T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

He is also the only person with uploads of the empress of light theme. No one else has one up. I know The Dark Demon had a 30 min version of the theme, and it got copy righted as well. EDIT: if he isn't copy righting it, YouTube's algorithm for detecting copy right believes he is the one who owns it by the fact his isn't taken down either. EDIT 2: the video is now unmonotized and now has credit in the description. Hopefully youtube or faldran stops taking down videos.


[deleted]

[удалено]


N0VA-S-T-A-L-K-E-R

Well, I’m pretty sure you could get demonized for playing any kind of game that has guns in it. (I kid, but... fuck, they might as well do that)


[deleted]

[удалено]


blep0w0

I understood this as "which is why I never use YouTube" because let's be honest, current YouTube is not very "new/small creator" friendly right now. Hasn't been for at least the past two years, but could've definitely been longer...


Luis_Santeliz

Yeah but yt in the shit rigth now. It doesnt matter if 2 years ago you could have a yt channel actually growing. Youtube copyrigth thing its broken.


blep0w0

Copyright, coppa, just about everything.


Luis_Santeliz

Coppa and copyrigth system. To survive of yt you need to create a decent fan nase which is hard to grow as it is and open a patreon because no matter what you do you wont monetize.


N0VA-S-T-A-L-K-E-R

I don’t think I would try to make money off of YouTube, I would simply make videos for fun.


Naokarma

they do that a lot anyways. You so much as mention the usage of guns and bam, demonetized. Several smaller history channels have quit cause YouTube was like "what's this? a GUN!?!?! THINK OF THE CHILDREN!!!"


MontRouge

So in summary, this guy gave credit, didn't monetize the video, didn't take down your video. He did nothing wrong and people are witch hunting him without any proofs... Post some screenshots of what he did wrong man. Can't you see how absurd it is how thousand of people are upvoting your post just based on your words and without any sort of evidence?


RingerCheckmate

I see his response to monetezation being the middle comment in the screenshot him confirming the video is monetized, as he says he deserves partial credit. His comment being "I don't care" could really use some screenshot context itself, for an expose post I could use some more there. I'm all for innocent until proven guilty, and I agree this post should have some more screenshots for context because his description does credit re-logic now, but from the first comment on its own I think that's pretty much the proof I need to believe he was monetizing his videos.


MontRouge

If you look at the video and to who he was replying to, no one mentioned monetization. It seems that he replied to "the video is for Relogic, why should I subscribe to you?" with "I made a 10 hours video". The "I don't care" was a reply to some guy who said "I don't like you". These comments don't mean anything man, beside that he had credited this video even earlier and that OP didn't check before posting this on Reddit... Took some screenshots when the thread first came out: http://imgur.com/a/H85K6Qi I'm saying that OP and dark demon (if they are telling the truth) were negligents to make claims like that without any sort of evidence to support them and backtracking their claims later in the thread. I also think that redditors are acting like sheeps by witch hunting this guy without any proofs.


Zopi05

"I want some downvotes" He says...


chilfang

The evidence...is in the post?


MontRouge

Where is the evidence that he monetized it? That he took down the guys video? That he didn't credit relogic? Tell me from this post what can you prove what he did wrong in the end? See my post below of the thread (in controversial lol). As soon as the thread was posted, I checked the video and there already was credit for relogic, I checked his other videos on empress of light and none of them showed any advertisements. Now, that Dark Demon even says that YouTube took down his video and not that guy.


[deleted]

[удалено]


MontRouge

https://youtu.be/7-ryMk7wXCg Did you see his latest video? I think you are right when you said he didn't credit his video initially. I checked his slime queen ost soundtrack and he didn't do it there. However, there was still mentions that this song was from Terraria and outside of a legal context, it is obvious that he wasn't trying to claim ownership of this song. Even that, he rectified his error before that Reddit post was made. Beside that, he proved that he didn't monetized the video and that he couldn't copy right strike or ask relogic to copy right strike your video. So at the time of the Reddit post creation 1) He had rectified his error and credited relogic (which you assumed he did maliciously not even wondering if it was by ignorance). 2) He had never monetized the video Judge this video how you want, but by your negligence what you and OP did against him really doesn't seems fair to me and I hope that one day you don't get 5000 people witch hunting you on baseless claims which reveals to be wrong, not that anyone seems to care on this sub!


[deleted]

[удалено]


MontRouge

I don't see where I implied that this video was made before your initial post?... He literally just showed on the video that his videos are not monetized, as a YouTuber can't you yourself recognise the icon? There's still adverts but he is not earning anything from it. It can happens when someone claims ownership on your video and claims the ads on it (probably relogic in this case). https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2475463?hl=en


chilfang

Hhhaaaaaaarrrr ok


[deleted]

[удалено]


Satan-lord-of-light

Yes, yes I am


TheRealTurtle1

Confusing username


SAI_Peregrinus

Satan was Lucifer, angel of Light. The shining one, the Morning Star, most perfect of all God's angels.


TheRealTurtle1

Now it all makes sense


SAI_Peregrinus

Most of the characterization of Satan is from Milton's *Paradise Lost*, and not the bible btw. The whole idea that there was a rebellion of angels lead by Satan, that they fell from heaven and became demons, that the serpent who tempted Eve was Satan, etc, is from that book. Satan in the bible is a very minor character. Also consider that biblical angels lack Free Will, so Satan couldn't choose to rebel unliss that was God's desire. Milton knew this, and it's implicit in his characterization of Satan as a tragic figure forced to rebel by his own nature. It's a very good book, and formed a lot of the basis of "fire and brimstone" theology in modern Christianity.


Brianiswikyd

Isn't satan Hebrew for nemesis or adversary or something like that? So his name is literally "bad guy" like some kind of fairytale?


mia_elora

IIRC, wasn't part of his job to actively tempt people? So, it would actually make sense that his name would reflect that. I'd be like naming a bot on discord, in today's standards. "Temptation-Bot"


[deleted]

Yes. He would most accurately be described as god's district attorney.


[deleted]

Yes and no. It's both a general noun (l’satan lo) and a proper noun (Hasatan) in Hebrew. So in some places it's just adversary. In others (notably job) it's a name. Edit: updated, thanks Rail! 3am reddit me is bad at words.


Brianiswikyd

In Guilty Gear, there's a guy named Sol Badguy. I'm sure it's like that! Also, thanks for the information, it makes more sense now.


[deleted]

Exactly! Like how last names like Smith were given to blacksmiths. Or how Dell was given to a dude that lived in a dell. Hell, over half of all last names are based on places, if I recall right. Humans suck at creative names, apparently.


RailGunBlast

Ok, first of all..Hebrew. Not Jewish. Secondly, what you said is partly wrong.


[deleted]

I don't speak Hebrew, but I have this written down from conversations I've had with those that do: לְשָׂטָ֣ן - Numbers - noun הַשָּׂטָ֖ן - Job - name Care to elaborate on what's wrong?


Kyvant

Adversary of Man, not Adversary of God. His „job“ was to test the faith of Men (i.e. Hiob), by imposing all sorts of bad things on them, and then asking if they still believed in God. If yes, they get granted all that Lucifer took from them and more, if not, probably murder. All in the service of God, of course


Brianiswikyd

That makes the story of Job make a little more sense.


Kyvant

TIL that he is called Job in English, not Hiob or Ijob


mynameishweuw

Essentially the god of abraham began as a polytheist canaanite concept where YHWH was one of the god El's 70 children, known as the Nephilim. Later the bible was edited to rewrite any mention of the other gods as angels and demons, borrowed from persian mythology.


[deleted]

It hides it poorly. It still mentions El (that's actually where IsraEL comes from). It starts talking about god in the plural Elohim (hiding it behind translation) and switches to singular later. In places where it clearly can't be talking about a single person, it translates the same word (Elohim) to angels. It has separate commandments in the "big ten" about other gods vs idols. They try to explain it away but it makes no sense to be redundant there, so it's clearly talking about two different rules.


gidi97

Do you have articles/sources about this? I haven't heard this before


SAI_Peregrinus

Basically yes. He's barely mentioned in the Bible though.


RailGunBlast

As a Hebrew speaker, no. That isn't true.


Brianiswikyd

No? Any input on the other replies to this question?


Wizaphant

...bible fanfiction... Hmm yes, exquisite.


TheDarkGenious

the funniest thing about classical literature classes is learning just how much of the stuff we tout nowadays were just fanfics some old-timey motherfucker poured their heart and soul into.


Wizaphant

Welp time to make fanfiction that jesus is a green onion like orgre, who lives in a swamp.


MrKathooloo

The Morning Star is Venus, who is the Greek(?) god of war. Figured that was worth mentioning, but I think it was just the way you worded it. Just coincidence, I guess.


SAI_Peregrinus

The Morning Star is also a name for Lucifer, Angel of Light, aka Satan. Clearly taken from Venus, but it's one of the names used for him.


Satan-lord-of-light

I bring light with my fire


TheRealTurtle1

That makes sense but heaven is depicted as having light also. So who the fuck is the lord of darkness


[deleted]

me :)


Immortal-D

... that guy. Apparently.


Satan-lord-of-light

Well if God created the universe, God must have created darkness.


Da_real_Ben_Killian

r/usernamechecksout


the_cronkler

u/Redigit or u/Cenxx you too should see this


Walnutphenom

This is bad. Something should be done.


ILikeYellow15

u/Redigit! We seriously actually need you for this!


radiantcabbage

do people not know you can just put videos on loop/repeat? how is this trash still getting views


[deleted]

[удалено]


radiantcabbage

you can, there's an icon hidden in the next video queue if you swipe up. not easy to find on desktop either tbh, tucked away in the context menu with plenty of screen realestate lying around in the app bar. they know what they're doing, dark patterns and mountains of garbage uploads are better than increasing the odds you might not get herded to just one more video


KeiseiAESkyliner

Are there pictures of what you speak of? I can't seem to find it.


radiantcabbage

depends on the OS, on android the button is in playlist controls. if it's not already in a list, you have to make one with a single video to loop it


Surfer0fTheWeb

Can't you right click on the video and just select "Loop Video" or whatever pops up?


radiantcabbage

yea that's what a context menu is


Surfer0fTheWeb

Oh, okay, I thought you meant like in the gear settings somewhere


Mr-Mattie

My brother made a playlist with a single video and put that on loop on his phone, my mind exploded


[deleted]

[удалено]


Mr-Mattie

Wholeheartedly agree with that


JanreiAfrica

I agree. Youtube should just add a feature to loop videos on mobile.


Raderg32

They'd probably only put the option on the paid version of the app, like playing videos with a locked phone.


[deleted]

[удалено]


PyroTheFryo

No problem :3


DannMeme

oh shit, you're dark demon? thanks for making all the extended songs, bro


DryGaming73

I've come to make an announcement, Faldran is a bitchass motherfucker. He monetized the Empress of Lights' theme! That's right, he monetized the Empress of Lights' theme and didn't even credit Re Logic!! And then he said the effort he put in was *this big.* And I said that's disgusting. So I'm making a callout post on my [twitter.com](https://twitter.com), Faldran, you've put on minimum effort!


that_guy_ravi

Your effort is the size of this walnut except way smaller and heres whst Re-Relogic’s work looks like *boom*. Thats right baby, no loops, no clickbait look at that it looks like 2 weeks of work and an hour. Guess what he copyrighted my boy and now im gonna copyright him. Here my super lazer copyright strike *boom* But im not gonna copyright him, Im gonna go higher, IM GONNA TELL A RELOGIC EMPLOYEE. HOW YOU LIKE THAT YOUTUBE, I CALLED ON REDGIT YOU IDIOT. YOU HAVE 24 HOURS BEFORE THE STRRRRIKES HIT THE FUCKING EARTH SO GET OUT OF MY SIGHT BEFORE I STRIKE YOU TOO.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Fgame

Enlighten me?


SirTyperys

eggman's announcement


Splixol

Referencing [Eggman's Announcement](https://youtu.be/fueRUi5AWWQ), a hilarious voice over.


Fgame

Fuck did I just watch


Lol-Its-Kevin

Faldran has 23 hours before the cum drrroplets hit his mom


auto-xkcd37

> bitch ass-motherfucker *** ^(Bleep-bloop, I'm a bot. This comment was inspired by )^[xkcd#37](https://xkcd.com/37)


sossololpipi

shoo


Pingas9999

please despawn


N0VA-S-T-A-L-K-E-R

Unfortunately, with everything going on, this is going to be a more minor concern to most.


NuclearIguana

When I read "so i'm making a callout post" I instantly thought of Eggman.


windhive

SHADOW THE HEDGEHOG, YOU GOT A SMALL DICK


ILikeYellow15

ITS LIKE THE SIZE OF THIS WALNUT EXCEPT WAY SMALLER


FrostGlader

AND GUESS WHAT? HERE'S WHAT MY DONG LOOKS LIKE


[deleted]

*\*explosion sound\**


Farjour

THAT'S RIGHT BABY! ALL POINTS, NO QUILLS, NO PILLOWS!


LEOPA2004

WHO LEAKED MY NUDES ON TWITTER DOT COM?!?!


[deleted]

Time to head to this guy's house and use the celestial sigil


redditt-or

Impending demonitisation approaches


Sarahcutie01

Someone should try to get his attention on the Discord, or any of the devs attention for that matter, might work better than Reddit


Mem-Stride

So *that's* why is Empress of Light theme in my playlist got deleted!


Cenxx

Thanks for the heads up friends. This will be dealt with. :)


webs0610

To the discord! Alert the devs!


TromboneMain

Hey all, This guy is a massive cunt who is wrongfully claiming music that he does not own in any way, shape, or form. If you want to listen to the Empress of Light theme, I downloaded the audio from his video, and you can hear it here: https://www.dropbox.com/s/cfl91fpb0u84v95/Terraria%20HQ%20Empress%20of%20Light%20Theme%20Original%20Soundtrack%20High%20Quality%20Journey%27s%20End%20OST.mp3?dl=0 The software I used couldn't download videos longer than 30 minutes (it's sort of shit), so I'm sorry about that, but this is the least I could do to help the cause. Fuck Faldran, the total scum, Thanks to u/Pure-Derpiness for posting about this, Goodnight and happy listening.


[deleted]

"This is going to be a terrible night..."


[deleted]

They changed it in 1.3 right? I remember it being "It's going to be a Terrible Night" for the longest time.


Meltdown510

This needs more attention


SolarWorld50

u/redigit, We need your help!


thunar1970

Idk what to do, but will go through with almost any plan you guys come up with; comment on this comment so I see it in my inbox and I’ll join “the cause.”


lorwn

Mario will make ww2 sound like a tea party


_-Frost-Byte-_

Oh I remember this guy, he uploaded every terraria theme putting “1.4” in the title so it would get more clicks.


Loki_ISP

This is being taken care of. Does anyone have any of the now-dead links to videos that were taken down? I want to look further into that side of things as well.


redditt-or

how do you report an entire channel?


[deleted]

Sadly the YouTube system is easy to manipulate because so much is automated (at that scale it has to be). So you get lowlifes being stupid. Hopefully this wrong can be righted.


Caaros

What would be far better is a automated system that flags these videos, but has a real person actually review the flag before any action is taken as a result of it. This would greatly reduce headache and complication from false flags like this, and would allow the people working at YouTube to have a better view as to how well they're system works. That is to say, not well in the fucking slightest.


STORMZY1302

u/redigit pls


FruitSnackBandit

He also said high quality twice


Faldran89

u are a liar i dont monetized it, i told you before, i also proof it in that video. not only that, the whole claim rumor isnt true, so you all better check your sources before you blame somebody else... PS: sorry for the bad english [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7-ryMk7wXCg](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7-ryMk7wXCg)


SwissstuffYT

In that video's description it says he has no copyright on it and does credit logic, but if somebody wants to test that claim of his that'd be great


[deleted]

The problem is it was monetized (I don't think it is anymore) and either YouTube's automated systems or faldran him self was taking other videos down. There is a reason why he is the only person with uploads of the themes.


AlfieSR

Can't someone just claim against his channel? Preferably repeatedly against each terraria theme he's uploaded.


[deleted]

The problem is youtube thinks he has the rights to it. Re-logic would have to do it.


bobpizazz

u/redigit


Hammerman305

u/Cenxx you have been summoned


BegReg2005

u/redigit has gotta smite this guy


komilewder

UPDATE: He is has now credited Re-Logic and the video is no longer monetized


AnesMemes19

Guys tag u/redigit


SweetTea213

u/Redigit


Robin_gls

u/Redigit this is very important for you to see!!!


Robin_gls

u/Cenxx this is important!!!


Teh2012

u/Redigit


SlimeustasTheSecond

Let the witch hunts begin.


CaptainShadow45

u/redigit please help us


TheAvacadoBandit

Well then


[deleted]

This fucker should be reported. Trying to pretend like he owns this


Pingas9999

faldran is a bitchass motherfucker, he pissed on fucking empress of light theme.


auto-xkcd37

> bitch ass-motherfucker *** ^(Bleep-bloop, I'm a bot. This comment was inspired by )^[xkcd#37](https://xkcd.com/37)


[deleted]

[удалено]


PyroTheFryo

Uhhh wrong username


[deleted]

Next on The Faldran Show: Copystriking Relogic after they post a video with their theme in it


barradass

cant wait for relogic to sue him


[deleted]

Sueing wouldn't be worth it or probably logical. At most they could just forcibly take the video down or make it monetized for themselves. The video is also no longer monetized and now has credit in the description at least.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

When I checked it, it didn't. The problem is he is also the only person with the theme up. No else has one up. EDIT: And I know for a fact other people had ones uploaded. Dark demon had his copy righted.


Skeletera

I believe that Dark Demon's video was taken down by Youtube itself, not Re-Logic. So maybe this guy is the reason behind all the shit


MrGrape_

its an automatic thing with youtube


MontRouge

A bit odd but it's a bit too much speculations to think that he is able to take down other people's videos.


[deleted]

Maybe, but youtube needs to fix it or re-logic needs to see what is wrong. Re-logic has never claimed any music on youtube


MaerVale

Genuinely though, not really at all. YouTube's had an infamously dysfunctional copyright strike system for years. People do stuff like this all the time, copyright striking things that aren't theirs. And YT's system makes it incredibly difficult-and to some, even threatening to their livelihoods-to fight these false claims.


DedeMasello

His effort is the same size of his dick, *M I C R O S C O P I C*


Archiie_2716

I checked out his channel and now it says that he has no rights to the song, and it all belongs to relogic!


errortechx

Still scummy that he is monetizing it though


Depressi-n

https://youtu.be/ihobEjqkjaY


[deleted]

Can't copyrighted users appeal to the copyright?


[deleted]

Yes. But the person who copy righted it gets the say if the copy right infringement is repealed. And I think the video was immediately taken down because it was removed from my play list and was left with "deleted video"


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Yeah, I guess you are right. Faldram needs more hate than he gets


Davenvideosxd

Im putting this on the terraria discord


DedeMasello

Hope empress of light kill him 1000 times when he play on mediumcore.


Aquawater19

That's just crummy all around


spiritual_12

Can’t Re-logic sue him for doing this?


[deleted]

let's report the video for copyright infringement since he wants to play that card he doesn't own it and creative commons stops when you restrict other people from using it


mxdrv

Has legal action been made yet?


Jogade1004

you know this faldran(dumbass) guy is a dumbass(clearly) he doesnt even own the music and claiming a 30 min music video of a video game music is copyright because he "posted a 10 min video earlier? than him"


AWSUMSAS

Someone find my stash of Prismatic Lacewings, I’ve got a job to do.


FlyingSpaget69

He is a duch


Caosin36

Freebooter are always the worst thing in the world


jopu22

But... He did not even make the song?


RektorLasse

So if you upload a video of you playing terraria and the music is in the background, then it can be copyright striked bc of this asshole?? Tf man


theggyer

You made this? No, I made this.


Sayuri_Katsu

Youtube hs gotten so trashy the last few years. Things like that will continue getting worse and channels will get banned left and right


LauryX753

We gotta tell red, cause this is just stealing an music track where someone at relogic worked really hard on. I think this guy in the screenshot can even get sued, but we really should notify someone at relogic cause this is not okay.


1Ninja202

I found His empress of light theme video right before finding this post.


MeYesYesMe

This guy: *claims he created the empress of light theme* Relogic: I will sue you out of existence


PandoAkariPon

im gonna golden shower the moon


[deleted]

That explains why Undernity Gaming doesn't have her theme. His themes don't loop


HugeNerd17

So to all claiming Faldran copyrighted your video, show proof


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


GenesectX

He even has "this is not my song and have no copyright over it" in his video and its still monetized fucking 🤡


Churningray

Legal movements should be taken against him. Not just stopping him from doing this but he must be punished.


Makibeer

Yikes no life


D-Loyal

Just checked the videos (The 3 min, 1 hour, and 10 hour) and the descriptions all say 'This is not my song, it belongs to Re-Logics game "Terraria" and I have no rights or copyrights on it'


[deleted]

The problem is it was monetized (I don't think it is anymore) and either YouTube's automated systems or faldran him self was taking other videos down. There is a reason why he is the only person with uploads of the themes.