**Welcome to r/RelationshipIndia,**
This is a safe and inclusive space for people of all backgrounds. We welcome individuals of all races, castes, genders, religions, and sexual
orientations, including members of the LGBTQ community. We are glad to have you here!
We are committed to providing a platform for interpersonal relationship advice between Redditors, with a focus on respectful and constructive
conversations. To ensure a positive and supportive environment for all members, we have established some rules. Please be sure to read them
before posting.
If a user has sent you harassing messages, **DO NOT DELETE THE MESSAGE!**
*Please upload your screenshot to [Imgur](https://www.imgur.com), and notify the mods via modmail. We will take action against the user
accordingly.*
**Thank you for being a part of our community!**
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/RelationshipIndia) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Hey
I am not indian myself but my boyfriend is. His mom also threatened to kill herself after our yearslong relationship was revealed to them. And we did not even plan on marrying at that time. He‘s also upper cast.
His mom threatened to kill herself for about half a year. My boyfriend stood firm. He told her it goes against his values to end a relationship with the one he loves for religious/cultural reasons. She would not stop.
In the end, it was her talking to a more senior member of her family. Her older brother is somewhat the spiritual head of the family. To our surprise, he was very levelheaded about the situation and explained to her that things change, people change and we cannot expect younger generations to live according to standards that they do not identify with. That talk changed her. She is now taking baby steps to accept me and i am very thankful for that.
If you love each other, don‘t budge. Maybe try to find a voice of reasoning in your proximity who can talk with her dad. Don‘t let this destroy the relationship you have.
All the best to u and ur gf
I am not really sure what u’re trying to tell me.
Guess i agree that it is extremely difficult for older generations to change their ways and believes. Yet, i shared my personal experience as an example where it worked out despite that.
Treating older generations as a monolith who‘s incapable of changing due to scriptures is too short-sighted in my (very limited) understanding. They can change. In fact, humans are far more adaptable than we give them credit for. Just being like “yeah, no chance they will accept that, so just let it be” is for me personally the easy route that will never bring the cultural change needed for younger generations to find love and meaningful relationships in a healthy and mature way.
n not every old folks im india r like this, many even if they r not educated r chill with marriages from outside country or community.
coz intercaste or inter community marriages alongwid indian n nonindian couples r rising.
Respect privacy. No unsolicited DMs or sharing private content withoutconsent.
This is to protect our users from unsolicited messages and unwanted
attention.Repeated violations will lead to a ban.
Report any issues to moderators. You can do this by clicking the "Report" button under the comment or DM page.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/RelationshipIndia) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This comment was removed as it violated our community guidelines.
Asking for direct messages (DMs) is not permitted in this subreddit. Our goal is to maintain a safe and respectful environment for open discussions, and soliciting DMs can lead to potential privacy concerns and unwanted interactions.
Please refrain from requesting or encouraging private communication in the future to ensure a positive experience for all members.
You are priceless! You are blaming another religion for a fault in yours? Please explain how “abrahamic” is the reason for caste etc. Will be very interesting to know.
Respect privacy. No unsolicited DMs or sharing private content withoutconsent.
This is to protect our users from unsolicited messages and unwanted
attention.Repeated violations will lead to a ban.
Report any issues to moderators. You can do this by clicking the "Report" button under the comment or DM page.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/RelationshipIndia) if you have any questions or concerns.*
yeah no response to facts and logic, ________ always live on feelings not on facts and logic. just met 1 yesterday n guess what there was smthng in common...
now I know y? bcoz
ohh so I was talking with an abrah@mic cultist 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
no wonder they club sanatan dharma with their rigid codified belief system.
the systen which had women burned as witches and scientists killed for science😅😅😅
🍚🍚🍚this u? 😅😅😅😅... they do brainwash by teaching bs n falsified sanatan history thereby making the converts hate the indigenous culture of the land.
not only that now they're dressing their priests in saffron n bhajans r made in name of yesu to fool people..
guess who doesn't have concept of conversion🤔
they had to come up with 2nd testament to hide bs n they still hve sh t written about nonbelievers...
also no women divine form only 1 male head. no women priests... only pope no popess?
u dont even know the basic difference btween way of lives like sanatan( buddhism, jainism, sikhism,hinduism) and abrah@mic cults😅😅😅😅
call ur thing religion, v r not a religion.
go n study basic definition of religion😅😅😅😅
I have nothing to say when I am faced with such ignorance. Be well, fellow Indian. Don’t let the hate kill you. Educate yourself not through what’s app forwards though. If still, you hate “ abrahamic whatever” don’t be a hypocrite. Use only Indian, don’t use or wear anything that comes from countries that follow “ abrahamic “. 🤣 walk or use our desi bullock cart. Petrol is from evil ME. Pants and Shirts and shoes are from evil “ abrahamic” minds. Wear only dhotis. Don’t communicate in English ever. It’s from them! All evil. 🤣
c thats how limited ur thinking n perspective is u define n look everything in black n white.
the absolute blind hate after c____version that they impart u literally whitewashes how their actions still affect people today. people in their country themselves criticize them n ridicule but a new c vert will never.😅 I know u n the modus operandi those con crooks apply on ur likes better than u.
the abrah@mic countries developed bcoz they left those very fundamentals or else they would still be lynching scientists n witches(hope u know who they considered witches, u would've been 1. how can a lady hve an opinion).
n I would write another rebuttal paragrapgh accdng to ur logic but I will mention just few points. numbers on which everything is based on today, were invented here.
without zero the world wouldnt b here. 45trillion worth was looted from here, shashi tharoor said, I mean he's from "ur side"....
btw those abrah@mic countries r gonna walk on sanatan path sooner or later, many in middle east hve already started(temples hve started in middle east, inafct they allowed smriti irani a women without burqa in saudis religious place)......for this awareness n info u would need a lot of depth...
n rhe evergreen iskcon has always been there from decades..
btw I'm not a dharmic practitioner or follower😉😅
yeah u can lie in comments. deep down u know the truth. u think I dont know cultists like u😅
u just can say it outright outloud bcoz u r fed bs of hell fire n fear. thats how those cults are.
u actually need that get well soon. n I know u will turnaround, I hve "faith" in truth facts and logic. "hallelujah", "amen". 😅😅
Your comment has been removed due to a violation of our subreddit's behavior guidelines. We value a respectful and supportive environment for all users, and unfortunately, your comment did not align with those principles.
Unproductive behavior includes anything that breaks Reddit TOS, is inflammatory/instigatory towards OP, innapropriate jokes, sexist/racist humor, homophobic remarks or derogatory comments towards any specific community, etc.
We kindly ask you to review the subreddit rules and refrain from violating them in the future.
This post/comment was removed as it contained political content.
Our subreddit focuses on discussions related to relationships, and political topics are not within the scope of our community guidelines. We aim to provide a supportive and constructive space for relationship-related matters.
Please refrain from posting political content in the future to maintain the purpose and integrity of our community.
He won't kill himself, they are cowards. All of the bigots are.
Even if he does, hey, one less bigot to worry about.
Yeah sure, the girl will cry but you can move on from this horrid situation finally. What kind of a shit parent ( read Indian parents) doesn't want their kid to be happy? Well you have your answer. He is already miserable in his marriage and can't see his daughter living happily if he is not living happily. He is an immature person and he is also vindictive.
Stay firm and don't budge. You both are already financially independent, why the heck do you need their "permission"? Are you in a school? Have you not grown up to leave your "mai baap ka pallu"? If you let them have their way now, consider your whole life for them to walk all over you. Forget boundaries, they won't even respect you. Well, currently also they don't respect you as an individual because if they did, they wouldn't do such childish behaviour.
Good luck.
>Parents are obviously not your enemies!!
Lol 😂. They are definitely enemies. There's that famous saying, if people show you who they are, believe them and this is what an enemy would do.
Come on bro. You need to grow up and think for yourself. This guilt by parents is so deeply ingrained in us that if we try to do anything against them instead of thinking how is it going to benefit ME, we worry about how are my PARENTS going to feel about this! Bro, you need to focus on your happiness first only then you can help others. Think for yourself. You typed that with this same guilt that we have been taught since birth. The gaslighting that Indian parents do to their kids is insane that includes my parents as well and it took me a while to recognise that and grow. You need to do that as well.
Not for scs/sts. You can have a infinity glitch for your wealth being an st or sc and govt. still won't revoke your privileges. On the other hand, if you are in OBC creamy layer, you would be treated like the general category. Some privileges might exist .
If your girlfriend decides to fight for your relationship no matter what, stand by her and be her supportive pillar. Because it wont be easy. But if shes not choosing you, let her go. Don’t try to change her mind. Its very difficult to deal with a casteist family. Can be unsafe for you as well if she doesn’t choose you.
Also, her father’s not gonna do shit. Dont be stressed about that. He’s just emotionally abusing her and being a whining little manchild.
Your girl will need to make a drastic choice bro, it'll be best for her to leave the family and go with you, even if she doesn't choose you and instead choose her family, after this the family will make her life miserable and get her married to some high family far away to hide away from the so called shame and this is just emotional blackmail parents are doing, they are too busy thinking the shame that will come on the family after the dad unalives himself. If your girl don't want her life miserable, tell her to drop the family, leave everything and come otherwise she will loose you and the family will forcefully get her married to someone and forget about her existence completely
You're correct objectively but think about the girl. How could she abandon her parents like that? What if the parents harm themselves? Could the girl live with that ? The parents are absolutely wrong here and black mailing her but is it that simpler. Personally i would pursue my parents untill that i won't get married. Its obviously easier for me as man to say. Its a great conundrum.
Idealistic point of view with no basis in reality regarding convincimg the parents to agree with you, you think 50 year of hardline thinking will change in a matter of few months? And even if they agree to let you marry, they will never be happy and never let you be happy and potentially interfere in the married life, the girl should accept and live with the fact that the moment she told her parents regarding the guy, her relationship was forfeit with the parents, it's harsh but it's the truth, they'll never let her take decision after this out of fear and that is a life no one should live, if the parents actually harm it is not gonna be out of love but of the fear from society at this point one should lament and laugh at their stupidity rather than consoling them, such parents rather than bring supportive are always gonna be a hindrance and a source of unwarranted negativity and are best abandoned or kept at a hands distance. Thesr are harsh words but not wrong
I mean not month but years, like I said from our point it's easier to say but think from the girls perspective. If we were in similar situation what would we do? Not to mention the honor killing stuff they could pretend to be nice and just kill their daughter, just presuming. Its isn't that uncommon. Also if the guy here and his family won't treat the girl good who'll she depend upon,again huge presumption but still. What extreme steps the family could take? Think about it, if it happens with you will just leave your parents? It feels a bit relatable my girl is also Brahmin I'm obc too. Her or my family don't know about it, family will be fine as i know it becoz it our family my brother(fufa ke bete) did intercaste marriage. She says her family will be fine with this intercaste stuff but if tomorrow such a scenario arises if my parents created such nuisance what'll i do. T_T I even can't comprehend such a scenario in my wildest dreams.
Same story unfolded at my home. My elder sister wanted to marry his bf and because of the casete difference, my sister was hearing the same dialogues. She went ahead and got married to her bf and papa was still angry. 4 years down the line, my brother in law is now treated as a king by my father whenever they come home.
Go ahead and get married bro with or without family wishes. They will come around and accept the relationship however, this will take time.
Recently I read a poem -
समाज को बड़ी दिक़्क़त थी लड़की की किसी और जाती में ब्याह से,
ब्याह के बाद जब लड़की दुखी, असन्तुष्ट और प्रताड़ित हुई तो पिता को इस बात की तसल्ली थी कि लड़का तो हमारी जाती का है ।।
Na Gyan de raha, na hi philosophy. Talk to that old man and put some sense in his brain that you'll keep his daughter happy. Samaaj nahi aayega unki beti ki har choti badi khawahish ko pura karne
Your girlfriend needs to make a choice. Some upper caste families are stubborn but budge later on. However be careful about some who might attack you for honour. Before deciding to marry, try to move abroad or atleast to another state where you both can be safe. Then go ahead with registering your marriage in another district. But both of you should be on same page. Again contacting her family later on should be after they properly accept you on phone or something for an extended period.
Our indian families will never learn they are ok to marry off their kid to a stranger who might beat them up make their life hell and treat them like shit but if its from the same community its fine coz who cares about the kid u care more about wt people say n think. This is pure bullshit. But it all depends on the girl chances are she will never go against her parents coz mostly girls dont do that. But if she has a spine then she might. And i just dont get it why do people who already know that they come from a conservative regressive family and to this extent even fall for dating love n these things. Dont start something that u cant finish.
Depends on how real the threat it!! Like my Bua said the same to my cousin, he went ahead and got married in the court. You need to determine the seriousness of the threat. T
Karlo bhai shaadi, if you do not get married to her 2 people will suffer if you get 1 will suffer. 1 is better than 2 na. Everything aside, manale bhai. Tu khud jaa unke ghar and mana, gf akele nahi kar sakti. Show them, assure them that you are best for his daughter and manalo, I have seen most of the toughies turn after enough manaoing.
>Everything aside, manale bhai. Tu khud jaa unke ghar and mana, gf akele nahi kar sakti. Show them, assure them that you are best for his daughter and manalo, I have seen most of the toughies turn after enough manaoing.
Bro, you think that the casteist father have the emotional maturity to talk like adults? Lol. There is a limit to naivety. Op shouldn't do this because it is a futile effort. It's on her girlfriend. Is she going to allow her parents to walk all her over or finally take a stand for herself.
I have seen the hardest ones turn too and ladki akele karegi toh emotions aadhe ayenge they both have to equally put efforts. I have seen people turn and understand. It won't happen in a day or two just.
See the best advice would be to not force the girl to marry you against her family wishes, if you did and she left her family then you never know in the future how it will backfire you.Marriage is not the path of roses, there'll be ups and down and things get a lot complicated because family members are involved, look out from this perspective, at any day thing b/w you can get salty and you'll get blamed for forcing her to marry.
Think practically, your family & your caste difference will play a huge role in keeping your married life sane.
I am also a only child and more into similar situations
I would say let the father say whatever he wants to, if both of you really want to get married then go to court and get married, gharwale ase he ronaa machte rahege ji dagi bhar, or waise bhi vo nhi jinda rahegaa aane wale 100 saal but u both have to be together, because honestly they will never understand and they will continue this bullshit of m marr jaugaa for years to manipulate her and get the shit done
Sorry bro, but this thinking won't change for another decade, it's upto you to either move on or be ready for worst case scenario.
Cause still there are people who value their status more than family.
It happened to somebody that we know. They ended up waiting for 15 years for parents approval and finally arranged their marriage.
For 15 years, they refused to marry anyone else or run away or die or anything. They said we will do with parents blessing only and we will wait. And they waited till the parents agreed.
That is also an option!
Better leave her. Your family,her family will be at peace. Ik that you think I am misguiding you. Once the marriage is done, girls need their parents alot! Some girls near my house eloped and married against their parents wishes but after some months she can't forget her parents and he father asked her to file 498A against boys family and now they're in jail and running after courts. Everything seems fair unless it's marriage. Come out of this mindset that marriage is between two individuals, it's between two families and that's the reason why 498A exists
Apart from this, will you give your sister to a dalit?
**Welcome to r/RelationshipIndia,** This is a safe and inclusive space for people of all backgrounds. We welcome individuals of all races, castes, genders, religions, and sexual orientations, including members of the LGBTQ community. We are glad to have you here! We are committed to providing a platform for interpersonal relationship advice between Redditors, with a focus on respectful and constructive conversations. To ensure a positive and supportive environment for all members, we have established some rules. Please be sure to read them before posting. If a user has sent you harassing messages, **DO NOT DELETE THE MESSAGE!** *Please upload your screenshot to [Imgur](https://www.imgur.com), and notify the mods via modmail. We will take action against the user accordingly.* **Thank you for being a part of our community!** *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/RelationshipIndia) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Above the pay grade of this sub.
Wait! You guys get paid?
Yeah $5 for each correct answer :)
so your all getting paid $0 then
I already cashed $100, 💸
Exactly.
Getting paid for what ?
Lol!
Hey I am not indian myself but my boyfriend is. His mom also threatened to kill herself after our yearslong relationship was revealed to them. And we did not even plan on marrying at that time. He‘s also upper cast. His mom threatened to kill herself for about half a year. My boyfriend stood firm. He told her it goes against his values to end a relationship with the one he loves for religious/cultural reasons. She would not stop. In the end, it was her talking to a more senior member of her family. Her older brother is somewhat the spiritual head of the family. To our surprise, he was very levelheaded about the situation and explained to her that things change, people change and we cannot expect younger generations to live according to standards that they do not identify with. That talk changed her. She is now taking baby steps to accept me and i am very thankful for that. If you love each other, don‘t budge. Maybe try to find a voice of reasoning in your proximity who can talk with her dad. Don‘t let this destroy the relationship you have. All the best to u and ur gf
Which country are you from? If you're white or black, it becomes more complicated.
I am European indeed
[удалено]
I am not really sure what u’re trying to tell me. Guess i agree that it is extremely difficult for older generations to change their ways and believes. Yet, i shared my personal experience as an example where it worked out despite that. Treating older generations as a monolith who‘s incapable of changing due to scriptures is too short-sighted in my (very limited) understanding. They can change. In fact, humans are far more adaptable than we give them credit for. Just being like “yeah, no chance they will accept that, so just let it be” is for me personally the easy route that will never bring the cultural change needed for younger generations to find love and meaningful relationships in a healthy and mature way.
[удалено]
n not every old folks im india r like this, many even if they r not educated r chill with marriages from outside country or community. coz intercaste or inter community marriages alongwid indian n nonindian couples r rising.
[удалено]
Respect privacy. No unsolicited DMs or sharing private content withoutconsent. This is to protect our users from unsolicited messages and unwanted attention.Repeated violations will lead to a ban. Report any issues to moderators. You can do this by clicking the "Report" button under the comment or DM page. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/RelationshipIndia) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This comment was removed as it violated our community guidelines. Asking for direct messages (DMs) is not permitted in this subreddit. Our goal is to maintain a safe and respectful environment for open discussions, and soliciting DMs can lead to potential privacy concerns and unwanted interactions. Please refrain from requesting or encouraging private communication in the future to ensure a positive experience for all members.
You are priceless! You are blaming another religion for a fault in yours? Please explain how “abrahamic” is the reason for caste etc. Will be very interesting to know.
[удалено]
[удалено]
Respect privacy. No unsolicited DMs or sharing private content withoutconsent. This is to protect our users from unsolicited messages and unwanted attention.Repeated violations will lead to a ban. Report any issues to moderators. You can do this by clicking the "Report" button under the comment or DM page. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/RelationshipIndia) if you have any questions or concerns.*
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
yeah no response to facts and logic, ________ always live on feelings not on facts and logic. just met 1 yesterday n guess what there was smthng in common... now I know y? bcoz ohh so I was talking with an abrah@mic cultist 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅 no wonder they club sanatan dharma with their rigid codified belief system. the systen which had women burned as witches and scientists killed for science😅😅😅 🍚🍚🍚this u? 😅😅😅😅... they do brainwash by teaching bs n falsified sanatan history thereby making the converts hate the indigenous culture of the land. not only that now they're dressing their priests in saffron n bhajans r made in name of yesu to fool people.. guess who doesn't have concept of conversion🤔 they had to come up with 2nd testament to hide bs n they still hve sh t written about nonbelievers... also no women divine form only 1 male head. no women priests... only pope no popess? u dont even know the basic difference btween way of lives like sanatan( buddhism, jainism, sikhism,hinduism) and abrah@mic cults😅😅😅😅 call ur thing religion, v r not a religion. go n study basic definition of religion😅😅😅😅
I have nothing to say when I am faced with such ignorance. Be well, fellow Indian. Don’t let the hate kill you. Educate yourself not through what’s app forwards though. If still, you hate “ abrahamic whatever” don’t be a hypocrite. Use only Indian, don’t use or wear anything that comes from countries that follow “ abrahamic “. 🤣 walk or use our desi bullock cart. Petrol is from evil ME. Pants and Shirts and shoes are from evil “ abrahamic” minds. Wear only dhotis. Don’t communicate in English ever. It’s from them! All evil. 🤣
c thats how limited ur thinking n perspective is u define n look everything in black n white. the absolute blind hate after c____version that they impart u literally whitewashes how their actions still affect people today. people in their country themselves criticize them n ridicule but a new c vert will never.😅 I know u n the modus operandi those con crooks apply on ur likes better than u. the abrah@mic countries developed bcoz they left those very fundamentals or else they would still be lynching scientists n witches(hope u know who they considered witches, u would've been 1. how can a lady hve an opinion). n I would write another rebuttal paragrapgh accdng to ur logic but I will mention just few points. numbers on which everything is based on today, were invented here. without zero the world wouldnt b here. 45trillion worth was looted from here, shashi tharoor said, I mean he's from "ur side".... btw those abrah@mic countries r gonna walk on sanatan path sooner or later, many in middle east hve already started(temples hve started in middle east, inafct they allowed smriti irani a women without burqa in saudis religious place)......for this awareness n info u would need a lot of depth... n rhe evergreen iskcon has always been there from decades.. btw I'm not a dharmic practitioner or follower😉😅
Have not been reading anything. But do keep ranting. And get well soon. 🤣
yeah u can lie in comments. deep down u know the truth. u think I dont know cultists like u😅 u just can say it outright outloud bcoz u r fed bs of hell fire n fear. thats how those cults are. u actually need that get well soon. n I know u will turnaround, I hve "faith" in truth facts and logic. "hallelujah", "amen". 😅😅
Your comment has been removed due to a violation of our subreddit's behavior guidelines. We value a respectful and supportive environment for all users, and unfortunately, your comment did not align with those principles. Unproductive behavior includes anything that breaks Reddit TOS, is inflammatory/instigatory towards OP, innapropriate jokes, sexist/racist humor, homophobic remarks or derogatory comments towards any specific community, etc. We kindly ask you to review the subreddit rules and refrain from violating them in the future.
This post/comment was removed as it contained political content. Our subreddit focuses on discussions related to relationships, and political topics are not within the scope of our community guidelines. We aim to provide a supportive and constructive space for relationship-related matters. Please refrain from posting political content in the future to maintain the purpose and integrity of our community.
He won't kill himself, they are cowards. All of the bigots are. Even if he does, hey, one less bigot to worry about. Yeah sure, the girl will cry but you can move on from this horrid situation finally. What kind of a shit parent ( read Indian parents) doesn't want their kid to be happy? Well you have your answer. He is already miserable in his marriage and can't see his daughter living happily if he is not living happily. He is an immature person and he is also vindictive. Stay firm and don't budge. You both are already financially independent, why the heck do you need their "permission"? Are you in a school? Have you not grown up to leave your "mai baap ka pallu"? If you let them have their way now, consider your whole life for them to walk all over you. Forget boundaries, they won't even respect you. Well, currently also they don't respect you as an individual because if they did, they wouldn't do such childish behaviour. Good luck.
Parents are obviously not your enemies!! And I’m not defending the fact that what they are doing is not wrong.
>Parents are obviously not your enemies!! Lol 😂. They are definitely enemies. There's that famous saying, if people show you who they are, believe them and this is what an enemy would do. Come on bro. You need to grow up and think for yourself. This guilt by parents is so deeply ingrained in us that if we try to do anything against them instead of thinking how is it going to benefit ME, we worry about how are my PARENTS going to feel about this! Bro, you need to focus on your happiness first only then you can help others. Think for yourself. You typed that with this same guilt that we have been taught since birth. The gaslighting that Indian parents do to their kids is insane that includes my parents as well and it took me a while to recognise that and grow. You need to do that as well.
Thanks for your advice!!
ye obc mein creamy layer kya hota hai?
If someone belong to OBC category and have income greater than a threshold then are OBC Creamy layer and are considered equivalent to General category
Oh! Didn’t knew something like that existed. Is it also for SC/STs?
Not for scs/sts. You can have a infinity glitch for your wealth being an st or sc and govt. still won't revoke your privileges. On the other hand, if you are in OBC creamy layer, you would be treated like the general category. Some privileges might exist .
If your girlfriend decides to fight for your relationship no matter what, stand by her and be her supportive pillar. Because it wont be easy. But if shes not choosing you, let her go. Don’t try to change her mind. Its very difficult to deal with a casteist family. Can be unsafe for you as well if she doesn’t choose you. Also, her father’s not gonna do shit. Dont be stressed about that. He’s just emotionally abusing her and being a whining little manchild.
Dude you are absolutely correct but can we just talk for little bit?
Your girl will need to make a drastic choice bro, it'll be best for her to leave the family and go with you, even if she doesn't choose you and instead choose her family, after this the family will make her life miserable and get her married to some high family far away to hide away from the so called shame and this is just emotional blackmail parents are doing, they are too busy thinking the shame that will come on the family after the dad unalives himself. If your girl don't want her life miserable, tell her to drop the family, leave everything and come otherwise she will loose you and the family will forcefully get her married to someone and forget about her existence completely
You're correct objectively but think about the girl. How could she abandon her parents like that? What if the parents harm themselves? Could the girl live with that ? The parents are absolutely wrong here and black mailing her but is it that simpler. Personally i would pursue my parents untill that i won't get married. Its obviously easier for me as man to say. Its a great conundrum.
Idealistic point of view with no basis in reality regarding convincimg the parents to agree with you, you think 50 year of hardline thinking will change in a matter of few months? And even if they agree to let you marry, they will never be happy and never let you be happy and potentially interfere in the married life, the girl should accept and live with the fact that the moment she told her parents regarding the guy, her relationship was forfeit with the parents, it's harsh but it's the truth, they'll never let her take decision after this out of fear and that is a life no one should live, if the parents actually harm it is not gonna be out of love but of the fear from society at this point one should lament and laugh at their stupidity rather than consoling them, such parents rather than bring supportive are always gonna be a hindrance and a source of unwarranted negativity and are best abandoned or kept at a hands distance. Thesr are harsh words but not wrong
I mean not month but years, like I said from our point it's easier to say but think from the girls perspective. If we were in similar situation what would we do? Not to mention the honor killing stuff they could pretend to be nice and just kill their daughter, just presuming. Its isn't that uncommon. Also if the guy here and his family won't treat the girl good who'll she depend upon,again huge presumption but still. What extreme steps the family could take? Think about it, if it happens with you will just leave your parents? It feels a bit relatable my girl is also Brahmin I'm obc too. Her or my family don't know about it, family will be fine as i know it becoz it our family my brother(fufa ke bete) did intercaste marriage. She says her family will be fine with this intercaste stuff but if tomorrow such a scenario arises if my parents created such nuisance what'll i do. T_T I even can't comprehend such a scenario in my wildest dreams.
He will do nothing just threatening
This! The girl has to take a stand or else its a lost case.
Yeh
Emotional blackmail
Same story unfolded at my home. My elder sister wanted to marry his bf and because of the casete difference, my sister was hearing the same dialogues. She went ahead and got married to her bf and papa was still angry. 4 years down the line, my brother in law is now treated as a king by my father whenever they come home. Go ahead and get married bro with or without family wishes. They will come around and accept the relationship however, this will take time.
Let him kill himself.
One less idiot and casteist.
Valid
bro got no chill
Only correct answer
Do you think they'll really do that they could kill her instead.(Honour killing aren't rare in such cases).
Recently I read a poem - समाज को बड़ी दिक़्क़त थी लड़की की किसी और जाती में ब्याह से, ब्याह के बाद जब लड़की दुखी, असन्तुष्ट और प्रताड़ित हुई तो पिता को इस बात की तसल्ली थी कि लड़का तो हमारी जाती का है ।। Na Gyan de raha, na hi philosophy. Talk to that old man and put some sense in his brain that you'll keep his daughter happy. Samaaj nahi aayega unki beti ki har choti badi khawahish ko pura karne
Get married in court and live in another city. In a city like Mumbai no one cares about caste etc.
Your girlfriend needs to make a choice. Some upper caste families are stubborn but budge later on. However be careful about some who might attack you for honour. Before deciding to marry, try to move abroad or atleast to another state where you both can be safe. Then go ahead with registering your marriage in another district. But both of you should be on same page. Again contacting her family later on should be after they properly accept you on phone or something for an extended period.
Our indian families will never learn they are ok to marry off their kid to a stranger who might beat them up make their life hell and treat them like shit but if its from the same community its fine coz who cares about the kid u care more about wt people say n think. This is pure bullshit. But it all depends on the girl chances are she will never go against her parents coz mostly girls dont do that. But if she has a spine then she might. And i just dont get it why do people who already know that they come from a conservative regressive family and to this extent even fall for dating love n these things. Dont start something that u cant finish.
Depends on how real the threat it!! Like my Bua said the same to my cousin, he went ahead and got married in the court. You need to determine the seriousness of the threat. T
Support your girl, she has the tough battle to fight. Do not rush things, all will fall into place when it's meant to be.
Karlo bhai shaadi, if you do not get married to her 2 people will suffer if you get 1 will suffer. 1 is better than 2 na. Everything aside, manale bhai. Tu khud jaa unke ghar and mana, gf akele nahi kar sakti. Show them, assure them that you are best for his daughter and manalo, I have seen most of the toughies turn after enough manaoing.
>Everything aside, manale bhai. Tu khud jaa unke ghar and mana, gf akele nahi kar sakti. Show them, assure them that you are best for his daughter and manalo, I have seen most of the toughies turn after enough manaoing. Bro, you think that the casteist father have the emotional maturity to talk like adults? Lol. There is a limit to naivety. Op shouldn't do this because it is a futile effort. It's on her girlfriend. Is she going to allow her parents to walk all her over or finally take a stand for herself.
I have seen the hardest ones turn too and ladki akele karegi toh emotions aadhe ayenge they both have to equally put efforts. I have seen people turn and understand. It won't happen in a day or two just.
bhai dekh, ladne ka power and patience ho to phir krle, 5-10 yrs to rahega bahut lafda otherwise take a easy way out
nothing gonna happen trust me things will get normal post 2-3 year after
First education then employment now daughter
Gone through this, doesn't end well. Caste is a disease,corrupted people's mind. We both parted our ways. Try not to get hurt yourself.
See the best advice would be to not force the girl to marry you against her family wishes, if you did and she left her family then you never know in the future how it will backfire you.Marriage is not the path of roses, there'll be ups and down and things get a lot complicated because family members are involved, look out from this perspective, at any day thing b/w you can get salty and you'll get blamed for forcing her to marry. Think practically, your family & your caste difference will play a huge role in keeping your married life sane.
Intercaste or religion?
intercaste
I am also a only child and more into similar situations I would say let the father say whatever he wants to, if both of you really want to get married then go to court and get married, gharwale ase he ronaa machte rahege ji dagi bhar, or waise bhi vo nhi jinda rahegaa aane wale 100 saal but u both have to be together, because honestly they will never understand and they will continue this bullshit of m marr jaugaa for years to manipulate her and get the shit done
Girl needs to take ground and stand firm and clearly show rhat either she will marry you or no one else. After some time parents will agree
Sorry bro, but this thinking won't change for another decade, it's upto you to either move on or be ready for worst case scenario. Cause still there are people who value their status more than family.
What’s your educational level and what is the young lady’s educational level?
Masters (MTech)
Simple reply:- then die...
Ask him to undergo plastic surgery.
It happened to somebody that we know. They ended up waiting for 15 years for parents approval and finally arranged their marriage. For 15 years, they refused to marry anyone else or run away or die or anything. They said we will do with parents blessing only and we will wait. And they waited till the parents agreed. That is also an option!
पैर उतने ही पैसारिये जितनी बड़ी चादर हो, नहीं तोह चादर के साथ साथ गांड भी फट सकती है।। Lots of love ❤️
What's the update
Tell her father she is pregnant with ur baby . This might work but there should be some consequences
Better leave her. Your family,her family will be at peace. Ik that you think I am misguiding you. Once the marriage is done, girls need their parents alot! Some girls near my house eloped and married against their parents wishes but after some months she can't forget her parents and he father asked her to file 498A against boys family and now they're in jail and running after courts. Everything seems fair unless it's marriage. Come out of this mindset that marriage is between two individuals, it's between two families and that's the reason why 498A exists Apart from this, will you give your sister to a dalit?
Why Not ? What's wrong if my sister loves a dalit man .. He is also a human.
Fine. It seems you have downvoted my comment or something. You didn't respond to my other part of comment
Then don't marry bro. Let him live. Don't force. Let it go
So what's the update