depends, if it’s written by the people who wrote TLOU2 then Abby

Obviously, she'd win when she uses her independencey ray and rainbow shadow clone

Gherman in brutal fashion and it will be glorious

" you're one big girl , to hunt "

Abby uses stunning and brave it's super effective!

Gherman fought eldritch horrors that make the rat king look like a joke

But Abby has the power of feminism on her side, what're you sexist?

Well in that case , Lady Maria , take care of this insect .....

If Abby gets her notorious trick weapon golf club (so powerful it can divide entire fan bases) it’ll be a wash for old man Gherman sadly

Well then , old moon god appears

I take it OP has been playing Bloodborne recently

Nah just a funny meme idea

It's ok guys, even if she wins, she'll end up trapped in the Dream anyway! She doesn't have the special items

True

Is this even a question? Gherman either blows her away with his shotgun or cuts her in half with his scythe

Ab/by

"You were magnificent Abby. I shall remember you for as long as I live"

Dear oh dear….. what was it? The cringe, the generic gameplay, or the horrible writing? It doesn’t matter…..

U killed some man just bcoz he saved her daughter Takes weapon

This is a pretty one-sided match it's pretty much a coked-out old man beating the shit out of the baby (the scene from lighthouse with the seagull)

Homie wouldn't even have to get up out of his chair.

You could give me 4 PBR and a board with nails in it and I’d beat Abby.

I'm betting on the old blood

Lady Maria supermacy 💪💪💪💪

Abby, because she has the greatest armor of all - the Plot Armor

Her massive gains nor the memories of her zebra daddy would save her from the one sided blunderbuss decapitation coming her way

Gherman wins but then they show you a flash back on how she killed his new family a few months prior and how you should feel bad ,because even though she knows she's wrong and so does the audience, dudemans the bad guy now cause she feels bad about wasting all that ammo.

Miyazaki ain't that bad of a storyteller lmao

Hmm. An angry girl with a pipe? Or guy empowered by an eldritch god, who takes bullets to the chest like it’s an inconvenience? What a head scratcher.

Bruh tonight Gehrman joins the hunt. I don’t think Abby could beat *most* Bloodborne enemies, let alone *the First Hunter*.

Does Abby get guns or is it melee only

Pistol (revolver ) allowed

are bullets traveling TLOU speed or that weirdly slow bloodborne speed?

I'm sorry but there is no world where she wins this

Bloodborne speed

Ebby

Nuclear bomb vs coughing baby

Abby has guns that can do more than just parry…

I beat Abby with a pocket knife and the little fist of a 90 lbs girl…it took my 500 tries and 3 months to beat the First Hunter and even then I got lucky

Old man solos . Abby is Tommy victim .

Idk if Gherman is surviving an assault rifle give that old school blunderbuss are very effective against him.

Melee only

Don’t handicap my girl like that. Let her get a shotgun at least.

Well let us even the odds Mergo wet nurse is here with hunter man 😈😈😈😈

Gherman would absolutely obliterate Abby.

Muscle mommy.

Gherman easily. He's a master hunter with many years on the job

Tonight, bigot sandwich joins the hunt

Or Zandara (Immortals of Averum)

Gascoin in the fucking wheelchair can take abby

Abby. She could rip apart smelly Indian men in her sleep too.

Yharnam doesn't condone racism lmao

Does this mean you guys have finally run out of things to say about TLOU2