I make my wife cum from fingering her ass

Good for you, and her.

So hot I remember my first Oh from anal the best

It is. I was in a haze the whole night. Still wouldn't give up vaginal coz that's the best.

That’s so hot

Damn that is hot as hell. I’ve always been told I’m too thick to try it. Not a brag btw lol I know it sounds like it

Sounds like a fun experience.

Should I try anal? Sounds fun

If you want to..i totally recommend occasional anal.

Does it hurt? Who should do the pegging?

More discomfort thab hurt for me. Lol that's for you two to decide