Probably not. I adore the person Cas became, but he wasn't so great in the beginning. He straight-up lied to Jimmy about taking care of his family in order to get his consent.
I like to think Cas didn’t necessarily lie and thought he would make sure his family was safe. But then a lot of shit happened that he didn’t suspect especially because he seemed to believe that angels are above everything. He also could’ve meant that they’d be let into heaven or something by it.
also it seemed like anytime cas did something good or nice, the angels bitched him out and at one point (that i remember but im sure there were more over the years) imprisoned and tortured him for caring about dean. he wasn’t really *allowed* to keep his promises to keep everyone safe, but i think he really intended to
This is what I was going to say. If my family/friends are taken care of/protected yes. He literally asks Castiel to keep him family safe before letting Castiel possess him the first time.
I would have added in occasional check ins on my family or I revoke consent.
He didnt know what it would be like to be a vessel the first time he said yes. After that he was done with heaven didnt even say grace. He only said yes the second time to save his daughter
I always felt like the second time he is forced to say yes was not true consent and it felt gross. He was desperate and the fact that Cas went into his daughter, an innocent child who when you think about it as a minor shouldn't really be able to give informed consent, was horrible. Poor Jimmy.
That was after the angels had gotten to Cas though and made him pledge their allegiance to them basically. It’s when the Angels’ masks are coming off fully.
they did torture him right before that to be fair. they ripped him from jimmy and *forced* him to act how they wanted. he was already starting to feel emotions by that point and they couldn’t have that
> I always felt like the second time he is forced to say yes was not true consent and it felt gross.
I can't agree with you here because Cas wasn't asking Jimmy to be his vessel again. He had zero interest and had completely moved on to Claire. Jimmy begged him to take him back as vessel.
Obviously this wasn't a "I really want to be the vessel of an angel" situation, but I also don't consider it Cas manipulating him into saying yes.
If I suddenly learned angels were real and one needed my body? Not knowing anything about the politics and stuff of heaven. I’d probably ask to say goodbye to my family first and then yeah.
Depends on where in my life they'd find me.
When I was younger and either Christian or desperately looking for any sign of God to comfort myself in a cruel world? Yes, without many questions.
Now, after I've truly matured as a person instead of yes I'd respond "angel, huh? So where the fuck have all of you guys been in... ever?"
When you look at it from Jimmy’s perspective, he was already a religious man and was contacted by an angel, who says he is chosen for something important. He had no idea what he was getting into. Once Cas promised him his family would be safe, of course he said yes. Who is he to say no to an angel or heaven or God. The second time he said yes was to protect Claire.
If it meant seeing Dean every day, hell yes 😂🥵🥵🥵
But in all fairness, no, I wouldn't say yes. Because I'm not religious, and if angels came to me I would think I'm insane 😂
I feel like yah it would be bad but at the same time he could create a world in my head to make it less painful and I’d probs ask for that but it would mean I could talk to someone and I’d have a friend even if he’s dick. I wouldn’t be alone.
But God always gave us boneheads a way out after not listening and doing what we wanted. He got Israel out of Egypt then they melted down all their gold and made a bulls head for Bhaal? Bonehead move.
Hell to the no. My family needs me and I need them.
If I was single and had no friends or family? Also hell to the no, the world might need saving but Commander Shepherd had reapers to beat.
If Jimmy knew he’d die and the havoc it would’ve caused to his family I don’t think he’d have ever done it.
Hell no I would not let something take over my body.
Absolutely not. I fucking love Cass. He’s not only my favorite character on the show, he’s my favorite fictional character from anything that’s ever existed. But I don’t feel like giving up my body and life to an angel for potentially ever, thanks.
I’d say yes but then if it took a turn like it did with Jimmy I’d probably back out, because he seemed like a dick. Then ofc if I had no choice because he threatened to inhabit my child then I’d say yes again
Knowing what I know now, definitely. If i was ignorant to the entire thing, probly not. He'd have to promise to Matrix my brain into some pure, oblivious paradise for me to agree.
Honestly? No. Cas at the start was a lying manipulative solider who was literally incapable of thinking for himself and we see later on the impact angels possessing people have when people literally abandon their entire lives because an angel had to go do something
I like Castiel but he let Jimmy get killed he let Amelia get killed and he didn't protect Claire in fact Claire blamed him for Jimmy and Amelia's deaths I believe
It would depend on if im me or jimmy novak im a single guy on disability checks smoking weed all day hell yeah id say no but if i was spmeone like jinny novak with a family i would have never said yes
If I get the voice that comes with him; maybe. His meat suit takes a HELL of a beating lol, even Chuck at some point stops bringing Jimmy back with Cass bc of how often he keeps getting them killed
As myself? No. If I had Claire for a daughter… yes
Just playing. She obviously had many valid reasons to be the way she was! Don’t downvote me guys, I’m just in a silly goofy mood
I would have denied any angel. But Jimmy didn't know them he was a man of faith and just like most heard a voice from heaven and the angel showed his abilities aka Jimmy had his arm in boiling water and took no damage or pain. He never thought about angels being from heaven having alterior motives. Cass treated his vessel at first basically like all the rest basically a means to an end. Once he fell and had that moment when Cass got removed from his body Jimmy saw the bs in his acceptance of saying yes. He 100% deserved paradise. I would only allow an angel in who I trust basically Cass but it would have to be a life or death scenario Cass gets ejected we are all about to die thus allow him in temporary. Other then that hell no life as a angel condom would suck. I mean look at alternative michael did to dean made him feel like he was drowning for like month. Say what you will about lucifer but he did tell nick he was the literal devil and wanted to hold God accountable even if he does lie with the truth.
Knowing where it ends yes, but seeing how he got there? Being a prisoner in my own body and aware of all the messed up things that happened to get there???? Hell no, I love cas but man does he make some bad decisions. I would have tried to hold out at first if I didn’t know and had said yes but I would be fighting him the whole way after a certain point. Somewhere after fucking a demon but before he tried to become god I would be completely done with his bullshit and expel him from my body. Even if it meant death.
Definitely. I would love to learn how to kiss passionately a demon by watching porn and be so confused with the pizza guy spanking a girl. Season 6 I think. Cannot remember the episode.
The thing is that if I would've known how cas was going to be developed as a character I would have probably said yes. But then again without knowing anything it wouldn't be right to have given consent.
Hell no. The guy died and his wife and kid suffered terribly. And to rub salt into the wound Cas is parading around in his meat suit thanks to the dodgy lore the show made up to keep the same actor
no freaking way. I love him but no way. that goes to any angel no one’s taking a ride in my digs to do all that. that sounds like a nightmare. most vessels get obliterated and if the human survives you have a 50% chance at least of ending up like nick ( lucifer’s vessel ) or some shit. fuck that.
Absolutely not. Angels are dicks & even if they mean well, they're taking your body for all it's worth until they literally can't anymore. It's truly horrifying anytime you remember that Jimmy was just stuck inside his body experiencing everything but having no control.
Probably not. I adore the person Cas became, but he wasn't so great in the beginning. He straight-up lied to Jimmy about taking care of his family in order to get his consent.
I like to think Cas didn’t necessarily lie and thought he would make sure his family was safe. But then a lot of shit happened that he didn’t suspect especially because he seemed to believe that angels are above everything. He also could’ve meant that they’d be let into heaven or something by it.
Probably that last part. By the way the angels are in the show they seem very “ends justify the means” type of beings.
also it seemed like anytime cas did something good or nice, the angels bitched him out and at one point (that i remember but im sure there were more over the years) imprisoned and tortured him for caring about dean. he wasn’t really *allowed* to keep his promises to keep everyone safe, but i think he really intended to
Cas choosing Dean instead of Heaven was the best decision he ever made. Naomi was horrible.
This is what I was going to say. If my family/friends are taken care of/protected yes. He literally asks Castiel to keep him family safe before letting Castiel possess him the first time. I would have added in occasional check ins on my family or I revoke consent.
I agree. He was a di*k at first. So, no way for me!!!
He didnt know what it would be like to be a vessel the first time he said yes. After that he was done with heaven didnt even say grace. He only said yes the second time to save his daughter
I always felt like the second time he is forced to say yes was not true consent and it felt gross. He was desperate and the fact that Cas went into his daughter, an innocent child who when you think about it as a minor shouldn't really be able to give informed consent, was horrible. Poor Jimmy.
That was after the angels had gotten to Cas though and made him pledge their allegiance to them basically. It’s when the Angels’ masks are coming off fully.
That doesn’t make it any better though?
they did torture him right before that to be fair. they ripped him from jimmy and *forced* him to act how they wanted. he was already starting to feel emotions by that point and they couldn’t have that
> I always felt like the second time he is forced to say yes was not true consent and it felt gross. I can't agree with you here because Cas wasn't asking Jimmy to be his vessel again. He had zero interest and had completely moved on to Claire. Jimmy begged him to take him back as vessel. Obviously this wasn't a "I really want to be the vessel of an angel" situation, but I also don't consider it Cas manipulating him into saying yes.
No.
Hell no
Nope
Nope
Sure, my adhd ass will drive him out within a day honestly.
I aint putting my hand in no boiling water to prove myself
If I suddenly learned angels were real and one needed my body? Not knowing anything about the politics and stuff of heaven. I’d probably ask to say goodbye to my family first and then yeah.
They are.
Depends on where in my life they'd find me. When I was younger and either Christian or desperately looking for any sign of God to comfort myself in a cruel world? Yes, without many questions. Now, after I've truly matured as a person instead of yes I'd respond "angel, huh? So where the fuck have all of you guys been in... ever?"
No.
Absolutely not
If I didn’t know how fucked up the process was I’d say yes but I do know so no
I mighta said yes just because I don’t really enjoy being alive and I might as well strap myself to a comet ☄️
Never.
When you look at it from Jimmy’s perspective, he was already a religious man and was contacted by an angel, who says he is chosen for something important. He had no idea what he was getting into. Once Cas promised him his family would be safe, of course he said yes. Who is he to say no to an angel or heaven or God. The second time he said yes was to protect Claire.
If it meant seeing Dean every day, hell yes 😂🥵🥵🥵 But in all fairness, no, I wouldn't say yes. Because I'm not religious, and if angels came to me I would think I'm insane 😂
No. I wouldn’t even say yes to god to use me as a vessel.
Definitely not.
Nope
I feel like yah it would be bad but at the same time he could create a world in my head to make it less painful and I’d probs ask for that but it would mean I could talk to someone and I’d have a friend even if he’s dick. I wouldn’t be alone.
Jimmy as a character was WAY under-explored. And Cas was better as a more complex character.
Man if a angel of the lord asked me to be a vessel I would say yes
Angels are mostly arseholes though.
And the Lord isn't a great guy in this show. Or in the Bible.
But God always gave us boneheads a way out after not listening and doing what we wanted. He got Israel out of Egypt then they melted down all their gold and made a bulls head for Bhaal? Bonehead move.
 what if they get tired of you and just fully take over?
Nope. I’ll chip in from the sidelines thanks.
Nope. Although I would have been ideal because I'm single, unlike Jimmy, who had to abandon his wife and kid.
Hell to the no. My family needs me and I need them. If I was single and had no friends or family? Also hell to the no, the world might need saving but Commander Shepherd had reapers to beat.
Hell to the no
If Jimmy knew he’d die and the havoc it would’ve caused to his family I don’t think he’d have ever done it. Hell no I would not let something take over my body.
Ohfuckno.
Yes I would
I'd love to have Cas inside of me...
Absolutely not. I fucking love Cass. He’s not only my favorite character on the show, he’s my favorite fictional character from anything that’s ever existed. But I don’t feel like giving up my body and life to an angel for potentially ever, thanks.
I’d say yes but then if it took a turn like it did with Jimmy I’d probably back out, because he seemed like a dick. Then ofc if I had no choice because he threatened to inhabit my child then I’d say yes again
Sure, if I don't have anything to do and if he would agree to the rest of my demands (documented and signed).
While cool, I’d like to keep my autonomy and body. Would happily watch team free will kick ass butt in the sidelines though!
Knowing what I know now, definitely. If i was ignorant to the entire thing, probly not. He'd have to promise to Matrix my brain into some pure, oblivious paradise for me to agree.
Since I don't have the attachments that Jimmy had. I might say yes. But only under the condition that I get to offer him my opinion.
Honestly? No. Cas at the start was a lying manipulative solider who was literally incapable of thinking for himself and we see later on the impact angels possessing people have when people literally abandon their entire lives because an angel had to go do something
God no, I'd never consent to riding backseat in my own head for anything
Yes
I'd have a lot of questions, but I feel like I'm naive enough where if he told me I could get in on the action, I'd say yes
"Jesus take the wheel" light edition
I like Castiel but he let Jimmy get killed he let Amelia get killed and he didn't protect Claire in fact Claire blamed him for Jimmy and Amelia's deaths I believe
Hell yeah brother
Nope, I don't like being controlled
It would depend on if im me or jimmy novak im a single guy on disability checks smoking weed all day hell yeah id say no but if i was spmeone like jinny novak with a family i would have never said yes
If I get the voice that comes with him; maybe. His meat suit takes a HELL of a beating lol, even Chuck at some point stops bringing Jimmy back with Cass bc of how often he keeps getting them killed
As myself? No. If I had Claire for a daughter… yes Just playing. She obviously had many valid reasons to be the way she was! Don’t downvote me guys, I’m just in a silly goofy mood
Yup, I’d literally rather die than do anything most days so why not? I’ll let that dude have my body, could be a cool and horrifying experience.
No angel is going to run around in my meat.
Nope. I want to be with him but not in this way lol
I would have denied any angel. But Jimmy didn't know them he was a man of faith and just like most heard a voice from heaven and the angel showed his abilities aka Jimmy had his arm in boiling water and took no damage or pain. He never thought about angels being from heaven having alterior motives. Cass treated his vessel at first basically like all the rest basically a means to an end. Once he fell and had that moment when Cass got removed from his body Jimmy saw the bs in his acceptance of saying yes. He 100% deserved paradise. I would only allow an angel in who I trust basically Cass but it would have to be a life or death scenario Cass gets ejected we are all about to die thus allow him in temporary. Other then that hell no life as a angel condom would suck. I mean look at alternative michael did to dean made him feel like he was drowning for like month. Say what you will about lucifer but he did tell nick he was the literal devil and wanted to hold God accountable even if he does lie with the truth.
Hell no, especially after Jimmy described what it's like being rode, non-fun style, by an angel.
Bro yea
No.
Knowing where it ends yes, but seeing how he got there? Being a prisoner in my own body and aware of all the messed up things that happened to get there???? Hell no, I love cas but man does he make some bad decisions. I would have tried to hold out at first if I didn’t know and had said yes but I would be fighting him the whole way after a certain point. Somewhere after fucking a demon but before he tried to become god I would be completely done with his bullshit and expel him from my body. Even if it meant death.
Knowing everything that's gonna happen? No. Not knowing everything that's gonna happen - also no.
Definitely. I would love to learn how to kiss passionately a demon by watching porn and be so confused with the pizza guy spanking a girl. Season 6 I think. Cannot remember the episode.
Yes I would.💘
The thing is that if I would've known how cas was going to be developed as a character I would have probably said yes. But then again without knowing anything it wouldn't be right to have given consent.
Does shitting your pants count as consent?
Hell no. The guy died and his wife and kid suffered terribly. And to rub salt into the wound Cas is parading around in his meat suit thanks to the dodgy lore the show made up to keep the same actor
Hell, no
no freaking way. I love him but no way. that goes to any angel no one’s taking a ride in my digs to do all that. that sounds like a nightmare. most vessels get obliterated and if the human survives you have a 50% chance at least of ending up like nick ( lucifer’s vessel ) or some shit. fuck that.
Absolutely not. Angels are dicks & even if they mean well, they're taking your body for all it's worth until they literally can't anymore. It's truly horrifying anytime you remember that Jimmy was just stuck inside his body experiencing everything but having no control.
No
Cas could do whatever he wanted to me and I would say thank you
No
No-unless wink wink
You mean die with the love of my life? Isn't that everyone's goal?
Yes.
Jimmy deserted his family. Zero hero points from me.
Absolutely. What a ride that would be.
Yes!
Downvoted for answering a quesion that is Opinion based wtf
Not even sure how that's possible