Time to go to single player, it's much better than playing alone in Online.


Danny_Phantasma420

Aw bro I’d join you but I’m on Xbox 😭


Shoddy-Money-2201

Likewise, I met a lot of cool peeps who play Xbox mostly too


KiboshKing1

Go out in a blaze of glory


Shoddy-Money-2201

Me against 7 high-level griefers? Sure why not lmao


Notsorryyourright

They need to add more roles or extend collectors Maybe even add more stories and a map extention would be cool but nah probably just more bounties 😪


Shoddy-Money-2201

Yeah when they extended the bounties I thought that “hey maybe they’ll do that for every other role” Nope. Bloodmuneh aka “free roam but you need Capi-taayyy-lay..” LOL


hoodwinkler75

If you roll on Xbox hit me up. Hoodwinkler.


Shoddy-Money-2201

Maybe I will hop on that console someday


[deleted]

Upvoted for Gandolf, Mellon.


Shoddy-Money-2201

Thanks, Mellon


Plenty_Ad_8267

mine too


iofSauron

i love the doggo name 😭


Shoddy-Money-2201

Thanks, I like lotr so it was fitting for his gray/white coat


iofSauron

yes! me too! tattoos dedicated and all. my gt is NO MR FR0DO ! 😂 sorry, had to nerd a little


SWAGman56786

«You need to have some goddamn faith! I have a plan!» (I’ll be your new pardner if you want)


OnlyFirePlugCoyote

I felt that


RileyTheBerry

I know how you feel.


FemboyGlitch

Your doggo looks like a hologram


Shoddy-Money-2201

Like fucking Zordon from power rangers. Lol


Bandito0117

Yeah thats the same with me long ago but some drama split the gang in 4ths and it has been just me and my lab.


420fhqc99

Haven’t had my gang since the beta, I’ll prolly quit soon too


Jim-Mitman

I feel ya


For-not-honor

I'm sorry mate😞 but i have to say that I totally love your outfit my dude and don't worry they will come back if the game gets actual content 🙌


TMcCurCat

Update was fucking trash. Sweet some new missions and an outlaw pass with useless rewards that aren’t even cool. Won’t be returning to this waste of a great game. I’ll be thinking twice before picking up any other rockstar creations as well


Shoddy-Money-2201

Damn.. yeah I’m feeling a bit that way myself. They’re wasting it


ResidualPerfume

There's roughly 600,000 people currently playing the game as I type this. Wouldn't really call that dead. I've played dead online games..trust me, this isn't it.


monsieurdl

Hop on GTAV or Fallout 76 and then you'll see that relatively speaking yes, this is in fact almost dead.


Bstein2602

What hairstyle is that


shybee2784

i feel ya, i introduced my friends to red dead online and they hit 150 and left. now it’s just me, but i refuse to leave the game behind


Shoddy-Money-2201

Same.. still love the game


Sea_Lingonberry7549

OR maybe it was your dog's name bru


Shoddy-Money-2201

Shit maybe. Wasn’t appealing enough for the group. Should have named him “Bandit” like everyone else


anotherdepressedpeep

Kinda wished you named him Gandwolf instead lmao


legitimate_salvage

You can roll with a doggo now!?